Discussion Locked

Pro's/Con's of CEO installing spyware w/o employees knowledge?

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I am a sys admin for a small company only 50 employees. Over the weekend the CEO installed spyware on all the machines to track activity on the network, i.e.-E-mail, access to files, internet activity, etc. I was here for the install, but did not do the install myself. There was an outside company that was brought in to do it. The spyware is the kind that runs in the background. It was a "hush hush" install. Nobody in the company know's about it other than myself, the CEO and the company that installed it. Do you think this was the right way to do it? Not letting anyone know? The software itself has caused a tremendous amount of "lag" on our workstations. I have to keep my mouth shut as to why and just say "it's from the upgrade to a 'secure network'" I just don't feel it's right. Any of you have this experience?

18 replies

by jdmercha

I've always been of the opinion that if you can't trust you emplyees, then you shouldn't have hired them in the first place.

But if I were in your situation, I would first of all voice my objections to my boss. I would then remind users of the company policy on computer usage. And remind them that there are always ways of tracking computer usage, such as temp files, history files, and cache on their computers, as well as traffic reports from routers and servers.

by oz_media

As an employee of a company yu must ALWAYS understand that the company reserves the right to monitor ALL usage of their investment. This includes reviewing outbound email, written correspondence and internet usage.

Some companies do this automatically for ALL employees, some just flag a suspicious employees actions.

Either way, whether you feel it is MORALLY incorrect or not is irrelevant. The company holds 100% right to do this without warning at any time they choose.

There is NO issue of privacy rights being infringed upon, it is their equipment and they can monitor whatever they want without your prior consent.

If they have called in an outside company, they have obviously been sold a network monitoring service/package and will probably get tired of paying for it after a little while, you never know he may have even been offered a free trial service to see what he thinks of it. Either way, it is the companies perogative to do so anytime.

You have done the right thing by merely keeping your mouth shut, sharing such knowledge is very easy grounds for immediate termination without notice.

You COULD tell the boss you feel wrong about it and perhaps suggest sending out a reminder of the computer policies, but if they are against the idea be prepared to just clam up.

by amcol

Hard to believe there's anyone who doesn't understand that public access and corporate computer systems come with no expectation of privacy. Having said that, I also understand your moral indignation at the stealth method of installation.

The CEO (who, remember, is in charge of and responsible for overall corporate performance) had every right to install this software. It's more typical for professional organizations to do so in a more public fashion...put a disclaimer of some kind on the initial splash screen with a "no expectation of privacy" warning.

My advice...seek new employment. Company culture emanates from the top, and your way of doing things (which I applaud, BTW) is inconsistent with this organization. People who don't trust other people are themselves not to be trusted.

Why would you want to stay in such an environment?

by hal 9000

Firstly if the company has a computer usage policy in place which all workers have signed they are within their rights to do this.

If they do not have a computer usage policy in place the CEO is treading on some very thin ice but provided that this is just used for research purposes to frame a computer usage policy it again is quite all right.

The one worry is that the installed software is slowing down the system which just should not happen with any half way decent monitoring software. From what you have posted & what I've so far read it sounds to me like a "Trial" copy of a program that they have either offered for free to work out the bugs or it is just for the CEO's personal gain example having a monitoring program in place which he isn't paying for until he either decides that it is worth the money spent on it or is a waste of money and man power to constantly monitor the thing. Either way the system needs a major upgrade to limit the Lag periods which should not be happening.

Col

by packratt

The CEO is more than welcome to install spyware on my workstation if the CEO is willing to let me install it on his workstation as well. ;)

by afram

Aren't there legal issues with that? Better check with the local laws.
As I understand it, any monitoring must be declared to the company employees BEFORE monitoring can begin.

I think it's best practice to announce it clearly in policy. As soon as someone find out, you can be sure they will be VERY untrusting of you and the CEO.

by dafe2

Like anyone else that's going to answer you, I'm sure we've all monitored and where asked to look through E-Mails and all the rest...distasteful part of the job really. Anyway, what's different here is the owner chose a "Monitor" rather than an "Investigation".

IMO he or she is looking for something or someone and wants privacy while he's doing it. While this is unorthodox, it's not illegal & for whatever reason he / she kept you at a distance.

Support them by keeping quiet and being respectful. I'd also keep a fresh copy of my resume at hand if I where you. CEO's don't usually wake up one day and decide to monitor the network so intrusively because they're bored.

Whatever trigered this shouldn't last long and at the END of it you'll likely get an explanation. I'll bet you'll (probably) get a hand delivered "invitation" from a Judge to explain that you did NOT know of the presence of the monitor.

However, if it goes on forever so to speak, look for another job. Your CEO has turned into a nosy clerk, not the leader they should be.

If this were a "legit" monitor the CEO would NOT be doing it. The CEO would ask YOU to implement it and write the policy. The employees would have full knowledge of it's presence at the very least. Something's up.

by evinjhill

I do appreciate all the responses. I know that the CEO has the right to do with his company and equipment as he so pleases and that it ultimately falls on his shoulders if someone is using the systems in a non-productive and business oriented manner. I didn't know what software was installed until I ran my Spybot Search & Destroy software. It's not "true" monitoring software. It's spyware and a hacker tool to log keystrokes and take screenshots of the desktops. I'm still at odds over this. I understand the business reasoning behind it all, but as everyone has stated, the trust issue is at odds with me. I feel there are other ways around having to "spy" on employees. As stated in other posts, if you can't trust them, they shouldn't be employed. I thank everyone for your replies.

by oz_media

YOu have elaborated oin the type of tracking that is installed, this leads me to wonder if a customer has complained of either information tampering, poor service or perhaps even malicious information being sent from an employee.

IF the CEO had asked you to install this on ONE person's system, the suspicion would rise and perhaps YOU are in cahoots with teh problem employees, how is HE to know? The best way to fo this without singling out a person is to install it as a blanket service. He may only actually be monitoring or interested in a single suspected users activities for legal purposes.

However, many companies write these policies now, NONE that I have ever worked for and some of the monitoring has been extreme. They are not obligated to remind you of the law surrounding thier freedom to access and review all information leaving the company, it is a courtesy offered to those of who wouldn't know otherwise for some reason.

If yor company is not acting morally as you would like, leave them and find another, it's not hard in most cases. I would hang tight though and see exactly what unfolds, for all you know he had soe hacker friend show him how to retrieve info and he will get bored with it or realize it is worthless o him, OR someone's malicious activity will be exposed and it will all make sense as to WHY it was done that way.

If YOU aren't doing anything wrong, which you are not in THIS case, why not just smile until payday and then smile until the next payday. Quitting because someone else is under suspicion just seems a little insane.

by bob in calgary

If he has uinstalled a keylogger on the systems he's just blown any chance of a successful termination. The keylogger will capture userids and passwords of all users therefore any good lawyer can argue that the integrity of the user accounts has been compromised, which means you can't prove any information attached to a particular user. Tell him he's blown his investigation, If he wants to play computer cop he needs to hire someone who can do it correctly, Depending on where you are located he has probably broken privacy laws so he could be the one in big trouble.

by oz_media

You gotta remember though, this isn't someone plotting to fire Bill Gates. Employees usually will not drop the cash needed to find and pay a decent lawyer in such cases, it's just a lost income at this level I'm sure. PLUS, most lawyers wouldn't even consider taking on such a case unless in a very with a very esteemed corporate opportunuty to further their career.

Having a corporate lawyer in the family myself, I hear about all the IDIOTIC cases where people try to sue major corporations over $80,000/yr jobs that aren't contracted past a standard employee contract with the company.

This person may just be surfing porn or sending out resumes on company time. Perhaps something got back to the boss from another company and he is just assuring the validity before saying bye bye to the employee.

Either way, they will most likely just lose a job and move on, disgruntled employees rant and rave about rights and laws and make noise but when it really comes down to it, they just take a pissed off atitude to the next employer.

But your story was much more exciting to ponder!

Have a good Christmas.

by bob in calgary

Small companies are probably different but the larger ones would be in serious problems over something like this, The joys of the privacy legislation are only just starting.

Have a good christmas, A high of -24 on Boxing day! time for movies and beer, after I feed the animals Brrrrrrrrrrr.

by aceskaraoke

It's too bad that these extremes would ever have to be considered, much less implemented.

A couple of rotten apples can spoil a REALLY big barrel.

I am hard-pressed to blame the supervisors either, the abuses of company assets and resources by employees can sometimes be more than can be believed.

Hope this was warranted. I don't know how quick to bring in an outside company to spy on my employees I would be.

by oz_media

I just finished blabbing with a friend in Ft. St. John (-37 with the windchill) brrrr, but she seems to deal with it for now.

The news tonight showed really crappy weater everywhere, I am starting to feel guilty because it was absolutely gorgeous today, sunny and clear.

Texas has it rather nasty, TO is yucky, etc., but the maritimes and west coast are surprisingly nice this winter.

Oh well, light a fire and pour a drink while enjoying the holiday.

by bob in calgary

My automatic waterers have blocked up or frozen so I need to wait till spring to dig up the lines which means that in the meantime I need to haul water by hand(well snow mobile or truck) for all the animals as well as feed them, It turns a 30min job into a 2 hour job. When the high is around -20's we get a wicked wingchill as there is nothing in between us and the mountains to the west and the longview pass so we can get winds up to 100Km per hour. Last year the wind blew our 25foot travel trail sideways 12 inches. Well it could be worse at least I won't be behind a computer.

by hal 9000

Just think of it this way tonight you could be on a yacht sailing to Hobart in not so great conditions.

At least it would be warm even if you did have a very strong breeze coming up behind you to help fill the sails.

Of course when you get to Bass Straight all bets are off as it can either be a smooth passage or all Hell breaks loose you just never can tell what is going to happen on that stretch of water.

Col

by oz_media

YOu can see a storm hitting the island LONG before it gets there, you get a lot of notice.

When I was camping in Kananaskis, Alta. you could have a heat wave and withing 1 minute you'd get hail the size of gold balls. I reme3mber watching the army evac people by the chopper load after getting nailed from the hail there.

Within a half hour, the swealtering heat was back and just trickles where the hail melted. VERY unpredictable and pretty wierd really, but that's the ALberta valley I suppose. All in all, one of the greatest places around though, Kananaskis country, now THAT's a spectacle to see!

by awfernald

And a court of law may be the one who decides or not.

As with e-mail, in a case such as this, if you have not been given a policy stating that your every keystroke is going to be recorded, etc.... then you have a reasonable expectation of a right to privacy.

However, if the company has a clear cut policy that states that all computer usage can/may be recorded INCLUDING the utilization of key press tracking/recording, remote screen capture, and various "other" methods, then the employees have no expectation of having privacy, and thus, they cannot complain if they are misusing company equipment.

The biggest thing I see here is that there should NEVER be a case (except when a legal authority is gathering evidence for a CRIMINAL case), where an employer makes this type of change in a covert fashion as if they are out to catch their employees doing something wrong. In the best case scenario (i.e. the owner/boss isn't an idiot), these tools should be advertised to DETER wrong-doing, and of course, to prosecute to the appropriate extent, violations that were not deterred.

This discussion is closed to new replies.