Sen John Kerry should be ashamed of himself
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tonythetiger
I see now how it could be taken as offense and I apologize. I did not intend to offend but to emphasize, and chose a phrase poorly.
Too many people throw around words like "freedom" and "rights" without understanding that these concepts do not and cannot stand alone. They are always accompanied by a "responsibility" to try to use that right or freedom without infringing on a right or freedom of someone else.
I surely have the right to flail my fists wildly about, but the instant one of them connects with some poor fellow's jaw, there are going to be consequences for which I am going to be held responsible.
Words can have just as much power. Most places I've been have laws on the books regarding inciting a riot, and, telling or asking someone else to commit a crime is itself a crime in most places. On the other side of the coin, many jurisdictions have "intense or continuing provocation" as an affirmative defense against an assault charge. I believe at least one jurisdiction calls it the "fighting words doctrine".
Again, I am sorry for my poor choice of words.
by road-dog
Each of those nations should search within their borders and should they find prisoners being detained or treated in a way not consistent with local law, then go in and deal with it.
I suspect that those nations where these prisons "exist" are aware of them and there is some complicity with the "host" government.
This is a ruse really. Secret prisons MAY exist where prisoners MAY be being mistreated. Then the US is expected to refute this.
Every journalist and foreign official who is pushing for a confirmation should be asked to provide proof that they have never had sex with a farm animal.
They have no evidence, so they make the allegation to push their anti-US agenda using a willing press to create a story where none exists.
They are getting the proverbial cart before the horse. They might want to find something to be outraged about first. Maybe their energies would be better spent saving their outrage for terrorists who have press releases when they torture and kill illegally held prisoners....
There was me thinking that the whole idea was that we were [b]better[/b] than the terrorists because we [b]don't[/b] torture prisoners and we [b]don't[/b] take photographs of the torture (which doesn't happen of course) of prisoners.
At least in the UK we have had the law Lords, the highest stratum of judiciary, declare that the use of evidence extracted by torture - wherever and whenever it was done - is inadmissible in any court.
Trust me, in this war, there's enough outrage to go round!
by m_a_r_k
I think those prisons where this tortrure allegedly is taking place is actually in countries that allow such appropriate means of pulling information from terrorist thugs. The issue the Europeans supposedly have is that we used European airports to fly the scoundrels to those countries. I have no problem with yanking out terrorists' toenails one by one. The problem is being sure the guy really is a terrorist and not a case of mistaken identity. Too often we rely on the guy's name. Hell, they're all named Mohammed. Can't tell them apart by their names.
It sure would be great if we could fight fire with fire and have press releases when we beat the hell out of terrorists, just like those thugs used to have when they chopped people's heads off. Thankfully, even terrorists have a few brains and realized that publicizing such a heinous act hurt their astronomically high public opinion in certain parts of the world.
The problem with Democrats is that they keep on voting even when they are dead. In fact, some people who were life long Republicans or independents end up voting Democratic after they die. This phenomenon is common in Chicago and in some of the rural counties in western Alabama.
Another similar phenomenon is people who would never vote for a Democrat when they are of sound mind end up voting for Democrats by absentee ballot after they have gone senile or insane and are in a nursing home or mental hospital.
The dead, the senile, and the insane are three constituencies that the Democrats have locked up.
by jdclyde
I love how the page you link is titled "Bush's lies about WMD's". All of the links I had followed when I first went there were all internal links.
I go back and find all kinds of interesting things. The beheadings were all done by the CIA?
Racism in Canada?
Euthanasia Rights? Followed directly by "Suicide, Talking to suicidally depressed people". (sometimes suicide is good and other times its not?)
I can't even begin to discuss my thoughts about the child porn posting there that [b]encourages[/b] hand drawn and CG pics of small children. Did you read it? You won't like it.
"It attempted to steal the second largest oil reserves on the planet worth trillions."
"It sent thousands of Iraqi children to hideously painful deaths."
Do I need to go on?
I will look at your other links in the morning, but I am done with this "source".
The problem is, Mark, that you set yourselves up as the example for others to follow. You and JD implicitly assume that a definition of "Human Rights" would come from the US. The term "Human Rights" is indeed relative but by telling the rest of the world how it should be done, you set yourself up to be scrutinised. I don't think that you're a "big" violator of human rights but you ain't whiter than white!
We look at Guantanamo Bay where your country incarcerated some of my countrymen and charged none of them despite lengthy detention and treatment that [b]we[/b] might define as torture. All ex-detainees were freed within 24hrs of their return to Britain. We wonder what is happening with "Extraordinary Renditions" and how much has been covered up in Abu Graib
According to British Home office figures, the US has the highest prison population in the world. At the end of 2004 there were 3,218 black male sentenced prison inmates per 100,000 black males in the United States, compared to 1,220 per 100,000 for Hispanic males and 463 per 100,000 for white males.
Sorry, Mark, but something isn't right.
Neil
p.s. Why is Guantanamo in Cuba. I thought that you didn't like them and that they didn't like you? By the way, you're talking to a man who would give Gibraltar back to Spain and probably even Ulster to the Irish...
by road-dog
from the pre-Castro days. I never got assigned there, but the consensus from acquaintances is that aside from the Cuban Snipers, isolation, and mosquitos, it's a slice of heaven.
As for the prison population breakdown, take a walk down MLK avenue in any metropolitan area. If you survive, you will know why the numbers shape up as they do.
As human rights go, detention seems pretty compassionate in comparison to the alternatives available around the world.
As for definition of human rights; look at the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights article 29 paragraph (3)
These rights and freedoms may in no case be exercised contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations.
http://www.un.org/Overview/rights.html
Human rights have their limits, even to the UN, the supposed arbitrary authority.
Extraordinary crimes require extraordinary responses.
by m_a_r_k
I understand what you're saying. I don't necessarily agree with the U.S.' go-it-alone "this is how it should be done" policy. And I am not privy to know what is going on in Guantanamo so I cannot even offer much of an opinion on the prisoners there, other than most of those guys were picked up in Afghanistan where they were ostensibly fighting for the Taliban or al-Qaeda. Enough said on that...
I'm not sure what the demographics of American prisons has to do with human rights violations. Why in the world is the British Home Office compiling statistics about AMERICAN prisons? Wouldn't the UK be better served if they were doing something about their own seething population of malcontents that set off bombs in subways?
As far as why we have a military base in Cuba...We like Cubans; it's only communism that we have a problem with. A base next door to Fidel is a convenient way to keep him in check. Just like we used to have military bases all over Europe to keep the Russian bear out of the homes of you and your friends. ;)
It's been widely reported that at least a couple of the UK detainees were visiting family in Pakistan, near the Afghan border, and were kidnapped by Afghanis, shipped over the border and sold to US forces as "al-Qaeda fighters" for a couple of thousand dollars. I can't say that this is true but I can certainly believe it!
Like all governments in the world, we collect stuff. How can we know if we're any good unless we compare and we have a Freedom of Information Act which means I get to see it. As for prisoners, we are well above the median which means that I can't be smug. The figures for the US actually came from the US government but the Home Office comparison paper just happened to pop up at the top of my google.co.uk search.
As for "seething" - most of the "suicide bomb fodder" are seething about Iraq. The recruiters and trainers recognised that and 7/7 was the result. Without the Iraq war, I think it was less likely to happen as it did.
As for "keeping Fidel in check". Do you have the moral right to do it? You may have some sort of treaty from the 1950s but, when all is said and done, they are a sovereign state even if you don't like their politics! They're hardly any danger to you now. To the outside observer it seems quite vindictive - and stupid - to refuse to trade with Cuba when that is the one thing that would bring communism down fastest.
The Russian Bear. Face it, Mark, it was in your own self-interest too. A totally Russian Europe would have shagged the world economy, including yours, in nothing flat!
But we're grateful. Really. We are! :p
(The French hate you for it, though)
:D
by road-dog
He ran a pretty good war as results show. Not a pre-existing war hero.
Quite frankly, Kerry's 7 months and 3 band-aid purple hearts don't make him an any better military authority than a fighter pilot as President Bush was. The consensus of his fellow "river rats" is that he was a dip$hit back then, too.
Troops are getting picked off because we are not searching every Iraqi on every street. Now, THAT would be a violation of Islamic custom, patting down their women for explosives.
Think about what you're saying. Bomb sniffing dogs can't keep up with a convoy moving at 50 MPH sniffing every car as they go by. It takes over a year and thousands of dollars to train a bomb dog.
They change tactics, we change tactics. We catch them placing a bomb, an Apache shoves a hellfire missile up their a$$. The body parts are collected and S-4 figures out what new tricks they're using. The daily battle continues....
Look around your neighborhood. If you had explosives, couldn't you do a lot of damage in spite of all the police in your town? They cannot be everywhere. Now imagine if you had a couple of hundred friends with explosives. That is what exists in Iraq.
If this is such a simple and easy task, why was the IRA in business so long, in spite of Protestant militants and Brit troops hunting them? Even the much vaunted SAS (COMPLETE badasses in any estimation) unable to stop the bombings and killings?
Training troops in counterinsurgency ops takes us lots of time and cross-pollination of experience. This takes advantage of a cadre of experienced NCOs to pass along hard-earned lessons to junior troops on an ongoing basis. We have an ongoing cycle of mentoring going on all the time.
The fledgeling Iraqi defense forces are starting from scratch. There is no hard-core NCO class to pass this vital experience along. The Iraqi army was 2 tiered, Saddam loyalists and draftees. No NCO class to provide institutional continuity.
Trained and equipped Iraqis will take over in time. To turn things over too early is foolhardy.
Our troops are doing a difficult and dangerous job. My brother was so close to an IED explosion that he had body parts fly over his head. To have Kerry insulting these honorable and valiant men is a cross we bear for our tolerance of dissent. He has the right to be an a$$, and I have the right to call him what he is.
by m_a_r_k
Neil, are you blaming the subway bombers' crime on the fact that British armed forces are involved in Iraq? You seem like a sensible fella, so surely you aren't going to blame the US for a crime that British citizens committed against other British citizens?
As for keeping Fidel in check, I wholeheartedly agree that our policy against Cuba is stupid. Trading and open dialogue would solve a lot of problems if given a chance. I'd be willing to be that every American president since Kennedy has no idea why our policy toward Cuba is as it is. They're just following what the previous administration did because of events from past history. Personally, I think wily ol' Fidel is smart enough to knock cross an invisible line in the sand (or at least not get caught doing it) and that has always been a frustrating thorn in the side of the US government. However, we aren't do anything to impinge on Cuba's rights as a sovereign state. Since when does having a military base across the border and not trading with a country impinge on their sovereign rights?
Yep, reining in the Soviet bear was in our self-interest too. But a totally Soviet Europe shagging the world economy? Do you really think so? Look at the economic state of the Eastern bloc countries prior to the fall of the Iron Curtain. You can't blame that on the quality of people living in those countries. For example, East Germans and West Germans were all the same kind of industrious, hard-working Germans before WWII. So there can be only cause: Soviet rule.
by jdclyde
In no way am I blaming the US for our July bombings. I'm blaming the bombers and, above all, the people who were able to subvert these ordinary guys to the extent that they did what they did. What I do think, though, is that the UK's involvement in Iraq made it easier for the recruiters and continues to make my country less safe. So far, the "War Against Terror" - at least in its visible manifestations - is a crock of crap.
Cuba? I don't really know the history but I still don't know why there's a border on the island that cuts off a small portion which is occupied by an unfriendly foreign power. If the roles were reversed and Cuba occupied (ligitimately in their eyes with treaties to prove it) a portion of Florida, you'd be spitting chips of teeth until you got it "back".
As for Russia, in no sense was I saying that a totally Soviet Europe would have been good for [b]anybody[/b]. NATO kept the balance.
Neil
there's hope left for the world yet.
Was watching newsnight (UK current affairs) program last night. Next Democrat presidential nominee (Robert Mcgovern ?) was on. He was much more erudite than Kerry, the two main points he was trying to score off the 'Bush administration' was
The burnt bridges and lowering of resepect for the US amongst it's allies after the 'My way or the highway' policies.
The other one he was hitting on was how even rumours of policies like extreme rendition, undermined the US's campaign for democracy and freedom in the world. I know a lot of you guys don't like democrats, but this guy was looking like a dangerous one, certainly he chose his words more carefully than Kerry and managed to string them together to make a sensible statement.
by jck
In my reference to that site, I told you it was:
[i]Rather than quote you tons of links, I'll give you a Canadian one that quotes US and British news sources, official CIA documents, and other things.[/i]
I gave you a website that contained credible sources. You went there, looked at the first few screens, and took a first-look stance rather than going through all the information available.
My original comment on the site was in reference to its links (which are to the BBC, London Times, the CIA website, and a couple others) where it references news sources and official government documents...not all the stuff at the top you hastily judged the site on (even though the site author does provide dates and what the material was from).
Again, enjoy the sources I pointed you to rather than the site that contained them.
Anyways...have a good morning. :D
by jck
... Kerry's statement.
Kerry didn't call them anything...he didn't call them "terrorists"...or "dip$hits"...or "a$$eS"... he simply said that what they were doing terrorized kids and children...and that there were Iraqis who should be performing that duty of going into homes.
And if you don't think someone crashing in your house in the middle of the night isn't terrorizing to your kids, then you haven't had it happen to you.
Hint: just say no to drugs :^O
As for putting dogs out to detect bombs:
Most of the bombings of the Iraqi police stations and recruiting drives and within Baghdad have been by terrorist insurgents who were on foot and detonated their devices. There have been a smaller number that have been detonated from within vehicles, and the majority of those were parked vehicles...not ones travelling 50 mph.
The dogs would be useful in detecting the explosives before they are detonated and saving military and civilian life.
And detecting one on a woman wouldn't mean there would have to be any infringement of their religious belief...it would mean that a man could not search them. We do have female military there who could perform those searches without breaking any religious standard.
As for Kerry's service career:
The 3 band-aid purple hearts were given to him by superiors under military standard for the award...not because Kerry jerked his way into them.
As for his "river rat" buddies...well, I've heard some say he was no good...I've heard some say he was a hero...so, I guess whose "river rat" you listen to that makes the difference.
Again, I think Kerry would know more about being in a live, action-front military role since he went to Vietnam where he was shot at...unlike Bush, who got to stay home near mom and dad in Texas and fly jets.
Hence, I think he better understands the situations and dangers our military is in better than Bush based on military experience.
As for why it's taking so long to train them:
One of the reasons could be, according to a counterinsurgency expert at Rand:
[i]"Efforts to train the Iraqi security forces floundered for 18 months after the fall of Mr. Hussein, enabling the insurgency to take root and flourish." - Nora Bensahel[/i]
I work with 3 retired military folks, one of which who was in the Marines and involved in special forces ops.
He told me that you don't plan to do this kind of thing quick and dirty...and that re-establishing Iraq back to a stable country is measured not in the scale of a couple of years, but more like a couple of [b]decades[/b]. This is a guy who knows what he's talking about and has been trained in the stuff.
Yet, the Bush administration keeps hinting at that they have a strategy...they have a plan...yet, you don't hear the real deal from them...you don't hear about milestones or goals they will meet...and just keep hearing the same vague, feel-good rhetoric like "things are going well" and "we are making progress". They keep playing like they're going to get this done quick and easy and they have it under control.
Well I got news for ya...this kind of thing is never quick...and it's never easy. Hence in the meantime, they're pumping out warm-and-fuzzies and hoping they can cover their a$$ when something comes up they didn't tell the public about up front.
Besides...Bush had to hide the facts...do you think if he would have said "We're going to invade Iraq, oust Hussein and... then we're going to spend the next 20 years and $1.3 trillion rebuilding their country." that he'd have been able to convince the American people that it was a "just cause"?
I think not.
I'm all for liberating people from the scoundrels of the world and making the planet a peaceful place. However, I think that has been FAR too much "floundering" in the process. We are supposed to be the one remaining "superpower" on the planet, yet we're botching so many things when it comes to successfully re-establishing the country of Iraq.
So, who in the end is responsible for that?
The Bush Administration
.
People who criticize President Bush for his military experience, and/or make light of how he served, fall into one of two categories. They are either doing it for purely political smear reasons, or they don't know much about the roll of the ANG in the late 60s and early 70s.
GWB flew an F-102 fighter interceptor jet, he logged more than 600 hours flying time over his weeks and weekends, and was, along with hundreds of other ANG pilots, the nation's first line of defense against air attack from the outside. And for those who won't acknowledge that threat, they don't know their history or didn't live at that time.
I served in the active duty Air Force at about the same time GWB was in the guard. And I, too, was in a position to be involved in the front line of defense for the USA. People have no idea how many thousands of times that a pair of ANG fighter interceptors, including the F-102s from GWB's duty station, were scrambled to intercept a lone, or even a squadron, of unknown aircraft approaching US air space.
The southeastern USA was especially busy because of the constant air traffic from Russia to Cuba, many of which were Russian military aircraft being met by Cuban military aircraft, flying into US air space. Those F-102s were, at times, out-gunned and out-manned up there, but they were the first on-site. I wouldn't be a bit surprised if GWB was among those pilots scrambled, and he may have even had the pleasure of looking into the eyes of an enemy pilot flying a faster and more lethal MIG.
It happened all the time. I saw it happen. I was involved in it happening. Active duty and ANG, working together, to defend the air space of the USA. And believe me, it was a mission that was, and should have been, taken very seriously. The threat was very real.
GWB did his part. Just like the hundreds of other ANG pilots who were the nation's first responders. Anyone who thinks otherwise is a foolish and ignorant dolt. And to criticize GWB for doing his part, they're also criticizing hundreds of others who did the same thing.
by road-dog
You can believe the 21 of Kerry's teammates who are against him or the one who backed him.
You can believe that Bush chose Air National Guard to be near "mom and dad". Perhaps you also believe that the thousands of NGs in Iraq are there to be near their parents also.
Were all those others who had jobs in stategic defense of Conus tyring to be near mom and dad also?
Your assertion that the primary modus operandi of terrorists is bombing of static targets is simply wrong.
The IED War in Iraq
by James Dunnigan
April 14, 2005
http://tinyurl.com/8shh7
Just how deeply into the minutae of the "plan" do you need to be briefed? The plan has always been to clear, hold, and build.
The plan has always been to establish commerce infrastructure.
The plan has always been to create an environment in which an electoral process could be created and fostered.
The plan has always been to create infrastructure to create a higher standard of living for Iraqis.
To the truly objective observer, these ARE mission objectives with economic, military, and diplomatic components. By any fair estimation, this is bold and honorable.
You can find information on all this if you care to look and have the courage to have your worldview disputed.
Get out of the echo chamber man!!!
BTW, would FDR have gotten the American people on board in WWII if he told everyone that we would be in Germany and Japan 50 years later?
Did he give the American people a "hedgerow by hedgerow" plan for the war plans?
To those who will be critical, no amount of detail is enough, no level of success is enough, no amount of evidence is enough.
I've got news for you too; the President said this was going to be a long hard slog. He chose to proceed because he believed that it was the right thing to do. Your "revelation" might be news to some who get their information only from a few sources that echo their own belief system, but it isn't "news" to me.
If you understand that this will take 20 years and over a trillion dollars, then how can you say this is floundering? If you plan to raise a child and expect the process to take 20 years, are your efforts "floundering" if the child acts 10 years old 10 years into the process?
Please post a link to the news story where the President said this would be quick and easy. You can create a false opposing argument and then argue against it all day..... Personally I like life in the real world. Care to join me?
.
Well said. I couldn't have said it better myself.
by road-dog
You have a funny way of making your argument. Your bias is laughably apparent as indicated by the point at which you stopped quoting your source material. Had you gone just gone ONE SENTENCE FURTHER, you would have been a little more fair, but that isn't your objective, is it?
Allow me to paint a more accurate picture of the article's assessment of the situation:
=============================>
Efforts to train the Iraqi security forces floundered for 18 months after the fall of Mr. Hussein, enabling the insurgency to take root and flourish. Several months ago, the United States made the training effort its top priority, and the early results are promising. Iraqi military and police forces are increasingly conducting joint patrols with U.S. and coalition forces and are starting to build the capacity for independent operations.
================================>
Hmmm. seems to paint a little bit different picture, doesn't it? Face it, you're busted. If you want to cite an article that supports your myopic view, at least wear your glasses and interpret it with some amout of intellectual honesty. There are plenty of hacks out there that share your penchant for cherry-picking items that support your biased view. Cite them and at least the casual observer can "consider the source".
On a side note, Ms. Bensahel's bio doesn't say how much combat experience she got while studying polital science at Stanford. Maybe serving in Vietnam is not a prerequisite for expertise in this venue..... Or is combat experience only relevant when it is attached to an opinion that suits your views?
by jdclyde
think that humiliating people is torture?
If that is the case, then I have people from back in high school that I need to go report, quickly, before they can get away!
Beating? Yes, that would be torture. Hurting their feelings or even making them fear for their safety is not.
All put into PROPER perspective when you look at what Saddam did in his prisions, and what goes on today in Castro's prisions and see what REAL torture is.
We don't hear the outrage againsts that though. Funny how that works, huh?
by tonythetiger
I certainly don't feel that I can use what Saddam Hussein may or may not have done to justify anything that might be done in my name by my country's representatives. I don't know too much about Castro so I won't comment on him.
As for Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo, yes, from what I have heard, there's been torture. I don't belive that it was necessarily policy to do it but we need to know whether there was tacit approval from them upstairs.
Can't help it, mate. You should know by now that I'm an anti-war liberal wimp...
Never mind. You have a Happy Egg-Nog!
by jck
Q) how long does it take to realize you're not doing your job effectively?
A) Takes the Department of Defense 18 months, evidently.
Making something your top priority after 18 months of screwing up doesn't mean it wasn't a screw-up you made. It's not a myopic view...it's realism.
If you or I did our job wrong for 18 months, we'd be fired for it...and probably long before then.
===============
Q) Did I state that terrorists' "modus operandi" was "static targets"?
A) No, I pointed out that most of their human targets had been ones that were static. However, I neither said those were their only or exclusive targets, nor their "modus operandi" (or lone pattern of strategy).
Terrorists are opportunists. And, static targets are the easiest ones to hit. Therefore, terrorists are going to do what is easiest for them to do the most damage.
I thought that would be quite obvious for anyone to realize.
===============
Needless to say, being over the flatlands of west Texas is not the same as being shot at by SAMs or AAF over the jungle of Vietnam, let alone being on the ground and trying to avoid the VC.
Again, I'd like to point out to you, since you can't seem to distinguish these things:
-being deployed to Vietnam was being sent into a combat theatre.
-being deployed to Iraq is being sent into a combat theatre.
-being deployed to the National Guard airfield near your family home is [b]NOT[/b] being sent into a combat theatre.
1+1 doesn't equal 5, bud.
===========
As for Ms. Bensahel's:
My point was spot on. The Department of Defense screwed around for 18 months (or as she phrased it "floundered") before they realized they were making no progress...yet they can tell in 10 weeks if someone is going to make a good soldier or not.
And, that led to the insurgent terrorists getting dug in (as Jesse Ventura said in Predator) "like an Alabama tick".
Nice try there. What they did in the past "several months" does not validate the "floundered" 18 months they wasted.
That is in the eyes of an expert in counterinsurgency...they took too long...which is what I was pointing out to you by prefacing that quote with this:
[i]As for why it's taking so long to train them:
One of the reasons could be, according to a counterinsurgency expert at Rand:[/i]
==========
Now I'd like to ask one thing of you, road-dog:
How many guys do you know got stationed during Vietnam on active manuevers stateside with the NG or Reserves within 100 miles of their home?
It was not chance Dubya got put where he did. Prescott was his grandfather. George was his father. He wouldn't have been put anywhere else but near his home or there would have been political repercussions.
He got preferential treatment. That's obvious. There were others who did too...who got waivers to attend university rather than serve...etc... because of their family status.
He's not the only one, but to imply his record is somehow equivalent to Kerry's active combat record when Bush was flying in a non-combative zone...is daft.
Plus, it's kind of funny that many of his papers from the Texas Air National Guard are missing now and no one can find them even though they are considered government service records and no one has been held accountable for it.
by jck
I'm not discussing things with you...remember? You are not worth my time.
Have a nice day. :^O
Would the american public be really unhappy about people involved in terrorist activities being poked with a sharp stick, I doubt it. Being viewed as a nation of lying hyprocrites has got to be a problem though surely.
I'm not saying you are liars and hyprocrites but your words 'Defender of freedom and democracy' and your deeds lock any suspicious bugger up without trial don't match up.
Defenders of America, **** with us and we'll **** you up, is not a problem though, why hide it, as though is was bad or dishonourable, it isn't. If your opponent won't play by the rules, then **** the rules, they were invented to protect you not them. That's what your doing, if you want respect for it though, make it what you're are saying as well.
If we can get GWB to be honest about it maybe poodle Blair will follow him again. We live in hope anyway.
Strange attitude for a renowned pinko commie left wing faggot tree hugger isn't it. ?
by road-dog
for you to realize you aren't making your point effectively?
you took issue with our troops being picked off. I pointed out (correctly) that the primary way our troops are attacked is via roadside IED, where bomb dogs are unhelpful.
Are you aware that in Islamic culture dogs are considered an "unclean" animal? Dealing with cultural hurdles is something that has to be taken into account. Maybe Kerry would like our troops to walk amongst Muslims with dogs, further "terrorizing" Iraqis, so he can further insult our troops.
As for Dubya's service in the TANG, think about it this way. The president is the CEO of the company. Joe trooper is the equivalent of working on the loading dock of the company. Does having worked in the loading dock of the company qualify one as the CEO, moreso than someone with a background elswhere in the company? Further, Does the CEO need to know the number of boxes that can be shrinkwrapped on a single pallet? no non sequitur. Your logic doesn't follow. The Presidency is a "big picture" position.
No, 1+1 doesn't =5. too bad (for you) I wasn't trying to make it so. You are drawing a false connection and I'm calling you on it. Too bad you are so tied up with Bush's proximity to his family. You might be considered as rational otherwise. BTW, I'm not sure his Dad was in Texas, as he was in the CIA and presumably in DC at the time.
No, I don't know anybody in the guard during Vietnam. I DO know that you enlist and join a particular unit. My brother is in the FNG, and his armory is within jogging distance from his house. It is not like the regular army where you can be assigned anywhere.
His service records were located, remember? Dan Rather found them, with the ink still drying. His drill time has been picked over ad nauseum. Nothing preferential found. Deal with it. Your profound desire for it to be so doesn't make it so.
As for taking 18 months... Do you recall when the Iraqi forces were being initially built up? There were desertions, stolen equipment, and numerous incidences where they turned tail and ran when the heat was on. There were incidences of misplaced loyalties. Many were indeed unfit for modern military service. How is this the fault of DOD?
Of course an armchair General such as yourself would have created the perfect plan and executed it with flawless precision and the Iraqi defense forces would have followed you without reservation, becoming super soldiers overnight. The insurgents would have bunkered down in easily identified fortified positions where they could be dispatched with ease and aplomb.
Please reread the article. Training was made a "top priority". This doesn't mean it was not a priority previously. More emphasis probably was placed at some point, possibly after pacifying the Sunni triangle, if one applies a minimal amount of reasoning. Obviously your bias prohibits you from accurately reading written words and reaching a cogent interpretation. Your filter is so thick that no opposing reality can permeate it.
Your criticism is symptomatic of myopia. Self-inflicted. You have an opinion and bash reality to fit it. I won't continue to waste my time, what you're reading is probably nothing resembling what I've typed anyway....
.
It simply can't be done. The guy is scrambled. And I've debated the guy into more corners than I can count. He's in his own little la-la land. Trying to reason with him is no more than an effort in futility. Try bricks. They're easier to reason with.
You want to kick 'em in the nuts, because you don't like them fine, because they don't like you, fine. Don't try and justify it with this sort of thing though.
The UK has supported terrorists, so has the US, course we called them freedom fighters, so we could stay on the side of the righteous.
You can't beat terrorism by going around sticking guns in peoples faces, you've got to take away the reason for the conflict. Difficult to impossible I know, but much more likely to succeed than invading the rest of the planet.
by tonythetiger
The reason is ignorance always has been always will be.
What side, one wants me to kneel to poverty igorance and Allah, the other to penury, ignorance and God. F***'em both.
I've been poor, the choice of God, Allah or the Jungle god Umbumweh doesn't impingeon my conscience, but no way an I doing homage to some twat benefitting from keeping me ignorant.
by jck
[i]"As for Dubya's service in the TANG, think about it this way. The president is the CEO of the company. Joe trooper is the equivalent of working on the loading dock of the company. Does having worked in the loading dock of the company qualify one as the CEO, moreso than someone with a background elswhere in the company? Further, Does the CEO need to know the number of boxes that can be shrinkwrapped on a single pallet? no non sequitur. Your logic doesn't follow. The Presidency is a "big picture" position."[/i]
Yes, that is very true...and obvious.
However the President, like a CEO, is responsible for the policies, operation and success (or lack thereof) in setting and overseeing the operations of his organization.
Knowing that 18 months had past and Iraqis weren't being trained effectively isn't a "knowing how many" reasoning. That is a broad analysis that would have been easily noticed by DOD leadership, and would have been inquired of by an effective head of an organization.
So either he made bad decisions, or he did not get "full briefings" from his subordinate commanders. Either way, he is still fully responsible for the failings. He can't just take the good and the glory for it when it does happen.
[i]"you took issue with our troops being picked off. I pointed out (correctly) that the primary way our troops are attacked is via roadside IED, where bomb dogs are unhelpful."[/i]
*ALL* IEDs account for 28.7 percent of attacks which lead to deaths of coalition deaths.
Note: Not *roadside* IEDs alone.
The DoD calls bombs left in police stations and cafes and in neighborhoods an "IED", so it's impossible to tell which were roadside and which were not.
IEDs have not been brokendown by the DoD into "roadside" and "other", so I can't give you specific statistics on what is what without going back and counting all 4 years of deaths up and reading every DoD death report release.
[i]"No, 1+1 doesn't =5. too bad (for you) I wasn't trying to make it so. You are drawing a false connection and I'm calling you on it. Too bad you are so tied up with Bush's proximity to his family. You might be considered as rational otherwise. BTW, I'm not sure his Dad was in Texas, as he was in the CIA and presumably in DC at the time."[/i]
I said family...not just his dad. "mommy and daddy" is a term indicative of being near your home.
And besides, are you implying that George Herbert Walker Bush wasn't allowed to go home while working for the CIA? haha
[i]"As for taking 18 months... Do you recall when the Iraqi forces were being initially built up? There were desertions, stolen equipment, and numerous incidences where they turned tail and ran when the heat was on. There were incidences of misplaced loyalties. Many were indeed unfit for modern military service. How is this the fault of DOD?"[/i]
Well...you can't prevent cowardice. That's true.
Of course, shouldn't the DoD be smart enough to station troops to prevent theft of US military assets?.
As for it happening, still is according to the AP:
http://www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/news/breaking_news/13395684.htm
49 of 209 haven't returned. Wonder if they're not paying them enough.
[i]"Of course an armchair General such as yourself would have created the perfect plan and executed it with flawless precision and the Iraqi defense forces would have followed you without reservation, becoming super soldiers overnight. The insurgents would have bunkered down in easily identified fortified positions where they could be dispatched with ease and aplomb."[/i]
Your skepticism is flattering...and again daft.
I would have done one thing very different in the beginning: Secured the borders.
We do have hundreds desert-ready attack helicopters equipped with night vision and infrared that would have been more effective in keeping out the initial influx of insurgents (that were crossing the borders in the desert) than ground patrols. And, you can't tell me a bunch of men scrambling through the desert aren't easy to pick out on infrared at night.
As for you not addressing me anymore, that's fine. I could care less. Just means you're as intolerant of differing opinion as Maxwell or Dubya.
I'm just glad you didn't do like someone else and say that my speaking of Bush's service in the TANG (not on the level of Kerry's service in military action) was belittling the entirety of anyone who served in the National Guard.
But still, you don't see there are obvious incompetencies that have been let to continue. That is a very lackadaisical stance to take when tens-of-thousands military lives are at stake while the administration meanders through the process.
oh...and...btw...that Bush quote you wanted?
President Bush said in a televised address from the U.S. Army War College in Carlisle Barracks, Pa., May 24, 2004:
[i]"Given the recent increase in violence, we'll maintain our troop level at the current 138,000 as long as necessary. This has required extended duty for the 1st Armored Division and the 2nd Light Cavalry Regiment -- 20,000 men and women who were scheduled to leave Iraq in April. Our nation appreciates their hard work and sacrifice, and they can know that they will be heading home soon. General Abizaid and other commanders in Iraq are constantly assessing the level of troops they need to fulfill the mission. If they need more troops, I will send them. The mission of our forces in Iraq is demanding and dangerous. Our troops are showing exceptional skill and courage. I thank them for their sacrifices and their duty."[/i]
Well, that was all good and well as they started moving them back.
Of course, the DoD then within 90 days re-deployed part of those same men and women of the 1st Armored back to Iraq on July 11, 2004.
Guess he for got the "...for just a little while." on the end of "...will be heading home soon."?
Guess Bush gave General Abizaid back the 1st Armored even tho they'd just finished better than a year of deployment not 2 months before they were sent back.
As for the 2nd Light Armored, they got returned to the states and restructured.
Open, honest truth would be refreshing...not vague language and terms of condition which leaves interpretation open to those who wish to and can/do manipulate the situation.
*ADDED NOTE*:
I just communicated by email with a friend whose husband is in Iraq with the US Army. They were told, initially, that it would be a 12 month deployment. It's been 16 now for his group and have been told they *might* be coming home in 2 months but they've been told they might get a *3rd* extension.
This is just to prove that their "plan" is not meeting "scheduled deadlines".
Reminds me of working for a corporation...gotta work overtime for the boss when stuff has been poorly planned.
by jck
Of course, this is coming from someone who quoted an expert in astromonical/stellar research for a reference in climatology.
I also heard Max consulted Stevie Wonder on colour schemes for his new dayroom. :^O
by tonythetiger
"How many guys do you know got stationed during Vietnam on active manuevers stateside with the NG or Reserves within 100 miles of their home?"
I don't think that question was even well thought out. I'm pretty sure his home wasn't deliberately built to be within 100 miles of the base. there are millions of homes that aren't.
"It was not chance Dubya got put where he did."
As I was a little young for Vietnam I can't speak to that, but I can state that in 1976, I was allowed to choose where I took my training (as long as an opening existed) and I assume permanent station would be the same, within limits. So while you are correct that it wasn't chance, there is no valid negative connotation that can be logically drawn from that fact. Now if you could prove that there were no openings at the time of his request, that would have meant someone would have to be transferred to make room, and you might have something.
"Plus, it's kind of funny that many of his papers from the Texas Air National Guard are missing now and no one can find them even though they are considered government service records and no one has been held accountable for it."
It's funny that in August of 1976, the medical building at Fort Sill, Oklahoma burned down, just when I was getting ready to be transferred, but I didn't think it was a grand conspiracy designed to make me have to get all my shots retaken!
Oh, and don't confuse "not found" with
"missing". You obviously don't know the finer points of government document handling :)
by tonythetiger
by jck
I work for a government department. I know how we're required to keep documentation, what we have to keep filed with what agencies, what documents must be submitted to Washington, and what we can or can not throw out.
Basic rule of thumb for me: don't throw it out until the director says it can be.
I'm pretty sure your military medical records were kept in a complex in Virginia as well, assuming you were full-time US Army.
Having been at Fort Sill in Lawton, Oklahoma, I would assume you were U.S. Army.
As for Dubya's records, I just find it out of the ordinary that there were service records from other members of his unit found, but his (which were the ones in question) were nowhere to be "found".
Also, I didn't say his family home was purposefully built out there. But, he got stationed on active maneuvers there which is kind of ironic.
I'm gonna call a friend of the family who is retired National Guard and ask him about how units were deploy in the NG during Vietnam for active maneuvers. And if he can't answer my question, I'll call my mother's relatives in Texas and see if they know anyone retired from the Texas Air National Guard and can give me definitive answers on how they stationed people.
Needless to say...when something doesn't smell right, I don't take a bite.
by jdclyde
[i]"when something doesn't smell right, I don't take a bite."[/i]
Yet you have dug your molars deep into the Democratic party and every twisted, hateful, leaching thing they stand for?
Now go give Kerry the big wet kiss that you seem to think he deserves. ;\
(can't you just see the sarcasm dripping from this post?) :p
by jck
dripping from it than something else...
hahahahahaha :^O
"Damn stain..." - Monica Lewinsky
by jdclyde
I saw a billboard of her during the last election. It said "I am voting Republican this time. The Democrats left a bad taste in my mouth last time".
too friggen funny!
by jck
I saw one like that too on the net years ago...had Donna Rice on it...said:
"My heart is with Bush, but my bush is with Hart." :^O
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending