Not sure I completely understand question, but here are some general comments.
WinZip and WinRAR are the 2 most commonly used file compression programs. Both are effective. RAR tends to give somewhat better compression but is not as commonly used and requires WinRAR to extract. Zip files are common and Win XP can handle them natively.
The amount of compression depends on file type.
JPEG and mp3 files are already compressed and will not compress further. The only advantage to Zipping these type files is to package files together.
Executable files including dll files will compress very little. Once again primart use of Zip is to package.
Doc files, txt files, inf files, and database files will compress greatly. For these type files, you may see your desired 10 to 1 ratio.
So both Zip and RAR are very good and about equally effective. Compression depends on file type rather than program used.
Dalton