He makes some good points. You just have to realize that for his statements to be correct, you have to consider that some of those tasks that can be easier or more difficult, to which a given application caters, are tasks not worth doing.
In other words, two applications are, according to this reasoning, equally easy to use. They are equally easy to use because one makes it easier to accomplish task foo, and the other to accomplish task bar, but in order to get ease of accomplishment for one task you give up ease of accomplishment of the other. Perhaps task foo is organizing your CD collection and building a searh index to aid in finding a given song, and task bar is flailing about for hours trying to find a given song because the CD collection isn't organized worth a damn. Obviously, task foo is a worthwhile task, and task bar is not, for most definitions of "worthwhile". That doesn't change the fact that the application designed to make task bar easier is not, in fact, easier to use toward that end.
It's bordering on sophistry, but that doesn't mean he's actually clueless.