Senate Democrats will [i]?. . . . .never give in. . . . .
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by deepsand
by tig2
My opinion of Mr Hunter is personal and based on my reaction to meeting the man and what he espoused.
At the end of that meeting, I was willing to paste the word "HOOVER" to his sides and fly him locally.
Yes, I can be a real b*tch sometimes.
But always well dressed!
by deepsand
by deepsand
by w2ktechman
by w2ktechman
He rejected the UN and all of the Mid-East countries when they told him that invading Iraq would cause destabilization of the entire region.
But he decided that having access to oil fields were more important than a unstable region.
by tig2
I think we had a Daddy vs Idiot... I mean GWB moment.
If he didn't know information widely known over 10 years earlier, GWB is rightly a MORON!!!
Just a minor point.
Does this reasoned observation mean that Max hates me now too? I shudder to think.
Incidentally, I don't think that this had much to do with oil. I think that it has everything to do with power. Just a thought.
by w2ktechman
it had to do with greed and power.
He set his eyes on Iraq after being turned down to drill for oil in national wildlife reserves. He was also turned down on his proposals to drill for oil in Alaska wildlife refuges'. Almost immediately after these were shot down, Iraq started making headlines. He kept stating that it was not about the oil, but I feel that it actually was mostly about the oil.
Although you are probably right on the power motive as well. And probably he was ignorant and stupid as well. He may have thought that everyone would 'dance in the streets' when our soldiers went by.
Lots of reasons, but I still choose to believe that oil was the main motivator.
by deepsand
by w2ktechman
I still think it was more about the oil.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=223906&messageID=2244542
But, yes it was probably partially due to pride from the first war as well. He seemed to want Iraq over everything else. Personally, I think that Syria would have made a better choice.
by tig2
Smarmy, back-stabbing SOB is really close.
I don't care for Mr. Hunter, much.
by jck
by w2ktechman
those last (actually 1 word) were nasty and sent chills up my spine. I was expecting a much different ending. Maybe one that involved a prison camp overseas perhaps!
But then again, I think he would need some friends as well. Dick perhaps!!
by absolutely
by deepsand
whatever means necessary, to be an inherent one, and therefore superior to the Laws of any Sovereign.
In this regards, therefore, they would not hold such overthrow, or the attempt at such, to be terrorism.
by deepsand
The juxtaposition of the FBI statement & that of myself, from the discussion re. the 2nd Amendment, is well within the scope of the subject at hand.
It serves to illustrate that those in power will seek to revise the understandings of the governed so as to best ensure the survival of those who govern.
by deepsand
by w2ktechman
attacking Mexico without causing a civil disorder across the board. Venezuela is also another which would have been harder to justify invasion, and he would have had NO allies at all.
But, since I do not know how to read his mind, I am just stating my opinion in the matter. I bet if I could read his mind though, I would probably die laughing, and not be able to repeat any of it to anyone!
:)
by deepsand
I'm sure that, between he & Dick, they'd have come up something semi-plausible at the time, particularly given the documented relationships between Venezuela, Iran & known terrorist cells.
Mexico wouldn't have required more than offering them Statehood.
As for reading GWB's mind, that could turn out to be a really, really bad trip.
by deepsand
having scheduled the trial 1st?
It behooves us to not lightly employ that which we despise in others against them. Sometimes that means saying we're sorry; in this case, to the widow Laura.
by deepsand
Yes, the allusion to Saddam's execution was intended. And, my use of the word "pardon" was double-edged, though, in hindsight, not so as to be sufficiently evidenced. See
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=223906&messageID=2245079
by f4a6pilot
by deepsand
by f4a6pilot
The point is the Democrats have been obstructionists and not very truthful. After cooperating in joint conferences with the White house on "No Child left behind" and other legislation have been absolutely vilifying Bush. Look at the post from Max regarding 1998 when Clinton described Hussein's WMDs. Look at the leading Dems support regime change. Understand they are betting on the short memory, and the ignorance (lack of being informed) of the general population.
The new tone Bush tried to establish never got the Democrat party to be less than hateful and many democrats never understood that Al Gore lost according to the existing rules and laws.
Unlike Clinton, (Who never got as many votes as Gore, or Bush either time) Bush had to deal with a much more difficult Congress. Clinton made deals and backed out of them... That made Republican leaders distrustful of the President. Since Clinton even alienated his own party with his political machinations he poisoned the waters for Bush. When you add the contested election cycle, it was a herculean task to foster civility. He failed.
Since the election was so hotly contested in 2000, post Nov 11, There was tons of bad blood. Most of it on the side of the losers. Jumpin' Jim Jeffries made it worse. The partisans in the Democrat party are endangering our country for political expediency.
Let no individual be uniformed. Politicians want to be elected, or re-elected. Sitting 2nd term presidents may be the exceptions as they have nowhere to go.
by f4a6pilot
Is in the media. It is also the only place the US lost in Vietnam...
The casualties in Vietnam were 40+ to one... We are slightly better than that in Iraq. (less druggies in an all volunteer force?)
We are winning. We only need the will to persevere.
I went to the Marine Museum in Quantico.
Marines were 60/1 in combat casualties. If we hadn't lost in the media we may have depopulated China. as in the last three years the ratio was 68/1 USMC... If we have the will, and we remove the Harry Reids and Nancy Pelosis of the world we will not have suffered loss.
We are winning... It will just take time. 10-15 years in my opinion until the Iraqi people accept and understand freedom.
by f4a6pilot
See my post...
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=223906&messageID=2245701
We won in Vietnam, but it was expensive...
by deepsand
by f4a6pilot
by deepsand
by av .
We failed. Lets leave. http://abcnews.go.com/International/story?id=3067607
What kind of message is this? I was very disappointed that Harry Reid would take this stance. He doesn't know that the surge won't work. He never gave it a chance. Why not give it a chance until General Petraous issues his report in September? Didn't the Democrats say that they want to work with Bush?
Bush has changed course lately. We have had talks with Iran that are somewhat positive. The war doesn't have to be lost as Harry Reid said. What bothers me the most is that I think he is grandstanding for political gain. Why can't both sides work together?
Everyone is tired of the war, but we can't walk away without giving the surge a chance. If it doesn't work, we can consider other options in a bipartisan way. Our country is at war and the outcome shouldn't be overshadowed by grandstanding for the 2008 elections.
You know Max that I'm not a Bush fan, but I'm most afraid of what the Democrats will do on this very sensitive issue.
AV
by f4a6pilot
The made great gains in the 60's and 70's by doing the same with Vietnam. They are trying to rerun the 1970s playbook. So if a Democrat is elected President expect price controls inflation and stagflation all over again.
They are trying to put Carter in front of us again aren't they...
by deepsand
the work of Nixon! (See below essay.)
As an Independent, I must take issue with your charterization of the Democratic party, both with respect to Vietnam & Iraq.
In neither is it the case that "sabotage" was or is their intent; rather, it is to publicly and unequivocably voice the realization that we were, both then and now, lead into armed conflict under false pretenses and with unrealistic expectations. In short, the Democrats seek to openly proclaim that we were deceived, that we know we were deceived, that both the strategy and tactics chosen have not worked and will not work, and therefore that change is in order.
I can well recall an evening spent, in late 1969, with a professor of the Army War College, in which he outlined & described the various stages of disconnect between the political perception and the reality of the Vietnam war; were that conversation to be taking place today, he would need change nothing but "Vietnam" to "Iraq."
by nicknielsen
I don't think the President is losing sleep over it. The only effort being put into this at all is by the military. And the President doesn't recognize the military successes as such because they don't match his definition of success.
This opinion hit the nail on the head: http://tinyurl.com/323agg
Of course, Americans tend to support and elect Presidents that reflect themselves...
by delbertpgh
You still haven't figured out the problem of Viet Nam, which was that we could keep on winning, year after year, getting no closer to victory, until we got tired of it. Because, what it took to actually finish the war, was something that we couldn't secure by our own efforts: a stand-up government of South Viet Nam, and a nation that believed in it.
That, and the fact that it doesn't matter how much you "win"; you never win the whole thing until your opponent quits and makes you a victor.
The galling thing is that the big dumb bunch of would-be heros running this war have gotten us into exactly the same situation in Iraq. It doesn't matter what the kill ratio is, or how many years it goes on; if it doesn't dull the enemy's will, it isn't conclusive. Our main goal, the establishment of an Iraqi government we can count on, is at the mercy of Iraqi politicians who use the police to assassinate their enemies and their position to rob us blind, and they don't seem to care that their indifference brings them nearer to disaster.
I have no idea where you get your idea that 10 or 15 years of us hanging around, straw-bossing the country and making enemies, will make the Iraqi people "accept and understand freedom." Sounds like a pipe dream to me.
If we can pull a victory out of this mess, it will take a whole different type of war than what we've got going now.
by deepsand
We [u]won[/u] in Vietnam?
And, how is it our right to insist that [u]any[/u] people "accept and understand freedom?" Per Jefferson, it is the right of a people to chose their own form of government, and to change their mind at any time.
by sn53
deep wrote, "And, how is it our right to insist that any people "accept and understand freedom?"
It is in our interest. That is sufficient. It is also in their interest. That is also sufficient.
"Per Jefferson, it is the right of a people to chose their own form of government, and to change their mind at any time."
The Iraqis have chosen their government. Nearly all of the provinces are as peaceful as any of our large cities. There are a few large trouble spots, Anbar, Basra, Baghdad, Mosul. Anbar is moving our way. Mosul is mixed. Basra and Baghdad have a ways to go.
We are winning, except in the most important province of them all, the USA.
by deepsand
"[i]It is also in their interest. That is also sufficient.[/i]
That is [b]not[/b] ours to decide.
And, the former is sheer hubris.
by delbertpgh
that accepting and understanding freedom demands a cultural background that may take a lot longer than ten years to acquire? Europe, for example, took about 900 years to work its way through feudalism, then 500 more to assemble a few strong states built on royal families, and 300 more getting religion under control and adjusting to modern ideas and economies, before democracy started springing up all over. Where's Iraq on this timeline?
If what it takes for the Iraqis is a couple hundred more years, then our presence there is wasted. Not to mention the setback we have delivered to the Iraqis. Of course, we can't be blamed for all their problems; we just kicked the stool out from under them. If we had gone in with enough troops to keep them pacified, and had quickly set up a dictator and then got out, maybe they could have avoided the breakdown. Maybe not.
What dream book are you reading that makes you think Iraqis can do anything with the government they've chosen, or that they chose wisely? (Keep in mind that the Sunnis abstained during the election, and the Shiites and Kurds voted narrowly in their own interests, and that there were no national parties that crossed sectarian lines.) Or that important parts of Iraq are peaceful? Or that if we take our troops away, they would stay peaceful? Basra, the second most important city in the country, was a garden spot under British occupation for three years, and now it is turning sour on us. Progress?
by f4a6pilot
Sometimes Passion can over rule reason It is not that I am less passionate than SN53, but I merely want the enemy killed over there and never let them get near here...
I have a son, who has been there and done that... I went over in a tech support role. I can say that some places in Iraq are safer than Detroit. (I will not go unarmed in many places in Detroit or NY) I have seen safer war zones recently.
As an American, I find the Old World full of old hates. As a U.S.A. citizen I find that the only way to prevent the escallation of their conflict to keep it concentrated and contained. I prefer not to kill, as a Christian, but they want to kill us. If our soldiers are there they are easier targets, but if the easy target isn't there, they will come here. They have done it already several times. I want it to be stopped.
They want to kill us, (they also want to destroy Israel, they want to do the things that really are evil beyond the capability of most people to imagine.) I have seen their evil, and understand I don't want it here with my own family, friends, and loved ones... I also want the violence kept From Max, Absolutely, Delbert, and Sandy's family also.
by f4a6pilot
The casualties lost were high,but the USSR started down a slide they could not recover from by supplying the NVA and the Chinese supplied many personnel. When Reagan started Star Wars, The USSR couldn't paly in the game, and the USSR fell...
The reason we won is that one of our greatest enemies (at the time) never recovered. We also won on the battlefields.
To those of you who haven't understood why John Kerry is a "Hero of the revolution" in Hanoi didn't realize that the NVA were beaten. The Chinese were routed, The Russians evacuating, and here comes the left wing media to distort the truth... The TET offensive was a failure for the NVA and Viet Cong. they lost more people in that one battle in a weekend than the US and French did in the entire conflict.
Our political will was weak. We should have dealt with the USSR in 1945, like Patton wanted to do. We always seem to start too late and leave to soon...
I would be remiss to mention that the problem is our will, not our might. Please read Patton's speech and then reconsider what we should do to end Islamo-fascism...
by delbertpgh
The USSR didn't suffer from supplying the North Vietnamese with materiel, and thereby begin the slide to bankruptcy that ended under Reagan. The Chinese didn't supply many personnel at all. Vietnamese don't particularly like Chinese, by the way.
I'd be amazed to find one official placard now or at any time in the past proclaiming John Kerry a hero.
The NVA never realized they were beaten. Sure, Tet was a disaster, but for the Viet Cong, not for the NVA. And Tet sure didn't rout the Chinese (who I think may have manned some supply lines in the North and some anti-aircraft facilities that they supplied) or force the Russian advisors to evacuate, not that there were ever many of either Russians or Chinese in Viet Nam.
Last, the idea that our political will was weak with respect to the Soviets, and that we should have dealt with them in 1945... our will to confront them, and to station half a million soldiers in exposed forward positions in Europe, stayed constant through Democrat and Republican administrations for 40 years. As far as the idea that we should have attacked them in 1945, remember that we won the cold war, without a hot war. We held some advantages in Western Europe, but none in Russia, at the close of World War II. (Remember Napoleon? Remember Hitler? They both took on Russia.) We won without any millions dead for the sake of our victory, and that's a more noble accomplishment than a glorious slaughter. Beats hell out of slaughter on a cost-benefit basis, too.
by f4a6pilot
Been there, and I have seen it.
I can tell you that we lost the heart and will to fight because many saw no threat to our populace. The US has isolationism deeply ingrained in our national psyche.
That is the real problem with most of our population in the US. 70% of the US population never, or very rarely goes over 500 miles from home.
They cannot conceive of people traveling across the world to try to kill them and their loved ones because they don't go farther than the corner store, and never bothered "those people". We all love the thousands of miles of ocean that shielded us for hundreds of years. Too bad airplanes were invented that can leap these oceans in mere hours...
The concept that they won't attack us is a throwback to the isolationists who didn't want to be involved in "European adventures and intrigues" to quote George Washington, I believe. The problem is not particularly European, but since 1960 French in particular. The French sell to our enemies and they try to stick it to the US at every turn. Then when they have troubles, to whom do they scream for help?
The French are for the French, and are not our allies. They may not be enemies, but they are competitors at the least.
by deepsand
He seems to believe that all the peoples of the world are dying to be just like us; and, if not, it's our right & duty to show them the error of their ways.
He'd have been right at home as the Governor of a Colonial Territory, or a Missionary in one.
He fails to understand that his own zealotry is no different than that of those he seeks to conquer.
by delbertpgh
... brutality was Saddam's game, and if there's one thing we still like to believe about ourselves, it's that "things now are better than under Saddam". A big part of our self-image and our historical image as seen by the international community is that we try to be humane and just, in the big picture, at least.
I grant you, if we had sprayed Fallujah with some of our stocks of VX gas and put down civilians by the thousand, like Saddam did in another town, we might have gotten a lot more compliance a lot quicker. Like you say, the Iraqis respect murderous, excessive brutality coupled with an iron will. And not much else, apparently.
Of course, since we went over there with the aim of building a democratic capitalist state, a little model of Kansas City between the Tigris and Euphrates, perhaps we were mistaken in our plans. Mistaken because daily mass murder does not fit our idea of public administration. Hilariously, metaphysically, insanely, tragically mistaken.
by deepsand
"ruthless and brutal." What he really meant was that, in regards to a certain specific situation, our response should be of a particular nature, which is neither ruthless (although some may argue otherwise) nor brutal, so as demonstrate our strength of will and firm resolve.
As it is not in my place to speak for him re. the particulars, I'll leave it to him to state them here if he so desires. But, should he not do so, do accept the verity of what I've said re. his intent.
by deepsand
It is part of the human condition that we are each engaged in our own daily struggles between our rational & irrational selves. Suc are not merely inherent to, but necessary for our existence as sentient beings. By way of analogy, our irrational self provides the wind for our sails; our rational self, the hand on the tiller.
By virtue of both its age and nature, it is our irrational self that is the stronger & the quicker of the two. The hand on the tiller must be ever vigilant for sudden & forceful changes in the winds.
It is only by use of reason to harness and direct our passions that we prevail in reaching our intended & safe harbor.
by sn53
sn53 wrote, ""It is also in their interest. That is also sufficient."
deep responded, "That is not ours to decide."
They have decided. The current government is popularly elected.
by deepsand
"[i]It is in our interest. That is sufficient.[/i]
You've deliberately ignored the fact that that is insufficient.
"[i]It is also in their interest. That is also sufficient[/i]"
Again, you've deliberately ignored the fact that that is [u]your[/u] opinion, based our your perception of [u]our[/u] interests.
"[i]They have decided.[/i]
We gave them no choice; hence, they have not [u]freely[/u] decided.
"[i]The current government is popularly elected.[/i]"
Not by a majority of the population, and not for a government of their own making.
by sn53
delbert wrote, "Has it not occurred to you
that accepting and understanding freedom demands a cultural background that may take a lot longer than ten years to acquire?"
Simply amazing. How long did it take you? The natural condition of humans is to long to be free and in control of our destiny.
Iraqis are no different than us in that regard. They voted for democracy and for freedom. We are supporting them against brigands, terrorists and Iranians.
You are so condescending.
by deepsand
best for others, what is within their grasp and what is not, what is within their character and what is not, what they desire and what they would eschew.
It is you who are condescending.
by sn53
F4A6 wrote, "They want to kill us, (they also want to destroy Israel, they want to do the things that really are evil beyond the capability of most people to imagine.) I have seen their evil, and understand I don't want it here with my own family, friends, and loved ones... I also want the violence kept From Max, Absolutely, Delbert, and Sandy's family also."
That is because you are a former sheep dog. And some of them are sheep. You know the wolves are there. You know the wolves want to kill the sheep. The sheep deny the existence of the wolves. It makes them feel better. The feel superior to the sheep dogs. But without the sheep dogs to protect them the sheep will always fall before the wolves.
It is the nature of our existence that most people are sheep. And a few are sheep dogs. You were once a sheep dog.
by deepsand
1) F4A6 is [b]not[/b] advocating that passion should run roughshod over reason; and,
2) To say that "[i]The sheep deny the existence of the wolves. It makes them feel better. The(y) feel superior to the sheep dogs.[/i] is to presume that [u]you[/u] are in fact superior to all those with whom you have no common military experience. As one who has also worn the uniform, I find such audacity both offensive & embarrassing.
by mjwx
that is not the goal of any guerrilla force, the point of Tet was merely to pull the underwear over the heads of the Americans. A guerrilla force works by making a war too difficult for an enemy to fight not by taking and holding territory.
The NVA or Vietcong leadership never expected any captured territory to remain theirs for a week let alone for an important target like Hue to remain in Vietcong hands for 26 days.
Guerrilla armies, especially in the case of the Vietcong were always meant to be a numerous disposable (poorly trained) force, for this to be an effective force they must keep recruitment high to replace casualties. In order to gain recruitment they had to make high profile strikes the Tet offensive is the best example of this. The Tet offensive was merely the VC leadership saying "look at what we can do to the Americans, join up now" to the Vietnamese people whilst causing as much mayhem as possible.
I also think that attacking the USSR in 1945 would have resulted in slaughter of both sides. The US had better production capacity and more aircraft as well as a large bomber force. The USSR had a good production capacity although not as high as the allies, larger armies, a large conscription base, better tanks (the T34\76 could take out a tiger and a tiger could take out 4 Sherman's.) and almost comparative aircraft (with the exception of jet aircraft).
If the USSR was to be taken out with a minimum of fuss, it should have been done in the 1930's, after the death of Lenin, during the power struggles for leadership of the party or after the purges of officers from the red army. In 1945 the USSR was strong, in 1930 the USSR was weak.
What's the matter Delbert, Cat got your tongue?
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=223906&messageID=2243619
by absolutely
[i]Islamic hardcases were getting traction all across the Middle East, and it started long before Carter, and had nothing to do with America. We were just hated, because we were the most powerful thing around, and [b]because we were pulling the strings when we could[/b].[/i]
Wielding power as if one has more of it than one truly has tends to undermine that power.
by absolutely
by sn53
abso wrote, "Wielding power as if one has more of it than one truly has tends to undermine that power."
Good point. Preemptive surrender has the same effect. I have come to recognize that one political party tends to surrender early and often.
by absolutely
[i]Good point. Preemptive surrender has the same effect. I have come to recognize that one political party tends to surrender early and often.[/i]
I recognize the same tendency in the same party. Another tends to attack early and often. Neither bias is supported by facts.
by deepsand
Politicians are not unlike the parents who alternately coddle them & act the stern task masters, all in an effort to gain both their good comportment & approval. With politics, the matter is only slightly different in that the two major parties are like two parents who alternately coddle the children so as to gain their favor for the next election(s). When the children find out that what they got isn't to their liking the other party wins their hearts, and the cycle is repeated.
It's not unlike the horror of watching an execution; while many are aghast, their bloodlust forces them to watch, even if but from the corner of their eyes.
While the subject of the below song - that of hero worship turning to distain and back again, as evidenced by the death of JFK & subsequent events - is not related to the issue at hand, the lyrics do serve to well illustrate the intricate dance of emotions that continue to play out on the world stage, as the People change from Doves to Hawks and back again, in a never ending cycle of violence.
=============================================
"Crucifixion" - Phil Ochs
And the night comes again to the circle studded sky
The stars settle slowly, in lonliness they lie
'Till the universe expodes as a falling star is raised
Planets are paralyzed, mountains are amazed
But they all glow brighter from the briliance of the blaze
With the speed of insanity, then he dies.
In the green fields a turnin', a baby is born
His cries crease the wind and mingle with the morn
An assault upon the order, the changing of the guard
Chosen for a challenge that is hopelessly hard
And the only single sound is the sighing of the stars
But to the silence and distance they are sworn
So dance dance dance
Teach us to be true
Come dance dance dance
'Cause we love you
Images of innocence charge him go on
But the decadence of destiny is looking for a pawn
To a nightmare of knowledge he opens up the gate
And a blinding revelation is laid upon his plate
That beneath the greatest love is a hurricane of hate
And God help the critic of the dawn.
So he stands on the sea and shouts to the shore,
But the louder that he screams the longer he's ignored
For the wine of oblivion is drunk to the dregs
And the merchants of the masses almost have to be begged
'Till the giant is aware, someone's pulling at his leg,
And someone is tapping at the door.
So dance dance dance
Teach us to be true
Come dance dance dance
'Cause we love you
Then his message gathers meaning and it spreads accross the land
The rewarding of his pain is the following of the man
But ignorance is everywhere and people have their way
Success is an enemy to the losers of the day
In the shadows of the churches, who knows what they pray
For blood is the language of the band.
The Spanish bulls are beaten; the crowd is soon beguiled,
The matador is beautiful, a symphony of style
Excitement is estatic, passion places bets
Gracefully he bows to ovations that he gets
But the hands that are applauding are slippery with sweat
And saliva is falling from their smiles
So dance dance dance
Teach us to be true
Come dance dance dance
'Cause we love you
Then this overflow of life is crushed into a liar
The gentle soul is ripped apart and tossed into the fire.
First a smile of rejection at the nearness of the night
Truth becomes a tragedy limping from the light
All the heavens are horrified, they stagger from the sight
As the cross is trembling with desire.
They say they can't believe it, it's a sacreligious shame
Now, who would want to hurt such a hero of the game?
But you know I predicted it; I knew he had to fall
How did it happen? I hope his suffering was small.
Tell me every detail, for I've got to know it all,
And do you have a picture of the pain?
So dance dance dance
Teach us to be true
Come dance dance dance
'Cause we love you
Time takes her toll and the memory fades
but his glory is broken, in the magic that he made.
Reality is ruined; it's the freeing from the fear
The drama is distorted, to what they want to hear
Swimming in their sorrow, in the twisting of a tear
As they wait for the new thrill parade.
Yes, the eyes of the rebel have been branded by the blind
To the safety of sterility, the threat has been refined
The child was created to the slaughterhouse he's led
So good to be alive when the eulogy is read
The climax of emotion, the worship of the dead
And the cycle of sacrifice unwinds.
So dance dance dance
Teach us to be true
Come dance dance dance
'Cause we love you
And the night comes again to the circle studded sky
The stars settle slowly, in lonliness they lie
'Till the universe expodes as a falling star is raised
Planets are paralyzed, mountains are amazed
But they all glow brighter from the briliance of the blaze
With the speed of insanity, then he died.
by delbertpgh
I'm sure they found it appealing that a decorated veteran would have then turned around and criticized the American policy in Viet Nam. They probably felt it proved something.
You're willfully misleading yourself.
by delbertpgh
A number of Khomeini's top people were definitely surprised by the energy of the Islamic fanatics, and their ability to steer the revolution. Sadegh Gotzbzadeh and Abolhassan Bani-Sadr, for two. Both were technocratic young men who worked against the Shah's regime, and got a lot of press coverage in the U.S. Both were Khomeini's loyal aides during his Paris exile. Bani Sadr, elected president of Iran, got on the wrong side of Khomeini, had his powers of office revoked by decree, and went into hiding while police searched to arrest him on capital charges. He eventually turned up again in Paris, a refugee from the new Iranian government. Ghotbzadeh was foreign minister; he didn't move as fast as Bani Sadr, was seized on what were probably trumped up charges relating to Iran-Contra, and was tried and killed by Komeini's courts.
I think it's pretty fair to say that both of these guys were surpised by how things turned out. Both seemed to want a modern and more just country, and figured that religious revival was the way to beat down the Shah's forces. Both got eaten by the tiger.
Maybe you thought I was saying something else, like Khomeini didn't know what his own plans were, or something. On the contrary, I believe that Khomeini regarded democracy as a means of overthrowing the Shah and instituting a religious dictatorship. Many of Khomeini's early followers were secular and democratic people, who figured that after the religious yahoos had their party and fell into doctrinal disputes, the people would get bored and go looking for someone who really knew how to govern a modern country. Woe to them.
I looked up a little on Alireza Jafarzadeh, and while I don't intend to buy his book and read it just so I can reply to you, I don't doubt that he has a lot of personal perspective on what happened. However, not he nor anybody else can say with authority what is happening in Iran today... the place has got too many power centers and too little transparency for anyone to clearly see the political forces behind the outcomes. It did seem pretty clear that during the election, Khamenei was pushing Ahmadinejad, but it's not clear to me now that Ahmadinejad is a mere sock puppet for Khamenei. Ahmadinejad knows how to pull the democratic levers, and how to build his own power base.
I believe that there is a strong body of Iranian opinion that says the West is okay, that modern life is okay, that an alliance with the U.S. (like in the days of the Shah) would be okay, and eventually that opinion will lead the country. The best way to destroy that good will is to make war against Iran. I also believe that there's no way a war against Iran could serve any American interest, that all it could do would be to suck us down in a tar pit where we could fight forever and never get victory.
by deepsand
and if he actually reads him, he'd know that Iran was quite taken aback by the events of 9/11, that a small group of upstart Sunni were able to so well upstage Shia Iran, and threaten their up to then unchallenged position as the dominant force for change in the Muslim world. Is is informative to recall that, at that time, Iran was most forceful in its condemnation of such attacks.
He'd also know that much of what has occurred in Iraq and the rest of the Middle East and Southeast Asia is the result of the efforts of Iran to regain its prominence, as best witnessed by Hezzbollah's (Shia) most recent attacks on Israel, and the subsequent deployment of 4 or 5 Salefite (Sunni) groups to Jordan to serve as counter-balance.
In short, 9/11 served to open centuries' old wounds in the long struggles between the Sunni & Shia, and our invasion of Iraq served to provide the perfect battleground for them to be resumed using the tools of modern warfare.
Had 9/11 not occured, Iran would not now be so belligerent.
by delbertpgh
Kerry visited North Vietnam as part of a delegation sent by Bill Clinton, the President at the time. The picture memorializes the normalization of relations.
Some bunch of swift boat liars put out the story during the 2004 election that this picture was present as a celebration of Kerry's contribution to the North Vietnamese victory. Frequently the date of the visit is moved up to 1983, probably owing to a mistyped date while copying the post from blog to blog.
Stories about it were usually accompanied by supposed quotes from General Giap in his 1985 memoirs about Hanoi being ready to surrender, but the Vietnam Veterans Against the War gave them enough hope to carry on. That, too, is a fabrication; there is no such quote, and Giap didn't even publish memoirs in 1985.
You've been duped, Pilot.
by sn53
delbert wrote, "There is a nearly endless supply of terrorists... every young Muslim man in the world is a potential recruit."
I don't think so. There are a billion Muslims. There are a few thousand terrorists. They are not ten feet tall. They are not smarter, more handsome or richer than we. But they have one significant advantage or the American forces who fight against them. The have the Democrat party leadership on their side.
"Our war in Iraq is an imperialistic adventure"
In what way? Has America ever desired an empire? If so why did we turn Germany back over to the Germans? Why did we turn over Japan to the Japanese? Why didn't we keep France after paying so high a price to liberate the French?
"...that motivates men around the world to fight us."
Abso nailed it in another forum where he described it as a mental disease. After due consideration I have to agree with him. Islamofascism is this generation's evil. The Islamo-terrorists who fight are mentally ill.
"They think they're going to fight the dark empire,"
As do Democrats...
"...save the Arabs, save Islam, make themselves a perfect sacrifice for God,"
Mental illness nicely accounts for the few thousands from a population of a billion.
"Defeating and occupying an Arab Muslim country..."
We defeated a dictator. The Iraqis are in charge of their own country. We are not occupying it. We are helping the Iraqi people become self-governing.
"...does not make us safer from terrorism."
On the contrary. It does. They are pinned down. By using the sword in Iraq and Afghanistan while using the shield in the US we have succeeded in preventing Al Qaeda from striking us again within the US.
"It makes more terrorists, and erodes our prestige, and makes us more vulnerable in the long run."
What makes more terrorists is the silly talk of defeat that traitors like Harry Reid spout. Put him in prison, try him for treason, and when convicted, execute him for the traitor he is. This will help both our prestige and stem the creation of new terrorists. Defeating the Islamofascists and their fellow-travelers, the Democrat party leadership, will enhance our security until the next bad actors step onto the world stage.
by deepsand
mentally ill, as are those who advocate executing those who exercise their Civil Right to dissent.
"[i]We defeated a dictator. The Iraqis are in charge of their own country. We are not occupying it. We are helping the Iraqi people become self-governing. [/i]"
So far, although we have killed some, we've [b]defeated no one[/b] in Iraq, the Iraqis are [b]not[/b] in charge of their country, we [b]are[/b] still occupying it, and, we've [b]still to see[/b] whether or not it is yet in the character of the Iraqi peoples to be self-governing.
Time to take off you rose-colored glasses, and see the real world.
by f4a6pilot
by f4a6pilot
The resolve is not displayed in a manner they would recognize. I do know the people and the area and I suggest a different strategy from being one of the boots on the ground.
I won't detail it here, but I do know that the Democrats are screaming about my opinions according to Ralph Regula (R) on the armed service committee.
1. First we get rid of all non combat correspondents. No Hotel room reports.
2.If a report comes from the country it comes from sources embedded with the troops and is cleared from the combat commanders.
3. No REMFs making decisions. If they aren't taking fire they don't make the decisions... That peeves off pentagon brass but is a better solution than letting deep water sailors plan assaults or submarine commanders planning aerial assaults...
This simple plan puts staff where they belong and places the guns in the shooters hands...
by sn53
deep wrote, "we've defeated no one in Iraq, the Iraqis are not in charge of their country, we are still occupying it, and, we've still to see whether or not it is yet in the character of the Iraqi peoples to be self-governing."
This is just wrong.
by delbertpgh
Some Swift Boat guy (Bill Lupetti) photographed the photo, and the legend below it, which is thus:
Below the photograph of John Kerry are explanatory placards in English, French, Vietnamese, and Chinese. The English placard reads: "Mr. Do Muoi, Secretary General of the Vietnamese Communist Party met with Congressman and Veterans Delegation in Vietnam (July 15-18, 1993)"
The photo wasn't hung there to honor Kerry, and the Vietnamese officials were not there to honor Kerry. Kerry travelled to Viet Nam with a group of veterans and politicians to arrange searches for bodies of missing American soldiers. The Vietnamese regarded it as an important step toward normalizing relations.
This broke in World Net Daily, and got republished in many other right-wing news sources and blogs. Errors and elaborations creep in: he is supposedly shown receiving a medal, though he is clearly not; he is being honored as a hero of the revolution, though no such legend is under the picture; he made the trip in 1983 instead of 1993, and is reported as "Lieutenant Governor Kerry receiving honors" (he was a Senator since 1984); he is reported as being present not in a photograph, but in a life-size statue, and hero of the revolution, to boot. The tale has been growing in dimensions ever since 2004, when it was brought up for the election, and got a lot more hoopla around Memorial Day this year.
This stuff is a bunch of silly lies, so silly that it's embarassing that many people are so ready to believe them.
See the photo:
http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=38738
The photo is said to hang in a section of the museum honoring war protestors.
http://johnkerry-08.com/war/hero.php
Here's a sarcastic, republican-hating analysis of the half-truths that have gone into trying to make a big story out of the photo (from Sept 2004):
http://www.unspun.us/2004/09/hanoi_war_crimes_museum_honors.htm
by deepsand
Nixon Tries Price Controls
Excerpt from The Commanding Heights by Daniel Yergin and Joseph Stanislaw, 1997 ed., pp. 60-64.
Essay
[Following the Kennedy-Johnson administration in the United States, there was a massive effort to manage the marketplace, in part by controlling wages.] This initiative was not the handiwork of left-wing liberals but of the administration of Richard Nixon, a moderately conservative Republican who was a critic of government intervention in the economy. As a young man during World War II, prior to joining the navy, Nixon had worked as a junior attorney in the tire-rationing division of the Office of Price Administration, an experience that left him with a lasting distaste for price controls.
What, then, were the forces that led Nixon to try to impose government management on the most basic elements of the market? Certainly, economic matters were hardly his passion. That was reserved for foreign policy. Even foreign economic policy did not much interest him. There was a memorable time during some moment of international monetary perturbation when he rudely suggested exactly what should be done with the lira. As for domestic economics, he liked to give his radio talks on economics at noon on Saturdays, because he was convinced that the only listeners would be farmers riding their tractors, and they were likely, in any event, to be his supporters.
For one thing, whatever the effects of the Vietnam War on the national consensus in the 1960s, confidence had risen in the ability of government to manage the economy and to reach out to solve big social problems through such programs as the War on Poverty. Nixon shared in these beliefs, at least in part. "Now I am a Keynesian," he declared in January 1971 -- leaving his aides to draft replies to the angry letters that flowed into the White House from conservative supporters. He introduced a Keynesian "full employment" budget, which provided for deficit spending to reduce unemployment. A Republican congressman from Illinois told Nixon that he would reluctantly support the president's budget, "but I'm going to have to burn up a lot of old speeches denouncing deficit spending." To this Nixon replied, "I'm in the same boat."
While Nixon may have philosophically opposed intervention in the economy, philosophy took a rear seat to politics. He had lost very narrowly to John Kennedy in 1960 -- 49.7 to 49.5 percent of the popular vote. He sometimes blamed the state of Illinois, whose electoral votes had made all the difference and where the Chicago Democratic machine was known for its effectiveness in getting out all possible voters, dead as well as living Kennedy won Illinois by just 8,858 votes. But Nixon certainly believed that mismanagement of the economy had also cost him the election. "He attributed his defeat in the 1960 election largely to the recession of that year," wrote economist and Nixon advisor Herbert Stein, "and he attributed the recession, or at least its depth and duration, to economic officials, 'financial types,' who put curbing inflation ahead of cutting unemployment." Looking toward his 1972 reelection campaign, Nixon was not going to let that happen again. And he had to pay attention to economics. Despite the optimism about government's ability to manage the economy, economic conditions had begun to deteriorate. The inflation rate, which had been 1.5 percent at the beginning of the 1960s, had risen to 5 percent. Unemployment was also up from the 3.5 percent level of the late 1960s to 5 percent.
So the central economic issue became how to manage the inflation-unemployment trade-offs in a way that was not politically self-destructive; in other words, how to bring down inflation without slowing the economy and raising unemployment. One approach increasingly seemed to provide the answer -- an income policy whereby the government intervened to set and control wages, whether in hortatory words or legal requirements. Such policies had become common in Western European countries. In the 1970s, the Democratic Congress provided the tools by passing legislation that delegated authority to the president to impose a mandatory policy.
The administration remained overtly dedicated to markets. But there were those in it who believed that the "market" was more an idyll of the past than an accurate description of how the current economy functioned. To them, the economy was like the question that Lenin had expressed -- Kto kvo? -- Who could do what to whom? That is, they saw the economy "as organized by relations of power, status, rivalry and emulation." Government intervention was required to bring some greater balance to the struggles for power between strong corporations and strong unions that would drive the wage-price spiral upward.
A critical push toward an income policy came from Arthur Burns, whom Nixon had appointed to be chairman of the Federal Reserve. Burns was a well-known conservative economist; Nixon paid special attention to Burns because he had warned Nixon in 1960 that the Federal Reserve's tight monetary policy would accentuate the economic downturn and thus threaten Nixon's chances in the race against Kennedy -- which is exactly what had happened. Now, a decade later, in May 1970, Burns stood up and declared that he had changed his mind about economic policy. The economy was no longer operating as it used to, owing to the now much more powerful position of corporations and labor unions, which together were driving up both wages and prices. The now-traditional fiscal and monetary policies were seen as inadequate. His solution: a wage-price review board, composed of distinguished citizens, who would pass judgment on major wage and price increases. Their power, in Burns's new lexicon, would be limited to persuasion, friendly and otherwise.
Further reinforcement of the pressures toward control came with the recruitment of former Texas Democratic governor John Connally to fill the critical slot of Treasury secretary. The forceful Connally had no philosophical aversion to controls. Indeed he did not seem to have strong feelings one way or the other on economic policy. "I can play it round or I can play it flat," he would say. "Just tell me how to play it." What Connally did like was the dramatic gesture, the big play; and grabbing inflation by the neck and shaking it out of the system would be such a move.
A second issue was also now at the fore -- the dollar. The price of gold had been fixed at $35 an ounce since the Roosevelt administration. But the growing U.S. balance-of-payments deficit meant that foreign governments were accumulating large amounts of dollars -- in aggregate volume far exceeding the U.S. government's stock of gold. These governments, or their central banks, could show up at any time at the "gold window" of the U.S. Treasury and insist on trading in their dollars for gold, which would precipitate a run. The issue was not theoretical. In the second week of August 1971, the British ambassador turned up at the Treasury Department to request that $3 billion be converted into gold.
With inflation rising, the clamor to do something was mounting in both political circles and the press. At the end of June 1971, Nixon had told his economic advisors, "We will not have a wage-price board. We will have jawboning." But resistance to an income policy weakened with each passing month. The climax came on August 13-15, 1971, when Nixon and 15 advisors repaired to the presidential mountain retreat at Camp David. Out of this conclave came the New Economic Policy, which would temporarily -- for a 90-day period -- freeze wages and prices to check inflation. That would, it was thought, solve the inflation-employment dilemma, for such controls would allow the administration to pursue a more expansive fiscal policy -- stimulating employment in time for the 1972 presidential election without stoking inflation. The gold window was to be closed. Arthur Burns argued vociferously against it, warning, "Pravda would write that this was a sign of the collapse of capitalism." Burns was overruled. The gold window would be closed. But this would accentuate the need to fight inflation; for shutting the gold window would weaken the dollar against other currencies, thus adding to inflation by driving up the price of imported goods. Going off the gold standard and giving up fixed exchange rates constituted a momentous step in the history of international economics.
Most of the participants at the Camp David meeting were exhilarated by all the great decisions they had made. During their discussions, much attention was given to the presentation of the new policy, particularly to television. President Nixon expressed grave concern that if he gave his speech during prime time on Sunday, he would preempt the tremendously popular television series Bonanza, thus potentially alienating those addicted to the adventures of the Cartwright family on the Ponderosa ranch. But his advisors convinced him that the speech had to be given before the markets opened on Monday morning, and that meant prime time. A few of the advisors would recollect that more time was spent discussing the timing of the speech than how the economic program would work. Indeed, there was virtually no discussion of what would happen after the initial 90-day freeze or how the new system would be terminated.
Nixon's chief of staff, H.R. Haldeman, went in to see the president privately at Camp David the evening before his speech. "The P. was down in his study with the lights off and the fire going in the fireplace, even though it was a hot night out," Haldeman wrote in his diary. "He was in one of his sort of mystic moods." Nixon told Haldeman "that this is where he made all his big cogitations.... He said what really matters here is the same thing as did with [Franklin] Roosevelt, we need to raise the spirit of the country; that will be the thrust of the rhetoric of the speech.... We've got to change the spirit, and then the economy could take off like hell." As he worked on the speech, Nixon tormented himself, worrying whether the headlines would read NIXON ACTS BOLDLY or NIXON CHANGES MIND. "Having talked until recently about the evils of wage and price controls," Nixon later wrote, "I knew I had opened myself to the charge that I had either betrayed my own principles or concealed my real intentions." But Nixon was nothing if not a practical politician, as he made clear in his masterful explanation of his shift. "Philosophically, however, I was still against wage-price controls, even though I was convinced that the objective reality of the economic situation forced me to impose them."
Nixon's speech -- despite the preemption of Bonanza -- was a great hit. The public felt that the government was coming to its defense against the price gougers. The international speculators had been dealt a deadly blow. During the next evening's newscasts, 90 percent of the coverage was devoted to Nixon's new policy. The coverage was favorable. And the Dow Jones Industrial Average registered a 32.9-point gain -- the largest one-day increase up to then.
The Cost of Living Council took up the job of running the controls. After the initial ninety days, the controls were gradually relaxed and the system seemed to be working. But unemployment was not declining, and the administration launched a more expansionary policy. Nixon won reelection in 1972. In the months that followed, inflation began to pick up again in response to a variety of forces -- domestic wage-and-price pressures, a synchronized international economic boom, crop failures in the Soviet Union, and increases in the price of oil, even prior to the Arab oil embargo. Nixon, under increasing political pressure from the investigations of the Watergate break-in, reluctantly reimposed a freeze in June 1973. Government officials were now in the business of setting prices and wages. This time, however, it was apparent that the control system was not working. Ranchers stopped shipping their cattle to the market, farmers drowned their chickens, and consumers emptied the shelves of supermarkets. Nixon took some comfort from a side benefit that George Shultz, at the time head of the Office of Management and Budget, identified. "At least," Shultz told the president, "we have now convinced everyone else of the rightness of our original position that wage-price controls are not the answer." Most of the system was finally abolished in April 1974, 17 months after Nixon's triumphant reelection victory over George McGovern -- and four months before Nixon resigned as president.
In retrospect, some would call the Nixon presidency the "last liberal administration." This was not only because of the imposition of economic controls. It also carried out a great expansion of regulation into new areas, launching affirmative action and establishing the Environmental Protection Agency, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. "Probably more new regulation was imposed on the economy during the Nixon administration than in any other presidency since the New Deal," Herbert Stein ruefully observed.
Only one segment of the wage-and-price control system was not abolished -- price controls over oil and natural gas. Owing in part to the deep and dark suspicions about conspiracy and monopoly in the energy sector, they were maintained for another several years. But Washington's effort to run the energy market was a lasting lesson in the perversities that can ensue when government takes over the marketplace. There were at least 32 different prices of natural gas, a rather standard commodity, each of whose molecules is based on one atom of carbon and four atoms of hydrogen. The oil-price-control system established several tiers of oil prices. The prices for domestic production were also held down, in effect forcing domestic producers to subsidize imported oil and providing additional incentives to import oil into the United States. The whole enterprise was an elaborate and confusing system of price controls, entitlements, and allocations. It was estimated that just the standard reporting requirements for what became the Federal Energy Administration involved some 200,000 respondents from industry, committing an estimated five million man-hours annually.
by f4a6pilot
Nixon did what the Demorats and socialists were trying to do for years, control means of production by government regulation so that government becomes more important than the market for determining prices. The labor unions once had a stranglehold on the country.
I think that the 1971 UAW strike was the final straw. The Mob and the Unions both had to go.
and on a voice vote had only two dissenters
Frank T. Bow, (R) Ohio, and Baker (R) Colorado.
There were only 85 Republicans in the house at the time...
Senators were likewise intimidated by several votes that included Massive mailings. Wayne Hayes (D) Ohio was going to fight it, but he was promised a seat on ways and means to vote with O'Niel. Robert F. Kennedy was one of the Sponsors in the Senate. The call was WIN!
Whip Inflation Now. All the program did was make things worse and set up the Carter administration for 40% true cost inflation...
(They removed energy, and Housing costs from COLA calculations to keep the cola to a manageable 14%)
I remember that time well as My one Uncle was running for Congress from the Franklin County
seat (Columbus OH). I was around the campaigns for years and years. I knew too much about the process that is why I say "An honest man can get only elected once, and only once. He'll make too many enemies or be ineffective."
by deepsand
by f4a6pilot
So he coopted the idea. He tried to guide it. He tried to make the bad idea work. The price controls were a throwback to the 1940s and the immediate post WWII era that saw rationing end slower than the war...
Nixon hated the idea, but if it is getting shoved down your throat you can at least ask to chocolate coat it... So he coopted the idea, and tried to guide it.
It failed in 1972 and it was a bitter pill, (along with rationing) that barely worked in the 1940s. Without the ration board, travel restrictions,etc. price controls were a very bad policy.
by f4a6pilot
In Congress where he accused all american servicemen of being war criminals who committed atrocities.
It was not the picture currently hanging on display. That picture is from a Diplomatic mission.
Kerry is a most probably a traitor and a liar. He gave comfort to the enemy while wearing the uniform of a Navy officer.
The socialists stick together and that is not the picture of him testifying in Congress saying that all service men committed atrocities...
Here are the salient points.
1. Kerry is a traitor.
2. He gave false testimony before congress under oath, (perjury).or he is a war criminal.
4. Read his book. Either he is a liar, or a person who should be executed. Pick your poison. Just give it to Kerry.
by delbertpgh
Tet was a lot more than a conventional guerilla offensive hit-and-run. There was a hope that it would ignite a popular revolt against the South's government, and open a whole new phase of the war. Even if they failed at that, they thought that by attacking cities they could deal a psychological blow to the South and to the U.S., and also take the pressure off operations in the countryside. The North engaged in large-unit operations, and those units were seriously cut up and set back. The Viet Cong batallions involved were esentially eliminated as operational units for the rest of the war, replaced by the NVA. To this extent, it was an American victory.
However, America had an odd response to this victory, and I don't mean the people and the press. While proclaiming the knockout victory we achieved, Westmoreland withdrew troops from the countryside to concentrate on the cities, and asked for 206,000 more soldiers. How does this add up to victory? Our military leadership crows about a defeated enemy, while handing over territory to him, and begging for 40% more troops to fight him. It didn't add up. It looked like they were completely surprised by Tet, and were afraid they'd be surprised again, so the Army leadership hunkered down and made foolish. This is not something the press did to us, either.
Following Tet, South Vietnamese desertions went up, and the population's confidence went down. The NVA's new freedom to move in the countryside erased much of the progress we'd made there. American confidence in its leaders was justly shaken. They had spent the previous two years saying that everything was going great, and the enemy was being hurt, and please send more divisions; and suddenly, after the greatest intelligence failure since Pearl Harbor, they said we were winning even more, and the enemy was hurt even more, and please send five more divisions. The U.S. population got tired of propaganda, and the press was led by public discouragement, not the other way around.
Which brings us back to the present day situation. I'll quote at you some remarks at a conference from a historian, David Schmitz, who has written a book on Tet.
The parallels between the Vietnam and Iraq wars are ?stunning,? said Schmitz, even though there has been almost nothing in the media about the similarities. He attributes the silence to the fact that no one wants to bring back that ugly time in American history when ?we were pitted against each other.?
Schmitz, however, found many parallels. Some are listed below.
* Support for both wars was high in the beginning at about 80 percent approval, but the public gradually withdrew support of them.
* Both administrations insisted the United States was winning even when it became apparent the opposite was true ?Stay the course? was the battle cry of President Johnson before it became President Bush?s mantra.
* In both wars, soldiers could not easily distinguish between friend and foe and often erred on the side of their own safety, creating more anger from the indigenous population and creating a Catch-22 situation.
* Both the Iraqi and Vietnamese governments lack(ed) legitimacy.
* Neither the Johnson nor the Bush administration understood the culture of the ?enemy.?
* Statistics show that in the Vietnam War, and now in the Iraq war, the enemy initiates more than 80 percent of the engagements. ?They are in control of the pace,? showing that the insurgents are in control of the war, said Schmitz.
Unfortunately, he added, American leaders have not yet learned the limitations of power even a superpower has. ?These are unwinnable wars for superpowers. Can they drive us out? No, but it?s a war of attrition and they just need to wait until support at home wanes and we leave.?
http://www.whitman.edu/whitman/index.cfm?objectid=75B0D10F-F56D-DDF9-6BF17493979824D0
by deepsand
I can well recall an evening spent, in late 1969, with a professor of the Army War College, in which he outlined & described the various stages of disconnect between the political perception and the reality of the Vietnam war.
Were that conversation to be taking place today, he would need change nothing but "Vietnam" to "Iraq."
by f4a6pilot
It proved that socialists and leftist regimes couldn't beet us on the battlefield. Therefore the only way for the leftists (here and abroad) to defeat the US is internally via our own political process.
That is the problem again, the left is attacking the will to fight. They aren't attacking the US directly, but via the press and the public opinion. The American public is more interested in watching Desperate Housewives than in understanding we are fighting those who want to kill every one of us...
by deepsand
To state this as an issue of left vs right is to miss the point.
To quote from my earlier posts:
"In neither (Vietnam nor Iraq) is it the case that "sabotage" was or is their intent; rather, it is to publicly and unequivocably voice the realization that we were, both then and now, lead into armed conflict under false pretenses and with unrealistic expectations. In short, the Democrats seek to openly proclaim that we were deceived, that we know we were deceived, that both the strategy and tactics chosen have not worked and will not work, and therefore that change is in order."
"Politicians are not unlike the parents who alternately coddle them & act the stern task masters, all in an effort to gain both their good comportment & approval. With politics, the matter is only slightly different in that the two major parties are like two parents who alternately coddle the children so as to gain their favor for the next election(s). When the children find out that what they got isn't to their liking the other party wins their hearts, and the cycle is repeated."
by deepsand
by deepsand
What's both particularly interesting & foreboding is the knee-jerk responses from readers who saw in it nothing more than a "knee-jerk anti-Republican leftist-media" attack.
Simple minds do not comprehend complexity.
by f4a6pilot
I really hope that most Americans will vote their conscience, and their personal values. That being said I have seen very moral people who are involved with church leadership who claim to stand against every plank of the Democrat party platform who claim to vote straight down Democrat party line. I find that sad and hypocritial.
I am a simple guy who can do tesor calculus who boils stuff down to the lcd. (least common denominator). I see right and wrong as absolutes. I look at the biggest picture which group is allowing the greatest killing of Americans.
So since abortions are far greater than 20X the war and the babies are more defenseless than an armed warrior, I support the rights of the unborn.
Any moral stand that the Democrats make must be made throught the filter that they have as a party supported the slaughter of American lives, that on an monthly basis rivals the slaughter at Gettysburg. This is the biggest mass murder in our history and it continues daily.
I am a simple Country folk at heart. Forget that I have the education of a Jet jockey. When I see right and wrong I stand against wrong. Until they take the railroad plank from each of their eyes, I care not at all the bitch about the sawdust in others eyes from doing constructive work like Iraq.
I support the mission and the commanders who think they are trying to protect the country. I disagree with them completely on tactics as we have dicussed privately, but I still think that the mission is really completely worthwhile.
Keep the fighting and attacks away from our home.
by deepsand
Therein lies the problems.
All things are not black or white; in fact, outside of Mathematics, very few are either.
Gray is the color of reality.
by f4a6pilot
It is an attempt to say that all people who simplify things are wrong.
He is obviously attempting to say that raw achievement or being able to tell right from wrong is important. He wants a Carter type who will appear to be complex while hiding gross incompetence. He appears to want outside the box thinking, while asking for the status quo. He wants a moral Clinton (oxymoron) Clinton was feared because he was unstable. You'd never know if he'd attack because it would help him escape a personal scandal breaking the next day... With him that could have been non-stop attacks.
by deepsand
by f4a6pilot
I suspect that most killers kill because they want to kill. I suspect that most thieves like to steal. I doubt that most criminals have no other possibilities.
If you have a simple right and wrong viewpoint, some choices are absolute. Most people want "wriggle room" and excuses for their own immorality. (Me, too)
The problem of environment is morality. Christianity and its precepts were once revered. That is not as true as it was 35-200 years ago. The mistakes that were made by the Christian community was in trying to blend into the society. There isn't as much difference as there once was. The divorce rate in Christians is about 3% lower than the 51% of those who either do not proclaim Christianity, or believe in its precepts.
Therefore the moral rudder that guided this country for most of the 200+ years of its existance has become smaller compared to the mass of the ship it is steering. That means that like a large ship without a significant rudder our country is being driven, but not steered toward moral choices.
by delbertpgh
The US was entering an economic phase that nobody understood: "stagflation", stagnant growth plus inflation (about 7 or 8 per cent, I believe.) All reigning economic theory said the two conditions were mutually exclusive, and nobody knew what the central bank or the government should do to break the cycle. Getting tough on credit could send the economy into depression; going wild on stimulus could make inflation really take off, with no assurance that growth would happen.
Nixon was more conservative than the liberals of his time, but he was far more liberal in outlook than today's Republican rhetoric would allow. He was facing a huge problem, how to deal with inflation and zero growth in a democracy that had gotten used to full employment and steadily increasing prosperity. He didn't want to turn back the American dream. He tried something new, and desperate, instead.
C. Jackson Grayson wrote a book called "Confessions of a Price Controller", where he explained that he thought his Price Board did a fair job of implementing a bad idea, but that the Wage Board was rotten, handing out pay increases to anyone who asked. Other economists since think that it would have worked better if the government had tried to engineer a mild recession to hold down demand, since high demand in conjuction with controls leads to shortages and loss of quality. Of course, Nixon did not try to force down demand; that happened naturally, when unemployment shot up under Carter, and was finally fixed when the Federal Reserve raised interest rates to 16% and held them high for years.
by deepsand
Who told you that it was "shoved down" Nixon's throat.
At best, Nixon was a willing co-conspirator.
by deepsand
but are common to the majority of cultural belief systems. They are best described by the Golden Rule, which, in its [u]correct form[/u], is "Do [b]not[/b] unto others, as you would have them [b]not[/b] do unto you."
Christianity [b]never[/b] had, and never will have, a monopoly on "morality."
As for killers & thieves so acting simply & solely from desire, those who are expert in such matters most emphatically disagree.
To say that gray is the color of the realities re. human interactions is to over-complicate is to over-simplify the nature of the human mind.
by f4a6pilot
Economists, weathermen, psychologists, are very often wrong. Especially, I suggest, the people in phychology and psychiatric practice.
The lack of civlility and the lack of discipline in our society can be linked directly to the removal of corporal punishment from the society. With no discipline it is no surprise that we have Juvenile delinquents graduating into penitentiary inmates.
I suggest that the removal of corporal penalty for juvenile miscreants and their associated violence has led to the increase in adult criminal violence.
by deepsand
And, while I agree that corporal punishment can be a useful tool, it is not one that is universally necessary and/or sufficient. Does a good DI get results because he employs such punishment? Would he get better results if he did? In both case, the answer is "no."
Discipline comes in many kinds, each of which has its uses & abuses.
The causes of lack of discipline are many & varied. Many of these causes have their roots in socio-economic factors that are beyond many families' control. Examples of such are the flight of businesses & the upper classes from cities to the suburbs, resulting in urban blight, and the disintegration of extended families owing to both changing economic bases & the relative ease of transportion for purposes of moving one's residence, with the result that many no longer have family members living close enough to assist them.
The overall result is that many of today's parents lack the ability to be good parents, by virtue of having either no elders to teach them, or insufficient time to be all things, at all times & everywhere.
This is a very complex problem, one that cannot be solved by corporal punishment alone.
by nicknielsen
[i]The lack of civlility [/i][sic][i]and the lack of discipline in our society can be linked directly to the removal of corporal punishment from the society.[/i]
Discipline can be exclusive of punishment (the military comes to mind), just as punishment can be exclusive of discipline (look at any abusive relationship).
There is no single factor to blame for the current rudeness of society. Perhaps a lack of appropriate corporal punishment contributed. Perhaps an increase in individual selfishness has contributed. Perhaps the education system has contributed. Perhaps lousy parenting has contributed.
In my opinion, if you want to blame one thing, blame it on the informal (selfish?) way our generation raised their children. Many of us didn't have dinner together so the children could see how to behave at table. We didn't make sure our children learned proper manners and how to be polite to others. Our children even got to see our courtesy attacked because we were accused of being sexist or racist when we tried to hold a door to be polite. As a generation, we weren't Mr. Smith or Mr. Jones to our children's friends: we were Mr. Pilot or Mr. Nick.
In addition, most of us grew up in small towns or neighborhoods where everybody watched out for the children out of community spirit. Now, nobody watches out for any children but their own. It all goes back to selfishness.
Edit: punctuation
by deepsand
That's why I stated that punishment was not perforce necessary and/or sufficient for good discipline.
It should be noted that, in the wild, mothers do [b]not[/b] punish their offspring. While, for example, a mother bear may give an overly rambunctious cub who is physically assaulting her a swat with her paw, it is [b]never[/b] sufficient to cause damage to or fear of her in that cub.
On the other hand, for the human animal, parents punish children precisely [u]for the purpose of instilling fear[/u]! Hence the phrase "putting the fear of God into him/her."
by f4a6pilot
Sometimes corporal punishment as it is referred to by the psycho-babblers is actually punishment, but most of the time it has been used as discipline.
My father put a list of offenses on the wall when I was growing up. It was the list my grandfather put up on the wall fore him.
If you broke the rules,and you got caught, you'd get the punishment. Because of the surety of punishment, it eliminated most of the times I could have gotten punishment. I wouldn't break the rules, if I didn't think there was equivalent balance of return. One time I did start a fight deliberately, and it was well worth the ten with the belt.
Growing up with fixed punishments let me discipline myself, and choose my punishments. I usually chose no punishment. Honor became the watchword.
My own children had the same lists on the walls growing up, and they have turned out to be fine adults, with great self discipline...
by deepsand
In your case, the "discipline" was that list of rules. It clearly set forth both that behavior which was deemed unacceptable & the consequences of engaging in such. The "punishment" employed by your father was merely one of any possible number of means of bringing consequences for bad behavior to bear.
My father, on the other hand, was quite good at disciplining my three sisters & I without resorting to the rod. Once we had each reached the age where we were capable of reasoning, he carefully explained the consequences of any undesirable behavior that we may have engaged in, making certain, by way of testing us with questions & answers about hypotheticals, that we understood how to make better choices in the future.
Our punishments were individually tailored to both the type & severity of the offense, and our own personal interests of the moment, with our being deprived of pursuing a particular activity for a specified period of time.
His method of disciplining was, as I later discovered, was little different from that employed by the military.
Was he a "psycho-babbler?" Not at all; just an ex-GI turned welder-repairman.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending