Discussion Locked

Project Mngmnt as a % of Dev. Time

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Is there an industry average for project management as a percentage of IT development time? For instance, if Development gives a high-level estimate of 1000 hours of development time, is there a percentage of the 1000 that you could use to swag the project management effort?

9 replies

by james r linn

Well a) Depends on your definition of project management and b) on your project.

Classical project management theory says that project managers manage tasks, budgets, schedules and resources. But in most projects, project managers also do a variable percentage of project planning, and often some of the analysis. While the classic model says they don't necessarily create the budget or schedule, in practise its almost always the case.

Successful projects spend more time than average in the planning and analysis phases - its always more efficient to find and fix deficiencies earlier than once development has started. This has always been a bone of contention - most people, including management would like to think they can skimp on the planning tasks.

One chart I've seen says you typically should spend 45% in Project Initiation and Analysis, 20% on Design, 20% on Development and Testing, 10% on Training and Implementation, and 5% on post implementation evaluation. Obviously the first figure can come down for simpler projects like migrating from one version of a db/application to another. But for a project to develop a new system where no system has existed before, thats a pretty typical ratio.

Hope that helps.

James

by daryl_f

James Linn gave a very good analysis of where the costs of Project Management (PM) typically are distributed in a project, but I suspect your question was more what % of the total cost of the project is reserved for PM. My gut feel on this is that there is a certain fixed cost associated with PM, and a variable cost related to the overall cost (size) of the project being managed. Small IT implementation projects may spend up to 20% of their total on PM, while large construction projects may allocate 5% or less to PM.

by tom.chambers

As noted by the others already, the percentage depends upon what the PM will do. If you mean the time the PM spends managing during development I'd say around 10-15% of the estimated development time. However, a more realistic percentage that includes overall management would be between 25-35%. At least from my experience. A PM who is involved on the 'front end' will consume a lot more time if they are part of the req/analysis team. Also, a PM who is the middle person between the client and your development team will consume even more time. These are factors that greatly affect a PM's involvement (time consumption):
a) what will the PM do and are they on the front end
b) what is the composition of the team? if you have a lot of 'rookies' then there will be more review of work during the development cycle
c) will the PM be the point of contact with the client?

One thing I saw work quite well was to have two folks handling the usual PM type work. The first is the point person. They call the client and get specs/info/clarifications etc. They also do the milestone demos with the client. The other 'PM' person is a true development manager. Assigning tasks, reviewing work, handling coding issues or design issues. We called the first person the Project Lead. The other is the Development Lead. Those two working in unison did well for most of the larger projects and gave both of them breathing room to do other things for the company.

Hope this helps some.

by sridharpandu

The industry average depends on the technology being used and the domain for which the project is being executed. The company that I work for has 8% for the project management effort for new technology (relative term, workflow is termed as new in our case) and it goes down to as much as 2% for client server projects. Currently I am leading a 112 member team developing various turnkey projects / products. One of the products is a trade finance solution for a large european bank, the solution is on Oracle Developer 6i and the domain is something that we know like the back of our hands (most of us have spent atleast 10 years in the financial services industry) so in this case we assumed a safe 3% of the total effort. This particular project is over 7000 Function Points and over 32000 person hours have already gone in. Now to arrive at a cost all you have to do is take the billing rate of the person who would be performing the PM role and multiply the number of hours. In this case 32000 *(3/100) * billing rate.

On the question if there is an industry standard for the PM effort the answer is that you should arrive at a standard for your oraganisation based on past experiences. Most of the methodologies - RUP, SDLC or for that matter KPA's of the SEI CMM LEvel 5 are non recommending. That is they allow the practioner to decide. However you could consult the PMBOK (www.pmi.org) if there is any such standard. I dont recollect any mention of a standard in the PMBOK. If you are practising Quantitative project management then your QPM plan which is part of your SDP should give you a percentage to determine the PM effort.

This discussion is closed to new replies.