Discussion Locked

Quintessential qualities of an American...

0 helpful
78 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Well that was a question posed to me by an non-American friend. Definitely, he was alluding to the fact that USA is a land of European Immigrants, mainly, hence takes qualities/properties/characterisitcs pertaining to Europeans. There is an element of truth. But, I think Americans did develop some special attributes in 300-400 years.

Without getting into the merrit of my friend's question, I invite your to say what you think is that uniquely portrays an American. If you are a not an American, say what you perceive that is unique about America.

Canadians and Australians are welcome to say about their country and countrymen..Oops countryperson too :-))))

No wars here please, this post is not to slight anybody. So try to bring out the points positively. :-)))

78 replies

by tomsal

To preface what I say here, realize I am an american myself, I was born in the States, as were my parents and I have never lived outside of the States....

Americans are mostly selfish people...especially between the 18-30 age group, I call this the "ME Generation" because its all about "ME" not "YOU". How do "I" feel, how does it affect "ME"...oh how does it make YOU feel or how does it affect YOU -- I don't care about that, the world revolves around ME...that's what I mean. (As chance would have it I am in the 18-30 age group myself - just barely lol, and no I do not fall into what most would call a selfish person).

The other thing about Americans, on the negative, is we are largely not very fit (as in physically). We are still the country with the largest population of fat people in the world.

Now on the positive end...

Americans , mostly, are VERY proud of their country and I believe would fight for it with deadly intensity, even more so than some other nation's citizens would of their own country.

Also Americans, largely, have -- get ready to gag, but I swear I think its true --- a spirit of caring for those who are down. But the catcher is this.. its only if the person that is down is in the national spot light. So if you need help and have a sad story that's great just make sure its covered by the nationality media and then you'll get tons of sympathy and help.

lol

There's lots more I can say, but hey..I'm bored now..so I'm done.

lol

by oz_media

Just kidding :-) LOL, I won't go there, YET.

I will say that I have left my home in England and dearly miss the people, the history, the open and wecoming nature of the British. People in Canada are said to be the warmest and friendly people around, which in many cities they are, but not even close to the closeness I feel to the British when at home. They absolutely LOVE canadians in England, you are a walking hero when you visit and for this I am very greatful.

As for being in Canada, I live in what has been chosen year after year as one of the top places to live in the world. It is a postcard here, I love by neighbours and small community yet can go to Vancouver in 45 minutes (Helijet) and be in the heart of the downtown bustle.

Today, I could kayak to a marine park in about 20 minutes to watch bald eagles and bears (Whales and sealions soon), I could then go skiing for the afternoon and be sitting in a Vancouver club before watching the Canucks hockey game by dinner time. Sounds like a little bit of an actiuve day but it is quite normal and not a stretch at all. I live in a playground, literally.

Why would I leave? I miss home, England, but money wouldn't do it for me. You'll have to pry my cold dead hands off the trees to get me going.

Now, without taking a SHOT at America, this is exactly why I am so ipssed when people say I am jealous that I am not Americanand don't live there. I find this the most absurd analogy, what do you POSSIBLY have that I don't? I don't like the flag waving, we are the best attitude so why would I join it? It isn't in my upbringing to feel that way toward others, I am not the best and you sure as hell aren't.

by oldefar

You always have to add that last paragraph. I wonder why?

Nice explanation of why you love your adopted land.

by oz_media

I add that because it's true, I think we are being asked to be honest without predjudice.

I have no personal perdjudices against America or ANY of it's citizens. I have said before that I think Americans are seen worldwide as arrogant and obnoxious (observation and experience, most people just roll thier eyes when you mention the US here and say some really nasty things that I have never voiced here). To this i have been told more than once that I am jealous of America, that EVERYONE wishes they lived in America and those that said it have been very serious in thier comments. This makes me fall over with laughter as it couldn't be farther from the truth, yet those who said it were VERY serious in saying it.
This kind of thought process is why people see your citizens as arrogant and obnoxious. I have met a few Americans who are quite humble, until you discuss, war, government or ANY poilitically related topic, then the WE ARE THE BEST attitude comes into play. America is great in many ways, but do you REALLY honestly think that your country and government are a paradigm to be followed? It works for you and that is cool, it doesn't work for me though and MANY others I know would run screaming at the thought.

Don't go assuming that everyone wants to be American, If I couldn't live in Canada or the UK, I would choose Germany, Australia or several other Euro countries with the US being somewhere above IRAN and IRAQ but not too far. Most would put you at the bottom of the pile.

Now if this upsets you, I apologize, I am not out to downplay anyone here, I am just speaking my mind and how I feel MANY others I've met also feel. When in England, if you walk into a bar and you are Canadian, they accept you like family. If they know you're from the US, you are almost sure to get into a fight before the night is out. WHY?

I have also said, it is fine and completely expected for you to be proud of your country, if you weren't I wouldn't expect you to live there.

by tomsal

...yet I must admit I see your points Oz.

Like I said before I'm an American citizen, born and raised in the States and never called another country home.

Selfishness is the most abundant quality I see in my day to day life, even more so than arrogance (which I guess is easier to see if you aren't a citizen of the US).

I basically think, speaking gloabally, that people are people. Which means to say we are all different and not all our peeves, irks, weaknesses, etc. are the cause of some nice and neat heading like "you are American, you are black, you are a blonde, you are Indian, etc etc." - I don't think its that simple really. Bastards live everywhere, so do polite and decent folks.

The problem I see is the former greatly outnumber the latter.

I merely think that its a shame so many of the younger people (again of which I am one) in this country have this attitude of selfishness and another thing I see as an increasing trend in the states at least...everyone has to be a tough guy. I swear everyone I talk to is the toughest guy (in some cases a few women are included) in the world.

That more cracks me up laughing to be honest. I mostly just hide my smirk and go "oh cool".

Finally, in closing this thing... I actually take it as uplifting to know so many countries have a poor regard for the US..because I know I don't fit into that mold and I am an exception to that mentality.

LONG LIVE THE USA ! :)

by oz_media

In stead of taking a defensive and offended stand, you saw the situation with weyes open and agreed, YES there are many people that degrade the reputation of others and these people are making the most noise and being observed more than others.

You then accepted that you are American and have been al yourlife, but you are a DIFFERENT American than most. Well done.

Most people, when confronted with such statements get instantly defensive as if I had spoken thier name and not generalized a population. You separate yourself as independant yet supportive of your country. Others seem to feel that they ARE the country and take instant offense to ANY negativity toward anything you say about America.

When I said I don't give a damn what you think of Canada, people called me unpatriotic etc. Why the hell should I care what you think of Canada, Canadians or myself??? I'm not CANADA I live in Canada?

Anyhow, this will get dragged out by somebody so I'll let it die while I can. Well said sir, be a proud american by all meas and if you notice that society is anal, be different but louder than they are.
Up the Irons!

by hal 9000

But more like the majority who never get noticed as it is always the loud mouthed arrogant bastards who are remembered and not the nice helpful guy.

The media doesn't help here either as they tend to point out the loud mouthed bigots and tend to make people think that they are the "Norm" instead of the exception. I know a lot of American's and I can honestly say that the majority of them are nice people who I could quite willingly spend a few night at a bar with.

However it is always the few who ruin it for the rest of us as they are always shown and are "BAD AMBASSADORS" for their country. I remember the Bazza McKennize that was supposed to be the "typical Australian" of a few years ago and other than a few people who where well and truly drunk and attempting to show off I've never seen an Aussie act like that like shaking up a beer can and then spraying most of its contents all over the place most Aussies would never consider doing this as it would be a waste of precious beer.

Enjoy being a member of the majority as we are never remembered and about the age thing that you mentioned this is just a phase that a lot of people in the Western world are going through after all "Peer Pressure" doesn't end when you leave school it is just a bit more refined.

Col

by onbliss

...is in for call. I am more looking at a set of shared attributes, charactersitics and values that would characterize an American.

by maxwell edison

.
America is the most diverse nation on the face of the earth. I suppose Canada might also fit that description, but there are just too many different cultures and cultural differences within our borders to come up with a set of common characteristics.

It used to be that we were considered a "melting pot", and it might have been, at one time, easier to define. But now, a "tossed salad" might be a better description.

If there are any commonalties that unite us all, I suppose it would be the love of freedom and liberty. But even that, I fear, has given way to the entitlement mentality.

by onbliss

Granted, major cities of America have people from almost every place on earth. But, I would hesitate to call it as 'the most diverse nation'. I believe there are other places that have comparable diversity.

I like your 'tossed salad' description :-))

Regarding love of freedom and liberty, again there are several cultures and people who seek that. It is not unique to America. Don't you think some of the Scandinavian countries are quite comparable regarding freedom?

I know on the whole my quest of finding the qualities/culture of an American might be real stupid. But I have shot out my mouth :-)))))

by oz_media

I think metling pot is derogatory although I hear it too. I prefer potpourri as it is more floral and smells better than slag.

I agree, Canada and the US are entirely built from immigrants of other countries.

I think we both hold a massive multi-cultural population, yet I see more of a MIXED society in Canada than the US where the differences seem more segregated. We don't have ghettos, black and white neighbourhoods etc. BUT we have mainly chinese neighbourhoods, East Indian neighbourhoods etc. I have noticed that the immigrants in the US, are more 'American' than Canadian immigrants become Canadian (a pet peeve). I think that if you move to another country, you should be willing to adopt thier language, lifestyle etc. without losing your beliefs of course.

In Canada, many Asian immigrants, are well...I better keep it to myself but in short, they don't WANT to adopt the English language or Canadian customs and segragate THEMSELVES from mainstream society. I watched a gentleman teachng his son to barter for bottled water at a MAJOR grocery store. These are places with fixed pricing, he stood and argued with the cashier for 5 minutes before people got pissed and urged him to let it go and shop somewhere else. This is an Asian custom where you MUST barter to get a fair price, in Canada with a 12 year old (approx.) son, you DON'T get to barter at a major food store with 17 checkouts filled with paying customers, we'd be there all day!

In the SAME store, different day, an Asian lady was arguing that her flower pot she had bought was broken (it was in about 10 pieces, SMASHED!). The store manager explained that there is absolutely NO way it was sold that way as they are under srtrict regulations to not sell any damaged goods at all. A hairline crack may have been unnoticed but not a smashed vase. She started to just scream, nothing specific, just a wailing. The manager just smiled and walked away leaving her to wail.

What's my point? OK, when I was in teh US in the fall, I was with a friend who is Asian and he wanted to visit his brother in Spokane, when we met, he was more North American than I was. he had a broad US accent and wore a ball cap, smoked Camels and drank Bud. My friend was joking with him that the Chinese community in Canada is still a Chinese community and not even interested in becoming Canadian or English speaking because they have such a massive Chinese community here, they don't need to become 'Canadianized'.

So while we are both multicultural countries, I think Canada allows it's immigrants to remain immigrants and not become North Americanized the way that citizens in the US must in order to make it. I've seen people get Canadian citizenship that need a translator or an Asian version of the citizenship test, we provide the Candadian citizenship test in many languages, WHY? Shouldn't being English speaking be a qualification for becoming a recognized citizen of an English speaking country?

Could be wrong but that's what I have seen and experienced.

by onbliss

Don't you think if the immigrants don't fuse into the new society fully, the nation would have a problem in their hands.

by thechas

The ONLY characteristic that fits ALL Americans is that we are a diverse culture.

Pick ANY other attribute, and you can find a person, city, even a state that does not exemplify that characteristic.

What are relatively common characteristics of Americans:

Arrogant: We are the best, and know what is best for the rest of the word.

Proud: We are number one. Even when we loose.

Isolationist: We don't need to know what is going on in other countries.

Victorian: At least in public, Americans have "Victorian" morals.

Fat: We have some of the most overweight people in the world.

Rules are for the other guy: At least when we are driving our cars, we can violate whatever laws we want. However, that guy driving the car next to us better not!

Sports Nuts: Football and Nascar racing are near religious events.
What are these sissy sports of Soccer, Formula 1, Bicycle Racing, Cricket?

Beer: No explanation needed.

Un-informed: Few Americans actually seek out or contemplate hard news.

Opinionated: I'm right and there is no option for discussion.

Crude: Our humor caters to the lowest common denominator.

Do the above sound bleak?

Yes, we do have many good characteristics.
However, we save those for family and friends. Plus the occasional national disaster.

Chas

by oz_media

Well Chas (and everyone else) I will see your points in a different light. All in good fun OKAY?

Delusional: We are the best, and know what is best for the rest of the word.

In denial: We are number one. Even when we loose

Father knows best: We don't need to know what is going on in other countries, "because we will show them how to do it our way or invade them until they do."

Prudish: At least in public, Americans have "Victorian" morals

Fat: We have some of the most overweight people in the world (I'll give you that one, even though Super size at MacDonalds is now considered large, as if that helps)

Rules are for the other guy: At least when we are driving our cars, we can violate whatever laws we want. However, that guy driving the car next to us better not! (OK, we are all the same there)

Uncultured: Football and Nascar racing are near religious events.
What are these sissy sports of Soccer, Formula 1, Bicycle Racing, Cricket?

Piss: No explanation needed.

UNI-FORMED: Few Americans actually seek out or contemplate hard news, "am I supposed to hate that guy? Who am I supposed to shoot, is he the bad guy?"

Mislead: I'm right and there is no option for discussion

PRUDE: Our humor caters to the lowest common denominator. "Maybe pathetically stupid humor but definitely nto crude or cutting edge"

Anyhow, like I said, just a laff Chas.

by hal 9000

"Peer Pressure" and not the real way people act!

Most people no matter where they are from think that they have to conform to a set of rules and that if they don't they will be ostracized.

While there are some Americans that do behave like this when at home or overseas most act differently and show just how good the people of that country can be however unfortunately it is always the "Bad Apple" who is remembered and not the god guy/gal who stooped and helped you out when whatever happened.

This is a flaw in "Human Nature" to only remember the bad things that they experienced when confronted by foreigner just like it was always better in "The Good Old Days" than it is today most people forget the bad things that they had to accept and only remember the good things that gave them enjoyment/pleasure and not the fact that they had to walk 5 miles bare footed to school each day and then home again afterwords.

While there are some people who truly act the way you described they are not the majority and only the minority who are very noticeable by their actions, however things have detracted within the last 20 years or so as things like common courtesy are not practices as much as they previously where but I think this is more a sign of the times that we live in as now most parents work and can not spend as much time with their children as our parents did and teach them the values that they had.

After all when was the last time you saw a male offer a seat on public transport to a woman if that was to happen now-days it is more than likely he would be slapped with a Discrimination Suit for implying that the woman was somehow inferior and unable to stand. but this is not restricted to the USA but most of the Western World so it really can't be held against the American's.

by wordworker

As someone whose formative years were spent in the USA's buildup to the 200th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, and whose mother painted the bricks along the driveway red, white and blue and planted scores of flags-on-sticks around the house, and listented to Elvis doing "Battle Hymn of the Republic" so many times I could hurl, here's my take. The quintessential American is anybody who still believes in the melting pot.

That's right. To me, quintessential American means tolerance, acceptance, and knowing that getting along peacefully is better than trying to beat up or shoot up the other guy to gain control of the village. Come to America, join the stew. You'll be assimilated, sort of, and the other ingredients will soon be trying to imitate you because they were bored with the old mixture.

I believe people still come to America for the same reasons the Pilgrams did, because they believe you can do anything here.

And you can do anything here, if you get off yer arse and do the work.

Don't speak English [yet]? You can vote for your next metro council member or member of the House of Representatives in Spanish, Vietnamese, Portugese, or whatever languages your state has authorized for elections.

Can you get a job? You can work hard, save and invest and grow your money.

Or blow your live and money on sex, drugs, and rock and roll just like.

And, like anywhere else in the world, you can be a redneck mutha'-f' or a pristine all-for-Jesus-like-Mel-Gibson in 'merica. Or anything in between.

What I hope is quintessential about being an American or coming to America to live for any length of time is this: Enjoying choices. There are lots of them, but you have to make them wisely, because who knows how long they'll last.

by oz_media

The description is fitting of a good novel. You 'painted' such a typical American picture for us, very 1950's Norman Rockwell, Saturday with hotdogs at the ball game.

excellent writing style !

by boxwood

here are my choices for "qualities of americans"
positive-
1. we are diverse individuals that are free to choose many things: education, jobs, religion, and where to live
2. we come together when tragedy strikes: forest fires, earthquakes, 9-11, and hurricanes, etc
3. we are a generous people- giving to countries: medical help and supplies to iran's recent earthquake
4.we are a patriotic people: we support our troops, celebrate fourth of july, and proud to have many historic homes/places from our founders
5. we are a democratic people: we are free to voice our opinions in many media and assemblies
6. we are orderly people: we wait in lines vs people in some european & other countries who will not

a number of years ago, when my mother, daughter, and I were in disneyworld in florida, we were taking the mono rail to epcot.while we all waited patiently in line, a french couple pushed their way in front of everyone to get in the car first. when i told my german friend this, she said that that was the way it is in europe. so we are orderly and wait in line... after line .....after line....for hours of our lives. i believe in britain it is "Que up!".

negative:
1.we can be disrespectful of and rude to others: Impatience makes us this way- we want it now we want to get there now
2.we are aphethetic and take things for granted: not too many will come out to vote unless it is a major election
3.we are materialistic: we have too many choices at times and too many ways to pay for things for the NOW wants
4. our pride gets in the way: we don't take the time to understand others that are different from us in nationality, race, or creed
5. we rush on by with our own lives: we don't make the time to check on our elderly neighbors or even our families

not everyone lives in a nice neighborhood. after living in 4 other towns, i have found our present one to be the best here in NJ, USA. we live here in a small village near the interstate and a larger town. in this village there is no mail delivery so we have to go to the PO and pick up our mail. many of us do this for our elderly neighbors. we also watch each other's homes, pick up each others trash when we see it, and try to share things. my husband uses our lawn tractor to clean up leaves for our land and 5 other homes of people near us- including one man in his thirties who is a carpenter and very busy . if we need this man to help lift or move something, he will always will help us. large cities and many communities don't always have this caring between neigbors-we need to improve this.

BTW, NJ is the most heavily populated state in the USA. the joke is that you give directions to your home by what exit of the Interstate, Parkway, of Turnpike you live next to. for nearly all of us, it is the truth.

by hal 9000

Once upon a Time Long Ago in a Galaxy Far away I was the Queensland Service Manager of a company and we had a brand new product being launched so an "Expert" was sent out from the factory in Switzerland to be their Representative here in Australia.

Now the product launch was scheduled all around Australia but Queensland was the first place it was held and there where some problems so this poor guy was rushed up from Sydney to help out, at this time he had been in Australia all of 30 hours and spoke next to no english or maybe it is better to say he had not a perfect comprehension of the language.

When he arrived in Brisbane the Queensland Sales Manager approached him and asked him did he think that a 90% failure rate was acceptable to which this guy replied quite quickly "Yes this is a good record" the sales manager then went on to ask him some more questions about the product and on every fault that we had found he keep t saying that it was OK but it was obvious to me that he wasn't comprehending the questions and only aggravating the sales manager who by this stage had blood vessels straining to burst in his head so I suggested I take this guy aside and show him the problem that we where experiencing as he obviously didn't understand what he was being asked "not a normal procedure for me to be the peace keeper."

Anyway the person in question wasn't all that experienced in the product and to make it even worse he was an "Electronics Guru" and we where experiencing mechanical problems so he was next to useless to help in our problems.

Now for the fun part after I had fully explained to him the problems that we had been experiencing and he proved to be of no use I suggested that I take him to the Hotel/motel where he was booked in so he could get some sleep as he was obviously jet-lagged and more of a hindrance around the place. Well he thought this was a good idea and I needed him out of the place before the sales manager murdered him so I took him to the hotel and got him a "counter lunch" and a few drinks before I sent him off to sleep it off.

When the meal arrived he started an all out brawl with the waitress as what he was offered was not what he ordered seems that he had ordered a T-Bone Steak and he expected something a lot smaller that the 4 pound bit of meat that he received, that meant another role as peace keeper and eventually he began to realize that what was served as food over here was different to what he was used to in Switzerland.

Anyway after 5 years here he was promoted and moved to the USA which came as another "culture shock" to the poor guy who by that stage had become quite used to our laid back style of doing things and wasn't prepared for the way Americans did things.

The last time I ever heard from him was about 3 years after he moved to America and he while likening the place still wanted to come back here as we had more fun in our work than he was experiencing there.

I guess you all could say I was a bad influence on him as I was the first person who showed him that when you where called for something that you didn't have to jump and run to whatever but you could sit back and have a few drinks before you had to go wherever and eventually he began to get the idea of what was important and what could be put off for a few minutes while you enjoyed you're self as you didn't need to kill you're self every time you where called out on a job.

Col

by onbliss

...can be gathered from what you said.

It is so sad that our society has degnerated to such an extent that a Man needs to think million times before offering a seat to lady. But you are right, this feature remains maily in the Western world. And, only hope it does not spread.

by maxwell edison

.
America is a land of immigrants. And other than Canada, I can't think of another nation that's even close in terms of diversity of culture. You might say France and England, I suppose, and I'd have to admit that others would be more qualified than I to make such a claim (since I've never been to either country). But from my understanding I'll stand by my comments. Which country do you think has more diversity of culture than Canada or the USA?

My "love of freedom and liberty" comments might require an understanding of my premise. Sure, America is certainly not alone in its love of freedom and liberty, at least in the sense that the opposite might be seen as some form of dictatorship. However, my premise would suggest that any socialistic tendencies on one hand require the forfeiture of certain freedoms and liberties on the other. For example, the Scandinavian countries that you mentioned, Sweden in particular, are among the most socialistic in the world. I suppose they might even refer to themselves as social-democracies. In order to maintain such systems, the government must take, by force, personal property (money) from one citizen in order to give it to another, whether that transfer be in the form of actual money, goods, or services. I believe that the mere act of seizing personal property (money) from its citizens takes away that citizen's freedom and liberty, at least in part. I believe this especially holds true when it's done for the purpose of funding social programs. And just because a citizen freely allows it, doesn't mean it isn't true. If a citizen chooses to give up freedoms and liberties in order to maintain a socialized society, they're still given up. And what does that mean to the citizen who would prefer not to participate in such a system. That person's liberties are literally trampled upon. So, like it or not, for better or worse, Americans, as a whole, are slowly but surely giving up their freedoms and liberties in return for, what they perceive, as a little personal social security. (And I mean "social" security, not as the program, even though that's part of it, but as a whole.)

As for my "melting pot" turned "tossed salad", it used to be that the immigrants who came to America would be, more or less, assimilated into a more common culture. One of the first things people would do, for example, is learn the language. All one has to do is look at the Spanish-English debate to see that it is no longer the case. I'm not suggesting that it's good or bad, but that it just is.

But if I had to name one "quality" of an American that always has and still does apply, I would suggest that it is the ability to be anything that you want to be - even if it's a failure to realize that.

by onbliss

..about my hesitancy in calling USA as the most diverse nation. I live in USA and can see that. I thought the usage of "one of the most" would have been better.
Anyway I was not thinking of England or France for being diverse :-)))) Certainly not. LOL

The answer in short would be India. But I was thinking of mostly countries like China, Czhec and Yugoslavia (in their previous incarnations), Russia, CIS countries

It is futile to debate which country has the most diverse culture, traditions and population. As we can always see some homogeneousity or heterogeneousity as the way we want it.

But were'nt the earlier immigrants mostly Engslish speaking? Ofcourse several Northern Europeans did come over here. What role do you think the ethinicity played in the assimilation process. I am sure the Spanish Europeans mingled better than the Hispanic people. Maybe there is an element of race, color, creed or whatever....Just a thought. You might cite that African-Americans, who probably brought more diversity, assimilated better. But they were brought far far in the earlier days. Situation and Time forced them to integrate faster and better. I might be totally wrong. Feel free to correct me.

by oz_media

Well I won't speak for Fracne, the laqst time I was in France there was NO cultural diversity to speak of, other than tourists it seems everyone is Parisienne.

As for England, England is within itself a melting pot of diversity, not due to immigration but just all the damn dialects and slangs. From one end to the other you feel like you are meeting foreigners all the time. Everyone speaks differently and acts differently, very entertaining. On a multicultural perspective, as a British Commonwealth East Indian's are VERY common in England but most I've seen are VERY British. They have generally attended British schools and studied in England, they are just slightly better tanned than thier sun starved skinned UK brothers.

It was funny about a year ago, while visiting my mothers stationery store, there was an East Indian man and a Chinese man in the line at the cashier which is very common here and I didn't think twice about it. Then I realized they were friends and were together, this is EXTREMELY strange (for adults anyway, school kids intermingle a little better that adults).

When they got to the counter, the Chinese man had an Cockney accent, living in Vancouver at the time, I was rolling on the floor at the sound of a chinese man with a cockney accent. I asked where they were from and the East Indian man said East London to whi ch i was more amused to hear an East Indian Cockney accent. It is just SO rare to hear these 'immigrants' with such a native UK tongue. They were laughing at it as they had also noticed that Chinese people here speak Chinese, East Indians speak Hindi etc.

As British commonwealth nations, East Indians and Chinese have been living in England for many years and several generations later, they are completely LOCAL and I am the immigrant in comparisson.

There is a massive East Indian and Chinese population in England BUT they are so 'local' you don't see them as immigrants, whereas in Canada, they simply don't assimilate as there is such a huge asian culture and East Indian culture in Vancouver. They have community centers, malls where you can't even begin to read the signs, thier own schools, churches, mosques, universities, we even have the Hong Kong Bank of Canada here.

another thing that's just popped nito my head as I type this is, in English speaking Canada, ALL labels of products in stores MUST have French AND English labelling on them. You just turn the box over, flip the instructions around or read the other side of the can whether you need English or French. This is a LAW.

I have seen Indian/Chinese/Japanese/Vietnamese and Korean stores and markets where nothing even has English on it?!? You can go past a mall and not know what a single store sells as the signs are nowhere near something I could decipher. Yet alone in French AND English.

These cultures are allowed to simply retain thier culture without problems, yet the English speaking Canadians must SHARE thier culture with the French Canadians.

Hmmmm?!?

by maxwell edison

.
...."one of the most". (Because it's probably a matter of definition and/or perception, anyway.)

One of the differences, however, is the absence (in America) of large scale conflict and battle (generally speaking) between the various cultures that existed (or still exists) in many of those other countries/regions, the Czech Republic being only one such an example. One group pitted against another, and so on. (And what I hope doesn't happen in a future America) After all, isn't that one of the things that drew many people to America in the first place - to escape such circumstances?

The avoidance of such an environment is/was, I believe, uniquely American (North American) in that these various cultural groups were, somewhat, assimilated into one, rather than remaining separate, but within a common border. That's a reason I am very reluctant to adapt any hyphenated description of an American. I believe that any and all Americans could be hyphenated, so let's just drop the hyphen. I don't think is serves to bring us closer together as one, but rather separates us by our different cultures.

And no, the early immigrants weren't all English speaking. Sure, many of them were - especially in the 18th century. But even then there were French and Dutch and Spanish. And all throughout the 19th and into the 20th centuries came immigrants from Ireland, Germany, Poland, Sweden, Italy, and more, not to mention the immigrants from China and Japan that populated the west coast. It wasn't until the mid to late 20th century, with a large influx of Spanish speaking immigrants, primarily from Mexico, was a "common language" even questioned.

By the way, I'm extremely uncomfortable contributing to such an off-topic discussion. I'm walking on egg-shells, here, running the risk of offending someone (again), even if it's unintentional. One more such incident, and you will see Maxwell Edison disappear into cyber la-la land.

by oz_media

I know what you mean about walking on eggshells, but I don't think that's realy neccessary. TR doesn't want us to FEAR each other more than not to directly insult or point a finger. A generalization of a given race or country is not offense (or shouldn't be) as it is observation and not personal attack.

Relax, we can all take it on the chin here, just don't poke people in the eye.

by oz_media

nor do I really care at this point. I am not native Canadian so who am I to talk right?

In fact if the natives had thier way, WE would live on money starved reserves and be gambling in thier casinos, drinking in thier bars etc.

I don't think ANYONE here has a right to say who stays and who doesn't, we took the land from the indians and are ALL immigrants ourselves. How can we now start placing rules on who must do what? Most Canadians resent the down and out native population that as just given up and decided to become victims of society. Then there are the 'four nations' of indians who most have the highest respect for as well as the land which they have so carefully preserved and fought for all this time.

Just like Americans, however you probably feel it is YOUR country now, we are all just immigrants and have no rightful say towards other immigrants.

by oz_media

Hi Colin, when you say "After all when was the last time you saw a male offer a seat on public transport to a woman if that was to happen now-days it is more than likely he would be slapped with a Discrimination Suit for implying that the woman was somehow inferior and unable to stand. but this is not restricted to the USA but most of the Western World so it really can't be held against the American's. "

I see your point but I don't see the reality here at all. In fact if you DIDN'T give up your seat someone would be giving you the evil eye. It is only common courtesy to open doors and offer you seat to women and of course elderly people. The whole being PC game has tired here and has become common courtesy instead of a learned or practiced behaviour.

Women have been given respect and treated equally for as long as I remember and therefore don't feel like they are being patronized by courtesy.

We can treat'em like ladies wine'em and dine'em but they'll still wear a double-can beer hat to a hockey game and rough it in the woods with the best of us.

by hal 9000

Particularly about the "PC" there will always be a small minority that adversely affects the majority of people.

Over this side of the pond I constantly see things on TV where people are just unwilling to help their fellow man. Recently we had a guy's car break down on a main road just north of Brisbane and he jacked it up and was under it when it fell on him killing him apparently he lay there dead for the best part of a day without anyone even noticing even though there was a police speed trap 100 meters up the road.

He was only discovered dead when some guy who had seen him there that morning and was returning from work saw him still there and apparently still in the same place that someone stooped and had a look to see if they could offer any help I think that they worked out that he'd been dead for 12 hours by then.

When I'm on the road and stop to see if I can offer any help to someone who has broken down they at first seem afraid of just why I stopped and what do I want from them. I can remember when I was younger that you would never consider not stopping when you saw someone in trouble on the side of the road but now it is the exact opposite.

by onbliss

Now that you tell this, I might be comfortable with a normal youth (not a freaked out one :-0 ) stopping to help than say anybody else.

Is it because a youth (child) ooze so much of innocence that age destroys?

by oz_media

When in auto school I used to drive up and down the East West connector in Vancouver just looking for people to help as a way to practice simple troubleshooting and diagnostic skills. I'd pull up and get my various testers out and go at it on the roadside. Made a tonne of tips (although not my focus as I would make $30/hr in the shop), and some very happy new friends.

I invited a former talent scout to stay with me in BC and tour the Island in my motorhome for a few days. He came up from Oregon and we were driving the Island Highway when I found my second tank guage had failed and I ran out of the jiuce.

It was 15 Km to the nearest town and we weren't sure if there was a gas station there so we just grabbed the gas can and started walking. He was sure nobody would pick us up and said it would be faster if we just walked instead of looking back all the time.

I don't think we made it 100' before a native indian couple picked us up. My friend was unsure about the ride but I was jumping in the back of thier truck so he reluctantly followed.
They drove us to the NEXT town, the first didn't have gas, and also drove us back to the motorhome. Round trip, 30-40 minutes (HOURS on foot though).

When we got back, I offered to make them a drink (fully stocked bar in my motorhome)and they said they didn't drink. I practically forced them to take $30 I had in my pocket, they were almost offended by the offer, they wouldn't even have lunch as I was stopped I figured may as well make lunch.

Before they drove away, I said how kind they had been and how grateful I was of thier unhesitated help and the woman just said, "Make sure you pass our kindness to someone else one day". I have.

The guy that was visiting from Oregon was stunned and couldn't stop talking about the helpful people from out of nowhere. All the rest of the trip he never forgot what they had done.

He moved to the Island about two months later and now works with me full time as I've closed my US scouting offices.

As much as I say Oregon is like BC, he adamantly disagrees and said the people woudl NEVER have helped him that way at his former home.

So prehaps it is rare, perhaps it is scary to some people, but in Canada, we ALL look out for each other this way. We are never too busy to stop what we are doing to help pick up someone else who has fallen, no matter wha thier race, religion or country of origin.

Stories like this will come from ALL corners and towns in Canada, and when I travel, I hear quite often how some happy Canadian has helped others when visiting Canada. Maybe that's another reason we have such a good reputation in other countries, we take an interest in the people here and take the time to help each other without question.

by onbliss

...well I felt uncomfortable bringing this up to. But, I thought what the heck, we techies have better sense and can judge when a thread is not to insult any human being.

I was just curious.

BTW, I am not going to get offended, I might disagree but that is different.

Thanks for your contribution. I am begining to see some answers.

[quote]
"The avoidance of such an environment is/was, I believe, uniquely American (North American) in that these various cultural groups were, somewhat, assimilated into one, rather than remaining separate, but within a common border"
[/quote]

I think the point your express here is very remarkable and insightful. Truly it is unique.

by hal 9000

back when I was younger even 20 years ago which would have put me close to 30 it was considered perfectly natural to stop and offer help to anyone who suffered a breakdown after all I do live in Australia where the distances between towns are great and you can wait days on some roads before you see another car/bike. But now it al is different and I now only see the "Old Codgers" like me still offering help to total strangers whit no intention of any gain other than that nice warm feeling that you know you have helped out someone in trouble as best you could.

Back when I was in my late teens it was perfectly natural for people to hitch hike to the Beach for the weekend so they could do their civic duty and work as Life Savers on the beach like one of my wifes brothers. I even worked in the "State Emergency Service" way back then as we all considered it our responsibility and while it was all volunteer work and sometimes you where required to attend horrific scenes to extract dead and near dead from the wreckage of whatever we all managed to get by without any form of counseling other than a few beers after the job.

Now we see far more graphic violence on the TV and are more shocked when we see some traffic accident with a bit of blood so the new group rush off for the counseling that they think they require. I can still remember attending a traffic collision where the bonnet of the car had come into the cockpit and removed the front passengers heads from about the shoulder up and these bits had rolled out onto the bonnet for all to see. We naturally covered them up and waited for the Police to come and take their photos and then we removed the bodies from the car after first extracting the kids from the rear seats and placing them in an ambulance and sending them to the nearest hospital. It was always ave those who could be saved and then think about the dead and we never experienced any real problems as we all spoke to each other about any ill feelings that we had after attending these scenes. But today it is the opposite as people tend to think they have to be the tough guy/gal and never show any emotion so they bottle all these feelings up and at some time in the future they break down and suffer for years after. I really think that the way we used to do things was far better as everyone that I ever worked with back then has always gone on to lead productive lives no matter what they do.

Anyway enough ranting for now I'll slap my wrists hard for going so far off topic.

Col

by fluxit

The American character is broad based collectively and uniquely formed individually. American principles are documented in the Constitution and Bill of of Rights. As adventurers we are willing and driven to explorer. In brief American's, namely United States citizens, are a principled people who are adventurers. They are also compassionate.

As the explorer American's reach for the stars, trek to the outer reaches of continents, and probe into the subatomic levels of Universe.

As a principle nation, the exploration is used to provide dignity to life and strengthen lifestyles. For example, exploration in computing has lead to products that now are used in underdeveloped nations to share medical knowledge and diagnose conditions. People are also able to expand markets providing incomes to those who otherwise would have never had access to other markets around the world. Thus bringing up incomes and increasing the dignity of life.

by hal 9000

That was very well worded and covers everything good in the USA which everyone should aspire to.

Col

by hereinoz

There is no doubt that the average cizen of the USA - I shy away from using "American", as America is actually a large continent, with many different countries involved - is a compassionate and free thinking person.

At a National level, when the US people are considered as a group - a Crowd, if you like, with reference to the book by Gustav Le Bon, there does appear to be a lack of introspection.

There does not seem to be an ability for self analysis on a National basis, to allow for the necessary self appraisal to appreciate their effect on others. There seems to be this feeling of "rightness" among the "US Crowd", that doesn't seem to be there as much on a personal level.

This leads to the US being considered the "international bully" by many countries, when in reality, on a person to person basis, they felt they were only tring to help.

The US, as a crowd, just doesn't seem to appreciate it's affect on others, when it does what it feels is the right thing.

Alan

by oldefar

Most US citizens are no more than third generation. They, their parents, or their grandparents on at least one side of the family left Europe or Asia or Africa or Central or South America or the Middle East to start a new life in America.

Right or wrong, the individuals who immigrated did so with a firm belief that what they were leaving behind was nowhere near worth the opportunity of the American dream - the idea that an individual's own efforts rather than society or circumstance would shape his future and the future for his children. That America was a work in progress in which he and his family could participate and shape into a better life than the "old country" offered.

The idea that someone could easily relocate is relatively recent. The ability to maintain close communication with those left behind was unheard of. Mail was the best that could be done, and maybe a one time trip back before one died. So these immigrants were deeply committed to this idea of a land of opportunity.

This attitude was passed down to children and grandchildren. No matter where the family was from, they now were Americans. Something new, something better, something special.

The links to home, the attempts to maintain a cultural identity with the point of origin is recent. Partly based on the ease of travel and communication today, and partly from fourth and fifth generation Americans digging into the family past.

The swagger many in the world view as uniquely American is based in large measure on this immigration. Severing one's roots, being the first generation in a new land without the support of an established social position is not for the feint hearted. Such a move comes only with an adventurous heart or with such a desperate state that no hope remains in their homeland.

Now this action also makes a statement about those who chose to remain - that they lacked the courage or gumption to strike out anew, or were part of the established power that created such a miserable state as to make someone choose the unknown. Not a happy thought, and one that many countered and still counter by deriding the American experiment. Of course, derision breeds arrogance breeds derision and so on. At the same time, severing ties to home brings with it a strong need to establish new ties. This is part of the American, uniquely American (?), patriotic ferver that is so easy to trigger with Americans. Roots that don't go deep had better go wide.

It is a bit foolish for those not directly involved to play along with such actions, but such is the nature of mankind.
------
I don't mean any slight to native American Indians, descendants of slaves, or those whose American roots go back to the Revolutionary War or before. Nor those Hispanics who settled in the West when most of the early Northern Europeans thought anything beyond the Appalacian Mountains was desert. It is simply that most of us Americans cannot claim such deep roots in this land.

Those who do have such deep roots have also embraced the American dream, even when prejudice from the "new" majority tried to deny them a place in it. We continue to be a work in progress and strive to live up to our proclaimed ideals.

by dc_guy

1. Americans are risk takers, not risk avoiders.
2. Americans regard rules and authorities as challenges to overcome, not constraints to live by.
3. Americans are individualists. Their first priority is to themselves, second to family, then to community..., finally to country, and dead last to humanity as a whole.
4. Americans think our system, our culture, our language, everything American is better than that in the rest of the world.
5. Americans will hang onto a trend far beyond the point that most people would say "this isn't working any more." Then the pendulum swings just as far in the other direction. Drug prohibition/drug use. Sexual repression/sexual promiscuity. Religion/secularism. Science/pseudoscience. Intellectualism/ignorance.

by onbliss

because, I don't know why..... :-)))))

I concur with you...infact your points don't belong just to the business world.

Ofcourse, I would think #3, more in a positive light and less with negative connotation. It has its merrits and demerrits.

But on the whole, I think you have summed up it well. I am looking at the positive aspects, discounting the negative connotations.....

by oz_media

Without flaming you or Americans, I see your points as extremely accurate but I don't think OTHERS outside America see these as personal qualities more than hinderances.

1) I'll give you, except that I think that attacking Iraq was AVOIDING risk as I believe it it was said to be a preemptive invasion.

2) From the outside looking in, I see the opposite. No rules are broken, authoritry is followed to the letter or else you are being unpatriotic or unAmerican. Perhaps I've generalized you point but you were not specific when making it. The President rules and that is that whether you like it or not, you MUST agree.

3) Individualists, this is OK but is alsio seen as self centered or egotistical by many, where these are not personal qualities that are admired. The everyman for himself, or get out of my way attitude is not too productive or at least not seen as productive anywhere I've lived.

4)This is just plain arrogance, you don't have a language, you have a dialect of English. your culture is one made of everyknown culture in the world, not 'AMERICAN' culture. But you did say Americans THINK this, so it just expresses an arrogant frame of mind.

5)Hanging onto trends? America is probbaly the most trend focused place I've seen but these trends change more often than Cher in concert.
Music is flavor of the week, clothes are a weekly thing etc. As far as the pendulum, I see it swings from right to center, back to right, back to center. As much as the left tries to pull it, it doesn't swing past center.

NOW...this is NOT an attack in anyway shape or form on YOUR beliefs, or the american society. It is an observation to show the contrast in what you see as qualities and why people outside America don't see these qualities in you.

What you see as positive, others have been taught to see as negative traits in buidling an open and accepting society.

This also expains how someone like myself can see you as arrogant or self centered, while you see the exact same actions as being patriotic or true to your country. What you see as positive, others see as negative. This is quite confusing in te case of say Iraq, where you all said you were saving yourselves from future attacks, make that LIBERATING Iraq, but others didn't see it as the great humanitarian effort you want them to see, including more Iraqi's everyday.

It helps yourselves, which by your statement is a positive thing, but others see as a negative thing. Where you see you are helping Iraqi's, others think you are in it for yourselves. Perhaps this whole fuss over the war is simply a matter of perception where neither side is wrong, whether for or against the effort. We just see different reasons for it.

Maybe it is BETTER to actually consider how you will be perceived before taking such bold actions? Perhaps not, I don't know myself as it is just observation and thought.

Al I can say is that America looked bad to the rest of the world for many years, it was HATED by others as you have seen through the attacks upon your soldiers and citizens.

In the coming years it may be beneficial to find a leader who knows how to deal with foreign affairs and utilize America as a positive player globally. You sure could use some Brownie points these days.

by hal 9000

Australia is even younger and we only had our 1st centenary a few years ago.

Granted this country/island started out as a penal colony but a lot of immigrants did come out here as well and that number grew long before the convict era ended, we however while being proud of our achievements do not go on to think that we should tell everyone how to act or what to do.

I think that being a "Superpower" has a lot to do with the beliefs of a lot of you're countrymen/women and that is where the main
difference lies.

There are many other countries around the world who have suffered Terror Tactics for a very long time but have never started a full scale war in multiple countries after a single incident {which granted was horrific but did not kill as many as it could have if executed properly. It could have and should have been a lot worse than what it was!}

If America is a "Work In Progress" then Australia is a younger version of that Work and many years younger as well but we do not get all hot under the collar when someone says something against our Political Masters most of us who are not of a Political mind are in all likelihood willing to agree with the spoken statement or maybe go even further and it is very unlikely that any adverse comment against AU will raise the storm of protests that are raised in the USA when the same thing is done. Granted there will be a few who go out all gung ho to support the AU government or its institutions but most of us are just unwilling to go to those extremes as we mostly feel it isn't worth the effort and only feeds the other parties thought patterns.

Col

by maxwell edison

.
Colin, you said, "There are many other countries around the world who have suffered Terror Tactics for a very long time but have never started a full scale war in multiple countries after a single incident."

The 9-11 terrorist attack on America wasn't the first. It wasn't even the first executed on American soil.

An overview:

In 1983, 17 were killed by a car bomb at the U.S. embassy in Beirut, Lebanon.

In 1983, 241 were killed by an attack on a Marine barracks in Beirut, Lebanon.

In 1983, 16 were killed in a bombing at the U.S. Embassy in Beirut, Lebanon.

In 1986 Pan Am flight 103 was blown up - 270 killed, mostly Americans.

An Iraqi intelligence agent, Ramzi Yousef, planted a large bomb at the World Trade Center in 1993. The intended result was meant to topple the city's tallest tower onto the twin tower, amid a cloud of cyanide gas. The "large scale" intention failed, but it did kill 6 and injure over 1,000 people. It was intended to kill tens of thousands.

In 1993 a plot to kill a former U.S president (by using a car bomb) was foiled.

In 1995, 5 were killed when a bomb exploded at a U.S. military installation in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

In 1996, 19 were killed and over 500 injured in a bombing of a U.S. barracks in Dhahran, Saudi Arabia.

In 1999, terrorist bombers attacked the U.S. Embassies in Nairobi, Kenya and Dar es Salaam, Tanzania. In Nairobi, 34 Embassy personnel were killed, including 12 Americans and 22 Kenyans. In Dar es Salaam, 8 Tanzanian employees of the Embassy were killed. In total, blasts killed 213 and injured almost 5,000 in Nairobi and killed 11 and injured 72 in Dar es Salaam.

17 U.S. sailors were killed and 39 wounded in the attack on the USS Cole in 2000.

9-11 was the preverbal straw that broke the camel's back.

Enough is enough. After 20 years of being targeted by international terrorists, the U.S. finally acted to defend ourselves against any and all international terrorists.

(P.S. Not intended to start a tangent to this discussion, but just to correct a misstatement.)

by hal 9000

On US MAINLAND SOIL by foreign agents.

But you forgot to mention the overrunning of the US Embassy on Iraq after the toppling of the Sh-ar of Iran and I'm sure that there have been others as well on US bases in other countries but foreign terror activities on Mainland USA have been very few and far between in comparison to some other countries Britain comes to mind right now when the hotel where the British Prime Minister was staying was bombed in an attempt to kill her. Of course they failed in that attempt but did get a few Cabinet ministers killed.

Actually I don't want to start anything here either I was just making a statement which I should have worded better.

Col

by oldefar

There are some key differences between Australia and America that you might have missed. The age of America is in my opinion a minor aspect in trying to understand the "quintessential" aspects of the American attitude.

Key difference one - America was a direct break with the established European experience by design. Australia and Canada are extensions of the British experience.

Key difference two - Americans feel they are a new experiment in nationhood based on that break with the past. Without the break, I suspect other nations feel they are evolving, part of the long history of European statehood, if they think about it at all.

Key difference three - Americans have traditionally been critisized by Europeans as upstart bumpkins going back to the 18th century. This is reflected in the writings of both Americans and Europeans of the time.

Key difference four - Measured as a factor of power to time, something about the American experience worked. We of course like to believe it is our attitude and beliefs, our emphasis on individuals and on freedom, rather than any factor of time or place.

Being a superpower has little importance to most Americans. I believe the fact that Canada and Mexico have not been absorbed or even flooded with American migrants reflects our isolationist attitude and counters the claim of imperialist ambitions. I am sure our neighbors prefer to believe it is because we fear their just and powerful response if we dared cast our imperialistic designs in their direction.

by hal 9000

Applies equally well to most of the Western world and should not be confined to just the USA alone in both the positive and negative aspects.

Col

by oz_media

Leaning proper comprehension will allow you to read an view point that is not targeted toward yourself and understand it is an observation or a view point. I have stated clearly that it is simply an OUTSIDE to INSIDE view not a personal opinion. You see, when I say people see you as.... People take offense and ask where I got such an idea. I am starting to see why our views of you are so different than your views of yourself.

What many have stated either as qualities or just realities of the 'American atitude' are what we see negatively in other countries.

For example, you see yourselves as compassionate, wheras others see you as self centered. While some say American's are looking out for others, others say you are stickig your nose in other people's business, Iraq was supposedly a nice jesture from America to save the Iraqi's from repression, yet an Iraqi I've met who 'accidentally' lost some family members in a door to door check(she called it a raid) but the Americans are 'checking' residences was extrenely upset that America had invaded her home country of Iraq as she saw nothing wrong with the way it was, at least not directly upon herself.

When some have said you look out for yourselves other will see that as arrogance. It's all perception, how others perceive you is not always the way you see yourself. How is THAT a bash on America?

Unless someone says they LOVE America does that mean that they are bashing America? Do you really think EVERYONE loves your country as much as you do?

What's wrong with Canada or a Canadian expressing an opinion?

You should rename your alias Hybernates-at-the-wheel. You just lay dormant until you can complain about someone without offering input towards a discussion, is there a reason why?

Is it personal insecurity or are you just feeling grunpy?

On second thought, don't bother with an answer, it's not worth discussing with you, but thanks for your input anyway, I'll take it for what it is. Next time you are pissed, try addressing me directly instead of complaining to the TR peers for support. I can take it AND dish it out, don't worry just ask me.

by boxwood

These kind of questions are good for thought and nice to have as answers for a foreign business associate. Honesty is what the person is looking for and not a polished view of ourselves.
I had to answer this myself when an Indian man came to work with us. the discussions, pro and con, were on for over 2 years. Eventually HE became and American, worked with us for 30 years and is very happy here. He said that those discussions helped him to decide on many things.
What are the qualities that YOU feel are good and bad for this description?
we need your input, too, so that someone can view them all.

by oz_media

I may as well start shouting stop hitting me, you're not but I'm not bashing America slow down and take a deeeeeep breath.

Man, what's the deal with that?

Nobody else has been upset, we are all grown ups here and can accept each others views, or at least we're supposed to be, leave it at that and move on, NEXT!!

by boxwood

Here is a story from the 1970's when our country was taking in immigrants from Laos, etc. of people that had befriended the Americans during that war. A family of 5 came to America and was being sponsored by a group. This group put the family in a home of one of the members, who gave them food, used the home for the donations of clothing and furniture.
Doesn't this sound nice? unknown to the group, this American, took most of the furniture for themselves, and a lot of the clothing, put this family in their unfinished basement, fed them mostly hot dogs, and didn't let them have any privacy sceens, [or hang a sheet even] for privacy. this member had had an immigrant family before, too.
Now what opinion do you think the Laoian family had of America?
This went on for several weeks until the family [luckily] had a friend further south and convinced the group that this friend would get a job at a certain hospital for him. The group tranferred the sponsorship to a group that I belonged to and I happened to be the one living closet to their then apartment. Through pantomine, and broken english, the wife told me her experiences and her husband , who is a nurse and speaks English, helped too. [I had to help the man learn that nurses here just don't do surgeries, repair broken limbs and tha the had to go by the rules- in Laos ,then, there were only 2 doctors and the nurses did surgeries of the war victims- it was a tough adjustment]It took a gentle ,caring approach from our group, and hours of conversation with me, to try and UNDO what their first "sponsor family" did to them. I had to explain that not all of Americans do this and what the others did was wrong. I asked them why they didn't speak out about this- what could they say? they were afraid of deportation- they had fled from laos through thailand to escape, sold the wife's wedding rings to buy food, arrived in the US in the dead of winter with summer clothes on their back, etc. and crossed a river. It was difficult time for them and an extreme embarassment for our group. We did everything to undo the unjust hurt that they received. Today, this man and his with are Americans themselves, they know that not all Americans are this way, they know the good points about America and have recently had a few of their relatives come and live here.
The point of this story is, of course, that we have good points, bad points, good people, bad people but on the whole most of us here try to help others understand that we are the americans who put all of our scandals on the front pages and open media to all the world. we aren't trying to hide things and, due to this, we hear all kinds of comments. We aren't perfect and we know that, too. I think, though, that it is every American's responsibility to come up front with the good and bad qualities that make up an "American". The foreigners and immigrants that I know have all appreciated this honesty.

by tomsal

I have to admit I was laughing pretty damn hard at TheChas's post...thanks I usually am not luaghing so early on a Tuesday.

I don't know about if all those things he joked about apply to americans in general but my god they immediately made me associate those qualities to certain people in my life.

Anyways..people definitely succumb to peer pressure and putting on an act. Sad but true, you'd think this stuff ends with our teenage years but nope..full grown adults still play these games.

Have I ever succumbed to peer pressure , honestly I can think of only two times I did my whole life -- other than that I've always been my own person (sometimes that hasn't been a good thing, I'll admit...but hey at least I'm true to myself right?).

I have a very dear friend who used to anger me all the time when I first met her..she plays the peer pressure "I must act this way around this person or I won't be liked" thing all the time. We had countless fights (arguments) over it time and again, but finally over the years she FINALLY knows to be herself with me at least all the time. But its still a shame I see her act differently to conform to a few other people.

Oh well..I guess some people can never change..at least not all the way.

by hal 9000

Back in those days I used to drag a 20 foot "Stock Whip" in behind me and a pair of handcuffs and then proceed to tell all the trainees that if any of them "Fucked Up One Of My Machines" I'd handcuffs them to a hook in the wall and proceed to whip the living SHIT out of them and when I'd finished I'd whip them some more for the mess that they had made on the carpet and no it wasn't really concerned with computers other than the fact that some of the machines where "Microprocessor controlled."

As I knew all these people fairly well they all understood exactly what I meant which was if you have a problem ask and we'll all fix it rather than wreck the machine but on one occasion it did lead to some interesting actions. We had a problem with the AUstralian release of a product and since my state branch was the first to hose the release we naturally where a "Testing Ground" for the product release. Now when these problems started occurring the Sales Manage panicked and called his bosses in Sydney and as they didn't have an answer and certainly didn't like mine which was to change the fabric for one of the promotions as we where experiencing a 90% failure rate but the units all worked perfectly on different fabric and all passed their mechanical/electronic adjustments with out a problem. But it was inconceivable to the Sales Department that something as simple as a bit of fabric could be the problem so they sent up "The Guy" from the factory who spoke next to no english and had only arrived within the last 24 hours. He was far more of a hindrance than any help and made my life far harder than it needed to be but then "Them's the breaks."

What I did find really funny was that when I started the "Mechanical Training Side" of the introduction with all the Techies I just followed my normal practices and used the stock whip etc. Well this poor guy from Switzerland nearly fell off his chair in horror and at the lunch break then proceeded to attempt to get one of the dealers to make a complaint about my method of training and he could get rid of me and have me replaced with someone who treated them much better. After he approached each one they all came in and told me what was going on but what he found a bit hard to understand was that none of these people would ever consider making any form of complaint about me and he was even more horrified when after the break which I had to work through for a rush order I returned to the lesson room and then began with "It has come to my attention that if just one of my so called friends was willing to make a complaint about the way I treat you lot I could get some peace and quite and be away from this bloody place and not have any of you lot constantly on my back about all you're problems." Well the poor guy this time really did fall off his chair while the rest laughed.

Just before he left AU 5 years latter I ran into him and he commented that while I had an odd way of dealing with people at training courses that they where the most effective that he had ever seen but he didn't think that most people could pull it off and he was just beginning to understand how I ticked. But what he really couldn't understand was exactly all the dealers reacted the way that they did and all of them loved the way I treated them and how I ran these training courses.

There you go mate have a good laugh on that one.

Col

by oz_media

As I was reading your post, I was confused at how you saw Chas's post as peer pressure examples. In a SENSE I suppose there is SOME peer pressure to conform in order to be accepted. THis is a sales technique called mirroring. You take the persons body language and mimick it, in a subtle way of course, you then take ther tone and match it, perhapse a little lower in volume at first, etc. This is conforming to the persons own traits, that they may or may not even be aware of.

So what you see as Peer pressure (in my eyes that's "c'mon take a puff, you'll like it, ALL the kids are doing it")I see as conformity. You are adjusting YOUR personality to match that of the person you want to accept you. THis is something I see as a detrimental quality and a reason I bailed out of sales. You eventually lose your OWN personality as your every day life is merely acting a role.

So when I say Americans are conforming to the president's wishes, maybe this is also seen as peer pressure by some?

I'm not trying to get something started but this discussion is teaching me exactly WHY I see you guys one way and you perceive yourselves another way. I think it has a LOT to do with a language barrier, funny as we are both English speaking countries. Yet I see these terms being used in completely different contexts. Just an eye opener and thanks for your input, you've cast a light on things for me.

So when I say SHEEP or CONFORMISTS, perhaps it is a form of 'peer pressure' people feel to stay true to the President, makes a LOT more sense.

by hal 9000

For the same word. But at least it isn't quite as bad as French where you assign gender to quite a lot of things.

But in the above I was using the term "Peer Pressure" loosely and it could be interchanged with "Conformity" from my prospective at least.

Now because I know so many Kiwis "Sheep" means something completely different to me but then again that may only be a Social Thing like the Commodore Vic 20 was used in most of the world but had a name change for the German market because VIC meant something totally different there.

Isn't it interesting just how different English has become as it is almost a different language in different countries even though you could go to each country and at least understand the basics if not the subtle differences?

Col

by jkaras

I am not fond of the toss salad analogy due to the double meaning from jail slang. If you heard it, it's not flatering but I get the true meaning :)

America is the trendy mecca of style. We speak English but talk slang. Other countries use dialects for their regions but still mainly speak true to form. Most foreigners get way confused on our double meaning. A lot of teen foreigners emulate our culture due to its diversity from the norm to accentuate individuality. Our teens emulate certain aspects of other countries to appear wordly or intelligent when they dont know a thing about that country and missinterpret it.

America loves to consume and aquire to show status to measure success and equal footing. WE are well trained cattle following what's in and what's out that changes rapidly (fads). We are always in a hurry, we like to get the last word. We dont openly trust due to bad experiences and remain guarded. When we trust I doubt that others can rival our generosity. We are grouped in socialization such as country folk, city folk, baby boomers, elderly, gothic,ect.. Its all about the label that you project for others to understand or fear you. We love our country but hate our system that fails us due to greed not the altruistic beliefs that our fore fathers started. We want someone to fix the issue, not get involved because it's someone else's job. We feel obligated to remain true to our hertitages that give us history but most couldnt tell you anything about their country of origin while prodly claiming that they are Italian-American, Irish-American etc...
We take every other country's recipes and merge it with our tastes and call it our own. We desire change and evolution vs. content for the same, we like new. We may be more violent than our other countries but we rarely kill over a sporting event. Fries dont belong in mayo. We know how to make better music and movies, just not cars or electronics. Deep down we really care for others and try to help other countries compared to other countries views that its not our problem let them deal with it. I guess if we meet the others halfway we all might just get it right who knows?

I do wish there is more established culture like in Europe. Everytime I go to a different state or city it looks very simular and not unique that points to history so I will give that point to our neighbors.

by pgm554

"The Peoples Republic of Berkeley" is my adopted home town on the west coast,so the following might sound might sound a bit out of step.The following is a bit more emotional than intellectual.

The American dream of family ,home ownership and economic security are what america has given as an ideal to the world.
(you know,the old mom,white picket fence, and apple pie thing).

The warm and fuzzy of a Norman Rockwell painting.

That rush you get from hearing a great rendition of Battle Hymn of the Republic.

Tolerance as opposed to intolerance.

Diversity.

Oh yeah,and if Bezerkley is noted for anything,it's tolerence and diversity.

This place IS uniquely American.(It is uniquely Berkeley!)

by voldar

Oz, I have to say that France is a multicultural society. I lived in France, in Lyon and some time in Grenoble. And there you have everything. From chinese to arabs, from african people to indians. Everything! I had best friends from Tunisia, from Algeria, from Congo, from Chile and from Madagascar. It's quite a conglomerate. Remeber, France was a super power some time ago, with a lot of collonies, like UK and Spain.
I live now in Canada, as you already know, and I live in Montreal - french speaking :). And I will never understand why is it so bad to speak english as a frenchman or french as an englishman. In fact I think is great! I am neither one, but I love english and french.
I agree that sometimes, the english spoken by a french guy makes you lough, but it's the same thing when you hear an englishman speaking french. But this is not something to be ashame of, it's a good thing in fact. Speaking someones language means that you really are interested by his culture.

And now, to come back to the topic. I am not from USA, not even Canada, but I have my thoughts about americans. The first thing I like to american people is when they stand up and sing the national song. They do believe and are proud about their country. And that's saying a lot to me. For the rest ... I don't know, but this is what I wanted to say. I'd like that my native "countryman" have this feeling, but ... it's a looong story. For the rest, I'll be back in five minutes ;).

by hereinoz

A bit rough, Sleep. Oz attempted to put together a reasonable treatise of how things were from his point of view, and to let the US citizenry know how they were perceived by the outside world.

This can only be for the good, and it is something that only friends can do - enemies will never tell you that you perhaps need to look at a few things to improve your image - only friends can do that.

And then you come back with that response. Not really in the spirit of international co-operation and understanding.

If the USA wants people to just stop saying bad things about them, regardless of what they do or say, then it indicates that the USA is not mature enough to accept criticism, and not mature or intelligent enough to see the other's point of view.

And I am sure that is not the case.

I am sure that all the US citizens who are contributors to this forum, are mature enough to accept criticism in the spirit in which Oz gave it, and they are certainly mature enough to see the validity of the other guys point of view, and perhaps even learn from it.

Alan

by hal 9000

They come in uninvited and make their home here and wreck the place destroying all the native flora and fauna. then start to spread out leaving a path of total destruction in their wake.

Whoops that's the Red Eared Sliding Turtle from the Mississippi that is currently invading the place over here could someone please come over here and remove every one before the little bastards destroy the entire place?

Should I have put a "Sarcasm Alert" first?

Col

by dc_guy

Homo sapiens has been driving species to extinction since long before the European occupation of the Western Hemisphere created the American nationality.

What do you suppose happened to all the arctic megafauna? After all, by definition they had no natural enemies. Sure the temperature has risen a few degrees, but there are still glaciers so there's no reason that there shouldn't still be a few colonies of woolly mammoths, woolly rhinos, and cave bears. No reason except humans.

The moa, the dodo, the marsupial wolf, plenty of species have become extinct during historic times in areas unpopulated by Americans. Just look at what the Three Gorges Dam is about to do a few species as the world turns a blind eye and applauds the "economic miracle."

America is a land of dichotomies of positively surreal scope. We have some remarkably strict pollution laws, and corporations who have found all the loopholes in them. Auto emissions and fuel economy regulations almost as tough as Japan's, and yuppies who've traded in their Jaguars for trucks thinly disguised as "sport-utility" vehicles that are exempt from them. A hunters' lobby that can swing an election, and entire cities that are overrun by deer (Buffalo) and coyotes (Los Angeles).

There is a violent, law-flouting fringe on both sides of this issue. We've got a few turtle snuffers, but geeze, we are the birthplace of both Greenpeace and P.E.T.A.

by hal 9000

Not the American People just one native American animal or whatever turtles actually are.

Lighten up after all I did add the "Sarcasm Alert" didn't I?

Col

by deane75

Our freedom of speech, including criticism of the current political and legal systems tops my list.

Nothing ticks me off more than the issues supported by the ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union), but I adore the balance it provides.

Our freedom of assembly, even though I witnessed the havoc of the Seattle WTO riots a few years ago is also on my list.

And as I've watched some of the evil despots come to power I've come to believe that our right to bear firearms is an integral part of keeping our government in its place.

All of the things that I belive make us uniquely American have both a positive and negative aspect to them. I choose to view the positive.

My optimism is not uniquely American, or even generational (I qualify as a Baby Boomer), but just my own personal nature.

I don't think we are as industrious as we perceive the Japanese to be, nor are we as relaxed as we perceive our Mexican neighbors to be, nor as traditional as we might attribute to some Europeans.

We have enormous resources and are inwardly focused.

JMO

Deane

by oz_media

As I said, I don't really know about France but all I've seen in a muticutural perspective are pretty much just tourists. Now this could be due to WHERE I have been in France as being major tourist centers too.

As for French Canadians, i think the problem is that they don't speak FRENCH OR ENGLISH, they have thier own language all together.

If you learn to speak Candian French and visit France, you will be shunned like a traitor, they HATE French Canadians there, you've probably een this yourself. In the same perspective, French Canadians don't care for the Parisienne French dialect (original French). It is like us tellnig the British that WE speak English, we don't though we speak Canadian an English dialect, but not a very pure one. Some parts of Canada and the US, the accents are so strong it's hard to determine if it's even related to English.

Parisienne French see French Canadians as bastards to thier country, they moved away and adopted thier own version of the French language yet still want to be considered French. They then have tried to isolate themselves from the rest of the country while expecting the rest of the country to cater to thier differences, it hasn't gone over well to say the least.

Peolpe in Canada are Canadian NOT British and they don't try to be considered British, even though they share the same base language.

Yet French Canadian's want to be considered French? They aren't though, not even close. I haven't been to Montreal in over a year so things may have changed since I was there, the last visit I made was when the BIG separation push was on, I decided we should let them separate if they choose. They'd loose the port cities, government support etc. We could cig a ditch around Quebec and puch it North through the Hudsons Bay and let em all float off into thier preffered isolated life. Of course we'd let you know so you could jump over in time ;-)

When I was in school, I had NO problem with French Canada, I even learned some of thier version of French, when I was in France and used it, I was stared at like an freak show. The attitude was speak english and keep that dirty French spew of a language out of our face, they really don't even sound similar yet alone the same language.

Tabernac!

by oz_media

That is very apparent even on TR, as we often use expressions and words that make our Southern friends so offended.

Such terms are just not accepted and usually drag out into a long discussion trying to explain what you have explained, comments are generally not accepted as mere comments, the wording is so acutely monitored.

In the same sense, I see conformity as a resuly of peer pressure. There is a peer pressure to become aaccepted or 'conform' to a given standard, way of life, dress code, belief etc. Once we have buckled to this retarted peer pressure, we become conformists. You do what needs to be done in order to be accepted by those you admire.

So even here, between Canada and an Australia, we find the need to explain the meaning of our words in order to reach a mutual agreement. We are clearing up our intended meaning of two VERY common English words too, not outdated or old english. Peer pressure AND conformity.

Go figure?!?

by oz_media

That's pretty good Vlad. I must admit, I often forget you are in Montreal.

'ow is it you say? Ahhhhhhh, dere is some diference you know?

by oz_media

A recent post got me thinking of an issue here that's been in the news a bit lately.

MANY people don't know that Automobile manufacturers have a BLACK BOX installed on all cars with airbags since the mid 90's.

What it does is record a 5 second loop and when the airebag is deployed (in an accident) it stores data about the speed the car was travelling at the time of impact, the positions of the gas and brake pedals, the position of the driver seat, wheter or not the seatbelt was being used etc. This was originally done to deny claims that airbags were deploying randomly. Some people would get into an accident and say thier air bag went off and caused them to crash! It was originally for the protection of the manufacturers but this data is now being used to determine fault in a courtroom.

So, some guy is screaming how his PRIVACY rights are being infringed up on becuase the blck box is recording a loop. The guy actually thinks he has a leg to stand on!

My question, why is it that the only time people complain about civil rights issues is when they have broken the law? I don't care if you scan my luggage, I don't care if the store or traffic light has a camera on it. I'm also not breaking the law, those that do break the law complain about civil rights!

by dc_guy

Their mere existence is a violation of our civil rights. Anything that makes them easier to enforce is a further violation. It's that simple.

by oz_media

I don't know if I get your conclusion. Are you saying that the black bboxes DO infringe on your rights?

If these are being used to determine fault in life or death situations, how does that infringe on ANYTHING?!?

Unless you are breaking the law, they will only help you out. If THIS is considered infringing on my rights then I welcome you to do it.

I have been in some VERY complicated car accidents, one with a fire truck (HOW DO YOU SUE THE FIRE DEPARTMENT!!) but bacuse of a redlight camera (since been banned here) it was proven that the firetruck ran a red light at high speed, nt on it's way to an accident but returning to the station with some tied firemen who were returning upset from a false alarm that interrupted the hockey game.

The cameras are now removed because people complained about rights and big brother watching them. I just managed to get in under the wire and they saved me tens of thousands and also paid for three years of rehab where I learned to walk, talk read and write again (another reason my keyboard dexterity needs much to be desired).

by dc_guy

I'm old enough to regret the wholesale loss of privacy. I despise having to remember that I'm constantly on somebody's video surveillance tape as I walk down the street carelessly performing acts that range from merely immodest to downright silly to borderline illicit.

And I'm cynical enough to distrust technology, especially in the hands of the government or any powerful organization. I'm happy for your salvation via a red-light camera, but I wonder how many of them are deliberately miscalibrated to generate extra income for the municipality. High-tech versions of the old speed-traps.

But I am definitely old enough to remember when the Constitution, no matter how badly twisted and torn, meant something. Today's government has learned that if they make people frightened enough, they will gladly surrender all of their rights in the hope of security.

So no, I don't want government thugs x-raying the contents of my luggage and my digestive tract. My suitcase and my colon may contain things that have been declared illegal by a legislative branch full of would-be-nannies, a power-hungry executive branch, and a judicial branch who think they're wiser than the Founding Fathers, but that are none of the government's frelling business according to the Bill of Rights.

Some of those things may, according to an AI computer analysis, "profile" me as an untrustworthy person. An AI programmed by the same IT industry that can't keep someone else from sending virus-laden e-mail using my own address. An AI designed by a government who didn't notice until 9/11 that the intelligence documents it needed to translate were no longer in Russian but in Arabic and Farsi, and has still not got enough translators in those languages to keep up with the document flow.

In short, I believe that the surveillance culture that America is happily stumbling into will do more harm than good. Harm both because of the innocent people that will be caught in the dragnet and because of the false sense of security it gives the population while the real risks are lying untranslated in some bureaucrat's in-basket. And "no good" because it will acclerate the destruction of our Constitution and allow the government to become even more inept at averting crises.

Americans are a people who have consistently, throughout our entire history, distrusted authority and rebelled against it when it became too big for its britches. In one generation that is changing, because the agents of authority are now machines instead of people. Everyone instinctively trusts computers, and that is REALLY stupid.

by oz_media

'paranioa self destroya'

Persionally, the cameras in the street watching your every move? Don't flatter yourself, nobody gives a crap what you're doing unless illegal or unsafe to others.

As for street cameras, I think there's a massive paranioa we are being watched where in 99% of the cases we aren't.

I can take care of myself and don't feel I need to be looked out for, but I also don't mind if you get off looking at my internal X-Ray at the airport. Can you tell me what I ate for breakfast? If so keep it to yourself!

WHO CARES!! It doesn't matter does it? Are you REALLY that important that you feel you need rights to stop people from viewing your stomache or anal contents?

Do you really think people WANT to see these things or care unless you are packing a bum full of coke?

It's not like the alien anal probe thing at all, THAT would be infringin on your rights, pubilc safety checks, who cares, I sure as hell don't.

Let the government do whatever turns their crank, it doesn't 'directly' effect me in ANY way shape or form.

by dc_guy

I find in none of these postings a compelling reason to retreat from my position that the government shall be prohibited from doing ANYTHING that is not specifically authorized in the Constitution. And I didn't think that up, that's pretty much the way it's stated in the Constitution itself. No exceptions. Period.

There are a host of problems with the rationalization, "What the heck, why appear unpatriotic to my fellow citizens? It's OK in this case because it won't cause me any harm personally. Besides, there's a vague chance that it might nail somebody too stupid to realize that no one will ever again get away with hijacking an airliner full of angry Americans."

For one, every dollar's worth of actual accomplishment that is delivered by a government program costs about ten dollars in abysmally mismanaged tax money. Diverting money from the private to the public sector diminishes the GDP and makes us all less prosperous.

For another, every time we let the government spit on the Constitution, it sets a bad precedent. As the country matured, each administration found a few ways around the supposedly sacred document, but generally during wartime, and often with measures that expired at war's end. Roosevelt elevated it to an artform and got his hands slapped several times, but he still got away with a lot. Yet he was a piker by the standards set after WWII by Washington under both conferences of the Republocrat League.

The post-9/11 government behaves as though the Constitution simply does not apply to them. The only reason they are getting away with it is that for the last 70 years people like you have stood by silently, thinking to yourself, "Oh well, there's a serious problem so I guess I can let them violate the Constitution just this once."

I have a morbid fear that during my lifetime, the Supreme Court will invent some bizarre legal theory supporting a ruling that since the Constitution has been treated like toilet paper for the past umpty-leven years and nobody (including the Supreme Court) complained, it is officially no longer the Law of the Land.

by oz_media

You see the difference is, we KNOW the Constitution of Canada is garbage that is ignored and laughed at by everyone. it's a useless and antiquated piece of paper. In the US lives have been BASED on the ancient scripts of yesteryear and it causes problems and disputes in every facet of a persons day to day life. "Mt constitutional rights are being violated !!" Get used to it or rewrite the Constitution. What was best then is definitely NOT what's best today.

It's no different than peolpe saying "you can't do that because in the Bible it says..." Sure, lets base our lives in the 21st century on a book written HOW many thousand years ago?? How long must we hang on to outdated Imperialist dogma until we can get on with our lives in live in the now instead of yesterday.

Example of how the Canaidan Constitution doesn't apply:

It is my Contitutional right to refuse ANY body search (including simply looking in my pockets), fluid samples etc. In an attempt to charge me with a drug or alcohol related offense. If I am pulled over, according to the constitution, I do NOT have to give a breathylizer test, I do NOT have to let the police look through my car. Furthermore, unless I am under arrest I must be allowed to leave within 3 minutes of being stopped by a policeman. We ALL know it takes longer than that for them to finish thier coffee and approach your car.

When a police officer asks you to empty your pockets, you don't have to unless you are placed under arrest. If you say this to a police officer, you will be immediately thrown to the ground and searched, not legal and definitely breaking my constitutional rights but not something ANY courtroom would allow you to get away with.

Police break your constitutional rights as if they never existed and there's nothing YOU or your lawyer will be able to do about it. THIS is a reality.

So what's the point in having these 'rights' if they don't stand up in day to day life or a court room? Why don't they hold up in court?

First, to give people a SENSE of security.
Second, because situations are acted upon differently these days and the old constitution doesn't hold anylegal water anymroe, there's always a way around it.

So either you guys have to accept that the Constitution is just a false sense of security and stop depending on OLD laws to save you or you need to rewrite the Constitution.

Don't you guys even brainwash the children each day in school with this false sense of security too or have they goten over that now? Actually that's the pledge of allegiance isn't it? Well I'm sure that still stands.

In Canada a flag tribute each day would be another 5 minutes you could be late for school.

I guess what I'm getting at is that in teh USA you place a lot of expectations on these documents that are broken daily and that raises many problems when dealing with day to day life.

In Canada, we couldn't give a toss what the government said ?? years ago and just go with the day as it comes. No government expectations means no government disappointments. You can't even BEGIN to start talking politics in most of Canada without someone telling you to shut the hell up because the hockey game's on.

Our perspective, if you don't rely on it, you won't be let down.

Your perspective, the government is continually letting us down and breaking my constitutional rights.

Who lives happier?

by dc_guy

Because our national characters are fundamentally different. From the very start. You got your independence by being patient and peaceful, we got ours by being angry and violent.

Your civilization is based on a tradition of tolerance, pacifism, minding one's own business, and respecting authority but expecting it to intervene only when all else fails. Ours is based on a tradition of racism, the Wild West, imposing one's beliefs on everybody, and defrauding authority but expecting it to intervene every time the neighbor's dog barks too loudly.

All we have in common is the English language, a love of beer, and joint custody of Celine Dion.

You're helplessly inundated by enough American news to know that our relationship with our police and other authorities is simply not the same as yours. Fifteen innocent people were just awarded several million dollars over being set up by an entire town government and its police force on false drug charges. All they were guilty of was being black and living in a state where a few people still don't know which side won the Civil War.

Because you have monarchs who are content to be ceremonial figures, you are content to have a constitution that is just a historical relic. Because we have elected leaders who sometimes attempt to be monarchs, we need a constitution that protects us from them.

by oz_media

Well I must say your words are very to the point and from what I see (on our end anyhow) very true, to an extent of course.

I'm glad you said it, because the same comments coming from me would have been misconstrued in nasty ways I'm sure.

Personally, I don't mind being on the 'passive' side of the border. It's calm and peaceful and i am left to just do my thing without worrying about what I consider irrelevant BS from our poltiticians.

I won't comment on your side of the border as I think you said enough already.

This discussion is closed to new replies.