Discussion Locked

PICTURES OF IRAQ. (Warning: Not for Anti-Amercans or Anti war supporters)

0 helpful
161 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Pictures that the media doesn't show you. The REAL stories of Iraq.

http://www.rock103.com/warpics/

Please copy and paste this link and feel free to comment. Thanks :).

161 replies

by garion11

They will NEVER publish that in TIME. My god, it might actually tell the TRUTH, or or *GASP!!!!* potray the military and the US involvement in Iraq in a positive light.

by hal 9000

That the general work done by the Troops would be well received in some quarters even most but it is actions that speak louder than words. Under Saddam they had running water, Electricity some form of hospital system and affordable food even though it may not have been of a 5 star standard they at least didn't go hungry.

Now however with Iraq virtually in ruins with most of its infrastructure smashed this isn't the case. Granted that Insurgents have done a lot of damage far more than the COW ever did but it is results that these people want to see not promises.

Unless the main in fracture can be fixed and guarded to keep it running there will only be continued discontent which is in the fanatics best interests so a lot more will have to be done before the majority of people will start to feel safe again {I know it is a relative term} but right at the moment they just do not know where their next meal is coming from or if they will have water tomorrow. It is in conditions like this that are currently happening in Iraq that brings about the Fanatical actions that are killing Americans in droves and this can not be argued with as the death toll mounts daily.

Of course the actions of a few does a lot of harm particularly if these people are forced into confessing something that they haven't done as this is exactly what happened under Saddam Hussein. What has been missed here is the other side of the coin where there are just as many people unhappy with what they now consider as American Occupation {even though there are other countries involved it is the Americans who are seen as the enemy for some reason.}

While the pictures here show some of the good being done they fail to take into account the rest of the situation happening in Iraq. Also the old maxim is forgotten here "Bad News Sells Newspapers and improves Ratings" where as good news does nothing for the newspapers or networks.

If you can remember Vietnam there where similar pictures as well but look at what happened there! Unless a reliable in fracture and some security can be restored to Iraq almost immediately the problems will only continue to snowball out of control.

I asked this question some time ago and as yet have still not got an answer "When the COW rolled into Iraq and vanquished Saddam Hussein and the Bath Party they where seen as Liberators and welcome now they are being killed daily what exactly has happened to make the general population change their attitude to the American Troops?"

I welcome any answers as I'm confused as to exactly why there are more troops being killed and maimed now that what there where during the main hostilities.

Col

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "however with Iraq virtually in ruins with most of its infrastructure smashed..."

With all due respect, Colin, that's a bunch of rubbish. Every aspect of life in Iraq, including water, electricity, schools, hospitals, and on and on is BETTER than before the fall of Saddam.

There are only a few problem areas, while the rest of Iraq is being quietly made better than ever.

Here's an interesting quote:

"To say that Iraq is being rebuilt is not true. Iraq is being built. There was no infrastructure
before; we are doing it."

- Geraldo Rivera

THE BUILDINGS THAT AREN'T BURNING by Geraldo Rivera:

http://www.houston.indymedia.org/news/2003/11/18035_comment.php

Colin, you should really open your eyes and open your mind. You're much too smart to be duped into thinking only the worst.

by garion11

...from his bitter, vile hatred of America and its power. I sincerely hope you don't live in this country cause if I ever see you or meet you I will punch you.

by maxwell edison

.
But I think he wants to believe that things are going dismally in Iraq, so he only sees things that support what he wants to believe.

I would suggest that the good/bad in Iraq is about a 90/10, 85/15 ratio. However, the news is just the opposite.

(Don't "punch" Colin. Actually, I'd love to meet the chap from the land down under some day.)

by maecuff

I think your post is one of the reasons we sometimes look bad. "I don't like your views or your opinions..therefore, I am going to hurt you". What the hell??

by hal 9000

You could maybe attempt to answer the question.

But honestly I did get a good laugh about {...from his bitter, vile hatred of America and its power.} You really do not understand the whole thing do you?

As I said try to answer the question and leave personalities out of the equation.

Col

by hal 9000

Who have been there since the end of Hostilities and that is what I'm being told directly by people that I trust not the media who are all doom and gloom. While the main city of Baghdad is somewhat more or less working the Hospitals certainly are not as I'm getting e-mails from friends there right now asking for medical supplies things like Panadol is just not available let alone the more complex things like what would be required for any form of major surgery. Did you know that rubber gloves for surgeons just are not available they are reusing these things as they have no alternative and they can only wash then occasionally in dirty water as there is no running water or electricity to sterilize them with or alcohol either. There are major cross infections occurring just because the basics are missing or not available.

While I no longer do any medical work I still am friends with several people who work for the organization "Doctors without Boarders" and these people do quite a lot of good in the world so along with a few friends in the industry so to speak we are arranging items to be sent over there but unfortunately we will only be scratching the surface as it is impossible to supply everything that is required in just the disposables and as far as drugs of any kind go we are at the mercy of the Australian Government who refuse to allow these items to leave Australian shores. They for some reason seem to think that it will cost them money for these medicines so we are not allowed to ship them. Then there is the problem of shipping these items as well as it is virtually impossible to get a carrier to transport anything into Iraq.

Currently we have 3 containers ready to go with no one willing to ship them in anything like a direct route that will reach there in under several months. These containers will be off loaded at several different ports and then shipped on if and when ships become available so we have no definite time frame for their arrival and there is a Premium Price involved in shipping these as well. SO we are paying top dollar and getting a substandard service with no known delivery time.

Col

by oz_media

For someone who has always prided himself in the accuracy of his findings and the integrity of his sources, I had to have a giggle at your quotes being attributed to Geraldo. What a slice!

Anyhow I'm not going to take this anywhere, other than personally I just see it as about effective as Bush's plastic turkey photo shoot, or landing on the carrier. YAY! Whatever, there's a war going on too.

by oz_media

For someone who has always prided himself in the accuracy of his findings and the integrity of his sources, I had to have a giggle at your quotes being attributed to Geraldo. What a slice!

Anyhow I'm not going to take this anywhere, other than personally I just see it as about effective as Bush's plastic turkey photo shoot, or landing on the carrier. YAY! Whatever, there's a war going on too.

by maxwell edison

.
CARE implements a broad range of projects in the water and sanitation sector in Iraq, including emergency repairs and long-term rehabilitation of infrastructure, supply and installation of generators and technical support programs. Our engineers have rehabilitated major water and sewage treatment plants, installed hundreds of kilometers of water networks, and made emergency repairs to water and sanitation systems in hospitals and health centers. Since the 2003 conflict, CARE's projects in this sector have improved the quantity and quality of water provided to more than 7.3 million residents.

CARE's health programme, led by a group of Iraqi doctors with long-term experience in the health sector in Iraq, includes infrastructure rehabilitation, health education and distribution activities. These projects have assisted more than 4.2 million Iraqis post-conflict and are integrated with activities in the water and sanitation sector to ensure that essential services are maintained at an adequate standard.

Since the 2003 conflict, CARE has rehabilitated more than 150 health centers and 40 hospitals. Hygiene and cleaning materials, blankets, supplementary food, insulin, I.V. sets and oxygen regulators, as well as other emergency medical supplies and equipment have been delivered to health facilities. CARE is working to supply laboratory equipment and supplies to reinstate Iraq's laboratory capacity and sentinel disease surveillance system, which will ultimately benefit the entire population of the country.

CARE Australia - the Australian face of overseas aid

by jardinier

I guess Australia has been especially blessed in its involvement in Iraq. I understand that Australian SAS soldiers were the first to exchange fire with Iraqi soldiers and, God willing, we have yet to suffer a military casualty.

by garion11

of all these people, who have never been down there, yet make all these stupid and ignorant claims about Iraq even after they see the evidence. Which in turn leads me to believe that they really don't give a damn about Iraq or anything, its just their vile hatred of US and its power. Sort of like why some people here hate Microsoft or the Yankees.

by jardinier

" (Warning: Not for Anti-Americans or Anti war supporters)"

Do you seriously believe that those who have seen the bad side of the story have closed minds, and do not want to acknowledge the positive events that are occurring simultaneously?

Bias works two ways. Perhaps you are just as biased in your viewpoint as are those whom you condemn.

by jimhm

Yes - gee most are so closed minded - gee when they think that a man forced to wear womens panties on his face is worse than beheading a young man. Makes me believe they would support pictures showing americans doing good - Gee why didn't you say they were staged.

Gee - when these Anti-American media folks and posters continue to bring up the tourcher that Iraqis sufferred in prison. But don't say anything about burnt bodies hung off bridges while these Islmic (religon of peace) dance for joy.

Gee - and you think we would say you all would understand and support those picture. Gee where was the post "Staged" - that the majority of military are doing an excellent job, and thats over 100,000 men and women!

And to say warning not for Anti-American folks is offensive to you - Get a life - to freeking bad.

Walk a mile in solders shoes then - speak - have someone shot at you - then speak - I've been there - These liberals are tring to turn this into another Vietnam - same vile Bull that they tossed at us coming back from Vietnam - they didn't know how we helped thousands - they read stories of solders killing kids... they didn't print the part where the kid had Granades taped to his hands by the VC - or was as they call them today sucided bomober - Na - why print the truth - when lies and liberal BS - gets you more milage.

Didn't print the horrors the american POW's lived with daily - Na why print the truth. Didn't print or report the horrors that the VC did to our men - cutting off parts of their bodies for payment! Na - Why print the truth. But let an American (5 or 6) in Mi'li and oh my god - or in the prison in Iraqi the liberal press is over it like stink on dog poop.

Yea - what you see in those photos is the truth - what you read in the liberal media are the lies..

by hal 9000

You should know that military intervention only works when there are set objectives for the military to achieve and they are given a free hand to use what is available to achieve this end. The trouble with Vietnam was that these people where sent in to fight a war without the full support of the Government so they effectively had at least one hand tied behind their back and where bound to lose.

Now about what is going on in Iraq right now there is a very definite credibility problem that the US and others forces are facing and that is on the one hand they are supposed to be a liberating force who will only bring good but on the other hand they are ignoring the rules of war example the Gevenia Convention. Granted the other side doesn't follow these but aren't we supposed to be better than these savages? If we lower our standards to their level we are no better than what we are attempting to destroy and will do as much damage as those that we are attempting to vanquish.

Col

by garion11

In fact I will go on record as to state that those people have a completely closed mind and nothing and I mean nothing (even in 20 years when Iraq and hopefully some more of the neighboring Arab states are full fledged democracies) will ever change their mind and their feeling of hatred and jealousy of US power and stature until we are not the world's #1 power anymore. Then whoever steps onto that stage will take USA's place (who hopefully will be as restraining as US is and was in controlling their power) and all the jealousy and hatred will be directed towards them.

They will find anyway, ANYWAY (whether they HAVe to make up stories, be negative, come up with conspiracy theories)to blame America first and foremost, in every situation that concerns the world. I am utterly shocked that the SARS virus event, Chechenya bombings, India and Pakistan rivalry, death of cockroaches in Iraq isn't blamed on America.

So hence I say screw the world's opinion, they hate us anyway!!!(unless America has a president that can curb US's power and might with his policies). As Bush stated, I will not ask the world's permission to protect America and its interests. And damn right he was.

So if you are offended just by my title, then you shouldn't go out into the world at all. Stay home with your carebears!

by thechas

In the few postings I have seen from you, there has been more vile hatred than from any other peer that I can recall.

Before you run off on another spiteful tangent, let me explain some of my views.

Prior to the start of the Iraq war, I was opposed to President Bush taking military action at that time.

Now that we have taken over Iraq, we NEED to stay until the mission is complete.
At a minimum, we cannot leave until Iraq has a functioning government, police force, and army.

While the Bush administration (and war hawks) credit the invasion of Iraq with reducing global terrorism, the more likely reality is that the World Trade Center attack served as a wake-up call to governments around the world.
The increased vigilance of police and intelligence groups is what has reduced terror attacks.

I fear that the murder of Mr Berg is the beginning of a new wave of 1 on 1 terrorism.

I find it interesting that so many conservatives consider the US press to be grossly liberal.

The majority of news organizations in the US are run by conservative businessmen.
The network owners and managers have "1" goal for the news programs. RATINGS!!!!!
In the US news organizations ratings are FAR more important than TRUTH. Or, balance.
Whether you like it or not, bad news from Iraq generates higher ratings then good news.

As a point of fact, I here many more positive stories about our actions in Iraq from NPR news than from any other news source.
NPR is the exception to the rule of US news organizations.
Their goal is to provide balanced accurate coverage of the news.
(Yes, I agree that most of the NPR commentators lean to the left.)

The "reporting" that I have heard from Rush Limbaugh is some of the most 1 sided and biased reporting I have ever heard. His show is designed to rile the conservative spirit. in the name of ratings.
I have yet to hear Rush report more than half of any story.

Also, we DO need to renew our efforts to build coalitions with the rest of the world.
The only way to significantly reduce the ranks of the terrorists is to have strong ties with ALL of the world governments.

So, calm down and allow some reasoned thought to enter your mind.
Just because someone is opposed to the war in Iraq does not make them anti-American.
Nor does blindly supporting our President make one a patriot.

Chas

by hal 9000

The have not's will always want more than they currently have and will always see the affluent countries as the baddies. Unfortunately it is currently the USA who is feeling the brunt of their rage at their current position rather then the real people responsible who are their countries leaders who keep them ignorant and feed a constant stream of propaganda to suit their own ends.

So is it any wonder that currently America is the brunt of most of this hatred? After all they where mainly responsible for Iraq being removed from the trade with the rest of the world in the first place {granted this was the right thing to do as the then leader needed to be taught a lesson but unfortunately he didn't suffer his people did.}

Now be honest if there was a "Trade Embargo" started against the USA tomorrow exactly who do you think would suffer the most? The current President of the general community?

Incidentally you can forget the idea that you are self sufficient as your corporations have moved most of their manufacturing off shore so you would be hit far harder that you could ever image but as long the the corporations make huge profits who really cares right?

Col

by maxwell edison

.
You make such great points, but then ruin it by saying something like, "Nor does blindly supporting our President make one a patriot."

Blindly??????

Blindly??????

Why must you (and others) always interject these inaccurate and insulting adjectives in an attempt to discredit.

Blindly??????

Blindly??????

I assume that you think that I also "blindly" follow President Bush?

Blindly??????

Blindly??????

Can't a person agree without being accused of doing it "blindly"?

Blindly??????

Blindly??????

For Pete's sake, some of us do have minds, you know. And there's nothing "blind" about it.

Blindly??????

Blindly??????

Just because some people see things differently than you dosen't mean we do it blindly.

Blindly??????

Blindly??????

My eyes are wide open, thank you very much.

(Yes, it does get me POed)

by thechas

Max,

My last comment in the post was meant to be a contrast.

It looks like you read it as some have read your humorous posts.

My point is that a person who is opposed to the Iraq war, and / or policies of the present President (at any time) can be more of a Patriot than a person who follows the lead of the President without question.

I know that you come to your conclusions from researching information on the topic.

I get the impression that many of the other citizens who fully support the war in Iraq and President Bush do so not from reasoned research, but because they are happy that the US Armed Forces are out kicking arse.

I consider many of these people to be "fair weather" Patriots.
Much like the sports fans that only come out and support the local team when they are winning.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
Do you know how often people like me are accused of "blindly" following....?

It's been done directly and indirectly here at TR, and it's common in editorials and opinion pieces that generalize about people who support the Iraq war effort. It's not accurate, and I'm growing tired of it. However, I certainly accept your explanation, and I'm sure it wasn't intended to offend.

On your Iraq prediction (reply to a different message) and democracy "seed planting", while I understand your sentiments, I don't necessarily agree. Japan is an example of a nation (and a culture) that transformed inself (with a little prodding) from an Emperor ruled nation, one deep in spirituality and tradition, to one of the most successful free-market democracies in the world. The same thing could certainly happen in Iraq, and I think it will. After all, the alternative is more of the same upheaval that's plagued the region for hundreds (or thousands) of years, and the entire globe over the past fifty or more.

I believe it will succeed because it must succeed. And from my estimation, many, if not most, of the people against this effort, have a vested interest in failure. I have to wonder why that isn't as clear to others as it is to me.

Nonetheless, I apologize if it sounded like I was spouting off at you. It wasn't at you, per se, but just some spouting in general.

by garion11

I thought the allies were with us? Hmm..Australia, Portugal, England, Japan, Kuwait, Canada, Saudi Arabia (they are all helping in rebuilding Iraq). OOOOOH!!!!, you mean, France and Germany? OH, I thought there would be so many more countries that refused to help us (the ones that CAN anyway).

by hal 9000

Perhaps you just don't want to be reminded what happened there and how that act of terrorism lead to a change in Government.

Or maybe it just slipped your mind as that didn't happen on American soil.

Col

by garion11

Spain did its part and left. The change of government was because its citizens became scared of the fundamentalists and voted off the ruling party to appease the terrorists. They didn't want to fight. I am not sure if American wants an ally whose a coward. I feel sorry for its citizens. They have no pride or honor. Almost remind me of the French.

Isn't that what you are waiting for? Another attack on American soil? So you greedily hope that Bush gets voted out or something?? and also point out and say WE TOLD YOU SO! I always wonder what happens if your country gets an attack like 9/11. Will your countrymen rise and meet the challange? or whimper in cowardness like Spain?

by hal 9000

Reason to dislike Microsoft not because it is American though even that's doubtful now days as they develop so much software off shore. But the reason that all their software is failing to do what it is claimed to do is enough reason why so many people dislike Microsoft.

Now I'm a Microsoft "Certified Partner" so I guess that tels you something about me but even I got really "Peeved Off" last week when I attempted to set up a new client with a "Volume License" only to find out that first I would have to buy OEM product for all the computers that I was building then pay a Volume License Fee {so they are effectively getting paid twice for the same thing} then a yearly subscription for Software Assurance so I could clone the HDD's to save time instead of loading each computer individually. Now you have to admit that business practices like this tend to upset some people don't you?

Col

by oz_media

I can walk around downtown Los Angeles or Vancouver a take similar pictures. I can also go around and show the negative pictures of gang warfare, drug abuse and the underprivaledged.

These pictures are nice to see, everyone loves happy children and big scary men petting kitty cats.

They don't show much other than the fact that not EVERYONE is having an awful time in Iraq, but that's never been contested either.

Iraq, Baghdad even is a very large place. I would rather see front line reporting to see how the resistance and daily terrorist actions are being handled.

It is nice to have a time out and see the happy few though.

by garion11

Since you obviously don't live here, why can't you just mind your own business? lol. So our corporations are making money?, Yeap, thats the USA's goal in the world. To turn every country into a Democratic, Capitalistic country, so they can be just like US and be our trading partner. OMG, what a horrible concept.

You mean people will get to choose their President/Primeminister, and and maybe even start a business to make money, provide jobs (sort of like what a programmer or Desktop Support, or Network Admin is considered, a job/career etc) , provide products and services to consumers, contribute to the economy and overall prosperity of the country.

by hal 9000

You obviously seem to think that everyone outside the USA is just out to get you no matter what and to this end you seize on a single sentence twist it out of context to suit your own ends.

Now your reply has absolutely nothing to do with what I posted and goes as far as trying to somehow imply that I'm against everything American, well my friend your totally incorrect and I do really feel very sorry for you as you obviously need some form of help for your condition.

Just for fun can you attempt to look at the whole thing and answer accordingly instead of just seizing on a few words and using them in a vain attempt to support your misguided cause?

Col

by thechas

Garion,

You can't give or bring Democracy to anyone.

Democracy requires a willingness to sacrifice, and can only be maintained by a strong desire for Democracy within the people in the country.

Yes, we may establish a Democracy in Iraq. However, within 20 years of the US forces leaving Iraq I predict that the government will change to either a new dictatorship, or a religious theocracy such as Iran.

As to our corporations: They do not want a Democratic government in the countries where their manufacturing operations are.
It is a lot easier to take advantage of the worker and the environment when you have a dictatorship or similar form of government.

Change in form of government is usually viewed as a bad thing by corporations, the stock market, and the futures market.
That is why the stock market tumbles, and gas prices rise when a foreign leader is overthrown.
Change means unpredictability.

Chas

by oz_media

"start a business to make money, provide jobs (sort of like what a programmer or Desktop Support, or Network Admin is considered, a job/career etc) , provide products and services to consumers, contribute to the economy and overall prosperity of the country."

Oh and I assume this is something we need to learn from America? A new country that thinks it has a grip on things? A country full of people who place themselves above the rest of the world's citizens and even believe that everyone WNATS to be American or live like an American?

I bet you are one of those guys who thinks everyone is just jealous of America and that you keep the world alive with all your exports right?

Do you have ANY idea how much America relies on other country's imports?

If it wasn't for Western Canada, California would be cold and dark. The homes in Washington would be made from plastic, the natural gas at your pumps would equal or exceed regular gas in price. And so on... you are not self sufficient, in fact you a VERY reliant on others as much as others may rely on you. That's the problem when we start looking outside in, it is a globe. A BALL not a plain that begins at the USA or hill where the USA simply opurs down it's great wealth and knowledge upon all the poor countires that wish they could be more like America.

If you actually managed to convince every country to be like America, the suicide rate would go through the roof. There are people who COULD easily beome Americans that choose not to, why would that be?

I have only ever met a few with the ego and self righteousness that you spout, funny enough, they were all on TR from America with very similar delusional opinions of the world around them. Read a friggin' book one day will you!?

by hal 9000

What happened in Spain is a lot more complicated that the simplistic way you are trying to push it. First they became a target because of their involvement in Iraq, Secondly the then ruling Government attempted to lie to its citizens.

The general population of Spain has been in a state of civil war for years so they can hardly be called cowards but it was the outrage that was felt by the majority of citizens against their ruling party trying to offset the blame for that attack that caused the change in government as prior to that incident the then ruling Party look as if they would be returned to power. It was only the attempt to place the blame for the attack on to a different organization that lead to their being voted out of office. If the then Government had just said we don't as yet know who is responsible quite likely there would have been a very different outcome.

However when a Government is caught attempting to lie to its citizens they quite naturally lose any faith that they previously had in the Government. I can remember the exact same thing happening in America when the "Watergate Affair" was exposed do you remember that one?

Col

by hal 9000

And what you perceive as my objectives can you try to answer the question that I asked above?

That would be a lot more constructive than any ramblings that are currently going on here and I for one am extremely interested in finding out exactly the mood in Iraq has changed so dramatically. Perhaps you do not think this is important but to me it is extremely important as it means that whatever was done there will be thrown out when we remove our troops from the area and in all likely hood it will revert back to what it was and possibly have someone worse that Hussein in power.

Col

by hal 9000

The Iraq Soccer team has just qualified to represent their country at the upcoming Olympic Gamed in Greek in the next few months.

What is truly amassing here is that despite their previous Dictator and all the turmoil that they have had to go through within the last 18 months they are able to perform at this level.

Even if they never win a single game at the Olympics they deserve a Gold Medal for just getting there.

Col

by thechas

Don't get me wrong Max,

I hope that democracy does take hold in Iraq.

I just don't believe that the average US citizen is aware of just what, and how long of an effort will be required on our part to allow democracy to take hold.

I'm also not sure that the Iraqi people WANT a democracy strongly enough to work for it.

With both the religious leaders in Iraq, and the leaders of neighboring countries being opposed to an open democracy in Iraq, I am not as optimistic as you that a stable democracy will take root.

Time will tell.

Chas

by garion11

Ok, I guess I should explain myself a little bit more clearly. Please keep an open mind and read through. I know its long but hopefully we can come to a better understanding after this.

At this point, considering America and its involvement in War on Terror, Iraq, Bush, and whatever else you guys can think of, I have one thing to say. Its really none of your business, period. It is not your business to comment, judge, criticize, and oppose, the US.

You are not being asked to fight in Iraq for US.
You are not being asked to fight in Afghanistan and hunt for Bin Laden.
You are certainly not being asked to fund the damn thing.
You are not being asked anything.
Unless we are attacking or threatning your country men and women in anyway, its not your problem.
So what business do you have talking about this?

We are not attacking any Democracies over in the Middle East (2 Democracies will never goto war by the way, just had to point that out). We are trying to rebuild a country, and hopefully make into a shining beacon for the rest of the middle east to follow and understand. Will we succeed? I surely hope we do. I really do, for the sake of Islam, middle east, US and its allies.

Yet you take this war as something thats your business. Why? Is your country involved? Then vote your government out. Why are you criticizing the US over what we are doing? Damn man, we are not conquering the world. Do you want us to lose in Iraq? Is that it? or do you want us to rebuild that country and hopefully in 20 years it will be a prosperous country (Japan and Germany come to mind)? Nation buidling takes YEARS, not a week, month and certainly not by supper time.

Every time something bad happens, I see and hear from the world (I post on other boards as well) "I told ya so", "You should have never gotten involved" "Bush is a Nazi" "I hate him for starting a war with a dictator" "You should've attacked North Korea" ... and Saudi Arabia" "You have been misled" "Violence doesn't solve anything" "If theres a terrorist attack on American soil, remember you deserved it" "9/11 was America's fault, you deserved it" "Your government controls your media" "Bush and the media control our minds" ""Those pictures of Iraq children with US soldiers are fake""Berg's video was fake""Iraq was better under Saddam""The prisoners were abused and Bush should be impeached""You should have gone through the UN" and so many more colorful comments that I can't repeat here.

And none of these people are Americans. None!!. Although the sad fact is several people here are saying them as well now. How come you guys never ever comment on the insurgents? What about the time those 4 contracters were burned and hung from the bridge? Were you guys dancing with joy as well when that happened? How come there was never any response from the Muslims and their leaders or other Arab nations over that incident, yet abuse of some prisoners is a bigger news story than the beheading of an innocent civilian or those contracters?

Yes true, I agree that not all of you have said these things, but the mentality that produced those above quotes is related. Its here in this country as well, and its by the media and trickles down to the populace. Don't ever think for one minute that the media is leaning towards the Bush administration. I'd say only one channel, and it only provides an outlet for conservatives (aka Republicans) to speak. The rest, there are about 7 that are soooo ANTI-BUSH and even anti-american its amazing that noone else sees this. All the reports we get here is everytime I turn on ABC, NBC, CBS is blame America first attitude. You don't see Al-Jazeera blaming the likes of Bin Laden, Palistinians, terrorists, and the Muslim leadership do you? You ever see or hear any Muslim leaders rise up and criticize the terrorists? (I guess they must perceive them as freedom fighters). But here, my god, every Tom, Dick and Harry has an opinion and a good majority of them support the US and its actions, while the rest are just boiling over in pure hatred of Bush, they are aka Liberals/Democrats.

HERE IS AN EXPERIMENT (if anyone is feeling up to it)
http://www.foxnews.com
http://www.cnn.com

Check out their headlines throughout the day, and throughout the week at different times and write down the different headlines they have and post them here with date and time. I will show you all the contrasts if you don't see them for yourself by that time.

Now on a world scale, multiply that hatred of Bush by a 100, 1000. 10,000??. The funny thing is, all these people have nothing, absolutely nothing to do with Iraq and US poslicies. They don't live here, don't pay their taxes here, and don't vote here. They certainly don't ask US for any opinion on how they should proceed when their country is facing an issue, domestic or foreign. And frankly you don't have to and shouldn't have to. Self rule is part of being a democracy. I don't see massive protests over Russia and its involvement with Chechenya. Americans aren't asked about Quebec and its desire to succeed with the rest of Canada? France and its involvement with certain African colonies aren't even mentioned. What about China and Thailand? or North Korea? Where are the massive protests when North Korea revealed that they had Nuclear weapon technology? South America and its drug infested cartel countries?? Any world opinion on that? or is it the US's fault?

I guess I am frustrated by all the criticism of the US especially by people who have don't even live here. What would you guys do if your country was attacked like it was on 9/11? Would you actually rise up and meet the challange? I hope thats what doesn't happen, noone deserves 9/11 to happen to them. But I guess it has to happen to their country before people understand why Americans feel the way they do.

by jimhm

They can comment all they want - they can critize all they want - they can whine and cry big liberal tears of sadness for those Iraqi prisoners all they want, and dance for joy over the 3,000 dead at the WTC and the 700+ in Iraq.

America gives that right to them - but we also have the right to return comments and argue our points. They can accept or reject, but they only show their true colors - of course (as you seen here) they will call it "Hate Speech" and cry that we aren't permitted to do that. Now in their country where the speech police work it maybe - but in America it is protected under the 1st Adm.

If you look at it the liberals in Europe - Europe tried to appease Hitler - but they still ended in the same spot... War - if they would of stopped him early then things may of been better. But then the liberals wouldn't of believed Hitler would of killed millions of civilians - Oh Hitler would of never done that.

Na neither did Saddam - Na 100,000 in mass graves is nothing (Not much said in the liberal press) - no reason to take someone out of power - Na can we say Kosovo and Clinton (little slick whillie)..

So let them whine and cry all they want - it is better to hear a dog barking and know where they are nd where they are coming from - we will keep quit and they will never see or hear us coming...... Shhhhhhhh we are hunting Liberals.... shhhhhhh hhhhhaaaaaahhhhhhaaaaaa

by oz_media

hum....Nobody says this war wasn't needed to improve life for mankind. gee..So take that WHOLE thought right out of your head, you are WRONG. hum..Nobody condones the events of 911, nobody condones people being killed IN ANY COUNTRY.

Gee..Bush Bs'd people into thinking they wer in grave and immediate danger from Saddam. Hum..UN inspectors had been successful and had said they would need a few more weeks, others wanted to wait on launching an attack for an additional three weeks so that UN inspectors could deem Iraq free of WMD, which YES they were doing successfully as they had found and seized some war heads, NEVER BEEN USED and uncapable of launching an attack on America.

Hum..The operation was hasty, poorlly planned and a solo mission that everyone else was dragged into instead of an Allied attack.

Gee..NOTHING to do with people condoning what happened or lead up to this war. Forget it Jim, you have a NON ISSUE.

Ok one more Gee and a hum for you.

by oz_media

I thought we were discussing why America went to war. Not what the UK troops uncovered while there. Are you saying now that you are justifying Amercia's knee-jerk reaction by stating that they found mass graves?

Maybe the British could use that excuse but not America, you had no knowledge of mass graves at the time, these were STUMBLED upon by UK troops.

by hal 9000

To you that our troops are in Afghanistan, Iraq and supporting the USA forces all around the world in any "hot Spots" when we are asked to. There have even been places where we've gone it alone Timore and Bougainville come to mind.

But what I get worked up about is the way that you seem to think everyone?s out to get the "Good Old US of A" I'm certainly not but you chose to read my postings that way so you can go figure it out as well.

As far as News reports go early this morning round about 3.00 am I saw an Interview with a "Republican" senator and some other guy and don't as I honestly don't know who they where or the first thing about American Politics and I'm not interested either because it doesn't affect me in any way so I'm just not interested. But the senator was saying that something like 82% of all the people in Iraq wanted the US out now! Well that just stupid as the place would collapse into anarchy in very short order.

I can also tell you that every one of the items against American civilians that you listed and more where reported over here with several Islamic Leaders berating the actions so maybe we get better news coverage here than you do over there but I'm leaving that one alone.

However while I'm constantly attacked for asking a simple question and even threatened by at least one person here as they chose to misread what I've posted to suit their own ends which is nothing short of paranoia I get concerned as I begin to feel that a large proportion of the American population feel the same way and that is worse than what happened on Sept 11 or in Bali or where ever. If you actually take the time to look through all of my postings on this particular subject I haven't said a single word against America in general and I very much doubt that I've said anything against the troops either as they are in an untenable position placed into an field of battle that they where never trained for with no set enemy. My first and foremost aim is to protect the troops as they constantly get the rough end of the stick every time something happens but even this is misread by some as an attack on the Americans and their political leaders. I also like the way that anything positive that I add here is ignored as well so it would appear to me at the very least that the bigoted responses are coming from a different quarter than my end.

Now JimHM has said he served in Nam so ask him exactly how it feels to never know where the next attack is coming from or if that person walking down the street towards you is going to just walk past you without another thought or attempt to kill you. This is just not the place for troops as they are not trained to work in these conditions nor should they be expected to either.

Then there is the idea that everyone is out to get the Americans at any cost and you claim that you only see adverse reporting about the actions of some of your troops. Well you are probably right as I'm not currently in America I just don't know but this I do know the American Government holds itself up as the righteous Government so their troops should behave accordingly just because the other side are savages doesn't mean that you have to descend to their level to win the conflict. Even if this action means that the conflict is ended sooner it will turn to ashes in your mouth as it is less than human to act like this and if it is insisted that the troops behave this way they will come home and continue to act this way which isn?t want anyone wants surely is it?

You are supposed to be better than that aren't you? As a good "Christian" country that America claims to be whatever happened to "Turn The Other Cheek?"

Col

by oz_media

Absolute crap.

"Its really none of your business, period. It is not your business to comment, judge, criticize, and oppose, the US."

Of course it our business, I lived only a half hour from your border until a recent move, now I am 5 hours fropm the border or 4 from Seattle by ferry.

EVERYTHING you do effect us in one way or another, including bringing hatred into North America. A nice big ditch along the border and you could all float South and be done with it. YOu could bnomb anyone you wanted and it would have no effect on us. Also lets not forget the economical hits we take as a neighbouring country that shares that garbage NAFTA crap with you.

So, YES sir, this has EVERYTHING to ddo with the rest of the world, remember YOUR president SAID HE WAS the leader of the free world, even though I still don't believe that he won the vote, there's just too many articles and documents stating how he used his political influence to change the requirements of the Military and Florida voters, but that's an old stoy I am definitely not backtracking to, if you don't believe it by now, you never will a the discussion (judging by your past comments) is entirely futile. You say so often how you want people to read with an open mind, yet you approach MOST of the responses that don't simply agree with you, with a very closed mind and negative attitude.

As for compasring FOZ and CNN, anyone with half a brain will understand that neither is a NEWS source and no matter which reoprt is shown by one, another can easily contest it as Left wing vs Right wing etc. Waste of EVERYONE's time.

As for "What about the time those 4 contracters were burned and hung from the bridge? "

Again, this is a war, did you expect something different? The men ad women IN a war, are supposed to be trained to suppress a reactionary response in such situations, this does not condone nor condemn anything.

You seem to have the understanding that thinks America went in too erarly on this campaign is in favour of Iraqi and against the US, how small is your brain I might ask? Do you think in binary or something? 'If it isn't FOR it MUST be against.' What kind of thought process is that?

"What would you guys do if your country was attacked like it was on 9/11?"

Make up your mind already, is it protecting yourself from WMD, 911, privatizing of Oil (which Iraqi's were strongly against when Saddam tried it) or freeing the Iraqi's? You do realize the ONLY benefit to America is that their price for crude will drop right?

You also seem to be forgetting that over 30 other countries are now active in Iraq, which you discount as being in Afghanistan, well we're still there too.

You have built such a negative opinion based on what you have heard in OTHER forums, probably from a bunch of kids who are just mirroring what their parents say at dinnertime.

""You should have never gotten involved" "Bush is a Nazi" "I hate him for starting a war with a dictator" "You should've attacked North Korea" ... and Saudi Arabia" "You have been misled" "Violence doesn't solve anything" "If theres a terrorist attack on American soil, remember you deserved it" "9/11 was America's fault, you deserved it" "Your government controls your media" "Bush and the media control our minds" ""Those pictures of Iraq children with US soldiers are fake""Berg's video was fake""Iraq was better under Saddam""The prisoners were abused and Bush should be impeached""You should have gone through the UN"

I think the war WAS neccesary, not with the unprepared and 'F-the-world' attitude that it was prematurely launched with though. Your soldiers have died due to a lack of support, NORMALLY obtained from America's former Allies. You RELY Canada's recon as you have in your other conquests, you RELY the Australians special forces etc. You have been successful in all your pther battles because of an amalgamated force utilizing the world's best. When SOME of you allies wanted to wait another THREE WEEKS, Bush went on the 'lets instill fear into America and justify and early attack'. Well what a mess, and now every other allied force is in there too helping to clean up and stabilize this country.

So in shot:
YES IT IS MY BUSINESS, IT'S EVERYONE'S BUSINESS, NEXT TIME CONSIDER THAT WHEN YOU DECIDE IT'S YOUR BUSINESS TO GO TO WAR ALONE AND BITCH ABOUTH THE REST OF THE WORLD THAT COMES TO HELP ANYWAY, YOU UNGRATEFUL AND SELF CENTERED LITLE SNOT.

by mlayton

Go Oz. Everyone has the right, the duty to speak up

to quote a pastor...
"They first came for the Communists and I didn't speak up-- because I wasn't a Communist... "
and it ends with
"Then they came for me -- and by that time no one was left to speak up."

War, by its nature, is filled with atrocities, on both sides. and to quote FDR
"More than an end to war, we want an end to the beginnings of all war"

I respect the men and women who are serving their nation and doing their duty, I reserve my disdain for the knee-jerk "eye for an eye" politics that lead to war in the first place.

And anyone who thinks everything in all areas of Iraq is better now probably also thinks everything in all areas of America is fine too. There is always work to be done, ideally we would like a leader who recognizes this, and sets forth a plan to accomplish those tasks - a plan that all of America and the world can get behind.

by oz_media

I won't correct all my typos but the following sentence was missing a word that changed the context.

"You seem to have the understanding that thinks America went in ..."

SHOULD READ

"You seem to have the understanding that ANYONE who thinks America went in..."

by garion11

LOL, um..yeah. Picked off sentences one by one eh? Taken out of context was given a new meaning in the above post ladies and gentlemen.

Well, here goes

Hmm...You country is part of something called NATO. One of the charters/rules of Nato was that if any member was country was attacked, it would be like an attack on all members and the response would be coordinated together. Obviously several countries didn't live up to their end of the bargain.

No America is not mighty, I never said it was. We are the most powerful country right now in terms of economic and military (till Russia grows up in 20 years, then talk about a trading partner!). I don't care how your damn media spins this, its an undeniable fact. Your media is so twisted dude, they are not stating the facts (about Florida election and what really happened, because they didn't want GW in the white house, they wanted someone that can control American power, Al Gore) and no matter how much I tell you you don't listen and you will never know and frankly I don't have time cause thats another topic all together.

"As for 'What about the time those 4 contracters were burned and hung from the bridge?'"

"Again, this is a war, did you expect something different? The men ad women IN a war, are supposed to be trained to suppress a reactionary response in such situations, this does not condone nor condemn anything."

Now the above paragraph(s) confused me. Cause the question at hand about the 4 contracters was taken out of context because I asked where the outrage and protests were when this happened?? Where were the Muslim leaders that condemened this? What about the Canadians for that matter?? Did you dance in the streets as well? Yet we are supposed to apologize when pics of prison abuse is shown? Oh and we did, cause we know we are not the terrorists, nor have that kind of mentality. So I guess you can actually come to the conclusion that *GASP America and its leaders aren't such bad guys, cause they obviously didn't celebrate on the street after Iraq was bombed nor did we celebrate when PRISONERS were abused.

"I think the war WAS neccesary, not with the unprepared and 'F-the-world' attitude that it was prematurely launched with though. Your soldiers have died due to a lack of support, NORMALLY obtained from America's former Allies. You RELY Canada's recon as you have in your other conquests, you RELY the Australians special forces etc. You have been successful in all your pther battles because of an amalgamated force utilizing the world's best. When SOME of you allies wanted to wait another THREE WEEKS, Bush went on the 'lets instill fear into America and justify and early attack'. Well what a mess, and now every other allied force is in there too helping to clean up and stabilize this country."

WOW REally?? You actually thought war was necessary? I am shocked and in awe. No the soldiers died because the terrorists and insurgents killed them, not because you didn't support us. What other conquests did we have? We depend on YOUR RECON?? Whoa, hold it pardner, yes possibly in the past countries have had joint military excersices and even missions together (India and Israel, India and US had some I believe), but I just hope you are not implying we need your recon. LOL. No, Bush didn't go alone, UK was a HUGE suppporter. ITS a MESS?? Did you even see the pictures above? No its not a mess, things are working, Iraq is being rebuilt, slowly but surely.

"YES IT IS MY BUSINESS, IT'S EVERYONE'S BUSINESS, NEXT TIME CONSIDER THAT WHEN YOU DECIDE IT'S YOUR BUSINESS TO GO TO WAR ALONE AND BITCH ABOUTH THE REST OF THE WORLD THAT COMES TO HELP ANYWAY, YOU UNGRATEFUL AND SELF CENTERED LITLE SNOT."

I went to Toronto on a business trip and I saw the news and certain talk shows (that featured an Indian military analyst no less). My god, these people are making up lies, dude. They were making up such lies about America and its activities in Iraq I was stunned. Yes you can say that thats the truth, blah blah, but its not. Cause the majority of the media in here hates Bush as much as you do and if it was true they would have been the first ones to jump on it. Which leads me to my point, is there anything America can do right in your eyes? Or do we all have to be one big Socialist continent? Its ok admit it if you are a Socialist, (aka communist) but don't sit there and support America only when it suits your needs. Oh but, thats silly, WHAT OTHER motivation does a country need to support another country if not SELF INTEREST? (Yes its a question that I am sure you will ask). Well thats the whole point dumbA**. America never denied it was not in our interest to go to war, however....

"Make up your mind already, is it protecting yourself from WMD, 911, privatizing of Oil (which Iraqi's were strongly against when Saddam tried it) or freeing the Iraqi's? You do realize the ONLY benefit to America is that their price for crude will drop right? "

...yes these are all our interests, believe it or not. We do care about the Iraqis, WMD, protection from a future 9/11 (because the battle is being fought in another country, not on American soil, so all the attention is over there, thats the genius of GW strategy), oil supply, etc etc..

Here is some facts your biased media missed.

1. Chemical and biological weapons manufactring equipment, plans, "recipes," and equpment, all of which could have resumed production on a moment's notice with Saddam's approval.

2. Reference strains of a wide variety of biological-weapons agents (found in the home of a prominent Iraqi biological warfare scientist).

3. A prison laboratory complex fo testing biological weapons on humans.

4. Long range missiles (prohibited by UN resolutions) suitable for delivering WMD.

5. Facilities for manufacturing fuel propellan useful only for prohibited Scud-variant missiles.

In the wake of 9-11, when a devastating attack on this country was planned and executed from a little nothing country like Afghanistan, could we take the chance that an even greater attack would NOT come from Iraq? Do we have to wait for the missiles to be in the air before we do something about them? I certainly hope not.

We've also found more than one link between Iraq and al-Qaeda; we've found Saddam harboring terrorists like Abu Abbas and Abu Nidal. There was the training ground at Salman Pak - Hijacking 101. Not to mention the Islamic Change Movement, a somewhat shadowy organization based in Iraq that claimed credit for the downing of TWA Flight 800.

Now about the oil. We didn't have to invade Iraq to get their oil. We could have bought it like the Russians, the French, the Canadians, the Germans. "No Blood For Oil?" I guess that's okay when it's Iraqi blood for cheaper French oil. And all of the business that Halliburton does in Iraq accounts for about three percent of its revenue. Iraq is hardly a cash cow for Halliburton (although it sure was one for TotalFinaElf).

Sixty years ago a lot of folks said that democracy would be impossible to achieve in Germany and Japan. How wrong they were.

Understand something, these Islamic Fundamentalists are playing a game of power dude. America is their target for whatever reason, (world's lone super power, support of Israel, their resuming of the crusades, etc). We are not going to let them win, period. Whether you support us or not, we will fight and we will go down fighting (although its in your BEST interest to support us, Canada and US do have a long and mutual history). We are not going to ask the permision of the world to protect ourselves or our interests, understand me?

If you want to talk more, come to NJ, I live there. And spew your communist crap and see what happens to you. Otherwise Shut The F**k Up.

by thechas

I'm an American.

Prior to George W. Bush, I voted solidly Republican.

In the 2000 campaign, there were a pair of back to back speeches.
To one group, George W. told them that he fully supported a specific program.
(This surprised me as I thought his stand was the opposite.)
To the next group, he told them that the program had to be eliminated.

Since that time, I have been paying more attention to what our elected officials are saying.

Far too many of the polices and legislation coming from Republican politicians are aimed at benefiting big business at the expense of the average American and the working man!

I won't say that I will never support another Republican. But, right now I expect to vote nearly a strait Democratic ticket this fall.

I'll say this again in case it did not sink in the first time:

Being opposed to the war in Iraq does not necessarily mean that one is anti-American.

Being opposed to President Bush does not mean that one is anti-American. Or, even a liberal.

One is NOT automatically a patriot by supporting a war, or President Bush.

The big problem that you fail to see in your rants against the people who call the US Government to task over our immoral actions is:

We can expect what we consider to be immoral actions from the terrorists and religious fundamentalists in Iraq.

The US entered this war in part on the moral high ground in opposition to a ruthless dictator.

Is it any wonder that the world in general, and Arab people in particular would be upset when we show ourselves to be little better than Saddam?

The present situation in Iraq can be likened to a parent eating a cookie after telling a young child that they could not have one.
Neither at home, or on the world stage can one earn respect by telling someone else to do as I say, not as I do!

Yes, we have done some good things in Iraq, and captured the spirits of many of the citizens there.

Yes, some bad things have been done to our soldiers in the middle east.
However, these actions have been done by individual groups, not a nation, and not a government.

If we punish 1000 men for the actions of 1, how can we prove to Iraq that we, and democracy are any better than Saddam's dictatorship?

Chas

by oz_media

Well Chas, that certainly deserves a round of appplause. How well worded and to the point, man you've got a real knack for that.

I must also state that in NO way do I condemn ALL Americans especialy soldiers. The guys that send them to war under false pretenses and the guys who think it is so righteous are the ones I target with my aggression, when you say you are American, it makes me realizwe i may be lumping you and others in with the bunch even when I don't intend to. Forgive me, 'they' know who 'they' are and I am sure you know that I don't look down upon ALL Ametricans.

by hal 9000

Exactly it is an abuse of our troops to place them in a position like this!

With something like 20 - 30 years to think on your service in Nam you should by now know exactly how it is that any military unit can not function without specific goals and with limited weapons available. After all you where there and have first hand knowledge of exactly what went wrong don't you? Perhaps you can explain exactly it is nothing short of scandalous the way our troops are thought to be able to function and under the type of circumstances where there is no set enemy, no land to be captured and continually fighting a rear guard action to keep their backs clear.

There is a common misconception that the military can fix anything which they clearly can not as they are not trained for a lot of the things that they are expected to perform. You can also attempt to explain exactly why it is an impossible position to be in where you do not have a clear cut enemy and exactly how the current military are not any kind of Police Force as that isn't what they where started for or trained for either.

What is currently happening in Iraq is this exact position and while there is no doubt that the majority of our troops are trying their best they are in an impossible position as anyone who even looks sideways that them is a potential enemy.

Perhaps you could attempt to explain just how frustrating this type of situation actually is. After all you do have first hand experience and who is better qualified to tell it the way it is?

Col

by jimhm

Did you ever hear of the First Adm - There Chas - Freedom of Speech - Now you liberals want to classify things you don't like to hear as "Hate Speech" and ban it - Against the First Adm.

Liberals speek from two ends of their bodies - and how do you know a Liberal is lieing - his mouth or arss is moving ... or talking ...

Waaa - Waaa - Waaa - Hate Speech - Waaa - I am A Liberal you can't say that - Waaa Waaa ... GET A LIFE!

by maecuff

It seems that a common theme from you is name calling. My 6 year old sounds more mature than you. Damn Republicans..always having to resort to name calling when they can't come up with something worthwhile to say.

by jimhm

Hey we all got to classify people somehow - whether they be Liberals, Conserative, Libertarin, Communist, Nationist, Zionist, Fundantialist.. you pick it you can be classified.

I have found that the major that cry "Hate Speech" are liberal and only cry it when something is said in oposition to what they believe. And they have no valid argument or counter points... They Cry that is Hate Speech and want the Speech police to come to their rescue...

And you call me or classify me as a "Dam Republican" - how do you know that? Hum I guess thats not name calling thats just calling the kettle black - but see I don't care, actually most conserative don't care, a name is only a name and can do no harm. I have found in life, only those with a weak belief fondation are troubled by being classified. The don't have the evidence or strength to defend their positions.

I guess not being classified is so they can change aligance in the mid-stream to a winning group. But being Classified locks you all into a group.

Oh well - just call me a "Silly Dam Republican" - or "Stupid arss Conservative" - or "Know nothing Liberatarin" - pick one of those three. Is fine with me, and being 6 you see the world for what it is - no preconceived ideas -

The beauty of the young eye - and mind - ability to see what others can not.

by thechas

Nowhere in my post did I say anything about limiting speech.

All I did was comment on Garion's vicious attitude against anyone who is not 100% behind the war in Iraq.

I used to consider myself to be a conservative.

If I have now become a liberal, there is but one person to thank for that happening.

George W. Bush has made me notice and dislike what the Republican party has become.

I voted for Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush, and Bob Dole.
I have written my Democratic Senators and taken them to task for liberal stands.

As the Republican party has become a party of, by and for big business, I find myself unable to continue to support the party.

The roots of the Republican party were in fiscal and environmental conservation.
Can you find any fiscal restraint in the current federal budget?
And, how come George W. spent the first 2 years trying to roll back every environmental initiative?
Yet, in this election year, suddenly sees the environment as something to protect?

Actually, I consider myself to be more of a centrist than either liberal or conservative.

From what I read in your political posts, I suspect that you are about 3 steps to the right of Rush Limbaugh.

Under George W. Bush, the Republican party has swung the political pendulum much farther to the right than the Democrats ever shifted the country to the left.

Chas

by oz_media

Well I see exactly what you are saying Jim, and that's one of trhe things that amuses me so about the American culture. People have to be molded or classified in order to be listened to or understood. If not, they have no right to speak.

Now from what I am told, I am a Democrat, Socialist, Conservative, Liberal. This was all by different TR members who simply couldn't get their head around that I do not favour a paticular party in Canada. I think people are simply unable of having a conversation without knowing or assuming they know where the other stands. This would be a very typical social disorder just like children have in school. If you want to be a jock wear must the uniform, if you want to look like a homey you must wear the uniform etc.

It seems that everyone must wear their colors on their sleeve and stand behind them vehemently.

When you have those that are indifferent, they are what? Anti-American, Democrats, lost souls, or they simply don't get heard because they don't stand for ONE party.

It's sad as well as scary, the kids learn this segregation in school, then grow up to be just like you, you must have a label to fit in.

Is this not also the underlying mentality that fuels MASS agression against other countries?

If they don't like Bush, they are the enemy, If they support or believe in something that WE don't, it MUST be stopped or corrected to fit into the American mold, yes there's a double meaning there.

by oz_media

Well you lumped SPAIN in as cowards, therefore all people FROM SPain are cowards.

Then you added France, ergo all French citizens are cowards.

I assume Canadians are also cowards.

The British are mighty and tough all of a sudden? Isn't this coming from the same country where MANY of the citizens think they won WWII and saved England? Would the British not also be cowards according to your reasoning?

Anyone who doesn't support teh US is a coward.

Why would you even require support if you are the only might in the world?

Perhaps others are reluctant to fight beside you due to your constant issues with killing your own or allies by "friendly fire", nice word to explain you F****d up AGAIN.

Get off your soapbox and at least have a valid point, you make somany accusations with VERY little logical defense for your own statements, If people aren't agreeing with you, they are just wrong. How about some compelling reason for someone to agree with you instead?

Support your own comments instead of shooting down others as America haters, it's people EXACTLY like yourself that make other people HATE America, not the average citizens with a sense of reason.

YOUR mentality is what has hurt America, not those who are against the US decisions.

So let out your deep breath and relax. We don't need to act like a peacock in 2004.

Listen instead, it may help you understand WHAT other people are against so that you can be more accurate in your accusations against them, if you can't support your own comments that is.

by jimhm

Oz long time no - point counter point between us.

Gee lets see labels - tags - classification -

Isn't that something that happens on a daily basis? What do you do at your job - you aren't the CEO / CFO then jump to the CTO and CIO (ok if you own your own company maybe). But if your a salesman - you don't do the programmers job do you - or do you not believe in labels - tags - or classifications at all.

Its the same with you are human - homo-erictus - huminoid - not bug - insect - plant -

Its the same with political views and beliefs - christian - islamic - jewish - whichever.

Same with Political views - or basic beliefs - Libertarin, liberal, conservative, republican, democrat, communist, nationalist, socialist or facist - If you jump around not speaking one belief then - you have no beliefs - and more of whatever the mood or argurment I can cause problems with.

If you - have beliefs then make them known and stay with them - if you don't like being classified I guess a long walk off a roof would help - everything in life is classified - labeled - taged - Otherwise it would be nuts.

Your vision is someone screwy - but then again - thats you Ozzie -

Thanks for the laugh and the point counter points..

by thechas

Sorry, if you had been around here as long as some of us have, you would know that Oz is very capable of criticizing people who agree with him.

Oz is also definitely NOT a communist.
He may be more liberal than you, but he is a capitalist pig.
Heck, I'm pretty sure that Oz is even pro-democracy.

As i look back at this thread, YOU have done everything you could to invite discord.

If you had left the disclaimer off of your original title, and just presented a positive image of our troops efforts in Iraq, you would not have received any negative comments.

I respect your right to your views.

You in turn (to be an American) need to respect the rights of others to their opinion.

Chas

by garion11

This title clearly states who should and shouldn't look at these pictures. I can't help it if they don't like what they see. I invited discord by expressing my freedom of speech on an American owned company's forum? wow, sounds a little like blame the victim crap.

by oz_media

Capitalist pig?!?

I am actually laughing at that one, especially from one so eloquent as yourself.

Yes I once suported capitalism and big business, I have since seen the error in my ways and have moved to a quiet little community surrounded by wildlife and beauty. I closed my ties to US partners. I only market into three major record outlets (they cover the rest though) and have downsized considerably as I was planning on moving back to England. Then I saw Port Hardy and it's going to be REALLY hard to move now, I kayak by the whales!!! How can I leave that behind???

SO I have humbled, as you have noticed on TR, somtimes anyway. I support small communities and home based business, I have removed ALL ties to North American contracts with labels so I can focus on the real music wolrd in Europe, Japan and Brazil.

I do appreciate your comments, but CAPITALIST??

I don't even think Max sees me as a capitalist!

but cheers mate, have a great one.
OM

by thechas

I did not see a single post that had any problems with the images.

Nor have I seen anyone who disputes that our forces are making friends and helping the people of Iraq.

The majority of negative posts have to do with your prejudicial attitude.

Julian may be the most liberal and anti-war peer in the forum.
He would / did not have any problems with your positive images.

When you stop and think about it, these images have very little to do with the war. Other than the fact that the war brought these Iraqis and our troops together.

In the US, there are many organizations that spend countless hours helping others to build and improve their towns.
They don't get any news coverage either.
Why?
Americans expect other Americans to help others in need.
It just is not a newsworthy story.

Chas

by oz_media

NO not everything in life is labelled,
a TITLE at a company is actually a job description, not a label.

Your TITLE allows those who wish to seek a specialist in your company to identify YOU as the one in charge of a given set of duties, again NOT a label.

Abtually I didn't know you were a "DAMN REPUBLICAN" it makes NO difference to my what soever what political party you favour, your views on war don't 'label' your political identity in my world. If you had different views on ONE aspect of politics would you no longer BE Republican?
No.

AMERICA has a need to classify everyone, as I've said befrore, we don't politically label each other in Canada, I couldn't tell you WHAT party my best friends support, politics isn't welcome in Canadian discussions, nor do we care.

Your political views COULD tag you as an arse in my books, but being Canadian I couldn't give a rats who you feel should control your country's economy. When it comes to YOUR views on war, am I to understand that no matter what YOU feel you will offer a Republican view? Do you not make your own conclusions?

No there aren't tags assigned to everyone, I will prove ANYONE wrong who decides to place my thoughts in a box and classify me. I guarantee you will find a different classification after we discuss a different subject. I reach my OWN conclusions based on what I see and feel. Not based on what party I support, which in Canada is none as I am not Canadian and cannot vote here on a Federal level.

You cannot tag me because I don't fit tagging. It may work in ONE opinion that I am Liberal, other views may be Conservative. There is no mould and I don't fit classification.

That's an American thing, come up here and see how often you are tagged. Come up here and ask people id they are LIberal or Conservative, you will see a LOT of furrowed brows as people say "Who gives a s**t?!"

Keep YOUR politics in America where it's appreciated, when it's effecting MY day, then it becomes MY business and I will tell you what I think. Not what I'm SUPPOSED to think or what all the others wearing MY tag would think.

THat's why I say you are such conformists, you build a set of beliefs and morals based on a political party, to meit is complete lunacy, I supose down there it is expected of people to simply find a group and stay there.

by garion11

ROFL, Ralph Nader eh? LOLOLOL. I can't think of a single witty smarta** remark, cause I am lauging so hard.

by garion11

Keep up the good work junior. Noone here cares about this so called "world". You attack our citizens, or our interests, we come and kick your ass. Plain and simple and god help you.

by maecuff

DO NOT assume that you can speak for all Americans. Because I can assure you that not all of us have the 'we're gonna kick your ass, and f*ck anybody who doesn't like it' attitude. In fact, I don't know many people who feel that way. Of course the rest of the world will have an opinion on what we are doing. We ALL inhabit this planet, so it IS everyone's business.

by garion11

You will understand why come November why I was laughing so hard today. But seriously though keep up the good work, that was a very informative website junior.

by oz_media

How ya been?!?

Well as you can see we have a new bouncing baby boy on TR. I wouldn't take too much offense, so far it has barely offered anything more than the od goo-goo ga-ga and a few F-off's to the wolrd, which he feels America has saved, YES, another live one with no education.

I think I've had about enough of it myself and I'm sure everyone else has too.

Well maybe another thread or two just to see if it improves.

Pop by more often "Junior".;-)

by antipodes

When I first joined in these discussions, I was meek, humble and polite. I spoke as I would like other people to speak to me.

However, as I have been following these discussions, it is now clear that rudeness, arrogance and stupidity get the most attention and score the highest marks.

So I will be a little more outspoken in my future postings.

by oz_media

You have oibviously taken immediate offense to my post and started off like all your other responses here.

What is out of context? Those were complete sentences taken from your posting, perhaps you should try and reword your thoughts if that's ot what you mean.

Now to begin:
'Hmm...You country is part of something called NATO. One of the charters/rules of Nato was that if any member was country was attacked, it would be like an attack on all members and the response would be coordinated together. Obviously several countries didn't live up to their end of the bargain."

THE ONLY COUNTRY THAT ACTED ALONE WAS THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. The other countries were in AGREEMENT that the UN was effectively seeking out the absence of these 'said' WMD that has since been proven as misinformation by the CIA. The Administration to which you bow daily confirms this themselves.

"Your media is so twisted dude..."
THis just goes to PROVE beyond a shadow of a doubt that you have NO idea what you are talking about.

Out of the 60 channels I get, FOUR are Canadian, the rest are US and other world reports. It is a FACT that the US media is heavily censored by the White House, ANY reporter around the globe (including US) will attest to that. You see what you are ALLOWED to see. You should see the difference between American photos of war and the BBc's or Iraq's or Canada's. WHY? The reporters are NOT allowed to show them in the US, they have been interviewed and are trying to fight the US now so that the stories and photos can be shown in the US but they are being cut off by the White House. What YOU consider left wing reporting is so candy coated it isn't funny, and YES I do see YOUR channels, too many of them really.

No Canadians weren't happy to see Iraqi's torturing allied soldiers, you seem to feel that everyone is against the war, which AGAIN they are not. WHat the big issue is, is that GWB bs'd FEAR into US citizens as in every similar situation, to allwo him the room to act alone and prematurely, THIS KILLED AMERICANS, but you seem happy about it.

As for Canadian recon, even the soldiers in Iraq have said that Allied recon would be saving lives (during the initial invasion especially when a low speed tank was hit as it was forced to do recon without the needed equipment. Look up Canada's Coyote reocon vehicle, it has served and saved YOUR men for some time now, the Gulf war showed it's importance more than any yet.
We have faster vehicles, better equipment for monitoring and long distance recon, YOU are wrong in saying you don't NEED Canada's recon. Dig through some of your war archives and see just how many times Canada has helped the US with recon needs, you WILL be stunned.

Toronto is an entity within itself and hardly a good example of Canada. I have left companies that wanted me to move there. Toronto is a country itself when compared to the rest of Canada.

"Or do we all have to be one big Socialist continent? Its ok admit it if you are a Socialist, (aka communist) but don't sit there and support America only when it suits your needs. "

First of all I don't know what I am as far as a political view. We have a Liberal government and for now it works for my so I guess you could tag me as a LIberal if you must, but do it in pencil. I am not Canadian and don't support a specific party here. As for me looking to America to support my needs, never happened for me as I have never personally needed America. I USED to have offices there and have sold many thousands of albums there but I don't need it personally, you guys will buy anything though so I appreciate the residuals.

"1. Chemical and biological weapons manufactring equipment, plans, "recipes," and equpment, all of which could have resumed production on a moment's notice with Saddam's approval.

2. Reference strains of a wide variety of biological-weapons agents (found in the home of a prominent Iraqi biological warfare scientist).

3. A prison laboratory complex fo testing biological weapons on humans.

4. Long range missiles (prohibited by UN resolutions) suitable for delivering WMD.

5. Facilities for manufacturing fuel propellan useful only for prohibited Scud-variant missiles."

Wrong, this all has been in our media, AND yours as I see that too remember? THe absence of proof has been questioned and the Long Range missiles were contested and to this day NO confirmation that Iraq had the technology to deliver weapons to the US has been shown, in fact quite the opposite. Even your God (sorry) President wouldn't say they were ready to attack the US, you were just fed the insinuations that America bought. Even Max, your best ally here for sure, will not agree with you on this one.

As ffor 911 and you saying that everyone ahs turned their backs like cowards on the whole Iraq invasion, perhaps you could explain why it took you four years to join the rest of the world in WWII after hundreds of thousands were killed and torured in Nazi death camps. Not until YOU were attacked did you then participate.

****YOU COULDN'T BUY IRAQI OIL****
As for the oil, you couldn't be more misinformed.
You say you could have bought iraqi oil, NO YOU COULDN'T Saddam cut off the US, that's why the US was buying oil from the countries you now condemn for trading dual purpose goods. If you want, I will send you a copy of the 'US Embassy report to the Congess' that completely details all aspects and issues behind the OFF program and dual purpose goods. The US was stopping shipments of food and needed supplies indefinitely, thus cutting off Iraqi's from neede supplies. All in spite of Saddam, you made other Iraqi's suffer by not completing inspections in the agreed time frames, some shipments taking more than 11 months, some not at all.
You were forced to buy it from Rusia and France etc who were all gettng it from Saddam and then marking up the price. IN essence, supply and demand created such a NEED for some of the smaller countries to export oil to the US that they were needing to buy mroe and more from Iraq.
This way you don't need the middle man and you just steal it yourselves, against a program which the US initiated.

As for nobody supporting the war you are wrong again, you are REALLY starting to show your age and mentality here as you seem to be missing the point ONCE again. The problem was that BUSH ignored his Allies and the recommendations of the UN and NATO. HE, MR GEORGE BUSH THE AMERICAN PRESIDENT, was the one who acted alone. HE ignored NATO , not CANADA. HE is the cause for such a rough beginning to all this, an unprepared military invasion that killed many. GWB is more of a threat to America than Saddam was.

I don't think Saddam should tay in power, Iraq needed to be saved, Saddam neede to be caught, none of the other countries you have comdemned ever disagreed with this. THe disagreement was that not enough PROOF that Iraq was NOT dismantling the WMD was provided. In fact the UN had found several things that COUDLN'T target America, that Iraq seemed to be dismantling it's WMD programs as they said they were and had said that within weeks the inspections would be completed. From THAT point on, the WAR ON TERRORISM, (remember the big world alliance that included everyone fighting in Iran?) would be fought as an allied interest.

You seem to be saying that YOU were in danger, that YOU were saving yourselves. IN Actuality, England was in MUCH greater danger of attack from Saddam than you were, so I suppose now you can say you did it to save England?

Your post is such nonsense and such unresearched or qualified information it seems like we've walked back a year in time here on TR. All of these points have been churned over and over again, at this pointin time, your claims hold no water they just aren't proven and have been proven otherwise over the past year.

As for your closing comment, you REALLY don't know me and it isn't ANY effort for me to visit New Jersey, in fact I have been there twoce on tour with acts I manage. You comments will be ignored THIS time, yet these things wont get you far on TR as unlike a kiddies chat room where these things are considered cool, at TR it is grounds to be ousted.

Now because you threw around some names in one of your posts, I called you a lttle snot.

Normally, a personal attack is grounds for membership cancellation here, your closing comments are very brave for someone hiding in another country so I will dismiss them as fluff like the rest of your post, keep in mind though that I won't be so kind in future as to just let it go, and you wouldn't be the first here that's for sure.

Perhaps next timeyou decide to start such a discussion you may want to keep in mind,
Such political discussions have to be very carefully worded so as not to defame any individual or the country in which they reside. Now I know I got pretty pissed at your ramblings but you seemed to attack every person and every country that didn't agree with you, without their provocation, just difference of opinion. Keep it up and you will be the nest TR big mouth to hit the road, people don't stand for such immature BS here.

by garion11

you dumbshit. Was that it? or did you want a more clarification on what I think of your stupidity, LOL.

My favourite is

"...WHat the big issue is, is that GWB bs'd FEAR into US citizens as in every similar situation, to allwo him the room to act alone and prematurely, THIS KILLED AMERICANS, but you seem happy about it."

Oh no he scared us and deceived us. OMG, we are soooo dumb.

"Perhaps next timeyou decide to start such a discussion you may want to keep in mind,
Such political discussions have to be very carefully worded so as not to defame any individual or the country in which they reside. Now I know I got pretty pissed at your ramblings but you seemed to attack every person and every country that didn't agree with you, without their provocation, just difference of opinion. Keep it up and you will be the nest TR big mouth to hit the road, people don't stand for such immature BS here"

You have a lot of nerve telling Americans, on an American owned message board on how and what we should post. You don't like my posts don't read em.
But you know what, Shut up already. Getting sick and tired of your lies and double talk. Please do me a favor and don't post anymore responses to my threads ok? I will do the same to yours.

As I stated if you really wanna settle this you know where I am. And you'd be shocked and awed at our patriotism, something you don't seem to have a concept of anyway so wtf is my point? I guess nothing, I am just insulting the alphabet by responding to your posts. Good day.

by oz_media

An American company run TR, it is NOT an American bulletin board in ANY form though.

The regular posters here are from England, Canada, Australia and the USA.

Now I can't find the exact phrasing anymore as the site is being changed a lot lately, but it was clearly stated that this is a GLOBAL forum, NO personal attacks or attacks on one's country are tolerated. The last couple of guys who were exactly like yourslef, no your not unique nor are your views new or your opinions of others new either, are no longer here.

Why?

Because they thought they had freedom of speech and had completely failed to understand that your constitution does not permit you to exercise your free speech on a PRIVATELY owned community that has it's own guidelines. Your constitution does not aply to all apsects of life, it just means that you have the right to exercise free speech and cannot be silenced by your government. It doesn't mean you can say whatever you want wherever you choose.

Out of curiosity how old are you? 16, 17 or am I being generous? PLEASE don't tell me your are an adult yet.

One point I did see you comment on that you may want to explain is :
But I guess it has to happen to their country before people understand why Americans feel the way they do.

London Blitz, Battle of Britain, there are many times when my countrymen have been attacked on their own soil. They also sucessfully defended that soil with the help of every allied country EXCEPT the USA, who hadn't been attacked themselves YET. Canada was one of the first Allied countries to join from outside Europe and lost thousands while your great grandfather sat at home with his flag waving proudly over the porch.

(before you form a response, Hitler was defeated in trying to invade England, you did NOT save anyone there, Germany had lost to the RAF and RN when trying to invade.)

The British and French slaughtered the USA out of southern Canada in 1812, we have fought here in Canada too, yet you lost all the lives in that one.

by oz_media

TechRepublic discussion and Technical Q&A guidelines are based on the belief that communities function best when members show mutual respect and cooperation.

The essential rule for posting to Discussions or Technical Q&As at TechRepublic is that you are responsible for your words. This means that you are responsible for posting responsibly and ethically, and for conforming to community guidelines.

You may, from time to time, find yourself in disagreement with someone on TechRepublic. Keep in mind that it's safer, more polite, and more persuasive to take issue with that person's comments, rather than attacking them personally.

Remember that we are an international, culturally diverse community of IT professionals. Standards vary, and meanings may be easily misunderstood.

To that end, please

avoid "obscene" language
be careful not to trample on the feelings of others
remember that hasty comments will be available long after you have entered them
use moderation and good judgement

So where within these guidelines can you justify your behaviour in this thread?

by thechas

Max,

Who ever suggested that the major news media was ever interested in the balance of good versus bad news?

Balance as it relates to the media is presenting opposing views on an issue. This stirs controversy and boosts ratings.

Why do I say that "good news" stories are not newsworthy?

They don't show death or destruction.
They are not controversial.

Good news stories just don't make it off the cutting room floor.

Our major local news TV station has increased their local news programming.
Part of this expansion has been the elimination of the "good news" segments.
It's been quite a shock seeing the reporter who had anchored the human interest segments covering "hard" news stories.

For the commercial news outlets, the focus is RATINGS, not news.
As soon as the focus groups, consultants, and most importantly the advertisers determine that the viewing public is interested in "good news" stories, they will make it to the news.

Until then, we will need to rely on individuals and NPR to let us know the other side of what is going on in Iraq.

Yes, I have heard a number of "good news" stories about our troops helping the Iraqi people on NPR.

Chas

by thechas

Oz,

I may have been a bit overboard in my comment.

However, you have to admit that you are much closer to a capitalist than a communist.

Being a liberal does not make you a socialist.

Chas

by oz_media

I can swallow that.

I feel like calling a few friends now and telling them that I have been politically tagged. It's so exciting, it's just so new and fun, how neat, I'm politically labelled!

Everyone else just calls me 'A**hole!'

Thanks again,
OM

by jardinier

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

Now I studied this document first with a magnifying glass, and then with a microscope. Nowhere could I find any reference to having a right to be abusive and offensive in exercising freedom of speech.

Before you learnt that Colin was not an American, you threatened to punch him for disagreeing with you. This would of course be interpreted as denying him the right to express his views.

Well it's lucky for you that Colin is not an American because if you punched him, and he retaliated (which I doubt that he would do) you would get your ass kicked good and proper. Colin trained under a Shaolin monk and is called upon to act as a bodyguard for the Dalai Lama when he visits Australia.

[Sorry to reveal these details of your personal life, Colin, but this mental retard is just asking for it].

Now as I am not as self-controlled and resilient as Colin, you are most welcome to try punching me, and I might even send you a post-card in hospital to see how you are recovering.

The type of rudeness and vulgarity which you have expressed in this discussion is not tolerated by the Management of TechRepublic, and you will see your sorry little ass deleted from the membership list in no time flat.

by hal 9000

If you are so adamant in your beliefs why do you not take the opportunity to explain them when asked?

Now I did ask you to speak out on just how troops proved ineffective in Nam because they lacked solid aims and an enemy but I have noticed that you declined to follow up on this offer.

Could it be that you only wish to post here on what you would like to believe in rather than the reality of the situation? But then again I suppose you could have been one of the few from NAm who was welcomed home with open arms instead like the rest who where spat upon and treated like dirt for something that they had no control over. You have no idea just how upset I was when I saw scenes like this as the people who where protesting aimed their wrath at the wrong people. Instead of attacking the people responsible for sending the troops there they transfered their dislike onto the troops who had nothing to do with the thing in the first place. But then again I'll bet you would have gone to Nam even if the US Government wasn't interested wouldn't you?

Col

by maxwell edison

.
Oz is on the record of having said that he despises capitalism. However, I don't think he really said what he meant. If he really despised capitalism, like he said, he wouldn't participate in it.

I would guess that he really despises the image of a particular life-style one might associate with capitalism. A person can certainly despise the stereo-typical, wheeling and dealing , wall street, suit and tie, big-business images that the term "capitalism" might conjure up. But capitalism is not a life-style, per se, but rather an economic system. Capitalism, in short, is merely the exchange of goods or services for something of value. The "goods and services" are privately owned, not state owned, as is the "value" for which it's traded.

The doctor who used to make a house call to attend a sick child in exchange for a chicken engaged in capitalism. If someone wants a house on a secluded corner of Vancouver Island, he might provide goods or services in exchange for that house. But in today's capitalist system, instead of trading our goods and services for a chicken or a house, we use money, i.e. capital, to keep track of the various exchanges. It's really not too unlike bartering. Moreover, I'm sure Oz utilizes capitalism to advance his creature comforts, which is really the accumulation of wealth, over that of others.

In my estimation, Oz is the consummate capitalist, but he can't bear to admit it because of the negative images it conjures up in his mind. Not that I'm suggesting that the images are an accurate measure of capitalism, or that they're necessarily negative ones, but he apparently thinks they are. (Not that I'm trying to psycho-analyze, but it's simply my observation.)

To know what a person really believes in, look at what he does, not at what he says. And Oz is a believer in capitalism. But capitalism is good. Without it, no one could acquire that house on a secluded corner of Vancouver Island.

by maxwell edison

.
"Congress shall make no law...."

I know we've discussed this before, but why doesn't it sink-in to people?

The "free speech" clause in the U.S. Constitution places that prohibition on the government, not private entities. It simply does not apply in cases like this, unless, of course, it's the government threatening to punch someone in the nose unless they "stop speaking" a certain way. He could certainly get charged with assault for such a threat, or battery for carrying out such a threat, but not for squelching free speech.

When was the last time a private person was charged with a crime by prohibiting or interfering with the "free speech" of another private person? I don't believe it's ever happened. A student can be kicked out of class for speaking freely. A person could be fired from a job for speaking freely. A person may be removed from a theater for speaking freely. And, I suppose, a person might get punched in the nose for speaking freely.

A person making some statement that someone else might find offensive equals exercising free speech. Someone else threatening to punch that person in the nose because he was offended equals exercising free speech. The former might be misguided, and the latter might be stupid, but neither is being prohibited by any government agency.

So the First Amendment is alive and well at TechRepublic since no government agent or agency is interfering with a person speaking freely.

(Until, of course, the powers that be at TR decide enough is enough and they exercise their own "free speech" by zapping all these off-topic discussions.)

by nd_it

I think you may have overstepped the boundry between personal bashing and freedom of speech. You posted a comment as it is your right to do so, and other posted comments as well. Those people do have the right to look at those comments and post their opinion, whether you agree with them or not. This is called debate, and it's to debate the topic at hand not to personally name call. Sometimes debate doesn't seem to go anywhere, but I think it does give us some understanding of others' views, not just our own. Hopefully, I know I do, hope to become more open minded. Be carefull with your first ammenment right, you are crossing a thin red line.

by garion11

See this is what my problem is with these people. This so called oz and a couple of others here in this thread. To me, in their eyes, America can never ever do any good. EVER! Unless we follow their countries opinions or the world's opinion, or have a President who does so. How dare they? Yeah, they never explicitly stated it? Its implied in every sentence and every posting.

I clearly stated America's concerns and our plan and clearly asked where all these protesters and all these so called "experts" of opinion were when other countries fuck up (some deliberately *GASP*) No answer, except more bashing me and America. I am sick of it, Fuck you! They make up lies and stories to fit their ideology. The pure hatred of American power that is spewing from their filthy dirty mouths is unbelievable. These people want us to lose and any American that doesn't see that is blind.

Did you know when the US soccer team went to Mexico that the Mexicans were chanting Ossama Bin Laden? WTF? Anyone that opposes American policy with the current administration is thrown up on a high pedestal and worshipped like God, yet I was told that Americans were deceived by Bush. Our media is controlled by Republicans, etc, etc. What kind of arrogance assumes that Americans are so stupid that we followed Bush blindly with every policy he puts out? Who the fuck are you when you don't live here to make that kind of a statement? Who? I don't agree with everything he does, but I will support him as a citizen and a patriot in these dire times and he is doing his best. And yet arrogance and over confident is what we were labeled as. How dare you?

LET ME STATE THIS VERY CLEARLY. SUPPORT OF AMERICA, ITS MILITARY, AND BUSH'S FOREIGN POLICY WAS A DELIBRATE AND A CONCIOUS CHOICE MADE BY ME AND MANY AMERICANS HERE, UNDERSTAND THAT VERY WELL.

Noone deceived me and noone put a gun to our heads. Its just that its been so long since you shitheads had to support and be patriotic to your countries that you have forgotten how, so this American support for our President seems so foreign to you and the only explanation you can come up with is we were deceived. Fuck you. Scumbags, don't ever assume stuff about Americans, nor think that you know what our mentality is. Fact is you don't and you never will unless you are an American. I don't assume to know Europeans do I? or Australians? I respect their wishes and assume that since they are a democracy that they have good intentions. But yet I haven't gotten that response once since I have posted here from anyone of these people. They think we are out to get them or something.

by oz_media

You ranalogy is somewhat accurate and you are quite right. If taken in the definitive form, Capitalism is simply trade.

When I spout about capitalistics pigs, I AM (as you assumed) speaking of the massive corporations that abuse the system and consumers ni order to gain those profits. You know, good business bad business.

I have actually grown to hate the wall street clowns as well as the posers in IT who think they have it all together and are the new world's builders. I've seen this for many years and it gets worse every year.

Yes Max, I was once VERY capitalistic, I would step on anyone to gain and did it quite sucessfully. After my rude awakening by the fire truck, I saw things in a much more passive light and have since started to have more concern for small and home based businesses.

It's the same with women who get all gussied up like the magazine covers they wish they really were and head out to the club to play the game. Give me a break, posers that wash the eight pounds of makeup off and put on their MacDonalds smock in the morning to go earn next weeks drinking money.

Yet they all look the same on party night, just a game and a role to play. MUCH like many of todays so called 'entrepeneurs'. THe capitalistic MINDSET that they have adopted prematurely is just a farce however it is a big beacon calling to the wannabe's to joing the ranks. So what do they do?
Buy a black leather car coat (just like EVERY wannabe)a pair of Dockers and pay over $1000/mo for a loft in trendyville.

Th ecapitalists are feeding off the wannabe capitalists. It's all such a sham, nobody has a personal identity onw and thus I am hating bug business for the way they rape and pillage their way to the top.

Thanks for such a non-offensive observation Max, I am somewhat surprised to see it, even if it was inended as a bit of a prod.

OM

by maecuff

It's so nice to see you two being nice to each other, at least kinda nice. It makes me all warm and fuzzy.

by oz_media

I always thought you were warm and fuzzy? (OOOOH!, BOOOOOO!)

Hey and what's with 'eh?' in your posts???

Are you trying to muscle in on OUR slang?

Perhaps you are a closet Canadian....(please don't hit me).

by hal 9000

I hope that the "Powers that be at TR" never pull the "Water Cooler" discussions as I think it was you who first called them this. If we where all stuck to only thinking about technical things all the time it would be as boring as hell here wouldn't it?

Anyway on-wards and up-wards I'm sure that something better will come along that consigning this to the scrap heap where it remains undisturbed so that nothing posted here in any way affects how TR works.

Have a great day.

Col

by hal 9000

Care Bear meeting. With Maxwell and Oz getting on so well things just have to go wrong here as everyone else is just getting on too well.

Col

by oz_media

Just like we have said over and over again.

Soe of us will disagree strongly with each other and agree other times.

Now Max has helped me with Q&A issues before, we have also exchanged non-vile comments regarding TR issues about teh forums, little glitches etc. We don't agree politically that's for sure.

We do (lately) try and respect each other in such discussions and even though we push and prod we generally settle down before it goes too far.

One thing I have always admired about the folk at TR, when someone like Garion comes in with his venemous BS, even those opppsed to each other will agree that such behaviour is not part of debating or discussing anything and is inappropriate. I don't have the time to read such crap, I'd rather discuss something than sit like two monkeys throwing feces at each other.

So although Max and I disagree on many things, we also learned to SOMEWHAT respect eaach others opinions. I try not to be so nasty in my replies and I think he has made an effort too. In most cases we just avoid each other if there's nothing constructive to say.

Who knows, one day I may even grow up.
I do like the thought of a rainbow on my tummy though.

by oz_media

"To me, in their eyes, America can never ever do any good. EVER! Unless we follow their countries opinions or the world's opinion, or have a President who does so. How dare they? Yeah, they never explicitly stated it? Its implied in every sentence and every posting."

You could not be more wrong than in making such assumptions. Personally, I couldn't give a crap who you are and what your government does, it SHOULDN'T have ANY effect on me, but it does in the case of your existing administration.

America isn't to blame here, the people that RUN America are (to me of course) and YES they are in my face ALL day and night. The papers report less and less about GWB now as public opinion says 'Don't put his face on our newspaper' we simply won't buy it. A neighbour who's son delivers the new each day had lost MANY subscriptions during all the GWB hype, people wer cancelling the paper because they were sick of seeing someone else's president in their face all day. It has NOTHING to do with hating AMERICA or ANYTHING American.

Here is my beef about "followers' or conformists.

GWB 'mislead' the people of America who supposedly voted him into office. Whether it was on purpose or by acident due to misinformation, it was still done. Everyone was screaming about saving their babies and America from certain doom caused by the madman as a result of all the hype of attacks on america from WMD.

WMD issue was brushed aside and instead, Liberating Iraq and defeating Saddam and his minions was the 'new focus' given to the people.

Well this just becomes the GLOBAL war on terrorism now and definitely NOT what the quick call to arms was al about and does not justify America's going in alone and unaided against the wishes of NATO and Ameriocan Allies in the WAR on Terrorism. You acted alone BY CHOICE, and then bitched at everyone else for not standing beside you, not ONE country but ALL your allies were ignored. GWB had been very happy to announce ths GOBAL effort to stop terrorism worldwide, there are MANY other countries in far worse condition and danger than Iraq, they were just a token target to help the oil companies help themselves, and that's EXACTLY who Bush needs for his reelection.

So if I was an American who had voted for Bush, been mislead and then redirected without a word of apology or explanation to the people who stood behind him, I'd be feeling somewhat pissed off about it. Instead I see all these Pro-Bush supporters standing by him as if he is so righteous and true to the game, he's already screwed up his job and it went uncontested!! Is everyone blind? Do they just have a soft spot for knobs with blue eyes or do they sincerely feel that this man is the best suited to govern what is considered the leaders of the free world?

If that was in Canada, the dude would be out on his ass and working at Burger Thing for $9/hour.

We don't stand behind such crap especially someone who misleads us and then expects us to support his next move. I see this as blind following.

So:
1) How does this mean I hate anything American?

2) Why would this observation piss you off?

3) "No answer, except more bashing me and America. I am sick of it, Fuck you!"
How is that kind of an attitude supposed to get any form of logical answer other than FU2.

Lastly and again, please refrain from using such immature language on these forums, it is NOT tolerated no matter WHAT you feel your rights may be. You are only minimizing your own mentality by such comments, at no time did you try to CLEARLY explain anything without flaming someone or someone's country. Many asked YUO questions directly as i have above which you have not addressed and just resorted to the same FU response. What's wrong with you, man do you ever need some help. Heaven forbid you should ever raise children.

To show everyone how YOU can be so much more professional than all these nasty American haters who do not answer your questions (which is all I see people doing here with your failing to respond to their comments without name calling) and start by answering the three questions above.

I guarantee you can't.

by oz_media

I think the real fun here maecuff is that we KNOW you don't feel that way. In fact this guy is wondering why everyone has such a negative attitude of America, which I don't see here other than a negative response to political actions.

I can only say it is people EXACTLY like him, who CREATE this hatred for THAT form of American attitude.

You have proven here that you are not like that and you have independant thought and feelings to many, as you realize you are entitled to.

When we talk about the few who ruin it for the rest, your poster boy here is the perfect example.

You are relatively reserved in your feelings and even though you do offer opinion, you keep your personal feelings somewhat reserved, which I can respect.

Unfortunately, it's the idiots who make all the noise around the world. Like he said, he gets this everywhere on OTHER bulletin Boards (kiddie chat rooms, ICQ etc.). This svenom gets spread by those who read it to others and surely enough small groups plot against the anal thought processs and then you have a whole room of people stongly opposing America, not just Garion. Because he spews such overpatriotic and arrogant, unqualified rubbish they now oppose America.

"Stand in the place where you live, now face North.
Think about direction, wonder why you haven't before.
Now stand in the place where you work, now face West.
Think about the place where you live, wonder why you haven't before."

Some people just need to understand the rest of the world instead of expecting the world to understand themselves.

by maecuff

Of course I'm not trying to muscle in..y'all don't have exclusive rights to eh, eh?

by maxwell edison

.
Y'all is singular.

All y'all is plural.

You're welcome.

(I'm a real stickler for proper grammar, y'all know.)

by oz_media

At least we aren't being tagged as the ones that say EH, no not Canada!

That's it, I starting to use 'Y'all' (probably get my ass kicked by an Angry Canadian thinking I'm American though).

Last night there was a guy wearing a T-Shirt the print was too small and faded to read but in essence it was something like:

Why do Canadian's say 'EH'and Amercans say HUH?

then there was a long definistion of terms Canadaians replace with the word EH, such as Okay? Right? Copacetic? etc.

The closing was "because it's better than saying'HUH?'

Something to that effect but actually humorous.

So stick to your Huh's and Y'alls and I'll stick to my Eh's, eh?

by oz_media

Are you serious that there is a PROPER plural and singular version of "y'all?"
I suppose 'You all' and 'you all'.......no still don't see the difference but I'm sure it's there somewhere.

In Eastern Canada (maritimes Newfoundland and Nova Scotia) they say 'You's guys!" I always loved that one, "Hey, what's you's guy up to yanoo?" "goo git in dat dere boot and sail"
"I's the by who builds the boats and she's tha girl that sails em"

Or the famous Molson Canadian commercial, two Americans are in an office and are bugging a Canadian about his accent. "Noo Doot aboot it!" HA HA HA . The Canadian turns around and pulls the guys Jersey over his head and knocks him out like in a hockey fight or like Adam Sandler did in Happy Gilmore.

Ah well, it's all in fun anyway.