Discussion Locked

Q&A - rating should HAVE to be complet or auto

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

FIRST, a post should not be able to be concedered "Answered" if there are still answers that have not been rated. Ideally I would like the $#^%#$$% poster to be conciderate enough to at least deny answers that don't work, but realisticly if any posts are "not rated" when a post is marked Answered, then AUTOMATICLY bump all not rated to denied.

Also, some prompting of a user to put in what resolved their issue if it wasn't based on what the posters recommended.

The last point would be, anything over a year old should automaticly CLOSE with a note that it was timed out or something, and deny all answers. Anoying to have so many answers sitting as "unrated". Would much rather have it moved to timed out or something. The at a glance you just know it wasn't a problem with your answer, it was a problem with the @#$%#$%en poster.

Last ides, a post of shame for people who have opened multiple Q&A's and then never bothered to close them out.

14 replies

by house

This has been a topic of much discussion. People don't rate answers, they reject valid solutions, they offer up 10 points for a $10,000 solution...

What are we gonna do? Just don't respond to rude people... there has to be a better way. Maybe we should block yahoo, hotmail, gmail, etc...

by jdclyde

If someone joins TR (I know the price is steep) and have to actually use their REAL mail, they may be people more likely to stay around.

I can deal with the low points, as I choose if it is a valid request before posting. But when they can't even bother to rate one way or the other is real frustrating. When it shows 2/3 of your answers are unrated, grrrrr. Like I said, even a timed out rating would be better.

by jaqui

but I would say do not allow closing the question with unrated answers and do not allow closing with all answers rejected.

they do close questions due to inactivity, but not sure how long it takes before that happens.
when closed due to inactivity they are all accepted unles user has rated as unacceptable/unhelpful.

by jdclyde

I thought that first, then thought if they are to lazy or inconsiderate to rate answers they problably would not bother to close them if they had to actually DO something to close it.

I would rather have a delined than unrated, but that is just me. At least I know SOMEONE read it.

I was roaming through the list the other day and thought I saw ones from 2001 that were still open?

Question on points, if someone is new and doesn't have any points, how can they award points? Is maybe that scaring them from rating people?

by jaqui

some at least, just by signing up.

probably just not clear how to use the system for new users.

I agree that a rejected is better than ignored completely.

by smorty71

This is definitely something we are looking at improving. You touched on a couple of the things we were considering:

1. Auto-closing or removing questions or discussions that have no answers or posts after a certain period of time. We get a lot of sessions from Google, so I imagine that finding a thread that only has the question can be disappointing.

2. Highlighting users who don't close questions. We just need to determine the criteria for that.

As for free e-mail accounts, I think we need to focus on promoting better forum etiquette before we ban free e-mail accounts altogether.

Thanks for your ideas.
sm

by bfilmfan

Frankly, I liked the Demerit idea. If someone can see that this person has 100,000 demerits for opening questions and never accepting answers, then no one will bother answering them.

Although, The Worm of the Week has been a fun way to give out a 1000 points and I am SURE woken up a few...

by willcomp

When ya'll finally get around to flagging deadbeats, how about making them standout so everyone can tell at a glance. One way would be negative points, another would be user ID in red or some weird color pattern.

Anything's fine as long as it's easy to tell so we won't waste our time. If deadbeats don't receive answers, maybe they'll quit posting.

Another problem is the one time user. Signs up, asks a question, and is never heard from again. Seeing a lot of that lately.

I know, I know, ya'll are trying. We just want you to try harder and faster.

Dalton

by house

Put their picture up on the homepage like some dilinquent account.

A rating is a good idea. If I remeber correctly, I think that the Q&A reputation meter was a much discussed idea a few months ago, 'pre' activity meter release. There was an idea that was tossed around that would display a 2-3 tier meter on a member's profile.

by jdclyde

one color for deadbeats
one color for newbs
one color for member in good standing (he said member)
one color for the extreamly gifted among us that shine oh so bright. (adds to credibility of answers given?)

for the deadbeats, go a step further and replace their avitar with someone getting whipped or spanked.

by jaqui

or the deadbeats, go a step further and replace their avitar with someone getting whipped or spanked....

maybe not a good idea.. after all that might get me all hot 'n bothered.

by deepsand

1) Create an escrow, into which a no. of Tech Points are deposited, proportional to both the no. of points offered, and the no. of unrated answers. Escrow points would be returned to one's available point total only when an answer was rated;

2) Failure to rate an answer within a prescribed period of time would result in the forteiture of the appropriate proportional amount in escrow to the respondent whose answer went unrated;

3) In the event that the question expired, with unrated answers, the entire remaining amount in escrow shall be equally divided among all who answered, without regard to whether or not any answers were rated;

4) Repeat offenders are required to offer an ever increasing minimum no. of points in exchange for a satisfactory answer; and,

5) As a prerequisite to posting a question, one must provide a working e-mail address, and allow peer-to-peer messaging; no more hiding in the shadows.

by jdclyde

Only allow a member to have a few open questions at a time.

If answers are not rated, the question is not concidered closed for this purpose.

If they want to ask a new question, they now have a REASON that affects THEM on why to respond to people.

And of course some check that they don't just deny all answers and move on.

Combined with the escro idea and a real mail to register, even if that isn't the one you use to recieve notices with. It can and should be hidden.

This discussion is closed to new replies.