Discussion Locked

Replacing Vista with XP on new computers - Good idea?

0 helpful
14 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
With all of the uncertainty about Vista, I am reluctant to ask my users to learn the new OS just yet. Unfortunately new computers now come preloaded with Vista. Is it OK to overwrite the OS with XP? Are there any issues to watch out for (e.g. firmware)?

14 replies

by charliespencer

You may have trouble getting XP drivers, especially from the system vendor. Fortunately, many of the component manufacturers have XP drivers for their current hardware. You'll have to invest a little bit of time surfing.

Load Vista first, then use Hardware Manager to get a list of all the major components (video card, NIC, sound, HD controllers, etc. Note the manufacturer and model. Go to the Internet and see if you can find XP drivers for those sub-systems. Try the system vendor's web site first; some vendors are better than others for having "legacy" drivers for newer hardware. If the vendor doesn't have XP drivers for your system, you'll have to check the site of each component's manufacturer.

If you find the drivers you need, download them to CD or DVD and then load XP. You may have to run it at minimal video settings until you install the correct video driver.

Oh, and Dell has agreed to continue selling systems with XP instead of Vista by popular demand.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

replacing Vista with XP is not particularly difficult. Palmetto appears to have hit the nail on the head with the above advice.
I have recently been involved with changing several newly purchased systems from Vista to XP. Things went remarkably smoothly. One glitch involving drivers that I eventually found is all that I have encountered in changing over 8 systems from 3 different manufacturers - Dell, HP and Acer. Go for it.

by rajan_arvind

Hello,

From your recent experience of replacing Vista with XP on Acer, can you please send me information on drivers for display, wireless, audio etc. and where you were able to download them from. I have a Acer Aspire 5050-3785. I upgraded the memory to 4GB but after installing XP, it only reads 2GB. What should I do to make it utilize the full 4GB?

by dallaslawyer

I got an Inspiron 1420, hated Vista, and decided to go back to trusty XP. I used Killdisk to wipe my computer, switched from ACHA to ATA in BIOS, then began to install Windows XP.

Everything worked fine until my computer got hung up at ?Setup will complete in approximately 39 minutes.? I know very little about computers, but I turned off all the wireless, etc. from BIOS. Still no luck. I have a feeling from reading some posts on different websites that this may be driver-related but have no idea what to do about that. So I?m stuck. Then came across your post. Any ideas about what I might do at this point? I've gone to the Dell site and downloaded all the XP drivers for the Inspiron 1420 but don't know what to do now. I would really, really appreciate any advice.

Thanks!

by boxfiddler Hot topic

switched from ACHA to ATA?
From what I can find, ACHA is a CPU architecture, and ATA is is a storage device interface.
How long did installation hang at "Setup will complete...?"

by a_p_muller

I build computers for a living, as well as provide data recovery and PC support services. Ever since Vista debuted with all its problems, I have replaced Vista with XP on no fewer than 20 machines. A quick way of removing preloaded Windows software is with the freeware KILLDISK (www.killdisk.com). Then you simply install Windows XP on your now blank drive. I have never run into problems with firmware, as these computers are capable of operating XP as well as Vista. Microsoft asked manufacturers not to offer XP installs as a way to boost Vista sales, which were not going well. Alienware, for one, still offers either XP or Vista.
The only problem I ran into was the loss of wireless capability on a laptop, which was quickly solved once I downloaded the driver for it.

by jristow

Since killdisk completely removes Vista, I assume that all application software is also removed. This means that in order for the DVD to work I must install something like Nero?

I have a brand new Toshiba laptop. when I turned it on for the first time it prompted for the installation of Vista. Must I go through with the first time install or can I remove all traces of Vista at the very beginning and THEN install XP Professional?

by dougw

Before I pull the trigger on KILLDISK on my new GATEWAY M-6307 w/VISTA...Has anyone been successful just reloading XP/SP2 Home Edition(2002)without crashing the load and getting stuck between OS's?....Thanks-Doug

by Former member

All it has is a little bit more security and eye candy, other than that Vista is no different than XP.
I have been using Vista for well over a year now, and i can say that it certainly works better. Vista is better at doing a restore than XP any day. You can make Vista look and feel like Xp also. So give Vista a go, load it on and find out. If you come un-stuck then give us a shout on here. But then it is your choice. New motherboards fair better With Vista than XP.

Please post back if you have any more problems or questions.
If this information is useful, please mark as helpful. Thanks.

by dallaslawyer

I meant "AHCI." The installation hangs indefinitely. It hangs at "Setup will complete in approximately 39 minutes" and just stays there. For hours on end until I realized nothing was happening. Rebooting didn't help.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

communication between Windows and some device that needs it, though I can't say for certain from my own experience. Below are some links, though the first is somewhat limited in its scope. Some later versions of Windows XP SP2 offer limited support for AHCI, but not earlier versions. Hope this helps.

http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/Advanced%20Host%20Controller%20Interface

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Host_Controller_Interface

http://www.intel.com/technology/serialata/ahci.htm

edit typo

This discussion is closed to new replies.