Discussion Locked

Repetitive Stress Injury

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

When the 'pointing device' first appeared on the scene, it
was a one-button mouse, at-first presented as an aid to save
some command-line typing. No one that I knew ever used their middle finger for that. The middle finger was usually reserved for other inter-office communications(hehe).
Frankly, I found that if I wanted to continue with computers I had to relax that middle finger. The answer was to switch the mouse buttons.
At times it has seemed that most users are so set on the 'right-hand' (which is actually the left-hand used w/right) button configuration, that they'd rather fight than switch.
I'm over it. I simply try to persuade people to switch if they want to reduce the pain radiating from their wrist to their elbow andsometimes beyond as the day progresses.
The people I know that have made the switch, though it takes up to a few weeks for some to adjust to it, have ALL later agreed that the pain was reduced.
Rarely does my wrist give me problems these days. Istill do much graphic arts and sound editing, which is almost all mouse motion, and if I don't need to touch the mouse I don't
(ALT and CTRL were always duplicated on both halves of the board).
So. . . did I put my faith where my mouth is? I taught many (incl. my own three now all grown-up daughters) to use the so-called 'LH' button configuration, and relax that middle finger! The complaints re: 'my arm hurts' have all-but ceased.If your wrist is hurting, see a doctor.
You can, afterall, go back to the old way- takes about twenty seconds to undo. (The pain in your arm will only take just a little longer.)
If you want to contact me directly about this post, either pro or con,
please use
I am genuinely interested in what you may have to say about this. I'll be watching this discussion. I'm curious.
(maybe I don't get out enough? haha)
Dan Ruth

18 replies

by epepke

I can't figure out what you are saying. I use my mouse with my right hand and use the index finger of my right hand to press the single mouse button (on a Mac) or the dominant mouse button (on a PC). However, as this seems to be what you recommend, and it's the default configuration, I don't know what you mean.

by cabidgeworm

Most Mac users would use just a single button so I see the confusion. All I'm say is that I see PC users all the time who keep the index finger over the left mouse button while keeping the middle finger lifted above the right-side button.

Dan

by epepke

Are you saying that there is less stress if you use your middle finger most of the time instead of your forefinger? Or are you saying that there's less stress if you don't keep your middle finger hovered?

by terrence l. gabriel

If you do indeed have carpal tunnel syndrome and cannot change careers to one where you are not abusing that particular piece of your physiology, the only solution for it is surgery. Period.

I had carpal tunnel for almost 30 years and finally out of desperation got the surgery. As soon as the block wore off the pain from the carpal tunnel was gone. GONE!!

Of course the healing process to about 6 weeks as do most things where you are cut and sewn back together but in the nearly 2 years since then, there has been no pain, no tingling, no numbness. The symptoms are gone.

Carpal tunnel is never cured, only treated. If you are unlucky enough to have the irritation start because of repetitive motions that cause it, the only ultimate solution is the knife. I used splints, aspirin, voodoo, good thoughts, furry little kitties, tea, honey, Jim Beam and Johnny Walker, late night walks, relaxation techniques, water torture, water therapy, rubs, ointments, oils, dictionaries, liquid nitrogen, yelling, and time. Nothing worked. Some things helped, but nothing but the knife worked.

Put off the surgery and suffer. Get the surgery and get over the syndrome.

by cabidgeworm

Your comments are appreciated and well-taken. That's why I wrote in the original post 'if your wrist hurts- see a doctor.'

As for me, I know of a few people who have had complications from the surgery that after seeing, I wished to avoid.

This solution allowed me to do just that and alleviate the pain.

Thanks for the response.

Dan

by kcmeister

Carpal tunnel syndrome and repetitive stress syndrome are 2 different injuries. Carpal tunnel is highly over-diagnosed. Treatment of the two are different. Carpal tunnel is when the thick piece of connective tissue between the bones in your hand puts direct pressure on the bundle of nerves going through the carpal tunnel. Unfortunately, with repetitive stress syndrome there is almost always a secondary nerve impingement either in the brachial plexus or cervicals. Hence surgery is often noteffective, only taking care of part of the problem, and the pain usually comes back. A test for carpal tunnel: hold your palms together like you are praying, elbows bent so that your thumb and index finger are touching your abdomen level with solarplexus. Press your palms together for 30 seconds with moderate pressure. If no pain occurs, you DO NOT have carpal tunnel syndrome. It is that easy. Think twice before going under the knife, I have seen too many horror stories.

by terrence l. gabriel

Eventually you will either lose the use of the hand that is affected or you will have the surgery or you will find an occupation where the irritation to the carpal ligament is not an issue. Carpal Tunnel syndrome does not get better, it is degenerative.

Again, eventually the solution will be the knife or a significant lifestyle change.

by epepke

Way cool.

I do know someone who had bona fide carpal tunnel syndrome, had the surgery, and says it's the best thing she's ever had done.

by sara l

I found that when I started getting very uncomfortable in my right hand with a dull ache radiating to my elbow, the best things I did were mousing left-handed, upper-body weight training, and resting. A good aerobic working out of any type was alsohelpful to relieve stress and improve circulation to arms and hands. I also take frequent short breaks and stretch my arms, back, hands and wrists.

For what it's worth, I found that this combination of changes helped me a lot. It may not work for everyone, especially those who are unable to achieve relief from rest and pain-maskers or anti-inflammatory medication because their condition has existed for too long. I'm not a doctor, so I don't really know. I'm just sharing what works for me, and if it works for someone else, great!

by dragon katie

they are in fact very different things, i have seen it many many times where soemone complains of pains in their hands and blame it on typing or mousing but they actually have their arms hyperextended or their hands in wierd positions to try and accmodate mousing and keyboardng on paperfilled desks.
how many head/neck and back aches are caused by poor monitor placement?
i think there are a great number of things that need to be evaluated before surgery is considered. indeed sometiems surgery is the best option.

by admin

And how long did it take you to feel the pain?
I have found that "mixing up" different solutions helps a lot. Changing body positions through lowering and raising the position of the mouse, using different chairs (I have 3 different in my office) using different wrist supports etc.

I realized this worked some time ago as it seemed most solutions worked for a while and then started producing diminishing results.

I'm going to try this and add it to my "bag of tricks" though. Thanks ;>
Also, regular weight training and good posture definately ALWAYS make a positive difference in conjunction with this, and changing things is definately not a cure all. My girlfriend had carpel tunnel and the surgery was very successful -these tricks didn't really work for her, medical help did.

by cabidgeworm

. . .of regular use to notice that my wrist simply felt 'tired' and that keeping my index finger slightly resting on the left button, while keeping the middle finger held slightly above the right button(ever-poised for a 'right-click')was uncomfortable.

Pretty sure that was in 95 or early 96,(using win 3.11 then and seemed never used R/side button anyway).

Sooo, I switched the button assignment one day and noticed that being able to relax the middle finger on the mouse pad and only use index finger on RH button solved issue for me. I've not noticed any discomfort since.

If your wrist is bothering you see a doctor.

Thanks for the input.

Dan

by terrence l. gabriel

You are absolutely correct that they are two different problems. That said, you might want to rethink the idea of overdiagnosis. I had my problem evaluated at Duke Medical Center in Durham, North Carolina. I spent a total of three days in evaluations, including one day of over seven hours. There was no doubt at all at the end of the tests that Carpal Tunnel was the problem. In fact, the surgeon who took care of me commented on seeing the results that it was so severe he was surprised I had any use of my hand at all.

There is no question that medical science can sometimes be "iffy" at best, but in my case with the quality of medical care I received, and the immediate and complete relief I got from over 25 years of pain made the treatmentI received completely worthwhile.

I continue to advise, if you have Carpal Tunnel Syndrome and if it is properly diagnosed, have the surgery. There is no other solution.

by epepke

There are a few surgical procedures that seem to border on the magical. Carpal tunnel surgery is one. Arthroscopic knee surgery is another--a lot of people who get it claim the knee works better after than before it was messed up. Maybe Lasik eyesurgery is a third.

Although medicine is the least scientific of all "scientific" disciplines, they occasionally do something right.

by cabidgeworm

Are you saying that there is less stress if you use your middle finger most of the time instead of your forefinger? No.

Or are you saying that there's less stress if you don't keep your middle finger hovered? Yes.

Took some time(less than a year) of regular use to notice that my wrist simply felt 'tired' and that keeping my index finger slightly resting on the left button, while keeping the middle finger held slightly above the right button(ever-poised for a 'right-click')was uncomfortable.

Pretty sure that was in 95 or early 96,(using win 3.11 then and seemed never used R/side button anyway).

Sooo, I switched the button assignment one day and noticed that being able to relax the middle finger on the mouse pad and only use index finger on RH button solved issue for me. I've not noticed any discomfort since.

If your wrist is bothering you see a doctor.

Thanks for the input.

Dan

by cabidgeworm

Are you saying that there is less stress if you use your middle finger most of the time instead of your forefinger? No.

Or are you saying that there's less stress if you don't keep your middle finger hovered? Yes.

Toward the end of a long day I noticed it was requiring(seemed like) more effort just to keep that middle finger hoisted above the right-side button.

Took some time(less than a year) of regular use to notice that my wrist simply felt 'tired' and that keeping my index finger slightly resting on the left button, while keeping the middle finger held slightly above the right button(ever-poised for a 'right-click')was uncomfortable.

Pretty sure that was in 95 or early 96,(using win 3.11 then and seemed never used R/side button anyway).

Sooo, I switched the button assignment one day and noticed that being able to relax the middle finger on the mouse pad and only use index finger on RH button solved issue for me. I've not noticed any discomfort since.

If yourwrist is bothering you see a doctor.

Thanks for the input.

Dan

by cabidgeworm

Just wanted to thank you all for your comments and suggestions.

I started this discussion simply to share something(food for thought) that I believe MAY contribute to a few user's avoiding what is apparently a very painful, and possibly(for some)avoidable, work-related condition.

As we all know, sticking one's neck out in some forums can get us flamed. Your professionalism is partly reflected in the fact my clothes don't even smell like smoke!

Thanks to all who replied.

Dan Ruth

This discussion is closed to new replies.