Discussion Locked

Optical Mice and Wood Desks

0 helpful
23 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hello all,
I have been having a problem with optical mice at my job. There are many users that say their cursor speed is sluggish at times and non-responsive. I replaced them with new mice an it's the same issues. Some are wireless some are USB, all are optical. I was having the same issues. But mine is also a gyro mouse. When in the air it works perfectly. I replaced some of the other optical mice with ball mice and I haven't heard a complaint. I was wondering if it could be the grain of wooden desks. Does the grain reflect light differently if depending on the color and direction of the grain? I know this is a stupid quesiton, but I get A LOT of calls about mice. It's ridiculous. If I need to get rid of opticals because of the desks, I guess I will.
Does anyone else have this problem?
Has anyone else noticed this?
Thanks.

23 replies

by dmarston

Several people here have the same issue. also a "sporadic" mouse.. all of a sudden the mouse will jump to the other side of the screen.
But the mouse on my desk (wood) works flawlessly. I don't think it is related to the wood, as I have given the users a mouse pad with no affect. if anybody has a clue, please let us in on it!
:)

by tig2

I found that I have better performance on a mousing "surface" as opposed to a standard mouse mat.

I have to assume that you have checked for driver updates for that mouse- I had a similar issue with a touchpad mouse that was resolved through a driver update.

Good thing to know- the 3M mousing surface can discolour wooden desks. It should be put on an alternative surface- I just laid it on a piece of paper and moused away.

by w2ktechman

the lay it on a piece of paper works well enough.
That is a good idea, I was going to mention it and I saw that you had posted it already.

If the paper trick works, it is the surface. You can try using a laser mouse (same as optical, but better resolution for reading surfaces), or look at alternate surfacing features. Using a notepad works for me in some situations, and a mouse pad in others are fine.
If the mice are of the cheap variety, they may have a harder time reading surfaces as well. A good optical should have few problems with mouse pads.

by j.lupo

until I put a mouse pad or sheet of paper under it. depending on the wood surface the mouse either would respond slowly if at all or it would go wonder off all on its own at top speed.

by faradhi

I have found that glossy surfaces are not conducive to using optical mice. I have had this issues with more than just wood. So a simple mouse pad might be in order here. Just make sure it is textured. Not one of the fancy high gloss cutesy ones.

edited for speling and cursing damnit.

by jmgarvin

Use a cloth, no gloss, mouse mat. Make sure to get the single color ones and NOT red ones. I use blue (they're ugly, but they work).

Buy better mice. It sounds like you might have gotten the cheapies.

Don't use the USB to PS/2 converter. That is going to cause similar problems (at least in my experience).

Some of the high gloss desks and some of the really freaky "wood grain" does do a number...

Let us know what works!

by oldbag

I have found that white mouse pads also cause problems with optical mice. Use a mouse pad but itneeds to be plain (no design at all) and dark coloured.

You also need to check the mouse and make sure that the bottom is clean. I have found that sometimes the little plastic 'feet' on the bottom get a layer of grunge and will also affect performance.

by sam hamwi

I have now had to use mouse pads after years of forgetting completely about them. I think the lacquer is the culprit, since it adds a shiny surface. I know you can't use an optical mouse on a glass table, so I am extrapolating here.

Thanks,

Sam

by Member 25348569

I use an A4 pad. Works a treat and when it gets a little grubby or worn, I peel off the top sheet. I guess the US equivalent would be your letter size that all of us European techs get SO p:ssed off at having to change on every bin on every printer. Why can't HP have a bloody "select and it's European" option mumble bloody groan damn Yankee world domination...

Ooops! Hijacked my own post there. :D

by johnnyxxl76

I am using frosted glass on mine, its worked fine now for 2 years same 2 sets of batteries. One thing I know many users have had to do is make sure no dirt in sensor, on feet, or anything blocking the radio reciever.

by jim_p

I am forever changing paper sizes too.
But lately I have noticed a lot of printer drivers are now defaulting to A4 if your regional settings are setup correctly.
But yes, glass, shiny surfaces do cause problems with optical mice. Just have to use the good old mouse mat or the simple paper trick.

Regards,
Jim

by mickster269

First, it's the A4 pads... then we fine tune all the spell checkers to accept ONLY American spelling...

Then, after we change all the default weights and measures-

VICTORY WILL BE OURS! TAKE THAT, AL-QUEIDA!

by x-marcap

At my desk at home I use a ball type mouse. The maple top won't work with logitech opticals,

In fact a cherry desk, too polished gives the same effect. a formica surface with a pattern is the best I have found for Optical Mice.

by now left tr

Apply the Elander theory here.

Run you hand from left to right across the surface of contact.
Should you feel abrasion from the right then a laser will not work.
Should you feel abrasion from the left then Optical will not work.
Should you feel nothing at all then both will work, but only after you have looked like a fuool for trying this.

by kylegeldmaker

What if you feel abrasion from both directions.
Does that mean Elander is the fool?

Also, I have tried drivers and mouse pads. I am not sure of the expense of the opticals. I could only assume that they were no more than $20, but mine does the same thing. Mine was $100. The mouse pads we have are the ones that are distributed with Dell's. They are white. I have been using a large manilla envelope, or I use the air (mine has a gyroscope in it, kinda cool but fidgety). I told the people who were complaining to use their desktop calendars and that seems to be working for now.

by tig2

I would give a darker surface a try. That may be why the mousing "surface" works so well- it is a dark blue purple about the thickness of 10-12 pieces of paper.

Sounds like you have at least a workaround anyway.

by onbliss

My wired optical mices behaved well compared to the wireless ones. Though I use rechargeable batteries, it is atrocious amount of batteries that they consume. Is'nt there any technology that would use the heat from the palm to drive these wireless mice?

The wired mice worked well on the wooden desks better than their wireless cousins.

by deadly ernest

wood - it's a big issue where desks a polished with wood polish. Just use a mouse pad or a piece of paper.

In one job we had some top exec types with real fancy polished desks had real problems with this, we just moved their nlotters to the right and had them use the mice on the huge desk blotters they had, and never used as blotters.

by bradt

I have noticed just a few issues with optical mice. When they act up I do the following;

1. Check for an eylash in the lens area, it is AMAZING what one little hair can do to an optical mouse.

2. Check for FAKE woodgrain, it is printed with an array of semi-regular dots that can sometimes throw an optical mouse one heck of a curve-ball. I had a spot on my dest that could send my mouse all the way across BOTH my monitors in about a 2 millimetere space. I have never run into real woodgrain that caused trouble, if it is too glossy then I guess that would be the issue but 'normal' levels of gloss have never been a problem for me.

The rest of these apply anly to wireless mice.

3. Check that the receiver is in the clear, my wife has a small desk and her receiver is on top of her PC under the desk, if it gets knocked down to the side there is an entire computer blocking the signal.

4. check the batteries (do this last, as I have swapped many a pair of batteries for one of the above reasons (usually number 1))

I have also noticed that my laser mice seem much more immune to these oddities (except the fake wood grain)

Brad

by rob

If the wood is a natural grain and not filled so that the surface is smooth it may reflect the laser back at a bad angle. It really depends on how well the grain indenttions were filled in the finishing process. Not much you can do about it short of thin plastic mouse pads.

This discussion is closed to new replies.