Discussion Locked

Obama misspoke.. or did he?

0 helpful
106 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

When one speaks off the cuff it is usually done openly and without guile. When one is speaking the truth one does not hesitate in their responses. Barak Obama did not hesitate when he spoke about his Muslim faith. I believe this is because his faith is based on a history of being raised as a Muslim and then being immersed into "Black Liberation Theology" as a young adult.

Do I believe Obama is a Muslim? In part yes. His father is a Muslim, his grandfather is a Muslim and (from what I?ve read) he attended Muslim schools as a young child. Additionally, being immersed in the "Black Liberation Theology" movement for so many years he cannot credibly call himself a Christian as that movement does not identify itself with the tenets of Christianity.

Does this remove him as a viable candidate for President?
As a matter of opinion I would have to say no.

The United States of America is inherently a secular nation. We are a country that was founded on religious freedom and the first amendment to our constitution forbids the government from making any law restricting the free expression of any religion (The fact that a decidedly liberal judiciary has decided to interpret that part of the constitution exactly opposite to the clear language it is was written in is a topic for a whole other discussion).

My point is: He should not disavow a particular part of his past, his religiosity or his makeup to appease certain voters. He is who he is, and he should not try to paint himself as something he is not all for a few votes.

There are certain ideologies and belief systems that are at their very heart prejudiced and racist. Does Sharia Law identify everyone (both man and woman, or the believer and the infidel) equally? Does the Black Liberation Theology movement promote inter-racial peace and harmony? Ultimately, I am saying that a president must firstly consider themselves an American above all other things. A president should not consider themselves a "Black-American" or an "Asian-American" first as this presupposes another ideology before that of the American. I want a president who will think of America first!

Note - I've changed this from its original posting in an effort to clarify my intended supposition.

Edited ? Corrected the amendment mistake. See what happens when I type really fast!

106 replies

by gate keeper

"Do I believe Obama is a Muslim? In part yes. His father is a Muslim, his grandfather is a Muslim and (from what I?ve read) he attended Muslim schools as a young child."
--------------------------------------------
let me correct a misunderstanding here:

being a Muslim is not hereditary i.e your father and his father for 100 generations might have been Muslims ... it does not automatically make you a Muslim.

as far as I know most major religions are the same .. you are not born into a religion you choose.

what in your opinion does Obama have to do or say to be accepted by you to be a christian ?

by protiusx

I am not suggesting that one?s religion is based on one?s parentage. What I am saying is that it is far more likely that a person who is raised in a family and a culture that espouses a certain religion tends to conform to those ways. More specifically, I was stating that there are fundamental lessons one learns at a very young age that tend to guide or influence ones decisions throughout the rest of their lives.

It is not for me to say whether someone is a Christian or not. However, there lacks a clear understanding today in America what it means to be a ?Christian?.
To be a Christian one must believe that Jesus Christ is the son of God, is God, is born of a virgin, died on the cross, rose from the dead three days later and did so to pay for our sin and to be the ONLY conduit to salvation. One cannot work one?s way into heaven. It is a gift that must be received.

Black Liberation Theology is a political movement garbed in the raiment of a religion.

by ic-it

How ingrained do you think it could be from a father whom by all accounts did not practice it? Obama went to a school that had Muslims present, he also went to a Catholic school. Do you think he may be a closet Catholic?
The BLT thing was wrapped in Christianity.
And Elvis is really dead. ;-)

by delbertpgh

You say, "I am not suggesting that one?s religion is based on one?s parentage. What I am saying is that it is far more likely that a person who is raised in a family and a culture that espouses a certain religion tends to conform to those ways."

You are suggesting, unmistakably, that he's a Muslim. Once a Muslim, always a Muslim. His father was over the hill by the time he was two, and his mother, though an atheist, was the product of a Christian family. He was raised for many years in the home of that family, and got a Christian upbringing. He attends an enthusiastically fundamentalist church as an adult. I'd say that if he picked up unerasable religious tendencies as a child, they were Christian. I see no reason to doubt his Christian identity, only coincidence falsly presented as evidence.

Your other core issue, "Black Liberation Theology", does not figure anywhere in his background. Possibly you are drawing a line connecting the pastor of his former church (the goofy Rev. Wright) and Marxist Caribbean priests? There's zero evidence.

by jmgarvin

"I am not suggesting that one?s religion is based on one?s parentage."

Yes, yes you are. You are implying that since he had a father who was Muslim, that Obama therefore, MUST be Muslim.

"What I am saying is that it is far more likely that a person who is raised in a family and a culture that espouses a certain religion tends to conform to those ways."

In that case Obama is a Catholic or Christian. He was raise by his mother, who by all accounts, was not very religious and raised by his grandparents who were Catholic.

So, does that mean Obama is a Muslim Catholic Christian?

"It is not for me to say whether someone is a Christian or not."

Nice try Sean Hannity. You are clearly implying that he is NOT Christian. It's insulting to my intelligence to state otherwise.

"Black Liberation Theology is a political movement garbed in the raiment of a religion. "

I don't even think I want to touch this with a ten foot pole.

Let me summarize what you've said: "Unless someone believe exactly as I do, they are not Christian."

by nicknielsen

[i]To be a Christian one must believe that Jesus Christ is the son of God, is God, is born of a virgin, died on the cross, rose from the dead three days later and did so to pay for our sin and to be the ONLY conduit to salvation.[/i]

If that's what you must do to be a Christian, what must you do to be Christian?

by oz_media

[i]However, there lacks a clear understanding today in America what it means to be a ?Christian?. [/i]

and

However, there lacks a clear understanding today in America what it means to be a ?Muslim?.

by jmgarvin

Because Obama's father was a Mulsim, who wasn't even in Obama's life, that makes Obama a Muslim?

I thought we'd be through all this about six months ago and it was a agreed this was backwards thinking.

by gate keeper

"There are certain ideologies and belief systems that are at their very heart prejudiced and racist. Does Sharia Law identify everyone (both man and woman, or the believer and the infidel) equally?"
---------------------------------------------
for example you single out sharia law as racist or prejudice ... no doubt you will come out with examples of sharia law with regards to homosexuality, infidels,heretic etc.

sharia law is based upon the same abrahamic laws that you can find in the Talmud and the Bible ... all three hold the exact same positions with regards to many things homosexuality,disbelievers aka infidels aka heretic.

from an objective theological point of view there is not a big difference between them.
unless you are railing against religion in general from the point of view of an atheist ... no single religion holds a monopoly on jihad(Islam) or crusades(Christianity) or ***** (whatever you call what is being done the Palestinians)

ps: the ***** are there so we don't get sidetracked into another debate

by jck

"When one speaks off the cuff it is usually done openly and without guile. When one is speaking the truth one does not hesitate in their responses. "

Barack Obama...MUSLIM?

Lemme give you his own website that debunks your whole basis:

http://www.barackobama.com/factcheck/2007/11/12/obama_has_never_been_a_muslim_1.php

There ya go, ProtiusX. He is not and has never been a Muslim. From his own campaign.

Now...as for others in the campaigns...

Sarah Palin's interview with Charles Gibson on ABC was filled with little "uhs" and pauses and you could tell she was fighting to push out the right words to make things extra nice and politically correct.

Especially trying to turn around that she called the military action in Iraq "God's".

As well, John McCain makes long pauses all the time. However, I give him benefit of the doubt. He is older, plus he's been through hell and back.

I've never seen a staunch so-called Christian conservative move away from God so quick, except for in the movies.

That shocks me. Normally Christians stick up for what they say. She duck and covered quick.

Kinda disappointing. I figured she had more guts than to let the media sway her religious convictions and her beliefs that God leads good people down the right path...including the military.

by nicknielsen

[i]We are a country that was founded on religious freedom and the [u]second[/u] amendment to our constitution forbids the government from making any law restricting the free expression of any religion...[/i] (my emphasis)

Have I misunderstood the Constitution and its amendments all these years?
.
.
.
I thought not.

edit: grammar

by delbertpgh

As a child he spent three years in Indonesia. For one year, he went to a public school, where they opened each day with a prayer to Allah. The other two years, he attended a Catholic school. The public school is the one that gets referred to as a "madrassa", although they taught science and other subjects, and no religion, and they taught boys and girls together.

By the way, when I attended Pittsburgh public schools in 1958 through 1962, my classes were opened every day with a prayer. Was I in a madrassa or a seminary? Did that make me a Christian for life?

Beats me how you figure his father, who left him by age two, could have imparted a unshakable religious commitment to Islam to him. Or his grandfather, even. Did he ever meet the guy? Did he remember his dad?

This all seems like an effort to discredit him in the eyes of voters by putting out false evidence for him being a Muslim. Americans won't vote for a Muslim, so the best way to defeat him is to spread a rumor. Do you realize you're a tool?

by mr stumper

I went to Catholic school! Does that mean I'm Catholic? Seriously? Wow...I thought that because I never got Confirmed that I wasn't. Crap...why didn't anyone tell me. All that "pre-marital sex" and stuff...and now I guess I'm goin to hell.

Not to mention the fact that my family is German...I guess I'm a Nazi too! I seriously wish someone would tell me this stuff. Guess it's time to start hating Jews. Which is going to be tough considering I really don't hate anybody.

So...If I'm a Nazi...do I get a cool uniform?

by the scummy one

however you really need to change your Avatar to reflect the Naziism :0
Oh, and make sure to have a cross with it, and some rosary beads... just to make sure there is no confusion :^0

by charliespencer

I distinctly remember you saying you were leaving. It was in your "I'm being censored; poor pitiful me" tantrum. You said it at least twice. Why are you still here?

Obviously we shouldn't have believed those posts. Why should we believe any part of this one?

by jiminpa

I want to make some graphics. I want a fancy waving flag... I want an Umpa Lumpa now... :(

Ok there was my weekly tantrum already :D

by charliespencer

I have the same problem with members of most religions, but it doesn't mean they're unfit (or fit) for elected office.

by jmgarvin

You mean let in the poor, or non Protestant, or those that aren't white, or those that aren't male!!??

Looking at this current election, you are wrong...we can't let them there MUSLIMS in office!!!

by captbilly1eye

 
I've been saving that ever since you suggested the change.

 
Glad ya liked it, sorry 'bout the soda.
:D

 
Besides... it's Saturday. Have a beer or two like me. It makes the bills much easier to deal with.

 


 

by jiminpa

But he was just at my uncle's wedding in August and he looked so healthy. Something must have happened to him when he left the building. :D

by jdclyde

Wright said as much in interviews that is his teachings.

Obama was right there, until it was not politically advantageous anymore.

by mr stumper

Being a member of a local church is paramount to making the preacher a "mentor"?

Tell me who your pastor is so that I can get transcripts and dessiminate every single word that your mentor says!

Seriously, what about all the pandering the loony right (Bush, McCain, Reagan) does to the fanatical evangelists?

by jdclyde

It was Obama that used that label until it came out what a racist git he really is. I know it has been over 3 days since Obama said it, but try to keep up.

You can make excuses all you want, changes nothing.

You can try saying someone else is just as bad, reflects pathetically upon you, and changes nothing.

Obama talks about his religion more than any other politician, past or present, that I can think of. Heck, even the "rev" Sharpton and "rev" jackson don't talk about religion as much.

by jdclyde

If I hold someone up to the world, and say they have been the biggest influence in my life and have shaped my spirituality, (as Obama did) then yes, his views ARE relevant.

You can make all the excuses you want.

You can overlook anything that you dislike if you want.

This man was held up as the single biggest influence, mentor, and friend for decades, of Obama. Are you going to TRY to say Obama isn't a lying punk for pretending to not know what a hateful racist git the man is?

Could one of your friends be so hateful, and you not realize it for decades? No.

Silly me, I always forget that for a Democrat, character is not a trait that is valued.

by jdclyde

oh wait, it is still politically allowed to go after them. Silly me.

It is only the Muslims that you are not ALLOWED to talk negatively about.

by jmgarvin

Race, creed, religion, fart smell, amount of money in he bank, or sexual preference should never enter into the equation...

Unless of course they're Mormon (that's what the MSM told me) ;-)

by oz_media

I agree.

I also see no reason to judge his ability to be a political leader, of a country that does not discriminate based on religon, because of his religious convictions.

The whole concept is hypocritically flawed.

by jdclyde

I would trust a Mormon before I would trust a Muslim, if I were to have to vote by religion.

Good thing that will not come to a vote, huh? Let the people trying to distract from any real points continue worrying about the religion of each.

If people waste their time attacking Obama the muslim, they distract from attacking Obama the Marxist for change. America is a great country, but he will "change" that, and all you will be left with is "change" in your pocket when he is done taxing.

by jdclyde

to most people, muslim equals subjugation of women, beheading of anyone they disagree with, and an orgy in heaven if you kill the infidels.

Maybe the liberal medias excessively biased coverage of Iraq is starting to back fire, huh? Instead of scaring Americans out of Iraq, it has painted the extremists as crazy people.

Is there any wonder people would be uncomfortable with a muslim leader?

by oz_media

I agree that it is the media that has blown things out of propotion and that they constantly miguide the public.

However, this also illustrates the blatant stupidity of most people to not question and investigate news. It is OUR jobs as citizens to seek out more information and confirm or reject such BS from the media.

It's as bad as people who listen to political jargon and use it to vote.

People need to take responsibility for their own actions, and that includes questioning media news, questioning the government and building an opinion based on research, proper research.

People don't question the government, this blows my mind because it is our jobs to question our leaders and hold them accountable for government action/inaction.

It is out duty to make sure the press is scrutinized so as to keep THEM in line.

The reason the press gets away with this Enquirer style reporting is because nobody really questions it. If it was held under a microscope, they would be more incluned to report truth and retain integrity as a news source.

If it is on CNN, many people believe anything they say, however the same goes for all other biased sources (thank God for SNOPES), its just a matter of finding one that lies by telling you what you WANT to hear.

In the end I keep coming back to the same thing; the more people I meet, the more I respect the bear I saw in the woods this weekend, what a smart bugger to just get on with his life and ignore the ridiculous world around him. Compared to wildlife, our so called advanced culture is quite simple and rather stupid.

As Freddy Mercury said:

"If there's a god up in the sky,looking down,
what must he think of, what we've done
to the world that he created."

Sometimes its embarassing to be human, I get these feelings when I return from a trip and see just how in tune and synchronized the rest of the world's natural creatures are.

We are just a bunch of buffoons who think we are an advanced civilization, what a laugh that is.

Mankind is like cancer to the world, it did much better without us and will do much better again, once we are all gone.

by jmgarvin

The MSM hates thinks like FactCheck.org and the blogosphere (blech...I can't believe I just used that term).

Finally, we're seeing people take power BACK and find out what is really happening in the election process.

by tonythetiger

[i]However, this also illustrates the blatant stupidity of most people to not question and investigate news.[/i]

Turn to another channel and watch THEIR news?

Read blogs?

Who CAN you (we) trust?

by ic-it

of only change in your pocket.
That has been dispelled in numerous postings. With Obama's tax plan the average middle class taxpayer will gain about 5%. With McCain's it is about 3%.
Now Greenspan has gone on record stating that McCains plan Will bankrupt America unless huge cuts in Federal spending are inacted (like that is going to happen). McCains plan will cost us about 3.3 trillion dollars in deficet.
So it would be more accurate to say McCain's plan will leave us with only change (or lint) in the pocket. ;-)

by ic-it

who says a Muslim gets more of a free pass than a Morman? The right wing will attack a candidate from either of those faiths.

Side stepping the tax comments? Hmm.

by delbertpgh

Quote, "Oh, we shouldn't discriminate against Mormons?
oh wait, it is still politically allowed to go after them. Silly me."

You sure ain't talking about Democrats. You might wish you were, but that wasn't who unfairly circulated prejudicial judgements against ole Mitt. I guess if you're a Republican, you maybe managed to discriminate against Mitt and the Mormons. It was Republican hillbilly voters who were busy circulating the story that Mormonism is a "cult" instead of a religion. And it sure wasn't Democrats who voted Romney down in those Republican primaries.

I actually didn't mind Romney as a Presidential possibility, that is until I saw him run for the office. As governor, he was a moderate (translate to Republican-speak: "extreme liberal") who took balanced positions and tried to deliver good government. As a candidate, though, he tried to run to the right of Cheney while sounding dumber than Bush, apparently believing these were the necessary qualities to attract what has turned out to be the Palin constituency.

Hmm... maybe if he wore his hair in a bun and shot moose, he'd have gotten further.

by jdclyde

when the media was seen as the watchdog of government, until they found it was to their advantage to control instead of report.

"reporters" are a dead breed, and left in their place are opinionists.

Unfortunately, there are so many whackjobs blogging as well.... :(

We are left with such a horrible selection because this is who the media put up for us. It was MEDIA coverage of Mit that knocked him out of the running and put one of the weakest candidates up there. This makes it less likely for him to win, and if he does, he is a lot more liberal in many of his views, so it is still a win, while the rest of us all lose.

by jdclyde

his many redistribution plans are going to as he said "hurt" people.

Like was discussed a few months ago, his plan to have a tax paid to go to other nations, run by the UN. If individuals want to donate to other countries, let them do so. I don't think obama should be wasting my money over seas worrying about their poor when people are hurting plenty here, thanks to jobs being sent overseas, and sucking money out of our economy and sending it to other nations that will sell us oil, laughing that we are to stupid do use our own. They are laughing all the way to the bank, as we sell future generations down the river.

Obama will never get my vote.

by gate keeper

JD are you just trying to score a cheap point here .. or do you seriously believe

"It is only the Muslims that you are not ALLOWED to talk negatively about."

let me remind you .... this whole thread and this topic revolves around obama allegedly being a Muslim ... as if that is enough to disqualify him from running for office.That is the underlying message here is it not ...Obama is a Muslim therefore not fit to run for office ?

I can drag up threads in TR .. where Muslim-bashing love fest was being held.

forget talking about Muslims negatively it is no longer even politically incorrect to outright racially disparage them as a whole.

by delbertpgh

"After listening to Obama and his plans
his many redistribution plans are going to as he said "hurt" people. Like was discussed a few months ago, his plan to have a tax paid to go to other nations, run by the UN."

Usually, I find people confine their delusions to something that can fit on a bumper sticker, but that doesn't fit you. You're the total package. You're running down the fantasy highway in a 409. Go, Speed Racer! Not that I'm suggesting you're Japanese, of course. If you were, you might start voting against yourself.

by jdclyde

talking out in the real world, in the mass media.

Now that we are all on the same page, care to try again?

by protiusx

Okay, let me be as clear as I possibly can for you. Generally, one tends to identify with the precepts (both religious and social)learned from one's parents. Notice I said GENERALLY.
If we are going to have a discussion on what a Christian is we really should have a common understanding of what we both "think" a Christian is. I mean do you think someone who does NOT believe in the divinity of Christ is a Christian? How about someone who thinks that there are loads of gods and Christ is one of them? Is that person a Christian? I was merely trying to provide some context as to what is conclusively agreed upon as what a Christian is. There are a lot of Christian's who disagree with one another on tenets of faith but they ALL believe in the common underpinnings of the Christian faith.

by charliespencer

Can you say why you think he cannot, without invoking his religious beliefs, regardless of what they may be?

by gate keeper

... whatever it is .. can i have some ...cuz it must be some strong sh!t

let me get this right .. you a think TR (a community of educated professionals) are prejudiced against Muslims.. but people out in the real world .. treat them with kiddy gloves.

How many people do you know that hold all Muslims accountable for 9/11 ?

cuz i know literally dozens ... and that's not even south of the border .. I imagine the number would be much greater.
--------------------------------------
EDIT

I just came across these words of yours .. in this thread

"Thanks to media coverage
to most people, muslim equals subjugation of women, beheading of anyone they disagree with, and an orgy in heaven if you kill the infidels." -jdclyde

it appears you were just playing dumb after all

care to try again ?

by jmgarvin

Oh, it smells like carrots and throw up. Oh, that could gag a maggot. I smell like hot sick. Ass and a dead carcasss. Oh, even stink would say that stinks. You know when you go in an apartment building and you smell other peoples cooking on each floor, and you go "what are they cookin?" That plus crap.

by charliespencer

With the hem of the skirt Scotch-taped up at least four inches above the knee.

"C'mon Virginia, don't make me wait,
You Catholic girls start much too late."

by jdclyde

Is that an addition after leaving the house? :0

[i]
"I don't usually say things like this to girls your age,
but when I saw you Coming out of the school that day,
that day I knew, I knew, Ive got to have You,
Ive got to have you."

by boxfiddler Hot topic

He's just another politician. Political success requires great skill in lying and manipulation. I thought we'd figured that out by now.

What, I'm wrong again? ;)

by jdclyde

"still".

Again would indicate you STOPPED being wrong at some point and started up again.... :p

by jdclyde

I am not sure if it is an inability to comprehend on your part, a poor job of communicating on my part, or a combination of them. I suspect people reading what they want to see in other peoples writings, combined with personal blind spots has made this calm attempt on my part to explain, a waste of time.

Since you don't understand or agree with what I am saying, you can go ahead thinking I am doped up or mentally deficient if it gets you through the day. I give.

by jdclyde

this was based upon listening to him talk in the DNC debates and during the primary's.

Not from blogs, or any outside source, but listening directly to the man, back when he and Hilary were debating "free" healthcare and such.

If you choose to not hear what he is saying, when he says it, that is your choice.

by charliespencer

Or roll up the waist several inches, accomplishing the effect of raising the hem. Girls who knew how to sew used a product called Liquid Hem (or something similar). It was designed to hold fabric temporarily while the pieces were sewn together, but it worked well to temporarily hold the hem above the mandated minimum. It's also much more interesting than the original topic.

by oz_media

BUT, just as we find here, you hear a story and see who else has reported it (not just reposted the same story and credited the first writer). When yuo find siz or seven credible sources that all say the same thing in a different way or in their own words from their own reports, its a good indication of consistency and credibility.

If you find ONE story that counters or corrects the point, thne you have some real diggint ot do, find out which story has credibility or is basked by facts that can be confirmed. Just as a reporter does his homework, so must we.

No we will not always get the correct idea but it certaionly beats taking CNN verbatim or any others for that matter. I find many people will instantly discount a source, just becaiuse of the source. Regardless of who said it or how often they are wrong, there is always SOME truth in it but we must disect what is said, who said it and try to determine WHY it was said.

All I am saying is don't rely on a single news source for your news. I hear a story and then instantly jump online and start looking into it and trying to confirm or deny it, whereas I find others that say "ahh, it's CNN they are full of crap" and they never look any further. But what if it actually IS true and yet the instant bias refuses to let you see the truth?

As they say on the X Files, "the truth is out there."

by oz_media

In the current election, we have soem locals that would be tarred and feathered, dragged through the streets and peed on by America, if they were running for office there.

While driving in Delta yesterday, very East Indian and Pakistani dominated city, I saw the following campaign signs.

Conservative: Sandeep Pandher
http://www.conservative.ca/?section_id=1051&linkTo=true&districtId=1801
Note that his bio states that although he was born in Edmonton (Alberta) he grew up in India. now if that was teh USA, would it not be, 'Although I grew up in India, I was born in Edmonton"

But as Delta is predominantly East Indian, they won't vote for a Canadian if an Indian is on the ballot. His key is that he IS Indian.

Surrey NDP MLA - Jagrup Brar
http://nid-1431.profile.bcndp.ca/
"Born in India, Jagrup moved to Canada to study at the University of Manitoba where he earned a Master's degree in Public Administration."

The list goes on and on, we don't care if politicians are muslim, in fact in their areas they actually get more votes for being muslim.

And poeple say Canada is just like the states. LOL, close but not quite, eh?

by jamesrl

There have been times when all the candidates for the three major parties were East Indian.

But most of them here are Sikhs not Muslims.

The Sikh community here is pretty tight, and the Sikh politicians use the community associations well.

My MP is Gurbax Malhi, he didn't live in the riding when first elected (parachute) but got in anyway. Next riding over is the lovely Dr. Ruby Dalla.

Didn't BC have the husband and wife conservative MPs, they were both of East Indian heritage. And BC had a premier who is of East Indian heritage - Usal Dhosanjh.

James

by jdclyde

that is not seen as any kind of racism, but if the same East Indian ran in a NONindian area and was defeated by a nonIndian how is that seen?

Is it racist to vote for "one of your own"?

If not, is it racist NOT vote for someone because they are NOT "one of your own"?

by mr stumper

Yours: Oh, we shouldn't discriminate against Mormons? It is only the Muslims that you are not ALLOWED to talk negatively about.

Also yours: You can try saying someone else is just as bad, reflects pathetically upon you, and changes nothing.

I'm sorry that you consider yourself "pathetic". You should really do something about that self-loathing issue you have. It's really not healthy.

In any case, I looked and could not find a single transcript or video showing Obama referring to Wright as his Mentor. I found tons of quotes of people saying Obama said "Mentor" but no direct quotes.

If you can post one (again, an unedited transcript or video) then I will happily admit that I'm wrong. If not, I'll just assume that it's just another right wing wacko talking point.

Besides, you should keep up, didn't you know the newest scare tactic is that Obama wants to teach sex-ed to kindergarteners? THAT's what you are supposed to be talking about now, or didn't you get the memo?

by jdclyde

You have taken on the debate tactics of pee wee herman, and not looking to discuss or be open to anything.

"councils me"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qpzHQ_PC1uI&feature=related

"like an uncle"
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kP2K4Lhas2o&feature=related

Yeah, it was a real surprise to Obama after 20 years. Got a bridge to sell you....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mXNk5OVLm4k&feature=related

And of course that is before we even take into consideration about his white grandma who avoided black youths based upon their being black, was a "typical white person".

by cactus pete

"Do I believe Obama is a Muslim? In part yes. His father is a Muslim, his grandfather is a Muslim and (from what I?ve read) he attended Muslim schools as a young child."

Where did you read this that has not already issued a retraction/correction? He did not attend a Muslim school, let alone multiple Muslim schools.

If anything, having a diverse background and experiences will help him make sensible and informed decisions - which is much more than I can say for the present administration and what it's party is offering up as a continuation.

by charliespencer

In theory ProtiusX is interested enough in this topic to have scooped it back out of the litter box, but he's only bothered to respond three time since the initial post. One of those was to thank someone for pointing out a typo, so he's only put up two posts of 'substance'.

by mr stumper

First of all there is no mention of the word ?mentor?, no wonder I couldn?t find anything. Get your facts straight.

Secondly, Obama kept referring to Wright as his Pastor who ?like an uncle?, ?counseled? him on taught him about Christianity when he was younger, which is exactly what a Pastor should do. Obama never even implied that Wright has any affect on his political views, nor councils him on politics in any way. It is people like you and the ?liberal media?, who are trying to spin this into a political issue. I wonder why the ?liberal media? isn?t going after McCain/Palin as viciously?

Also, your mention of Obama?s grandmother is another cute little spin on what Obama really meant. Which is that good people who are not necessarily racist can still harbor stereotypical views. Honestly, from many of your own comments, it sounds like he could have been talking about you, JD.

Seriously, you should learn to think for yourself instead of parroting RNC talking points. I realize, while you may not, that the tactic is to continually repeat the same thing over and over again until it becomes ?fact?, but free thinking people will simply be turned away from those using such tactics. It really is getting to the point where people are catching on to the RNC below the belt tactics and are being turned off by it. Even Rove has figured this out.

You know, if I were as brain-washed as you I could twist statements and fact to state that Palin hates jews, Bush is in league with Bin Laden, McCain is a admitted war criminal and Limbaugh goes to the Dominican Republic to have sex with underage prostitutes. I?ve actually heard wackos say such things, with twisted documentation ?backing? it up, but I would never believe them, nor repeat them with serious intent because I have more respect for myself than that.

Keep you ear open for that newest talking point to spread around!

by charliespencer

Did the EPA declare the immediate area a Super Fund clean-up site? Did a new hole open in the ozone layer? Did it smell like at least six other people should feel better after that one? Did wine glasses shatter and small children faint, scarred for life? Did it smell like an opossum crawled up in me about three days ago and then died, an opossum with a wharf rat already three days old up inside it?

My work is done here.

by netman1958

"I wonder why the ?liberal media? isn?t going after McCain/Palin as viciously?"

Excuse me?
They call Palin a Christian fanatic/lunatic/extremist
because they heard she once bought a copy of Neil Diamond's "Brother Love's Travelling Salvation Show"

Give me a break.

by mr stumper

Called "Palin a Christian fanatic/lunatic/extremist
because they heard she once bought a copy of Neil Diamond's "Brother Love's Travelling Salvation Show""

Was it ABC, NBC, CBS, PBS, CNN, MSNBC or FOX?

You seriously cannot tell me that McCain/Palin have been grilled as much as Obama. Of course Palin has had only one interview so far...'cause she's in "media" boot camp right now, learning how to interview. And McCain has only received softball questions.

No questions regarding the Keating five, Rod Parsley (personally think this is about as stupid as the whole Wright thing), or the fact that this maverick's campaign, who keeps talking about "change", is filled with lobbyists for the Oil companies. Or how about the fact that he flipped flopped on the state of the economy not 48 hours ago, or how he stated that those running failed companies should give up their "golden parachutes" but has not asked HIS OWN ADVISOR, Fiorina to give back her 40 million golden parachute for screwing up HP!

Answer me that batman!

by netman1958

Actually I was making a snide remark in an attempt to demonstrate how silly and ridiculous some of the attacks that have come from BOTH camps really are. In reality though, Palin has been attacked and accused of being a Christian zealot in reference to a video of her addressing a graduating class at Wasilla Assembly of God. See this article for an example:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/09/02/palins-church-may-have-sh_n_123205.html

"You seriously cannot tell me that McCain/Palin have been grilled as much as Obama."
Are you kidding? Which of those media outlets you listed do you watch/read? Maybe you just see what you want to see.

"No questions regarding the Keating five, Rod Parsley (personally think this is about as stupid as the whole Wright thing),....."

If you haven't already done so, you might want to take a look at this website:
http://www.factcheck.org/

I think you will find that there has been plenty of crap coming from both camps. The whole thing disgusts me.