Discussion Locked

Should government ever compete with private industry?

0 helpful
104 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

If possible, please answer the "generic" question.

Should government ever compete with private industry?

Why? When? Does one or the other inherently have an advantage and/or disadvantage?

What are the repercussions?

Are you willing to answer the question and just let the chips fall where they may?

104 replies

by deadly ernest

want to include a thirty thousand word response.

Simply put, - Sometimes, when private industry can't do it right for what's needed for the country, at this time.

I can give a few examples based on government involvement in Australia.

In the early days of Federation in Australia, there was not enough population or usage to justify the commercial establishment of certain types of services that the government felt were required - so the government provided the services and heavily subsidised the costs. Two such services at the time were Interstate rail service other than Melbourne to Sydney, and telephones to all major towns and cities. The government stepped in and nationalised the existing services so they could manage one major network. Some state governments did the same, at the state level, for the rail systems within the state.

In recent years the population and usage has grown that some of the previously government owned services have been sold off to commercial enterprises, but badly done as the people organising the sales had no commercial knowledge.

The same thing happened to the banking industry during the great depression, the government stepped in and bought the smaller banks that were folding and created government owned banks to give the people safe places to deposit moneys and get the money back into circulation for loans etc - it happened at both the state and federal level. Many of them are now being sold off again.

If the government should get involved or not is tricky as it varies with the circumstances of the specific situation.

Hope this helps you out.

by deadly ernest

I once did do a thesis type document on this subject, some years back, for a course I was doing. This is no simple answer.

A commercial utility service for 300 million people in cities spread over an area the size of Texas is a different situation to the same service for 300 million people spread over continental USA, to twenty million people spread over continental USA. The commercial viability will depend on the need and number of customers, if that isn't there and the government sees the need for the service, then they have no choice but to do it.

On another side, standing commercial military forces have been around centuries longer than government ones - feel like firing all the military in your country and replacing them with foreign mercenaries? That's another government type service that used to be commercial, at times.

by j-mart

By now I thought most on this forum would have realized Max deals only with with his own totally theoretical political points of view and only accepts a point of view if it agrees with his own,

Shades of grey and variable factors, as found in the real world, that allow more than one possible answer to a situation, to be debated with supporting augments, are not what Max is about.

As I see it, the shades of grey, and many valid points of view, are what make a discussion interesting. I'm sure we would soon become board with a series of posts of yes, or no.

by tonythetiger

I want an Escolade.I can't afford one. Should government take over GM and have the taxpayers subsidize Escolades so I can have one?

Yeah, I know. An Escolade isn't a "necessity".

Well, neither is health insurance, nor high speed internet. That humans have survived tens of thousands of years without it is proof!

by deadly ernest

election that takes place. Heck, the world did without permanent national armies for many centuries, but try and suggest you don't have one now. Ditto re police forces and hospital systems and fire fighters.

What the government should or should provide at any time can, and will, vary with the era. Much of the initial Australian major rail network was built at the behest of the Australian Army, so they could move troops and gear about the country in a hurry - they don't need that service now as they use various cargo planes. There are many things like that.

by jamesrl

GM is a touchy example for me.

I'm a GM shareholder, as much as you.

Because in order to keep the level/perecentage of GM jobs that exist in Canada constant, my government had to do what the US Government dictated, so we had to buy a big chunk of GM stock for Canada.

If you get yours, can I have mine?

Honestly, I'd never drive one, even if I won the lottery.

James

by oz_media

I see that as the main problem behind people, such as Max but not only Max,accepting it.

Some people feel that having a set of core values means that everything must be viewed and treated on a blanket level. Independant consideration is sometimes seen as a sign of weakness, wavering and uncomitted values.

In many cases individual consideration is exactly what is needed, especially in the case of government regulation, political support, individual freedoms etc.

There is too much grey area to actually set a fixed set of rules, as you've noted, and this it does deserve independantconsideration. In this case that means YES, in my mind but obviously not to those who feel a rule is a rule and must be applied to all instances regardless of complexity.

by deadly ernest

people within the area taking up arms and going out to fight invaders as they arrived. I wonder if Max would support getting rid of all the modern military personnel and handing that role back to people as well?

I know I wouldn't, as the modern soldier, to be very effective, is a highly trained specialist technician - not something you can train a militia person in within a few minutes or hours. Although, we could go the way of some countries where EVERYONE does national service in their late teens, is fully trained, and then a member of their version of the National Guard until they're forty something.

by charliespencer

Should business ever compete with government?

I didn't realize there was a 'perfect' answer. I thought this was a discussion; I didn't realize it was a graded quiz.

by santeewelding

Ernest has obviously given it more than cursory thought, having apparently been occupied with the matter for a time.

So have I been occupied for a time, measured in most a life.

Consideration for and care of another with no expectation of favor returned, instituted by force of law, has something to do with it (the "agenda" behind much of what Oz might have to say).

I do think I know how [b]you[/b] would answer your question, given how you put it.

___________

Thought out in longhand while, and before others after Ernest posted.

by maxwell edison

Considering the full and total capabilities of each, would it be fair or unfair? Are you ready to take-on such a competitor?

There IS a simple answer.

by santeewelding

Would come from Hayek and the Austrians, sources you are undoubtably familiar with. Deeper, wider-ranging answers are sought by university people studying the altruism of voles, among other species.

When I want to be a firebrand, you'll know it.

by charliespencer

How is competing with the government different from competing with other private businesses in my same line of work? If I lose business because I can't compete, does it matter who got the business?

If you already know the answers, why are you asking the questions? I ask again, is this a discussion or a quiz?

by delbertpgh

Back in the bad ol' days, before the French revolution, when the idea of the state was new and without the authority it has today, collecting taxes was sublet to private individuals. Usually ones with a lot of inside connections. People who won these positions were "tax farmers", and they worked within rules set up by the state. Any money they collected in excess of what was required by the state they kept. They had special legal powers, of course, as the I.R.S. does today. Some commodities (especially salt) were subjected to special taxes, and the right to deal in them was restricted to certain monopolies. These were hated functions, of course, but those who enjoyed the privileges of raking in and skimming off the money saw great virtue in what they did.

Kind of reminds me of the health insurance companies today. They aren't insuring against risk, really; instead, all the money for the payment of all medical bills (except for the old and the poor) get passed through them. They take a little taste for themselves, of course, about 20%, and use that to operate big bureaucracies and pay a large corps of executives.

Why would we want government to compete with that?

by jamesrl

Thats the problem, you'd like to reduce this to an exlusive black and white.

I would suggest that in principle, that governments should not compete where there is a working/functional private market.

The Postal Service in most countries, is owned by the government. It competes with private courier companies, even at the level of delivering letters and post cards. But it provides a service at the low end of the market that benefits greatly not only private citizens but private businesses. Do I think that the Post office should compete in the package business? Only if the private companies can't or won't service "all" areas where service is needed.

Of course circumstances change. Perhaps the post office's raison d'etre(letters) will dissapear, and in that case, I'd not support them competing in the package business.

I don't think the government should own car companies, or banks (fed reserve is a special case). And GM could have been bailed out with guarentees instead of ownership - the government could have worked to find partners who would own and run GM backed by a loan guarentee from the Fed.

In terms of health care, which I suspect is something you are interested in, I don't think so. I wouldn't change our system in Canada, but when we set it up, there wasn't affordable insurance available to all, so a single payer was workable. The crux of the argument in the US to me should be, is government providing insurance the only way to ensure access to reasonable coverage?

Canada did own an airline, and an oil company. Both were sold, and I was happy with that. They managed to put things in place so that there was still air service to remote communities.

But would I say ever as in; in every situation, no, I'm not willing to exclude the idea that it may be a necessary evil. But in that circumstance, the government should be looking for ways to make the market work, and then withdraw from it.

James

by j-mart

In New Zealand Gov. owns postal service. but at a local level sub contracts out local delivery of packages and parcels to independent owner/drivers with their own courier businesses. Gov. handles main trunk shipping from center to center allowing many small Ma and Pa operators to do business on a nation wide basis. The customer ends up with a cost effective service, and because the local man has a stake in it, this service has a face and a determination to provide the best service possible, with the added benefit of the big players, many of who are overseas owned, being prevented from screwing us, as they tend to when given the opportunity.

by charliespencer

Should businesses compete with government?

At one time, delivery mail and packages was solely a government function. We allowed businesses to grow into competing with that operation, partly because they could perform it better. If the government can perform a function better, why should it not be allowed to do so?

by jamesrl

I attacked your response to Ernest, your use of Ever, with regards to the question.

You are attacking not my arguments, but me.

Something you castigate others for doing.

James

by tonythetiger

[i]The crux of the argument in the US to me should be, is government providing insurance the only way to ensure access to reasonable coverage?[/i]

Nobody has provided or even hinted at an ethical principle that says any person should be obligated to provide anything to any other person. And since "government" equals "people", it shouldn't do what "people" have no ethical obligation to do.

I would also argue that "reasonable coverage" cannot be satisfactorily defined, but since the government shouldn't be providing it anyway, it's moot.

by j-mart

Not like the dick head you obviously are. As for going to Hell your the one who lives there, I'll stay here in Heaven, I'm sure Max can form his own reply as he is never short of a point of view of his own, there is no need for you to make one up for him, I know you feel left out, but who in there right mind would waste their time and take any of your mindless dribble seriously

by j-mart

Max asks a question, Ernest replies, with his slant on it, I add my bit with my slant, which happens to be along the lines of what Ernest posted. Max, I'm sure will continue down the path he has started and come up with his own rebuttal along with supporting augments. that is how a discussion forum works. Dribble as contrubited by you adds nothing to either point of view. It just makes you look thick.

by deadly ernest

been the case for the last ten to fifteen years, prior to that it was all government employees. Before the government created the national postal service it was only a few private operators who also had transport services and you had to take it to, and collect from, on of their few depots and nothing was handled outside of their depots. The government operation started and suddenly it was available to every damn town and village in the country, and later expanded to be every residence in the country. Which is where we're at at the moment.

If the postal service was left to a normal commercial enterprise to operate it wouldn't exist as we don't have enough people with enough business to cover every town and village to justify as such.

by j-mart

Because of large areas of low population density will always have the situation where it is not commercially viable for private enterprise to become evolved in servicing. Many of these areas provide GDP to the country way greater per head of population than the more densely populated areas. In most cases tax payer subsidy of services is fair enough when you consider the contribution the income they earn is of benefit to us all. very little in this world is black and white.

by deadly ernest

competition with private enterprise - in some situations it's required because the private enterprise operation just doesn't do the job.

In Australia, the government postal services deliver mail and parcels, for most of the country their are commercial parcel delivery services as well, but in many areas the commercial companies either refuse to deliver or hand the job off to the postal service as they don't get enough business in those areas to justify operations; yet, the postal service does because it's seen as a need services by the government.

by delbertpgh

There are some areas where private business priorities do not match public objectives. You could say that the United States Army is in competition with private security services and mercenaries. Got a problem with that?

The U.S. Post Service is in competition with FedEx and UPS, among others. Most people regard the USPS clownishly inefficient, but I think that estimation is not based on measured performance, and ignores the built-in difficulty of their mission: provide mail and parcel service for every American, everywhere, all year round. Private business can't make money doing that.

When it comes to health insurance, I don't see a problem. Insurance is a lousy way to cover what is actually a payment transfer program. In fact, it's not even really insurance coverage; it's delivery of an entitlement. We just call it insurance. I wouldn't mind seeing the business of administering all the accounts subcontracted out to private business, so long as we don't re-create the farcical business known as Medicare Advantage. (Private business commited itself to delivering Medicare benefits cheaper thean the government could; it wound up actually costing 20% more than straight government-run Medicare. That's Medicare Advantage.)

by jck

Used to be the mailman walked mail to every address.

Now, they put large multi-user boxes in a central location.

A bit more granulated than parcel services offer, but still the same concept. Centralized parcel pickup for an area with unscheduled letter drop-off.

Just that you can't get UPS or FedEx to drop a letter for $.45

Go figure.

As for medicare advantage...well...goes to show you that people like jdclyde are wrong; business doesn't always do something better and cheaper than the government did it.

Again, go figure.

by dmambo

Not to put words in Max's mouth (he's already got plenty of words :) ), but I believe he feels that one of the only legitimate functions of gov't is in the realm of defense/public safety. Should private industry compete in that field?

It's been done to an extent in Iraq and elsewhere with, IMO, less than stellar results.

Thoughts?

by jck

It's also happening in the energy industry.

Some cities/states have their own power utilities/generation, which compete on a real-time basis with corporate entities to buy and sell power.

You won't hear a complaint about that from the "doom and gloom"ers on here.

Because...they don't see it pulling the bucks from their wallet.

Doom and gloom...doom and gloom...where's my $100 for golf and booze...doom and gloom.

by jamesrl

I'm consistent in my inconsistency :)

Lets take Iraq.

Do I think there is a role for independant companies doing logistics work (supplies, food prep) in a war zone? No. Its important that everyone in a war zone be able to both report through a chain of command, and also be protected by their brothers in arms. But when the "war" was over, and it was a question of supplying an occupying force, then I might be persauded. Unfortunately Iraq never got "cold"

Do I think there is a role for independant companies to provide security in a warzone? No. I have the same concerns about people with guns who don't report to the military taking the law into their own hands while they are providing security.

James

by jck

I think that with the government/military contracting adds a layer of inconsistent, intransparent responsibility to the hierarchy.

I think if anything that the military is best to handle their own security. No one else.

by larryd4

Government does not compete with private industry. At least in the US, state and federal bodies can't make money. So how could a government agency compete with a commercial company?

I can see deciding if an IT project should be developed in house rather then hiring a consulting firm. But that's all based on the experience and ability of your in house developers.

by maxwell edison

Because business and government work with a different set of rules.

Business needs to make a profit. Government can run deficits.

Business has to meet financial obligations. Government can simply print money.

Business can't raise prices without runnung the risk of losing customers. Government can raise taxes.

Business operates on the principle of supply and demand. Government can simply make laws that force people to comply.

And on it goes.

When government suggests that it wants to compete with private industry, red flags should be popping up in everyone's mind.

by charliespencer

"Government can run deficits."

This is a problem regardless of whether the gov't is competing with anyone.

"Government can simply make laws that force people to comply."

Gov't can make laws, but forcing compliance is another matter. Most traffic, drug, gun, and tax laws are ignored as a matter of convenience.

by tonythetiger

[i]Business can't raise prices without runnung the risk of losing customers. Government can raise taxes.[/i]

There is probably some point where the big boys will say 'to hell with it', and pick up their toys and leave... Will we get to that point? I don't know.

Saw an interesting quote...

[i]"You cannot legislate the poor into freedom by legislating the wealthy out of freedom. What one person receives without working for, another person must work for without receiving. The government cannot give to anybody anything that the government does not first take from somebody else. When half of the people get the idea that they do not have to work because the other half is going to take care of them, and when the other half gets the idea that it does no good to work because somebody else is going to get what they work for, that, my dear friend, is about the end of any nation. You cannot multiply wealth by dividing it." - Dr. Adrian Pierce Rogers[/i]

I've always thought (and tried to convey)... If you're going to insist on others paying for the consequences of [b]your[/b] risks, is it not logical that those others are going to seek to control the risk they're being demanded to take? Would that not necessitate a loss of liberty? How much is too much to lose? Where's the tipping point? And what's on the other side?

On the "How much is too much to lose?" question, I think that differs by the individual, and [b]that difference[/b] is the sticking point in all this.

by j-mart

On second thought is more black and white than I originally Thought. It is to compliment rather than directly compete, regulate and control as required to keep the competition fair, maintain equality for all.

In light of this can anyone confirm that some of the lucrative contracts to supply goods and services to your troops in Iraq did not go out for tender but were allocated to some with good political connections. The interface between Government and business must always be totally transparent, open and offer a fair go to all that whish to be involved

by jck

Yes.

Otherwise, government is not serving its purpose to protect and serve the rights people.

When the enterprise of this country serves not to further itself through satisfaction of their customer base, but through their decline, it is the responsibility of government to correct that.

And when rule of law can not be established to do so, then it is direct involvement that becomes necessary to stem that which only harms a country's people.

Now please since you wanted a simple, generic answer for the simple, generic question...don't try to pick out details from something obviously not meant to be specific.

Thank you.

by charliespencer

There are entire industries that have the government as their only customer.

Taxpayers gain nothing by paying a private contractor his markup / profit margin over having the government do those functions for itself. There's the additional costs of the government infrastructure to run the contract auditing or monitoring processes.

Companies that work only for the government are dependent on Uncle Sam's teat. Their undiversified business model forces them to spend part of their funds on lobbying, political donations, etc to maintain relations with their only customer. Since their lobbying costs are included as operating costs when they submit a bid, the government is effectively paying for them to influence ... the government.

Once entrenched, these industries use the threat of lost jobs in a state or district to block legislators from cutting outdated programs. If those employees worked for the government instead of private contractors, it would be easier to transfer them to other locations where they skills were needed.

There are the questions of legal liability for the action of contractors in foreign countries. If those functions were performed by government employees, the lines of responsibility would be a lot clearer.

by jamesrl

Province of Ontario's eHealth program to create a universally accessable database for doctors, hospitals etc to be able to access patient records is a prime example of private comapnies going haywire.

The government hired a bucnh of experts, without a formal bidding process. They in turn hired their own companies to do more work, no bidding. High paid consultants charging thousands of dollars a day were expensing the government for coffee, newspapers, gum. They produced very little. When it came to buy hardware, they just went to IBM, no competitive bids.

I'm not sure we couldn't have hired civil servants to screw it up the same way, but they would have cost less.

James

by charliespencer

if we choose to engage him, that's our decision. Most of us are 'grown ups', capable of deciding who we want to talk to without a nanny reminding us the conversation might be unpleasant. If you don't like his opinions, consider ignoring the discussions he starts.

by delbertpgh

The only place you can buy liquor or wine is in a state store. You can't buy beer or any other alcoholic beverage in a grocery store; you can buy six-packs or cans at a bar, or for case quantities, go to a designated "beer store". Beer stores are all privately owned. They are not allowed to sell anything less than a case. They can also sell soda pop, cigarettes, and snacks.

I've lived in a lot of places, and for general variety, the state stores have private liquor stores beat. You can find more kinds of liquor and wine in the typical state store, at about the same price. This came as a surprise to some of the people I told this to, whose habit was to insist that private enterprise and free competition inevitably resulted in a better deal for the consumer. In Western New York I could find lots more booze stores than in Pennsylvania (the state stores are widely spaced), but they all kept the most basic levels of stock on hand: five kinds of bourbon, a dozen kinds of red wine, etc. You didn't have to drive as far to get it, but there was way less to choose from. Here, even when I go to the state store in the poor part of town, I have a choice from over a hundred varieties of red wine.

Most of the beer stores (even po' folks' ones) stock 50 or 100 kinds of beer. It's pretty inconvenient sometimes, though, having to make a special trip to one.

by charliespencer

Here in SC you can get beer or wine at any grocery or convenience store, in quantities as small as a single can.

Liquor or distilled spirits are sold in liquor stores dedicated to that purpose only. They're state licensed but I have the impression they're independently owned, although I could be wrong. (If you're a private business, but the government controls where you and your competitors can locate, how many competitors you have, and how much you can charge, how does that differ from working for the government?)

Bars and restaurants sell alcohol for on-premises consumption, not for taking off site.

Oh, and here you can't buy any of it retail on Sunday, unless the county has a certain level of tax income from tourism-connected business AND the voters have opted to allow alcohol sales. Apparently we don't care if the tourists ruin their livers or go to Hell. Bars and restaurants are good to go, but I recall the license for Sunday sales costs more than the rest of the week.

by jamesrl

Up until 1997, no serving alcohol, no liqour/beer stores etc. Whats was funny was a major thoroughfare was the border, so one side of the street had bars and restaurants that served alcohol, and the other side had delis, coffee houses, but no booze. But no place was more than a 10 minute walk from booze, so it kinda defeated the point.

We had restrictive hours for liqour stores/beer stores and restaurants/bars for a long time, but it eased in the late 80s. I still remember a time you couldn't have a Mimosa with your brunch on Sunday till after 12:00. I also remember beer stores closing at 9, and people driving across the border to Quebec to replenish their beer supplies after 9.

James

by jamesrl

In Ontario, we have one type of store owned by the breweries for beer(mandated by the government) and one type of store owned by the government which sells primarily wine and liquor (Liquor Control Board of Ontario/LCBO) but it also sells beer/coolers etc. We also have some Ontario wineries that operate small stores in malls/supermarkets.

The selection at the LCBO is amazing compared to a liquor store in Michigan or NY state. The prices is ok, sale prices in the US will beat them, but average prices are comparable.

In Quebec, Liquor(beer and wine) is sold in a provincial store (SAQ) but beer and wine is sold in supermakrets and corner stores as well. So there is much competition in beer and wine, and that drives the SAQ's prices down.

But there were other reasons for the establishment of these organizations. The government wanted to insure that sales were regulated to try and eliminate sales to minors. They also work with the liquor licensing commissions to ensure they only sell to licensed commercial establishments.

Does that take away just a little bit of my freedom? Perhaps. But like many things in life it is a tradeoff.

James

by delbertpgh

This is not to say I don't believe he has wacky ideas. He's a bit of an absolutist. However, he's thought his way into whatever position he occupies, and we share a lot of initial principles.

by maxwell edison

Okay, I'll agree. I absolutely agree that I have NO RIGHT to tell you how to live. Will you afford me the same? No, apparently not. You advocate using the government broker to force me into your way of thinking.

by jamesrl

I don't see anyone suggesting you don't have the right to think the way you do, or having the government force you to think one way or another. I see many attempts at persausion perhaps, but not force.

James

by oz_media

How about you let everyone else get on with their lives then and just continue paying whatever company you choose to charge you whatever rate they want for whatever your need?

Why are you so concerned about how other people chose to live THEIR lives?
Because their choices effect your government? That's called democracy, the pulic masses speak and if their voice is loud enough and supported by a majority of their peers THEY are heard.

If you WANTED a government supported health care system and others didn't, you'd say they had no right to decide your level of medical support as it treads on your rights and freedoms to be able to make such choices yourself.

When you supported many of Bush's actions that others did not, were you not then trouncing on THEIR rights in the exact same way?

Of course not, I know.

It seems your core value extend as far as having your immediate desires are catered to.

by j-mart

You have to give Max the credit for having an opinion, and an argument to go along with it, not just dribble.

by maxwell edison

.
What a silly assertion.

Nothing is as simple as black or white.

Therefore, the question is, who's best suited to determine the shades of gray? And how many shades of gray are there?

It's government that paints with a broad brush. It's government that paints only black and white pictures. Only the individual can act upon various shades of gray.

You see your gray, I see mine, others see theirs. Who are we to dictate the shade of gray any individual might see?

Government control is what's really "black or white". It's individual determination that sees the various shades of gray.

Therefore, it is I who acknowledges the various shades of gray - and the individual's right to determine the proper course of action. It is others who advocate the black-and-white world or government control over the individual.

by jamesrl

Your question was black and white, based on your response to Ernest. That doesn't lead me to say that everything question you pose, or all you see is black and white.

So here is a shade of grey question for you. At what point does the will of the majority of individuals overcome the right of the individual? If 90% of the citizens of the country want the government to control something, and 10% say it contravenes their rights, is that for Congress to decide, or the courts(knowing the Supreme court is appointed by politicians). I know the Bill of Rights is your bedrock, but it doesn't cover all situations.

James

by maxwell edison

[i]At what point does the will of the majority of individuals overcome the right of the individual? If 90% of the citizens of the country want the government to control something, and 10% say it contravenes their rights, is that for Congress to decide, or the courts (knowing the Supreme court is appointed by politicians). I know the Bill of Rights is your bedrock, but it doesn't cover all situations.[/i]

My answer:

Democracy is not nine wolves and one sheep deciding what's for dinner.

Too many people have lost the sense of individual rights around here. ([i]Here[/i] not necessarily limited to discussions in these threads, but rather in the whole of the USA.) It's the foundation upon which all things should be built.

by maxwell edison

My shade of gray answer:

You asked, [i]At what point does the will of the majority of individuals overcome the right of the individual? If 90% of the citizens of the country want the government to control something, and 10% say it contravenes their rights, is that for Congress to decide, or the courts (knowing the Supreme court is appointed by politicians). I know the Bill of Rights is your bedrock, but it doesn't cover all situations.[/i]

My answer:

Democracy is not nine wolves and one sheep deciding what's for dinner.

Too many people have lost the sense of individual rights around here. (Here not necessarily limited to discussions in these threads, but rather in the whole of the USA.) It's the foundation upon which all things should be built.

by santeewelding

You have, realizing it or not, endowed or not, invoked the name of God to sanction your post.

This puts you into the curious position of having to explain both ends of an identity.

Let me tell you a little story, paraphrasing, from the history of journalism.

The Jonestown Flood. Cub dispatched by his grizzled editor to go, see, and report on what passed.

The cub, awed by the death and destruction, begins his telegraph back with, "God sits on a hill here and..."

Grizzled editor, interrupting the post, wires back, "Forget flood. Interview God. Get photo."

Both ends of the identity, Max. Get photo.

by santeewelding

Had to do with both ends of an identity.

I think I understand your reluctance to go where few tread, preferring instead to reconnoiter, before they experience a bullet hole in the forehead.

by jamesrl

..Max lives in B&W. "This" being the question you raised . And I thought the way you responded to Ernest's response was a black and white - you wanted a simple yes or no. Do you deny it? I would not have said it had you not dismissed Ernest's response out of hand.

But I reiterate, I did NOT say that you live your life that way.

When Jmart said it, I didn't defend you or JMart. Didn't feel I needed to.

James

by drowningnotwaving

An example amongst many hundreds:

Local government in a vast, rural, sparsely-populated community.

They hire out their heavy equipment and personnel to local farms and businesses who need such facilities.

For those farms / farmers who don't have either the full-time need or capital to buy some equipment, this is a great service and significantly cheaper than shipping in the gear from a distant large town.

That's a tick! Good service and efficient use of equipment during down-time.

In my shade of grey, of course.

There are hundreds of other examples of government selling legitimate services and they have every right to do so.

Another example of reasonably positive public sector intervention: The key technical developer that enabled WiFi was an Australian government department.

Here's a question: Would the world genuinely have been better off, if NASA was privatised?

by maxwell edison

Your arguments have simply lost the sense of being reasonable. I don't think you're being reasonable when you say things like, [i]I don't see anyone suggesting you don't have the right to think the way you do, or having the government force you to think one way or another. I see many attempts at persausion perhaps, but not force.[/i]

And if I'm not persuaded, [i]the majority[/i], as you mentioned in another message, will force me to capitulate by way of government legislation. If I can't opt out, it's force.

by jamesrl

Governments may indeed be able to modify your behaviours, but my point was they can't modify how or what you think.

James

by tonythetiger

[i]As I see it, the shades of grey, and many valid points of view, are what make a discussion interesting.[/i]

Either agreeing or disagreeing with you about what is interesting is also a black and white issue.

by delbertpgh

I don't generally believe government should compete with business. Government does usually not show the quick adaptability a successful business does (many businesses don't, either, but they go broke), and can wind up subsidizing inefficient operations to the detriment of the taxpayer and of the competing businesses. However, I say "generally". There are times when you can't trust private business, or times when the phenomenon of "market failure" makes bad social conditions. I'm interested only in outcomes; I don't fantasize that there's some eternal virtue in private control that makes men better, or similar Ayn Rand nonsense. Bottom line results; that's all that counts.

However, if government's proper activity is governing, what does that mean? There are lots of things we expect government to do that can be privatized... roads, water supply (in France, municipal water supply is usually run by private companies... France!), prisons, fire departments, you name it. Do you see a bright line dividing the realm of business from government?

Do I think that government should actually participate in a marketplace in competition with private businesses, offering the same class of services to the same customers? Like Obama proposes with the "public option"? That's the riskiest ground, and I don't support it, unless there are very good public policy reasons, which I'm inclined to say there are.

by drowningnotwaving

Hi DelbertPGH I don't share your concern about govt getting into business at a 'structural' level. In some cases I think govt businesses do an excellent job, where in some cases your concern that they are hopelessly inefficient is spot on.

Are you saying that, simply because a component of government business [b]can[/b] be outsourced, it therefore [b]should[/b] be?

by maxwell edison

Or did they simply move from the shackles of chains to the shackles of finance? Physical slaves or financial slaves - what's the difference? Only in the chains that bind them.

by jamesrl

I was hoping for a little divergence from the party line.

I do believe we should hold certain rights inalienable, but who and how do we decide. Is the Bill of Rights complete and unamendable? In Canada, we've only had such a thing until recently, and yet we ended slavery sooner, didn't have the same kind of Indian wars the US had, and we have been reasonanbly free. Has the introduction of the Charter of Rights over 25 years ago made us freer? Would we have Gay Marriage in Canada without the charter? Interesting questions, I'm sure I don't know all the answers, but its an interesting discussion.

James

by maxwell edison

I suppose that would be the Libertarian Party - one for whom I've never cast a single vote. It's hardly a Republican Party line, unless you go back to about 1964. But I can continue to hope and try.

What's telling about my answer, however, is that it illustrates the fallacy of majority-rule vote, something upon which so many folks in these discussions try to rely as support for their argument. None of them, however, will freely admit to being a wolf feasting on the unwilling sheep.

by jamesrl

That would have to be the Maxwell Party.

I fully realize you aren't a slavish adherent to the Republican Party.

I'm still interested in the idea of amendments to the Bill of Rights. I know we have a method to modify the Charter, but it involves a complex formula than means it is very difficult to amend.

As for being a wolf, I've often been on the side of the sheep. As a conservative, I've often found myself arguing the intent of previous historical actions. I have supported Quebec's French language rights, because the British granted those rights before Canada was a country and they were reaffirmed when Canada became a country. Similarly public funding for Catholic education was an issue where the "right" was enshrined in the act of British Parliament that created Canada, so it was part of the political bragain struck when the independant provinces got together. Many other conservatives argue that times have changed and French is a smaller part of the whole than it was. I'm not French, those things do more to hinder my life than to help, but I don't think its our place to just overthrow the longstanding rules just because of convenience.

James

by j-mart

They are not exactly the same thing, and as with close cousins the produce of their "marriage " does not always give consistent results.

by dwdino

Government has the power to set the rules by which you operate.

Now, before everyone points to Wal-mart's abilitity to "persuade" others, that is a secondary to supply and demand.

Now, if you can undercut Wal-mart's prices and create sales, their only recourse is operate differently. If government is losing, it simply tilts the playing field back to its favour.

by oz_media

Why?
Because insurance costs are uncontrolled and government regulation would seem just as bad as "competing".

When?
In the case of universal health care. ;) LOL, you didn't think I'd miss your objective, did you?

What are the repercussions?
Many right wing supporters will feel it is unjust and consider such an offering as competition. Whereas I only see competition as being two compaies offering identical products and undercutting one another. In the case of universal health care, I think there will be some regulation as to who qualifies for such low rates and as the same, affordable product, is not offered by private enterprise there is no competition.

What are the repercussions?
Spending day after day arguing with republican supporters on TR over it, none of which are lawyers or have any control over it anyway.

Let the chips fall, the toes curl and the paint peel.

by oz_media

I've said the same thing, about several peers here now, and it results in them getting a little defensive and pissy.

You are right though, a post with nothign but agreement sure as hell would kill off TR in a hurry. I dunno, maybe people get upset when they think they have a point and the masses don't run to agreement, so they can be proven wrong on their previous coments.