Discussion Locked

Scientists finally agree that humans contribute to global warming

0 helpful
359 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

359 replies

by tonythetiger

[i]It is because I have examined enough of the research for myself, to persuade me of the worthiness of some effort to have a "small footprint."[/i]

I thought it worthy to expend some effort to have a small footprint long before I ever heard of "Global Warming" or "Climate Change" or whatever it will be called tomorrow, but I do not think it worthy to force my thoughts down others' throats at gunpoint (because it [b]will[/b] come to that ... ).

by jdclyde

and because we have not taken the time to disprove it for you, does not make your case any more valid, nor does it validate you.

by absolutely

Also, the comparison to religion ignores important dissimilarities in the presence or absence of better theories to explain the phenomena each addresses. That's why global warming is the purview of science, and theology is the purview of those with too much time on our hands.

Also, your message is mere assertion, not rebuttal; the text you put between " was not attributed to anybody else, though your formulation implies that it characterizes your opponent. Such characterization, however, is merely your assertion, one which you have not, in that post, even attempted to substantiate.

In conclusion, you're really doing no good for the agenda you claim to advocate. I suspect you are a fanatical ecochondriac, portraying the argument for voluntary conservation measures in the worst possible light, to discredit anybody who would present similar arguments, but competently.

by absolutely

jdclyde claims: "You refuse to support your case and because [u]we have not taken the time to disprove it[/u] for you, does not make your case any more valid, nor does it validate you."

Correction: You have not undertaken the [b]effort[/b] to so much as rebut any of the science, the correct meaning of which is [b]substantive[/b] counterargument, not the sarcastic middle-school quality quips which constitute the entirety of your working vocabulary. In particular, you have both ignored the fact that the laws of probability completely discount your citations of inaccurate predictions by local news channel meteorologists as basis of objections to long range predictions, by researchers whose agenda, by the way, is somewhat more important than whether your picnic is rained out. Those errors do not imply what you have claimed they imply, and deepsand and I [b]have proven[/b] that.

by tonythetiger

[i]you're really doing no good for the agenda you claim to advocate[/i]

could be sent to Mr. Gore, who is responsible for hundreds of times as much CO2 as the average American. Why, one of his transatlantic jaunts uses more fuel than my family uses in an entire year!

[added]

[i]better theories[/i]

You assume that everything [b]can be[/b] explained by science. Or that which cannot be explained by science isn't happening or doesn't exist.

I make no such assumption.

by absolutely

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2375033

[i]Actually, cause is a valid point
it has never been shown just how much of
an effect humans have on changing the temp
on a global scale. It has also never been
shown how much of a difference we can make
to STOP the global changes that are
naturally accruing.

You're welcome to show some of this
information for a change instead of
following the same high road of only
pissing on anyone else's posts to smash
them down.

If we have gone through ice ages before,
that are completely natural and the SUN is
hotter now than it has been in ages, you
are more than welcome so show what
percentage of THIS temperature increase is
caused by humans, and after you show that,
what CAN we do about it?[/i]

Yes, I know all of that was addressed to
deepsand, but since (1) I crashed this
party late & (2) I'm in agreement with
deepsand, at least on the questions of
science I just quoted, I offer to accept
your challenge:

Here is 'square one' of my effort "to show
some of this information for a change
instead of following the same high road of
only pissing on anyone else's posts to
smash them down," which I selected because
of the painstaking effort made to
differentiate between 'natural'
and 'enhanced' greenhouse effects.

http://www.maui.net/~jstark/nasa.html

If you're agreeable to it, I'd like to take
this to minimum message depth and argue
like civilized men.

by absolutely

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=244956&messageID=2392915

[i]But your insistence on proof is evidence in that direction[/i]

The fact is that many of your statements contradict the evidence, and your position that global warming must be proven beyond a shadow of your doubt, in light of the inability you have demonstrated to understand the evidence, is a bit silly, unless your actual purpose is to discredit the position that government has no business taxing carbon emissions.

by tonythetiger

[i]unless your actual purpose is to discredit the position that government has no business taxing carbon emissions.[/i]

That presumes that the position had anything to its credit in the first place.

and re: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=235329&messageID=2393147

[i]I won't say they're irrelevant, but I won't say they're the whole story, either![/i]

They're relevant (and applicable) to the extent that if one is going to claim that humans are [u]mostly[/u] responsible, they had better be able to show what percentage is human, and what percentage is everything else, and before you can do that, you have to know the "everything else".

I liken it to the claim I've read that "We've identified only 10% of the earth crossing asteroids".

by tonythetiger

[i]Suppose that thieves could not be put on trial until the prosecution has proven that everybody else on Earth did not do it.[/i]

That is exactly how police [u]zero in[/u] on a suspect when there isn't any direct evidence. They eliminate people that can most likely be eliminated first. DNA evidence is an example.

[added] Perhaps scientists could learn a lot from the police (well, maybe not the LAPD :) ).

Also one usually waits until the trial is complete and the jury reaches a verdict before meting out the punishment. Instead what we have are vigilantes who have decided to sit in judgment on everyone (except themselves) before we've even been to court.

by absolutely

Absolutely: [i]Suppose that thieves could not be put on trial until the prosecution has proven that everybody else on Earth did not do it.[/i]

TonyTheTiger: [i]That is exactly how police zero in on a suspect when there isn't any direct evidence. They eliminate people that can most likely be eliminated first.[/i]

They begin their process of elimination from a list of most likely suspects. You want to include the Sun in the list of most likely suspects of present climate change? OK, let's go.

[i]DNA evidence is an example. [added] Perhaps scientists could learn a lot from the police (well, maybe not the LAPD :) ). Also one usually waits until the trial is complete and the jury reaches a verdict before meting out the punishment. Instead what we have are vigilantes who have decided to sit in judgment on everyone (except themselves) before we've even been to court.[/i]

Point.

Do you mind taking a look at this, and commenting on it?

http://www.maui.net/~jstark/nasa.html

by tonythetiger

It seems to say that we need more information and better models.

One question I have is how is this 0.5C rise arrived at? Are the before and after measurements measuring the same thing?

Is a thermometer in a field in Central Ohio in 1890 measuring the same thing as the same thermometer at the same location which is today surrounded by freeways and parking lots? Does that indicate anything for an area 20 miles away that remained rural from then until now that wasn't measured?

Are there areas that weren't being measured before, but are being measured now? If there are, and those measurements are being used to determine the current global average, are assumptions being made as to what these measurements would have been had they been measured before (it seems that's the only way to do it)?

by absolutely

The NOAA has a number of buoys in use for that reason; changes to the landscape such as your urbanization example can't happen at sea, or at least, the real estate isn't considered by the market to be attractive for stationary settlement! Anyway, the sea isn't changing in those ways, and generally, you'd need to demonstrate that specific measurements are [u]in[/u]valid, much as you would have to prove that evidence presented in a trial has either been planted, counterfeited, or is misinterpreted.

If your car was the only one near the scene of the crime, and if the paint on the victims' corpses matches your car's paint job, even if it's "generic" paint used in all models [You can have any color Model-T you want, as long as ... ] ever produced by the manufacturer of your car, that might be strong circumstantial evidence against you, or more.

Anyway, in science, studies have to be reviewed to be published, by people who are at least competent in statistical analysis and capable of understanding the jargon of each paper they review, even if they have to look up a couple terms. To call into question the methods, as you just did, the responsibility is on you to find specific examples of bad measurement or analysis techniques.

by tonythetiger

whether it's people who can't get what they want on their own merits, and want to control other people as a way to get what they think is their due; or if these people honestly think they know what's better for us than we do ourselves.

Either way, it's undesirable in my book. There was a phrase in the 50s, "Better dead than red" that applies.

by deepsand

Those with whom I take strong exception are those who cannot and/or will not undertake to engage in a scientific investigation that has the potential to threaten their cherished views, those who cling to those views with all the fervor of a religious zealot.

In their quivers they have no arrows but those by which they accuse those who would be rightly informed that, because absolute certainty in all things is unattainable, doubt alone, no matter how small, should prevail.

by deepsand

Perhaps you are unaware that the West has in fact exported its smokestack industries to China; in some case the very equipment itself has been painstakingly disassembled, shipped to China, and been reassembled.

China in turn uses those factories to produce goods that are shipped back to the very countries who used to produce such locally. It is the demands of the West for such products that results in the great amount of CO2 and other noxious by-products now generated in China.

Therefore, we've done nothing but relocate our own "pollution" to another part of the world.

Were the U.S. to repatriate such factories, its own level of CO2 generation would be roughly 30% higher than at present.

So, before pointing fingers at others, you would be well advised to consider the responsibilities that you bear for their acts.

by deepsand

as having been based on faulty data.

Endless repetition will not suffice to make your claim true.

Deal with it.

by deepsand

To concentrate on a single hypothetical "loss," to assert that such "loss" will arise in any eventually, and that the "value" of each such "loss" is likewise equal, with absolutely no attempt at justifying such assumptions, is to dissemble by design.

You now engage in naught but intellectual dishonesty.

There was once a time when I held out hope that your mind was still open to knowledge; it now appears that I was mistaken.

by deepsand

the very traits that best serve to describe your zealotry is both pathetic and laughable.

"Religious fervor?" "Fanatics?"

If that's the best you can muster in defense of your position then you are forfeit.

by deepsand

populated by sellers and buyers who are equally ignorant of such constraints can hardly be called a "free" one outside of a narrow and relative sense.

That the condemned may chose the means to his end does not a "free" choice provide.

by deepsand

[b]very big assumption[/b] re. knowledge.

Given the case where the probability of A being true cannot be ascertained as being 100%, you [b]assume[/b] that any other possibilites are equally likely to be true, even if such alternative possibilites are unknown, whether in kind, scope, or effect.

This is common, and is typically exhibited by the tendency to ascribe 50-50 odds to the outcome of randomly selecting 1 of 2 possible outcomes.

That the probabilities of all possible outcomes are not known does not make them equal.

In the case of GW, there is a high probability that those with whom you disagree are correct. That the exactitude of such remains unknown does [b]not[/b] raise the probability of your being correct to match that of any other possibility.

Your posts implicitly admit of your understanding this, as evidenced by your persistent insistence that you have no burden of proof, and that your opponents' burden can be satisfied only by proof certain, i.e. "100%," to use your words.

by deepsand

chickens, lamb, eggs, and dairy products, including whole, raw milk, taste a whole lot better than the crap that most today eat.

by jdclyde

What you seem to be ignoring is the lack of STANDARDS of emissions in China has plants putting out a HIGHER concentration of pollution than a plant that does the same job in the US.

Not having to meet EPA standards is a big savings on top of the almost free work force.

In China, they don't have the dillusion that ANYONE "has a right" to free health care, do they?

by tonythetiger

[i]Given the case where the probability of A being true cannot be ascertained as being 100%, you assume that any other possibilites are equally likely to be true, even if such alternative possibilites are unknown, whether in kind, scope, or effect.[/i]

assume that any other possibilities are equally likely to be true, I just don't assume that they are FALSE just because I don't know about them.

[i]This is common, and is typically exhibited by the tendency to ascribe 50-50 odds to the outcome of randomly selecting 1 of 2 possible outcomes.[/i]

We wouldn't need "odds" if we had enough information. Isn't that the whole idea of gaining knowledge? The more you know, the better you can predict.

[i]In the case of GW, there is a high probability that those with whom you disagree are correct.[/i]

First, let's be clear. I do not "disagree", I am skeptical. I have never claimed that GW isn't happening, or that humans aren't mostly responsible for it. I simply do not think there is enough evidence to justify the forced violation of personal liberty in order to "fix" it, especially when I also do not think there is enough evidence that the steps taken will "work" and that they may have the potential themselves to produce unexpected and undesirable side effects.

Secondly, assuming you meant "skeptical", what does that mean (high probability)? High compared to what? Is there a calculation you performed to determine this probability? What is the result, as a percentage? or perhaps a range of percentages? And please show your work.

by tonythetiger

you'll discover that I have a few arrows, among other things having a potential use related to the political aspect of this issue.

by absolutely

Address it to your satisfaction; mine doesn't need to be any of your concern, but thanks.

by jdclyde

Sorry, been on the road doing emergency support all week. I did NOT forget, and will be back....

by jdclyde

Well, I have doubts as to the amounts man contributes/causes GW, and I also have doubts as to how much of a difference we CAN have to stop GW.

Or is it only your doubts that prevail?

by tonythetiger

They might have wondered about the probability of a big rock hitting the earth and killing them all, and decided it was too small to worry about.

by absolutely

TonyTheTiger: [i]We wouldn't need "odds" if we had enough information. Isn't that the whole idea of gaining knowledge? The more you know, the better you can predict.[/i]

Do you have any hypotheses other than "It's only the Sun"?

Ironically, even if I convince you to accept global warming, caused by human emissions of CO2, as the only reasonable theory, I'll still agree that taxes and regulations first is bad form, and bad strategy, on the part of enviros.

by tonythetiger

but $hit happens, regardless of the presence or absence of hypotheses, theories, or even science itself.

by absolutely

[i]...but $hit happens, regardless of the
presence or absence of hypotheses,
theories, or even science itself.[/i]

Therefore ... what?

by deepsand

[i]possiblities[/i] which, owing to their lack of empirical support, are [i]implausible[/i]; i.e., you allow of them a probability that far exceeds that which can be reasonably assigned to them.

by deepsand

You've conveniently ignored the facts that:

1) Many of these plants were [b]transplanted[/b] from the West to China; and, the,
2) Many such old plants continue to operate [b]only because of Western demand[/b] for their output.

If you like, we could repatriate those plants, and give you the choice of either living with their resulting pollutions here, or of paying for their replacement by way of significantly higher prices for the goods they produce.

You can have cheap production that is polluting, or more costly production that is less polluting. Either way, there is an unavoidable cost to be paid.

by deepsand

as demonstrated by your persistent claims that any Policy based upon the present understandings of Science re. GW would trample on your "rights," perhaps you would elaborate. Specifically:

1) What "rights" do you envision as being "taken?"

2) How would such be accomplished?

3) And, by whom?

As regards the taking of "property," as referenced by you:

4) Real property or personal?

5) same as 1)

6) same as 2)

7) same as 3)

8) To whom would these properties be transferred?

by tonythetiger

[i]Policy based upon the present understandings of Science re. GW would trample on your "rights,"[/i]

Not "based upon the present understanding"... based on your [b]claim[/b] of what is the present understanding.

1. My right to live my life unmolested.

2. By force, most assuredly, unless they want to wait until my natural death.

3. An agent of some government (which government I cannot say. I am hoping that the USA will survive as a nation but if a lot of people don't get off their asses and do something to stop what's happening, it's questionable.)

4. Both.

5. Same as 1.

6. Same as 2.

7. same as 3.

8. To someone else. the "who" doesn't matter.

[added:]

It's not that I am not interested in science, it's that I am not in awe of it. I am more interested in policy because it is a much more immediate threat to the wellbeing of myself and those I care about. My wellbeing is important to me, and I will defend it just as if it were my life.

by deepsand

"[i]Not "based upon the present understanding"... based on your claim of what is the present understanding.[/i]"

Call it a claim if you like, but take note that it is indeed a substantiated one.

"1. [i] My right to live my life unmolested.[/i]"

You'll need to both defined "unmolested" and demonstrate a basis for your claim to so be.

"2. [i]By force, most assuredly, ... .[/i]"

While that may be a possible way, you state nothing as to the means; please try again.

"[i]5. Same as 1.[/i]"

Wholly non-responsive. Please name those [b]properties[/b] which you envision as being taken.

"[i]6. Same as 2.[/i]"

Again, avoids the means involved.

"[i]8. To someone else. the "who" doesn't matter.[/i]"

Evasive. Kindly answer.

"[i]It's not that I am not interested in science, it's that I am not in awe of it. I am more interested in policy because it is a much more immediate threat to the wellbeing of myself and those I care about.[/i]"

All the more reason to become sufficiently informed as to the Science, so as to be better able to determine what is and is not appropriate Policy.

by tonythetiger

You people have been chomping at the bit for decades for an excuse to control energy (Hell, you're already doing it in government housing... tennants can't even control their own thermostats!). Control the energy, control the people! ( And now you've conjured a "crisis" as an attempt to do it. You pretend to be "for the poor" but in fact your policies [b]widen[/b] the gap between wealthy and poor, and squelching opportunity and progress by controlling who can participate. Yeah, lets make electric cars and tax the $hit out of oil. That way the rich will drive around tax-free and the poor can't afford to drive to the next town to look for a better job. Your alleged compassion makes me want to vomit!

I believe there are two kinds of liberals... the incredibly ignorant and the incredibly evil, and that the latter must be destroyed to avert the subjugation of most of us. If I can contribute to that destruction in even a small way, I would consider myself a hero for humanity.

We are diametrically opposed and will always remain so. I hope at least that part is crystal clear.

This will be my last post in this thread.

by absolutely

[i]Yeah, lets make electric cars and tax the $hit out of oil.[/i]

The People pay taxes. The corporations receive subsidies, when in financial distress.

by absolutely

The weather's here; wish you were beautiful!

I just checked in on this thread for the first time since my last message, probably more than a month ago, now. Re-subscribing, so whenever you're ready to resume the conversation, I'll get notification. I hope the weather improves soon, where you are.

by absolutely

[i]All the more reason to become sufficiently informed as to the Science, so as to be better able to determine what is and is not appropriate Policy.[/i]

Having represented yourself as knowledgeable of the Science, what Policy do you propose?

This discussion is closed to new replies.