Open letter to Sir Elton John
.
Link to story:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/3902833.stm
Sir Elton,
With all due respect, you are very, very wrong.
Of course you have a right to voice your opinion, and you have a right to oppose things our US administration is doing. I'm all for that, and I'm all for you in standing up in such a manner.
But in this case, it's a little bit funny that you are accusing the government of doing something that they are not doing. You said that people (entertainers, I presume) are "frightened by the current administration's bullying tactics". Will you please be so kind as to point out the "bullying tactics" employed by the US government to squelch such free speech?
What you and other entertainers don't seem to understand - or admit - is that while you, on one hand, have every right to stand up in protest of anything, on the other hand, people who disagree with you have the same right. You mentioned the Dixie Chicks. The government didn't do anything or say anything in "retaliation" for their statements of a year ago. But other people did. Are you suggesting that I, as a "free speech" advocate who happens to disagree with the Dixie Chicks, doesn't subsequently have the right to stand up in disagreement, boycott their concerts, throw away their CDs, and so on? The US government's not doing it, Sir Elton, but other people are. There's a difference.
The most recent crude remarks by Whoopie Goldberg is another such example. Sure, she certainly has a right to stand up and be heard by spouting off as much disgusting vile as she wants. But other people, and companies, have a right to react to it however they please? If you hire someone who embarrasses you, do you not have a right to fire that person? Does Slim-Fast not have a right to fire Ms. Goldberg because she was becoming an embarrassment to them?
So please, Sir Elton, don't confuse another person's "free speech" with government "bullying tactics". It's people like me who wrote letters to Slim-Fast voicing displeasure over the remarks of Ms. Goldberg. It's people like me who decided to not buy any more Dixie Chick CDs or concert tickets. It's people like me who are now using the old Barbara Streisand records for Frisbees. The government is not doing anything. Just little people like me exercising their own "free speech" in response to others with whom we disagree.
Can you not see the distinction? Or is "Your Song" the only one you can tolerate to hear?
Respectfully Yours,
A Life-Long fan and lover of your music,
Mr. Maxwell Edison