Discussion Locked

Principle vs. Politics -and- Reality vs. Rhetoric

0 helpful
47 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
Definitions (From American Heritage):

Rhetoric: Language that is elaborate, pretentious, insincere, or intellectually vacuous: [i]His offers of compromise were mere rhetoric.[/i]

Reality: That which exists objectively and in fact: [i]Your observations do not seem to be about reality.[/i]

Principle: The collectivity of moral or ethical standards or judgments: [i]His is a decision based on principle rather than expediency. [/i]

Politics: Intrigue or maneuvering within a political unit or group in order to gain control or power: [i]Partisan politics is often an obstruction to good government. Office politics are often debilitating and counterproductive. [/i]

All too many people either don't know the difference and/or substitute (knowingly or otherwise) one for the other.

An argument based on principle is usually (but not always) followed by an application of, or as applicable to, reality. While an argument based on politics is usually (but not always) followed by rhetoric.

Personally, I always try to apply both principle and reality to my arguments. I try to avoid the usual political rhetoric.

Examples of political rhetoric:

The rich are getting richer on the backs of the poor.

Bush is in the pockets of "big oil".

Examples of principled reality:

The individual owes it to both himself and society to accept full and total self responsibility.

Oil is a vital factor in both the American economy and the world economy.

Disclaimer: Yes, I know. I chose examples based on my "principled reality", or my "bias". Feel free to share your own.

Another disclaimer: "Bias", when based on "principled reality", is not a bad thing, especially if clearly admitted and supported. For example, my "bias" is towards less government involvement in social issues, not more. (Will anyone admit to having a "bias" espousing MORE government involvement in social issues? If so, admit it, rest on YOUR principles, and have a go at it WITHOUT relying on rhetoric.)

In my experience, the political left relies almost entirely on political rhetoric. (And the only ones who will probably disagree are the left-leaning among us.) However, how can the argument [i]"yes, it is right and proper to take the property from the person who earned it, so government can give it to a person who did not earn it"[/i], stand on its own merit? Personally, I've never even seen anyone try (except, of course, in cases of Mao's little red book or Marx's The Communist Manifesto) without relying, either in whole or in part, on political rhetoric.

And in regards to my previous example, [i]The individual owes it to both himself and society to accept full and total self responsibility[/i], how can the opposite possibly be argued with any semblance of merit without relying on the usual, tired and old political rhetoric?

Political rhetoric is intended to sway and convince by appealing to the emotional heartstrings of the listener. Political rhetoric is usually intended, to some degree, to deceive, because, in my opinion, the argument being presented can't stand on its own merits.

The man-caused global warming argument is dripping with political rhetoric, since it is neither conclusively proven nor universally accepted.

The war on terrorism (or, as I like to call it, the war with Islamo-Fascism) is dripping with political rhetoric.

The [i]"lied about weapons of mass destruction"[/i] argument is dripping with political rhetoric.

(The same disclaimers apply.)

Principled reality is intended to sway and convince by using facts based on reason and logic. Principled reality can usually stand on its own merits; and whether you agree or disagree with the premise of the argument, the worst case is that two people might simply agree to disagree. On the other hand, it's much more difficult, and in some cases impossible, to simply agree to disagree when presented with an argument based on political rhetoric, because it's usually based on a flawed premise, and the opposing argument gets side-tracked dispelling and/or pointing out that flawed premise.

Many people around here will take exception to this comment, but there way too few who can present a clear and concise argument based on principled reality, and way too many who rely, either entirely or in part, on political rhetoric.

People should present an argument like they might write a computer program. When you see two people going at it, going "round and round", never resolving an issue and/or not even agreeing to disagree, it's tantamount to an endless loop because of a flawed or poorly written computer program. One side -- or both -- relies more on rhetoric and less on principle. And that, my friends, will only result in the debating equivalent of the dreaded blue screen of death. It just won't compute.

47 replies

by tony hopkinson

"In my experience, the political left relies almost entirely on political rhetoric. (And the only ones who will probably disagree are the left-leaning among us.) "

I could n't agree more with that point of view, let me start off by saying.

In my experience, the political right relies almost entirely on political rhetoric. (And the only ones who will probably disagree are the right-leaning among us.)

Tears in my eyes and coffee on my screen.

Point proven, case closed , achievement NIL.

by rob mekel

starting with "In my experience" followed by whatever statement, principle, rhetoric, politics or reality; is always right.
More to the point: starting a statement based on personal opinion, believes or whatever personal vibes (not meant in a mean way) is always true as you can't decline a person to be and having experiences. Or, to put it more direct, you can't argue with ones experience as they are his/her experience.

However your conlusion is right; achievement -> nil.

Rob

[i]Has Friday's YUK already started? I could need a laughter[/i]

by Member 25348569

Mar. 21, 2003 White House Press Secretary Ari Fleischer - "Well, there is no question that we have evidence and information that Iraq has weapons of mass destruction, biological and chemical particularly."

Mar. 22, 2003 Gen. Tommy Franks: "There is no doubt that the regime of Saddam Hussein possesses weapons of mass destruction. As this operation continues, those weapons will be identified, found, along with the people who have produced them and who guard them."

(I could go on for several pages but you get my drift...)

by maxwell edison

Those comments aren't rhetorical. Those comments were made by those people with 100 percent certainty they were true -- or they were, in the very least, thought to be true. If you define that as rhetoric, you and I are in different worlds.

To elaborate:

Neil: Man-caused Global warming is a reality.

Maxwell: Man-caused global warming is a myth.

Now Neil, I wouldn't consider either of those comments "rhetoric", but rather simply stating facts and opinions as we believe them to be. Worst case scenario, we can simply agree to disagree.

Rhetorical example:

Neil: Vote for me (or believe in me), because Maxwell, my opponent, wants to destroy the planet and kill millions of people and various life-forms, and see cities flooded and people displaced from their homes because he refuses to do what's necessary to stop global warming.

There's a BIG difference, Neil.

Back to your list. I could quote Tony Blair, Bill Clinton, Democrats, Republicans, news analysts, and so on with similar quotes. I could go on for volumes, not mere pages.

"If Saddam rejects peace and we have to use force, our purpose is clear. We want to seriously diminish the threat posed by Iraq's weapons of mass destruction program."
- President Clinton, Feb. 17, 1998.

"In the four years since the inspectors left, intelligence reports show that Saddam Hussein has worked to rebuild his chemical and biological weapons stock, his missile delivery capability, and his nuclear program. He has also given aid, comfort, and sanctuary to terrorists, including al Qaeda members ... It is clear, however, that if left unchecked, Saddam Hussein will continue to increase his capacity to wage biological and chemical warfare, and will keep trying to develop nuclear weapons."
- Sen. Hillary Clinton (D, NY), Oct 10, 2002.

http://www.jrwhipple.com/war/wmd.html

But like I said, stating a fact as you believe it to be is not "rhetoric".

By the way, Neil. Were ALL those people around the entire world wrong about this, or did the WMDs just vanish into thin air? OR, did Saddam, during the 12 month VERY PUBLIC build-up to the invasion, smuggle them out of Iraq into Syria or Iran (possibly with Russian or French help), and/or bury them in the desert? That's the observation and suggestion made by General Michael DeLong. And, as I mentioned in another discussion, that kind of information might be known, but is being "censored", for a variety of reasons, from becoming public knowledge.

Note: General DeLong defines "stockpiles" as a briefcase sized container for biological weapons, and a cargo truck sized container for the chemical weapons. And for reference, Iraq is twice the size of Great Britain. Could you hide a briefcase and/or cargo truck in G.B? Or if G.B. was primarily a land-locked country, take them across a border somewhere?

So Neil, in reference to the WMD issue that you brought up, will you answer the questions I asked? And try to do so without employing any rhetoric, now that you know what it is and is not.

by Member 25348569

What we always have to do with political statements is ascertain the BS quota (Rhetorical Index) in any statement.

It was you who suggested that those of us who tend to be suspicious of claims of the presence of WMDs in Iraq [b]at the time of the invasion[/b] are guilty of political rhetoric. I dispute that we are the [b]only[/b] guilty party and I would suggest that, quite possibly, we are not the [b]most[/b] guilty.

The simple facts from the perspective of myself and people of similar views is that we say "There are no WMDs in Iraq" and no WMDs have been found in Iraq. That does not seem to quite fit your definition of rhetoric.

The alternative: "There are WMDs in Iraq" and no WMDs have been found in Iraq strikes me as a fairly obvious RI problem for you regardless of how many General DeLongs you could hide in Syria.

A general point here on which we probably agree: the majority of statements by politicians are partly or completely founded on what they believe that the voting public need to hear to keep those politicians in office. Now we differ: in the case of the US government post-911, you needed someone to punish and Iraq was your target and you needed an excuse. I am suggesting that your pro-war politicians were a little less careful in examining the evidence than they should have been. They were less careful in their endgame planning than they should have been but that's another issue.

The [b]absence[/b] of WMDs is not down to me to explain. It is something that [b]you[/b] have to explain. Non-existent, buried or exported, they haven't surfaced yet.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/3718150.stm

I quite like the NY reader comment - " Saddam Hussein may be guilty of a number of dreadful things, but thought crime - is this a new legal precedent?"

by mjwx

Starting from the start

I wont dispute your definitions but I prefer (bias) a British dictionary like oxford.

Rhetoric is mostly hot air, mostly sometimes they reflect truth. Political (originated) rhetoric is the worst but you would sooner get a polly to do an honest days work than to speak the truth.

I will answer your two examples of rhetoric with pertinent questions you may answer or ignore at your discretion:

[i]"The rich are getting richer on the backs of the poor."[/i]. Are the rich getting poorer? how do the rich gain their wealth?

[i]"Bush is in the pockets of "big oil""[/i] Who does pay for GWB's campaigns? Do they do it out of the kindness of their hearts or do they expect favours?

The right uses far more political rhetoric. For example:
"Your either with us or against us"
"There is an axis of evil"
"There are WMD's in "
The word "Islamo-Fascism" is in itself political rhetoric of the worst kind and it also happens to be one of your favourite words. So I am going to paraphrase Apocalypse now and say "what is it when the fascists accuse the fascists" and I'm sure you know the rest of the lines.

[i]"how can the argument "yes, it is right and proper to take the property from the person who earned it, so government can give it to a person who did not earn it", stand on its own merit?"[/i] I much prefer to say "A portion of tax revenue should go to help the needy" Welfare for short, to help the disadvantaged of this dog-eat-dog society. Just to be humane rather than human for a little while. I find any-one who would say "Why must [b]I[/b] pay for welfare" is incredibly selfish, your not being asked for much and it means a world of difference to those genuinely in need (I don?t consider it selfish to deal with your own (US) needy first/only). To those who would say "Why must [b]I[/b] pay for welfare" I sincerely wish that you suffer the worst that society has to offer. Hold your noses in the air all the way down. My POV on welfare here. http://tinyurl.com/qprz2

Man caused global warming, well it sure as hell wasn?t the dolphins. We are at the top of the food chain, responsibility goes up. Man must take responsibility.

"Lied about WMDs" is political rhetoric but that doesn?t make it untrue. I prefer to say "the Bush administration deliberately misled people about the presence of WMD's in Iraq" Which is actually what happened.

Being a net admin, I would make things work and work well. I don?t have the luxury of controlling what I have to work with like a programmer (at least a lot less control), if I get a bad user or a Macintosh I have to work with them and make them work. This kind of analogy is better for the political systems and politics must have some awful admins.

Personally I am sick of rhetoric, I am even more sick of fear mongering. The Bush admin is trying to monger fear against Iran amongst western nations and their Iranian counterparts trying to monger fear amongst Middle Eastern nations against the west. [b]We have ultra right-wing nutcases who are trying to make me scared of other ultra right-wing nutcases who are trying to make others afraid of me[/b].

Meanwhile there?s me in the middle and all I want to do is RELAX, have a beer and watch the bloody footy in peace so give the rhetoric and fear-mongering a break. I would think a lot of people would echo these senitments.

by maxwell edison

.
From the [i]Oxford Dictionary[/i]:

Rhetoric: Language with a persuasive or impressive effect, but often lacking sincerity or meaningful content.

by Member 25348569

Can you give me an idea, phonetically, as I'm stuck with Dick VanDyke in Mary Poppins at the moment and I'm sure you can do better than that?

Jean-Luc Picard would be about right.

:)

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"Are the rich getting poorer?[/i]

Well, there are some people, I suppose, that we would call [i]rich[/i], who have lost some or all of their wealth, thus becoming [i]poorer[/i], but I've not seen any statistics in that regard. I'd bet a dollar to dirt, however, that most of them earn it back.

"[i]How do the rich gain their wealth[/i]", you asked?

Do you really not know?

Okay, I'll answer.

Some rich folks, like Senator Ted Kennedy, inherit it, never having to work a day in his life, like the rest of us, at a real job to earn it.

Some rich folks, like Senator and presidential loser, John Kerry, marry into it.

Some rich folks, like Bill Gates (or John Smith), actually earn it.

In a nutshell, however, if we eliminate the inheritance or marriage means of wealth acquisition, I would suggest that most people get [i]rich[/i] by providing goods and services to other people who are willing to pay for them. The more you offer, the more they pay, and the more you earn. Do it well enough, often enough, and long enough, and presto, you're [i]rich[/i].

The challenge, however, and the reason not everyone can do it, is to properly define the goods and services you provide, and come up with an effective means of doing so. Some people are actually convinced that they CAN'T do it!

But if a person realizes that very simple principle, and if a person is smart with the money he or she earns, it can be saved and invested so that the money is actually working FOR you; the magic of compound interest will add even more to one's wealth.

That's assuming, of course, the government allows people to keep the money they do actually earn. If not, and the government takes it away in the form of taxes, then perhaps not as many people have a fighting chance -- and ironically enough, they then have to depend on government.

Tax something, and you get less of it. Subsidize something, and you get more of it.

Tax wealth, and fewer people become wealthy. Subsidize dependency, and more people become dependent.

Personally, I don't think we should tax the rich because, as I said, we then get fewer rich people. And we want lots and lots of rich people. (Or do you really want to see fewer rich people?)

Instead, I think we should tax the poor. Let's literally soak them with outrageous taxes. That way, they'll avoid being poor like the plague, and perhaps actually earn their own living. Great idea, don't you think?

by tonythetiger

among the sources of wealth. Fact is, unless it's buried in someone's yard, it is benefitting the economy, and in any example I can think of, benefitting it more than anything the government does (Did you know it takes over $300 of tax money to give a family $100 in food stamps? Multiply that by 10,000 and you can feed 167 families for a year. Give it to an entrepreneur and he can create 167 [b]jobs![/b]).

As I think I've said before, today's politicians aren't really all that different than professional wrestlers. They pretend to be against each other when they're in 'the ring', but when the bout is over, they're best buds...

by mjwx

It will not work in this fashion. We've tried it before, just ask the Europeans. In fact I believe you yanks have fought a war because of this (independence).

If you don?t tax the rich you create a small superclass and a very large underclass in so doing eliminating the middle class. An underclass completely unlike the one's we currently have. An indentured underclass worse than serfdom and slightly better than slavery.

If people gain wealth unchecked then the extreme few will gain all the wealth. I mean less than 1% will control 99% of the wealth. Thus the middle class will cease to exist and you and I Maxwell will be little more than well treated slaves.

The Middle class gaining power was the driving force behind most of Europe?s revolutions. Take the French for example, Fighting the 7 years war and supporting the Americans during your (either civil war or war for independence, my memory fails me here) bankrupted the French monarchy. They increased taxes on the poor and middle class but not the rich. The rich were then sent to the guillotine by the arm of the people, most nations learnt from this. If we laps back into theocrasy we'll have another revolution and it very well may not be one for democracy.

Now as a new tax system (For all the other Aussies, I never supported GST but I'll admit when I'm wrong). Once you earn past a certain point ( for example $1 Mil for individuals and $25 mil for companies, Keep in mind these are just examples) you should just be flat taxed 30 or 40% straight off the top and loopholes should be left for those who could benefit from them (those in the middle tax brackets). That Maxwell is how you create more wealthy individuals. those on welfare are too poor to be able to benefit from such a tax scheme but they are not shafted by it also and I'll say again [b]I have no patients for dole bludgers, go and work for a living[/b]

Maxwell, I can tell you?ve never had to do it tough, born into middle class, have a good job. Yes you may have worked at macca's in your youth but you?ve never had to do a hard job. Me I've been a gardener, cleaner, unskilled labourer as well as an IT professional. Unskilled labour pays well but that is an exception to the rule. I?ve done the hard yards, low paying and menial work (been looked down on quiet a bit) and I'm glad to have gotten out (got a tertiary education and a good job) but others aren?t so fortunate. I don?t hate you for not having to do the hard yards but you do need to be reminded of how much you really have to loose. So max don?t look down your nose at the poor (working poor at least) because for the most part they didn?t choose it.

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"Who does pay for GWB's campaigns? Do they do it out of the kindness of their hearts or do they expect favours?"[/i]

An incredible amount of money is spent on political campaigns in the United States. I don't know what your guys spend in the land down under, but here, it's huge -- especially the presidential campaigns.

Who pays? You name it. Individuals and corporations both. And, believe it or not, it's not just paid to GWB's campaign. People and corporations actually contribute to BOTH major parties. Imagine such a thing!

I haven't looked it up, but I'd bet that both the Democrats and Republicans spent over $100 million EACH in the 2004 presidential campaigns. (And I won't even get into the new 527 organizations!)

You asked, [i]"Do they do it out of the kindness of their hearts or do they expect favours?"[/i]

Well, some might expect favors; some might expect that their agenda be advanced; and some might just like the person to whom he or she contributes.

What they "expect" and what they get, however, might be two different things. For example, I contributed to GWB's campaign, and I actually expected him to advance an agenda of smaller government in regards to social programs. Well, do I have egg on my face or what? On the other hand, however, if I contributed instead to John Kerry's campaign, and he actually did win, then I would have gotten even more "more government", not less "more government". Yea, I know. It might sound kinda' confusing.

Your suggestion, however, that GWB is granting "favors" (I'll spell it my way, you spell it yours -- the [i]Oxford[/i] way), is a great example of that rhetoric thing I was talking about. Thanks for sharing that example.

by mjwx

But if you were funding a polly wouldn?t you want him to pass laws favourable to you? Don?t answer, everybody knows it?s a yes (everybody with half a brain would answer yes to this question), I just want you to think about the question not the answer.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"The right uses far more political rhetoric...."[/i]"

First of all, your suggestion that [i]the right uses far more political rhetoric [/i] is just an opinion. I'd sure like to see you document that "finding" in totality. I might suggest that the "other side" does it more, regardless of which side one might fall. And I say that because people, including you and me, see the world through the prism of their own bias.

Your examples:

[i]"Your either with us or against us."[/i]

Yep, I agree.

[i]"There is an axis of evil."[/i]

Yep, I agree again.

[i]"There are WMD's in .[/i]"

Nope, that's simply stating a fact, or stating a fact as one believes it to be true.

But two outta' three ain't bad.

by mjwx

The right doesnt use more political rhetoric is an opinion. Politics is opinion based when it should be factual based.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"The word 'Islamo-Fascism' is in itself political rhetoric of the worst kind and it also happens to be one of your favourite words."[/i]

First of all, why do you consider it [i]political rhetoric of the worst kind[/i]"? Don't just say something like that, but explain why you said it.

My use of Islamo-Fascism, is in regards to naming this war we're engaged in, and it's something I picked up from someone else. I like it better than President Bush's "war on terrorism". After all, terrorism is a tactic, not a clearly defined enemy. And if we're fighting a war, which we definitely are, I'd like to call it something. This war, however, is different than wars of the past. During W.W.II, for example, we were engaged in a war against Germany and Japan, two clearly defined enemy nation-states. But the factions against whom we're fighting are not the nation-states themselves, but rather elements within many nation-states, including our own.

I certainly can't say that we're at war with all Islamic people, because that's not the case at all. And I can't say that we're at war with all nations with predominantly Islamic populations, because that's not the case either. However, there are Islamic Fascist element operating within many nations, and those are the elements against whom we're fighting, and to whom we should bring ultimate defeat. If you think that's "rhetoric", perhaps you can help me out. What do you call it? What should I call it? And who are we fighting? (Not to be confused with, who are YOU and others running from. And yes, for the record, that was rhetoric ..... but based on truth.)

Let's have a contest. What do we call this war? And try to call it something without using your own rhetoric.

And second of all, how do you know what my "favorite word" (or words) might be?

Julian thinks my favorite word is "disingenuous".

Oz thinks my favorite word is "core values".

In the context of these off-topic discussions, others might think it's "self-responsibility".

But no, my favorite word is probably "liberty".

You said, [i]"So I am going to paraphrase Apocalypse now and say 'what is it when the fascists accuse the fascists' and I'm sure you know the rest of the lines."[/i]

Nope, I have no idea what you're talking about. In fact, that sounded kinda' stupid.

by mjwx

is meant to inflame HATRED that is why it is rhetoric of the worst kind. Here in australia we lock up people like that. Jack Van Tongerin is a RacistBastard from my neck of the woods (West Australia) and has just been locked up [b]again[/b] for inciting (anti-Asian) violence. He was locked up the first time for firebombing 4 Chinese restaurants.

Terrorism is a Idea (tactic) that?s why a war on it is doomed to fail, wars cannot be fought against ideas (Ideas lack form so you can only kill supporters but ideas live on). Islamo-fascism is an idea to. Islam is the only thing you can (in the literal sense) fight a war against. This is debating semantics which is (whilst sometimes is fun) fairly pointless.

I think it is [b]one[/b] of your favourite words because you use it a lot. The saying "good sir" is one of my favourites at the moment and you may have heard me use it from time to time.

I thought you would have seen the movie Apocalypse Now. Here are the lines from the movie. It pertains to how the Vietnam War was run.

[i]"What is it when the assassins accuse assassin. They lie, they lie and we must be merciful to those who lie."[/i] Swap assassin for fascist and it applies to both sides perfectly.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]".....I much prefer to say "A portion of tax revenue should go to help the needy.....Welfare for short, to help the disadvantaged of this dog-eat-dog society. Just to be humane rather than human for a little while. I find any-one who would say "Why must I pay for welfare" is incredibly selfish, your not being asked for much and it means a world of difference to those genuinely in need (I don?t consider it selfish to deal with your own (US) needy first/only). To those who would say "Why must I pay for welfare" I sincerely wish that you suffer the worst that society has to offer. Hold your noses in the air all the way down. My POV on welfare here."[/i]

First of all, you live in Australia and I live in the United States. It's really pointless to debate each other's social issues. You can all pool all of your earnings, equalize outcome all you want, and sing kumbaya every night, for all I care.

Second of all, why do I always have to correct "you people" when you lump all government social programs into "welfare for the needy" category? Sending Warren Buffet a Social Security check and paying for his medical care hardly fits that definition.

Third of all, if you live in a "dog eat dog" society, perhaps you need a bigger dingo.

Fourth of all, you said, [i]"your not being asked for much..."[/i].

Actually, I'm not being "asked" for anything. I'm being TOLD that I must give, and give a lot. And it's for more than just "the needy". We are living in more and more of a collectivist society, and that's not only wrong, but counter productive.

Fifth of all, for you to define someone else (like me) as selfish, is selfish. You don't know any such thing about me. I would even venture to suggest that I GIVE more of my time and money to others than you do. Of course, it's pure speculation, since I don't know the first thing about you, just like you don't know the first thing about me. But my "giving" is in the thousands of dollars and hundreds of hours, each and every year. How about you?

Sixth of all, why is it "you people" are so willing to "give" other people's property? Giving comes only from within. Taking is what you're talking about.

Seventh of all, those kind of comments are the most ignorant and stupid things a person could possibly say.

P.S. "You people" is in quotes because "you people" all know who you are!

by mjwx

Which allow me to judge you in such a fashion. You would happily deny someone else the chance to the start you benefited from and that GOOD SIR makes you a disgrace of a person.

(spelling mistake: I would never judge anyone in "fusion")

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"Man caused global warming, well it sure as hell wasn?t the dolphins. We are at the top of the food chain, responsibility goes up. Man must take responsibility."[/i]

If global warming is happening, you need to go a little further up to find the cause -- about 93 million miles up -- TO THE SUN!

by mjwx

Crap goes down the ladder whilst blame goes up. Simple as that. Take some damn responsability the buck cant be passed any more.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]"Lied about WMDs" is political rhetoric but that doesn?t make it untrue. I prefer to say "the Bush administration deliberately misled people about the presence of WMD's in Iraq" Which is actually what happened."[/i]

If the definition of telling a lie could be to delibertly mislead, then you're just saying the same thing but in other words. How stupid is that?

President Bush did not delibertly mislead anybody. Feel free to disagree, but that's the absolute best you can do.

First of all, you don't know for sure if he misled anybody. Second of all, your "deliberately" is pure speculation. BECAUSE YOU'RE NOT A MIND READER!

You are telling THE BIG LIE about the big lie.

by mjwx

And no-one has evidence either to the contrary or of Actual WMD's in Iraq. Notice the GWB admin is suspiciously quiet about the WMD's in Iraq now. Max do you want to know the irony.

If you didn?t invade Iraq you would have unilateral support for any action in Iran. Hell you would have an entire Iraqi army ready to fight for you. You (US) didn?t choose your enemy very well, so its a good thing you have a better taste in allies.

by jardinier

To be on the far right side of politics is a greater degree of bias than to be moderately on the left side.

by maxwell edison

...on your point of reference and/or subject matter. To merely identify "left and right", as though there's some predetermined middle and all encompassing issue, is not necessarily indicative of anything. A proponent of the extreme form of collectivism, for example, would even consider our most leftist Democrats right-wing. And the most libertarian among us would consider President Bush left-wing.

If left and right were merely defined as more government or less government respectively, as it pertains to involvement in people's lives, then I proudly and freely call myself right-wing -- even extreme. However, if that's the case, then those who hold the exact opposing view must be, by definition, extreme left-wing. If you try to define some sort of middle ground and call it "moderate", you'll probably always be aiming at a moving target, and one that moves farther and farther away, probably to the left, as time goes by. Actually, I should say that it moves definitely to the left, unless you can name one government social program that has been either eliminated or significantly scaled back. They always grow. They never shrink. We are a much more leftist nation than we were 50 years ago. And nothing has ever been phased out or reduced in scope. I shudder to think what we'll be like in 50 more years. (Disclaimer: Of course, I'm speaking of the USA. I'm not as familiar with Australian government involvement into private lives.)

I find it interesting that many people have called me "far right", even though they don't take all things into consideration, nor do they really know that much about me. It's more indicative of their mind-set and their desire to pigeon-hole people, I believe, than it is descriptive of me and my views. I'm against the death penalty and in favor of legalizing recreational drugs, for example, neither of which is hardly a "far right" position. And although I'm generally not in favor of government social programs, I would compromise and concede a modest amount earmarked for the truly needy, again, hardly an extreme view (see note below). But no, I don't espouse government control over a national retirement system, or health care system, and so on. If you ask me, those things are EXTREME leftist ideas, first suggested in the United States by the Socialist and Communist political parties. I might be called extreme right-wing when calling for the systematic phasing out, and eventual elimination of our national retirement system (known as Social Security); but that was a very extreme leftist, and even socialist, idea as recently as 1932. Moreover, in that regard, how can you call a person who espouses self-responsibility for one's own life extreme anything?

I think the only issue on which I'm probably farther to the right than most is when it comes to America's sovereignty and maintaining a national defense that's second to none. I abhor the collectivist notions of the United Nations (something it was not designed to be, by the way), and I don't trust other governments to set aside their self interest in the name of any collectivist interest. All nations will act in a manner that's consistent with their own self interest, with no exceptions. The only difference, at least as it seems to me, is that people and leaders from those nations won't admit it. They try to advance their self-interest under the guise of some silly world-collective view. Get me as far away from that as possible. World trade, yes. World collectivism, no way. And regardless of someone's Polly-Anna wish for a world that gets along in total peace and harmony, that's about as far removed from reality as one can possibly be. When there are people in the world who want to destroy the nation in which I live, I want the biggest dog on the block, bar none.

Nonetheless, I've rambled on a bit, but I'm sure you don't mind. Getting to your comment, [i]"To be on the far right side of politics is a greater degree of bias than to be moderately on the left side"[/i], let me try to read into that. Correct me if I'm wrong.

I assume you might consider me to be on the far right side of politics, and yourself to be moderately on the left. If you consider me far-right, how did you come to that conclusion? And I'm sure you'll consider my "ramblings" into your comments. Moreover, I think the word "bias" can be used in many ways. For example, the definition of a "biased" news story (something we never discuss?) speaks for itself. However, you and I both have biased views, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. My bias falls in favor of less government, while another's might fall in favor of more government. What perturbs me is when people try to conceal their bias instead of admit it.

(Note on "...a modest amount earmarked for the truly needy...: This particular view holds true using today as a reference point. If we could, somehow, wipe the slate clean and start over again from, say, 1900, I would redefine my position.)

by jardinier

or any other particular person. So how did you read into my simple statement that I was comparing your political stance with my own?

Perhaps "bias" was not the best word to use as it can imply a deliberate distortion, although of course you did not read it that way. You read it, as it was intended, as a pendulum swing between extreme left (socialist/communist) and extreme right (fascist). And of course both these extremes meet eventually as they both lead to a totalitarian government.

It is quite pointless comparing American politics with Australian, as our "left-wing" party, The Australian Labor Party, dropped the word "socialist" from its platform some time ago, and is now much closer to the hypothetical "centre."

John Howard, on the other hand, is EXTREMELY right wing and has subtly changed the administrative branch of politics -- the Public Service -- to suit his own needs.

Believe me -- nothing would make John Howard happier than to see all social programs abolished, but he is a shrewd politician and has left the welfare programs largely intact, because he knows that he has to please (appease) voters from across the spectrum.

Like most things in life, politics has its ebbs and flows. Currently Howard is enjoying a long term in office (this year will mark his 10th) -- largely because the Parliamentary Labor Party is hell-bent on destroying itself through factional infighting.

But two decades ago the conservative party -- named by its founder, Sir Robert Menzies, the "Liberal" Party -- was in exactly the same position.

I have a rather simple but I believe valid theory as to why there will always be a left and right wing in politics.

In order for the individual to survive/thrive (right wing) the group must also survive/thrive (left wing.).

by maxwell edison

If you couldn't follow my message, differentiating between when I was serious and when I was joking, YOU ARE AN IDIOT!

Are you for real? It's no wonder you couldn't see a JOKE on your computer screen, you've been distracted by the JOKE IN YOUR OWN MIRROR!

For the record, jerk-off, I was not born into privilege. I was out on my own at 17, dumb as dirt, so broke I couldn't pay attention (another joke for the DENSE among us), with practically only the shirt on my back and the car I paid $300 for (I earned the $300 myself, by the way), and without a friggin clue as to how the world worked.

You're an absolute fool.

by mjwx

It's hard to tell. When I make an off beat joke I at lease leave a smile :) to let people know I'm not serious.

Second of all, I dont beleive you have ever suffered. Hardship marks people.

by jardinier

I have no idea whether Maxwell has ever suffered or not.

But I could hypothesize that his current beliefs might be a reaction to or compensation for some unpleasant events or suffering in his early life.

by maxwell edison

And if you think movies, especially ones like [i] Apocalypse Now[/i] are indicative of reality, you confirm my suspicion that YOU ARE AN IDIOT!

by mjwx

Figures, I didn't think reality was your thing.

I like movies like Apocalypse now because of a human factor, particularly when that factor is twisted, distorted and removed. Which is what happens in war

A good example of this is a BBC miniseries called ?the warriors? which is about a British Mech inf platoon in the Balkans and how they try to re-integrate into society afterwards. Kind of like full metal jacket in reverse with half the budget.

by mjwx

Doesnt make it so. When confronted with logic and reason you respond with an insult. I GOOD SIR will not stoop to your level.

by maxwell edison

To suggest that one person "take responsibility" for the forces of nature is the epitome of stupidity, arrogance and ignorance.

P.S. I changed my mind. In YOUR case, my favorite word is IDIOT

Julian, THIS IS YOUR COUNTRYMAN! I hope you're proud of him.

by mjwx

The amount of heat produced by the sun is increasing in [b]Geological time[/b] not by human (perceived) time. Geological time is on a scale of [b]millions[/b] of years.

It is a well known and accepted scientific premise that you can not live somewhere and not affect it.

I work in GIS (Geographic Information Systems) and I have 10 Environmental scientists in the building that tell me MAN is the key factor in global warming. All I have against is one ignorant American. You are up against 10 bachelors (of science) and 1 PHD.

Head in Sand, but even there you should notice that your arse is getting warmer?

by Member 25348569

"Head in Sand, but even there you should notice that your arse is getting warmer?"

I reserve the right to plagiarise this fine comment and shamelessly pass it off as my own. :D

by jardinier

is exercising the right of free speech -- which is practised in Australia without the need for a special amendment to our Constitution.

And if he gets up your nose, well I don't mind that either. It takes some of the heat off me. B-)

by maxwell edison

....seems far removed from reality. It's no wonder, really, since he admitted forming his opinions based on movies, such as Apocalypse Now. That's really sad if you think about it.

And no, he doesn't "get up my nose". (That's a new one on me!)

by maxwell edison

That sure is a tired old comeback. Talk about belaboring the obvious. Why do people always have a compulsion to cry [f]free speech[/i] whenever that [i]free speech[/i] is rebutted by another exercizing the same right. Of course your countryman can exercise his [f]free speech[/i], just as I can by calling what he says foolish.

Your comment, by the way, about the need for such an amendment in our constitution only shows your lack of understanding about it. But you have no need to understand it, since it doesn't apply to you guys in the land down under.

by mjwx

Smart Arse Comment Industry Association of Australia.

Feel free to plagiarise as long as I get 10% like any other artist :)

I'll give you the UK distribution rights.

by rob mekel

To be on the far left side of politics is a greater degree of bias than to be moderately on the right side. :D ;)

But then the bias could be in being moderately. :0

Rob

edited for format

by cactus pete

But you left out "time"

The earlier posts were a bit rosy for my tastes, which is what I was trying to point out.

This discussion is closed to new replies.