Discussion Locked

Parents on strike till kids pitch in

0 helpful
42 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is going on in my area. Do you think they are bad parents or inventive?

By Errin Haines | Sentinel Staff Writer
Posted December 8, 2004

DELTONA -- Roasting marshmallows over a hibachi and sitting in lawn chairs in front of a tent Tuesday night, Cat and Harlan Barnard looked more like happy campers than frustrated parents.

But the Barnards are not on vacation. They're on strike against their 12-year-old daughter and 17-year-old son, with whom they have begged and pleaded to help out around the house, with no success.

"This was our last-ditch effort," Cat Barnard said.

Dishes, garbage and dirty laundry would pile up for days before Cat Harlan would have to do her children's chores, she said.

Recently, the 45-year-old stay-at-home mom said, she was running a 104-degree fever.

Her son asked for a ride to the mall.

During the Thanksgiving holiday, the Barnards decided they were fed up. A talk show featuring a similar stunt by an equally exasperated parent gave them the idea to move out of their Jena Drive home and onto the front yard.

Monday morning, they put their plan into action and have only gone inside the house to use the restroom and shower.

On the first day, their children came home from school confused.

"I thought she lost her mind," said Ben, a senior at Deltona High School.

The next morning, Harlan Barnard, 56, said he woke up feeling stiff, but liberated.

"It was like I'd done something to take back my little corner of the world," he said.

On Tuesday a neighbor called The Philips Phile, a call-in talk show on Real Radio 104.1 FM (WTKS), about the tactic. More media attention followed.

"It's extremely inconvenient," Ben said. "Every time the phone rings, we have to run outside to give it to them."

There were also visits from one of their daughter Kit's teachers, and the Volusia County Sheriff's Office stopped by three times Tuesday night to check on the children.

Whether the couple's actions could be regarded as abandonment depends on how much guidance the parents are still providing and "if the children are suffering as a result," said Carrie Hoeppner, a spokeswoman with the Department of Children & Families in Orange County, which is in a different DCF district than Volusia.

Ruth Peters, a Clearwater clinical psychologist and author who specializes in treating children and adolescents, said the tent tactic could easily backfire on the parents.

The children probably won't clean the house or do any chores as they might have with mom and dad living under the same roof, she said. In fact, it might give the youths star status with their peers because they drove their parents out.

"All this does is inconvenience the parent. It doesn't inconvenience the kids at all," Peters said. "I can't imagine the kids begging their parents to come back."

She said good parents set limits for their children and say no. The best thing to do if you are losing control of your children is seek professional help, she said.

"Seek it before pitching a tent," she said.

Both children admitted they could do more to help their mother. Still, they expect their parents to give up the stunt in a few more days.

Cat Barnard, however, said she thinks the strike may already be working. Tuesday, she said, Kit washed her own clothes for the first time.

With good weather predicted to last through the week, a freezer full of frozen dinners and the kids down to plasticware, the couple said they are ready to ride out the standoff.

"This is war," Cat Barnard said. "I love my babies, but I don't like what they're doing."

http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/local/volusia/orl-loctent08120804dec08,1,5929370.story?coll=orl-home-promo

42 replies

by jamesrl

I see this as childish tactics that will teach the kids the wrong message. Instead of teaching the kids that there are shared responsibilities in the house, it will teach them that the people with the strongest will will win - and that might not always be the parent.

My wife and I struggle with similar issues at home, but we are not about to stop providing the essentials of life. Surely there are better ways to motivate these kids.

James

by oz_media

You are not allowed to physically discipline your kids and they know it.

When I was a kid, if I threatened to call 9/11, my dad would hand me the phone and remind me to call an ambulance for a dead kid first.

My dad never hit me, THANK GOD, but never needed to. I knew if he ever did whack me, and he could have, I would be hospitalized.

Kids in Canada, KNOW thay can be disciplined physically if needed, so there is less to put up with from them. I am not suggesting that all Canadian kids listen to their parents, parents are too soft and sensitive these days (thanks society!)to do anything about it.

If I even said "SHE" when referring to my mother, I would be punished. "It's your MOTHER, not SHE!"

Sure respect is earned, most kids aren't aware of that reality YET though. They still live in a world where violence dictates the leader of the pack. They have NO problem being violent to parents, parents need the ability to scare the cr*p out of the kids once in a while, just to show who's boss.

A comedian on TV the other night was talking about how kids these days have thier 'quiet space or personal space' generaly thier bedroom , where parents knock first and leave if told not to enter.

Now if MY dad had knocked MY (locked) bedroom door and I said "go away, this is MY space", he would have kicked the friggin' door in and held out his hand for rent. As the comedian added, "The LAWN is your space, now go and cut it!"

"This is war," Cat Barnard said. "I love my babies, but I don't like what they're doing."

No it isn't, these are CHILDREN in YOUR care. Now go and take care of it. I don't LIKE what they are doing? So STOP it! What's with people these days?!?

by mrafrohead

These kids need a serious ass whoopin'.

And the son, needs to just be beaten. Severely.

And just so y'all know, in Washington State, it is legal to spank your kids. As is most places, it's just that the media has hyped it up so most people think that it's taboo.

There's nothing wrong with discipline. Beatings are bad, but discipline is okay.

But in the special sake of these kids. The son needs to be beaten up. If my wife had a 104, and my kid asked for a ride somewhere, I'da kicked his ass into next week... The parents should be embarassed for how they are raising their kids. They let this happen.

by oz_media

How ya been? Long time no hear, I suppose you have been doing something clever and academic just to make us look lazy.

by don_c

I'm from the US and my children tried that crap with me an one called CPS well they were supized when the social worker look at them an said I was in the wrong instead of spanking them I should have spanked them an grounded them for a month haven't had a problem since

by bacrcr

I support you 100%, I have a 11 year old, a 13 year old and a 17 year old, we face the same challenges as you. I believe we will folow suit........ Graet Job. Hang in there.

by awfernald

Seems to me... when the wife had a fever of 104, and the son asked for a ride to the mall, the answer should have been "No".

Unfortunately for these parents, teaching a child responsibility should start when they are an infant, not when they are a teenager.

Seems to me that these parents failed because they tried to "use a village to raise a child", and now they are going to extremes to try and get their children back into obedience/respect/love to/for them (the parents).

You don't have to spank your children, or hit them, or whatever.... however, it seems to me that it is SOOOO much more helpful when the child KNOWS that you are willing and capable of a physical punishment (not abuse), and that failure to comply and/or will result in progressively worse punishments until compliance is achieved.

This belief that "rewarding" kids for doing what they are SUPPOSED to be doing, is simply teaching them that if they want something nice, simply DON'T do what they are supposed to and then someone will come along and "persuade" them to do it.

by jdclyde

If you lead by example, kids will follow in many of the cases.

If they do the things around the house and at school that is expected, they get praise and rewards of good behaviour. Positive reinforcement.

If they don't do well in school or help out around the house, then you discuse with them why they feel they shouldn't have to do X, Y, and X. If this doesn't work, start taking away privilages.
No more TV, Computer except for doing homework, No Xbox/PS2/GameCube, no DVD's, no going to the mall.

I see too many people that say if the kids get an A on the report card they get something special. That is months down the road and much too far away to be meaningful to a kid. Has to be on a day by day and week by week basis. Did you get your homework done today? Are the dishes done? Has the dog been feed. If not, don't ask for anything and don't ask to go anywhere. How did you do on your test? Did bad? Let me help you study for the next one. Did good? Lets hit Barns & Nobles or let me whoop you at Halo.

You get from kids what you expect from them and you get out of them what you put into them.

by trockii

Anyone that would move out of their house that they are paying mortage or renting and let the kids live there while they live in a tent in the backyard is insane. My mom and dad both disciplined me. Sometimes I thought it was child abuse, it really wasn't. It's called discipline! It's called YOU are the PARENTS and THEY are the KIDS. YOU make the rules. Ever hear "while you are in MY house you will obey MY rules?" If they don't want to do the little chores to help out, charge them rent. If they don't like that then tough luck. Parents are too easy on their kids. I wish my parents would have moved out when I was 17. This kid is definitely gonna be the envy of all his friends.

As for washing her own clothes.....You don't have to wash your kids clothes. Let them wear smelly dirty socks and clothes. They will figure it out sooner or later. If clothes are lying all around the house pick them up and throw them in their room and close the door. That's the nice thing. You can close the door and sorta be "outta sight, outta mind" This just makes me so mad. Parents take control of your kids. You are allowed to spank your kids, just don't abuse them. Kids raised like this make worst adults.

by mikel~t

My parents weren't the greatest, but they were providing for me, and I respected that when I was growing up. We didn't see eye to eye on a lot of things, but their house, so their rules. I did what was asked of me, and I knew if I did, I would be able to do what I wanted.

I was also raised without the stupid spare-the-rod save-the-child or whatever the saying is. If I got out of line, my butt knew it before my brain, but the brain understood later.

You can't even look at your kids funny anymore. I have a 15 year old daughter that thinks she shouldn't have to do anything but what she wants. My wife caves in to every request she makes, and I am the exact opposite. First question out of my mouth after ever request my daughter makes is, "did you do your chores?". When the answer is no, my answer to her request is no, if the answer is sort of, followed by a lame excuse, my answer is no, when she answers yes, I confirm the answer by getting up and looking, and then she might get her request if she has shown a concious effort to do her chores recently...no one day of doing chores is going to get her anything.

I don't believe that any stay at home mom has any excuse as to why her kids can be so selfish. She isn't working 9 to 5 away from them, and should have more of an authoritative role in her "babies" life.

Spare the tent, get your kids off their butts, and the answer is no to any request when they haven't done what they are required to do.

A tent...good lord...my kids would laugh themsevles silly if I did something so useless.

Mike

by oz_media

Generally a drill seargeant will scream and freak out on you, minimizing you until you break physically and mentally. They are not known for beating people into submission but they are still respected and can WEAR people into submission. They don't HAVE to lay a finger on most men, most men wouldn't challenge them to begin with.

How can parents accept having their authority challenged for many years before STARTING to do something about it, even if it is by a weak and pathetic submission as shown here.

by bfilmfan

Having been raised by pair of USMC officer parents, I think I can explain the experience of being raised by a Marine parent(s):

Parents do not scream. They speak in loud voices so that your simple mind can clearly understand. In addition, they will be one inch from your nose and looking you directly in the eye when speaking to you.

Parents do not strike children for discipline purposes. Parents make children scrub the bathroom floor with a tooth brush. Should materials for cleaning be totally unvavailable, you may do pushups until your parent is tired.

Parents expect their instructions to be followed exactly. Parents also expect you to be able to think for yourself. If your parents wanted a robot, they would have had a last week Marine Corp Boot Camp specimen assigned to them.

A few observations about parenting from being the father of 3 teenagers. Although I am not even in the same ballpark as my parents on the subject of discipline, my children understand clearly there are reprecussions from failing to obey instructions. And I will admit that I have indeed had them in the bathroom with toothbrushes over the years.

And you cannot expect children to have discipline when their parents have none. I chalk up a great deal of the issues that I see in the parenting crisis today to something my father always called "Poor Impulse Control." I didn't always understand him then, but I certainly do now.

by mrafrohead

I the DI's do a great job. That's partly how I am when I raise my kids. They do a good job, and they are rewarded for it. They F up and I'm all over them like flies to honey. I only spank it it's really important, or if the kid is too young to be yelled at (where they wouldn't understand what is going on).

Then for my boy, there are other ways to do things to get the point across. More father/son kinds of things, that I think are passed on generation to generation.

But you gotta nip that stuff QUICK, because the next time you blink, those rugrats will be twice as old and if you aren't careful, you can screw yourself.

I'll tell ya one thing, It'd be a cold day in hell , the day that my kids take over MY house. WE are a family, but it's still MY house, and they just reside there. They can be removed just as fast as they came into this world. One call to Military Academy, and buh-bye... ;p

Mrafrohead

by fat chink

that we (yes, the 'voting' public) have allowed our government to take away almost all of the parent's disciplinary rights. God forbid that the child should be given more than a time-out, even verbal reprimands can put a parent into possible legal trouble.

I vote we go back to using corporal punishment. Stiff discipline (including spankings ) should be done from an early age. Strict limits should be imposed and taught to the child from an early age. Children who are not taught limits end up as out of control spoiled brats.

I could go on for ever on this topic, but will gracefully bow out now....

by mrafrohead

Man, I LOVE your nick!!! Though I do hope you're of some kind of Asian decent to be able to pull off the ummm, Chink part without having the "racist hounds" running in.

@first I thought it said, Fat Chik, but when I took a closer look, ahhh-soooooo, it is a whitty one!!!

by oz_media

Some people have a sense of humour, some don't. I say it will just be a matter of time before the whiners come out of the closet again.

by fat chink

Been an overweight asian my entire life, and have used that handle since time began.

And for any of the whiners who may read this thread, don't bother to post whiny messages, unless you are willing to meet me face to face and get your a** kicked.

by mlandis

I have 2 kids. 11 and 9 years old. Discipline is a constant job - teaching that there are consequences for every choice, some good, some bad - depends on the choice. And it is not easy to do.

Sometimes I understand why some parents take the easy way out and do everything - the chores, laundry and cleaning - to avoid the ugly and nasty confrontations. The kids in this story don't respect their parents, and haven't learned any boundaries - how come? How much have the parents let go by?

What have the children been taught? Have they been taught anything? How to do laundry, basic cooking skills, sew a button?

These lessons are necessary, and often inconvenient - teaching moments are not something that can always be scheduled, they must be not only scheduled but taken advantage of when offered. Sure,when I am cooking a dinner I can get it done in half the time without a kid or two at my elbow - but all they learn by that is that meals magically appear out of nowhere, and I find them a pain in the butt when I am cooking. How is that a good lesson?

Have boundaries ever been set up by these parents? I tell my kids that to do their own "stuff" their own rooms - whatever. Then they can help me - as an award. It still works sometimes, depending on the chore - probably because they are still young enough to think helping us is cool.

I try to keep one common room - the living room - off limits to their junk and mess. I have a large measure of success with that. It is a boundary -but it's not always perfect either.

I am not a proponent of physical punishment, but there are effective punishments that work. I'm not perfect at discipline either - but I am always at it.

What took them so long to realize that things were way out of line? People often confuse a stay-at-home mom with a good mom. That's not always true. How are these kids at school? Have there been problems brought to the parents' attention?

Me - I think that sadly, this is more refective of poor parenting, and what kids become when the parents are ineffective.

The whole family needs to be turned around, not just the children.

Maureen

by ravenhawk

This is clearly a case of poor parenting. The children have learned that they can drive their parents out of the house. There's no respect for them, which is evident by the boy requesting a ride from the mother who was running a high fever.

My wife doesn't believe in any sort of physical punishment which I respect as she is the primary caregiver. Our children (ages 4 and 2 so they aren't rebellious as of yet), are very respectful and usually listen well. When they misbehave or show disrespect they are punished by having privlegies removed (T.V., desserts, storytime, etc...). I think this set the groundwork for later in life more teenage desired privleges will be used such as the phone, T.V., car, weekends can be removed as punishment. I believe this can be as effective as having your child going out and 'cutting their own switch'.

But leaving your house and basically telling your kids that you're on strike? That just makes you look incompetent. Stand your ground, you are the adults. Just don't cook for them or do they laundry.

by oz_media

Nothing better than bending your date over your knee for a good spanking! They are usually somewhat receptive, however people seem to get quite miffed when the waiter can't get past your table. :)

by mrafrohead

I prefer to make them take their arses outside and immediately pick out their own switch.

And when they act up really badly. I braid them together into a "megaswitch".

;p

by mlandis

dominatrix in this relationship you sniveling little worms!

Now give me your paws.

Good, good boys!

Here is a little treat for you. Come on boys!

Now go get your leashes! If you are real good I'll tie the both of you together, and you can go do whatever it is male dogs do.

by fat chink

I love your attitude. You are absolutely right that it is work, and never ending. That's one of the big problems with many parents these days, they want the perks, but not the work. They are from the 'feel good' generation. I love my wife, but as far as paying attention to what's going on and maintaining boundaries which are set, she is lacking.

The last of our boys is now 17 and it is still a daily 'battle' to keep boundaries/limits in place.

He's a great kid/young adult, but still pushes the limits as is to be expected.

by mlandis

We haven't even hit the teen years yet.

Such a headache I see coming!

And thanks.

Maureen

by mrafrohead

Yeah, I took a few weeks off of work, went and took the tests to get my PhD. I got it in #420. So I'm now a bone-r-fried chr0nic doc... ;p

Just kidding. Been REALLY REALLY busy. We're replacing all of the computers at work, so it's been a handful. That and getting my boxes at home running, I had multiple hardware pieces crap out on me on the same box at the same time. Talk about trouble shooting hell... ;p

Oh, and I'm finally learning linux... again... This time for real though. I did the greatest motivator of all. I converted my wifes computer to Fedora last night. I figure that if that doesn't get me to learn it nothing will. Because when she's breathing down my neck with the, why won't this work, why won't that work... I figure I'll learn it really quick. ;p Oh, and she doesn't know I did that yet either, and she has a hard time with Windoze, so it'll be an adventure.

It's nice to see ya again. I've been reading through your posts of late trying to find something to nitpick. I'll have something whitty for ya soon ;p.

Mrafrohead

by oz_media

Damn, ponies aren't coming in tonight, exactors split and triactors topped all the time. Oh well...

As for you post, you had me going, had to open a window but then you brought mrafrohead into it and the freeze set in. Your subtle yet effective shock value was bang on that time!

Sorry mrafrohead but that there just aint funny at all!

'Tie us together'...you sick, sick woman you! Buy us both a beer, now THERE's an idea! :D

by mlandis

but the sick humor was what I had available. So it had to do. I don't know mrafrohead asyet, but when I read the chat between you I figured he could take a joke.

You are easy to buy beer for as you and I like the same ones. What does he drink?

Sorry about the ponies. Odds and all that! Were you at the track?

Maureen

by mrafrohead

I'm mrafrohead. So, now that we've been introseduced, now you know me... ;p

Yep, I can take a joke very well. As a matter of fact, I'm usually the butt of the joke. I'm still working on that one.

I drink vodka. Prefer Grey Goose. Or Belvedere. But I smoke the chr0nic... Yah have to ask Oz about that... And a few others here, though those that have fessed up are limited...

Mrafrohead

by oz_media

POnies ahhhh, the ponies. Well I made a huge mistake a few years back, I opened a Horse PLayer Interactive account. Just like a debit card, you fill it up and spend away, saves getting betting vouchers and lineups.

So it's great at the track, you can sit at your table with a drink in one hand and the new palm pilot style betting devices in the other and just do everything on your card number, including paying your tab and tipping the hostess (another benefit of live racing).

The downside, it allows you to bet ONLINE. Many tracks show full video simulcasting now, HPI members get selected tracks for free viewing. So you can sit on your arse with a bottle of Johnny and a bucket of ice while watching and betting races. Actually I'm just waiting for Woodbine to start at 4:30 and playing Flamboro in the meantime. All play and no work but someone's got to do it. I have band members out here for the holidays so aside from their Prima Donna whining, I don't have shows to promote right now.

What more can I say other than "THEY'RE OFF!"

mrafrohead, he and I bumped heads some time ago now, I can't remember what we were so fumed about (probably politics) but we went toe to toe pretty good for a while. I think we both realized we were being a little over the top and after a short hiatus we managed to find out that we had quite a bit in common. Go figure, eh?

Now I think he's this really cool dude and he has a great sense of twisted humour, thus your comments were just fine I'm sure.

That's the funny thing about guys, they can beat the crap out of eacch other then brush each other off and go for a beer, often ending up in them becoming friends. It's an animalistic instinct of showing your magnificent tail feathers or pounding your chest like an ape.

WOMEN on the other and will have a spat of an argument over absolutely nothing at all and absolutely despise each other for life, often feeling even more angry as time passes by. This said to be due to the natural instinct of women to seek security and protection.

Before women's libbers go all snakey, even single and very independant women display such behaviour of seeking stability and security. It doesn't necessarily mean seeking a provider or relying on someone.

by mrafrohead

so getting in over your head... ;p

For starters, we can keep Oz in the gimp suit, and you mlandis would be the one tied up...

From there it would all be up to me to command. And you would listen... ;p

Mrafrohead

As for Me and Oz. Only in his wildest dreams... ;p wocka wocka

by oz_media

Geez afrohead, I didn't say squat and yet you are talking about ME being in a gimp suit and MY wildest dreams! Blow it out your...!

Take it out on the poster, not me, believe me she'll dish it out just as well.

You've run into two of the most sarcastic humour ridden women to grace us here, you know I can go at it pretty good but you need to know when YOU are in over you head, mate. :D

I wish you luck but leave me the hell out of it, I know better ! :p

by mrafrohead

I couldn't resist... You were brought into it and just had to run with it. Tweaked of course. Because, no offense, but the though of being tied to you....... well, ..... hrmmm, I don't know what to type, but if I could type **shudder** you'd get the drift... ;p

As for the getting in over her head, it was for the poster. Not you, you just got caught in the cross fire. Think of it as Collateral Damage. It's all fair in love and war... ;p

So, now that I have met one, who is the other?

by mrafrohead

"Go figure, eh?"

Dude, you are SO Canadian... ;o) eh?

Mrafrohead

ps. thanks for the kind words. I'd reciprocate, but I think you're a dick... wocka wocka j/k

by mlandis

Good evening!

Is it January 15th yet?

Been swamped - at work, at home and at the kids' school. I leave you two lunatics alone for the afternoon and already you're posing...er, I meant posturing!

What in heaven (or hell, after meeting some of the "Heaven" candidates I'd much prefer hell, I think)is a gimp suit?

Wouldn't one of those sky-diver outfits do? Harnesses? THAT has potential.

A jump suit?

(I have a feeling I'm really getting in deep over here, and am going to be ridiculed and humiliated. I can deal. But remember, as OZ pointed out, I can be interesting. (Does that mean weird? I guess so.)

Really, what is a gimp suit? I ain't never heard of no such thing.

Maureen

PS Vodka is cool. I was worried that I was gonna hafta buy you a Rolling Rock or something else from Beer 101.

by oz_media

Could said "no doot aboot it" or "fer sure,eh?"
but didn't want to get TOO Canadian on you.

As for the dick comment, that's fine, I was just being courteous, I rarely say what I really think here, I still have a login to prove it. ]:)

by oz_media

I really don't know but one can assume it refers to afrohead's daily attire. ba-dum-dum

I kind like the thought of the gag ball and zippered undies and ....well, I won't get into it.

by mrafrohead

I hope that you know I was only joking. that's the j/k - just kidding...

I'm not sure if you took my comment seriously or not. It was meant in good humor.

Mrafrohead

by maecuff

Just watch pulp fiction and then you'll see a gimp suit. I'm thinking about making that the required uniform for my IT department.

by oz_media

Believe me, as a former Richmond resident (BC, Canada not Virginia) I am used to Asians and Asian jokes, that's actually where I heard the best ones.

I have no problem dishing it out and I can take it all to owell, when you start saying you are gonna kick someone's a** though, THAT'S where you will run into issues, believe me! Some dude said the same to me and when I called him on it, he managed to squirm and lie his way out of it for at least three months of BS on here, it's not worth it there are too many clowns around that will waste your time and never show up to the party.

You need to remember that even though this is a fairly casual discussion board, there are people here who go crazy when you say black instead of Afro-American (labelling all black Americans as African and not American no matter where they were born). There are some really over the top politically correct wannabe's here, they THINK they are being PC when they are actually trying to further segregate people. You will hear from them I am sure, but instead of saying you'll kick their ass, which isn't going to be likely in a global community just stand up for WHY it is okay for you to say you are a fat chink.

Personally I think it's quite funny, I have known many a fat chink in my time and most agree they are fat chinks. Some people can't take it, usualy not people that are part of a visible minority themselves though, I am just saying your time will come when people rant about your politically incorrect alias, it won't be me though.

This discussion is closed to new replies.