Discussion Locked

Politics AND Religion, all in one thread !

0 helpful
27 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://tinyurl.com/mmv8c

"Six weeks after urging voters to elect only "tried and true" Christians, Senate candidate Katherine Harris is questioning her opponent's faith by saying he "votes completely contrary" to Christian principles. "

"Harris said that God did not intend for the United States to be a "nation of secular laws" and that failure to elect "tried and true" Christians would allow legislators "to legislate sin."

She said "God is the one who chooses our rulers" and suggested non-Christians "don't know better.""

Now, that's what I want to see in an elected official. Compassion and all that.

Ironically, her opponent has the following resume:

"Nelson is a non-denominational Christian who was baptized Baptist. He grew up attending Baptist and Episcopal churches and joined First Presbyterian Church after moving to Orlando last year, according to spokesman Bryan Gulley.

He has served as chairman and vice chairman of the National Prayer Breakfast and, when in Washington, D.C., attends weekly prayer breakfasts with other elected officials."

I am so glad I don't live in Florida.

Edit: I can't spell my way out of a paper bag.

27 replies

by tonythetiger

That would be a neat trick :)

[i]He has served as chairman and vice chairman[/i]

There's the problem.... [b]vice[/b] chairman

:^0

by nicknielsen

they deserve what they get. But with all those Godless d*mnYankee retirees down there, I don't think it can happen.

As for spelling your way out of a paper bag, I've always found that "abracapocus" works well... :^0

by schuyler

The last person God ever 'directly' chose as a "leader of people" was Jesus, the Christ of Nazareth. Ever since then, man has chosen every single elected official that has been placed into office. Man is the one responsible for choosing, all public, and in some cases private, officials, not God. So buck up people and stop complaining or accusing God for electing so-called, self-professing Christians, or non-Christians into any public or private office. The people have made their own bed. Now it is up to them to sleep in it.

How does that saying go? Oh yeah. Give them enough rope and they will hang themselves.

by tig2

She must have missed the memo. You know, the one about glass houses and throwing stones?

Or in more biblical terms, removing the timber from her own eye before attempting to remove the speck from Nelson's.

People like her give Christians a bad name.

by jdclyde

As many of todays Christians, (especially ones that vote for people with a "D" by their name), they are "Caffeteria Christians". They seem to think it is like a buffet, where you can pick and choose which parts of religion they like and which they don't.

Very few major religions support abortion-at-will laws. If you vote against what your beliefs are, then it shows you have no convictions in your own beliefs.

While we don't want a fire-and-brimstone person in office, I don't think we want anti-religious people their either. The people that hide behind religion, but do not support it are suspect.

Morality is not a bad thing. Expecting and even demanding some form of moderation in public is good for the WORLD. If you don't think so, what would you say when the guy in the trench coat sits across the street from a grade school, self-serving? Not acceptable behaviour in public. do you have to be a religious nut to think this way? No, but you are a very disgusting human if you think that it should be allowed.

Can't people be "DECENT" anymore?

by jamesrl

Harris makes the mistake of attacking someone for being a non Christian, who evidently has some credentials as a Christian. Bad move.

First of all, I may be Christian, but I don't take someone's religion as a reason for voting for someone. I've voted for Hindhus and Muslims who were conservatives and felt the same way I do on issues. And frankly I don't judge a "Christian" on what they say but on what they do. I would look at voting records, support for charitable causes etc.

They are plenty of strident people who claim religion as a consuming factor in their life who do not demonstrate a consistent moral code in their life. There are aethiests who are very moral.

I wouldn't vote for Harris if thats how she choses to attack her opponents. It would violate one of the two prime laws Jesus handed down.

James

by jdclyde

[i]"and felt the same way I do on issues."[/i]

And there is a difference between that and someone that votes against the way you feel in an issue, correct? Christians would have a hard time justifying topics like abortion-at-will.

If someone is not voting in alignment with their professed beliefs, you do have to question them. Someone with no convictions either way is just someone who beleives in nothing.

No, I would not recommend attacking someone in this fashion, but you do have to wonder if the tone and text is true to the way it was delivered AND keep in context to who the audiance is.

by tonythetiger

It's not what they believe (or say they believe), it's what they [b]do![/b]

[added: It's not what they [b]feel[/b] either! (we've had more than enough of that already)]

by onbliss

You said "They seem to think it is like a buffet, where you can pick and choose which parts of religion they like and which they don't."

Almost all the major religion's major texts were written atleast 2000 years ago. Islamic texts being the youngest ones. And almost all the interpretations, translations, ideas and concepts are thousands of years old.

You would agree that the world is different today. So why should not a person not take what s/he thinks fits for the modern times, from her/his religion?

Say if one were to not consider the time frame, and why does it have to be all or none when it comes to beliefs?

ps: My post is generic. It does not pertain to any one religion.

by jdclyde

If you go to your chosen flavor of spiritual leader and tell them that they need to relax and party because it is a different age, how will you be recieved?

If you pick MAJOR teachings of that chosen flavor of religion and calmly explain that you don't like those parts, so you would like to have a spiritual hall pass to get an exception to these rules, again, how will you be recieved?

The two topics that WERE mentioned were abortion and gay marriage. How many major religions accept either of these as "a good thing"?

It is valid in context to be reminded that according to the major religions, there is still a moral right and wrong. If you do not support your chosen flavor of religions moral right, then you are spiritually immoral.

Lucky for us, MOST religions are not insane, and think that all people will be converted or die.

by protiusx

So well put I wish I would have read it before I posted my dribble. Yours is much better!

by onbliss

I agree, spiritual leaders are less likely to receive our suggestions. But do we pursue a faith for their sake? Why can't we learn what we need to from them, and then make our own decisions on what we are going to follow?

And don't tell me people on this planet, all, are following ALL of their religious rules.

As I said, the birth of religions happened thousands of years ago. The conditions were different and their views on abortion and gay marriage was conditioned by their time and needs.

Yes from the religious point of view, when a person deviates from, say, one of the moral right, the person might be considered immoral. But then we are what we are and want to be. Similarly we can make our religion what we want to be. If people did not deviate then religions would not have grown mature, tolerant and moderate.

by jdclyde

Then when does it become acceptable to make up our own rules and which ones should we keep?

Should we see it as morally wrong to not honor your mother and father?

Should we see it as morally wrong to be unfaithful to our mate?

Should we see it as morally wrong to steal?

Should we see it as morally wrong to kill?

Where do we start and where do we stop?

Is there really no right, wrong, moral and immoral anymore, if it is all just subjective to our mood?

This approach does help to explain why school shootings are up, if everything is subjective and subject to change?

I think if you look around, totally secular societies are not exactly the shining examples of the world.

What is the beginning basis for ALL major religions to be against homosexuals? WHEN did it start and why? What was the need to be against this "alternative life style" that it still not accepted in many circles any more than is legally required?

by onbliss

Are your basing your argument on my last paragraph of the previous post? Or does it consider my other posts as well?

Down below I use the word "texts" to mean religious scriptures and commentaries.

Let me begin by addressing the context of my thoughts and posts. There are innumerable ancient texts with copious references to morals. And, there are thousands of such addressing man and the society in different ways. My point of rejection pertains to "things" that made sense and that do not make sense now. Essentially it urges to consider the situation.

I did not say discount everything that has been said in the texts. So it would be upto an individual or society to determine if those 4 issues that you question are relevant today.
I have not said there is nothing right or wrong, or that there is nothing moral or immoral anymore. Did I? My thought is that things are little complex. Issues do need to be weighed and can not be seen in isolation. Let us take the 4th issue in your list - killing. If one were to make a statement killing is immoral, then is it immoral to kill a terrorist too? Would a person honor his/her parents if they discover, say, his/her parent is a terrorist or a rapist or a molestor?

In what way do you think secular societies are not shinning examples of the world?

As far as your question about major religions and their view on homosexuality. I honestly do not know the basis' beginning. What is your point you are driving towards? Different religions speak against it with varying degree of force. Procreation was more in mind.

And by the way, the word 'morality' has roots in 'custom'. And custom is nothing but practice among the majority.

by jdclyde

He has not voted in line with HIS proclaimed Christian faith.

Is that something valid to point out to Christians? I would say yes, but it could have been said better.

by nicknielsen

His faith is his faith. I don't think any of us can know his beliefs and how he interprets them and justifies his actions.

My primary belief is in The Golden Rule and I try to live my life by that. As almost everybody here knows, I often fail, but I keep trying. Isn't that what it's all about?

by jdclyde

I was just stating what she said in the article, not going over his voting record on my own.

That is how I know.

It wasn't about what I think, because it was only discussion what she said about him and if she was out of line for it or not.

If it was about anything but religion, the free speechers would not have an issue with her expressing her opinion, would they?

by tonythetiger

It's not valid in my eyes. For one, her definition of 'Christian' might be quite different from that of her opponent, or that of those she is addressing; And two, we all know how bills get tacked onto others. Perhaps something he might have voted for had it been by itself he didn't because of what it was bundled with.

I don't have the patience to dig through the layers of half-truths and out-of-context quotes. I simply look at whether and how someone votes on the issues that are important to me. Campaigns ads are merely sometimes humourous distractions.

by jdclyde

Everyone has their own idea of what is important to them.

Why is this not valid just because it isn't an issue that is important to you?

For people that do take their religion seriously, it should direct their lives on all levels, and those are the people she was talking to.

I recently had a discussion with my nutcase liberal weenie aunt that I do love so dearly and had to point out something that was the main difference between her politics and mine. She does not like, nor trust Republicans. I do not like, not trust politicians.

by jdclyde

Start with the religions view on homosexuality, because it was based on your comment of things being "conditioned by their time and needs."

Based on that, I was just curious of the "need" to be uniformly against homosexuality. The procreation would make sense to a point, but doesn't really explain it. I don't understand what the "need" was. (still don't)

under the gun this morning, but will come back later when I have more time to discuss the rest.

Cheers.

by protiusx

Albeit shocking to some of you I will agree that ours is a secular nation and should remain so. I have never advocated for the melding of government and religion. What I do advocate is that we require that our government adhere to the letter of the second amendment and NOT make ANY laws regarding religion OR the restriction thereof.

As a Christian I constantly strive to love my neighbor more than myself and to love the Lord my God with all my heart, mind and soul. Is my "holiness" directly linked to my works? Does God consider me holier than someone else because I go to Church regularly and they don't? The answer is no for both questions. God looks at my heart and judges me accordingly. From a Christian's perspective we believe that all things are as God wills them. So, for her to say that God chooses our rulers and governors she is entirely correct. What she is failing to understand is that God often uses those who do not believe in him to quicken or correct his flock. Just as he used Pharaoh to convict Abraham of being a coward and a liar who was willing to allow his wife to sleep with another man all because he was afraid, God will use who he wills to do his bidding.

What she is referring to is someone who purports to be a Christian and may put on all the accoutrements of a Christian but then does not act accordingly. A Christian would not nor could not vote to murder the unborn, no more than a Christian could vote to recognize homosexual union as the same as marriage.

by yobtaf

I would say the exact same thing but in my case I would
have to change Christian to agnostic.

I think that Jesus had a great philosophy of life and I
follow it, more or less. The only difference is, to me God is
unknowable and a lot of people try to attribute human
values to Christian values.

In short anybody can be a good person, it has nothing to
do with religion.

by tonythetiger

valid to some. That's why I said "in my eyes".

Actions are a better indicator than words (we all know politicians like to tell us what they think we want to hear.)

I love some of the ads. We have one running here where a candidate claims to be against shippoing jobs out of the country, but supports buting prescription drugs from Canada... Duh!

by jdclyde

That is just fine to buy your drugs from the Canuks because it saves YOU money.

It is wrong for a COMPANY to ship their money overseas to save THEM money.

It is just one of many of the shining examples of the lack of any moral code or intellectual honesty from "that" crowd.

Our current governor that has driving our state to the highest unemployement in the country, and the slowest economy, ran on that same idea. (as she IS a canuk AND we are right on the boarder, so it is an easy jump over and back) She is also "cracking down" on the out-sourcing of jobs. (yeah, right)

by tonythetiger

I would think that since there is a pharmacutical company in his district, that he would be interested in saving [b]their[/b] jobs... :)

This discussion is closed to new replies.