Discussion Locked

One UP for the Climate change sceptics

0 helpful
166 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

166 replies

by maecuff

You gave me a Pulp Fiction flash back with your post title..allow me to assist. You suddenly became Samuel L for a moment. "Oh, you were finished? Well, allow me to retort".

by Member 25348569

And then you change your mind occasionally when some more information comes along. It's allowed.

Not too sure that I'll be around to see whether either camp is right.

:)

by jdclyde

[b]What percent of the total co2 going into the atmosphere NOW is caused by [u]AUTO[/u] emissions in the US?[/b]

Neil, you admitted to your number including planes and trains, and I would also assume semis.
[b]
What percent of TOTAL CO2 GLOBAL emissions come from US AUTOS?[/b]

JCK, your numbers of fossil fuels isn't even narrowed to just transportation, so you were even further from providing an honest/accurate answer.

by jdclyde

Global Warming Deniers, dare to compare them to Holocaust deniers, and would pass laws against being such.

by Member 25348569

might tell ME. I can get the breakdown for the UK and Europe very easily but my Google searches tend (always) to be skewed to UK sites and I can't easily find out.

I think that occasionally you might agree to help me out unless, of course, you're afraid that you might not like the answer that you get.

Neil :D

by Member 25348569

that air travel is around 3% of the total CO2 emissions in the US. Cars, light trucks and other private vehicles amount to around 20% of the total CO2 emissions in the US - that's around 1.2GT per year of the 6GT pa that the US produces. The rest of the transport emissions are accounted for by commercial vehicles.

Total World-wide emissions are around 30GT pa. The USA is responsible for 13% of that CO2, just less than China. So US cars and other private vehicles account for 4% of ALL CO2 emissions. Might not seem a lot but that's about as much CO2 as the billion people in India produce in total!

More than you thought?

by puppybreath

then they should have their own prayer. How about:

Our Al Gore,
Who Art in Nashville,
Robotic is your frame.
Your doomsday come,
Since you believe Man has done,
On Earth, as it is in Hades.
Give us this day our paranoia,
And forgive us our anger,
As we hate those who drive SUVs.
And lead us not into oil fields,
But deliver us from the Real Truth.
For thine is the Oscar, and the Peace Prize,
And the millions of gullible people who believe in you.
Amen!

by jdclyde

how you can tell how much india or china is kicking out, since clearly china is not going to honestly report it, nor allow anyone else to measure and report it.

When I have looked for such data (US cars), for some reason, it is not made readily available. Why is that?

by maxwell edison

You ask me to answer yes or no to a question with a flawed premise? Sorry, dude, but I won't take that bait.

All you did was to repeat your elementary explanation of why human activity is causing global warming - to which I repeat, not only can you not prove your theory (and it's only a theory, not a fact), but there are others who are exponentially more qualified than either one of us who dispute the very thing you claim.

You present a theory as though it is fact, but you fail to address the qualified experts who disagree with such a theory.

On a scale of 1-10, what you really know about such things has a decimal point in front of it. In reality, you're merely repeating the party-line argument of your preferred political party and your (their) desired end conclusion.

Not only has your side failed to prove your assertions, but you've not even come close - and if anything, NONE of your predicted outcomes have come true. And don't forget, twenty five years ago, your side was predicting doom and gloom within the next twenty years. But when it became obvious that you (and your side) was wrong, they (you) changed it to fifty to one hundred years. Give me a break!

The burden of proof is on you - and you've failed to meet it. Which brings us to the political agenda - you want to advance it, I don't. Take [i]the science[/i] out of it, and you STILL want to advance the same political agenda. And that speaks volumes.

Moreover, I look at what they DO (and fail to DO), not at what they say. That also speaks volumes.

jck, I don't think it's possible for you to remove your own political bias from this issue. You're a Democrat, through and through (bordering on a Socialist), and all you do is spout the Democrat party-line talking points. You don't speak for yourself. You might like to think you do, but Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid, Barney Frank, Barack Obama, and YOU all spout the same propaganda - and I don't trust or believe any of you.

MM-GW/CC is the biggest scam in the history of mankind, and you are in denial, my friend. And the day will come, when the general consensus acknowledges it - and you'll be eating crow (or providing food for daisies).

by Member 25348569

It's interesting why it's so difficult but I have no more idea than you. I doubt that the PTB are ashamed to publicise them as you all seem pretty blase - proud, even - about emissions levels given the kicks that have been aimed at me on TR for daring to suggest that you might like to rein back on the SUVs.

Getting data for China is done using satellites to pick up emission plumes over cities for the big numbers. There is a pretty good correlation world-wide between lifestyle and carbon emissions so I think the figures are accurate enough.

by jackofalltech

The Scientific Method follows the evidence and builds an hypothesis from that and then a theory from that. What I've seen so far in support of MMGW is a bias in search of corroborating data.

by jackofalltech

and I wish I had the time to give a proper answer. Unfortunately, being at work, I don't have access to all the sites and references.

Briefly, (from memory,mind you) they are only using data from the last 40 years or so, they are only using selected sets of data from selected areas of the world, they ignore any indications of contrary conclusions.

I truly wish I had access to the stuff here at work. I will try to do it from home.

by tonythetiger

most of them are doing exactly what they're supposed to be doing.

It's those who trying to base policy on hypotheses as though they are iron-clad facts (or doing what they want to do and latching onto these hypotheses because they can make them appear to support what they want to do.) who are the problem.

by jdclyde

instead of an honest examination of the data, seeing where it will take them.

Computer models are nice toys.

by jck

Prove to me you are born, and not a machine typing this stuff in to just cause debate.

Prove that this isn't all just a dream and is real.

Existence can't even be proven definitively.

Think about it. Ever had a dream that seemed "real"?

This could all be your imagination.

The magic CO2 fairy said so. :^0

I think it's pretty conclusive:

We measure the CO2 that's been in the atmosphere for centuries with technologies we trust.

We show that since embarking on the industrial revolution, world CO2 levels have risen steadily higher and at a faster pace than seen in centuries prior.

We show by reporting on it that the worlds' countries are consuming more and more fossil fuels annually.

We show by investigation how much of the worlds' CO2 plant life is being destroyed each year.

We have proof CO2 traps heat in the atmosphere.

Yet from all those pieces of information, you can not sensibly derive that in diminishing CO2-recycling plant life, ever increasing use of fossil fuels whose combustion produces CO2, and the measured out-of-whack rises over the past 100 years of CO2 concentration in the atmosphere, and the rise of sea water temperatures outside of normal variations....

That all that together doesn't substantiate any proof of what is happening?

Honestly, I don't promote going back to conestoga wagons and using lard-fueled lanterns.

But, linking the processes that happen in nature with what is happening to plant life and how much CO2 we produce and rising temperatures across the globe...seems to me to tie one thing into all that: mankind.

I guess it's easier to blame it on whale farts or something.

by saurondor

Although I agree that sun activity can cause higher temperatures it doesn't explain the higher CO2 concentrations being measured.

Refuting higher CO2 concentrations is not possible. If it were it would have been done by now by better more precise measurements. Showing us that CO2 concentrations haven't risen in centuries.

But they have. More so there is a relation between CO2 concentrations and temperature. During the ice ages CO2 was low and temperatures were low. Millions of years ago CO2 was high and temperatures were high. Actually, CO2 concentrations were higher than today's.

Now that higher CO2 concentration couldn't be due to fossil fuel burning by the dinosaurs. Because they are the fossil fuel we're burning today.

So clearly we see that CO2 is related to global warming. I wouldn't even question that. What I find more interesting is figuring out how much does our CO2 emissions affect the temperatures.

Is it but a drop in a bucket? And the rising CO2 levels are due to something else we still haven't discovered or is being withheld. Is there a manipulation of the press as some claim. A manipulation leading us to overvalue the issue and thus create an economy around the buying and selling of emission quotas?

Or is it true and fossil fuel emissions are causing a temperature rise?

Either way you look at it cutting down on fossil fuel emissions is a good thing. If CO2 emissions are changing the weather then you're helping to save the planet. If global warming is just a media push to justify unnecessary emission quotas. Then you're helping the economy free itself unnecessary constraints.

It wouldn't need to buy other's quotas to keep producing what it produces today. Because it would run on "green" energy sources.

And fossil fuel burning has one key feature that is unquestionable, undeniable and utterly true. It will run out. This leads to another type of warming. A warming of the economic type. As fossil fuel becomes scarce and demand continues to rises so does price.

It is this warming that worries me most. Because unlike global warming which may be due to a series of uncontrolled and uncontrollable factors. This one isn't. We are in complete control of what we want our economy to depend on as a fuel source. If we continue to depend on fossil fuel as if we'll never go cold turkey on it. We must be prepared to face the consequences.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

All?
[i]I doubt that the PTB are ashamed to publicise them as you all seem pretty blase...[/i]

;)

by santeewelding

Neil tries to hand-crank a southern U.S. expression through his pedant English sausage maker and it comes out sounding like punditry of the Absolute.

by Member 25348569

Please delete the word "all" and substitute whatever you feel is most appropriate to give the meaning of "too damn many".

:)

Santee, thank you. Really, I was just sloppy.

by jdclyde

a few reasons for not making data available.

First, it does not support the desired outcome.

Second, the more information that is held up as specific numbers, the higher burden of proof to back the numbers up, as well as giving a target that is much easier to disprove.

When you go to court, your lawyer tells you to stay as general as possible. I suspect the same for this.

"emission plumes"? And how do you know the composition of the plumes? This is the same country where they were temporarily forcing plants to shut down during the olympics to pretend they are not the environmental bad guys.

by Member 25348569

I think we're discussing the USA.

China doesn't give a damn about emissions as they're immune from anything in this round of Kyoto. You guys are just ignoring it for your own reasons.

It's also worth trying to take on board how much of your low-level manufacturing - and the emissions that that produces - you have exported to China.

by jdclyde

you have to know that the estimates of the whole aren't fairy tails meant to make the mean old US look bad.

As for the export, I haven't exported, and I don't endorse, and fail to believe that the UK is not also receiving goods from China, so rejected as a slight on the US for how China has zero concern for anything.

And you will notice very little of my post talked about China, just to ask about how it is determined as fake numbers throws everything out of whack when I asked my very specific question. I do not believe their numbers are not higher, making the US auto's an even smaller contributor (minuscule).

That also takes nothing away from my guess as to why this data is intentionally not made available, and it reflects negatively upon those that worship at the alter of MMGW.

[i]"First, it does not support the desired outcome.

Second, the more information that is held up as specific numbers, the higher burden of proof to back the numbers up, as well as giving a target that is much easier to disprove.

When you go to court, your lawyer tells you to stay as general as possible. I suspect the same for this."[/i]

by jdclyde

They only way China is NOT a part of the question is if there is not an honest attempt to answer my very specific question.

What percent of the [b]TOTAL[/b] co2 going into the atmosphere NOW is caused by AUTO emissions in the US?

To try to pull China out of the mix is to refuse to try to give an honest answer.

Again, the burden is on those that wish to pretend the SUV is the cause of our woes.

by amoeba1

Never said CO2 was not increasing, just was offering alternatives.

Another alternative is water vapor, it is theorized that early Earth had a higher concentration of water vapor (humidity) than currently experienced. That is what greenhouses use to raise the temp for growing plants. It would be difficult (if not dangerous) to raise the level of CO2 to raise the temp of the greenhouses.

The problem I see with all the discussions on CC/GW is that there is absolute venom poured on anyone who offers an opposing view (as evident in the responses to my original post). I neither denied nor stated that CO2 did not have a factor, but was attacked for not including it. This has become a religion. If you disagree with the premises, then you must be attacked. I personally think if it was CO2, then as the 'scientist' who are working on it would be able to show the same results no matter what variables are added. As it stands currently, CO2 models only work in limited scope and they are not sure why.

To kind of reveal my age, I remember in the late 70's they were using high CO2 levels to push the theory that global COOLING was happening and we need to prep for the coming ice age. The climate is very complicated and we do not fully understand all the interactions. Change is good, it keeps us (humans, animals, and plants) on our toes and ever adapting (or dying if we can't). I'm afraid if the models are wrong, what then?

by amoeba1

Has anyone heard anymore on the Ozone hole at the south pole that was to destroy us by now (melting the caps and all)? If memory serves me right, they got that one wrong as it 'closed' itself as it was a naturally occurring phenomenon that happens every so-often. We just 'happened' to notice it one year...

by jck

So it is my fault that you and others can't understand elementary chemistry, physics, and thermodynamics.

Good Lord, next you'll blame me for the snow in December.

I asked your opinion because I wanted to know.

I asked you to answer yes or no, because it seemed elementarily simple and I figured that you could determine the sensible conclusion.

So let me give you an example so basic that even you can do it:

1)Take a cheapo cooking pot, and drill a 1/4" hole on the side at the bottom.

2)Now take another cheap cooking pot of the same size, and drill 3 1/4" holes in the side at the bottom as well.

3) put the 2nd pot above the first pot so the holes allow drainage into the first.

4) keep filling the second pot with water and watch what happens with the first pot.

basic principle: if you put more of anything into any container (and the Earth's atmosphere is a container) than it can deal with dissolving/converting/eliminating, it will eventually fill up.

So maybe it won't happen in your lifetime? Guess it's okay to leave a mess to your kids or grandkids, right? Let them deal with the screw-ups of dad's generation.

As for Pelosi, Frank or Reid, I hardly ever hear what they say because...in all honesty...I rarely watch US television news, and avoid reading newspaper articles about speeches given by them or ANY member of Congress. I tend to either read transcripts when I need detail, or I read various international sources since the American media is so biased about American politics.

I don't like but about 3 people on Capital Hill, and you've never named any of them. And, 2 are Republicans.

As for being a Democrat, I have never been a Democrat. I think spending has to be done SMART, not stupidly as most all members of Congress practice...or to fill your pockets more no matter what the negative effect like you'd have done.

You claim to follow an antiquated precept of government engineered for a time when oxen pulled plows, and white masters raped their black female slaves.

Will Madisonian and Jeffersonian government ever work in the modern day era? No. It was formulated for a day when government was small, representation was more direct, and most representation was territorial rather than state or local...hence why US Marshals were prevalent. Most states were fledglings then, and did not have near the responsibilities of today or the organization.

Todays America is far more complex and would not work within that framework which you claim to hold so dear.

And no, I don't mean government. AMERICA is far more complex. And for you to think America could work successfully within such a simple model of "just don't spend" and "minimal government is best" is foolish. Establishments have to be in place to deal with things.

Jefferson had no interstates to build/maintain and collect taxes for
Madison did not have to maintain an NSA, CIA, DMA, etc., to make sure of his nation's security
Washington did not have such capitalist corporate proliferation whose actions needed to be monitored and adjudicated.

As for what I know about meteorology and climatology, I will say this: That unless you never sleep and spend nights doing research for NCDC or NOAA, I am willing to bet that even though I am younger than you that I have been to far more training on weather, climate, storm assessment and emergency response than you ever have. I worked for CD/FEMA as well as having been to various NOAA/NWS forums, workshops and seminars over a period of about 11-12 years before, during, and after i attended college.

So take that and stick it in your pompous greed pipe, kemosabe.

And honestly, your form of thought on government really isn't even modelled to truly form those you profess to admire like Jefferson or Madison.

Madison wanted the president to negotiate treaties.

Do you really think that's effective government?

And Jefferson, he wanted government to keep corporations in their place as not to become more powerful than government and able to abuse her citizenry.

I thought you wanted government to get out of private matters and leave people and business alone?

In truth, your belief system follows more the mentality of the capitalist robberbarons of the 19th century, as well as capitalists today who nearly crashed the world economy: the only dollar that matters is the one I get to keep.

You must not believe in karma, the Bible, or zen...cause if you did, you'd consider more than just yourself when bitching about paying too much taxes when there are millions of others paying more percentage-wise than you...or demanding government diminish services that support the general welfare so that you can have more money to spend on just yourself.

But if that is what you want, I hope you get a huge tax break, the US and Colorado governments deregulate your state and leaves your street to localities to try and maintain, and that you can determine a way locally to keep out TV and radio signals from Wyoming and Kansas that you don't like because the FCC won't help you anymore.

Anarchy via radical frugalness and antiquated minimalism for the purposes of greed.

Nice. But if that's what you want, I hope Colorado breaks from the Union and you get no taxes, little infrastructure, and more work necessary on your part to make everything be as seamless as it is now for you.

I hope you and Colorado get your dream come true. And when your state goes bust, you've spent all your retirement money on expensive maintenance of your roads, sewers and other infrastructure...I'll bring my savings up and buy houses on the cheap.

I would have done it in Detroit, but that city is beyond help.

by jck

Total world carbon emissions: 28,431,741,000 metric tons

About 33% of carbon emissions in the USA are from transportation (excluding air travel).

The USA emits about 20-21% of the world's carbon footprint.

So about 6.7-7% of the world's total carbon emissions are from American automobiles.

There's your answer you wanted.

And again if 6-7% is miniscule, then send me 6-7% of your income for the rest of your life.

Now not only do I know you are ignorant of facts about things, but I know that after a week of suggesting you go find things that took me 5 minutes ...that you're lazy too.

Have a nice day.

by tonythetiger

[i]I should have said all AVAILABLE facts. [/i]

doesn't inspire a lot of confidence.

Three times last week, all three local stations predicted sunny skies and a zero percent chance of rain... and got it wrong (it poured!). If you can't get it right a few hours in advance...

by jdclyde

But after looking, I have never seen anything that says what percent of all co2 emissions world wide are estimated to be from US autos. Of course, that takes us to what is the percent of autos in Mexico? Or California?

And how do you know which comes up on which side of the border?

by jck

the magic CO2 fairy showed me her report.

Jeez man. Do you doubt everything just because it's not put in numbers in front of your face?

If so, how do you really know you're human? Did you see yourself be born? Maybe you're alien? Maybe you're Mexican?

I bet you never went to your bosses and said "Hey...did I really earn this paycheck? Can you break it down for me and tell me what I did to deserve this exact number?"

It's convenient for you to believe what you want. Even when I put the numbers [b]you asked for[/b] right under your nose, then they are not good enough for you.

As I said before, I'm done trying to prove anything. I'd explain how the US tracks cars, oil and coal production and imports, oil refining, etc. But, then you'd just ask how I knew if the oil really came in and if it was foreign if we really count it as ours.

Just silly rhetoric from you now on the matter. No one can be that obtuse as to ask for data they say isn't out there, then when you are give it...you balk at it.

Have a nice day

by tonythetiger

[i]Think about it. Ever had a dream that seemed "real"?[/i]

[i]I think it's pretty conclusive:[/i]

A conclusion is simply the point where one tires of thinking. Fortunately, as has happened many times in the past, someone else will pick it up again.

by jck

That's part of the problem why I have sleep meds...I can't stop thinking about things all the time.

I just got tired of being told I did not do prove something, and then when I did the parameters changed of what I have to show.

If I want to chase the impossible, I would go pursue dating models in Miami while working at Jack-in-the-Box.

by Member 25348569

was never going to destroy you, just Australia and New Zealand. No-one (sensible) ever said that it would melt any ice-caps.

It's still there (forms every Spring) and it still lets far too much ultra-violet through. It's not getting much bigger - 2006 was the record - but it's not getting any smaller.

by jck

amoeba: They spend a lot of money and dedicate a lot of resources watching it for something that's not a real issue.

http://ozonewatch.gsfc.nasa.gov/

I would think that if it were a non-issue, scientists would have determined it since 1985.

Evidently, there has to be some concern and valid justification to warrant further investigation and monitoring.

Bureaucrats would rather spend millions on their pet projects than a hole in the ozone they think poses no threat whatsoever...trust me.

by Member 25348569

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=314129&messageID=3130844

I'll post it again, though to save you the clicking.

Cars, light trucks and other private vehicles amount to around 20% of the total CO2 emissions in the US - that's around 1.2GT per year of the 6GT pa that the US produces. The rest of the transport emissions are accounted for by commercial vehicles.

Total World-wide emissions are around 30GT pa. The USA is responsible for 13% of that CO2, just less than China. So US cars and other private vehicles account for 4% of ALL CO2 emissions.

Although 4% might seem small, that's 4% of the TOTAL emissions by over 6 billion people.

:)

By the way, John gets 6% and I get 4% because I was able to find the split between commercial and private.

It's all easy to work out. The US government produces the figures - and then proceeds to hide them.

by nicknielsen

[i]Most states were fledglings then, and did not have near the responsibilities of today or the organization.

Todays America is far more complex and would not work within that framework which you claim to hold so dear. [/i]

America has been working (for the most part) within that framework for over 200 years; it's only in the last 70-80 years that the framework has been stretched.

The issue that many of us have is that today's federal government [u]should not[/u] be doing some of the things it is now doing because those things are [u]outside[/u] that framework:

* When did it become the federal government's responsibility to see that everybody succeeds? The only responsibility is to ensure everybody gets the same [b]chance[/b] to succeed.

* When did it become the federal government's responsibility to save businesses? The only responsibility is to ensure that all businesses have an equal chance to succeed (i.e. anti-trust).

* When did it become the federal government's responsibility to provide health care? There's not even a responsibility outlined unless you extend "promote the general welfare" well beyond its intent.

I tend to be a little less restrictive than others, so I can justify, at least to myself, the existence of the USDA, FDA, FAA, and similar regulatory agencies as supporting both the general welfare AND interstate commerce. However, any rules those agencies generate should require [u]explicit[/u] legislative approval and not just take effect by default.. Entire departments of housing and urban development, homeland security, education, veterans affairs (even though I am one), or health and human services should simply not exist. With the exception of homeland security and veterans affairs (which should both fall under Defense), the functions performed by all the mentioned departments can more easily and economically be performed at the state level. Some functions, education in particular, should have advisory committees to promulgate national standards, but not one of them should be even an agency, much less a full blown cabinet department.

Why does the federal government have to step in and take functions from the states in direct contravention to the 10th Amendment? The further you get from the problem, the less likely you are to make an informed decision. What makes some bureaucrat in DC qualified to decide the fates of people on the street in Peoria, Portland, or Piscataway?

edit: added key "federal"

by jdclyde

does this total include factories and power plants? Natural events such as volcanic eruptions? Cow flatulence? Or is this just transportation?

by Member 25348569

The World total - nearly 30GT pa - is from burning coal and oil and other fossil fuels. No cowfarts included (that's methane) nor the contribution made by deforestation.

The quoted 1.2GT pa was just for US private cars and that's the figure that you wanted to know.

The US private cars alone put out more than twice as much CO2 as the UK's complete CO2 emissions. That's everything. Power, heat, light, industry and transport.

Neil :)

by amoeba1

Neil:
Thanks for verifying the US media/liberal party is not sensible. I whole-heartedly agree.

jck:
From the satellite images, it is a 'trick' of color that makes it look like there is a hole. All the 'data' points to a thinner layer, not a hole. I would have picked pink instead of blue to show the lower end. Blue makes it look like water.

by jck

For as far as I can tell, government does not run medical care and never has. And, what they are doing right now is trying to revamp the operations of healthcare regulations and infrastructure of Medicare to save money and provide basic healthcare for everyone.

What's the advantage to that? Well, first of all if people who are sick get into treatment it diminishes the spread of communicable diseases.

Secondly, it gets people treatment before the symptoms and issues from a basic illness can compound to something far more costly (basic cold treatment + antibiotic is much cheaper than hospitalization for pneumonia...right?).

Next, I can't and never will argue the point to bail out the car companies or the banks. Fact is, those companies were run into the ground by careless business practice. No one made them buy bulk packaged loans as investments that they did not individually check as they would for each one they directly write for themselves, as well as a sheer level of stupidity of the automakers not to change their product lines to go with the economic condition of the times. They were STUPID, and stupid business people deserve to FAIL.

As for government making everyone succeed, I have never seen a program that gives $5M cash to each person in this country so that we can all live in some state of opulence.

I think most things the government does are right. Opportunity should be made available.

However, I have ALWAYS disagreed with programs that give ANYONE bias or preference on the basis of race, religion, gender, etc.

If you apply for the job and you're the best, you should get it.
If you apply for a educational grant and are the most needy, you should get it.
If you apply for a scholarship and are the brightest and most achieved, you should get it.

The irony is that government tells others they should not discriminate, yet the US government is the biggest giver of money to people based on ethnicity and/or gender.

Bias is bias. And, that to me is more of an issue than whether homeless people are getting free medical visits to a doctor.

And you know why homeless and poor getting free medical care shouldn't be a huge concern? Most already are...via county/state health clinics that are majority funded by...tada...US government tax dollars.

As for what others want, all I have heard from Max is the minimalist chatter. His derivation of Madison is what he wants that benefits him, not the pure meaning of what Madison ascribed to desire of government.

As well, running a government can't be done like running a corporation.

A) Because some redundancy has to be available in government. Government serves all sectors of society, not just a niche. Therefore, it must be more resistant to disfunctionality.

B) Because government is accountable to all its constituents. Business is only responsible to those from whom it takes lendings.

I still say government shouldn't be run on a skeleton crew like a midnight shift at a warehouse. It should be run smart.

I see the healthcare reform plan as a step toward that. Make Medicare, which is the fastest growing expense in the US Government today, run better and more cost-effectively. Is that such a bad idea?

I also see healthcare reform as a preventative measure from keeping our country from having as many major health issues that would have been preventable with basic care. That will also drive costs down.

And as I said, those ideologies of Madison and Jefferson were written some 200 years ago. They were not designed for a country who oversees interstate highway systems, defense satellite monitoring networks, an international space station, or military deployments and bases in over 60 countries.

And as I said to Max...Jefferson wanted corporations bound by government as not to harm her citizens. That, in itself, breaks the minimalist precept Max espouses to (what he calls Libertarianism) in wanting government not to interfere in private or business matters.

I want government of, by, and for the people...not just the few in power or those with influence...like it is today.

by jck

The world "hole" must be taken literally.

Of course if there were a hole in the atmosphere, more than likely hyperly-cold air would have rushed down by now and frozen Australia into a popsicle.

Hole is a relative term to a thinning in the layer, not some gaping chasm as you interpreted as.

by jck

You need to go ask Vulcan, Roman God of Fire, for his annual report on CO2 and sulfur dioxide emissions from his volcanoes.

Then, you have to go stick a gas chromatograph up each animal and person's arse in the world to measure the CO2, methane, and other gas emissions.

JD needs EXACT numbers, even though he can not and will not contradict the effects of the information we've already given him or acknowledge what we have given him as accurate and factual.

It's a hopeless effort. He will not be convinced until either you become God and give him divine assurance...or until Michigan becomes a dry grassland and his house has been burned down from a lightning-triggered fire from climate change.

It still amazes me how people can't figure out A + B + C = D

by amoeba1

solve GW... ;D

Last time I looked in a dictionary, the term hole did not mean a thinning of a surface, it was defined as a puncture/opening in the object. Why did alarmist use the term hole if it was not to imply an actual hole? Why use a color scheme that implies an actual hole (if you just look at the diagram, as most busy people might do)?

Words have meaning and are used to convey a particular image.

by amoeba1

Every day, more scientist have reviewed the data and more are changing their mind on GW. This is a good thing, science is not consensus, but those who want to force change turn to name calling and ridicule of those who present an opposing view.

One of the funniest things I have heard that could be applied to this discussion was the following:

Someone called a local radio show in a panic. They had 'done the math' and proved that it would be completely dark by mid-june (this happened to be before the winter equinox). Now, it is true and a proven fact days are shorter in the winter than the summer and the person was using a valid data set. But the problem, as we know, is that is only half the equation...after the 'low' point in the winter, the days start getting longer.

Now, do we have all the information on CC/GW? Absolutely not, as even the scientist (not the politicians) will admit the theories do not work under ALL conditions and they don't have a full understanding of all the variables. 'But we can say in this specific, controlled setting; this happens'.

Looking at several graphs and charts 'showing' an increase in CO2, I noticed a little blurb "After removing...". Pardon me for using my brain, but if you remove a part of the sample, do you not increase the concentrations of the remaining substances?
I know of at least a couple of ways to 'prove' an increase in CO2:
1.Early research used 'water laden' samples and newer ones remove the water.
2.Artificially inflate the water vapor (causing lower ppm of CO2) for your start, then in recent sample, remove it.

I still fall back to an actual greenhouse as a theory. The more water vapor in the greenhouse, the 'hotter' it is. There have been studies that show water vapor it more of a GW-causing gas than CO2. That is not to say CO2 does not increase the temp, just water vapor is better at it.

by Member 25348569

I don't want to turn to name calling (although that can be quite enjoyable) so I'll very politely draw your attention to a couple of things in your post.

The increase in CO2 concentration is very, very easy to measure. They've measured it in several places for many decades, the most well-known of these being the top of Mauna Load in Hawaii and it's being going up for a long time. Here's a link to the NOAA - http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/ccgg/trends/

So, its still is rising. They haven't changed any measuring technique. There wouldn't be any point and too many people who DON'T want to accept climate change would leap on them if they did.

No need to fudge this one. It's absolutely irrefutable data and, generally, ignored by those who want to convince you that GW isn't happening. You won't EVER find one of the "scientists who have changed their minds" mentioning CO2 concentration. NEVER. They DARE not and not because they will be shouted down and accused of being ridiculous but because they know that they WOULD be ridiculous. So they keep quiet.

CO2 is a greenhouse gas and - as you rightly state - so is water and I agree that it's much more important. However, the unfortunate thing is that the molecular chemistry of water and CO2 means that they absorb energy and re-radiate infra-red (heat) at different wavelengths so that the effect of CO2 is additive to the water vapour.

You know, got it absolutely right in your last paragraph. Take that thought one step further.

Neil :)

by amoeba1

That I noticed they were removing the water vapor. If you have 1 million parts and remove something, you will need to pull in more sample to bring it back up to 1 million.

For example, I have 10 balls of various colors and sizes. If I remove all the red ones (5 of my sample). The one black ball goes from 10% of my sample to 20% of it. Maybe I am being too logical and my scientific background is getting in the way...

by jck

Actually if you increase CO2, it does increase the thermal retention.

When air is heated to a higher temperature, it holds more water vapor.

That not only causes more sustained time at higher temps with increased humidity, but causes more pronounced and intense tropical interaction.

by amoeba1

I can cause a rise in temp using only trapped water vapor and no CO2 added. Which is the cause and which is the effect? Why not eliminate both if GW is so bad? Because we can't, to remove all the CO2 plants would have nothing to convert into O2 and everything would die if we removed water.

I wish I could find the study I read almost ten years ago. It was a study of the change in the forestation of the USA since the settling of it. While it stated the acreage of trees was down, the actual number was up due to planting closer together. I do know if you look at some older pictures of parks and compare the same area today, there are more trees in the background. Granted, that may not be true everywhere.

by jck

uses of words in context and not in the literal sense is a metaphor.

Plus I guess Ozone Divot didn't sound as cool :^0

BTW, you best get on cosmologists for calling a Black Hole a hole. :^0

by jdclyde

tell me we are not all going to die in lighting storms as all of our houses are leveled by mmgw? I don't wanna die! Here is my checkbook! How much do you need to stop the lightning from coming?

by jdclyde

So, the US gets on-board and cuts this to .6GT pa, what will the measurable impact be on the globe and global warming?

What would be the measurable impact if we were to double that to 2.4GT pa?

by jck

mathematics and what not done, I suggest you email Goddard Space Flight Center and ask them the answer. They have scientists who are paid to do that sort of thing with YOUR tax dollars.

I'm not doing any more math, elementary or otherwise. Last time I did it, you ignored it even though you asked for the answer and diverted to another excuse not to acknowledge things as fact.

If we could reduce it by half? It would be great. But as I told you before, it's only half the problem.

We need not only to reduce what we're dumping into the atmosphere, but also reforest the deforested lands where CO2 consuming plants once stood.

Just to show you what man is doing around the world:

Story about the destruction of 99% of a Rwandan rainforest:
http://news.mongabay.com/2009/0609-nasa_rwanda.html

New Guinea rainforest to be destroyed or damaged by 2021:
http://www.reuters.com/article/environmentNews/idUSSP30581820080602

Explanation of how deforestation can affect climate in this article:
http://www.nasa.gov/centers/goddard/news/topstory/2006/amazon_crops.html

The last one is a scientific article so that you can see the two news stories aren't just bull.

Or are NASA scientists not reputable enough?

by Member 25348569

My scientific background usually requires a "them", a source - hence why I posted you a link to the NOAA. They describe their methodology and they have always removed the water vapour because it varies so much from day to day or even hour to hour and can skew the results. I'm OK with that so long as they always do it and always have.

Post your sources, please. Once I have a source then I can accept or not their authority and their methodology and, if I want, their conclusions.

:)

by amoeba1

They=NOAA.

If the water vapor varies, would that not also indicate everything would also vary (more water vapor equals less of everything else)? Since the atmosphere also includes water vapor as part of it's make-up, why NOT include it? That is my point, it seems too much like data manipulation to me.

by Member 25348569

You'll find that water vapour is in single figure parts per million in the atmosphere so its contribution - or not - to the measurement of CO2 is irrelevant.

by amoeba1

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/05/06/mike_hulme_interview/

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/04/09/arctic_aerosols_goddard_institute/

This one doesn't believe it is caused by man:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/02/25/jstor_climate_report_translation/

And this one is my favorite:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/01/28/nasa_climate_theon/

I know this is a limited selection, but all I had marked as I found it interesting that in two of the articles, the scientist(s) involved changed their mind.

Take from it what you will...

Found another one:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2008/11/19/nasa_giss_cockup_catalog/

by Member 25348569

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/05/06/mike_hulme_interview/ I find myself reasonably close to Mike Hulme's views. I see the potential for the worst type of fascist environmentalism to do immense harm.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/04/09/arctic_aerosols_goddard_institute/ is a bit weird because if the Arctic ice cap were to melt completely, it wouldn't do anything to sea level as it's all floating ice. Greenland is another matter but they didn't mention it.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2009/02/25/jstor_climate_report_translation/ Hmmm. This is Japan, you know. They can't do anything major to reduce their carbon emissions without serious consequences. They have no coal, no oil and use a lot. I do believe that there might be a bit of political prodding. They eat whales (killed, of course, for "research"). Nuff said.

by jck

When water evaporates and becomes...water vapor...it increases temp...sure.

But when the sun goes down, water vapor condenses and forms dew.

CO2 doesn't condense. It lingers. Therefore, it keeps the heat trapped even through the night time in the atmosphere.

I wish I could find you the weather analysis that they did over the last 50 years of the geographic regions east and northeast of the Atlanta Metro. Because Atlanta had gotten so big and so deforested with construction, the actual thermal pattern E and NE had been affected and caused a rise in the outbreak of tornadic activity there.

Scary stuff.

by jdclyde

unless it is endangered, why not?

And not pretend endangered like the polar bear, done for political measure.

by saurondor

A perforation in the ground doesn't need to reach the other side of the planet to be called a hole. Heck it doesn't even need to breech the crust much less reach the core of the planet. A hole is simple a thinning of the earths surface. A very insignificant thinning by the way.

Would you suggest we start calling water holes water dents?

This discussion is closed to new replies.