Discussion Locked

Non-US Citizens *especially*, who would YOU vote for?

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Ok this is sure to be a can of worms, judging by past threads on this board over politically charged issues -- but then that's partly why I'm asking it as well.

This question is for EVERYONE of course, however I'm *especially* interested in the views of non-US citizens or ok I'll say it bluntly...folks who really don't care about the US even.

There is only one condition - you can't say you'd vote for no one because that's a cop out and its too easy to get out of the discussion with that answer.

However anyone who is on the ballot for president is fair game -- this includes even Nader.

Please explain the reasons why.

I'm very much genuinely interested in the feedback on this one.

Thanks.

Tom

26 replies

by pooksmin

...but worth talking about none the less. I am from South Africa and I'm confident that quite a few South Africans have the same view as me. When the Trade centres were attacked, I was devastated and felt a huge amount of compassion for the American people. This, of course, happened in the first year of George W.'s term. Since then, my view has changed 180 degrees. This president must be doing something wrong when it comes to managing the rest of the world's impression of the US. I have visited the US and the people I met were great - I feel sorry for them that they have to be represented by this man. I'm sure that Pres. Bush is a charasmatic guy in private but anyone who wants to destroy natural environments in Alaska for oil needs his values questioned. I'm not pro Democrat nor Republican - the US needs anyone who respects that the US is part of a world full of people with their own cultures and ideals - not someone who forces their own culture onto others and shows no tolerance. Don't come to us for sympathy for the thousands killed in the Trade centre attacks when you're willing to kill just as many innocents in other parts of the world.

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "...anyone who wants to destroy natural environments in Alaska for oil needs his values questioned."

To that I might suggest that anyone who believes that President Bush WANTS to destroy natural environments in Alaska for oil, needs their reason questioned. It's that kind of rhetoric that distorts the real issue, and makes the solution to a problem even more evasive.

Just because a person is in favor of drilling for oil in Alaska, it does not automatically mean that he wants to destroy the environment. What a silly and misguided assumption to make.

To the contrary, there is a large contingent of people in America who actually believe that we can drill for oil in an environmentally friendly way. Why do we think that? Gee, because we are doing it right now. Just because some people want to increase domestic production a bit, so we may become less dependent on foreign oil, it doesn't automatically equate to an ecological disaster.

We can tap into oir own oil AND do it in an environmentally friendly way. I wonder if the folks in South Africa can say the same things when it comes to their mining.

As to the latter part of your message, same old song, different verse, and not in touch with reality.

by pooksmin

I assume that you are from the US and therefore, you probably know a lot more about what's going on there than me (and in turn I know a bit more about SA, and yes, our mines are doing fine thank you). If Pres. Bush IS making an effort to mine in an environmentally friendly manner (yet I'm still not quite convinced considering his approach to the Kyoto treaty) then why isn't the rest of the world seeing it??? I'm not discounting the fact that he may be making the effort - the rest of us just don't hear of it. We are clouded by all of the "bad" things he gets involved in - I just don't think he's talented when it comes to building a good impression of himself. And he's been at it for so long now it's going to take a lot to prove us wrong......

by jamesrl

As a Canadian, I recognise that many of the issues between us have been going on for some time, and frankly its a bunch of congresscritters that harm us most, not the president.

Softwood lumber is a fine example. Canada and the US have a "free" trade agreement. The dispute mechanism was agreed upon. But despite that fact the US has challenged Canada on softwood lumber three times in the last ten years. Each time, the US wants more concessions than Canada will give. The US lets the talks end then charges tariffs on softwood lumber imports(which affects the price of new houses in the US BTW).

Each time it goes to trade court, Canada wins, and the US starts up 6 months later with another challenge. 3 times in court, everytime the same result. Why does it happen? Because the congressmen from lumber producing states have a powerful lobby and can make it happen. BTW the "unfair" accusation from the US is that Canada unfairly subsidises softwood production - but in reality Canada just charges less to lumber companies who cut on federal land than the US government does. And if you look at how much federal land we have, you'd understand why.

Relations were more cordial under Clinton than now, but the issues have not chaged in any case.

I would probably spoil my ballot - Kerry seems protectionist and I think thats pissing in the wind. Bush is often anti-Canadian

James

by mlayton

...who will focus a lot on the International policies and representations, but let's also remember the president plays a domestic role as well. My son will be starting school in just under 4 years - I can't suffer through another term of Bush's dismal educational policies and priorities. So Kerry will get my vote in hopes that the domestic situation, especially in regards to education, will improve in time to affect my son.

by maxwell edison

.
President Bush is in favor of giving you a tuition voucher so that you, as a parent who accepts full and total responsibility for the children you bring into this world, can decide what's best for your own child, and choose whatever educational environment you deem appropriate. John Kerry, on the other hand, is in favor of forcing you to send your child to the government run school of the government's choosing, teaching the agenda they deem appropriate, even if the school has a history of failure.

And did you know that it's possible to educate a child at a top-rate private school for the same cost as a dismally run government run school? You don't believe me? Do some research and discover how much - per student - it costs to maintain the government run schools in your district, and compare it to the average cost of private schools in your area. In my case, my district spends $6,500 per student, and a lot of private schools' tuition are in that range or lower. (Yes, some are higher, but it remains the choice of the parents who accepts full and total responsibility for the children they bring into this world.)

In some of the most dismal districts, in New York, New Jersey, Washington D.C, et al, they spend closer to 10 grand per student to send each student to failing government run schools.

Open up competition in the "school business", and supply will increase, quality will improve, and your children will be the beneficiary.

You know, it might just be me, but the choice seems like a no-brainer - especially for parents who accepts full and total responsibility for the children they bring into this world.

by mlayton

...as you keep saying the "failing government run schools" - I believe the government has some responsibility to ensure that their schools are NOT failing. I am a child of the public education system - and a child of public education teachers - and believe in the power of public education when the government stands up and takes responsibility and ensures that the schools don't have a history of failure and aren't "dismally run". There are better options then going to private schools, and one of them is to fix the system, and that starts with governmental education policies beyond just saying "go to another school, look you have a choice."

by maecuff

There are many areas in this country (mine included) where there just aren't many 'private school' choices. The US is made up of more than the East and West coasts.

by maxwell edison

.
You and I agree, we need to "fix the system".

I'm not suggesting, nor has President Bush suggested, the full and total abolition of the public school system. Not at all. Not even close. What I am suggesting, however, is that if you keep doing what you've been doing, you'll keep getting what you've been getting - only more of it.

Sure, the public school system, in general, needs to be "fixed". (Disclaimer: There are some EXCELLENT public schools. Not all of them are "broken".)

But if we keep trying to fix the existing system by simply doing more and more of the same things, it won't get fixed.

Competition among schools doesn't necessarily mean competition among private schools, although that will certainly be part of the equation. Let them remain public, and let them compete for the public school dollar. If they get better, they will survive and prosper. If they don't get better, the customer (the parent and student) can take their "public education dollar" elsewhere.

And to the folks who say the "rich" (whoever they are) will benefit, I would say that maybe they will. Since they can afford to send their kids to private schools regardless, they would indeed get some of their school tax dollars returned to them in the form of vouchers. But after all, they paid the taxes for the schools, so why shouldn't they? But IN ADDITION, the kids of parents who aren't "rich" (whatever that is) will ALSO benefit by having more - and better - options for their kids' education. Why hurt the latter just because of some "class-envy" rhetoric? (Besides, I'd even support an income limit for those who can receive vouchers, so the bulk of the dollars would go to the less-fortunate families - and so would President Bush.)

When has a monopolistic system not resulted in a poorer product AND higher prices? And conversely, when has true competition in a free market not resulted in a better product AND lower prices?

Like I said, this one is a no-brainer, at least if you look at it rationally.

by mlayton

..for me. What is an issue for me is that "No Child Left Behind" (which yes, I realize both Kerry and Bush supported) does not do enough for arts, music, social studies, civics, or languages within our schools.By reducing the core curriculum and reducing funding for these, especially on an elementary level, students who could excel in school run the risk of losing interest. By reducing overall exposure to languages and the civics of society, we are continuing to narrow the view of the world, rather than promoting the extended global view which should be more prominent in today's interconnected society. I can already tell that my child learns well when we apply things with music. This gives me hope for his math skills - since they are interconnected in many ways - but if music instruction falls by the wayside, where does that leave him? Yay for reading, math, and science, but without a well-rounded education, it will be hard for our children to get ahead in the global society.

by maxwell edison

.
It's all the same, when you get right down to it. If you place value in a particular core curriculum, you should certainly have the prerogative to send your kids to a school that places an emphasis on such a curriculum. You shouldn't be held hostage and have your school choice limited by some government bureaucrat or government program. What if I place value in a different kind of curriculum? Why should I be held hostage, and forced to accept someone else's "values"?

Moreover, you skipped over entirely the part of my message that suggested we already spend enough on the schools - $6,500 per student in my district alone. Half the private schools in my state have a tuition substantially lower than that, and their success rates are much higher.

Why is it that "throwing money" at an issue is always the right answer in the eyes of many people?

by maxwell edison

.
Forgive me, but I don't understand what point of yours I proved. (It's late.) Will you rephrase?

But on Kyoto, the U.S. Constitution requires that a treaty be sent to our Senate for its approval. Moreover, two-thirds of the U.S. Senate, not just a simple majority, must approve of a treaty - any treaty - before it can become law. In the summer of 1997, the U.S. Senate voted against entering into the Kyoto treaty by a vote of 95-0 (5 Senators did not vote). Sure, President Bush is against the Kyoto treaty, but so were 95 U.S. Senators in 1997 - about half Democrats and half Republicans, and just about the same number are against it today.

The Kyoto treaty was (is) plagued with problems and inconsistencies, at least that's my understanding. (No, I haven't studied the issue, nor do I care to.) I suppose that's why the USA is not the only industrialized nation NOT to ratified Kyoto. Do a little research and discover what other industrialized nations are against it.

Without getting off on a Kyoto tangent, let's just say that it was not a good deal for America to enter into. Whatever you heard about our rejection of it, and whatever spin was put on that, is unknown to me.

What I do know, however, is that President Bush was not the president in 1997, and even if he did try to push it through our Congress today, they would reject it again. And for good reason, from what I understand. If you want to "blame" anybody, blame our Congress, not President Bush. But like I said, I really don't want to go off on that tangent.

by pooksmin

Lets not get onto the Kyoto tangent :-) The point that you have proven: what I, as a non US citizen, see and hear of President Bush (along with many other non US citizens, otherwise this discussion would never have been initiated)is HUGELY different from the view of many US citizens. Which I suppose isn't so surprising as you live there and I don't. BUT it is a problem when the actions of a man (who of course is influenced by senators, congress members and the list goes on..)has lead to a general feeling amongst many non US citizens of contempt, and sometimes downright hate, against the US. The IMPRESSION Pres Bush is portraying is one of an arrogant, greedy, inarticulate man who believes he wields the power to dictate to others how they should live. Like I said in my first posting, I've visited the US - and you guys deserve better then this man. And I know that many of you feel the same - anti-war demonstrations, movies like Fahrenheit 9/11 all show that it's not just non US citizens feel this way.

by maxwell edison

.
You said, ".....The IMPRESSION Pres. Bush is portraying is one of an arrogant, greedy, inarticulate man who believes he wields the power to dictate to others how they should live."

With all due respect, as a point of accuracy, I might suggest that the impression other sources are giving you is portraying him as such.

I'll give you two examples of this phenomenon, that illustrate what I mean. One of them can be found in our very own messages in this very own thread.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but when you said, "....considering his approach to the Kyoto treaty....", I assume you formed such an opinion based on what you have been seeing/reading in various news sources in your country.

Here's President Bush's actual stand on Kyoto:

"I oppose the Kyoto Protocol because it exempts 80% of the world, including major population centers such as China and India, from compliance, and would cause serious harm to the US economy. The Senate's vote, 95-0, shows that there is a clear consensus that the Kyoto Protocol is an unfair and ineffective means of addressing global climate change concerns. As you also know, I support a comprehensive and balanced national energy policy that takes into account the importance of improving air quality. Consistent with this balanced approach, I intend to work with the Congress on a multi-pollutant strategy to require power plants to reduce emissions of sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, and mercury. Any such strategy would include phasing in reductions over a reasonable period of time, providing regulatory certainty, and offering market-based incentives to help industry meet the targets. I do not believe, however, that the government should impose on power plants mandatory emissions reductions for carbon dioxide, which is not a pollutant under the Clean Air Act. A recently released DOE Report, Analysis of Strategies for Reducing Multiple Emissions from Power Plants, concluded that including caps on carbon dioxide emissions as part of a multiple emissions strategy would lead to an even more dramatic shift from coal to natural gas for electric power generation and significantly higher electricity prices compared to scenarios in which only sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides were reduced. This is important new information that warrants a reevaluation, especially at a time of rising energy prices and a serious energy shortage. Coal generates more than half of America's electricity supply. At a time when California has already experienced energy shortages, and other Western states are worried about price and availability of energy this summer, we must be very careful not to take actions that could harm consumers. This is especially true given the incomplete state of scientific knowledge of the causes of, and solutions to, global climate change and the lack of commercially available technologies for removing and storing carbon dioxide. Consistent with these concerns, we will continue to fully examine global climate change issues - including the science, technologies, market-based systems, and innovative options for addressing concentrations of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. I am very optimistic that, with the proper focus and working with our allies, we will be able to develop technologies, market incentives, and other creative ways to address global climate change."
- President GW Bush

Now that seems like a pretty reasonable approach. Moreover, when it really came down to a vote in the USA, President Bush had nothing to do with it at all. Why do you have the impression that he, somehow, single-handedly struck it down?

I was in another discussion with an Australian who absolutely swore that President Bush said that he wanted to rule the world. Why was this Australian given the impression that President Bush wanted to rule the world? Not because President Bush said it, but because someone reported that he said it. It was a blatent fabrication.

Neither you or the Australian was correct in your "impression". I could cite hundreds of such examples, if I wanted to take the time.

In my opinion, President Bush is inaccurately portrayed around the world. Why? I don't really have a good answer without risking going into the tired-old rhetoric about a biased media, but misleading people is certainly a possibility, and I gave two such examples of it happening.

Agree or disagree with his policies, that's all fine and dandy. But he is not arrogant. He is not greedy. He is not inarticulate. He does not believe that he wields the power to dictate to others how they should live. Those things are false, and I'm certain that you did not form those "impressions" by following the actual person, reading the actual speeches, seeing the actual events first hand, but rather reading and listening to what others have said about him.

Why does this happen with such frequency? I have no idea. What can I do about it? All I can do is try to explain in a civil way why those things are extremely inaccurate.

Why were you under the impression the President Bush "was handling Kyoto" in any particular way at all, when, in reality, it was our U.S. Congress's handling of Kyoto? Because someone else, apparently, convinced you as much. It's obviously inaccurate, as we now know. So the bigger question is why do you continue to believe inaccurate sources?

by tomsal

I never think that one candidate is all "hope and glory" or has all the answers, however this time around I will say I'm finding it harder than before to make my decision.

I know the world community at large just simply wants Bush gone -- and that's the only reasoning or rationale they need to make "just get him out! period.".

I'm not comfortable with Kerry or Bush, but yet I wish to exercise my right to vote at the same time.

Bush - the main reasons he irks me (besides the fact he sounds like a bumbling fool half the time when it talks) I don't like how the whole Iraq thing was handled and I don't think our country should of got locked into such a war that takes away the lives of brothers, fathers, sons..and costs us billions upon billions of dollars on such a notion as "let's liberate the Iraqi people!". It didn't look that cool either when there are no large amounts of WMD found either (outside of the few thousand pounds of nerve agent they found - but I was expecting HUGE hoards of WMD capable of killing millions).

When the towers were knocked down its right that our government got pissed. Its right we wanted blood. However, and I thought and read about this a lot since then, today if you ask me if I think Saddam (or Iraq) had anything to do with the towers..my answer is "no, I don't think they did."

Now Kerry...he's just someone who appears fake to me through every pore in is body. Every meet someone new and you just get a vibe about the person that isn't good? That's what I get about Kerry. I think he is a BS artist from his first commercial on TV. Every political figure is a BS artist, the problem is most (if not all) are good at "pretending" to be genuine, Kerry doesn't even have that skill down.

It would be scary to see him president.

by nd_it

I am in the same boat. I too want to exercise might right to vote, but don't care for the options too much either. Kerry just doesn't strike me much as a leader, especially in a time of conflict. Even though I think Bush fudged the reasons of why we are in Iraq, I think he is a man of convictions and sticks by what he says whether you agree with him or not, he is not back and forth like Kerry.

On the other hand, I don't think Bush has done a good enough job of mending relations with our allies, which I feel even though I believe we are a super power and leader of the free world, we should start acting like it. We do need countries in our corner, and we need to be a place of opportunity and a place where people feel they can come to live that opportunity just like my ancestors did more than a century ago.

I actually wish it was John Edwards for president, not John Kerry. John Edwards relates more to me and more to the people of my state I think, (even though I am sure it will vote Republican again). He comes from rual America, small town, blue collar, doesn't forget about his roots.

What to do, what to do...VOTE!

by garion11

You know after I saw him talk, I felt the same way. I felt like the positions should be switched. He should be running for President and Kerry should be his VP. He came off as much more real and if he was running instead of Kerry, I'd have voted Democrat this November.

Another thing that can throw this election up in the air, I wouldn't be surprised if Bush got rid of Cheney and picked Rudy as his VP.

by mlayton

it's time for a change of government. I support a government that shares my values. I never said I support "throwing money". I do support responsible education, recognizing the value of the students as a whole - and school choice is not the same as initiating changes in the government sponsored core curriculum. It's not even close.

by pooksmin

You're right - of course my views of Pres Bush are based on what I see in the media - and so are yours. And of course Bush doesn't "single-handedly" run his country - no president does, they all have advisors etc etc. All I know for sure is that something has gone very wrong in the last three years with respect to the world's attitude towards the US. As for your comment that I believe "inaccurate sources": you've participated in the other TR discussion on media censorship in the US - and I think you should be asking yourself the same question. There was so much censorship in SA during the apartheid era - since then things have come full circle - I am exposed to the views from South African news, CNN, SkyNews, BBC News, Chinese News, African Arabic News, (the last two with subtitles ;-)), even a bit of Al-Jahzeera . Can you say the same? I respect your opinion and you do seem to be backing it up with good evidence unlike some on the censorship discussion (and it's a perk that I'm conversing with someone who has sufficient vocabulary to dull the need for profanities:-)) All I'm saying is that I'm not the only one with these opinions. And perhaps we are putting too much of the blame on Bush alone - I think this feeling of resentment has been building up for a while (the attacks on the Trade Centres were probably planned way before Bush came into power). I think the US needs someone who can radically change the US's approach to international affairs, and I don't think Bush, along with his administration, are the ones to do it. If you are happy with the way Bush manages domestic affairs, that's great - I can't comment on that because I really don't experience it. But I urge American citizens (some, not all) to realise that the "American dream" will be rudely awoken if international relations (with ALL nations) are not treated with respect.

by tomsal

Seriously,

let's "pretend" that Rudy would be tapped for Bush's VP...since I'm tettering on the line between Bush and Kerry anyway, Rudy would tip me over to Bush for this election. Put aside Rudy's relationship woes in the past, I have to say I like Rudy a lot as a leader. I thought he was pretty decent before 911 but my did he impress me during and after 911. He, in my opinion, showed a textbook example of how to LEAD a nation through a time of crisis.

Besides...please make someone worthy - remember in 2008 everyone is already saying "Hillary!" AGHAST!!! GULP! UGH!!!

by nd_it

There's a scary thought. I think it's all part of a consiracy theory, GWB to win re-election, to setup Hillary for 2008. Is there is disruption of the space time continum (sp?) :)

Seriously though, I think Rudy would be a good choice for a VP, but there is something about John McCain's charism that I like. IMO, he should be the one in the White House.

by maxwell edison

.
You said that you "support a government that shares your values". I, on the other hand, support a government that respects individual values and individual liberties. And I must ask, on which basis was the U.S. government conceived and founded? I assure you, it was the latter.

by mlayton

A government that respects individual values should respect more than math, science, and reading, and support an individual's exploration of their entire being, leading to more well-rounded citizens, without the solution being that you can, but they won't provide it. That's just silly. The current educational policies do not provide for the citizens of the country and half-assed policies are not the answer.

by maxwell edison

.
....that you won't concede my points. And it's equally obvious that we are both forming our opinions and desired sulutions on a different set of core principles.

I don't want the government to tell me what my values should be, not in school, and not in life. If you want schools that create a citizenry that's consistent with the government's defined set of "values" and criteria, look to China. Now there's a great model.

In the meantime, this dead horse is beaten to death (intentional pun), so let's just agree to disagree. It's too bad, however, that you are trying to dictate to other parents how they should educate their kids. It's that kind of sentiment that causes me to spent 8 grand a year to send my son to a private school.

(I know, I said that many are below the $6,500 my district spends. But I chose the absolute best one. And being the kind of parent who accepts full and total responsibility for the child I brought into this world, it was the right decision.)

This discussion is closed to new replies.