Discussion Locked

Newsweek: Catching a spy at Hewlett-Packard

0 helpful
30 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Everyone is complaining about the United States government data mining to protect civilian lives. Invasion of privacy hu? Well, read this article:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14687677/site/newsweek/

The guts and the glory of this article is that Hewlett-Packard spied on board member private homes(phones)to find out who was leaking information. Yea well, if a 100 billion dollar company(read my previous posts on this) is willing to spy on it's own people. What do you think they are doing to the common person that buys their products? The only reason this became public is because when a board member resigns, they must report the reason why to the Securities monitoring agency.

What don't we know about what they are gathering on us? Or, is everyone still to blind to look at Corporations because they are still so anti President Bush. And you know what, not all of these corporations are American. You've given these rights to multinational cooperation's also. Owned and controlled by individuals outside the United States.

American citizens have no privacy, none. Let the government have the same ability you freely allow corporations to have to protect your life. Or else, quit being such hypocrites about it and apply the same standards to these corporations that you do the official government.

Dan

30 replies

by techexec2

"...Let the government have the same ability you freely allow corporations to have to protect your life..."

What planet did you post from? Uranus? :-)

"Nobody" freely allows corporations to spy on them or misuse their personal information.

The HP corporate surveillance was or should have been illegal and should be prosecuted. And, surveilance by the government must be within the 4th amendment to the U.S. Constitution. And, during a war, some things are different than when there is not a war.

by jamesrl

The slippery slope on the HP case is that they did analysis on information that was HP's: the telephone billing that these directors submmitted as expenses to HP.

James

by danlm

I feel we are at war right now, and the government needs these abilities to combat foreign nationals that are using sleeper cells in the us. I feel the arguments against them having this ability is one sided when you look what various corporations gather and use on every day Americans. With no over site, with no good reason other then to turn a profit. At least the government is trying to protect our lives.

I used this article to highlight what I feel is routine collection and manipulation of information on American citizens by various corporations and what could happen if only a few people decided to run with it.

Dan

by jdclyde

If you have a shopper discount card at a store, you are giving all of this information away.

If you pay with a credit card for all of your purchases, you are giving this data away.

In both places, they keep a data base on you. What you buy and how often, and that information is sold to others.

Do you "register" any product you buy because it tells you to? That registration card has small print that this information is gathered and sold.

Yes, HP does that with all of their products too.

YourAnus just got a little closer, huh? ;\

by techexec2

Hey! I thought that "Uranus" double entendre was pretty good! :-)

Anyway, thanks for your post. I was aware that they collect all of that data that we willingly give. But, that is not "spying". It's the reported taking of data that was not given that is the apparent problem.

The only possibly objectionable thing in this HP boardroom case is about the way they obtained the phone records. If they obtained them through some kind illegal means, they should be prosecuted for that. Quoting from the MSNBC.COM article:

"...According to an internal HP e-mail, Dunn [chairwoman of the board] then took the extraordinary step of authorizing a team of independent electronic-security experts to spy on the January 2006 communications of the other 10 directors?not the records of calls (or e-mails) from HP itself, but the records of phone calls made from personal accounts. That meant calls from the directors? home and their private cell phones..."

That sounds like what they did was illegal, or should be.

edit: typo

by protiusx

The United States Government is restricted by the 4th amendment only with respect to US citizens on US property. Foreigners (especially the foul, fetid fuzzy, filthy French) are open game.

by w2ktechman

After reading the article, I have to admit that this is appalling news. The company policy is probably set to nothing is confidential if it relates to HP equipment or over HP lines. But, they bypassed that and went for personal equipment and data. This sounds illegal.
Without a court order, I would hazard to guess that someone can/should be prosecuted in this matter.

by jdclyde

and that is how they got the information. They impersonated the individual to gain access to personal information. Something the government has not done, by the way.

I think MY uranus joke was better than yours was! :p

by tonythetiger

the "shoot the messenger" mentality will overshadow any other wrongdoing. If you blow the whistle, you will be persecuted, regardless of ANY law.

by techexec2

From an eWeek article (link below):

[quote]
"...HP denied it had recorded calls or eavesdropped on conversations. But it said that some form of "pretexting" for phone record information had been used in its investigation of leaks in 2005, when the board ousted Carly Fiorina as chairman and chief executive. Pretexting is the practice of calling a telephone company pretending to be a customer in order to obtain calling records without that customer's permission.

Congress earlier this year considered a bill to make pretexting illegal, but the proposal has been held up, apparently due to concerns in the U.S. intelligence community..."
[quote]

This is what I figured HP did. Apparently this is not currently illegal. But, it should be. Calling a phone company, lying to them about who you are, getting them to give you private information, and then using it for your own purposes is fraud and should be illegal.

CA Attorney General investigating
http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,2012774,00.asp

by danlm

What I am trying to get at here is that various corporations do collect various information for any number of reasons. This information is what a lot of individuals would consider private. This information is given with the belief that 1). They have no choice. 2). It won't be used for any other reason then what is stated when it is given.
Would we all agree on this?
Ok, now some examples of information collected in this manner.
1). Again, Google or any search engine. What do we look at on the Internet?
2). Various desk stop solutions by companies(Google/Microsoft) now have access to all of our files that we store and these same programs do communicate this information back to the server farm.
3). Hey, got a new car? How about On Star. They can track where ever you go. Shoot, rent a car and there ya go. They use these same types of tracking devices in shipping and now more and more so with various products that are bought and sold.

Just a few examples. What I think I have shown with this article posting is. With such a vast database of your personal habits, these companies hold a lot of power over what they can do. HP basically has shown that these same companies, that most people say they trust are not above using this type of information for their own gain. Or not above acquiring this type of information in other ways then they have previously stated. What I feel is the ultimate kicker when saying this is that they have no other reason then the almighty dollar. They would sell their soul to the devil basically to make a buck. They could sell yours at the same time, and you would never know it. No over site, no control, only a secretive board of directors calling the shots on what they should do with what they know about you.

The government on the other hand at least has what I consider a valid reason for needing some of the abilities to perform a small fraction of this collection of information. Protecting citizens against future acts of violence by foreign nationals that do have sleeper cells in the United States. If, a person is known based upon previous acts of terrorism to be contacting someone in the United States. Wouldn't you want to know that number? Or, if a person in the United States contacted that terrorist? Again, wouldn't you want to know who this person is? Don't you think this is much more important then the all mighty dollar for a reason to collect information?

Dan

by techexec2

I think your heart is in the right place. But, I disagree with your premise and conclusion. In your original post, you said "everyone is complaining". Well, I'm not one of them.

-----

CORPORATIONS DO IT? SO, THE GOVERNMENT SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO?

[quote]
"...Let the government have the same ability you freely allow corporations to have..."
[quote]

I disagree with your premise and your conclusion.

Regarding your premise: People don't freely allow corporations to misuse their personal information. Corporations collecting personal information are required to disclose their "privacy policy". Customers are entitied to "opt out" of their information being disclosed to others. There are laws designed to protect privacy. Do I trust them? Not at all. But, I don't "freely allow" them to do anything. If they get caught breaking the law, they should be prosecuted. I would not advocate revoking those laws, however easy it might be to ignore them and get away with it.

Going further, I think there needs to be NEW and more powerful laws restricting what corporations do with personal information. But, that is whole new conversation.

Regarding your conclusion: I don't think the government should be "freely allowed" to surveil U.S. citizens in the name of doing good. That's what you advocated. That's where I disagree. There are good reasons for the 4th amendment and for the way the FISA law was written.

Having said that, I think the "NSA spying program" (the phone records thing) should and MUST continue. It must continue on a legal basis. There is disagreement about whether it is legal or not. That must be resolved, whatever it takes. And, in my view, the resolution MUST include enabling the program to continue without breaking the program's effectiveness. That is a prerequisite for me.

WHAT HP DID WAS UNACCEPTABLE

What HP apparently did was unacceptable. I thought it was very clever and effective at finding a rat, but a clear misuse of power. Those involved should be charged with a crime. But, if it is really not illegal, a new law should make it illegal.

EPILOGUE

My problem with your post is that it is advocating "freely allowing" surveilance by the government. The 4th amendment has been around for over 200 years. It has survived all sorts of serious threats to our country. I think it should survive this one also. And, what we must do now (e.g. NSA "spying" program) must be done.

I think you are a good guy though and your heart is in the right place. Those misguided souls who would TAKE AWAY the NSA "spying" program now probably had ancestors on the Titanic who were upset about the arrangement of the deck chairs.

edit: Removed political reference. It's not political. It's ignorance. And, ignorance crosses party lines.

by tig2

But the failure to disclose a Board Member's resignation and rationale for same may get them into some interesting waters with the SEC. The SEC doesn't appreciate witholding of information a corporation is required to disclose.

Individually the privacy rights of the individual may also come into play.

Either way, HP ends up looking bad. I personally think that Dunn crossed the line on this one. I would like to think that something will be done about it.

by techexec2

I agree with you about Dunn.

My view: If Dunn was directly involved in this, she should be commended for being clever and effective at solving a serious boardroom secrecy problem. And, she should be immediately fired. That was a "mafia" tactic that is unacceptable in a public corporation.

Of course, I don't REALLY believe she is the only one. So, why fire her? Because she got CAUGHT! :-)

by x-marcap

Is it because there are no ethics at the top of the corporate ladder?

Invasion of privacy--> crime or just slimy?

HP uses private investigation process.
eight years ago a company did that trying to find out if the Sci-Fi book club was harassing a woman.

Her maiden name was Recluse. She went by one of her married names. We were reading "The Magic of Recluse" She was threatening all of us because "Recluse was our current fantasy" 5' and 300# was not any of our "cuppa tea".

The company spent 58,000 to investigate the charge,but never asked a one of us...Until we all decided to leave about the same time...

by jamesrl

The appropriate thing to do would be this.

Hold a closed door, no minutes meeting of the board - could be after a regular one.

Remind the board of the non disclosures they signed. Even have a lawyer on hand to explain the rules and answer any questions. Perhaps even go as far as to have them sign another copy suggesting they understand and have been informed.

Inform them of the consequences.

Tell them the evidence.

Tell them that if they have any knowledge of any such incidents, they should speak to X within 48 hours, and if they do so they will not be penalized.

Then close the meeting and wait for the calls.

You may not get a confession but you may stop further occurances.

James

by danlm

When I did the original post, I let my frustration with people that don't see how much private information is known by everyone get the best of me. I think some people wear blinders, and only see what they want.

I don't think the government should be free to do what ever it wants. But I do think the NSA program is/was being done in a reserved framework to try and protect the civil rights of Americans while still providing a tool to pursue the where abouts of the terrorists.
For modern corporations to survive, I don't know how they could compete unless this type of data mining did occur. But something needs to be done to protect the citizens from the power they have.
What does make me feel better is the knowledge that others do see that individual privacy can be infringed on by more then just the Government with a lot less honorable intentions.
Chuckle, I still don't trust Microsoft though. Just the thought of someone poking around my hard drives without my knowledge bothers me. Encrypt, encrypt, encrypt.

Dan

by absolutely

I owned a Hewlett-Packard computer once. Never again! A piece of crap like that can only be the by-product of infighting, mistrust and other irrational behaviors.

by nicknielsen

and keep it holey.

I used mine for target practice. The amount of damage a 9mm copper jacket can do to a power supply is amazing... B-)

by techexec2

This story is getting better.

There is a specific law in California that makes "pretexting" illegal. The board member who resigned (Tom Perkins) says that Chairwoman of the Board Dunn was personally behind the illegal actions taken at HP. Dunn says she was not aware the private investigation company used "pretexting" to obtain the phone records (bullsh*t!). HP admits to "pretexting" in an SEC filing! And, Perkins has a personal letter from an AT&T investigation that confirms his personal phone records were compromised.

Prediction: She's out.

HP story reveals dark world of phone records
http://redtape.msnbc.com/2006/09/hp_story_reveal.html

HP SEC filing admits pretexting (illegal in CA)
http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/47217/000110465906059471/a06-19246_18k.htm

HP targeted board in leak probe
http://www.thesmokinggun.com/archive/0905061hp1.html

edit: clarity

by tig2

And great links.

I thought that they would wiggle out of the illegality of pretexting but would get nailed by the SEC. With this, I can also see a Sarb-Ox audit failure and a Reportable Event to the stockholders.

Dunn needs to get outta town, change her name, never come back.

Tom Perkins is no dummy. He did everything in the right order in teh right timeline. Even teh corrected SEC filing supports this.

I had hoped after Carly Fiorina was gone, they would have a chance to re-group and go back to doing what they are capable of doing well- building solutions. I was wrong.

Thanks again for including the links- I have learned to value "Smoking Gun". Why pussyfoot when you can scan in the original and let the people read that?

Great post!

by techexec2

Patricia Dunn will be replaced as COB by current CEO
http://news.com.com/Leak+scandal+costs+HPs+Dunn+her+chairmans+job/2100-1014_3-6114655.html
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601103&sid=aLLSNn8GkIBM&refer=news
http://www.marketwatch.com/News/Story/Story.aspx?dist=newsfinder&siteid=google&guid=%7B9A8F3514-0B81-462D-B3F9-7CA841F2A170%7D&keyword=

P.S.

There are also continuing investigations by the State of California (where the CA Attorney General has said a crime was committed but it is not clear by whom), the Federal Department of Justice, and the U.S. House of Reps.

Prediction: There will likely be criminal indictments over this.

Stories on C-NET
http://news.com.com/HPs+boardroom+drama/2009-1014_3-6112817.html?tag=st_lh

edit: added the P.S.

by tig2

That Dunn must step down was inevitable. That she is being retained as a member of the board is unbelievable.

She may avoid criminal prosecution because a third party vendor actually committed the crime as opposed to the primary vendor, although it has come out that she was told that pretexting would be used and was told (incorrectly) that it was a legal practise. I don't see how in the world that she can claim now that she has only just learned that pretexting was involved- Perkins states that it was the method used to acquire HIS information. I believe that it is provable that she knew as early as May. There are allegations that she discussed this with the firm that contracted the investigation.

I personally don't see her lasting until the January transition date. This whole issue is not going to "softly and silently vanish away".

Hurd may not last too long either based on his multiple roles. My guess is that he will be interim or there will be additional changes. What do you want to bet that Perkins is asked to re-join?

The big question in my mind is how Dunn could have NOT known that doing such a thing would get her into deep do-do? [i]"According to a biography of Dunn on HP's Web site, she "also serves on the advisory board of the (University of California at) Berkeley Haas School of Business, as well as the conference board's Center for Corporate Governance.""[/i] Has she only been a figurehead throughout her career? She should have known that she was at the very least crossing the line.

Nice to know that this is still being persued. It should never have happened. Hopefully lawmakers will take this opportunity to revisit how compliance is carried out at the board level.

Thanks for the update, TechExec!

Edit for a reason

by techexec2

According to a WSJ article today (1), HP CEO Mark Hurd knew about the boardroom leak investigation and the fact that phone records were involved. Reportedly, Hurd even suggested names of directors who might be leakers. HP's legal counsel were directly involved in the investigation [i]"to protect the attorney-client privilege, in the event there is litigation or a governmental inquiry of some sort."[/i] Wow!

Also: WSJ reporter Pui-Wing Tam was secretly followed by HP investigators between January and March 2006 because she had direct contact with directory Keyworth (who was found to be the leaker).

There's more fascinating stuff in the WSJ article.

The investigation by the CA Attorney General and the Federal DOJ, and the involvement of the U.S. Congress continues!

Prediction: There are going to be several HP executives in addition to non-executive HP chairwoman Dunn who are criminally indicted in California.

What an amazing story!

REFERENCES

(1) HP CEO Hurd Might Have Had Bigger Probe Role
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB115880917385269774.html?mod=home_whats_news_us

by tig2

I would love to read your citation but it is blocked to non subscribers. Could I ask the favour that you link it to an open site or copy the text here?

Had a sneaky that others would be involved. that the culprit may be Hurd will hurt HP badly. In the wonderful world of executive power, he is perceived to have way too much.

I have the feeling that following the reporter, while it should be illegal, will be considered to be business as usual. The public perception will not be so forgiving.

California can be reactionary when it wants to be. Wrong doing on the part of a Silicon Valley giant can potentially go either way in the court of public opinion. My current sense is that they (HP) will be villified- what we have is a case of "We caught ONE, but suspect that MANY have done the same".

by techexec2

Just for you, here are some free links that are just as juicy. B-) This story is lighting the web on fire. Washington Post, NY Times, and LA Times are all free registrations.

This activity inside HP is no surprise to me at all. But, it is SO INTERESTING!

How much you wanna bet that HP executives testifying before Congress next week all take the 5th?

LINKS

HP CEO linked to journalist probe
http://news.zdnet.com/2100-9584_22-6117944.html

HP CEO Allowed "Sting" of Reporter
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/09/20/AR2006092001964.html

HP Investigators Sought Meeting with Top Leaders
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/09/21/technology/21hewlett.html?ref=business

Documents suggest HP's CEO knew of boardroom leak investigation
http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/business/15568364.htm

HP Spied on More Than Phone Calls
http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-hp21sep21,1,4290745.story?coll=la-headlines-business&track=crosspromo

HP's Hurd may have had leak probe role
http://money.cnn.com/2006/09/21/news/companies/bc.tech.hewlettpackard.reut/

by techexec2

I haven't DUNN anything. I haven't HURD anything. (This is WAY too easy! :^0 )

I was born at night, but not LAST night.

SCORECARD (CONGRESSIONAL HEARING 9/28)

Ann Baskins (former HP General Counsel, resigned 9/28) -- 5th
Kevin Hunsaker (former HP Chief Ethics Officer, resigned 9/26) -- 5th
Anthony Gentilucci (former HP Global Security Manager, resigned 9/26) -- 5th

Ronald DeLia (private investigator) -- 5th
Joe Depante (private investigator) -- 5th
Cassandra Selvage (private investigator) -- 5th
Darren Brost (private investigator) -- 5th
Valerie Preston (private investigator) -- 5th
Bryan Wagner (private investigator) -- 5th
Charles Kelly (private investigator) -- 5th

Patricia Dunn (former HP Chairwoman, resigned 9/22) -- Oops! I didn't know.
Mark Hurd (HP CEO) -- Oops! I didn't know.
Larry Sonsini (HP outside counsel) -- My firm was not involved.

PATRICIA DUNN, FORMER HP CHAIRWOMAN (SORTA RESIGNED 9/12, RESIGNED 9/22)

During testimony on 9/28, Patricia Dunn actually said she thought the PIs obtained the detailed telephone records from publicly available sources. When questioned what sources she thought they were, she had no idea.

Note: I just found out that Dunn is very sick and fighting cancer (breast, melanoma, ovarian, liver). She is a tough, strong-willed person, and has little more to lose. This helps explain some of this. We should all say a prayer for her. (5)

MARK HURD, HP CHAIRMAN AND CEO (FOR NOW)

During testimony on 9/28, Mark Hurd actually said he had not heard of the term "pretexting" before June 2006, and when he did, he did not ask anyone what it meant. He was given an 18-page report from the investigators in March 2006. He claims he did not read it.

Nobody that incompetent, or that bad of a liar, should run one of America's finest tech companies.

BEST LINE

Quoting from the TV show "Hogan's Heroes", Rep. Edward Markey, D-Mass. produced one of the best lines at the hearing: [i]"HP seems to be suffering from the Sgt. Schultz syndrome. I heard nothing, I saw nothing, I knew nothing."[/i]

PREDICTION

Mark Hurd will also resign. Some people say HP needs Hurd. After watching him talk (what he said, and the [i]way he said it[/i]), it is clear that HP will be better off without him.

REFERENCES

(1) CNN Money page for this
http://money.cnn.com/2006/09/28/technology/hp_hearing/index.htm?cnn=yes

(2) HP Execs Testify Before Congress
http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,2022286,00.asp

(3) Dunn Resigns; HP CEO Hurd Apologizes for Investigation
http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1895,2019586,00.asp

(4) The peculiar logic of Patricia Dunn
http://money.cnn.com/2006/09/15/technology/FastForward_HP.fortune/index.htm

(5) Suspicions and Spies in Silicon Valley
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/14736379/site/newsweek/

(6) Two HP employees depart amid leak probe
http://news.zdnet.com/2100-9595_22-6119811.html?tag=nl

(7) Dunn grilled by Congress
http://news.zdnet.com/2100-9595_22-6120625.html?tag=nl

(8) Hurd Written Testimony
http://energycommerce.house.gov/108/News/09282006_Testimony_Hurd.pdf

(9) Dunn Written Testimony
http://energycommerce.house.gov/108/News/09282006_Testimony_Dunn.pdf

This discussion is closed to new replies.