Discussion Locked

No more negotiations with Iran. It's time to declare war!!!

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Dear Editor:

Mohamed ElBaradei, chairman of the International Atomic Energy Agency
(IAEA), said last week that Iran is only a few months away from
producing a nuclear bomb--and suggested that the way to prevent this
is "to go back to the negotiating table" (i.e., cave in to extortion).
Following his suggestion would be suicidal.

No amount of negotiation will persuade the Iranian theocrats to give
up their longtime quest for nuclear bombs. To ensure Iran will not
produce--or use--nuclear bombs, the United States and its allies must
destroy Iran's nuclear facilities and wipe out its regime--and must do
so without delay.

Iran presents a much greater danger to the United States' security
than did Iraq and Afghanistan combined. Once Iran gets hold of nuclear
bombs, the United States will be an easy target for blackmail and a
likely target for mass destruction. As one of the principal
ideological sources of Islamist totalitarianism, Iran is an avowed
enemy of the United States and a leading state sponsor of terrorism.
It finances, trains, shelters and equips terrorists from organizations
like al-Qaeda, Hamas, Hezbollah and Islamic Jihad. Iran is currently
waging a proxy war against the United States in Iraq and killing
American soldiers by the dozens (if not by the hundreds). Under those
circumstances the United States has a moral right--indeed, a moral
obligation--to defend its people from Iran's threats and preempt
future terrorist attacks.

The Iranian regime has repeatedly threatened to use its
soon-to-be-produced nuclear weapons to wipe Israel off the map. It has
repeatedly called for "Death to America." These threats must be taken
seriously. We did not take Osama bin Laden's threats seriously, and
lost the Twin Towers. We do not want to make the same mistake with
Iran, and lose all of Manhattan.

David Holcberg
Ayn Rand Institute
Irvine, CA

[i]ARI's letters to the editor are solicitations sent to addresses obtained from commercially available databases and from Web sites that have an apparent interest in publication material.

[b]It is going to happen sooner or later. It is inadvisable to wait until they are in possession of a nuke. Better to have the war there than here especially with the potential for any fall out, nuclear or otherwise, no pun intended.[/b][/i]

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

24 replies

by Member 25348569

We would have had someone in the region as a counter to Iran. I don't think that we'd see too many Iranian nuclear facilities completed considering the emnity between the neighbours. Fairly obviously using 20/20 hindsight, we got the wrong country.

We would also have a lot more troops spare to invade the victor and pacify the whole region. The UK doesn't have a single spare soldier so if you want the US to invade they'll be on their own.

by garret`

Read that and substitute 'Iran' with the 'United States', and the 'United States' with 'the rest of the world'. Some paragraphs made more sense to me that way.

by road-dog

After all, they have a history of that type of things. Remember Osirak? The Israelis know what they're dealing with. They have the doo-dads to do something about it.

The question is which Arab nations will come into it against Israel. I suspect that Syria will come into it, I think the Saudis will sit it out, wanting to keep the oil flowing. Egypt might be opportunistic, depending on which way they think it's going to go. My guess is that they will sit this one out though.

Iran is in no position to try to go to war with Israel and would have no small amount of trouble crossing Iraq to get to the fight.

I think the UN will condemn the action, but will do nothing of substance. After all, the nuclear program is in violation of UN intentions anyway. They will probably breathe a sigh of relief that thay won't have to do anything of substance themselves.

I think selling Israel a couple of our biggest bunker bunker bombs to destroy underground facilities might be fair payback for Iran's support of AlQeda and Iraqi insurgents. They already have nukes to deal with surface targets.

by tony hopkinson

think a nuclear capable 'enemy' invasion force dominated by a fundamentally opposed religious creed in a neighbouring state has anything to do with the Iranian posture do you ?

Silly Tony, silly.

Holcberg again, doesn't get out much does he. There are a lot of UK citizens of iranian extraction in the UK, if he came here, one complaint and and he would be toast. He'd be in Belmarsh next to the other preachers of violence.

PS, what allies ? He isn't seriously expecting international support for such a venture is he? Fellas got to be in la la land if he is.

by dw_ay

US and UN don't fair, that's why the terorist come. don't you see in Iraq? there is no nuclear or mass destruction weapons there, what about israel they are killing many innocent palestin children and women, US/UN just watch out, no one help so there come jihad actions, and I think Israel already has capability to produce a nuclear weapon but no one says it. what have people in Iraq and Palestin done to US or Israel before? No moslems like israel because too many killing they have done. It looks like moslem souls are no value for Israel. Why does US protect Israel? it must be a goal behind, does US have right to change Arab? The true moslem will not hurt anyone if they don't get hurt.

by road-dog

declared war on Israel the day it bacame a country..... And got their collective asses hammered into the sand.

Learn history from a book not in a Mosque. Be careful throwing the 'J' word around.

J - Jewish
I - Israelis
H - Have
A - Atomic
D - Devices

Y'all have a nice day now, y'hear?

by noyoki

> The true moslem will not hurt anyone if they don't get hurt.

Uh, it's not the *TRUE* moslem we are worried about or condemning. I don't count Al Queda as "True Moslem". (No, I'm not for the war against them in Iraq either, but that's a different topic.)

The point is, beaurocrats, politicians and war mongers don't CARE that they aren't living up to the 'rules' of their religion. All they see is a red haze clouding their vision. That haze is hate, prejudice, 9/11, call it what you will.

PS. Correct me if I'm completely wrong here, but we (the US - or the politicians/people in charge of it at least) DID bring 9/11 on ourselves more or less, by helping to train the Al Quieda then ditching them when it was convenient. Unfortunately, when you train a lap dog to become a viscious guard dog, you can't expect it to revert back to it's kind and gentle nature just because you are done with it.

by sleepin'dawg

Generally speaking, when your need for guard and/or attack dogs is over; you put the dogs down becasuse they are too dangerous to be permitted to exist in regular civilized society.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

In 1948 Israel did not attack its neighbors; the neighboring nations did, with the stated purpose of pushing Israel into the sea. Time and again the neighboring Arab nations have set out to destroy Israel and failed; mainly due to stupidity and incompetence. The fundamentalist Imans ignore the real neads of their people and are constantly encouraging them to attack Israel and the west, which in their eyes means primarily the USA. The centre of current Islamic hysterical fundamental philosopy is Iran and the sooner they are subdued the sooner the world will have some order of peace. For the present, all immigration from Islamic nations should be curtailed to exert pressure on Iran to change its ways. Failing that the present regime in Iran needs to be crushed. Under the current state of affairs, war with Iran is inevitable. Better to get it over now, while they don't have a nuclear capability than to wait until they do. Yes, lives will be lost but thousands more will be lost if we wait.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by noyoki

As long as you can include the Christians in that hogwash, and... well... just about every organized religion has its vendettas, then sure, whatev.

Crusades anyone? With a side of witch trials?

Oh, and we ALL agree with our leaders, don't we? Go Bush! *sarcasm*

It's just the ones that make the news that you hear about. I'm sure there were Catholic/Christians that sheltered suspected witches even as there were those that turned them in because the person weighed as much as a duck. But do we hear of any in history?

by mjwx

Firs off all I don?t like this thread, it angers up the blood, next as an aussie and self respecting human being I don?t like seeing our diggers (what us aussies call our soldiers for the un-initiated) dying for no good reason.

Now that that?s out of the way I will point out the flaws in dawg?s plan, it depends on either this state can be wiped out completely or if not, 1.) there will be no uprising or the state wont be replaced with something else 2.) the Iranians actually want this (see art of war ?the moral law?).

As an American (dawg) you must understand by this point that a government that does not have popular supports rules by either deception or force (the price of freedom is eternal vigilance and so on). The same is true for a military action. If the people of an invaded country do not want you there they will do everything in there power to force you to leave (see ?Vietnam?).

The solution you propose is the Stalinist solution (quote ?death solves all problems, no man no problem? Joseph Stalin) so the only way to win is to destroy Iran entirely (state, buildings, people, lock, stock, the f**king lot) then you will need to eliminate all those related or tied to Iran (Muslim?s, Arabs, etc?). So far all you have on Iran is fear and suspicion, if I can see a Nazi style death camp then you will have some support (and ?the moral law?).

War is not the answer to all problems. If you need to drive a nail you use a hammer, but if you need to drive a screw do you use a hammer (this is a metaphor you are supposed to think about).

Mike

by neil higgins

"war is the continuation of state policy by other means".Attack Iran,or take out the leader,fire a few cruise missiles,which will hit schools,and residential areas.Followed by many years of mess,terror attacks by loonies seeking vengence,body bags,instability,chaos,etc.I dont know how to solve Ahmadinejad's reteric rant,but declaring war is'nt one of them.As neilb said earlier in his post,the UK does not have enough troops to fight everywhere.Probably the sensible solution is the UN.

by mjwx

it was carl von clausewitz who said it, I think. he wrote the book on kreig (on war) which decribes the principal of ultraviolence (think trench warfare in world war 1).

for those who are not familiar with ultraviolence it is a method of warfare where armies are thrown onto armies en mass in a bloody napoleonic/civil war style hence it is called "ultraviolence".

fortunatly this style of fighting is frowned upon in the western world but sometimes it is still used on a policy level (I.E. send more troops).

i suppose the point to this (and most of my posts on this thread is that there is always another solution, or atleast a different way of achieving the current solution).

by mjwx

it was carl von clausewitz who said it, I think. he wrote the book "on kreig" (on war) which decribes the principal of ultraviolence (think trench warfare in world war 1).

for those who are not familiar with ultraviolence it is a method of warfare where armies are thrown onto armies en mass in a bloody napoleonic/civil war style hence it is called "ultraviolence".

fortunatly this style of fighting is frowned upon in the western world but sometimes it is still used on a policy level (I.E. send more troops).

i suppose the point to this (and most of my posts on this thread is that there is always another solution, or atleast a different way of achieving the current solution).

by itgirli

I don't think it's likely.
I don't even think Bush is fool enough to try that again. War against al-Qaeda was one thing, but he screwed up with the war in Iraq. I saw it more as a move to finish what his father started. Saddam should have been taken out in Desert Storm, then none of the war in Iraq would be an isuue. At this point in Bush's career, Iran could be pointing nukes at us and I don't think Bush would declare war. My reasoning: Bush has been so criticized by the liberal media, other countries, and now even his own party, that I doubt he'd make a move. And trying to get a decision through congress is like trying to shove an elephant through a keyhole.
Many people say that war is not the answer, and I think they are right; however, if you have a better idea that actually works, let me know. At least keep them too busy to organize an atomic assault. War is not something new, people. I'm sure if someone would come up with an effective, reasonable, peaceful solution, war wouldn't be an issue. Until then, the governments decide.

by montgomery gator

Give us 2 or 3 years to build up Iraq, and if the Iraqi army is strong enough to fight with us, and the Iraqi government would go along with it, we could send a combined force from Iraq into Iran. And if we can get Afghanistan and Pakistan to go along with it, that would open up an additional front for the invasion.

The only thing we can do now is precision strikes with cruise missles and bombers to take out their nuclear facilities, and that would require good intelligence to know where they are. And event that would be politically dangerous, we would have to make sure our allies in the region would not object, particularly Turkey, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, Azerbaizan, and Afghanistan.

by mjwx

The irony is if bush snr had of taken out Saddam?s regime in the 90?s there could be a US friendly state in Iraq? Maybe, maybe not? My point is that in the 90?s the US had some popular support in the Middle East (going back to my earlier post on ?the moral law?).

During desert storm the US incited the oppressed majority of Iraqis (Kurdish in particular) to rise up against Saddam?s regime, the problem is not that the rebellion failed to start but that the US abandoned them when Kuwait was safe. The result of this is that many Kurds were slaughtered by Saddam in revenge. The US may have forgotten this (like they forgot Vietnam) but many Iraqi?s haven?t. The US?s image problem in the Middle East is that for the last 50 years the US has used Middle Eastern states and abandoned them when they had no further use.

BTW I don?t hate Americans it?s just sometimes you need to be reminded that you are very, well to be nice I will call you headstrong. As a friend I should try and stop you from making an ass_out of yourselves.

by noyoki

As if every American is of the same mind of whoever is the leader at the time.

I *HATE* when people judge ALL Americans by a select few. *Especially* when the few includes a Bush. Thats like saying all americans are lazy, violent, a-holes, just because some people are and they've made the news or attracted attention. I could say all Jewish people are greedy, all French people are obnoxious and think they are better than everyone, black people are all in violent gangs, and all Asians are hard-working, over-achieving people. However I don't because that's something like being called... oooh... racist?

Saying "All of" whatever is "this", will only lead you to trouble when you find out they are just the 'sqeeky wheels'.

You want to stop America from looking like an ass? Write to the damn president. HE's the one making the decisions, lord knows *I* didn't vote for either of them, nor have I agreed with their actions.

Oh, and I, at least, didn't forget. Actually, I said it in my last post. But I couldn't do anything about it as I wasn't even in high school yet!

by sleepin'dawg

violence is the last resort of the incompetent.(Bush?) Having said that however, as I see it, a War with Iran, under its current leadership, is inevitable. Aside from strategy, tactically it would be best to take them out before they have an operational nuke in there possession because their current leadership is either too fanatical or too stupid and will use it. Once that happens any moral restraints to make a nuclear response will be removed and it won't be with strategic nukes, it will be with the tactical variety. There are more then enough of those in the armories of the western armies and those of Israel to leave that particular corner of the middle east glowing in the dark for the next couple of centuries. From the strategic viewpoint, the armies are already in place. Take a page from the Israelies and make a preemptive strike now. Yes lives will be lost but more lives will be lost and/or affected adversely if this thing ever goes nuclear. While you're thinking of that, how will you feel when Australia is knee deep in Iranian refugees suffering from radiation sickness??? Just remember it will be your tax money that will be providing the palliative care and you may end up having to deal with all the religious fanaticism that may accompany a lot of them.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by m_a_r_k

And who are you proposing should declare war? Should the U.S. do another poorly thought out go-it-alone strategy? The UN? Someone else already mentioned it in this discussion, but the best counterweight to a nuke-ified Iran is a strong Iraq. Iraq ain't gonna be strong again for years. Saddam was Iran's enemy and he was wacko enough to keep Iran from doing anything too aggressive. I agree that Iran's nuke intentions are a problem. And their nutjob president (I can't even spell the guy's name) is a loose cannon. I don't know the best solution.

by jck

I am bottling up my bodily gases as we speak...

If I put a lot of French's on some beans and eat them...could I really prosecuted for making mustard gas? :^O

by mjwx

Ok let me clarify my last post. I wrote about America as a state not Americans as individuals. I have found most of the Americans I have met to be good people. People I would proudly call my mate.

Now that that?s out of the way your president is elected by ?popular vote? meaning that 50% or more of your nation agrees with their policies. When a head of state is elected by a ?popular vote? individuals cannot escape blame, so the I didn?t vote excuse doesn?t work. Now to back this up back in the Australians have kicked out one of our PM?s (Prime Ministers) when he fucked up the really badly (I think it had to do with the economy but it was a bit before my time).

Now as part of the American nation and as a part of their electoral process if you don?t like the current state REBEL it?s your right as part of your constitution. If you are not part of the electoral process STOP WHINGING.

As for writing to the president, it won?t work he dismissed your own constitution when it was convenient. Besides we have made our opinions quite well known but the American administration will ignore them as long as they have power. As for our government (Australian) little Johnnie (John Howard) will at the very least loose the next election (at worst look up Malcolm Frasier).

If you want the opinions of other nations I suggest you check out a foreign news site like bbc.co.uk (british) or news.com.au (aussie)

by noyoki

> so the I didn?t vote excuse doesn?t work
No, I said *couldn't* vote. You need to be 18. I was not 18 till I hit my freshman year of college. At the time of Desert Storm/Shield (which was the timeframe you were speaking of), I was still in High School! I was, however, of age for the next election, and voted against Bush for Nader. Then again, against the current Bush. And will again, against him.

In the election b/t Bush and Nader (I forget who the third person was atm), if you REALLY look, combining Nader and the other guy would have meant that Bush did NOT have majority vote. Majority voted AGAINST him, it was just split by 2 people. Many feel that if Nader hadn't run, Bush would not have been president then, and probably would not be now. The majority who voted for Nader, would have voted for whomever wasn't Bush.

As far as impeaching him, what would you suggest I do, voting against him aside? (Because I already do that.) Without up and moving to some Spanish speaking country (because Spanish is the only other language (besides Sign-Language) that I speak) where I likely would not be welcome, or donating money (which I don't have) to the other side, just what would you recommend for my "rebellion"?

Oh, and sadly, I'm not convinced that ANYone we voted for would be much better. Generally an election isn't about choosing the *best* president. It's about picking the lesser of two evils.

As far as the veiws of other countries, I've heard enough "Americans are uncivilized", "Americans are uncultured", "Americans are uneducated", "Americans are lazy" to last me quite long enough. If 5 out of every 6 youths you spoke to from another country said "Wow, you're from Australia? I thought (or 'My mom said that...') Australians were stupid and greedy", I think you'd be annoyed and offended too.

I don't need foreign news to know how ppl think of us, I talk to PEOPLE.

A friend said that the moment she goes to another country, people often mistake her and her husbend for French tourists. And that the moment people find out differently, they are automatically snubbed and assumed to intend to ruin the place of business. (Via graffiti, leaving trash around, etc.)

Oh, and we HAVE impeached a President. Two in fact. Look up Andrew Johnson and William J. Clinton. http://www.infoplease.com/spot/impeach.html

This discussion is closed to new replies.