Discussion Locked

Rock and hard place

0 helpful
115 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

115 replies

by vltiii

I'm sure this will be interpreted as rude or combative, but it is my opinion. I truly question if we've been following any of the same discussions here. The majority of the questions posted and many of the responses indicate to me that those that come here are not the very best in our fields as you claim they are, else most questions would not need to be asked. This is not to say that there aren't some that participate here that certainly qualify as experts in their respective areas. To date, every discussion I've followed (and this is pretty much true everywhere, not just here at Tech Republic) withing 3 or 4 responses, they start to veer off topic. We all know there is more than one solution to many issues effecting IT, but the responses generally end up ranging from criminal recommendations, to unethical, to a few decent and respectable responses. I've seen more than a few post such as yours that portends to present ITs as great professionals, yet without fail there is a lack of respect and courteousness towards one another in groups such as this. That being the case, how are our customers supposed to perceive us as the professionals we claim to be?

by servicetech

"To date, every discussion I've followed (and this is pretty much true everywhere, not just here at Tech Republic) withing 3 or 4 responses, they start to veer off topic."

And just what part of your reply was about the original question? :-)

"else most questions would not need to be asked."

Last time I checked, I haven't found anyone, Myself included, that knew it all.

by vltiii

...but he will have to do that anyway once he is no longer on the payroll. At this point he's only delaying the inevitable and in my mind raising more questions.

by vltiii

You would think in a situation such as this that the CFO would explain his/her rationale behind making the request instead of having the IT Director essentially working in the blind.

by hal 9000

Told you why they wanted something done and not just told you to do it?

Face it we are the service side of any industry we are a necessary evil that they would dearly love to do without but can not do without because they need us. I've never known any Upper Managment person to justify their demands to me they just make them and expect them carried out. :)

Col ]:)

by willap

You have morals and beliefs, stick to them. I would tell him "NO" and start looking for a new position with a place that has my same beliefs. If your CFO wants you to watch somebody else, the day may come when the same is done to you.

by kjenkinsaf

Does the guy asking you to do this have any power over you? i.e. does he sign your paycheck, write your evaluations, have the bosses ear? If the answer is yes to any of these questions. Do as you are told if you value your job. Then quietly, from home do a job search for yourself. As I wouldn't work for this bunch.

by gardoglee

There seem to be two fundamental misconceptions implicit in most of the responses here.

First, everyone seems to think that if you have an email system, then evey employee will ahve email, so the CEO should have email so long as he is an employee, or a contractor. that is not implicit in your situation as you have described it so far. In many situations not all empoloyees have email, voice mail, or even access to a phone.

Second, it is clear from your description that you really have two separate problems. One is what to do while the ex-CEO is still an employee, and the second is what to do after he is no longer an employee. It is very likely that the legal implications will be different once his status has changed.

Third, most of the earlier posts seem to asusme that your company has policies for things like this, and therefore either has an acceptable use policy, or will be happy to adopt one once you suggest it. You sound like you are in a small company. I've been there, and know that small companies tend to be focused on other things (like, for example, selling products), and therefore are often very lax about having explicit policies for a whole host of issues. If you do have an AUP, then it probably came out of some dimestore software package which one of the company founders got at Wal-Mart with "1001 Legal Documents You Don't Need A Lawyer For."

I have been asked to secure the email, the hard drive, and the network files of several terminated employees, both those who resigned and those who were fired. In some cases I have been explicitly directed to do this without the knowledge of the current LAN administrator, and without the knowledge of the email server adminstrator (in our case they are two differnet people, one on site, one off site). I know that in most of the cases where this was requested that the managers who requested this were then examining the contents, particularly when a terminated employee took legal action against the company. That said, I think I know how you feel about this. It is a lousy position to be in, and the CFO doesn't really seem to be on your side, even though he might be trying to convince you that he is.

My advice is to do the following.

Get the request in writing, and keep multiple copies at multiple off site locations. Mail one to your best friend, or sister, or mother if you have to, and ask them to hold onto it without reading it. Tell the CFO that you are going to keep the written copies of the request, so that he knows you are covered that way. He will be less likely to deny asking in the first place. If you can, get someone to date and sign an envelope with a copy sealed inside, so you can prove that you had the written instructions before any questions were raised. You not only need the copy, but you need to be able to prove that it is authentic. Impress each person to whom you entrust a copy that it is confidential, and don't enlist anyone you would not trust with your future.

Tell the CFO that you expect him to notify the outgoing CEO of the monitoring. Get him to include his response to that request in the written instructions. He may or may not agree, and he may or may not do what he agrees to, but you want to have documentation both that you raised the issue, and on what basis you proceeded.

Do not inform the person who is being monitored yourself. You may want to do so, but don't do it. Not only will you lose your job (will, not might), but you may be in for even bigger problems, like being sued by your employer after they fire you.

Talk to a lawyer. If the company has an attorney, and the politics allow, then talk to him/her/them about this. If the company does not, or if that is not acceptable within the political situation, then find an attorney of your own and talk to them. There are both Federal and State laws to cinsider, and the State laws vary wildly, both in letter and in interpretation. And don't use the attorney who did your real estate purchase, your divorce, or who wrote your will. Get someone who knows privacy laws. Lawyers are like programmers. You don't hire a Java guru to maintain legacy COBOL code.

Your instinct to do this yourself rather than delegating it is a good instinct. As an earlier poster noted, there is both the question of what you can monitor/review/read, and what contents you can disclose. If you are the only one doing this, then you are the only one who needs to keep it to herself. Don't disclose anything to anyone other than the CFO. Since your isntructions are to report to him, that is as far as any safety goes for you. If anything else leaks then you are completely on your own, since you are outside the scope of your instructions.

With the exception of what you have been instructed to disclose to the CFO, protect the privacy of the outgoing CEO at least as much as you would anything else while he is an employee, and even more so when he leaves. If a question comes up, you don't want anyone to have a basis for saying you were sloppy and caused a leak. No matter how innocent it seems, treat it like a top secret.

At the same time, assume that whatever you disclose to the CFO is just as good as published in the local paper, so keep it to a minimum. It might not work out that way, but better to prepare for the worst.

Be prepared for some other executive level person to come to you with further requests and/or contrary instructions. Be prepared to tell them to go to the CFO for whatever they need. Don't be the one who is later blamed for expanding the scope, stopping the surveillance, or whatever. Make sure it is his decision, not yours.

Assume that everyone will eventually know that you have done this, both the outgoing CEO and every other employee past, present and future. As above, prepare for the worst. Some people will see it as company loyalty, others will see you as a fink and a spy. Life's tough that way, and there is no way around it, so deal with it when it happens.

Keep a contemporary log of everything which you do report to the CFO. Don't assume that you will be able to recall when and what you disclosed later on. Write it down each day, attach copies, and keep offsite copies as above. If the worst happens, and you must defend yourself down the road, a journal you diligently wrote each day will carry much more weight than your recollections after the fact.

Last, don't speculate, ask around, or try to figure out why the CFO is doing this. You will not substatially improve your position in any respect by knowing, and may well jeopordize it. Part of your defense, should it ever come up, is that you were following explicit instructions from someone in a sufficient position of company authority to issue those instructions, and that you were not aware of any illegal purpose or action. If you do come to suspect that something illegal is going on, or if you are in a position where you reasonably should have known so, then you don't have much of a defense.

Good luck. Most likely this will all blow over and become an unpleasant memory and a good learning experience. Just be prepared for worse.

by randy hagan

If the CFO of the company is "driving" this deal with the CEO, then asking you to map the course, it's very fishy.

The idea of a CEO leaving the company, but using the company email system for "other deals" is pretty suspect. The fact that the CFO is endorsing this, then trying to monitor it, makes him rather suspect as well. It's commendable that you are taking this project on yourself, though it may leave you vulnerable to whatever skulduggery is happening up above your pay grade.

Wayne M.'s answer is probably the best compromise available ... do what the CFO wants, but inform the CEO. Email gives you a documentation trail that you may well need if things go horribly wrong at a later date.

by mary.shaw

Regardless of what else you do in this situation, you must get the CFO's request in writing and save it - for your own protection! You don't know what kinds of shenanigans are going on, you don't want to know, but you especially don't want this to come back and bite you in the butt if the CFO is being underhanded.

by gardoglee

In many cases the building also belongs to the company. However, there are still some places, even in a place of employment, where there is a reasonable expectation of privacy.

Email is not specifically legally protected, but it is still a gray area, so it is foolish to immediately assume that anything the company wishes to do is okey-dokey. The original questioner was wise to think carefully before jumping into this.

by nelsonm

I worked for a company with another IT person who was reading a users email because of personal interest in that particular person. This is completely improper. Upon request by management however it is the correct thing to do. I had a user get upset with me because I copied a system file from her compter that I needed. I had stopped by her desk to look for her and ask if I could get on her computer to get the file but could not find her. I got it thru the network from my computer instead. Later, someone who knew that I was looking for this user informed her that I had been looking for her so she asked me what I had needed from her. I told her I had already copied the file thru the network. I considered this person a friend and didn't think it would be a big deal. The next thing I know I'm in an argument with her and the other women in her department defending myself against a charge that I had somehow violated her. Their argument was that it was as if I were her landlord and gone into her apartment, opened her refrigerator, and takend a sandwich. I had to point out that it is not her apartment(computer) and not her sandwich(file) and that unlike the limitations of a sandwich (cannot be copied), the file was copied and not moved. The other point I had to stress was that all the files on a computer in a company belong to the company and if you have personal information on the computer you had better get it off if you don't want anyone to see it. My boss stood by me on this and it was resolved by me apologizing for hurting her feelings and explaining that I never intended to do that - even though I would not apologize for my actions. She and I are back to being good friends now and I think she has a better understanding of the IT/user/computer relationship.

by ryk1

Unfortunately, the issue of monitoring mail content is far too common. Yet, if the actual objective is truly to mail monitor traffic volume to a specific account, this in most cases can be accomplished through user statistics available through most mail management consoles, without having to access the actual content.

When monitoring content, many arguments can be made about the ownership of the mail system and the rights to access content. However, unless specific policy has been established and the user has been made aware of such policies, perfarably with a signed rights of use contract, the user may have a strong case against the enterprise. Even if you have established rights to monitor mail the problem may still exist along the lines of the chicken and the egg where the question of whether privacy transcends policy or if policy transcends privacy. Regardless, these are not waters you want to tread as they may become career limiting.

As a specialist in SoX, PIPEDA, HIPAA, and othter global privacy initaitives, I have assessed this very issue on more than one occasion, and suggest that if the actual objective is to monitor content violation, transfer of corporate secrets, or other private information THAT IS IN VIOLATION OF CORPORATE POLICY, then policy will in many cases transcend privacy. Yet, to monitor all mail using human resources will violate the users rights.

One of the best methods I have seen to collect content based policy violations from mail, FT, HTML, or IM streams is through the use of devices using complex linguistic and mathematical filters, such as is manufactured by Vericept. With such devices, information is montired over all modes of TCP/IP based communication (relevent to the position is resides on your network), and will identify only information in violation of established policy. No other information will be exposed to the manager, and EMPLOYEE PRIVACY IS RESPECTED UP TO THE POINT THAT THEIR CONTENT VIOLATES POLICY. In this case Policy transcends privacy while establishing a method to respect privacy up to the pooint of violation.

This discussion is closed to new replies.