Discussion Locked

Question to all the Liberals -- Instead of Bush bashing, provide solutions

0 helpful
86 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

If I am the average American looking to vote this November, why should I pick you Mr. Kerry? What would you do to keep American people safe and secure? How would you do it differently? What are some of the exact solutions you would provide? What is your stance on domestic issues such as Tax care, medical benefits, education, Terrorism (international as well as domestic).

I am all ears. Please, any liberals looking to contribute, please feel free, I would love to hear what you have to say about these issues. Instead of Bush bashing, why don't you provide some constructive solutions on these real and important issues?

86 replies

by garion11

Because if you are a liberal, you should know answers to these important questions. You should have some kind of solution. I am not just talking about Kerry, but the left overall SHOULD have something constructive instead of this constant criticism.

If you do have something, I wanna hear it because in order for me to debate something I need to see your side of the story/solution/answer etc.

by cactus pete

...just present your understanding of your side, and let the debate begin?

Do you have all the answers to those questions for whomever your candidate is? And did you happen to get those answers from his website, or do you just intuit them?

by admin

To me that seems like the best choice thus far. We'll see as it gets closer, maybe something will sway me.

:)

by stress junkie

One problem with government is that no single person
or political party has all the right answers. When it
comes to the Congress then the party is more
influencial than the individual. On the other hand when
it comes to the Presidency the individual is more
influencial than the party. The Republicans address
some issues pretty well most of the time. The
Democrats address different issues pretty well most of
the time. They're all subject to human weaknesses that
the press blows out of proportion.

I supported the current war in Iraq from the outset. I
also believed that there were no WMDs there. I believed
from day 1 that the war was to avenge the attempt on
Bush Sr.'s life and to clean up the loose ends left by
Bush Sr. I recognised the current war in Iraq as a
family feud issue from the start. But I also believe that
Sadam Hussein had to be taken out of office. I further
believe that the United States HAS to kick some butt
from time to time because most of the time we look
weak in global politics.

As for voting I'm never happy with the choices offered
by the two major parties, so I always vote Libertarian.
Aside from agreeing with much of the Libertarian Party
platform I also see voting for them as a vote of no
confidence in the two principal parties.

I've got my stick in hand. Where is that hornet's nest?

by garion11

What I have are questions, cause all I see is Bush bashing from the Democrats and the immediate populace. Since we already KNOW where and what Bush is doing (or we claim we all do) I'd like to hear the OTHER side of the story. WHAT WOULD YOU DO DIFFERENTLY? HOW would the liberals protect America and her interests? Whats the stance on Domestic issues? Give me specifics if possible, like cost, man power etc...

Please give me constructive solutions, I really don't care for Bush, lets just assume he is a lying sack of shi*. So now, lets hear your side of the coin/equation. I am all ears.

by cactus pete

From what side ARE you coming? I'm not actually interested in arguing FOR Kerry against anyone - but I might argue against something I truly don't like. So, if you don't like Bush, who's your man? What are YOUR positions, and that of your chosen candidate?

I just don't think it's fair, cool, or whatever, to say "I don't like Kerry - someone come here to argue him with me." Go ahead and throw in the parameters, not necessarily all the details at this point, and maybe then someone can more intelligently debate.

by thechas

If I do vote for John Kerry, my primary reason will be that John Kerry is NOT George W. Bush.

I personally hope that an alternate candidate comes onto the field.

It's NOT that I am a liberal, or that I hate George W. Bush.
It's not even that I believe that John Kerry has a better plan for the US.

The main reason that I cannot bring myself to vote for George W. Bush is that I do not TRUST the man at ALL!

As I have stated previously, since we are in the middle of our efforts in Iraq, we must stay there and finish what we started.
We need to maintain a presence as long as the Iraqi government wants / needs us there.

Realistically, in the short term, it is not possible either politically, or physically to cut the Federal budget enough to bring it into balance.
The first thing that needs to be done, is to rescind the portion of the Bush tax cuts that were targeted to INDIVIDUALS that earn over $200,000.

At the same time, we need to recognize that businesses do NOT pay taxes. Any taxes levied against a business are passed on to the consumer.
We need to move away from taxing businesses, and shift the entire tax burden directly onto the individual.
The primary advantage to sticking with an individual income tax is that we each get to see what government costs us.
With sales, vat, or businesses taxes, you never realize just how much you contribute to running the country.

Welfare needs to change.
The primary goal of welfare needs to be job and skills training.
Rather than cash payments, welfare recipients should receive the specific goods and services needed.

As part of moving people off of welfare, the minimum wage needs to be at least 20% above the poverty level.
We cannot continue to provide healthy people with welfare benefits that exceed what they can earn working a minimum wage job.

We may need to extend Medicaid coverage for 2 to 3 years for people that move off of welfare into low wage jobs.

On a similar bent, the prison system needs to change.
Anyone sent to prison for 5 years or more MUST earn their GED or high school diploma before they become eligible for parole.
Anyone in for over 8 years must complete at least a 2 year college program or trade school.

As i said, I am all for dropping taxes on business activities to 0 provided the business operates in a socially responsible manner.
Social responsibility would include.
Pay all employees a living wage.
Meet or exceed ALL current pollution limits.
Offer (not necessarily pay for) health insurance to ALL employees.

On health care costs in general, we need to place some restrictions on mergers.
Companies must NOT be allowed to borrow money to pay for a merger or acquisition of a competitor.
I am convinced that a large factor in the rising cost of prescription medications is related to the cost of competition reducing mergers.

Next, we need to review preferred cost plans that insurers negotiate with providers.
At a minimum, the lowest negotiated rate needs to apply to ALL users of the health care service.

Then, to help small business afford the cost of health insurance, rates must be set regionally.
If GM negotiates a $100 per month per employee insurance rate, that same rate and coverage must be available to all businesses in the area.

On terrorism, we need to beef up our foreign intelligence operations significantly.
Our leaders need to have up to date "factual" information so they can make informed decisions.

Chas

by oz_media

I was not actually going to enter into this discussion as I am not a voting American but since reading your post I was quite surprised that many of your ideals reflect exactly what I see in Canada. I am not blowing my horn, nor am I saying we have exactly what you want, but we see the same alot of the same values. I just kept thinking 'we have that here' while reading.

Here's what I mean:

>"The primary advantage to sticking with an individual income tax is that we each get to see what government costs us.
With sales, vat, or businesses taxes, you never realize just how much you contribute to running the country"

Well we do have several almost hidden taxes or 'double taxes' but in many ways, we are completely aware of how much tax we pay (WOWSERS!!). We used to have an 11% federal tax automatically included in prices, this was ditched for the questionable Goods And Services (GST) tax at 6% that was added at point of sale. Low income citizens get a quarterly rebate cheque on GST taxes (about $300.00/yr).

For the most part it is all income tax that we get nailed with here, especially in British Columbia (it's like we pay extra for the view, but that's ok I because it's a nice one). Our government taxes everything, then taxes us for using it, disposing of it etc.

Taxes upon taxes, but I am aware of 'most of' them and still see the rewards in Medical and other government services, although many crown monopoly's have now been deregulated for Canadian privatization.

Our budget balanced last year, the year before that and so on, Cretien spent money wisely, or at least as wisely as you could expect a politician to spend tax dollars.

We could have gained from a slight increase in military and hospital funding (thanks to our Liberals playing money games) but for the most part I see a good deal of my money being used to better my personal life directly as well as helping others.

When I injur myself (which used to be often)I get immediate attention from happy people with only your best interests in mind, not money or selling medical services but genuine help. For this I am proud to be in Canada, there are many people in many countries in the world that are less fortunate than me.

In a nutshell, we all bitch about paying taxes upon taxes but we deal with it because we see where it goes.

>"Welfare needs to change.
The primary goal of welfare needs to be job and skills training.
Rather than cash payments, welfare recipients should receive the specific goods and services needed.

As part of moving people off of welfare, the minimum wage needs to be at least 20% above the poverty level."

Exactly, people here often complain because welfare doesn't pay them 'enough', after rent and food, they have almost nothing for the rest of the month. Well this is pure crap because it is not their job to provide you with 'quality of life' you haven't won a court case, just housing and food support.

The welfare check for a single person in BC is about $575.00 month (barely higher than pensioners who have worked and paid up all their lives get, this bothers me that we don't cater to our elders). The average rent for a one bedroom suite in a Vancouver suburb is $550.00, this means a roomate at least to help with expenses, not easy street. Welfare will pay your rent directly to the landlord if you prove questionable or incapable of managing, they wil provide food vouchers if neccessary and also bus fare/pass and rebates for workboots etc. used when starting work, not looking for it.

General Minimum wage in BC is $8/hr
Welfare is approx. $6.79/hr or 15% less.

Welfare is barely enough in most cases to stop them comitting crimes to make ends meet but it is effectively NOT making it easy to live on welfare while not letting those in need really suffer.

Most places a younger or unskilled person would normally seek work, fast food, retail etc. will start you at $8.50 and give you $9 to $9.50 shortly after a probationary period.

So there is incentive for someone on welfare to get a job, as well as mandatory job clubs, resume and interview skills training and worksheets to prove your job search to your welfare worker.

Everyone here bitches about "welfare bums" but it's only those that take advantage of or cheat the system that bother me, the system itself is great even if there is some room for improvement, as there always is in a changing economy and society.

Your prison training ideas? Absolutely fantastic! We don't have that but what a great idea.

Medical costs, anyone earning less than $30,000.00/yr in BC gets Premium medical assistance at $34.00 fixed rate. My own is only SLIGHTLY higher and yet my income is a lot higher than minimum, those on welfare are covered automatically of course.

Focus on increasing foreign intelligence is another great idea that any nation would benefit from. I am unsure of our military soending here but I know we invested a tonne in the Coyote Recon vehicles, surley that counts as foreign intelligence. :-)

Great post Chas, may the best man win and do some good for you all. I think you're in too deep to leave now too, you'll be there for at least another year or so anyhow.

Hopefully enough people have seen the other side of the whole issue and a better choice (whomever it may be) is elected this fall, yet at this point you must remain in Iraq at least until it is stabilized however long it takes.

by garion11

How come the the Democrats don't say this?? on HOW they are different and What specifically will they do in this country if they get elected? All they ever say Bush this Bush that, constant Bush bashing.

Thank you Chas, I don't agree with you, but atleast you provided constructive solutions to the national issues at hand. Thats a lot more important than voting for someone because HE/SHE is NOT BUSH.

by skipperusn

I can accept that - but now he has selected a first term running mate - that has zero experience at anything in government. If something would happen to JFK (Oh shit) you would have John Edwards as the Pres. He has no foriegn policy - he has no experience at handling foriegn or local affairs -

So thats what I was waiting for - now that he has select someone with Zero experience in government (first term senator - first time at anything in government - was a lawyer) I will vote for GWB.

I also wish there were bettern canidates to run - but we have what we have - at least GWB handled 911 correctly - and got the economy back on track. Even if the democrates don't think so - but 750,000 new jobs (that aren't Mcdonalds) have been created in the last 7 months...

I will take someone that has had successes over a Flipper that can't formula a decision without changing it depending on who he is talking with.. And an Inexperienced VP... Of course the people that don't matter (Non-Americans) will think different - but they don't count - uptill they are under attack or need money - then they beg the USA to send Aid...

by garion11

that we obey them like sheep and send them aid and money. I am getting sick of these wackos who thinks USA owes them something.

by maxwell edison

.
And I can't say that I really disagree with too much, at least in principle. We may want to try different ways to achieve the same thing in some cases, and you and I have conversed enough for you to know on which points we would differ, but very well said indeed.

On your voting for Kerry just because he's not Bush, I might suggest you reconsider and vote for the person who might best advance the agenda you just laid out. If it's John Kerry, then so be it. If it's GWB, well, hold your nose and pull the lever for him.

by maxwell edison

.
At least this is how I would see them.

Point 1: You said, "As I have stated previously, since we are in the middle of our efforts in Iraq, we must stay there and finish what we started. We need to maintain a presence as long as the Iraqi government wants / needs us there."

Since John Kerry has been so adamantly against the war, one could certainly surmise that his heart wouldn't be in bringing this to a successful conclusion. Planting the seeds of liberty in the middle east is the bigger the goal here, it will take a "steady course" for many years to come, and we have to move forward as though this is the right thing to do. On this point, the man to get the job done is George W. Bush.

----------

Point 2: You said, "Realistically, in the short term, it is not possible either politically, or physically to cut the Federal budget enough to bring it into balance. The first thing that needs to be done, is to rescind the portion of the Bush tax cuts that were targeted to INDIVIDUALS that earn over $200,000."

Let's put this one on hold.

----------

Point 3: You said, "At the same time, we need to recognize that businesses do NOT pay taxes. Any taxes levied against a business are passed on to the consumer. We need to move away from taxing businesses, and shift the entire tax burden directly onto the individual. The primary advantage to sticking with an individual income tax is that we each get to see what government costs us. With sales, vat, or businesses taxes, you never realize just how much you contribute to running the country."

This is almost right out of the Republican handbook. This obviously would have a better chance of being achieved under a conservative platform. After all, the Democrats literally demonize "big business", and want to regulate and tax them dry. This point goes to George W. Bush.

----------

Point 4: You said, "Welfare needs to change. The primary goal of welfare needs to be job and skills training. Rather than cash payments, welfare recipients should receive the specific goods and services needed."

Republicans

----------

Point 5: You said, "As part of moving people off of welfare, the minimum wage needs to be at least 20% above the poverty level.
We cannot continue to provide healthy people with welfare benefits that exceed what they can earn working a minimum wage job. We may need to extend Medicaid coverage for 2 to 3 years for people that move off of welfare into low wage jobs."

Democrats love the welfare system. It's their system. They conceived it, they gave it birth, they fed it, they nurtured it, and they turned it into the bloated pig it is right now. And they want to expand it even more. One has to surmise that it would only grow bigger under Democrat control. I'm not sure about your minimum wage increase, however. If you feel so inclined, compare Americans in "poverty" to Europeans. You'll discover that a person living in "poverty" - as defined by (whomever defines it) - today, is about on equal footing with the average middle-class European. The doom and gloom picture that people try to paint is misleading at best. The "war on poverty" has been a Democrat party failure for the past 40 years. This issue goes to George Bush.

----------

Point 6: You said, "On a similar bent, the prison system needs to change. Anyone sent to prison for 5 years or more MUST earn their GED or high school diploma before they become eligible for parole. Anyone in for over 8 years must complete at least a 2 year college program or trade school.

I don't know who this would fall under. I'd have to read up on the candidates' position on the prison system.

----------

Point 7: You said, "I am all for dropping taxes on business activities to 0 provided the business operates in a socially responsible manner. Social responsibility would include: Pay all employees a living wage, Meet or exceed ALL current pollution limits, Offer (not necessarily pay for) health insurance to ALL employees."

Since the Democrats would NEVER drop all business taxes, this easily goes to GWB.

----------

Point 8: You said, "On health care costs in general, we need to place some restrictions on mergers. Companies must NOT be allowed to borrow money to pay for a merger or acquisition of a competitor. I am convinced that a large factor in the rising cost of prescription medications is related to the cost of competition reducing mergers."

This is a great point. Restrictions on mergers might, I must admit, fall into the Democrat's camp. I'm not sure, however, if it would achieve your desired goal, and I'm not enough of an economist to form any opinion.

----------

Point 9: You said, "Next, we need to review preferred cost plans that insurers negotiate with providers. At a minimum, the lowest negotiated rate needs to apply to ALL users of the health care service."

I really don't have an answer for the rising costs of health care in America. In theory, I'd like to scrap the whole system and go back to everybody pay for yourself as you go. Medical costs were always under control and quite competitive until someone else, other than the recipient, started to pay for it. But I fear we're too far committed to turn back. What I don't want, however, is a national health care system, as the Democrats have proposed, because it just makes a huge and out-of-control system even bigger. And personally, I don't want the federal government to control one-third of our economy.

Republicans on this one.

----------

Point 10: you said, " Then, to help small business afford the cost of health insurance, rates must be set regionally. If GM negotiates a $100 per month per employee insurance rate, that same rate and coverage must be available to all businesses in the area."

Same answer as number 9.

----------

Point 11: You said, "On terrorism, we need to beef up our foreign intelligence operations significantly. Our leaders need to have up to date "factual" information so they can make informed decisions."

John Kerry voted against every "pro-intelligence" bill ever put before him. This is easily one for George W.

----------

The score:

Democrats and John Kerry - 1 (maybe)
Republicans and G. W. Bush - 8
Unknown or needs more research - 2

There ya' go. Even if the 2 unknowns went to the Dems, which is no certainty, the scales easily fall to George W. Bush.

If you really want this agenda, GWB just might be your guy. (Do you want me to send you some nose-plugs?)

by thechas

While I fully agree with your logic and deductions, I still don't know if I can bring myself to vote for GWB.

Thanks for the offer by the way, but nose plugs won't make the difference.

I am seriously considering a 3rd party candidate (not Nader this time), or just skipping the Presidential election portion of the ballet and concentrating on the other races and issues that will be on the November ballot.

Ever since our first discussion on the topic, I have been trying to determine just why I do not like or trust GWB.

So far, I have concluded that something about GWB was bothering me from the start of the 2000 primary season.
The back to back speeches that I have referred to only served as the trigger point, confirming my gut feeling.

I will continue my introspection, at least up until the moment of casting my vote this November.

My mind is not closed on this subject. So, we'll see what happens.

Chas

by admin

If you don't want to vote for Bush and want to see change in those directions, I am curious if you would Consider Voting for Michael Badnarik.

:)

by thechas

As to our dependency on foreign oil:

There is no need to establish a hydrogen economy.

We do not need another Manhattan or Apollo project.

We have the raw materials we need right in the Mid-West.

Ethanol and Bio-Diesel can be the answer to our energy needs.

Once we make a national commitment to switch to a renewable energy bio-fuel, we will need to protect what is left of America's farmland.
Developers will need to switch to the inner city, and non-tillable land for new opportunities.

Fuel made from corn and soybeans would not require any new technology breakthroughs to get off the ground.
The only hurdle to bio-fuel is creating efficient processes to convert the raw materials into fuel.

On the car and truck manufacturing side, the primary issue is changing a few elastomer compounds used in the fuel systems, and changing the engine tuning.

Sounds win-win to me.

Chas

by admin

If it was good enough for our forefathers it's good enough to grow and burn in my car. It grows like mad with little care in the Midwest.

BTW for those of you who would snicker, it lacks THC- the active ingredient that exists in Marijuana. Hemp is not a drug.

by pctech

I agree with much of what you say here, Chas, and would love to comment on each point. Due to the late hour, I will restrict my commnets to one point.
While you are correct that any taxes placed on business is a fee passed along to consumers, you are niave if you think any such tax savings would be passed on to employees, consumers, or even shareholders. This just doesn't happen this way. Not in today's corporate methodology on doing business. This simply is not their modus operindi.

by thechas

I agree that I would not expect business to automatically reduce prices or pass any savings on to shareholders.

What reducing business taxes would do is make US companies more competitive.

Hopefully, allowing companies to be more competitive would result in more jobs in the US.
Or, at least fewer jobs moving off-shore.

In my panacea, the reduction of business taxes would result in sufficient new employment to offset any lost government revenue from reducing the business taxes.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
...I would be shooting myself in the foot, since he doesn't even have a snowball's chance (in hell) of winning.

One must ask, therefore, which of the two candidates who DO have a chance of winning come closest to this guy?

There ya' go.

(Hint: It ain't John Kerry.)

by maxwell edison

.
...I would be shooting myself in the foot, since he doesn't even have a snowball's chance (in hell) of winning.

One must ask, therefore, which of the two candidates who DO have a chance of winning come closest to this guy?

There ya' go.

(Hint: It ain't John Kerry.)

by admin

Sure, I understand that in one way you really might as well vote for someone that can win. On the other hand I have talked to SOOO many people who have said that. In my quick non-official estimate of people I have talked to, over 10% of voters would vote for Michael Badnarik if they thought he had a snowballs chance of winning.

Now, if all of those people actually voted for him would he win? No. But would they win as voters? YES! Why do I say yes? Well it is because if ANY candidate gets over 10% of the vote, the media will pick it up and both existing parties will start to lean as much as they can in the direction of that voting population. A vote for Bush or Kerry ensures the current system will continue as it is. A vote for Michael Badnarik will, however, send a clear message that there are people in America who want change of a specific type. Even though he will not win, the Republican camp for sure will look at what the trend is and how many people voted for him and where possible they will try and lean that way to capture future voters. In this way I believe that my vote will actually count for MORE than a winning vote for Bush would. If it was going to be a close election, I may think differently, but I see no possible way Kerry will win anyway, so a vote for Michael Badnarik is my best possible way of getting attention for truly Libertarian issues and a leaner government in Washington.

My candidate may not win this battle, but every vote towards the Libertarians will help win the war- even if it just gets the other parties back on track. To me, many votes for Michael Badnarik most probably means a better Bush administration- and that's worth my vote. :)

by maxwell edison

.
Admin - I absolutely understand, I truly do. But it's the old "catch-22".

On one hand, the Libertarian Party cannot become a major player without a lot of real support. But on the other hand, a trickling of support from year to year might (probably will) result in a person's LEAST desirable candidate being elected.

But should a person vote with his heart, or vote with his head?

When the Libertarian platform starts to receive some serious consideration among the voting public, or when the Libertarian Party starts to win a number of seats in the US House or the Senate, I'll reconsider. (Of course, it's the same "catch-22" here as well, because we, or at least I, don't want the Democrats to become the majority party in either chamber of Congress.)

You see, I personally blame myself for Bill Clinton getting elected in 1992. I accept full and total responsibility. It was I who did it. No one to blame but me. I was a sell-out and a fool. I let my emotions get the better of me. My reason took a vacation. By better-judgement took the day off. My logic became scrambled. Why? Because I voted for Ross Perot - just because I was ticked off at George Bush Sr.

It's called cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Never again. I learned my lesson.

by maxwell edison

.
You know, I might be wrong here, but I would think that the best chance for a strong Libertarian movement in America would come from a split of the Republican Party. In my opinion, the Republicans are really no more than "baby Democrats", especially when it comes to social and domestic issues, and there may come a time when a rather large contingent of Republican lawmakers get fed up and split from the party.

I think that would be the best way to shake up the political landscape. With such a split, especially if they picked up the existing Libertarians and a good percentage of independents, we might then see a strong three-party system instead of just two.

Speculation, of course. But I really don't see it happening in my lifetime.

by garion11

This is what a liberal/democrat voter posted on another site with the same question.
After this answer I said I'd vote for him, (Ethe poster, NOT KERRY)why?? Because at least he gave a frigging answer, He didn't Bush bash. He was constructive and provided solutions. I don't necessarily agree with everything he says, but HEY LOOK, HE SAID SOMETHING.

" 1. Put the American Public on a True War footing, instead of this ?don?t worry?go shopping? cra.,p.

- Put a true alert system in place ? the one we have is a joke and too passive ? need to access and redefine the Emergency Broadcasting network ? when we hit ?orange? we should do more then ?look for strange things or behavior:?and shop?. Model it after the weather warning system ? complete with preparedness education and drills.

- Place a ..05% use tax on gas or utilities to fund homeland security and the War on terror. Nothing gets an American engaged and paying attention like having to pay a new fee or tax. Right now we have a zip less fcuk??gov spending off the charts, tax cuts?unless you?re in the service ?you got zero sacrifice. This money can also be used to cover cost of needed investment in military personnel noted below. Might not be enough?.and it is certainly not a one time tax.

- Provide tax incentives for conservation of war related resources?.purchase of fuel efficient cars?.home technology?business technology.

- Establish $50 billion dollar bounty to HAVE an alternative fuel source in the next 10 years. Incent the American public and business to get this done in 10 years. $50 Billion is a start. We need a Manhattan Project like effort. Enough fcuking around.

- Screen middle school children for select skill sets in math, language, medicine, tech, computer, engineering, etc?..endow their education to work in those fields?.cover all costs for school and associated living expenses with a 5 year hitch in government service (Military, FBI, CIA, NSA, NASA) at the end of that education to bring a continuous stream of needed skills to the war on terror. If they bail out on the deal?.they get 4 years in the infantry.

Military:

1. Immediately begin increase the size the US Military by twice its current size through increasing pay (15% in all ranks?25% combat Arms?...35% in specific skill areas?.Special Forces) by 2010...and maintain that force level.
2. Increase military retention bonus?s 50% for select skill areas.
3. Lower from 20 to 15 years the minimum service requirement for pension qualification. Rise the 20 year pension % amount from 50% to 75% of last highest pay grade.
4. If this doesn?t get the needed numbers?.draft?.4 years ?.3 if you join?.zero exemptions. Provide for alternate domestic service for 4-F and CO?s.
5. Implement a new GI Bill which not only cover the cost of all post service education for all vets? but will allow access to a no interest revolving loan fund for the college education for all child of ex military . This program will also be used to help start businesses and provide tech training to vets.
6. All children of KIA soldiers or those with 50% or more service related disability go to college?any level?free. PERIOD. WE DON?T TAKE CARE OF OUR OWN?we need to keep that promise.
7. Invest in the airlift ability in order be able to move 2 Infrantry, 1 Armored, 1 Air cav, and One logistical Army divisions anywhere in the world in 72 hours within the next 7 years....this has huge costs.
8. Increase our Special Forces troop levels by 200% in the next 7 years and maintain that force indefinitely.
9. Reverse the trend started by Clinton and endorsed by the GOP to increase dependency on Reserve and Guard units and private contractors for military support functions?.that was down to fight short hitter wars like Gulf War I and Kosovo to hold down long term fix cost (pensions, dependent housing/healthcare, etc) ?.we ain?t in that sort of war and we need a professional support arm?it takes 6 soldiers to put one guy behind a rifle?they deserve the best.

Intelligence.

1. Nothing short of a Cold War level of human source based intel will do. This war is going to last the remainder of my life time?get in the Mideast and start recruiting kids now to be our agents of the future.

Doctrine:

1. No more NATION BUILDING. We have a problem nation ?.roll it?or slap it....don't move in and pick up the overhead of cleaning it up.....help the UN do that....save the Marshal Plan stuff for after we are on waaaayyy on top and have the resouces to do the job.

2. State it now?..If we are hit ---- a spit ball..a plane.. a WMD.. we will respond with ANY weapon ?up to and including a Nuke of our choosing?.on ANY suspected site or host nation??.considering how bad our intel has been?this might get some of these countries to cooperate in order not to be hit in a case of mistaken identity. We have no true deterrent now?.you hit us?we invade (and you use it for recruiting and open season on our troops)?Fcuk that...don't make martyers.....make converts..... You hit us?we kill everyone in your neighborbood to get you?will engender cooperation from the neighbors too. Unfortunately, we?ll need to do this at least once to make believers out of them and reap all manner of world condemnation. We've done the Hearts and Minds deal.....but we all now...the grab the balls and the mind will follow is the only thing we've ever been good at.

3. Include cooperation (criteria to be established) in the War on Terror a requirement for receiving Make Most Favored Nation trade status.

That?s a start. sloopy and way lacking in detail.....?and before you say ?you?re not a liberal??.give a good listen to Kerry ?he?s said or bordered on saying a great deal of it the last two years."

by nd_it

I am not a left wing or right wing, but even though I think GWB is not the best candidate, I think he is the best candidate for the present. The biggest thing I look for is leadership, and I think Bush has that skill whether people agree with him or not. There are times I agree with him and don't agree with him. I do like John Edwards though, a man with values and convictions, and a good running mate for John Kerry, however, I don't think he has enough experience in politics to change the election much, but he does have a skill of debating. He has experience as a trial laywer of drilling CEO's (watch out Cheney!). Hell, Bush will only have four more years left, then the Democrats will put who they really want in office, another Clinton! Just think, first Bush Sr, then Clinton, then Bush Jr, and Clinton?? I am sure I just opened a can with that statment. :)

by maxwell edison

.
You know, in my observation, Dick Cheney is one of the smartest, wittiest, most well-versed people in policy issues, and is one of the most articulate vice-presidents we've had in recent memory. Whether you like him or not, or agree with him or not, I think one has to admit that when he's giving a speech, answering questions from the press, or in a debate with his counter-part, no one can "shoot from the hip" better than him, no one has the depth of knowledge that he has on a wide range of issues, and no one can come across as well as him. I haven't had a lot of exposure to John Edwards, only what I saw during the Democrat primaries, but if he's as good as you are suggesting, I'd pay money to see the vice-presidential debates. But my "betting" money would be on Cheney to get the best of Edwards.

You forget that Cheney was not only the CEO of a major corporation, but also a US Congressman from Wyoming, a White House Chief of Staff, a Defense Secretary under Bush Sr., and, of course, current vice president. Moreover, his wife, Lynn Cheney, is an expert educator and speaker. The Cheneys are a couple of extremely smart cookies.

My guess is that Dick Cheney will cause the lesser experienced John Edwards to crash and burn.

by nd_it

Nothing against Dick Cheney, I forsee his experience as a politican (he does have quite a resume) will outweigh John Edwards. Sure, Cheney is a great speaker, a little monatone as times, but able get his point across. I am just comparing the candidates in that John Edwards has a lot of experience speaking as well being a trial laywer you need to be able to speak and get peoples attention obviously, but probably not the broad political background Cheney has.

by pctech

... And that is why I am putting this here. There was no room on the other thread.

You suggested that tax cuts for General Motors Corporations helped finance a "move" overseas. You also inferred that the "move" was to save money making Cadillacs for the American consumer. I suggested that it was not a "move" overseas, but rather an expansion overseas - an expansion that's both reasonable and understandable, at least from the perspective I articulated. I further suggested that it was not to sell to the American consumer, but rather the Chinese consumer. Do you agree or disagree with my rebuttal? Do you agree or disagree with my conclusion?
********** I told you that I understood the econmics behind it. Rather it is a move or an expansion is nothing more than symantics. The point remains the same. GM to spend $3,000,000,000 in China. The rest of that post was to show a different perspective other than the economics and I stated as such. Do you doubt that the tax cuts did not help finance the new plant in China? I lack proof of such but, the tax cut did help finance this to one degree or another.

You suggested that the overseas profits made by General Motors were not being brought back to the USA. However, we did agreed on this, but I offered a viable solution to solve the problem. Do you agree or disagree with my conclusion?
********** No, what I said is that the money will stay where it is needed. I have no doubt GM would bring the money here, if it was needed here, even if it is taxed when they do so. What was your conclusion? May I guess? Do not tax the money when they bring it back. Would this be your conclusion? Should this be the case, the answer remains the same. GM will leave the money where the money is needed and even if they brought it all back, unlikely, it would be for the simple reason they will not have to pay taxes on it? Anything for the dollar, right, Max? If it makes money, it should be legal? Anything that inhibits profits should be cast aside? There are no costs associated with the country you choose to do business in? ... Too many questions, Max? I will condense this to one question. Is there not a cost to doing business based in any country?

You didn't address these initial issues, but rather made the jump (for whatever reason) to China attacking Taiwan and preparing for a war with the USA.
********** The "jump" was just another example of why I think it is a bad move for GM to spend $3,000,000,000 in China and build a manufacturing plant there that could be sequestered and used against us later. This was all to bolster the same the point. ...... A question to all. How many of you have knowledge that China wants to take back Taiwan, with force, if needed? How many of you are aware that the US has vowed to prevent this from happening, with our military, if needed? ... Long nap, Max?

How about not getting ahead of yourself, and address the initial points - one's that you brought up initially. Or, if you want to tie one to the other, go for it. But don't forget to answer the "thefore what" question.
********** Which, "therefore what" question?

by admin

How interesting. I thought that one would be close and it was the only Presidential election I did not vote Libertarian.. Ironically, I did not think that the last race would be close. :)

I will continue to try and gain popular support for the Libertarians each year though, and someday perhaps it will be possible that a vote from your heart will also be a solid decision for the rest of you! :)

by admin

to some extent. I find this interesting.

Basically it seems that if you want less goverment and are in any party then Libertarian can be a good choice. Of course more personal freedom and less government intervention requires people to accept differences on a personal level without demanding that the government intervene. Because of this, there has been a lot of growth from the edges of the unsatisfied Democratic party as well as the unsatisfied Republican party this year. I see more of a split between Libertarians on the one hand. Pro big government conservatives (Yes, I think those exist now) and pro big government liberals would then be on the other two parts of the other hand.

The Democratic party is really already barely holding together and "split" in many ways IMO. The Republicans are publicly more together for the vote , but there is a lot of dissent, especially on how much government should be cut.

I think the Libertarian party is the only party capable of uniting people on a return to the American values of "Governing Best by Governing Least". I don't see this as a splinter from the current Republican party per se, but as a split from an increasingly bloated system.

by oz_media

Is it the people who power California? The people who's forests you log? The people who waters you fish? Who is it that is asking for a handout and help from you?

by hargerd

As US has the largest economy in the world, one would expect the dept burden to be higher than other nations.
Time to stop bringing up the ?begging bowl coffers? script whenever the country is in for a bit of criticism (whether warranted or otherwise)

by oz_media

although you were incertain so you left it as an open statement. You mentioned before that Canada NEEDS the US, that you give Canada money and protection. What money and what protection do you give us that is not given back?

the US relies on Canada for a LOT of its resources, it also relies on Canadian military for its resources and more advanced recon and humanitarian trained troops.

Contrary to what you believe, you are NOT the worlds providers, people don't run and hide under America's skirt when they are scared. That is just what you are lead to believe.

by oz_media

Yes I snickered and I knew exactly what you meant. THey actually have had hemp forests where they are literally 40'+ trees in a neatly rowed forest. Hemp clothes are actually a thousand times stronger and longer lasting than the synthetics and even cotton clothing we wear (no they aren't all brown like potatoe sacks :-) )

They only thinkg I can see not flying well (no pun intended) if cars burned hemp;
In BC, everyone would bypass the 'low THC hemp' solution and would be burning the world famous BC Bud instead as it is cheaper andmore abundant. It would be interesting to see how it effected air care rules and the complaints of heavy smog in the city.

It would certainly slow the pace to say the least!

Anyhow, just having fun, I think it's a great concept and many hemp stores are flourishing here as they seem to be popping up everywhere. Clothing, teas and whatever all sold under the sweet scent of incense. We always look back in history to learn our lessons for tomorrow,why is it that often it is the most logical lessons of history that we overlook in the race for synthetic solutions ? If it wasn't for synthetic drugs, hemp and marijuana would still be legal.

by komplex

First, this is really the first presidential race of my adult life in which I've had a very strong commitment about which major-party candidate was the lesser evil. I've had leanings in previous races, but they were uncertain, and typically mitigated by a sense that both major-party candidates had crossed some threshold of unacceptability. This time, it seems very clear to me that the Bush Administration has failed basic tests of competence in policymaking and execution, and of trusteeship of long-term interests like alliances and trade negotiations and moral credibility. I expect to dislike an awful lot of John Kerry's policies. But I don't expect that kind of failure of the basic responsibilities of the office. Four or eight or twelve years ago, I guess I wouldn't have known how important I found those considerations, as I hadn't seen a president who had failed along those dimensions. Now I have, and I do.

http://volokh.com/archives/archive_2004_07_00.shtml#1089132048

by admin

I believe the bloggers particular use of Kantian ethic is greatly flawed when he says: "Third, and most important: I find that this year I can't actually will the universalization of an LP vote" due to his unhappiness with George Bush and his eagerness to get him out of office by any means possible. There are also those Libertarians who are taking a similar stance and voting for Bush because they can't stand the thought of Kerry winning.

The problem here is that if these actions were truly universally willed then it would weaken and ultimately destroy the Libertarian party. This is the exact opposite of what Kant meant and to me is a fallicy of the "ANYONE AGAINST THE BAD GUY" mentallity. The point of democratic elections is not to be in continuous revolt of any leadership, the French revolution spoke to that. The point of democratic election is to vote according to your wants, needs and beliefs which, if in majority or significant minority will be considered by those that need to operate in our system of checks and balances once elected. The point is to have a voice by having a vote, and I want my voice heard. It is not a voice for the bloggers values to vote for someone out of fear, it is a nod of the head to the status quo, a loss of a voice in effect.

I agree with the bloggers self appraisal when he states: "At some level this is silly, of course. I could vote for Badnarik in complete confidence that my vote wouldn't put him into office, and I'd never have to worry about it again. But I do try to vote as if my vote would be decisive, irrational as that is."

He IS being silly, over-idealistic and irrational IMO.

I am voting for Michael Badnarick believing that he won't win, but also knowing that my vote will have more influence to bring about my needs, wants and desires in my government more than any of my other choices. This is a rational and logical conclusion which, if universally willed would bring about needed fundemental change to restore our government. I also believe that with a larger Libertarian showing we will get better Libertarian candidates over time. It's a two way street, top potential leaders will be more likely to flock to the party as it strengthens, and voters will more likely flock to the party as top potential leaders come to it. I encourage those who are dissatisfied with the current choices to strongly consider voting Libertarian and if we continue to double every year we WILL be in Washington soon.

by komplex

I find it silly that small government Libertarians would vote for Bush after the last 4 years. On Bush's watch we've seen the government expand on entitlement programs, erode Civil Liberities, privacy, an interventionist international policy and a growing theocracy. After 8 years of the Clintonian Fiscal responsibility, it boggles the mind why Libertarian would vote for Bush.

With Kerry in charge and a hostile GOP Controlled congress, spending is going to be controlled and the old GOP Civil Libertarians will get their backbone back and fight for the President.

The author is saying that it will be very dangerous to the United States to have Bush in power because of his complete disregard for common sense. He doesn't like Kerry, he knows he disagrees with Kerry on many issues, but he knows that Kerry can do the basic stuff.

You are subscribing to the chemotherapy version of you let the Republicans really screw everything up then millions will reject the "Deficits doesn't matter" Republicans and escape to the Libertarian Party. It's a risky bet, Liberals made that 4 years ago and we are still kicking ourselves over that decision.

If you want another 4 years of what we've been through, then by all means vote Libertarian.

by brandon_usa

I'm very pleased to see everyone in this room discussing politics and government. It's very important that everyone votes, and it's so nice to see technology friends engaged in the democratic process.

I'm a liberal democrat, and if you don't hold that against me, then I?d say my post is efficient. :) I really feel that most of you have a bad opinion of Liberals, and for whatever reason you are entitled to that. The centrist Democratic Party by far does not represent my personal views, but they are the closest thing I believe we have to electing a strong leader.

Let's just face it; the Green party isn't ever going to elect a president. :) But the most compelling part of my liberalism is my deep passion for social liberty, above all else. I am a gay information systems student. And, in my personal struggles, I'm very glad that there is one thing that links liberals and libertarians together, and that's our common dream of social liberty.

Thank you for reading this post, but more importantly, even though our economic views are polar opposites, many democrats, like myself, touch base with libertarians on fiscal responsibility.

The Democratic Party, the green party, and the liberal left are your friends of civil liberties. Are core social libertarian values second place to conservative economic policy? I sincerely hope not. No matter what your positions are, just Vote. Each vote does count (Florida 2000). :) Thank you.

by sullyman

Interesting post, and an even more interesting dilemma. We had a very similar situation here in Canada, and once again he Liberals remained in power. In most cases when the opposition is fairly unknown and not clearly stating it's platform, people would rather vote for the devil that they know, than the devil that they don't. The liberals here in Canada, have ( in my opinion ) done nothing except to strain Can-US relations and bring down our stature in this global economy. At the same time STEAL 100 Million from the taxpayers to give to advertising and marketing agencies in one of our provinces, and most of that made it back into their parties coffers. All this is going on during the election campaign, but the opposition was a newly developed party ( a combination of two parties ) with a young leader that had no track record. So the population voted in the DEVIL that they knew - instead of the devil that they didn't. I think you will see something very similar happen in the US, just an opinion....

Cheers

by garion11

I agree, people like familiarity. They hate to have things change on them. Imo, this Democratic party of today is hurting itself by aligning with the loony extremist leftist people of Michale Moore nature. Its a shame that they are not the parties of JFK (Ask not what your party can do...) and Truman. They are leaving so many people/families without a voice by doing what they are doing (by not contributing positively).

by admin

Yes, you right about that. Most everyone says we should be doing something different, complain about the way things are, and yet are afraid to do something unknown.

I was in a foreign country a while ago and got a shoe shine from a nice young kid that carried his kit up and down the sidewalk. He asked for the equivalent of about 50 cents in local currency and since I wanted to tip him well but was short on local currency, I offered him a ten dollar US bill instead. He threw a fit and insisted that I shouldn't try to rip him off after the fine job he did. He got his 50 cents after that.

Go Figure.

by admin

That is why cancer patients choose it so often.

If anyone really believes that "Not Throwing Your Vote Away" means that your candidate must have some chance of winning then we all better vote for Bush.

by pctech

Chas,
I am sorry for the long delay in making this post.
Let me comment on your hopes, one at a time.

"the reduction of business taxes would result in sufficient new employment to offset any lost government revenue from reducing the business taxes."
I wish this was true. There will be NO significant job creations until the market demands require a company to hire any new employees. Hiring simply because you have the money to hire is a bad business practice and any hiring will be limited to business needs, not just business dollars. The days of keeping the "fat" have long since died and trimming the "fat" is still the standard business policy. As it should be. Consumer demands drive hiring policy, not tax cuts. While companies will have more monies for hiring, through tax cuts, is not an indication that they will hire. Even if they did, where will the hiring be done? Logically, this happen in the countries where the manufacturing facilities exist. Foreign based employees, ever increasinging, do not add to our tax rolls and thus there is no gain to alleviate the loss of tax revenues from companies. Result, a net loss of tax revenues. Should hiring be done stateside, the emphasis is on lower wagers, not higher wages. Lower paying jobs, or even stagnant wages, will not compensate for the loss of tax revenues from companies.

"allowing companies to be more competitive would result in more jobs in the US.
Or, at least fewer jobs moving off-shore."
This is not a likely scenario. Shareholders demand the greatest profitability of the company. This usually comes from outsourcing to other nations and/or building plants in other nations. Major investors look to companies that have already done this or plan to do so in the near future. Inspite of recent major tax cuts to corporations, GM has announced it is spending $3,000,000,000 in China for a new manufacturing facility and many of the future Cadillacs will be built there. Obviously, tax cuts have not detered their decission to move overseas. Tax cuts, more than likely, helped to finance this move. What is worse, monies corporations make overseas are never taxed here until the money is brought back into the US. Where do you think the money is going to stay? Even if you eliminate this tax, the money will stay where it is needed.

"I agree that I would not expect business to automatically reduce prices or pass any savings on to shareholders."
Now, we are at the crux of the problem of making US companies tax free. You also left out that tax cuts to companies will not necessitate higher wages to their employees. What would be the result of this? You had suggested that individuals offset the the loss of tax revenue dollars through higher personal taxes. Let us look at the real costs associated with this plan. Consumers will not be likely to see a reduced price at the checkout stand, employess will not be likely see higher wages, and shareholders will not see much of the capital either. MAJOR shareholders ( major investors and company officials )are more likely to gain from higher stock prices than are minor shareholders as they will not fare nearly as well. Certainly not enough to offset their new higher individual taxes. We end up with everyone making approximately the same wages and paying the same prices for goods while given the extra burden of taxes that companies no longer pay. This is not a win-win situation by any means. Not even a win-break even situation. It is a win-lose proposition with only the companies winning.

I like the way you think, Chas. Unfortunately, I see little hope that your proposals would help any of the situations you suggest it would help. Logic would dictate that it only worsens the problems, for individual tax payers, and not improve them.

by maxwell edison

.
General Motors is indeed investing 3 billion dollars (over the next 3 years) in China, but not to build automobiles in China so they can be sold in the USA. They are doing it to remain a global competitor in the largest growing automobile market in the world. General Motors currently builds cars in China, both domestic (models Chinese domestic) as well as the familiar GM models, and they have been for some time. They currently hold about an 8 percent market share in China.

The Chinese automobile manufacturing sector has not been able to keep up with the growing demand for new automobiles, so they've (the chinese government) been inviting foreign companies to help meet that demand. The German company, Volkswagen, has been the major foreign manufacturer building automobiles in China for the Chinese consumer, and they are currently the number one supplier of cars in China, holding about a 38 percent market share.

China is the fastest growing consumer market in the world. And if American companies don't build plants in that country to fill the demand by that population, manufacturers from another country will.

What other (automobile) investments are being made in China?

General Motors (USA) ......... 3 billion.
Volkswagen (Germany) ......... 7 billion
Nissan (Japan) ............... 2 billion
Ford (USA) ................... 1.5 billion
DaimlerChrysler (USA & Ger.).. 1 billion
Honda (Japan) ................ 1 billion
Peugeot (France) ............. half billion
BMW (Germany) ................ half billion

China's economy is expected to grow at an annual rate of almost 10 percent in the first half of this year alone.

Total sales of cars made in China reached 2 million vehicles in 2003.

Total sales of cars made in China in the first quarter of 2004 was 567,000 vehicles sold.

General Motors plans to build and sell 1.3 million automobiles in China by 2007, up from an estimated 530,000 this year.

It's not cost effective to build cars in the USA and ship them to China. If GM tried to do that, they would be priced out of the Chinese market entirely, and sell zero cars in that country.

General Motors is also spending about 1 billion to build new facilities in Delta Township, Michigan.

Industry watchers are expecting China to become one of, if not the, world's largest car consumer market within two decades.

General Motors can either join the boom, and get a piece of the "Chinese Automobile Pie", or not and be left watching other companies (and countries) reap the benefits.

by pctech

Max,
I can easily understand GM's economic reasons for doing this but this should not distract you from the fact that this is money not being spent to modernize or enlarge our own facilities. This should not distract you from the very good possibilities that GM is at least partially financing this deal with the tax cuts given them. That is not money returned here nor is it jobs created here for the individuals to absorb the greater tax burden that will be placed on them.
Economics aside, let us look at this from another perspective. Are you aware that half of the profits Chinese companies make from exports go towards building China's military? State of the art jets and electronics. ( They recently placed a man in orbit, Max. ) So, you say that the cars being built there, by GM, are not for export here nor is GM a Chinese company. This would be a fair enough statement until you realize that China has long threaten to take Taiwan back and has threaten to kill all of its inhabitants to do so. So what? This nation has pledged to defend Taiwan from such actions taking place by China with our own military, if necessary. Why has China not taken Taiwan already. Simple. China is not at a state of military power to go against our military. They are getting closer to doing so with the pass of each year and definitely have the manpower to do so. So what? Now you have GM building a new modern manufacturing facility in China that they can easily sequester and convert to military manufacturing for themselves, along with GM's other assets over there. Including any cash they have there. We kind of lose twice with one GM plant, don't we Max? We survived the attack on Pearl Harbor and rapidly converted our manufacturing facilities into war product facilities to wage the war against Japan. Is the picture becoming clearer, Max? Where are the manufacturing facilites going? Where will we find the experienced personal to man any new facilites for war efforts? Where will we find the experienced managers to run them? Are we to import our needs from China, Max? Our soldiers will be faced fighting a war against China using nothing but sticks and stones and will be fighting naked. Is this picture starting to show some color now? Economics over national security? Not by my favor! ... Do the research, Max. You can read all about it. Fire up that search engine and see what it pulls in.

Enough passion?

by pctech

Are you suggesting that GM doesn't have the right to invest as they, themselves, deem appropriate?
********** No, I am not.

Are you suggesting that the U.S. government dictate how GM chooses to invest?
********** No, I am not.

Are you suggesting that the money "taxed" from GM is not - was not - GM's money to begin with?
********** No, I am not. The same is true of anyone or any company that pays taxes. Here or elsewhere. I am saying that each of us pays taxes in the country we choose to live in. GM made its start in the US. GM grew and prospered in the US. American workers helped GM to gain its multibillion dollar empire. What I am saying is that GM owes this country a great deal. Inspite of taxes being placed upon it, GM has grown to on be of the world's largest and wealthiest automakers. GM has the right to spend their monies as they please. I think GM owes this country and its workers a great deal of gratitude and its current actions shows where their loyalties lie. With the country that helped it grow into a massive corporation? To the workers that helped it achieve this status? No, their loyalties lie with whatever and whomever further pads their bank accounts. GM is loyal to itself and nothing else. As far as I am concerned, they move theri headquarters and their corporate managers to China. GM and any other company that refuses to show loyalty to the country and its workers that it made it what it is financially. .... Max, are you not against communist nations? Ohhhhhhhhhh, if you can make a dollar from them, it is OK. I see now, Max.

I say that it's GM's money to do with as they dang well please. Period. End of story. Are you suggesting otherwise?
********** No, I am not. Do you suggest that anyone or any company should be able to anything they wish with their money?

Which GM facilities in the U.S. need to be "upgraded", and who should make that decision, GM or the government (or you)?
********** GM should make the decission where they build. Should GM shows any sense of loyalty to this nation and its people, it would build where it can help build the US economy and employ US workers instead of the economies overseas and their workers. Building here and hiring here will help this economy and our workers, do you not agree?

You are asking questions that suggest you and I - or the government? - should tell GM what to do with their business. If you're a shareholder, fire away at the GM corporate managers and investor relations. If not MYOB. It's GM's money. It's GM's business. I'm willing to let them mind it.
********** Max, either this is the most baseless comment you have ever made, or you attempt to intentionally deceive those that do not know how corporations work. Take a guess, Max. How many shares of GM stock would I have to own to have a voice to be heard over the major stock holders and the corporate leaders? Do you really think that the board takes a shareholder vote before they make a business move? Rarely are any business decissions given a vote before the shareholders. The exception to this rule is when mergers or buyouts come into play. Boardmembers and possibly a few outside major investors make nearly every other business decissions for the company. Boardmembers have the right to make business decissions and the shareholders are along for the ride. If shareholders do not like the ride, they bail out. This is about their only option.

Can you provide support for your assertion that China spends half of all corporate generated profits on their military? And if they do, so what? Therefore what? Are you suggesting that the U.S. government should ban American companies from investing in China?
********** Yes, I can. I asked you fire up your search engine to do so. I thought that you would place more confidence into your own searches that you would in any links I supplied you. I am now convinved that this is not how you obtain your information. You, most likely, have bookmarks to like thinking websites and futher like thinking sites from thes sites. Should you need a link to paste, you simply go to one of these onesided sites and find an appropriate link to paste. What initiative, Max. What a brilliant way to look "smart". .... Do you wish for me to supply links for you, Max, or, is this something you can do for yourself? I do not mind and I will help you do the research, if you need my help.

In my opinion, we either open up free trade with China or we don't.
********** Well, Max, I have the same exact opinion. .... See, we can agree.

As far as Taiwan and China, I'm willing to trust our State Department (of any administration) to do whatever they decide is in the best interest of the U.S. Those folks know a lot more about it than I do.
********** Those folks know a lot more about it than I do as well, Max. Should this imply that I give them my blind faith to right by this nation? What they know, and how they use this knowledge is questionable at best. Besides, MAx, I thought you didn't trust our government to do anything right.

By the way, will you not bunch up your messages so much? It's really hard to read when they're not separated into paragraphs. This is not criticism, but if you're going to press me to answer each and every question, will you please "clean up" your presentation a bit?

********** I agree, Max. The layout of my posts are not as pleasing to te eye as they should be. I could do much better using basic HTML tags but, alas, this is not possible here. I have considered creating a page on my website and supplying you a quick link to it. This would allow anyone to read it but, alas, I can not grant you privalages to make your responses there. I will work on the astetics of my posts.

And I would prefer to stick to one point at a time, instead of going all over the place. Asking too many unrelated questions tends to distract from making specific points.

********** I did make a unified point Max. My point was that by US manufacturing companies moving their facilites to other countries cost us the manufacturing capabilities to gear up for a war such as after Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor. We lose manufacturing plants, workers, and managers that know how to run them. The only other point was to make the statement that these US corporation plants made in other nations can be sequestered and used against us. We loose twice with one plant built overseas by US companies. ... Too much for you? OK, I'll use less examples to bolster my case.

For example, you never did reply to my suggestion that the U.S. not tax the money GM made in China. I supported my argument, provided proof that other "experts" agreed with my argument, but you never provided a clear rebuttal or some sort of "closing" on that question.
********** I can not find the question you refer to. Please supply me the link and I will respond to the question.

by maxwell edison

.
From the Experts:

----------

Corporate taxes in Ontario, Canada are being cut in half over the next few years.

"This will make our companies much more competitive," Burleton said.
- TD Bank senior economist Derek Burleton

"Lowering the tax they pay frees up more of their resources to expand and grow."
- TD Bank senior economist Derek Burleton

"This will be the lowest general corporate tax in Canada,"
- Finance Minister Ernie Eves

----------

The Portuguese parliament has approved the government?s budget bill for 2004 that slashes corporate taxes amid growing economic instability.

Portuguese Prime Minister Jose Manuel Durao Barroso claims that the corporate tax cut is needed to boost competitiveness, fight rising unemployment, and that it will help the economy and spur job creation.

----------

There has been a great amount of talk lately about how to make Arizona more attractive to business. Unfortunately, the proposed solutions have generally ignored the root problem: Arizona?s corporate tax burden. A study proposes and defends six business tax reforms and projects their revenue implications. The reforms are ranked from least to most aggressive:

Equalize state income tax rates, so that the top rate on corporate income taxes is the same as that for personal income, currently 5.04 percent.

Lower the corporate income tax rate to a regionally competitive level, from 6.97 to 4.63 percent, Colorado?s flat tax rate.

Suspend the unemployment tax for at least a year, and lower the rate thereafter.

Suspend the unemployment tax and lower the corporate income tax rate to a regionally competitive rate.

Eliminate the corporate income tax.

Eliminate the corporate income tax and suspend the unemployment insurance tax.

The last option, abolishing the corporate income tax in conjunction with a suspension in the unemployment insurance tax, is the best option available to Arizona?s legislators. If enacted in a single year, it could lead to the creation of approximately 150,000 new jobs and boost payrolls in the state by $5.4 billion.

- From the Goldwater Institute

----------

The state of Nevada has:

No Corporate Income Tax

No Taxes on Corporate Shares

No Franchise Tax

The state of Nevada is (and has been) the fastest growing state in the union, and has (and has had) the highest employment rates in the country.

----------

Democrat John Kerry said he would lower corporate taxes by 5 percent to promote job creation while eliminating tax incentives that sends work overseas.

"Some may be surprised to hear a Democrat calling for lower corporate tax rates," Kerry told an audience at Wayne State University. "The fact is, I don't care about the old debates. I care about getting the job done and creating jobs here in the United States of America."

----------

"The largest single barrier to full employment of our manpower and resources and to a higher rate of economic growth is the unrealistically heavy drag of Federal income taxes on private purchasing power, initiative and incentive."

Our tax system still siphons out of the private economy too large a share of personal and business purchasing power and reduces the incentive for risk, investment and effort--thereby aborting our recoveries and stifling our national growth rate.

I am therefore proposing the following:

Reduction in individual income tax rates....

Reduction in the rate of the corporate income tax...

- President John F. Kennedy in a Special Message to the Congress on Tax Reduction and Reform, January 1963

"The final and best means of strengthening demand among consumers and business is to reduce the burden on private income and the deterrents to private initiative which are imposed by our present tax system; and this administration pledged itself last summer to an across-the-board, top-to-bottom cut in personal and corporate income taxes.....Corporate tax rates must.....be cut to increase incentives and the availability of investment capital.....Next year's tax bill must reduce personal as well as corporate income taxes - for those in the lower brackets, who are certain to spend their additional take-home pay, and for those in the middle and upper brackets, who can thereby be encouraged to undertake additional efforts and enabled to invest more capital. Third, the new tax bill should improve both the equity and the simplicity of our tax system."

- President John F. Kennedy in an address and Question and Answer Period at the Economic Club of New York, December 1962

----------

".... I recommend the elimination of the corporate income tax."

..."it was excessive taxation, deflationary monetary policy, and overbearing regulatory policy that undermined companies and entire industries that otherwise were thriving and had a bright future."

- Jack Kemp, former Congressman and co-director of Empower America, and chairman of the tax commission.

----------

"A subject area in economics, called the incidence of taxation, says that the party upon whom a tax is levied does not necessarily pay the tax. They might shift it onto some other party. That's precisely what corporations do. They are merely tax collectors."

- Walter E. Williams, Professor of Economics at George Mason University

----------

I could go on and on and on, but before I do, I wonder if you could answer one question.

Who should a person believe when it comes to the merits and/or pitfalls of taxing corporations, you or this host of experts - and why?

by jamesrl

Some of us would prefer to see more modest tax cuts and prefer instead to pay down the deficit debt.

As you may know, we commie pinkos in Canada managed to eliminate our deficit on the federal level and in some provinces. One province, Alberta, used its oil revenues to eliminate its debt all together. But how should we spend our surplus?

On the federal level, we have a debt load roughly the same as the US - a little less on a per capita basis, but then so is our income, so it works out about the same. I would prefer to see more of that surplus spent in reducing the long term debt. Its like paying down the mortgage or investing - nice if you can do both, but most people and countries have to make some harder choices. But to a "conservative" like me, paying down the debt in good times makes some sense, in order to provide flexibility in the bad times.

James

by maxwell edison

.
You were correct when you suggested that corporations keep money earned overseas, sitting overseas.

However, instead of taxing them, as you suggested as a way to keep them from invsting overseas in the first place, we should not only encourage overseas investments, but not tax them on their earnings, thereby giving them the incintive to bring the cash back to the USA.

Consider this (cut and pasted from the Financial Times):

Overseas earnings will help America prosper

On October 1, 2003 the US Senate Finance Committee moved American tax policy one step closer to letting American companies invest hundreds of billions of dollars at home to fuel economic expansion. Now the full Senate and the US House of Representatives have a chance to release this huge sum and create an estimated 500,000 new American jobs. But until they agree to change the tax law, those billions will remain locked up overseas.

Many US companies have operations overseas to serve their foreign customers. At present, however, those companies have no incentive to return their earnings from foreign operations to the US and invest them in domestic operations. In fact, they have a strong incentive to hold those earnings overseas.

Unlike a lot of countries, including many European nations, the US does not exclude repatriated earnings from domestic taxation. While companies based in other countries have a clear incentive to reinvest the money at home, that is not the case in the US. It imposes a tax of 35 per cent on foreign earnings, a formidable barrier to economic recovery, job creation and innovation. Companies are allowed to defer US tax by simply keeping the money abroad and investing it there.

As a result, a large pool of accumulated foreign earnings is currently sitting outside the US. According to the US Joint Committee on Taxation, a temporary change in US tax law could bring $140bn back to the country. A recent JP Morgan report suggests that the change could generate $300bn in US re-investment, lifting US gross domestic product by 0.5 per cent and creating 400,000 more jobs.

The legislation passed by the Senate Finance Committee would allow companies to bring foreign earnings back to the US subject to, for a one-year period, a 5.25 per cent tax. The bill enjoys bipartisan support: Republican backers include Senator John Ensign of Nevada, while Democratic backers include Senator Barbara Boxer of California.

The potential benefits to the US economy are enormous. The repatriated earnings would have a powerful stimulus effect. A report released earlier this week by Allen Sinai, chief global economist for Decision Economics, an economics consultancy, identified the following benefits: reduced unemployment and significant job creation, peaking at 660,000 additional jobs in 2005; sharply increased domestic capital spending, primarily on equipment, averaging $30bn per year over the next four years and peaking at $78bn in 2005; stronger US companies, as a result of healthier balance sheets, reduced domestic debt loads and improved corporate bond ratings; increased dividends paid to individual shareholders, potentially reaching $14.2bn a year; and a $75bn domestic deficit reduction in the first 5 years after the legislation is passed.

Sceptics will argue that these benefits are not guaranteed - that the proposed change is nothing more than a corporate tax break that could simply be used for executive compensation. But that would be wrong. Every US company knows that the keys to economic recovery are corporate growth and expansion.

Companies know that they need to invest their earnings in the US. Most would take these savings and use them to fund research and development, capital investment and the hiring and training of staff. Yet unlike their counterparts in many other countries, the tax system deters them from doing so.

What is more, the proposed change would bring a windfall to the US Treasury and, according to the Joint Committee on Taxation, at no cost to the government. Decision Economics estimates that federal receipts would increase by nearly $12bn a year through to 2008, due to collections on the repatriation of funds that would otherwise remain outside the US.

In a global economy, companies need to operate close to their customers; this helps to ensure a good balance of trade. However, global earnings by American companies should be brought back to the US for domestic investment.

The bottom line is clear. This legislation would bring about an immediate and large infusion of cash into the US for domestic investment and job creation. It would provide an economic stimulus and position US companies for a period of sustained growth. For US companies and workers, the sooner Congress moves to finish enacting the change, the better.

The writer is chief financial officer for Sun Microsystems

By STEVE MCGOWAN.
23 October 2003
Financial Times

by admin

our government needs to STOP spending money and let people directly choose how to spend it themselves. If we stopped relying on so many government programs we wouldn't need so many taxes.

Which is the cart? Which is the Horse? I wonder if a lot of it isn't the cart trying to pull the horse these days!

by jamesrl

A couple of ways you can look at it.

The numbers Garion quoted would show that Japan is a lot more generous than the US, on a per capita basis. You can also look at foreign aid as a perecentage of Gross National Product, which is probably the most fair way of looking at it. In those measures, the US is not number one either.

You could argue that the US's military spending is also a contribution to world stability, -but that cuts both ways me thinks.

James

by maxwell edison

.
Why don't more people believe in the basic, underlying principle that admin so clearly articulated when he said, "Our government needs to STOP spending money and let people directly choose how to spend it themselves. If we stopped relying on so many government programs we wouldn't need so many taxes."

Well done indeed. (However, don't hold your breath for anyone to attempt to answer. No one has a good answer - and it really makes you wonder.)

Okay, PCTech - there's my debate topic. And I'll take the side that admin so wisely falls on.

Get ready to defend the government seizing the personal property (money) of the citizen who earned it, for the sole purpose of redistributing it to a person who didn't earn it. However, I would expect more than just rhetoric and opinion. I would hope that any argument can be supported and validated in some way. I'll start the thread very soon. (Thanks admin.)

by garion11

We contribute much that WE DON'T HAVE TO. Just like other industrial nations, they contribute, but frankly speaking, WE DON'T HAVE TO, neither do they. What do we get for this? 4 planes hijacking, 3000 dead Americans, G8 summit riots. Its like these third world nations (some of the are breeding grounds for terrorists) are biting the hand that feeds them, I don't get it.

by oz_media

I must be readiing yourpost wrong or just gettig the wrong message.

YOu said you don't NEED support from others countries as far as Imports to America.

Then why MUST you log our forests?
Fish our waters?
Buy HydroElectric power for California?

SO withour OUR much needed support, California is cold and dark and completely unproductive as no PC's, servers and businesses would have power?
We don't suply AL of California's power, but a great deal of it. In fact they say it is enough to power several cities in BC. THis is SOLD to the US government the same way the SELL us needed resources.

You seem to have the impression that America is a solely independant nation that NEEDS nobody else to survive.

Perhaps you could offer someideas as to how and where you got this message from?!?

by garion11

What are you blind? Trace this thread back up to where I responded to Skipper, when did I say we are independent? In a trade between industrialized nations we are dependent on other countries for resources we can't provide for ourselves, OIL is a big example.

How did you get to fishing? power? and whatever else?? What MADE YOU ASSUME that? Is it because you already had a desired outcome/response to my post regardless of what I may have said??. You are such a fucking liar, omg, Lying asshole, everything you accuse America and Bush to be. Fuck head.

by pctech

admin, I have to wonder this myself. Which is first? The cart or the horse? The horse or the cart?
I will qualify myself by saying that I am an Independent that will not box myself in with the mindset of either major political party. I am also a fiscal conservative. I thought the Republicans were as well. Once the Republicans gained control of the House, with the 104th Congress, spending actually increased. When the Republicans gained control of both the House and the Senate, spending outpaced all previous peacetime Democratic controlled Congresses. With the House, Senate, and White House in control by the Republicans, this nation has seen record spending and record deficets. We are also seeing record trade deficets. To qualify this even further, Bush has not vetoed a single spending bill. Bush has not vetoed ANYTHING. Not even some token legislation! ... Which does come first? The horse or the cart? The cart or the horse? ..... Do we even have a horse or a cart?????????

"our government needs to STOP spending money and let people directly choose how to spend it themselves."
How do the people "directly" choose how we spend our money if not through our elected officials, or do you suggest that taxes not be collected and indivduals decide how much and for what purpose they send money to the government?

"If we stopped relying on so many government programs we wouldn't need so many taxes."
I need further clarification on this. Which government programs do we keep and which do we scrap? Which do we simply trim and by how much?
I am not disagreeing with your reasoning, admin. I just need some clarification as to what it is you are suggesting.
BTW, taking tax dollars and services taken away from the federal level will only shift the tax burdens and services to the state and local levels. Where do you think they get so much of their money? Selling state flowers or from their tax payers? Dry up the federal contributions and the burden will shift to the locals. I am not saying this is good or it is bad. I am saying it is nothing more than a shift of money from one entity to the other. Either way, we are not likely to see any tax relief from it.

TheChas has never responded to my post to him:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155025&messageID=1623163

Nor has Maxwell responded to this post:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155025&messageID=1623641

I do not suggest that they should but, they seem to do so when they have ready answers. TheChas is a busy man. I have seen the efforts he has made to help many with problems brought before us and is an excellent resource for computer related problems. Maxwell also spends a lot of his time helping others here and, to be honest, he will need time to research what I have asked him to research. I was just wondering, admin, if you would be kind enough to give response to this post. We are all busy people and I will understand if you lack the opportunity to do so. I was only hoping that you would respond.

by maxwell edison

.
On everything you said, therefore what?

Are you suggesting that GM doesn't have the right to invest as they, themselves, deem appropriate?

Are you suggesting that the U.S. government dictate how GM chooses to invest?

Are you suggesting that the money "taxed" from GM is not - was not - GM's money to begin with?

I say that it's GM's money to do with as they dang well please. Period. End of story. Are you suggesting otherwise?

On other statements you made, I question the validity - or the relevance:

Which GM facilities in the U.S. need to be "upgraded", and who should make that decision, GM or the government (or you)?

You are asking questions that suggest you and I - or the government? - should tell GM what to do with their business. If you're a shareholder, fire away at the GM corporate managers and investor relations. If not MYOB. It's GM's money. It's GM's business. I'm willing to let them mind it.

Can you provide support for your assertion that China spends half of all corporate generated profits on their military? And if they do, so what? Therefore what? Are you suggesting that the U.S. government should ban American companies from investing in China?

In my opinion, we either open up free trade with China or we don't.

As far as Taiwan and China, I'm willing to trust our State Department (of any administration) to do whatever they decide is in the best interest of the U.S. Those folks know a lot more about it than I do.

There were probably more questions you asked, but that's enough for now. Besides, I believe I probably answered all of them in "general", bu stating it's GM's money and GM's business to mind themselves.

By the way, will you not bunch up your messages so much? It's really hard to read when they're not separated into paragraphs. This is not criticism, but if you're going to press me to answer each and every question, will you please "clean up" your presentation a bit?

And I would prefer to stick to one point at a time, instead of going all over the place. Asking too many unrelated questions tends to distract from making specific points. For example, you never did reply to my suggestion that the U.S. not tax the money GM made in China. I supported my argument, provided proof that other "experts" agreed with my argument, but you never provided a clear rebuttal or some sort of "closing" on that question.

by maxwell edison

.
You suggested that tax cuts for General Motors Corporations helped finance a "move" overseas. You also inferred that the "move" was to save money making Cadillacs for the American consumer. I suggested that it was not a "move" overseas, but rather an expansion overseas - an expansion that's both reasonable and understandable, at least from the perspective I articulated. I further suggested that it was not to sell to the American consumer, but rather the Chinese consumer. Do you agree or disagree with my rebuttal? Do you agree or disagree with my conclusion?

You suggested that the overseas profits made by General Motors were not being brought back to the USA. However, we did agreed on this, but I offered a viable solution to solve the problem. Do you agree or disagree with my conclusion?

You didn't address these initial issues, but rather made the jump (for whatever reason) to China attacking Taiwan and preparing for a war with the USA.

How about not getting ahead of yourself, and address the initial points - one's that you brought up initially. Or, if you want to tie one to the other, go for it. But don't forget to answer the "thefore what" question.

by admin

Cart, horse. horse, cart?
admin, I have to wonder this myself. Which is first? The cart or the horse? The horse or the cart?
I will qualify myself by saying that I am an Independent that will not box myself in with the mindset of either major political party. I am also a fiscal conservative. I thought the Republicans were as well. Once the Republicans gained control of the House, with the 104th Congress, spending actually increased. When the Republicans gained control of both the House and the Senate, spending outpaced all previous peacetime Democratic controlled Congresses. With the House, Senate, and White House in control by the Republicans, this nation has seen record spending and record deficets. We are also seeing record trade deficets. To qualify this even further, Bush has not vetoed a single spending bill. Bush has not vetoed ANYTHING. Not even some token legislation! ... Which does come first? The horse or the cart? The cart or the horse? ..... Do we even have a horse or a cart?????????

"our government needs to STOP spending money and let people directly choose how to spend it themselves."
How do the people "directly" choose how we spend our money if not through our elected officials, or do you suggest that taxes not be collected and indivduals decide how much and for what purpose they send money to the government?

"If we stopped relying on so many government programs we wouldn't need so many taxes."
I need further clarification on this. Which government programs do we keep and which do we scrap? Which do we simply trim and by how much?
I am not disagreeing with your reasoning, admin. I just need some clarification as to what it is you are suggesting.
BTW, taking tax dollars and services taken away from the federal level will only shift the tax burdens and services to the state and local levels. Where do you think they get so much of their money? Selling state flowers or from their tax payers? Dry up the federal contributions and the burden will shift to the locals. I am not saying this is good or it is bad. I am saying it is nothing more than a shift of money from one entity to the other. Either way, we are not likely to see any tax relief from it.

TheChas has never responded to my post to him:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155025&messageID=1623163

Nor has Maxwell responded to this post:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155025&messageID=1623641

I do not suggest that they should but, they seem to do so when they have ready answers. TheChas is a busy man. I have seen the efforts he has made to help many with problems brought before us and is an excellent resource for computer related problems. Maxwell also spends a lot of his time helping others here and, to be honest, he will need time to research what I have asked him to research. I was just wondering, admin, if you would be kind enough to give response to this post. We are all busy people and I will understand if you lack the opportunity to do so. I was only hoping that you would respond.

From: pctech@houston.rr.com Date: 07/13/04

by admin

Cart, horse. horse, cart?
admin, I have to wonder this myself. Which is first? The cart or the horse? The horse or the cart?
I will qualify myself by saying that I am an Independent that will not box myself in with the mindset of either major political party. I am also a fiscal conservative. I thought the Republicans were as well. Once the Republicans gained control of the House, with the 104th Congress, spending actually increased. When the Republicans gained control of both the House and the Senate, spending outpaced all previous peacetime Democratic controlled Congresses. With the House, Senate, and White House in control by the Republicans, this nation has seen record spending and record deficets. We are also seeing record trade deficets. To qualify this even further, Bush has not vetoed a single spending bill. Bush has not vetoed ANYTHING. Not even some token legislation! ... Which does come first? The horse or the cart? The cart or the horse? ..... Do we even have a horse or a cart?????????

"our government needs to STOP spending money and let people directly choose how to spend it themselves."
How do the people "directly" choose how we spend our money if not through our elected officials, or do you suggest that taxes not be collected and indivduals decide how much and for what purpose they send money to the government?

"If we stopped relying on so many government programs we wouldn't need so many taxes."
I need further clarification on this. Which government programs do we keep and which do we scrap? Which do we simply trim and by how much?
I am not disagreeing with your reasoning, admin. I just need some clarification as to what it is you are suggesting.
BTW, taking tax dollars and services taken away from the federal level will only shift the tax burdens and services to the state and local levels. Where do you think they get so much of their money? Selling state flowers or from their tax payers? Dry up the federal contributions and the burden will shift to the locals. I am not saying this is good or it is bad. I am saying it is nothing more than a shift of money from one entity to the other. Either way, we are not likely to see any tax relief from it.

TheChas has never responded to my post to him:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155025&messageID=1623163

Nor has Maxwell responded to this post:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155025&messageID=1623641

I do not suggest that they should but, they seem to do so when they have ready answers. TheChas is a busy man. I have seen the efforts he has made to help many with problems brought before us and is an excellent resource for computer related problems. Maxwell also spends a lot of his time helping others here and, to be honest, he will need time to research what I have asked him to research. I was just wondering, admin, if you would be kind enough to give response to this post. We are all busy people and I will understand if you lack the opportunity to do so. I was only hoping that you would respond.

From: pctech@houston.rr.com Date: 07/13/04

by admin

I believe in some of the original founders of the United States of America's principles when it comes to government. I do believe that freedom should ring! I also believe that one of the ways this is best achieved is through less government and more personal responsibility. This has been expressed as "The government which governs best governs least" and to me was a solid principle for the founders and a good premise from which to start. If you want a government that is small, efficient and effective, a good tool to use in policy would be the razor of William Occam, which was well known by our founders. He stated that: "Plurality should not be posited without necessity"

It does not make any sense whatsoever to do things more than once, or to do them in a way that demands extra resources. For instance, if I need to get a short message to the baker, and I am going to go buy bread at his store that day, why would I take the time to write it out on paper, address an envelope, pay postage and leave it for the postman? this would be ridiculous in this case.

If I am quite capable of making my own meals, or have a household arrangement whereby I can take my meals at home for little cost, should I instead regularly pay for others to prepare and transport my meals on a daily basis? Of course not.

Now, if my neighbor is elderly, feeble and ill and I find I can take her a portion of my food and wood for her hearth personally would I instead request that a great number of individuals are collected to insure the legal ramifications of this act, to provide the said services, to addtionally oversee the service provision and instead of real goods to effect this through an accounting system at both ends: collection and distribution? When Occam's razor is applied, we will most certainly see that the former system is a much simpler, cost-effective and elegant solution. It is also provided by neighbors as opposed to government workers which has it's own set of social benefits. Had the British asked for the help of their neighbors, there would of been no Tea party here. It is simpler and best if people are encouraged to take responsibility for their communities at the most local level possible.

"How do the people "directly" choose how we spend our money if not through our elected officials, or do you suggest that taxes not be collected and indivduals decide how much and for what purpose they send money to the government?"

In order of priority:

1. Their private services and pocketbook.
2. Through their local government.
3. Through their state government.
4. Through their national government.

Obviously, some taxation is necessary for social order, however, the control on spending should be as close to the tax base as possible. This is what was properly meant by "taxation with representation" and works well with "Government governing least is best". The best way of choosing directly is to depend on the government as little as possible for yourself, your family, your community and your state. There is a direct loss of state, local and personal freedom attached to most federal dollars if you look at taxation history. This runs through all levels of taxation. I do not blame the federal government for this, but those who would accept it. "Those who would trade freedom for security" as it was said, deserve what they get.

by pctech

On Taxes and Government
I believe in some of the original founders of the United States of America's principles when it comes to government. I do believe that freedom should ring! I also believe that one of the ways this is best achieved is through less government and more personal responsibility. This has been expressed as "The government which governs best governs least" and to me was a solid principle for the founders and a good premise from which to start. If you want a government that is small, efficient and effective, a good tool to use in policy would be the razor of William Occam, which was well known by our founders. He stated that: "Plurality should not be posited without necessity"
********** Since the topic is, "On Taxes and Government", are you not saying that the government which governs the best, taxes the least? You have shown me nothing to have me think otherwise. There are countries that have little or no taxes. Do you suggest they are better governed for this reason?

I believe by all of the principles handed down to us by our forefathers. Since you only beleive in some of these priciples, where do you disagree?

It does not make any sense whatsoever to do things more than once, or to do them in a way that demands extra resources. For instance, if I need to get a short message to the baker, and I am going to go buy bread at his store that day, why would I take the time to write it out on paper, address an envelope, pay postage and leave it for the postman? this would be ridiculous in this case.
********** This is a good scenario and I agree that there is too much waste in government spending. Why should the tax payers have to keep paying for Bush to go to Crawford, Texas for R&R? Why not just leave him there and cut the costs of future trips? Seriously, I fully agree that we need to cut the waste and redundancy in spending.

If I am quite capable of making my own meals, or have a household arrangement whereby I can take my meals at home for little cost, should I instead regularly pay for others to prepare and transport my meals on a daily basis? Of course not.
********** Again, I agree. Why should we pay millions of dollars to a major oil and energy company to cater food to our troops in Iraq? This makes absolutely no sense. What ever happened to the army, navy, marine, and airforce cooks?

Now, if my neighbor is elderly, feeble and ill and I find I can take her a portion of my food and wood for her hearth personally would I instead request that a great number of individuals are collected to insure the legal ramifications of this act, to provide the said services, to addtionally oversee the service provision and instead of real goods to effect this through an accounting system at both ends: collection and distribution? When Occam's razor is applied, we will most certainly see that the former system is a much simpler, cost-effective and elegant solution. It is also provided by neighbors as opposed to government workers which has it's own set of social benefits. Had the British asked for the help of their neighbors, there would of been no Tea party here. It is simpler and best if people are encouraged to take responsibility for their communities at the most local level possible.
********** I agree with this, in principle but, a major flaw exists within the game plan. Most people do not even take the time to know their neighbors, let alone help them. The fascinating aspect of this is that the higher the population density, the truer this becomes. Rural farmers are much more inclined to help their neighbor three miles away than is a person in an apartment complex to help someone three doors away.

"How do the people "directly" choose how we spend our money if not through our elected officials, or do you suggest that taxes not be collected and indivduals decide how much and for what purpose they send money to the government?"

In order of priority:

1. Their private services and pocketbook.
2. Through their local government.
3. Through their state government.
4. Through their national government.

Obviously, some taxation is necessary for social order, however, the control on spending should be as close to the tax base as possible. This is what was properly meant by "taxation with representation" and works well with "Government governing least is best". The best way of choosing directly is to depend on the government as little as possible for yourself, your family, your community and your state. There is a direct loss of state, local and personal freedom attached to most federal dollars if you look at taxation history. This runs through all levels of taxation. I do not blame the federal government for this, but those who would accept it. "Those who would trade freedom for security" as it was said, deserve what they get.
********** No, taxation with representation is through our ability to vote for representatives to go for us as our voice. Spending as close to the tax base as possible is not even implied, in our Constitution, as taxation with representation. ( Where did you get this from? ) Put simply, if you voted for the dummy that is on the Hill spending all of your money, well, you got represented. Should you not like this representation, vote for another dummy that is going to do the exact same thing, possibly just in different areas.
I agree that you lose a degree a freedom by relying on federal dollars to solve local problems. The problem is that most local communities do protest most loudly whenever the local or state governments need to raise taxes for services its citizens demand. Why expect to have something and not have a cost associated with it? Schools, teachers, parks, infrastructures all need to be paid for, just not with my money, right?
Well, we agree again. Those that would trade freedom for security ( a paraphrase of Benjamin Franklin ) deserve, or will have, neither. Think of this the next time you think of the Patriot Act or the Homeland Security Act. The latter is in name only, since the funding was not given to it.

Admin, are you a Libertarian? I only ask since you speak well of ideology and know little of the "nuts and bolts" aspects of our government. All, without fail, of the Libertarians I talked with are nihilists, at heart. Anarchy over any form of government. I can only say that the Libertarians I have talked with were born too late for the ideology they seek. The ideology that they cling to so dearly would have worked well in the old west of the 1800's. Neighbors were few and far apart. You were free to do as you wish and never have concerns that it may interfere with others' wishes. Even in the 1800's, where ever population density increases, so does legislation and "fees" imposed upon you. The higher the population density became, as a rule, the more legislation and fees imposed upon you. Why, you may ask. Simple. You are not out on the plains running around by yourself and not being an impostition to anyone else. Your personal freedoms were near limitless. The higher the population density, the greater the loss of personal freedoms. Even simple logic should dictate that your personal freedoms can directly impose upon the personal freedoms of others just due to the near proximity of the indiviudals. You have the freedom to run naked and firing your pistols on the open plains but, these acts impose upon the rights of others when you live in a crowded neighborhood. Libertarians never seem to have caught onto this. All ideology and no "nuts and bolts" approaches to anything. ........... "Take my clothes and give me my pistols! I just want to be free!" Not in the big city!
There is hope for Libertarians and their ideology. The Australian Outbacks can still afford you this kind of freedom.

by admin

" Which government programs do we keep and which do we scrap? Which do we simply trim and by how much?"

We did not get into this position of a big Federal Government overnight, nor will it be quick to remove ourselves from it. We can make a difference and restore it however over time if we wish.

People are now dependant on these programs and a sudden drastic change would create more ill than good. The best way would be again to apply the principle's of choosing the most simple cost effective solutions in our personal lives, and collectively to encourage our local, state and federal representatives to do the same. An example of fallicious thinking would be to expect the government on some level to effect change of this type. Occam's razor would suggest it is simplest to not let ourselves or those around us rely on a welfare state, but to provide as best we can for their well-being personally. We also would find ourselves well served by an active ongoing militia such as the National Guard having many more citizen soldiers in the ranks. This would allevieate the burn out of the professional soldier, which will always be in a smaller number than the available citizen soldier.

It requires less taxation if more of us served our government directly as opposed to making that the professional task of the few in any position and can be applied according to age and ability.

"taking tax dollars and services taken away from the federal level will only shift the tax burdens and services to the state and local levels. Where do you think they get so much of their money? Selling state flowers or from their tax payers? Dry up the federal contributions and the burden will shift to the locals. I am not saying this is good or it is bad. I am saying it is nothing more than a shift of money from one entity to the other. Either way, we are not likely to see any tax relief from it."

I agree. This really needs to be driven by changing the thought patterns of the governed individuals to take on an active role. Every time you convert a service to money or money to a service, some waste occurs. When you look at this from the individual up through the different levels and then back to the individual, a huge amount of waste occurs. If your elderly neighbor needs heat and food by which would you prefer your energy spent: By getting a few folk in the neighborhood to visit with a portion of their meals and stop with a few loads of wood, or pay for a barrel of oil through your church? Or would it be more efficient to have Federal aid come to her rescue and pay for the hundreds of people and programs it must go through to get her these basic needs?

We need a fundamental shift in responsible social thinking, not merely a change in where the numbers of people are employed in government. This tends to be most efficient closest to the taxed individual, and responsibility is lost the farther away the individual is from their personal taxes. This is true taxation with representation and a return to personal responsibility.

by dbertsche

Good one Garion11. I'm laughing so hard, you should have added the word "meaningful" in front of solutions.

They bash Bush because they have no meaningful solutions!

by garion11

This isn't the only message board I asked this question. Its incredible what the thread turned into. It went something like this...

First of all, once a thread reaches a certain amount, it goes to pages, meaning Page 1, 2, 3, etc..

Well it reached 7 pages. IN all those pages, the responses were, Bush sucks...taxes!, bush sucks, Iraq!, bush sucks, muslims!, bush sucks. I had to ask 3 times to stay focused on topic and reminded them that "yes I know Bush sucks, but what would Kerry do different?" I still have yet to hear that answer and its been 2 weeks.:(. Bush sucks is all I get.

All I ask is a positive contribution from the left on How you would do things differently? What in specific would you do? All I got was Bush sucks! *sigh*

by oz_media

Judging solely on your rants, name calling and continual swearing on this forum, I can only suggest that you provoke such answers.

Now THIS question you have posed is more eloquent than most of your comments yet it still asks for conclusions with no basis of debate.

If you want it to be a logical reply you shopuld start by saying what you see as the pro's and con's of GWB yourself. Then you may ask others what they feel Kerry would do DIFFERENTLY. God you'd make one crappy salesman.

by maxwell edison

.
I'm not going to make any efforts to prove your assertions. You said them, not me. Why should I take the time to either verify or disprove anything? In this case, I didn't necessarily disagree. I simply asked you to support a statement. You said it. You must have had a reason for saying it. You should be willing - and able - to provide support for any assertion you make. And you ask me to prove what you say? Get real.

Moreover, you contradict yourself, and you form no conclusions.

You are overlooking the "therefore what" to everything of what you're saying. What point are you trying to make?

You go all over the place - you make no sense - you are simply rambling incoherently.

And you know, I'm not crazy about the condescending attitude coming across from you.

Find someone else to play your games with. You're becoming a real bore.

by pctech

Max,

Kuwait not only does not have any taxes the government pays royalties to its citizens from the oil revenues. The other country I can think of is Iran, but the information is dated. I personally knew a man from Iran that told me his country does not collect taxes and also pays royalties from the oil revenues to its citizens. This information was told me, by him, a few months before the fall of the Shaw of Iran. He left to return to his country to fight in the revolution that had already taken his brother's life and shortly before the Iranians took control of our embassy and took our citizens as hostages. Since the information is dated, I can no longer assure you that taxes are no longer collected or that oil revenues are given to its citizens. I have never heard from this man again. I have also talked to people that have visited the islands of the Bahamas and they have told me that there are no taxes there either. Can I PROVE either of the statements? Having never lived or visited either place, no. I have relied on information supplied to me by people that have lived there or visited there.

Max, in your other post where you claim I do not answer "So What?" and that I ramble, you say our discusions are a waste of time. I disagree with this assessment and had took the time to place your comments and questions in my post and answered or commented on each point you had taken. What do you want from me?

I had offered you the chance to research for yourself my claims about China. As I have already explained to you, I did this thinking you would more appreciate your own searches as opposed to the results I would offer from my searches. Would this not be logical assumption on my part? And, yes, I was condenscending towards you simply because you seemed unwilling to discover for yourself as to what I say is true or false. I thought you would thoroughly enjoy the opportunity to prove me wrong as result of your own searches. I guess I was wrong. I will supply you with

Max, why not start your own topic based upon what it is you wish to debate. Pick a topic. Post your comments and questions and then state how you wish for me to respond to them. I will do my utmost to comply with your wishes. Let me if this acceptable to you. I will warn you that I will not be a patsy for any leading questions or commnents.

by maxwell edison

.
And on your China (and other) tangents - what more can I say? I don't want to do your research. I want you to support your assertion - just like you did with your Kuwait answer. You said I was, "unwilling to discover" for myself if what you say "is true or false". What a stupid thing to say. First of all, I don't give a damn what China does with their money, primarily because I can't do anything about it. If they spend 50% of their "export profits" on the military or 100% - and you made the statement - I don't care. (Nor does Chinese "exports" have anything to do with GM building and selling cars in China.) My guess is that you just pulled that statement out of your ass, and you have no way to back it up. There - prove me wrong. If you don't want to - or can't - then let it go.

And on your constant invitation to "debate", based on your tone and demeanor, I can tell that you're just itching to get into a tussle with me, and I don't want to do that. You're coy and evasive, you come across as extremely pompous, and I don't care for your constant snide remarks.

If you want a debate, pick a damn topic and open a discussion yourself. I may or may not get involved, depending on my level of interest AND your presentation. But the last thing I'm gonna' do is get into a pissing match with you. Besides, I don't think you're up to it. You're much too flaky.

End of replies to this discussion.

by dkwaczala

I would like to add on to this comment. If there is anyone out there who has the balls to change what is going on, Please step up to the plate. I am open to any suggestion. Mr Kerry, so far, has not shown me anything that he COULD change. He just wants to get to the White House. All he is is a double talker and a back stabbing politician. He is a disgrace to his own party.

by oz_media

That IS a politician, you wouldn't even make it into a politics otherwise. EVERY politician in practically every country will double talk and back stab, whether it's for what you want or not is another story though. Those that appease one group of people, lie and backstab another group and vice versa.

Welcome to politics, get used to it.

by aldanatech

I don't know if I'm a liberal or not, but here is my reasons. First and foremost, so far just about anyone would make a better president than Bush. Second, if you want security then forget about the war on Iraq, focus on intelligence. There might be a need for a small apology of some sort for bringing the country to war for the wrong reasons to restore some of international?s credibility on the US. This should provide us with greater support from the world in the TRUE war on terrorism. As for domestic issues, lower some of tax cuts for the rich to balance the national deficit. Remember that tax cuts are okay only if you can afford them. After the country raises the budget to run itself, lost jobs will be restored, people will be more productive and the economy will go up. Just think of how great the country was under the Clinton administration.

by pctech

Max,

While I did not find a direct hyperlink to China using 50% of its corporations' export profits being redirected for use in the expanding and modernization of its military, in my internet searches, I did find the following links that you may find to be interesting reading. I did see a business discusion show, on PBS, that was related to trade with China. The guest had asserted that although China uses 50% of corporate export profits to fund China's modernization and expansion of its military, that the threat of economic sanctions against China had kept China from launching against Taiwan during a Chinese military operation in the strait between China and Taiwan. I view that while this may be an effective tactical move against China now, it will be less effectual as China gains monitary and military independence.
You may notice that my links are to a variety of sites with differing political alignments and without political affiliations at all. What I assess as a threat to the future of this nation is not based on politics but, rather, if my assertions against trade with China are founded or unfounded. You will find references to the Clinton and Bush administrations and even of prior administrations policies towards China and the effect of these policies on us now. As with the tragedy of 9-11, there is blame to be rightfully passed around and no specific "smoking gun". Just bad policies.
So what? I will let you decide that for yourself.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,94355,00.html

http://www.aviationnow.com/avnow/news/channel_aerospacedaily_story.jsp?id=news/chi04264.xml

http://edition.cnn.com/2004/LAW/07/01/china.weapons/

http://www.cnn.com/US/9904/21/china.nukes/

http://usembassy.state.gov/islamabad/wwwhpr29.html

http://www.fas.org/nuke/guide/china/

http://www.fas.org/nuke/guide/china/dod-2003.pdf

http://www.country-data.com/cgi-bin/query/r-2950.html

http://www.cia.gov/nic/confreports_chinawmd.htmlhttp://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/3809067.stm

http://www.cphpost.dk/get/74741.html

http://www.ceip.org/programs/npp/nppchnct.htm

http://www.rense.com/general53/noik.htm

http://www.taiwansecurity.org/Reu/Reuters-101100.htm

http://usinfo.org/wf-archive/2000/000719/epf314.htm

http://nuclearweaponarchive.org/China/

http://www.nuclearfiles.org/edcoursesyllabi/prc-weapons.html

http://www.nti.org/db/china/conpos.htm

http://www.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2004/7/1/165100.shtml

http://www.thebulletin.org/issues/1991/may91/may91fieldhouse.html

http://english.aljazeera.net/NR/exeres/9CCCA355-871E-4A42-A7C2-2D798E3299A2.htm

http://www.stimson.org/pubs.cfm?ID=82

http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/China%20and%20weapons%20of%20mass%20destruction

http://www.taiwansecurity.org/CNN/2002/CNN-032902.htm

http://www.cfr.org/pdf/china.pdf

http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1166876/posts

http://www.meadev.nic.in/govt/wallst.htm

http://www.comw.org/cmp/fulltext/cafnuke.html

http://cns.miis.edu/research/china/coxrep/wwhmdat.htm

http://www.geocities.com/Area51/Shadowlands/6583/project447.html

http://www.cdi.org/issues/nukef&f/database/chnukes.html

http://www.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2002/9/11/192152.shtml

http://www.afa.org/magazine/sept1997/0997china.asp

http://debate.uvm.edu/handbookfile/WMD2002/177.htm

http://www.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2001/6/19/205940.shtml

http://static.highbeam.com/i/insightonthenews/august052002/symposiumchinasmilitarybuildupandtheunitedstatesst/

http://www.nti.org/e_research/e3_17b.html

http://sify.com/news/international/fullstory.php?id=13425246

http://taiwansecurity.org/IS/Heritage-991202-Military-Contacts-with-China.htm

http://www.uscc.gov/hearings/2004hearings/written_testimonies/04_06_16hasc_testimony%20_robinson.htm

http://chinastudygroup.org/index.php?type=news&id=6093

by pctech

This Republican controlled Congress has exceeded the spending and deficet spending of ANY peace time Congress, bar none. With the funds for the war in Iraq excluded, this Congress still exceeds any other peace time Congress's spending and deficet spending.

Spending bills vetoed by Bush to date - 0
Any bills vetoed by Bush to date - 0

I consider Bush to be directly responsible for the record national debt and deficet spending due the lack of his use of the pen to veto at least some of the spending bills placed before him. Bush has not developed any policies that would help lower record trade deficets, even against nations that subsidize their manufacturing industries or that penalize our companies on attempted imports into their countries. China intentionally devalues its currency, by an estimated 40%, to keep exports from China high and imports into China low.

Would Kerry do any better? This is, as yet, unclear. The actions/inactions of Bush and this Congress ARE clear.

by maxwell edison

.
On the veto-less President Bush, any number of conclusions could be drawn.

For example (cut and pasted story):

Aided by a Republican-controlled Congress, President Bush is on track to become the first chief executive since John Quincy Adams in the 1820s to complete a full term without vetoing one bill.

He has, however, made frequent use of the veto threat, and so far that's been enough to get what he wanted."

Rutgers University political scientist Ross Baker said there was a time when "a large number of vetoes was seen as a sign of a vigorous presidency."

Not now. Bush's veto-free presidency, Baker said, is "a recognition that at this particular point in history the Republicans are showing an incredible degree of solidarity."

The GOP has controlled the House for all three of Bush's years in office; Democrats held a slim majority in the Senate for about half that time. That Democratic period mostly followed the September 11, 2001, attacks, however, which fostered a rare level of cooperation between the White House and congressional Democrats. Republicans now control the Senate.

Unlike Clinton, who couldn't always rely on the support of his fellow Democrats, Bush can count on like-minded GOP leaders to make sure that bills reach his desk without objectionable provisions.

by pctech

Max,

You have freely admitted, by your example, that it is the Republican controlled House, Senate, and White House that has created and passed the huge debts that this country now faces. What you fail to admit is that Bush could have cut some of this spending with a PEN. He failed to do so and thus is responsible for all the spending of this nation over the length of his administration. The fact that Democrats signed on to SOME of this spending is irrelevant when you consider Bush could have controlled a lot of this spending with a stroke of a PEN! Bush is a fiscal failure. Fiscal responsibility is SUPPOSE to be the battle cry of the Republican party. Their cry has proven to be less than a whimper.

by admin

pctech,

Yes, I am a Libertarian. I am an Anarchist at heart, you are quite correct. Anarchy is often misunderstood, but affords a wonderful base for small societies as you have pointed out. There are still places in America to live this way to a great extent. I live in Idaho where you can still shoot and be naked even in the cities (well if you call Boise a city) as long as you are not a jerk about it.

Moving to towns like Atlanta, Idaho for instance, the nearest law enforcement is often 3 hours away- longer in the winter. They live just like you describe, completely old west to this day. I hear there are places in Montana and Wyoming still like this too. Many Mountain towns are still like this here.

I do think that taxing least and spending least are always good signs of a healthy society and therefore government in an elected Democracy. It's the society that chooses the government after all, and if they choose collectively to be wasteful by spending in programs because they are to lazy to do anything personally that would help with the efficiency of their social order, well they deserve what they get IMO.

The population density does seem to increase along with increased government responsibility being offloaded from the individual. I have read many Sociological and Psychological studies of this, and would posit that another possibility of why this occurs is that humans expect someone else to do what they would like to when there are more people around. One study clearly demonstrated that everyone would assist a person who appeared in trouble in a small crowd while almost no one would in a large crowd. There is a tendency to look the other way and hope someone else will help in large density areas. Education can help alleviate this problem. For instance, even in big cities Neighborhood Watch trainings have brought neighbors together to improve their crime ridden neighborhoods with good success.

I believe we need to educate in this way on a larger scale as it is impractical and inefficient to think of trying to limit urban scales, as some have suggested.

Again, thanks for your examination of my position, it was helpful and fun. :)

by dbertsche

Really weak and a typical liberal response. Most people already have an opinion of GWB's strenghts and weaknesses.

The original issue was to provide alternative solutions not rehash GWB. Your lack of a meaningful response just proves the point of the original post, that liberals don't have any solutions.

There's a group of undecided votes out there, perhaps 5 to 10 percent that are just waiting to here what the liberal's solutions are, but none are ever forthcoming. It's easy to be a monday morning quarterback and criticize the guy in power but much more difficult to provide meaningful solutions. I daresay that if these undecided voters are not convinced the democraps have some solutions that make sense, their boy won't make it to the whitehouse.

Ah, four more years of Bush, won't it be great?

by maxwell edison

.
Why don't you come right out and say what spending bill the President should have vetoed? Be specific, and we may be able to discuss it. You never know, I just may agree with you.

This discussion is closed to new replies.