Discussion Locked

OK would someone like to tell me just what is going on

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In America now?

Yesterday I was handed a copy of 9-11 In Plane Sight and told to watch it. Well I watched it and dismissed just about everything except what had happened at the Pentagon as within the last few weeks I had seen a story called the "Last Few Seconds" which dealt with the events of what happened at the Pentagon and when I watched this film I got concerned as some things just where not possible.

The main thing that I noticed at first was in the other doco it was claimed the the aircraft penetrated into the Pentagon on the ground floor now I'm no Aeronautical Engineer but I do realize that something that big just can not fit into the ground floor of even an older building with high ceiling's. I'm personally unsure just how high the ceilings in the Pentagon actually are but they have to be under 15 feet and more like 10 feet at best. Now allowing for the fact the the undercarriage was up at the time the aircraft if it actually was a 757 would have to have been flying below ground level to fit under the ceiling of the first floor. Even if it was on a dive trajectory it had to be fairly flat at the point of impact as it entered the building and didn't bury itself in the ground like it would have if it had of been even in a shallow dive let alone a steep dive angle.

In the other computer generated description of the official story of the impact it was told that the only video camera was on a time delay of 1 second intervals so the aircraft was not caught in frame during its decent into the building. But in the 911 story it is claimed that it is a CCD that is filming in real time and the time doesn't match up first the date is incorrect and the time is way out. The crash into the Pentagon was supposed to have happened at 10.00 AM on the 11-9-01 and the time stamp on the camera shows 17.35 hours and the 12-9-01.

Well I can maybe accept the incorrect date being on the camera through some form of error but the time would be a different matter as this was watching a secure area and should have been monitored so at the very least there should have been alarm bells ringing in the monitoring room with at the very least one camera being 7.5 hours fast.

Then I had a good look at the DVD on a computer screen and grabbed still images off the screen and there are several indisputable facts the first being that the second plane to strike the World Trade Center had something on its underside and it was not small either. Whatever these objects where they would have of to be fitted with major modifications to the aircraft to make them stay put at even cruising speeds let alone the high speeds that the actual aircraft was flown at, at the point of impact.

Now the film is typical video footage so it isn't very clear or fast but was made for the mass market to be cheap and not a high resolution variety image capture source so I used a still that I took from the video of the second aircraft which hit the WTC and picked a easily recognizable part the right tail fin which I could count 5 of in that particular still that was captured off the video so as well as being out of focus it is also going far too fast to be captured on the commercial and professional video cameras of the current generation but there is defiantly something there that is 3 dimensional and runs along the axis of the aircraft on either side of the center line, and what is worse is that there is a flash of light just prior to impact that reflects off not only the building but also the fuselage of the aircraft and distinctly shows something underneath that aircraft.

At 1600 times magnification there are no distinguishable things visible except the flash from the front of the aircraft that reflects off the building and the fuselage of the aircraft and whatever it is that is underneath the thing. There is a differencing intensity of the flash whatever it is along the lines of the aircraft and the flash is very bright as it overloads the imaging devices and just goes white then slowly fades to gray the further it gets away from the point of the flash.

Now I've discounted the eyewitness accounts of the incident as being unreliable as the people who where either talking or giving reports where not sufficiently well enough trained to know exactly what it was that they where seeing in that split second just prior to the crash. One of the reporters insisted that the aircraft was not a passenger aircraft but some sought of commercial freight carrier as it had no windows. On this the video is inconclusive so I'm giving them the benefit of the doubt and allowing for both shock and terror.

On examining the only footage of the first aircraft to strike the WTC it also gave off a flash of light just prior to impact but because the angle is almost directly behind the aircraft it is not as noticeable as with all the different angles that are available for the second aircrafts impact.

I've also disregarded the claim that the hole in the side of the Pentagon was only between 14 to 16 feet in diameter as I have no outside proof of this but I can accept that the entry point could only be as high as the first floor but should be much wider. However there just is not the expected wreckage lying around the outside of the Pentagon after the crash either. At the very least the bulk of the wings should have sheared off and been left outside the building no matter how mangled and they should have contained the bulk of the fuel. The relatively small tank in the aircraft would have accounted for the relatively small fire that ensured after the crash. But from aerial pictures taken just after the crash there are no score marks in the ground from the engines which would have needed to be skimming the ground to achieve that point of entry and how it got through the Light poles on the nearby freeway is way beyond me particularly as the supposed pilot was not considered as a capable student and was unable to land a Cessna successfully I can not see him being able to fly such a large aircraft so close to the ground without crashing it before reaching his target. The fact that there where no impact marks on the outside of the Pentagon Walls from the tail plane is also confusing as it should have nearly reached the top of the building and there is no sign of it in the wreckage either.

The one part of one of the engines that was recovered also is not from a commercial aircraft as it is way too small for a bypass jet engine that is used in Commercial Airliners and looks more like one used in a high performance jet engine where noise constraints are not a consideration.

Now according to the official documentary that was shown recently the aircraft disintegrated on impact and proceeded further into the building that it would otherwise do but of course the extremities should have been ripped off and only at most part way entered the building. There are no signs of this happening by the "live footage" that was shot before the outer wall collapsed as all of the window supports where intact and there was no sign of the wings impacting upon these. As mentioned previously the tail plane should have survived the impact more or less in some form of recognizable structure which of course it didn't.

After reviewing all of the footage that was supplied and shown on the numerous news channels there is only one verified crash site and that is in the field in the middle of nowhere and even that doesn't look quite right as the wreckage isn't scattered over a wide enough area, it almost looks as if the aircraft was dropped into place with little to no forward momentum almost as if it was stalled and allowed to fall out of the sky.

I've also dismissed a lot of the so called live reports as being erroneous like GWB saying that he watched TV as the first aircraft flew into the WTC as this was an unexpected incident and was not televised I'm inclined to believe that he saw live footage of the second aircraft fly into the second building of the WTC and misunderstood the implications of what he was being told at the time by the people around him who also didn't know what was happening.

While I do not know what type of aircraft actually flew into the WTC the second one certainly was not a commercial passenger caring aircraft as it would never have been allowed to leave the ground with whatever it is that is hanging under it. Whatever hit the Pentagon couldn't have been a 757 either as the damage just was not wide spread enough and there was not the fire from jet fuel that should have happened also the area around the outside of the impact site was not dug up and carted away as contaminated waste as it would have certainly have been if there had been a jet fuel spillage of that magnitude and there just was not enough fire to support that amount of jet fuel either.

Now this person called Dave von Kleist raised some interesting Hypotheses but they are also unbelievable as well and while some of the facts might fit his theory's I'm inclined to accept that he is attempting to explain away what he has seen by these theory's rather than what the real facts actually are/where.

NOW WOULD SOMEONE LIKE TO ENLIGHTEN ME AS TO WHAT IS HAPPENING OVER THERE?

Incidentally Garrion I do not think GWB is responsible but you are welcome to blame him if you like. :p

Col ]:)

14 replies

by maxwell edison

9-11 In Plane Sight is a conspiracy theory put to film. I haven't seen it, but I never place too much credence in such things.

by hal 9000

So I went and got the CNN DVD which shows exactly the same thing at least as far as both aircraft hitting the WTC.

As I've said elsewhere the flash could have been the airframe collapsing under the pressure of the air being bounced of the building and while interesting I'd be leaving that one to people experienced in air crashes to explain.

But whatever it was under the second aircraft was defiantly there it is shown on the CNN footage and I can see no reason to disregard it as what would be their gain? You have to slow down the video to about 2% speed to actually see it and most would think it was a trick of the light or something painted on the airframe maybe but it protrudes away from the airframe.

Anyway I really don't know it could just be an optical illusion caused by the high speed and low quality recording material but it is if nothing else strange.

Col

by hal 9000

I tend to ignore these as well but in this case I had someone push this down my through insisting that at the very least the second plane that flew into the WTC was an air force refueling "767?" I think it was claimed but I'm not the slightest bit inclined to believe that one little bit either.

However the picture of the hole in the side of the Pentagon seems way too small to me at least and while I can understand that quite a lot of the airframe disintegrated on impact I can not see just how the wings and engines at least didn't damage the window struts of the Pentagon if even in a small way and there should have been some form of impact mark left by the upright part of the tail which just isn't in photos prior to the collapse of the outer wall.

The video of the second aircraft hitting the WTC shows clearly bits of junk coming out of both engines as they impact the building but on the Pentagon there is none of this impact or any other form of intrusion just around the initial point of impact.

Actually what got me thinking about this was the Documentary that was shown recently here on the final few minutes of that flight and what was supposed to have happened just after the impact.

I can also remember quite well the news reports of the time and it was claimed "maybe incorrectly" that because of the construction of the roof of the Pentagon the fire was very hard to extinguish something about Bitumen burning that was on the day of the incident and I do not know just how true it was as like most of the reports then it was mostly conjecture and wishful thinking as to what would make a good story.

As for the flash just prior to contact with the WTC it could have been the cockpit collapsing in on itself because of the shock wave effect of flying so fast toward a unmoving object the air forced in front of the plane would have bounced off the building and applied pressure on the front end of the aircraft maybe enough to partially collapse it.

However the differences in the supposed facts are the most worrying and it is the little things the Official Version has the surveillance camera at the Pentagon on a 1 second delay time exposure and then others are claiming that it was shooting pictures in real time.

It's all way too confusing for this little black duck but I don't like what I'm seeing around me.

Col

by fonken monken uk

Its a bit sensationalist and generally a bit thin on the gorund if they start any form of documentary with a dictionary definition, in this case defining 'Conspiracy' and 'Theory'.

To my mind, that made the whole thing a bit flimsy, but you have got to ask questions, especially how one of the most secure buildings in the country only has 1 camera pointing at that part oif it, and the nearest other camera mysteriously had its tape removed by mysterious men....
And what about all that fuel?

by oz_media

That's actually a pretty cool breakdown, the guy seems to know his planes or has researched them. Not that I have ever felt so inclined to even begin looking for such information.

ONE tiny flaw, he uses the example fo a 3/4 tonne truck to describe the size of a piece of wreckage. While the measurements seem SOMEWHAT accurate, it is NOT a 3/4 tonne truck with 17' or 18" rims. It is a half tonne with 16" stock rims. Minor detail but the writer really emphasized that point, regardless of reaching a similar conclusion. The difference is only 2-4 inches if doubled as explained but as it is JUST a reference it makes no real difference to the point being made.

by hal 9000

You've muddied the waters even more. :)

I have several people here who insist that they can see a refueling boom under the second aircraft but I'm dammed if I can and I'm more inclined to believe that it is wishfully thinking on their part.

However whatever it is under the second Aircraft is defiantly there and I'm unsure exactly what it is maybe open landing bay doors that appear stretched because of the speed and low quality recording material but they are along the central axis of the airframe and in about the right position at least at the front to be the landing bay doors open with the landing gear retracted.

As I said I can count 5 right hand tail fins in that picture so the recording material was being pushed way beyond its limits for accurate images. So my first inclination was to disregard it as unreliable footage.

But the hole shown in the side of the Pentagon to me at least seems all wrong as there should at the very least be impact marks from the engines on either side on the actual penetration point and damage done by the wings along their length which just isn't visible in any of the photos.

But what really got me thinking was the Official story as shown recently where the airframe entered the Pentagon at the ground floor level and there where accounts of people in a conference room directly above the impact site escaping before the collapse of the outer wall through an external window.

I just can not see how something so big could fit into such a low place without doing more damage along the way.

Col

by ippirate

The beat goes on....

Col. In all honesty, if you can figure it out and definitively show a solution, please, I want to be the first to know. It'd do me a lot of good to at least be able to lay this one to rest, right or wrong, truth or farce, whatever. I readily admit that I do not trust the goverment's position on honesty, however I also still retain a faint glimmer of hope that we have not regressed to that point.

I will make a few comments to your post, maybe it will help.

Muddy waters, I apologize, not my intent, just trying to give you something to counter that video.

On the refueling boom. I see no indicator of such. I spent 10 years USAF, firefighter for 7.5 years of that and have observed refuellers from almost every angle possible. I readily admit that I am open to failure but I am generally right on for calling A/C identified from days out. In the case of KC's, there are two in the inventory, the 10 and 135, I don't see a similarity. I just don't buy it.

The "pod" that the video hints at lends more to an RC 135. I think that would be even more difficult to hide from inventory. Possible, but the likelyhood far surpasses what I would be comfortable with.

The hole. I would tend to agree but for two things. First is the sweep wing aerodynamics, the wings would have folded back at impact, from the centerline or fuselage, by virtue of physics and engineering. The second is the collapse. To my observation, any evidence of the impact would have been destroyed when the building collapsed.

The official story, I don't know. I honestly haven't heard that part but I will look into it, sorry I can't comment to it presently though.

On the damage. Col, I would tend to agree with you, it is odd and seems drastically out of place but, it is not uncommon. The thing that I would encourage you to do is research known impacts, look at the damage. Usually it is really odd how little collateral damage there is. Impacts are odd things, at least the ones that I've seen are.

Like I said, I don't honestly know. I hope the best and honestly fear the worst but I don't want to jump without surety.

Sorry for the confusion.

J

by ippirate

The KC's mentioned above are the only two that would fit into the primary descriptions. There are modified 130's, choppers and other smaller aircraft but only those two that approach airline size.

Sorry for the confusion.

J

by hal 9000

It comes with the DVD as a reference point and while I tend to dismiss most of it there is just some truth in what has been placed there.

HTTP://www.thepowerhour.com

It has a few links to other sites which if nothing else are interesting and good for a chuckle.

But the footage that I used was from a CNN DVD on the incident at the WTC so I can not see that they would have any hidden agenda in altering the footage. I didn't trust the footage that came on the movie so I went to another source which the movie claims they got their footage from.

Col

by hal 9000

But as I said what was called a 767 midair tanker aircraft just didn't even look similar to what hit the tower in the video. It could have been a trick of the light as by the time you had enlarged it to a stage where you could see anything closely you had lost so much resolution that the whole thing was pointless.

As for whatever it was under that particular aircraft I'm now inclined to believe that the rear landing bay doors where open with the landing gear retracted and it is just the speed and slow speed filming method used that makes them look bigger than they actually where. As I said I could count 5 right hand tail fins on that still image so it only stands to reason that the landing bay doors if they where open would appear bigger/longer than they actually where. The only thing that I am happy about is the fact that the video presented in the Documentary appears to be identical to that as shown in the CNN release of the 9-11 incident but it has been heavily cut to show what they want to rather than what happened.

But there was one interesting thing that hasn't seemed to have been addressed and that is a cloud of smoke or something about 40 stories high that is shown in only one shot on the Northern side of the Twin Towers I don't know what that was and because of what was under the ground at that site I'm inclined to believe that a quantile of jet fuel found its way into the bottom of the underground car parks or at least toward the bottom and then was somehow ignited. This isn't so hard to believe at all because of the amount of fuel that these aircraft where supposed to have on them all that would be required is a rupture of a lift shaft to allow this to happen.

However I've been talking to a mate of mine who is chief engineer for Qantas and I've actually been looking at the construction drawings of the 757 well at least the ones that are provided to the airframe fitters to work on these aircraft.

There is a very strong mounting to the engine pods and then the wings become disposable in the event of a crash, they are designed to break away and keep the main fuel tanks as far as possible from whatever remains of the wreck. However the hole shown with firemen walking in I'm not overly inclined to believe was at the Pentagon either although several sites have shown it as factual but I just can not see how the resulting fire would have been extinguished before the collapse of the outer wall for these men to be walking in there without better protection. But the official explanation doesn't bear close scrutiny either as it would be impossible to fit a flying 757 into the ground floor of a building in something that resembled some sought of level flight path. There is a problem of Ground Effects which tend to suck the aircraft down violently when in close proximity to the ground. The bigger and faster the aircraft the more violent the effect, I should have already known this as it was something that I did study at UNI and though it was not related to aircraft the same still applies.

Also the height of a 767 sitting on the ground on its underbelly and engine pods is about 35 feet to the top of the tail plane and the engine pods are a good 3 feet below the bottom of the fuselage so I still do not see just how something that big could have got into the ground floor and still allow people in a convention room directly above to survive. I don't know maybe I'm missing something which has not been shown but Allen agrees with me on that point and since he works with those things almost on a daily basis I would tend to believe him.

But as he said even if the aircraft did get in there and he thought it would require some very fancy flying what happened the the broken off wings? Why wasn't there some sought of damage to the outside of the building along the lines of where both the wings should have been and the tail plane hitting the building and for that matter what happened to the tail plane again this is designed to break away in the event of a crash as it carries an auxiliary gas turbine motor to power the aircraft while on the ground with out the motors running. It powers the air-conditioning and hydraulics but the AC is considered as the more important as without that the passengers would be complaining.

I actually learned to day that these aircraft are not all that maneuverable either as the computer or Avionics prevent any violent changes in direction or banking so that the first class passengers don't spill their drinks all over themselves again this has nothing at all to do with aircraft safety but passenger comfort. And it can not be overridden in flight as the person flying the aircraft would loose control of the thing it can be changed on the ground but even then requires quite a bit of time spent to reprogram the Avionics to allow this to happen. It is not just a matter of pulling a plug as that would result in no control at all. These "Fly By Wire" are great things when you think about it as without the Avionics working the plane is un-flyable and in every simulator where this has been tried the total failure of the entire Avionics systems always results in a crash and a nasty one at that as the pilot can not even keep it straight and level they literally just fall out of the sky.

The only other aircraft crash that I can think of that is in any way similar was the French Concord that came down onto the hotel and that basically flattened the place but it fell on it rather than trying to fly through it.

On the one air crash that I did attend the wreckage was spread over a wide area and the smell is something that you never forget all that burnt Kero and airframe parts makes an unforgettable smell.

Today I also had a look at several of the other aircraft crashes and although they where smaller planes like DC10's and the like and old 707's and 727's they where all spread over a large area with recognizable bits on the outer edges of the crash site. I'm told that it is impossible to totally clean up a crash site and 20 years latter you will be able to find small bits on the ground that remain from the crash.

I even read a report of the aircraft that came down over Queens a short time after 9-11 after suffering a catastrophic airframe failure in several different areas almost simultaneous the left hand motor which fell from at about 600 feet was still recognizable when found. That was a really nasty one and probably the worst aircraft crash in recent history. But even without a motor and the Vertical part of the tail plane that aircraft still flew for a few minutes before hitting the ground again over a very large area in a populated zone as well. The report claimed that the buildings that where destroyed by that aircraft limited the area of damage as the buildings acted to prevent the spread of the wreckage any further.

But what I did learn today was that the airframe {except for the cockpit} could have peeled away at the top but the main structure from the passenger compartment floor down should have remained intact in some form and done more damage that what actually happened, then there is the question of just what happened to all of the jet fuel as it couldn't have burnt off so quickly. Maybe a lot of it was collected on the helo pad and funneled into the rain water disposal system that could conceivably account for the major part of the right wings tanks contents but whatever happened the the contents of the left wing tanks is way beyond me. All of the available photos show wreckage thrown out by the initial blast but even what was thrown out by the explosion doesn't account for the bulk of the airframe that shouldn't have entered the building and certainly not the engines. They at the very least should have remained in a somewhat recognizable form and left a heavy impression on the outside wall before they broke off.

Well I really don't know what happened and I'm not overly worried either but I certainly do not subscribe to the idea that some form of armor piecing munition was used in that incident I just can not understand what happened to the bulk of the airframe.

Confused is normal I suppose. :D

Col

by ippirate

Like I said before, I'm still out on this one. I hope that the conspiracy theorists are just that and still completely out to lunch but I also fear that they may not be.

I've seen enough as an airfield firefighter to be able to come up with plausible reasonings on everything surrounding the crash but as an American and given the deep foreboding I feel in my heart over the days to come, I have some very serious doubts as to the events that led to and/or allowed for it to happen.

Join the crowd, just remember, confusion is all the more reason for a search to understanding.

J

by louk

There is another crash you could use for comparison. Back in the late 80's (I think) a cargo plane came down shortly after take off from Schippol airport in the Netherlands. It hit an apartment block. If I remember correctly it was one of the larger Boeings that crashed, not a 747 though.

Lou

This discussion is closed to new replies.