Discussion Locked

Should Bush - Blair receive Nobel Peace Prize?

0 helpful
20 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

According to the Nobel e-museum some of the criteria are as follows:

http://www.nobel.se/peace/index.html

Peace is one of the five prize areas mentioned in Alfred Nobel's will. The will was, however, partly incomplete. Nobel simply stated that prizes be given to those who, during the preceding year, "shall have conferred the greatest benefit on mankind" and that one part be given to the person who "shall have done the most or the best work for fraternity between nations, for the abolition or reduction of standing armies and for the holding and promotion of peace congresses."

The question becomes should Bush/Blair recieve the Peace Prize? Or should they have even been nominated?

I will comment in another post.....

20 replies

by sullyman

But I didn't know until today that there had been no Pope's that had recieved the NPP.

by oz_media

Yes certain people should be recognized for their outstanding contibutions to modern society, including the pope. How does such an important pat of mankind become missed, when politicias are considered?!?

I also had no idea a pope had EVER been awarded the NPP, guess you learn soemthing new everyday.

Any idea WHY a pope has never received it?

Is there some detail somewhere that possibly removes the Pope as a candidate?

by sleepin'dawg

Both of them had a history of terrorism; Anwar El-Sadat under Nasser and Menachem Begin with the Irgun and Stern Gang??? of course they called themselves freedom fighters in those days but the British called them terrorists. Anyway I think they got it for the Camp David Accords that were signed when Carter was President. The year was 1978. Sadat even did time in jail for his activities in the late forties. They never laid a glove on Begin. I don't think Popes are excluded but a lot of them haven't been squeeky clean like Pius XII who gave tacit approval to the round up of Italian Jews. Also some of the others have been suspected of ignoring their vows of celibacy and having it off with nuns.

by oz_media

They should have received it for their action in Afghanistan and then had it taken away for removing the needed forces and runing off to their next crusade in Iraq.

by robinhood70

Bush/Blair nominated for PEACE when they declared WAR?!? How do you figure?

Iraq, as it turns out, had no weapons of mass destruction, no bio-weapons, no nothing! When initial investigations didn't turn anything up, rather than accept that as an indication that maybe there WAS nothing, Bush haphazardly decided to declare war instead. Outside of the US, it's rather strongly suspected that the "evidence" in support of war came strictly at Bush's direction. He needed a reason to go show off his testosterone levels and goddammit there was going to be one, whether there was any REAL reason or not.

And as for the pope, while he may or may not have done anything for peace, he's done the most of any recent pope to regress society by about 100 years, trying to put women in their place...in the home, denouncing same-sex marriage and single mothers, and a host of other social issues. Peaceful he might be, but beneficent he's not!

Rob

by oz_media

That is, if you read it the first time, which your response shows you didn't.

I am known all over TR as the person most adamantly oposed to the Iraq war and GWB as a person and leader of your coutry that has brought terror un us all.

Saddam should have been removed but not the way it was done, justified or timed.

I also noted that while I did support the ATTEMPTS at liberating Afghanistan and building a democratic government (even though it seems to be failing miserably since much needed troop support was removed), they should have their NPP taken away for actions in Iraq which are NOT justified and should be seen as a war crime on Bush's part.

Try again, you're way off here.

by sleepin'dawg

The award is for creating peace and I don't see any evidence of that yet. If they had been successful, maybe but so far it's still a clusterfu*k. When and if its's SUCCESSFULLY concluded then the conditions can be examined and perhaps then but not yet. Success would be the installation of an 'effective' democracy in controll of the country without outside influences.

by philospher

Well, Blair does deserve a pat on the head for sticking with Bush. But for this clusterf**k situation in which no WMB has been found, no connection to Osmama Bin Laden and real threat was found. The only thing Bush deserves is a swift exit from the Whitehouse. For the bungled four years and going his own way. He needs to go no doubt about it.

by nd_it

The troop support in Afganistan isn't any less than what it was when military operations begin in October of 2001, right around 12,000. When the President asked General Tommy Franks how many troops he needed, that was the number that was requested, and 3 brigades of the 10th Mountain and 101st Airborne, along with Special Forces from the US, Canada, France, Britain, and the Afgan Allies made the entire contigent. Bigger armies don't always win wars. Our troops are the best trained and have the lastest technology, that is the advantage. More recently, the US sent 2000 more Marines to Afganistan to continue the search for Bin Laden. The area which I am sure he is hiding is no easy task for anyone to search through, alot has to be done on horseback and foot. We don't need heavy armor divisions in Afganistan, more special forces and light infantry. As far as the status of Afganistan is concerned, it isn't going to happen overnight. Mulsim women are still discriminated in some parts of the country, but they are also discriminated in Saudi Arabia. The biggest issue for the Afgan government is bringing it's people out of poverty and get it's economy going, which is going to be hard to do when it's largest export is opium. At least Iraq has oil to help rebuild it's economy, what does Afganistan have? Rocks? But at least it isn't a haven for terrorists anymore and it's government supports the fight against it.

by oz_media

Well after watching a former government official in Afghanistan be thown out of governmet by a fundamentalist that now suports th Taliban VOTING for the upcoming election in October, one has to wonder who's getting th fullstory.

Your numbers are simply trivial and not actually an answer. There is NO protection in DOWNTOWN Afghanistan, one of the "safer places" as so many sem to believe. The response from teh various countries where support and security was requested including the USA "We no longer hae the numbers of troops or logistical ability to provide security".
Som, while YOU think there's enough support, those providing the support IN Afghanistan do not. I'll take their word for it, if the government says theres not enough troops available, there's not enough troops available.

II am not referring to the people who are fighting off terrorists in Iraq and protecting government buildings and military installations.
I am refering to the peole who were supposedly liberated and then when security was removed and turned over to Afghani's, find themselves STILL repressed in the exact sam way as they wer before.

So how do YOU fel about the fact that Taliban are actualy IN governmet positions?

How do YOU feel about th Taliban being allowed to vote ni the upcoming election, with the exception of 50-100 that are deemed to hae blood on their hands?

How do you feel about fresh water wells built by coalition forces being destroyed as soon as support was reduced?

How do YOU feel about the fact that ordinary citizens in downtown Afghanistan, not some seedy little neghbouring area or cave, are being represed, stoned and spit on daily for trying to be liberated?

How do YOU feel abotu th pedig attacks on th eupcoming electiion not being BY al-QAEDA but stil being formed and acted out upon by another radical group of terrorists?

How do YOU eel about Kandahar reverting to Taliban domination once again?

How do YOU feel about the women who are too scared to attend schools or hospitals for training because the security that took over for the troops is actually controlled by fundamentalists that beat and humiliate women lining up for sttudies until thy no longer attend?

HOw do YOU see this turning around by addressig different issues than liberatig Afghanistan?

The people don' want it, do you intend on forcing it upon them?

Even in the supposedly better reegions, Westerners are still seen as infidels and the women are repressed just as always.

So what happy rosy places are you referring to? The one's closest to military and government buildings that see some protection and force in a second party scenario? Or the ones crying out that they have lost all the freedoms they were given when troops occispied the area in full force?

How long will you actually fool yourself that they are beter off now? They sure as hell don't see it, glad you do from your home in North America, perhaps they just need to be reminded that these fundamntalists don't exist any longer and they are free and liberated, they can walk the streets and ignore the stonings and spitting while they attend classes, they seem to have forgotten.

by robinhood70

I had intended that to be posted as a reply to the main thread topic, not as a reply to your post.

by oz_media

YOu really threw me for a loop though.

I almost posted it as a new discussion, "Hey someone think's I'm behind the Iraqi war!"

Man THAT would have raised a few eyebrows!
I wouldn't do it though as it wouldn't be very fair on you.

I thought you'd either not read my post, or had never seen my views, which on this board stand alone too often to be funny.

Have a good weekend!
OM

by oz_media

Actually I think this may be beter suited for peer mail, yes I'll have to set mine up again someday.

I know you have seen some things taht only someone who was there could relate to, so have most people even if not at war.

I know that you hav a SOMEWHAT justifiable hatred towards Muslims.

What I hav noticed rom you moe than ANY othe member of TR in the few years I've been hre is that you hav no disgrace in soundig so predjuduced against others. Yes, I also speak my mind without apology, as you well know.

The point I think that needs to be considered is that it shows no respect for othrs here that ARE offended by such an opnion, SOMETIMES (don't aassk me when because I'm a big offender) it is best to respect others by refrainig from such racist comments. The post above is not such a bad or racists post, but it does echo racism quite well, as do most of your posts.

Again, I am not taking pot shots at you or tryig to do anything other than ask you to respctfully refrain fom racist comments in such a ublic forum.

We may have Muslim members, in fact I would be SHOCKED if there wasn't, also there are Afro-American (hate that term), German, Chinese, Phillipino, Japanese, French and every other race of people here too. JUST because they don't post, doesn't mean they don't read. YOu know many people pop up here saying that they read posts and this is their first reply.

I dunno, it just sems a little out of line and disrespectful of others that may be stopped from sharing an opinion after reading such comments.

Just food for thought.

Have a good weekend.
OM

by sleepin'dawg

You are quite correct in stating that I am prejudiced against Islam but against Muslims as individuals, no that is not correct because as I will try to illustrate I am prejudiced, hate if that's the term you would prefer, against ALL ORGANIZED religion. I strongly believe in the separation of church(read religion)and state. It is my contention that most of the conflicts that have taken place in the world, are taking place in the world and will take place in the world are rooted in religious differences especially in the most fundamental aspects of these religions. You are also correct when you think I say things for shock value. I do so in an effort to shake people out of their complacent acceptance of religious teachings as fact because most if not all are hearsay, stories from oral history and tradition finally put into book form and passed down to the the uninformed(I use this instead of ignorant because that is one of those shock value words that tends to upset people) as gospel or whatever version of God, Allah or Brahma the religious leaders are endeavouring to promote. We in North America are treated to the occassional visits of the Jehova's Witnesses or the Seventh Day Adventists and this will surprise you I have a curious respect for them despite my lack of belief in their particular brands of Christianity. I admire their perseverance because going door to door as they do, only to get so many slammed in their faces cannot be an easy thing to live with even though they know this is the reaction they will provoke.
If you think my anti-Islamic comments are provocative you should be in a room of Irishmen when I make the comment that if one wishes to see Chritianity in practice all one needs do is visit Northern Ireland. That often puts the fox amongst the chickens. I despise any form of discrimination whether it be gender based, racial or religious, especially religious because it/they are all so illogical. The epithet that I most commonly hear is that I'm an aetheist but this also would be wrong because I do believe there is something guiding this cockeyed world of ours but I am prepared to admit that I don't have any idea of what it is or isn't and I contend that neither does anyone else. People may believe but they cannot know and the only way they can find out to a certainty is to die, something I'm not prepared to do just yet. I read your post amongst a group of my friends and your racist comment raised a fair amount of hilarity. In the group were a few women several orientals whose origins trace from various points in the South Pacific or Pacific rim, one North American Indian, an Inuit couple, two or three black couples four white couples of assorted ethnicity and one curious individual, probably my best friend, of mixed ethnicity, Chinese/North American Indian who has been with me through thick and thin since my school days. As one of my friends pointed out, if I am a racist then it must be a curious form of reverse racism since I spend so much of my time, both working and pleasure, in the Orient, specifically, China. I am fairly well read and consider myself a student of history. I mean how many engineers do you know with honors history and political science on their tickets. For that matter I even have credits in accounting and commercial law; all the result of not knowing what I wanted to be outside of being a professional army officer. I settled on engineering because my father had been one and while I never knew him I had been told by so many people how much I was like him I figured it was a safe choice. As to whether it was the best choice I don't know since I dabble in many different areas but I did have to choose something because the army wasn't willing to pay for me going to school indefinitely.
So, you call me a racist. That is kind of strange because as I sit here hammering away at this I can look across my den to an award from The Montreal Black Business Persons Association for my efforts such as they are to promote opportunities for black people, male and female, in business. A quick check of my schedule will show that next March I will be spending six weeks in China on a technology transfer at the Nanjing Radio Factory for the Ministry of Coal and Petroleum of the Peoples Republic of China as well as a week of consulting work for the Ministry of Post. I was hoping to squeeze in some vacation time at The Great Wall but I may have to forego that for a few days in Taiwan to check out the installation of equipment at a circuit board facility we have an interest in. I also have donated time in Kenya, Nigeria and Dahomey and have visited Rwanda, Burundi and Zaire or Congo as an observer. Strange behaviour for a racist wouldn't you say??? I admit a lot of this isn't altruistic. I am in business and I always have an eye out for profit potentials but I do feel racist or racism is an incorrect label.
I do love shock value but I think I have one saving grace in this. I am fully prepared to say what I do to peoples faces if for no other reason than to generate a reaction. Fortunately I am of an imposing enough size that makes people hesitate taking a swing at me and the fact that I'm usually smiling and paying for the drinks averts most violence. Besides as you so ungraciously pointed out I'm getting too old for this type of sh*t but I do so love to provoke reactions.
My anti-Islamic rants are probably more pointed and as you said based upon a somewhat justifiable prejudice. As I said, I was shot by an Arab. However, this is not the foundation of my prejudice. At the time I was a newly minted Second Lieutenant 19 years old and this was my first trip, other than the UK, outside North America. In the 60's a 19 year old's knowedge of the world was extremely narrow and limited. Interests in international politics was totally absent. So imagine, if you will, a kid fresh out of officer candidate school leading men for the first time in his life, plunked down between two warring factions and told to keep them apart. Most of us when we arrived were excited and nervous about the implied resposibility of peace keeping. We were neutral or supposed to be and since the Israelis were usually more proficient at attacking Palestinians we spent a great deal of time protecting them. For whatever reason since the Palestinians couldn't or wouldn't stand up to the Israelis the peace keepers became one of their easier targets despite the fact we were protecting them. So in my third month there I got shot. And now comes the part that still inspires my fury. I was shot not by a man but by a 14 year old kid and you can guess the rest. To save my own life I blew the kid away. I was 19 years old on a peace keeping mission and I HAD TO shoot a kid that some gutless iman had whipped up into a suicidal frenzy. Sure everyone tells me I had no choice and yes I have shot at many others but everyone that I know who has had to kill in the line of duty or self preservation has told me the first time is the hardest. I know guys who did whole tours and never fired a shot but me, I had to shoot a kid and that is what makes me so prejudiced against Islam because it would never have happened if that kid hadn't been so aroused and fanatically crazy. It's strange because I don't hate Arabs or more specifically Palestinians but I do hate any organization that would willingly incite it's children to blindly attack others for no other reason than we were there and not Muslim. Not all Muslims are like this but the ones that are carry a sickness that can only be cured by extermination. All other attempts have met with failure. My Muslim friends tell me I don't understand and I tell them I would turn on my own if I thought they would use children in this manner and for what it's worth I include some of the Irish in that sentiment. To date the only people who have used children in this fashion are Muslims and a few supposedly Christian Irish. Even a butcher like Sadam was shocked that Iran sent poorly armed regiments of children against trained troops incurring casualties as high as 75% and these were all kids incited by the Shiite clerics. If that makes me racist so be it. I don't know what other term you could use except sacreligious heretic(Christian) or Infidel Great Satan(Islam) but for me racist seems wrong. I know lots of Muslims of differing national origins and have no problem with them but I will always have a problem with any group that institutionalizes the abuse of children in this manner. You can use any label you care to I frankly don't care but if you are bound and determined to piss me off just try telling me that it's okay to send your kids out to kill and be killed. For me that is sick beyond redemption.

by sleepin'dawg

Just thought I'd throw that in here for its racist "shock value". ]:) ]:) :D Have agood weekend. LOL The Dawg

by robinhood70

What scares me is that while the rest of the world can clearly see that Bush deserves, as you said, "a swift exit from the Whitehouse", the bulk of the American population doesn't seem to! Depending on which polls you look at, it looks like the world might end up facing yet another four years with him.

by oz_media

I think he is under a MUCH greater threat of assassination from US or other friendly citizens than he ever was in Baghdad, where he was shuttled in and out quickly so as to appear he visited the troops to celebrate thier victories over Christmas.

How may president's have been shot for less?

You are right, he is GLOBALLY despised, and yet he puts on the guise of having the world as an ally and seeking justice and righteousness in countries that simply don't want it.

Even his main ally in the middle east is promoting and supporting al-Qaeda now, they are said to have one of the busiest al-Qaeda recruiting centers of all.

Hopefully not all Americans will be dumb enough to think that he's the right guy for the job after all his deception or 'mistakes'of you prefer.

HIS life is a complete and utter failure, if it wasn't for daddy and friends he'd be bitching about not qualifying for welfare.

Education- scraped by (especially considering WHO he is)

Business- Failed once, failed again and cost everyone a bunch of change

President of the USA- don't get me started.

He is a bum a loser and a failure. "YAY, lets vote fo BUSH!"

As for Kerry, no personal opinion really. From what I have seen though, most of the BS about his DISSERVICE is just that, BS. The military agrees he earned his medals fairly. Form what I've seen, those who fought with him or were on HIS boat have not stood up and argued his accusations about NAM, which one would expect if he was really a liar.

More importantly, I don't see him as a cowboy who is going to make knee jerk reactions just to show his personal power and status in the world, he doesn't seem as needy and insecure as Bush and has a few other general personality traits that create a decent human being.

There's no point in posting a bunch of anti-Kerry crap to follow this, I couldn't care less what Republicans have to say about possibly losing an election. It's all the same old same old anyway.

My feelings are that after 4 years in office, Kerry will not be hated globally, you will STILL not have been attacked as a result of Bush's failed war campaigns and life will go on and the world will once again show some respect for Americans for finally removing the world's most hated president and poorest excuse for a leader of the people.

Now I CERTAINLY feel for those in England now who are sitting and waiting for the Tuube to be terrorised, or another of England's important and historical landmarks.

It isn't an IF as much as a when. They KNOW they have been targeted ad are said to be next, but WHEN is the hard part.

I wonder how Blair will react, will he send troops to attack al-Qaeda (the force that Americans have supposedly thwatred already and choose to ignore now) or will he go and attack Belgium to get at thier chocolate? MMMMM chocolate!!!!

But I guss that doesn't matter to you, that's England not the USA, why should YOU care about others You have already said screw the rest of the world, we should be doing our own thing and worrying about ourselves.

Well if you reelect Bush you just may have your wish come true.

This discussion is closed to new replies.