Discussion Locked

Personal income tax in the USA

0 helpful
70 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[b]I lifted this item from a discussion at a Christian website.

I invite (read that as encourage) anyone to study this and to either vindicate it or debunk it.[/b]

Luke 20:25 And he said unto them, Render therefore unto Caesar the things which be Caesar's, and unto God the things which be God's. (KJV)

The point here is that we are to give to Caesar the things that belong to him not the things that do NOT belong to him. But in America we have a different situation.

Under a Caesar a person is bound to obey him because he is the ruler and sole authority, but we do not have a Caesar...at least not yet.

Here in America we are governed by "THE LAW",..that is...the United States Constitution and protected by it and The Bill of Rights. Under this system it is "We The People" who are the rulers, not the government we elect. The Constitution is the sole authority that ALL must obey including the Government. If a law IS lawful and is not in violation of the Constitution, then we are to obey it and make sure the government does too. If the law, including the Tax Law under Title 26 USC says we have to pay a Federal Income Tax then we are required to. HOWEVER if the law does not say we are required to file or pay a Federal Income Tax then we are not to pay it.

The problem is that Title 26 USC was written in such a way as to deceive the American people but at the same time tell the truth. That is why the referrence sections of each section was removed from the last issue of Ttile 26 but did exist in the previous issue. When you investigate it you will find something very interest. According to the LAW, USC Title 26 known as the Internal Revenue Code, the final section in which we are to determine our Federal Income Taxs is burried in a little known section under Subsection "N" section 861. In this section it makes the final determination as to WHO owes Federal Income taxes. You will be shocked to find that you will not find the DOMESTIC income of US Citizens to be taxable. Foreign income yes, Non-Resident Aliens yes, Foreign Nationals yes, but NOT the domestic income of US Citizens. Domestic income means any money you made within the 50 States and it's NOT taxable.

The Government and the IRS are up in arms over the truth being exposed and are trying to do anything to quash it, but they do realize that thanks to Patriots and the internet, it's a matter of time before the momentum of truth will be unstopable. For more information... go to http://www.whatistaxed.com (also -- http://www.taxableincome.net -- under reconstruction so keep checking) Numerous former IRS agents, Tax Attorneys and CPAs among others are coming forward and blowing the whistle

70 replies

by maxwell edison

....why not try to assemble some coherent thoughts and point out exactly what about it is crap? Point out what is wrong, and give us your version of why it's wrong. Break it down, sentence by sentence, point out the crap, and give us your alternative.

by escheitz

Maybe I will, take some time to look at this, but I have seen these conspiracy tax theories many times every year there is a new one and they are usually a waste of time, or maybe a good laugh. I will give it a look later, and post my analysis, should be interesting?

by maxwell edison

If I could find an extra hour or two to write and submit a detailed answer to this, I would. It deserves more than a mere passing comment. Mine would be a message that would come from an early and quiet Sunday morning over a few cups of coffee. And it is one of my pet-peeve issues, so I'll try to make some time.

by maxwell edison

However, I'm also of the mind-set that forced taxation of one's income is a gross violation of one's individual liberty, and is tantamount to denying a person's constitutional right to life and property. Quite frankly I'm not sure how the government gets away with it. And to paraphrase Yogi Berra, the founders, upon seeing the state of the government and its infringement on individual liberties, would be turning in their graves if they were alive today.

I just thought the issue deserved more than an off-the-cuff remark. It's certainly more important than one.

by rkuhn040172

If you no longer want to be forced into paying taxes, then stop driving on the roads that we have paid for, stop going to public hospitals, stop sending your kids to our public schools, etc.

I think you get it.

Hey, no one likes taxes but they are a necessary evil. We all benefit from certain aspects of them.

by maxwell edison

It is so silly to take my comments on taxation and apply them as though I'm suggesting ALL taxation should be abolished. Isn't it possible to have a genuine discussion around here? This sure is getting old.

There are TWO types of taxes. One type is necessary to maintain the infrastructure and sovereignty of a nation. These would include the roads and such, military, fire and police protection, and so on. The second type is a tax that goes to support social programs such as Welfare, Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, or any other tax that takes a dollar from the person who earned it only to give it to a person who did not.

Of course, you won't concede my valid point because it won't suit your desired outcome.

And for the record, even though my taxes contribute to paying for the public school system, I choose to pay for private school anyway. I don't like the notion of a government school dictating to me how I should educate my kids. And speaking from a basic principle, I don't believe that you should be forced to pay for the education of my kids, or my retirement or medical care, for that matter. That's my responsibility, not yours. I can tell, however, that you believe I should pay for yours.

by rkuhn040172

I like the idea.

No politician can get elected without a majority vote. Then put on the ballot politician A, politician B, and Boob.

Besides, I've always been a boob kind of guy.

by jdclyde

that are saying things like this, and claim that they do not have to pay federal taxes.

I look at it this way, it will cost me a lot less to just pay it than to try to get out of jail and prove my point with all of the US government having a direct interest in keeping me from winning in court.

by maxwell edison

....as others have lost time and time again. But I still don't know how they get away with it.

Consider this. I don't want to work for money. I want to live off the land that was passed on to me by my father, and I have no money. But I don't need money, I can just "live off the land". However, I must pay property taxes on my property. How can I do that? I MUST work. I MUST give my time to others so that I can pay the taxes.

Moreover, if I build a fence for my neighbor, and he gives me a side of beef in return, I MUST pay taxes on the value of that side of beef as though it's "income". I have no money, remember, but again, I MUST work to pay only the taxes.

Therefore, the practice of taxation is that of FORCING a person to WORK against his will. What does that sound like? Something I thought the 13th amendment made very clear.

Section 1. Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.

Section 2. Congress shall have power to enforce this article by appropriate legislation.

Like I said, I don't know how they get away with it.

by greggn

I almost hesitate to use the phrase "Common Sense" in the same sentence with the word "Government" - but I'll hazard it anyway.

No man is an island. We all rely on the government to do things which an individual can't do for themselves. This would include safeguarding our borders, keeping peace in the streets, making laws to protect our environment, and educating even our poorest children so that we can all benefit from their improved productivity. There are many other valid assignments for our government.

You can argue that government isn't doing their job very well, or very efficiently. You can argue that government is overstepping their rightful tasks. But it's hard to argue that the citizens don't benefit from government services. Common Sense dictates that if I benefit from people working on my behalf, I should be responsible for some fair allocation of the costs.

Naturally, nothing on this earth is fair. Should we only tax property - or only sales - or usage - or what?

Frankly, I'd rather have government than anarchy. Government has to be funded in some fashion. I don't know a more equitable way to fund government than by taxes voted by the people.

Since you brought Religion into the discussion, I'll mention that I've always enjoyed that story of the coin. In my opinion, Jesus was saying that the coin showed the image of Caesar - and therefore could be taxed by Caesar. Yes, this means that Christians should support their government in anything that doesn't violate God's laws - including taxes. But I've always found the next phrase to be more touching. We should render to God what is God's. Mankind was made in God's image. I'm sure that God less interested in our money than in having us yield our entire self to Him.

by jdclyde

every political party realizes that they have gotten accustom to the income raised based on "temporary" taxes during war, that they were not about to let it go.

Now it is even to the point were the democrats expect only the rich to pay this extorted tax for everyone else as the poor poor shouldn't have to be expected to earn their keep in the world.

The same compasionate people that assasinated everyone at Ruby Ridge and also used military equipment (a tank) against civilians (also against the law) in Wako after making the deliberate choice not to peacefully pick their leader up when he was in town earlier.

Demcrats are not the only people that are adicted to this, as Republicans are not about to let it go either.

The biggest problem I have is when these leaches refer to this as "revenue". Money that I am FORCED to GIVE is NOT revenue. Revenue is something you EARN. Then the whole "redistribution of wealth" of taking money from people who work for a living and give it to people who DON'T work for a living is NOT just or fair, nor should it be legal.

If there are people in this world that feel so much compasion for the poor poor that they think that the poor should get something for nothing, then let these compasionate, caring people give their OWN money away instead of giving MY money away. I have my OWN family to take care of.

by maxwell edison

There are less oppressive ways than the income tax to generate necessary revenue for government. Moreover, more than half of today's government expendetures are not "necessary" to maintain our government.

P.S. If a man wants to be "an island", who are you to tell him otherwise?

by greggn

You're absolutely correct to state that our government does far more than is necessary. No doubt the founders of our country would be angry to see how we've allowed the Federal and State and Local governments to usurp our individual rights and freedoms.

Nonetheless, our government is a result of the democratic process. Whether we like it or not, the people allowed it to happen.

p.s. It is not _me_ who would tell a man that he cannot be "an island". It is a simple statement of fact. Every individual in the United States is a beneficiary of the services which are funded by taxes. No man can be entirely self-sufficient. Can he avoid using the publicly paved roads and sidewalks? Can he grow all his own food so as to avoid using anything from a farm subsidy>

Even if some hermit could do these things, he would still not be "an island" since he enjoys the protection from anarchy that Law Enforcement and military provide. He would benefit from the clean air and water that is only possible because of the laws enforced on industry by the government. In any interaction with other people, our imaginary hermit would benefit from their publicly funded education.

No man is an island...simple fact. The entire earth is a closed environment. We depend on each other and need government. That government must be funded in some manner. In America, the political process has determined that the funding will be a complicated combination of income and property taxes (and who knows what else).

I'm in favor of a more equitable method - but someone has to come up with that method first, and then get that method approved by the democratic public and passed into law. Until then, I'll keep paying my taxes.

by stdog

The Constitution set up a means for the governemnet to fund the protection activitive. Tarrifs. Bringing goods into or sending them out of the U.S.A. Was ment to be the governments source of funds.

If the income tax were not there, then the federal governemnt would not have been able to stick it's hands into so much.

by jer.stephens

I partly agree. Most taxes are necessary. Property taxes to fund schools. Gas taxes to fund our infastructure....etc. But the as I read about how the income tax is basically just paying the interest on the debt we have incurred to the federal reserve, a band of private greedy international bankers then that is where I draw the line! Congress signed off on the Federal Reserve Act back in 1913 so congress can abolish the Fed and take back the power to create and coin money!! I see first had how our government just wastes money that it borrows from the fed and I have to work hard to help pay back that loan??? I will not stand for it. I work hard for my money and also the fact that the income tax is unconstitutional just makes me more angry!! PEOPLE WAKE UP!!!!!

by maxwell edison

You said, "Since you brought Religion into the discussion.....".

How and where did I bring religion into the discussion?

by greggn

My comment should've been a reply to the message at the start of this discussion. Posting my comment as a reply to your message was my mistake. Sorry.

by jardinier

Maxwell didn't bring religion into the discussion.

The only mention of religion is in my initial post which stated:

"I lifted this item from a discussion at a Christian website."

by reddiewhip9

>The only mention of religion is in my initial >post which stated:
>"I lifted this item from a discussion at a >Christian website."
-and you quoted scripture and verse from the Christian Bible - King James Version, and elaborated further on it for a paragraph or two.
Since we are discussing finanace from Christian biblical perspective, why don't Christians blockade check cashing places that charge userious fees? That is a rhetorical question. You'd rather angle an attack at me since I'm pointing out your truthieness.

by jdclyde

Your one and only post on TR, and you feel someone is trying to "angle an attack" at you?

Ok boys and girls. Your word for the day is "delusional". Can you say "delusional"? I knew you could!

Where do you get this "we"? :D

If ANYONE should picket a QuickCash joint it is the NAACP and other equal rights groups because it is taking advantage of the poor, not the Christians. But then, you can't be taken advantage of if you have made the CHOICE to use their service, now can you? Stop blaming people for other peoples stupidity.

While I get as many typos as the next poster (sometimes more), I still have to wonder just what "truthieness" is?

[/sarcasm]

by jardinier

As I am not an American, the subject matter of this discussion is of no interest to me.

However all I am hearing so far is a re-hash of the usual stuff about paying taxes to subsidise dole-bludgers.

Has anyone yet even LOOKED at the website listed in the question?

Has anyone LOOKED at USC Title 26 Subsection "N" section 861?

by jdclyde

Wow, talk about rush rush rush.

I just saw this as I was going to bed last night and sent one quick post. I have now been in my office for less than an hour and your already expecting us to have done our research?

Remember the time zones....

"dole-bludgers"? Never heard that one before, but a quick check on google shows it is pretty common. I have just always heard "Welfare rat".

I also challenge your first statement. I will say this IS of interest, just not consequence?

by jardinier

Nothing to do with time zones. Note the date of the initial post by myself (January 28) and the date of the first comment (January 30).

So it was the weekend. I have not noticed that factor to slow down a discussion for quite a while now.

Or is it that you all post only when you are at work?

Anyhow the discussion is now getting under way and thanks for your contribution.

by jardinier

for the verdict of the jury.

Is the claim made by the guy in the initial post correct or not?

Is domestic income of American citizens taxable or not?

by rob mekel

funny how people don't read others reactions. But do expect others to read theirs.

Or maybe they put it in just a few seconds after one an other.

Rob

@life is too short to not enjoy it

by maxwell edison

And I must admit that I am getting extremely tired of rehashing the same old points over and over, never having anyone concede a valid point, and never having changed anyone's mind. What an absolute waste of time it is.

by maxwell edison

....has read USC Title 26 Subsection N section 861, or any other section, subsection, subsubsection, or subsubsubsection.

But who could possibly read the stupid thing?

If an average person can read 300 words per minute (and some people can't even do that), it would take that person 5,616 minutes, or 94 hours, or almost 10 days of reading, 10 hours per day, to read the entire tax code. But wait, there's more. The entire volumes of IRS regulations, the supplements to the tax code, contain over 6,752,000 words! At 300 wpm reading speed, that's 22,507 minutes, or 375 hours, or almost 38 days of reading, 10 hours per day, to read all the IRS regulations. The combined reading time is almost 50 days of reading -- nearly TWO MONTHS -- 10 hours a day to read all the material related to federal taxation in the United States.

And that doesn't even take comprehension (or lack thereof) into consideration!

So I don't really blame anybody for not reading it. Heck, I'll admit that even I haven't read the whole thing myself. But neither have my legislators who voted the stupid thing into law! At least not in its entirety. Just how stupid is that? It's not as stupid as stupid people wanting even more of the same stupid thing, that's for sure.

Facts and figures:

- As of 2001, the Internal Revenue Code contained 1,685,000 words?a 13% increase since 1995 and nearly 380 times the number of words in the U.S. Constitution.

- As of 2001, IRS Regulations contained over 6,752,000 words?a 10% increase since 1995 and over 8-? times the total number of words in the King James Bible.

- There are 733 separate sections of the federal income tax code?a 612% increase over the tax code in 1954.

- As of last year, the IRS produced 649 separate forms, schedules, and instructions with pproximately 16,100 lines. IRS publications providing guidance to taxpayers alone totaled about 13,400 pages.

- In 1998, 46 tax experts surveyed came up with 46 different answers when determining a particular tax liability. The tax calculations ranged from $34,240 to $68,912.

- Ten years ago, the IRS said it took the average person 9-? hours to complete the 1040. Today?s average is 13 hours?time enough to complete at least 4 baseball games.

- This year, Americans will spend an estimated 6.4 billion hours complying with the tax code?6.4 billion hours ago was 734,645 years before the birth of Jesus Christ.

- It cost all taxpayers an estimated $203.4 billion in 2003 just to comply with the tax code?that is enough money to buy a fleet of 5.1 million brand new Cadillac DeVille 4-Door Sedans at retail price. Annual compliance costs
are projected to rise to $244 billion by 2007.

- Nearly three-in-five tax filers use paid preparers.

- In 2002, businesses spent an estimated 2.75 billion hours complying with the federal tax system?that?s the equivalent of 1,000 employees working 40-hour weeks for more than 132 years.

- The IRS spent $9.4 billion in 2003 (up from $9.1 billion in 2002)?that?s more than the FY2003 appropriations for the FBI and the Federal Prison System combined.

- In FY2003, the IRS employed an average of 98,824 people?more than the number of employees (as of September 2003) at the Departments of State, Labor, Energy, Housing & Urban Development, and Education, plus the Environmental Protection Agency combined.

- Yet, with all these resources, in 2001 the IRS answered less than 60% of the phone calls they received requesting information or assistance. When the IRS does answer, one out of every five answers they provided is either incomplete or incorrect.

- Throughout the rest of the year, Americans will continue paying more federal taxes every time they fly on an airplane, make a phone call, fill up their gas tank, or even sit down to have a cold beer. These federal excise taxes cost the average American about $500 per year.

- Since the federal government taxes corporations, they are forced to factor these costs into the prices of the products and services they sell. Corporate income taxes and the employer share of payroll taxes cost consumers over $1,600 a year in increased prices.

- Last year, 100% of the income the average American earned from January 1st to April 13th (103 days) went to pay federal, state, and local taxes. Therefore, April 14th was ?Tax Freedom Day,? the day on which the average American started working for anything besides taxes. This year the Tax Foundation reports that, thanks to Republican tax cuts, Tax Freedom Day is April 11th (the earliest Tax Freedom Day in 37 years).

- However, if current law prevails and the tax cuts are not extended, the Tax Foundation projects that Tax Freedom Day will fall back to April 14th next year and reach April 29th in 2014.

- Americans spent more time working to pay federal, state, and local taxes than they spent working to pay medical expenses, put food on their tables, and buy clothing combined.

Sources for Tax Facts:

General Accounting Office, IRS, Office of Management and Budget,
Office of Personnel Management, and The Tax Foundation
This Document Was Prepared at Taxpayer Expense

Prepared by Republican Study Committee
Rep. Sue Myrick (R-NC), Chairman

http://www.thelibertycommittee.org/taxfacts.htm

And then there's state taxes, local taxes, sales taxes, property taxes, capital gains taxes, inheritance taxes, user taxes, and loser taxes; road tolls, surcharges and misscharges; access fees, special fees; and probably even peeing fees.

Go ahead all you stupid people out there. Keep supporting more of the same.

by will_eaton

Ok, I read the link on Cornell's site and here's my two cents:

For those of use that have a regular 9-5 job, we have to pay taxes.

Quote from the Cornell link:

(a) Gross income from sources within United States
The following items of gross income shall be treated as income from sources within the United States:

......

(3) Personal services
Compensation for labor or personal services performed in the United States; except that compensation for labor or services performed in the United States shall not be deemed to be income from sources within the United States if:

...the IF's don't apply to the majority of Americans.

SO.....keep paying your taxes. If you don't like it, write your Congressman, exercise your right to vote (which costs you NOTHING), or move out of the US.

Don't get me wrong...I'm not fond of paying taxes, but I understand that if I wish to do more than just "live off the land", then I have to have money to buy things. And since I'm not a criminal (stealing money), that means I have to work.

I am all in favor of doing away with government programs that take my (tax) money and give it to someone who is too lazy or stupid to go get a job at their local McDonald's, and any other programs like it.

Will

by stdog

"In 1998, 46 tax experts surveyed came up with 46 different answers when determining a particular tax liability. The tax calculations ranged from $34,240 to $68,912."

This is one of my biggest issues with the current system. If "experts" cannot even agree on this, how am I supposed to figure it out?

"It cost all taxpayers an estimated $203.4 billion in 2003 just to comply with the tax code... Annual compliance costs are projected to rise to $244 billion by 2007."

That's a lot of money wasted in my book.

"The IRS spent $9.4 billion in 2003"

Another waste.

The tax code should be simple enough that the averge time spent is 30 minutes to 1 hour.

All member of the legislative branch should be required to do their own taxes, no CPA or tax-pros. Same for IRS employies.

On think not mentioned above is that if you call/visit the IRS for help, and you get a wrong answer, guess who's liable? But, how are you to know it was teh wrong answer? You find out 3 years later when you get audited, then are force to bay interest and fines for _you_ mistake. Any documented answer from the IRS should be binding, or at least not penalized.

No payroll withholding. Individuals should file quarterly like the "self employed" do. Once people start paying the tax directly, we might see a push for changes.

by rjhenn

I think this is actually the core of the matter, not the (possibly crazy) theories many of the tax protesters use:

Who can possibly understand the tax code well enough to produce a return that is both accurate and complete?

By 'accurate and complete' I mean that you aren't paying any more tax than you owe, and the IRS can't successfully challenge any of it.

I estimate that it would take me 3-6 man months of work just to determine if I was capable of understanding the tax code. Currently, I don't believe that I am capable (and I consistently test well up in the top 2% in both verbal and math skills). If this is so, then how likely is it that anyone preparing or auditing tax returns is competent to do so? Or anyone enforcing the law or judging in the courts?

Given the political realities, I don't see any way to reform the income tax code to fix things. I think the best solution would be to completely eliminate the income tax, and replace it with a sales tax. Most of the states already have a sales tax, so the mechanism for collection and enforcement is already in place. It's simple, and there are ways to make it progressive (see www.fairtax.org for one proposal). It would make everybody's life simpler, and might even strengthen the economy by removing much unproductive effort.

"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein

by rob mekel

is getting to you, ain't it. ]:)
Haven't seen you this pissed off on any discussion. :(

It's all about government equalizing the wealth of a county/state/country/union/world. Whether you like it or not. :) It's a money carrousel like a never ending story and all in favour of the people that are not as "lucky" as you are. :D

But then again some is to your benefit as your getting good roads, nice parks, etc. On the other side government do tend to forget the safety of its inhabitants, as shown on New Orleans, if they think there are more important issues to take care off, Iraq warII. :?

But then these are all questions of importance answered by politicians and judged by elections.

Rob

@life istoo short to not enjoy it :x

by jdclyde

just giving money away to others isn't.

I can't speak for the others here, but I can say I am not where I am now because of being "lucky". It took years of working 50 hours in a shop, teaching on weekends and taking classes on week nights. Leave at 6:30 am everyday, and half of the days not get home until after 10 pm. No "luck" there, just busting my ass to get where I want to be.

I have no sympathy for people too lazy to get off the couch and do something to earn their keep.

New Orleans had been given money to work out an evacuation plan, but they spent the money elsewhere. Why isn't there criminal neglect charges?

oh, I could go on..... but I won't.

All I know is I bust my a$$ to be able to raise my boys and it is getting harder and harder, with the "feel gooders" that don't have an intellegent thought in their heads looking for more ways to spend MY money. Logic will see us through.

by rob mekel

you can't let go. Really pissed off still (maybe never getting over it). Would be sad. :(
Cause if you did take a step back from my lines you would, as I meant it to be, read that I don't disagree with you. :)

Government is responsible for the right investments made with/on tax money. At least that?s the case over here.
What me really pisses of is a government deciding money for one project redirecting to an other project and then when they see that it was not very fare to the people whom it concerned give them a little money so they can move. When, in the first place, if they didn't redirect the money would not have been necessary.
But then again lazy a$$e$ must go to work and earn there own money. (and pay taxes, yes yes yes ]:) )

In the end it still is: These are all questions of importance answered by politicians and judged by elections.
lol, when do you have those elections? ]:)

Rob

@life is too short not to enjoy it :x

by jdclyde

about the government taking care of infrastructure. some will claim that even education is NOT something they have the power to do, but it is in the best interest of the country to have an educated population. (too bad they do such a bad job).

The government does NOT have the right to spend my money on social programs that have failed for over half a century already.

People will howl up a storm if any tax money is spent on anything related to religion, but they have no problem dumping cash by the bucket on "the arts".

Fair taxes. If you have a tax rate that says everyone pays X%, the more you make, the more you pay. Why is it then fair to ALSO increase the percentage that must be paid by the people that actually decide to work? The more effort I put into advancing MYSELF, the more I am penalized.

A fine is a tax for doing something bad.
A tax is a fine for doing something good.

by will_eaton

Because the poeple that make the most money also do a better job of hiding it so it doesn't get taxed.

However, I agree...flat tax rate for all. Or better yet, higher tax rate for lower income. That should motivate people to better themselves and get the illegal immigrants out of McDonald's. :p

William

by rkuhn040172

I like the idea of a fair/flat tax.

However, is it really fair? Ok, say the fair tax is set at 15% (flat, fair, or sales tax).

One person makes $50,000 a year. They pay $7,500. Another person makes $1,000,000. They pay $150,000.

Did they really consume $142,500 more goods and services that our government provided? I think not.

Fair (or fairer) would be a fair or flat tax, say 15%, capped at some point. Just because someone makes more doesn't mean they should pay more.

And maybe, for every job you personally create for our economy, we cut you some slack. You helped create another tax payer, why not decrease your tax for the favor?

by rkuhn040172

I agree with you almost entirely. However, others don't. And in a democracy, the majority rules.

While there are issues with most any government program, some are still necessary. Not all poor people are poor because they are lazy, fat or stupid.

Your kids education is none of my business, until you recognize that we all have a vested interest in a well educated society...that benefits us all.

Anyways, some people do get into financial trouble through no fault of their own. A safety net is sometimes needed and if you don't think so, I pray you never find out the hard way.

by jdclyde

I found my problem. I thought I had already added you as a contact a long time ago, and I usually go off the "posts by my contacts" list. Problem resolved.

Oh, and yes, I am on at home more than when I am at work. (not much of a social life yet!)

by jardinier

flattery will get you --- everywhere :)

As for social life, I have been pounding the pavement of the internet matchmaking highway and hope to be able to announce some good news in the not too distant future.

by gadgetgirl

to hang around waiting for this good news?

Huh?

How cruel is THAT, Jules??!!

C'mon. Spill it

You know you really want to..........

GG

Translation: Nooooooooo! Put me out of my misery NOWWWWWWW!! :p :D

by maxwell edison

You said, "I agree with you almost entirely." But then, you disagreed (and misrepresented -- AGAIN) not only what I said, but the intent of what I said.

You went on to say, "However, others don't. And in a democracy, the majority rules."

Sorry, that "democracy" bird won't fly. It was "democracy" that facilitated legalized slavery, the suppression of women, and so on. The intent of the USA's form of democracy was to ensure that the tyranny of the majority couldn't deny the liberty of the minority. Or, as the old analogy goes, our form of "democracy" is not two wolves and a sheep deciding on what's for dinner.

You said, "While there are issues with most any government (social) program, some are still necessary."

I disagree. Just because there's a problem, perceived or otherwise, it doesn't mean that government provides the only -- or the best -- solution.

You said, "Not all poor people are poor because they are lazy, fat or stupid."

Did I limit my comments to poor people? Do you know how much of our tax money (in the form of social programs) goes into the pockets of Warren Buffett, Ted Kennedy, and millions of other people who don't exactly fit the definition of "poor people"?

You said, "Your kids education is none of my business, until you recognize that we all have a vested interest in a well educated society...that benefits us all."

Well, it sounds as though you ARE suggesting that my kids' education is your business. Make up your mind, will you? Besides, my point is that all too many people simply yield their parental responsibility to the government. And that's sad.

You said, "Anyways, some people do get into financial trouble through no fault of their own."

So gee, let's fault other people. Let's make people in Oklahoma, for example, pay for the "financial troubles" caused by the people of New York or Washington D.C.

You said, "A safety net is sometimes needed..."

Unfortunately, our "safety net" has not only turned into a crutch, but it's become a mandatory crutch.

You said, "...and if you don't think so, I pray you never find out the hard way."

I have found out the hard way. And that's when I discovered that the harder of the two hard-way choices was reliance on government. The best thing I ever did for myself was to refuse government help and rely on myself. The difference between you and me is that I don't presume I'm better or smarter than others. I apparently give people more credit than you do.

by tink!

Even if this whole thing was undeniably true, I think it is far too late for anything to be done. The American people have accustomed themselves to the "fact" that they pay income tax to the government every year to the point that they'd be apathetic to an attempt to change this.

Number one because the average literate American would not understand the language of the law(s) and therefore can easily be dissuaded by further confusing language, either spoken or written to them. As well, the illiterate make up a large portion of the American population.

Number 2, even though many Americans would be outraged enough to want their money back, the litigation would take so long that the average income earning American would probably never see any of it.

Number 3, a large majority of Americans will have strong opinions, but not the strong drive for action. These average Americans will consider the above 2 points and feel that there is no use trying to fight the government and therefore will not join in any protests or legal fights.

by underwhere

See Great-West Life Assur. Co. vs. United States, 678 F.2d 180, 183 (Ct. Cl. 1982).
"The determination of where income is derived or 'sourced' is of no moment to either United States citizens or corporations, for such persons are subject to tax under I.R.C. (section 1) and I.R.C. (section 11), respectively, on their worldwide income."

For additional info on this and other frivilous tax arguments, see http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-utl/friv_tax.pdf

by jardinier

"Don't count your chicks before they match."

However here is the current line-up.

Mary (aged 52 and quite beautiful) from Peru is emmigrating to Australia and is expteced to arrive in March.

Susan (aged 48 and very attractive) from China is emmigrating to Sydney in April/May. She has two brothers living in Sydney. We talk on MSN Messenger and there seems little doubt that we will have at the very least a nice frienship, which will include helping each other with our respective languages.

Anna (aged 27 and utterly beautiful) from Russia has one sister who is married to an Australian and has her mind set on me as her ideal partner.

I would be wary of any young woman from Russia as they are notoriously clever scammers. However in order to protect myself I have explained this to Anna and have told her she will receive no financial assistance from me.

She emails me twice a week, each time with a new poem written especially for me; she works as a psyhologist, she plays the piano, she is h**ny as hell and, well, after my rotten luck with relationships I reckon I deserve a break.

Sneak preview:
Mary:

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/Mary_70.jpg

Susan:

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/Susan_3_crop_50.jpg

Anna:

http://www.topsciencenews.com/images/hithere_crop_60.jpg

by donkey

I have a donkey that could do all of your income taxes for 10 bucks a shot.

Whos your daddy and what does he do?

by rob mekel

Mmm, that is an option. But then the donkey would be employed and y'll be your donkey's employer. Mmm, that will give you the employers tasks. So you wouldn't be unemployed any more. So as from now on you won't get anything from welfare (if you did get anything from them whatsoever). lol :d:d

But please do tell me what has anyone's daddy to do with your donkey? (except for the donkey's daddy that is.)

Rob

by maxwell edison

I recently received this email (in my "real" email accout):

---------- Start ----------

Hello have a good day,

I am not sure where to begin,it is first time I try to use internet to meet the man but the thing is,that I will work abroad I can choice USA, Canada or Europe and I would like to meet the man to share free evenings and be my guide. My friends helped me to send a few letters to different address and I do hope that I am lucky to meet good and kind man.you should know that now I live in Russia and my goal is to leave this country because it is impossible to live here for young pretty woman.they tell I look well enough,I am good looking girl. I will send a few photos if you reply. if you don't have wife or girlfriend, maybe we could try to meet? I am free, I have no children .and I have no boyfriend here. I am 25 years old ,please write to me directly to my mail- ferreira@gorideitnicely.info See you soon ,with great hope.

Virginia was at ferreira when that happened roadway. autism at laxative or even lao as in alkaloid

---------- End ----------

One minute later, I received an identical one, only with the name changes to protect the guilty.

A scam, obviously. I just thought you might be interested.

Best of luck, by the way. I'm sure your wisdom and good judgement will guide you.

by jdclyde

he is walking into this knowing the potenial down sides up front.

I personally would have requested a topless photo with them holding a sign saying "Hi JD!".

Then I would know that they either really look like that or are great with photo shop. :D

Of course, exactly what is important in a woman is quite unknown as you didn't come by the discussion for such!
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=188645&start=0

I have a worse case bad luck thing for you to think about.

What happens if they are all real and serious AND show up at the same time????? Too much of a good thing, aye? ;\

by jardinier

Thanks for your concern. Russian and Ukrainian girls are notorious for scamming. While I get very regular scamming attempts from young African girls, they are easy to pick because of their lack of sophistication in composing emails, and in many cases send pictures which are obviously studio-quality photos of someone else.

In the first instance of studio quality photos, I spotted a small copyright notice in the bottom corner of the photos. The girl had lifted them from an adult erotic website.

Russian girls however have a good command of English and can write emails which sound very sincere and personal. But how long does it take to copy and paste a message into a Word document, select: "Edit," "Replace," and replace "Fred" with Julian?

If you do a search for "russian scammers" you will find oodles of websites related to this.

My nephew (who was on the receiving end of a Russian scam attempt) found this website:

http://www.anti-scam.org

There are some 800 known scammers listed with photos, real addresses and particular type of scam.

I searched right through but could not find my Anna.

HOWEVER another Russian girl who had tried to con me was listed at least six times under different names.

Because of this scamming racket I have told Anna that I will not assist her financially or marry her for a long, long time.

However what does concern me is that my "adopted" daughter, 19-year-old orphan Addisu from Ethiopia, to whom I gave details of the three women, sent me an email which said in part:

DAD,I LOVE ALL YOUR 3 PARTNERS BUT I'M ASKING GOD TO SHOW YOU THE BEST AND PLEASE BE CAREFUL WITH ANNA,I SAW A BAD DREAM WITH HER BUT I'M STILL PRAYING TO KNOW WHO IS SHE, WHETHER SHE COME TO DESTROY YOU?

But then again, she may just not like the idea of me having such a young wife to compete with for my affection and attention.

by jdclyde

it should be interesting.

I had never heard of all the scamming like that until you posted those links. Amazing what gets some people through the day.

Best of luck!

jd

by will_eaton

Ted-

What is the source of your information? Quoting a single sentence could easily alter the context of the entire story.

For instance, what does the 203.4 billion represent? The cost of paying for professional tax help? Does it include the cost of tax software (TurboTax, etc). Does "all taxpayers" include businesses? If you think about it, that number may not really be that surprising. Take into account that business employ an entire staff of people. Business could easily report the sum of the salaries for their Tax staff for an entire 2 month period to "tax compliance". Plus the cost of even minor changes to their software/databases/mainframe systems, etc. Plus the cost of outsourcing payroll. That would skew that $203.4 billion when you divide it out "per tax paying entity". Heck, the cost of tax software is $40+. I'm just throwning this number out, but if there are 100 million individual tax payers (not tax filers and not businesses), at the minimum that would be $4 billion. Businesses will spend MUCH more than that on "tax compliance".

"The IRS spent $9.4 billion in 2003"....What did they spend it on? Coffee machines? Bonuses? Office improvements?

30 minutes to 1 hour, huh? That would be nice.

And as far as IRS employees doing their own taxes....I think they would do pretty well by themselves, don't you? That's like asking a chef to cook his/her own meals.

As far as liability from info you get from the IRS web site...I don't know this for fact, but I'm willing to bet that if I found some information from the IRS web site (which I have before), if I was confused in ANY way, I would call them (which I have before). Then I would document the phone conversation (name, phone#, date/time), print off the web page where I found the information, and keep that with my tax documents so that when they do come audit me, I have documentation to back up what I did. You've just proven that you made a reasonable effort to get the right answer. I doubt you would be fined for that.

Or better yet, use that $40 tax software. Most of them guarantee that if there is an error in your tax return, they will pay the fees. $40 is much better than a $100/hour lawyer.

by will_eaton

How is the government dictating how you should educate your kids?

They are taking the funds set aside for Education and OFFERING you the option to go to the public schools for which a portion of your tax dollars have been used to fund. If they wanted to dictate (or mandate) that you go to public schools, they would pass a law that made private schools illegal.

If you don't like the laws that are being made, write your congressman or other government official and excercise your right to vote. Voting is free.

What we need is a new option on the ballot:

"I VOTE FOR NONE OF THESE B00BS BECAUSE THEY ARE ALL LIARS AND DON'T DESERVE MY VOTE!"

And then let's see if ANY politician can win the majority over that vote! :D

William

by jdr1812

I did a few minutes of research onto this matter and here is the results I found.

I'm no lawyer, or anything for that matter. Actually, I'm still in college. So don't flame me if I miss state something or misinterprate.

OK, here we go!

The Constitution of the United States of America, Section 8 states "The Congress shall have Power to lay and collect taxes...". Now if I remember my Government classes then the Constitution superceeds all codes and regulations. Which would suggests to me that charging Federal taxes are within the law.

Second, if you read on the official government website for the United States Code
"www.gpoaccess.gov/uscode/about.html". Then you will find this note:

"NOTE: Of the 50 titles, only 23 have been enacted into positive (statutory) law. These titles are 1, 3, 4, 5, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 17, 18, 23, 28, 31, 32, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 44, 46, and 49. When a title of the Code was enacted into positive law, the text of the title became legal evidence of the law. Titles that have not been enacted into positive law are only prima facie evidence of the law. In that case, the Statutes at Large still govern."

If you look at the titles (23 of them) that are listed as statutory law then you will notice the absence of title 26.

I looked up the definition of statute at Dictionary.com and it means:

"1: a law enacted by the legislative branch of a government"

Which means to me that it is credible.

I didn't know what "prima facie" means so I looked it up too from Dictionary.com. Here it is:

"At first sight; before closer inspection..."

So I assume that its a little uncertain. It has not been proven yet.

My final assumption: Since the Constitution of The United States of America gives the power to Congress to collect taxes from the census (meaning me and you, I looked that up on Dictionary.com too) and since Title 26 (the section this article refers to) is not of Statutory Law (has not been enacted by legislature) then it is lawful to collect a Federal Income Tax on incomes earned within the domestic 50 States.

Thanks folks! I'd like to hear your feedback on this.
P.S. I don't like paying all these taxes either! But its better then Google censoring my searches of freedom and religion!

by jdclyde

The Democrats that want to raise taxes on the "evil selfish rich" are deluded to thinking that it isn't "fair" that you have so much while others have so little. The FACT that you busted your rump to GET so much while they did NOTHING to get the little they have is besides the point.

Their idea of "fair" is to eliminate completely all taxes on the poor poor, and increase the tax burden on the people that have decided to work for a living.

I have known people that will turn down overtime, because it will push them into the next tax bracket and they will LOSE more money in taxes than they will gain for the OT. This is directly an incentive to NOT want to be as prosperous as you can be.

By changing to a USE tax, as you use something or buy something, you pay taxes. The more money you have, the more expensive toys and house you will buy, not to mention the VAST difference between what is spend on furniture and appliances between the righ and the poor poor. Couch for $300 instead of $3000? Who is paying more USE and Sales tax? The person buying the more expensive things.

Why are the majority of the jobs at places like Kmart,Walmart, and the other chains PART-TIME? Because some feel-gooders decided to legislate that any full time people were to get health care. did more people get health care? No, they just got cut down to part time instead of full time, now they not only don't have the health care, but they need to work at two jobs because they can't get enough hours at one.

And yes, there are a lot of people that figure on that Kmart job as their full time job to support their families.

The bad things that happen when people [b]FEEL[/b] instead of [b]THINK[/b].

by dave.leigh9

Is the domestic income of American citizens taxable or not?

The short answer is; yes, it is taxable, according to Title 26, Section 861. Specifically, you first find your gross income:

861.(a)"Gross income from sources within United States The following items of gross income shall be treated as income from sources within the United States: "...
(1)Interest from the United States or the District of Columbia, and interest on bonds, notes, or other interest-bearing obligations of noncorporate residents or domestic corporations..."[followed by some very specific exceptions]...
(2)"The amount received as dividends?..."[followed by some specific conditions]...
(3)"Compensation for labor or personal services performed in the United States..."[followed by some very specific exceptions, the gist of which is that a person in the US owes taxes on their salary if the person makes more than $3K/year working for an entity (whether that be a person or organization) that exists within or does business with the US or its territories]...
(4) "Rentals or royalties from property..." including intellectual property...
(5) "Gains, profits, and income from the disposition of a United States real property interest..."
(6) "Gains, profits, and income derived from the purchase of inventory property...and its sale or exchange within the United States." [and a reference to what is meant by inventory property]...
(7) "Amounts received as underwriting income derived from the issuing (or reinsuring) of any insurance or annuity contract?..." [along with some conditions and references]...
(8)"Any social security benefit..." [and a reference.]

IOW, your gross income is any compensation you receive from any source, excepting perhaps magic money bestowed upon you by a genie, leprechaun, or God himself. Then you determine the taxable portion:

(b) "From the items of gross income specified in subsection (a) as being income from sources within the United States there shall be deducted the expenses, losses, and other deductions properly apportioned or allocated thereto and a ratable part of any expenses, losses, or other deductions which cannot definitely be allocated to some item or class of gross income. The remainder, if any, shall be included in full as taxable income from sources within the United States. In the case of an individual who does not itemize deductions, an amount equal to the standard deduction shall be considered a deduction which cannot definitely be allocated to some item or class of gross income."

IOW, at this point the IRS takes over the definition of what is "properly apportioned" and what deductions may be allowed. Pay specific attention to this: "The remainder, if any, shall be included in full as taxable income from sources within the United States." IOW, ALL OF THE GROSS INCOME specified by subsection (a) is taxable UNLESS the IRS allows an exemption, deduction, or credit.

IOW, this specific assertion of the website you quote is a load of horseshit.

Hope that helps.

http://www4.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode26/usc_sec_26_00000861----000-.html

by sncking

You may be correct in what you say, but if you don't pay taxes, you end up in jail and losing all of your personal property.

by montgomery gator

You said you have "baited" breath. Around these parts, what some folks call sushi, we call bait. :-)

Anyway, the 16th Amendment to the US Constitution allows a Federal Income tax, so it is taxable. However, the rate has gone way above what was originally promised as the maximum rate when it was originally passed. The problem is that the amendment did not specify a maximum rate.

by jardinier

Oxford Dictionary.

[b]with bated breath:[/b] very anxiously.
[past part. of obsolete bate (v.) ?restrain?, from abate]

[b]Amendment XVI.[/b]

The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

Thanks for that. I should have thought to check all the amendments.

Which means the smart-a$$ who started all this is a w*nker. I will inform him so.

And I am astonished that certain other Americans didn't spot this right from the start.

by dave.leigh9

It doesn't matter whether you looked at the Constitution or not. Read the original post (and links) again: it didn't actually say the income tax was unconstitutional (though it mentioned the Constitution several times). In fact, he says, "If the law, including the Tax Law under Title 26 USC says we have to pay a Federal Income Tax then we are required to."

Neither of the links (http://www.whatistaxed.com, etc.) make that claim either. They can't... the Amendment is very clear.

The argument they make is that Congress hasn't EXERCISED that power; that the law doesn't specifically state that residents' income is taxed. Sadly for whoever came up with that fiction, the law DOES say that, in exactly the spot where he says it doesn't.

Which means you can still tell the smart-a$$ who started all this that he's a wanker. But for the right reasons.

by reddiewhip9

thanks for pulling a reason to attack me out of your -whatever (and a shot at African-Americans!). Proved a couple of my points. If you are going to be so idiotic as to use the phrase 'word of the day' without being aware of the 'word of the year' (or newspapers, magazines - or Google?!? - and you post on a tech site . . .) -you are an uninformed moron. In my opinion.

by jdclyde

I didn't "prove your point" because you didn't have a point.

Shot at African Americans? Why, because the NAACP is an advocate for blacks when they are taken advantage of? When you do that thing "we" around Tech Republic like to call "read", you will see I also mentioned advocates for the poor in general. It is only the poor that get ripped off by places like the check cashing places as well as all the "rent to own" places. Again, delusional.

"word of the year". depending on where you go, you get different words. After scrolling to the BOTTOM of the search page is your:
[b]truthiness:[/b] the quality of stating concepts or facts one wishes or believes to be true, rather
than concepts or facts known to be true. Stephen Colbert: ?I don't trust books.
They're all fact, no heart.?

Working professionals use Webster to look up words, not google. This "new" word is very "quaint" - [b](3 a : unusual or different in character or appearance : ODD)[/b]

Word of the day fits now more than ever.

So much for YOUR "truthiness".

Good thing your opinion means nothing.

by nicetamecha

I have read many of the reply's to this post. I'm not a tax lawyer or a CPA so my knowledge in this area is limited, but I have done some research on it and from what I can tell there is no law requiring US citizens to pay income tax on wages. Wages are defined as pay for services rendered. There is a great documentary on the subject titled "America, Freedom to Fascism" The movie explains in much better detail how this all works. Also I just want to comment on one other persons reply about having to pay taxes so we have roads and public schools and what not. Income tax does not pay for any of these things. Other legitimate taxes take care of those services. From what I understand income tax goes to pay the interest on money borrowed from the fedral reserve, which many do not know is a private banking system and not a government agency. Our money is in the hands of private bankers. The same bankers who need bailouts from our government. Now thats scary.

This discussion is closed to new replies.