Principle vs. Politics -and- Reality vs. Rhetoric
.
Definitions (From American Heritage):
Rhetoric: Language that is elaborate, pretentious, insincere, or intellectually vacuous: [i]His offers of compromise were mere rhetoric.[/i]
Reality: That which exists objectively and in fact: [i]Your observations do not seem to be about reality.[/i]
Principle: The collectivity of moral or ethical standards or judgments: [i]His is a decision based on principle rather than expediency. [/i]
Politics: Intrigue or maneuvering within a political unit or group in order to gain control or power: [i]Partisan politics is often an obstruction to good government. Office politics are often debilitating and counterproductive. [/i]
All too many people either don't know the difference and/or substitute (knowingly or otherwise) one for the other.
An argument based on principle is usually (but not always) followed by an application of, or as applicable to, reality. While an argument based on politics is usually (but not always) followed by rhetoric.
Personally, I always try to apply both principle and reality to my arguments. I try to avoid the usual political rhetoric.
Examples of political rhetoric:
The rich are getting richer on the backs of the poor.
Bush is in the pockets of "big oil".
Examples of principled reality:
The individual owes it to both himself and society to accept full and total self responsibility.
Oil is a vital factor in both the American economy and the world economy.
Disclaimer: Yes, I know. I chose examples based on my "principled reality", or my "bias". Feel free to share your own.
Another disclaimer: "Bias", when based on "principled reality", is not a bad thing, especially if clearly admitted and supported. For example, my "bias" is towards less government involvement in social issues, not more. (Will anyone admit to having a "bias" espousing MORE government involvement in social issues? If so, admit it, rest on YOUR principles, and have a go at it WITHOUT relying on rhetoric.)
In my experience, the political left relies almost entirely on political rhetoric. (And the only ones who will probably disagree are the left-leaning among us.) However, how can the argument [i]"yes, it is right and proper to take the property from the person who earned it, so government can give it to a person who did not earn it"[/i], stand on its own merit? Personally, I've never even seen anyone try (except, of course, in cases of Mao's little red book or Marx's The Communist Manifesto) without relying, either in whole or in part, on political rhetoric.
And in regards to my previous example, [i]The individual owes it to both himself and society to accept full and total self responsibility[/i], how can the opposite possibly be argued with any semblance of merit without relying on the usual, tired and old political rhetoric?
Political rhetoric is intended to sway and convince by appealing to the emotional heartstrings of the listener. Political rhetoric is usually intended, to some degree, to deceive, because, in my opinion, the argument being presented can't stand on its own merits.
The man-caused global warming argument is dripping with political rhetoric, since it is neither conclusively proven nor universally accepted.
The war on terrorism (or, as I like to call it, the war with Islamo-Fascism) is dripping with political rhetoric.
The [i]"lied about weapons of mass destruction"[/i] argument is dripping with political rhetoric.
(The same disclaimers apply.)
Principled reality is intended to sway and convince by using facts based on reason and logic. Principled reality can usually stand on its own merits; and whether you agree or disagree with the premise of the argument, the worst case is that two people might simply agree to disagree. On the other hand, it's much more difficult, and in some cases impossible, to simply agree to disagree when presented with an argument based on political rhetoric, because it's usually based on a flawed premise, and the opposing argument gets side-tracked dispelling and/or pointing out that flawed premise.
Many people around here will take exception to this comment, but there way too few who can present a clear and concise argument based on principled reality, and way too many who rely, either entirely or in part, on political rhetoric.
People should present an argument like they might write a computer program. When you see two people going at it, going "round and round", never resolving an issue and/or not even agreeing to disagree, it's tantamount to an endless loop because of a flawed or poorly written computer program. One side -- or both -- relies more on rhetoric and less on principle. And that, my friends, will only result in the debating equivalent of the dreaded blue screen of death. It just won't compute.