Discussion Locked

Should the U.S. have nuclear weapons?

0 helpful
530 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

530 replies

by oz_media

Well seeing as you added nothing nor corrected anything, I thank you for your post but it wasn't really of any substance this time, James.

I guess I need to repeat, when American US naval forces on OTHER ships in the middle east were questioned, they said that they envied the detection systems on board the Canadian vessels and were amazed at the maneuverability of them. They had grossly underestimated the Canadian ships and were shocked at their effectiveness with such small crews of trained seamen/boarding crews.

Perhaps, they too had these systems aboard their ownvessels and simply weren't aware of their own capabilities. Perhaps the deployment of this technology on Canadian ships was not also retrofitted to their own. Perhaps they just plain lied about it.

The show I watched did focus on he helicopters and how they were used to stop smuggling and the importance of their role.

You seem to be missing the entire point of the post though by over analyzing irrelevant details.

It was posed that Canada has not really done much to help lately and that Canada's military is really not looking to support US efforts, this is of course very wrong and can be proven wrong by looking at efforts such as those in question here.

EDIT:
The comment I responded to was [i]"It seems that Canada is becoming a less reliable ally as time goes on. "[/i]

The French and Canadians can fight alongside US troops for years, but the second they don't stand with the US, they are said to be unreliable?

They protested France when they didn't back Iraq, yet they welcomed them and the Embassy's support in Afhganistan?

They say that Canada is an unreliable ally, when we have been participating in enfocing the OFF program for years, we supported the US in Aghanistan too.

But now because we don't agree on ALL perspectives, we are no longer a reliable ally?

This mindset is quite scary and I have seen it many times when used to justify American actions. "nobody else does anything about it so we are taking it upon ourselves."

God help us all, should the US have the only nuclear arms on Earth! I had a freind like that, would be buddy buddy with a enw friend until they said something he didn't like, then he was the enemy, and the NEWER friend was the cats meow.
It's childish, it's not constructive and it certainly isn't sane nor a reason to give that person control of power.

Nobody came running to support all US efforts and therefore they must be an enemy now. The old, 'you are either with us or against us' bullsh*t

by jamesrl

You were the one who posited the superiority of the Canadian Ships. And when the facts don't agree with what you said, you call them irrelevant.

I simply pointed out the facts -that we use the same sensors and weapons as US ships. Now perhaps some of them are found on larger US ships like destroyers, but these days the difference between a destroyer and a frigate isn't the size, its the mission.

I've never argued and always agreed that the Canadian military output and our missions has always been ignored by most Americans. We were in Bosnia before the US. We asked the US to join and they refused, until the Dayton accords were signed. In the interim we actually had a battle with the Serbs which took place over three days with hundreds of men, tanks, involved. We may have disagreed with their position, but we didn't chide them as poor allies. We were in Rwanda trying to stop a genocide, and Americans not only did not come when asked, but interefered in the mission, refusing to allow the troops on the ground to play a role, which in turn allowed hundreds of thousands to be slaughtered with axes and machetes.

We were in Somalia. We are in Haiti. We are still in Crete. During the cold war we had a much bigger military, and much of it was in Europe.

Canadian units won Presidential unit citations in Korea for standing fast and covering an American retreat. Canadian soldiers won American medals for bravery under fire in work in Afghanistan. We didn't participate in Grenada(wasn't asked), Panama(wasn't asked) or Vietnam(wasn't old enough to remember, but don't think we were asked).

Tens of thousands of Canadians fought for the Union(many won Medals of Honor), and Canada had been the terminus of the undergound railroad, yet
all Americans seem to remember is that Jefferson Davis travelled to Montreal during the war, and came back after it.

But I don't blame the American people for the short memories, its usualy the politicians that make hay out of it that drive me bannanas. As I watched the remake of the Alamo the other night, my brother in law remarked that making US congressmen fight should happen in all sitautions.(Davey Crockett had been a congressman, but lost his seat and went down to Texas in time for the Alamo).

James

by oz_media

It's always fun having a little banter with you, as you seem take it all so light heartedly. :)

What I had said was;
"The show I watched focused on their high speed ships that were the "envy of US seamen" as they were faster, more manueverable and had FAR better detection systems and more sophisticated electronics than their US counterparts."

SO what this actually says is that ON THE SHOW that I had watched, THEY (the US Seamen) were envious of the level of sophistication on the Canadian ships, as compared to their own (the US counterparts in the same areas undergoing similar missions).

The systems WERE said to be of US and European design. However, I got a strong and clear impression from those sailors interviewed that these systems were not available on THEIR ships operating in the area.

I at no time made the assertion myself that Canadian ships were superior. Just that they were superior, as documented, to US ships provided for the mission.

I somehow thought it would be a defensive American to reply with such comments, thus I was very clear in saying that this was how it was portrayed and shown on a television report/documentary. US sailors pointed at their own systems while saying they were envious of those used on the Canadian ships. Perhaps they were pointing at the exact same system as used on their own ships and just didn't realize it, but I doubt they are really THAT dumb.

by jamesrl

These are not "nationally" or federally mandated. These are declarations by city councils on things that are out of their jurisdiction.

If Toronto decided to declare a nuclear free zone, they would have to close all the highways cause there is a nuclear fuel processing plant nearby and the only major multi lane highways between the processing plant and the nuclear plant go right through Toronto.

We had a similar sitaution when I was at AECL. Our facility at Cahlk River was looking at testing using weapons material in a CANDU reactor, as kind of a swords to plowshares thing. The idea was that if you used it as fuel you could no longer use it in weapons. Initially the US pressured the Russians to sign up, and the Russians insisted that the US participated.

The fuel was supposed to be shipped from the US by truck to the research site in northern Ontario. Many towns along the route objected strenuously, with protests planned and people prepared to lie down on the highway.

I drove in the front gates one morning to see a military helicopter sitting nearby, a rare but not unheard of situation since the local army base is close, and the army drills with the plant security forces. Turns out the fuel was shipped oevr the border to a small airport, picked up by helicopter and flew to the plant.

Vancouver and other Canadian cities have laughingly declared nuke free zones. When US warships arrive on shore , they refuse to confirm or deny the presence of nuclear weapons. They have them. The city council knows they have them, but no one says anything.

Most people in Canada are leary of nuclear power but not as much as in the US. Our reactors are safer. The last major incident was in the 50s.

The AECL facility in Chalk River makes 85% of the world's medical nuclear isotopes. The federal government, when the conservatives were in power, sold off the isotopes business to a private concern. So what could have been a source of funding allowing AECL to be independant of the government, was tossed away. Now a private company "owns" the reactors and AECL personel run them.

James

by oz_media

THey have refused passage to more than one US naval vessel, although they have no athority to. The city council cannot place such control on the inlet.

BUT, ANY nuclear POWERED ships have been denied access, but public opinion and city council's suggestion. They (US military vessels) usually come here, much to most people's dislike, and se every few actual visitors and tours as they would in other cities. Sure all th ehookers hang out like vultures at a meatshop, some familes from Washington come up to visit loved ones but for the most part they garner very little interest.

Due to a pulbic outburst some years ago regarding a Nuclear sub that was supposed to dock in Vancouver harbour, they simply don't bother with nuclear powered vessels in Vancouver anymore. Like I said, that last one was moored offshore and local water taxis and other small private craft offered sea to shore services for the sailors.

The sailors aren't welcomed into town, our bars are mainly owned by large bike clubs and it always results in American sailors getting too drunk and tough for their own good.

It really as nothing to do with Arms as much as it does that people don't want to see them (US Naval ships and sailors), hear about them or deal with them in Vancouver.

Military is just not too welcome here at all. Even bases here get shut down due to public outcry of military personelle/meaneuvers being unwelcome in their area.

The military has fought tooth and nail with the city and people of Vancouver and Chilliwack for years to be accepted, but people just don't want to have any part of it.

Vancouver and the LEFT coast, as you deem it (I know very few people who would actually be considered lefties, even though the island is full of NDP'ers due to the forestry and fishing industry) doesn't care about military, war and politics. That is a Central/Right Canadian thing.

by computer dude

I believe that South Africa voluntarily gave up its nukes if I remember correctly. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

by aldanatech

I agree jck. At the rate we're going, it would seem that the only to drop all nuclear weapons is to start from scratch. It just goes to show that have truly not evolved as much as we think we had.

by computer dude

I have to agree with dawg. The necessity for deterence dicates that we have a nuclear arsenal and would use them if necessary, though hopefully the only nukes to go off would be in a Hollywood blockbuster. Nobody truly likes the idea of war except those who profit from it, but we cannot give up our most powerful deterent.

But I wonder what would happen if the U.S. "gave up" (makes it sound so easy) it's nuclear arsenal. And the question of whether we should have nukes in the first place is about 60 years too late so it's a moot point anyway.

With the rate at which we are sustaining China's economy out of our desire for cheap plastic Wal-Mart things and low-priced electronic equipment, I don't think it's far-fetched to suggest that maybe in a few decades we could be up against a super-power China, and we'd better pray that's it's not hostile to us. If we dumped all of our nukes in the ocean and tree-hugging anti-American hippies could sit around and sing Kum-Bi-Yah and We Are the World, what would the logical response be from a hostile nuclear-armed Red China be? Try on a little reality before you dismantle our nuclear aresnal.

by jamesrl

I hate to speak for all Canadians, but with the exception of a few nutters, Canadians know that the US is our friend, neighbour and business partner. We don't always agree, and we bicker from time to time, but when our back is to the wall, we rely on each other.

James

by oz_media

Canadians don't care for the US politics they are drowned in daily, we are not a politically focused society for the most part.

Canadians don't care for the US military flag waving that we are drowned in daily, we are not a military focused society for the most part.

Where does this then in turn become, Most people in Canada would like to see the U.S. destroyed?

I bet you're also one of those who believes that Canadians are jealous of America too. That Canadaians all smoke dope and don't care about the evils in the world.

THat stereotype works both ways, I don't think that all Americans want to see Canada destrpyed though. We rely on each other FAR too much in our day to day lives and would both suffer without each other. BOTH of our economy's would take a huge hit. Like it or not, you need us and we need you...I think.

by deepsand

Main Entry: dude
Pronunciation: 'd?d also 'dy?d
Function: noun
Etymology: origin unknown
1 : a man extremely fastidious in dress and manner : DANDY
2 : a city dweller unfamiliar with life on the range; especially : an Easterner in the West

by jamesrl

So let me get this straight - Vancouver thinks that if they block nuclear powered vessels, they still allow other ships and they think thats more important - what a joke - still.

A nuclear powered attack sub has a reactor for propulsion, but conventional weapons(normally). A non nuclear powered destroyer or cruiser could have nuclear weapon tipper Tomahawk cruise missles. Which one would you rather keep out. Kinda reminds me of don't ask don't tell.

As for you left coasters, there is an underwater test range for torpedoes that Canada lets the US use at their will - just off the Coast. Canada also let the US test the cruise missles in the 80s on our air defense testing range because it was bigger than anyone in the US. We still have NATO aircraft playing over Canada because they aren't allowed low level training over much of Europe.

So Vancouver can stand on their high horse all they want. It doesn't impact anything except a few goodwill visits by US ships. They probably prefer Esquimault anyway.

James

by oz_media

You are referring to nuclear arms in the harbour. Iwas repsonding to a question as to whether or not Vancouver has nuclear power plants?!?!?

NOW you are talking about cruise missiles off the west coast in international waters of the Pacific Ocean? Somewhere we have missed the price of oranges here.

I merely mentioned that NO Vancouver has no nuclear power plants and as a matter of fact we are a declared nuclear free zone. Do you disagree and feel that we DO have nulclear reactors here afterall?

Ships being disallowe din the Vancouver harbour, it's mroe a distaste of US warfare than anything else i think, as far as the public is concerned. Not just since Iraq but in fact this was the general feeling shared long before the Gulf War.

As for Esquimault, IF they were able to squeeze more than a harbour pickle (those little Victorie harbour ferries) into THAT tiny little base, I would be amazed. Last time I was there, they were shuffeling ships frantically so they could fit another delivering goods the next day. I am surprised they haven't started mooring them in Victoria harbour for the added space.

AGAIN though, nobody is being rigtous or having a ride on a high horse, I just said Vancouver doesn't have nuclear power plants, is declared a nuke free zone and rejects US miltary ships looking to stay in the Vancouver harbour.

How did you somehow get the impression that any of this has anything to do wih nuclear arms or secret cargos entering Vancouver harbour? OR even moreso that the LEFT coast, as you call it, claims moral superiority over you?

Have you had some nice little arguments on these issues in the past or something?

by deepsand

You said, "what you are saying is almost like saying that because people don't drive, they must have voted against cars at some point in time. When in actuality it could be a result of no need for cars as there is an abundance of horses."

The Old Order Amish possess neither automobiles nor telephones, as they believe that the daily use of such would be to the detriment of their lifestyle.

However, the use of such is NOT proscribed. In the press of urgency, they will pay the "English" for the provision of such services.

That BC may not have the need for nuclear power does not explain the fact that someone felt the need to ban nuclear "devices" from Vancouver.

So, the question remains on the table.

What led Vancouver's city council to issue its edict?

by oz_media

It has nothing to do with the Amish and neither did my analogy, I had a feeling someone would compare it that way though. I said 'if there was NO NEED' not 'if people of a certain faith felt...'

Nobody banned nuclear devices from Vancouver.

It has never beensomething wanted by the people, it is also not a source of power that is needed. NOR do we have any reason to develop nuclear arms, for this reason, City Council officially NAMED Vancouver a nuclear free zone and posted signes at the entrances to the city.

NObody has set a lw in stone that nuclear devices will not be devloped here, nuclear fission is a very popular university course here.

Is California REALLY the sunshine state because it is on their licence plates?
Is Alaska REALLY the last frontier?

People don't welcome nuclear weapons or power in Vancouver, they have never BEEN welcomed by society, there is no issue for or against it, it is not a topic of discusison there, get it yet?

As for the rest, whatever. It's a complete waste of time even trying with you sometimes. Don't get it? Too bad, sorry.

by deepsand

One should not assume that their particular colloquialism will be universally recognized and accepted.

by oz_media

Man you need to get some help, maybe just a vacation from work and life. You have made an issue out of 'SOMETHING' in every single post you have responded to for weeks now. Here, there and everywhere, you are challenging and contesting the most irrelevant issues of every post you reply to. YOu are seeking argument, you have no constructive input, just flames and bitter intentions. Grow up or take a friggin' holiday, you're tiring and boring.

Are you trying to imply that if someone walked up and said HEY DUDE, you would be lost as to what he says? YOu know very well whet the alias meant and are just being a knob for the sake of wanting to flame someone you didn't agree with by purposely bringing attention from others who disagree right in your title.

You were just being a dick, and you know it.

by deepsand

Your posts left the impression that the city of Vancouver had enacted some legal stricture re. nuclear "devices."

You stated "It was officially declared by the city council in 1983 and signs were erected at the cities entrances."

Now you seem to be saying that such was merely an expression of sentiment.

Fair enough; but it still leaves the question of the reason for such sentiment unanswered.

It's a legitimate question, without prejudice.

by hockeyist

We had the French setting off NUCLEAR EXPLOSIONS off our Australian and New Zealand coasts a few years ago, basically in our backyard. The French even sent two of their commandos to blow up the Rainbow Warrior (Green Peace there protesting against French nuclear tests) in New Zealand which resulted in the death of the ships cook and the sinking if the ship. These French government assassins were caught and lightly sentenced. Absolute madness!! After Aussies and Kiwis protested by not buying French products and other means, the French took their bombs and went home. One of the French car suppliers packed up shop and went home because trade stopped, not sure which one (don't care really).
Every dumbass thinks that it's ok because it's a global thing and it's safe because it's "over there". It's a global neighbourhood and everyone is affected when things go bad.
Let's take this to a local level, say your local suburb. A couple of LUNATICS in neighbouring suburbs have created some hefty bombs made from bird turds (that fertilizer crap, easily constructed just like a nuclear device only cheaper). I can't see any difference between these imagined suburban LUNATICS and the elected LUNATICS that are charged with the safety and well being of this planet.
Now if these suburban LUNATICS then called the press and informed them that they have bombs in their pantry that could wipe out every suburb in the state, and the only reason that they have them is for your protection against the other LUNATICS, do you think that it would cause more concern than what is currently shown? Do you think that it would get people off their fat arses and maybe protest that little bit which could make a difference?

by jamesrl

My point is that it is entirely silly for Vancouver or any other city to declare themselves a nuclear free zone. Denying a US warhsip entry because it has a nuclear power plant is even sillier - because you could deny a ship with no nuclear weapons and allow a ship with a conventional power plant but that carries nuclear weapons(but won't admit it, they never do).

As for the left coast, I didn't make up that saying, its been around longer than I have. BC does tend to have more people at the extreme, both left and right, and fewer in the centre.

I will admit I am sometimes overly long and convuluted in my discussion, but not trying to be obtuse.

James

by computer dude

I believe that Canada and probably most of the world hates our guts right now, thanks in large part to our fearless leader. There are plenty who'd be having wet dreams if we were defeated and had our influence in the world destroyed.

But when you have a economic problem or some other drastic situation who does everyone come running to first begging for a handout?

by jamesrl

Canada doesn't hate your guts. The majority may not like your leader, but we know that politicians come and go, and that our long term interests remain. If you want to look at polls, they exist.

You are our best customer. We need you to be strong. We want to see your economy strong.

But at the same time we don't like to be bullied. We want you to live up to the agreements you have signed(which is not the case with trade agreements with Canada).

We don't ask for handouts from the US. We do ask for fairness. On occasion we do get US help for military transport - we don't have enough. But we also rent Russian transports when we can, so we don't ask for help too often there. And its a reciprocal arrangement - the US asks for our help all the time, not because they need our armed forces, but because it puts a different spin on the situation.

Canadians don't hate Americans. There was some incident a year or so ago where some American kids hockey team was booed at a Quebec arena, and I recall an amazing outpouring of warmth and generosity from many parts of Canada. I would venture to say there is less anti US government speech in Canada than at many US universities.

James

by liame

Fearless leader huh? I tell you what takes REAL couragae - admitting when you made a mistake.

by oz_media

and your government does not exactly constitute wishing death of Americans.

If America was destroyed, invaded, taken over or whatever, I would be out tens of thousand every year in US revenue.

What gets me is that a country that has such a poliyically focused society allows someone like GWB to do as he pleases and they actually support it even after the BS surfaces.

by computer dude

You make it sound like we have any control over what the prez does. Contrary to popular belief, GWB does not answer my calls and emails...

by computer dude

The hundreds of thousands of anti-war protestors? Not everyone liked the idea of invading Iraq, myself included. Be careful who you generalize as 'everybody'.

by jamesrl

We don't have the same kind of thing such as the invasion across the Mexican border. We do get the standard boatloads of immigrants smuggled in, or visitors dissapearing into the woodwork. I remember skiing at Whistler, and alot of the lift attendants and so on were from Australia - they would say G'day as you got on the lift. We heard through the grapevine that the immigration officials came up in the night and all of a sudden there were fewer workers on the hill and not an Australian accent to be found. I have also heard of chinese restaurants in major cities being busted, and having to close because they no longer have any cooks.

But WallMart hasn't been convicted of hiring illegals here.

I think the difference here is that Canada's immigration and refugee system is pretty forgiving and lenient - you can appeal for years, and deportation is not often used. But we don't have people walking over the border, except on occasion to get a health card.

James

by computer dude

I could have sworn our immigration 'policy' was pretty lenient and forgiving. Bush is inviting illegals as we speak.

by oz_media

One major issue we have is the automatic citizenship for children born in Canada.

During the big toos in China some years back, many Chinese poeople flocked to Canada to seek refuge. If you are a child born in Canada you have automatic citizenship. Pregnant Chinese women came to Canada in droves to give birth while 'on holiday'.

Their children can then return to Canada anytime as thy are automatically Canadian and then sponsor the parents immigrating.

As far as not having boatloads of immigrants landing on teh shores, we do. There was a major incident just two years ago where boats were stopped entering the Canadian waters, only to see everyone jumping ship. Some were rescued, some were not. They were detained at CFB Esquimault until most were actually deported back to their homeland. This happens all the time here, on the lefty coast.
For the most part though, our imigration laws make it easy for people to seek refuge in Canada so there is less need for illegal immigrants.

I also have a couple of Aussie freinds, two of whom work in Whistler. They haven't actually moved here, but are staying an 'extended term' before returning home because they like it here. But British colony residents all seem to share multiple homes in multiple countries without too much effort. We don't exactly have an issue with Australians or Asians working for pennies and stealing jobs, our employment laws are too heavily regulated to allow it. Sweat shops are few and far between as they simply can't find people dumb enough to work for nothing and they are soon ratted out.

by jamesrl

In the War of 1812, many American congressmen lobbied for the invasion of Canada to fullfill the Monroe Doctrine of "Manifest Destiny", that the US was destined to own all of North America.

There were numerous expeditions from the US to Canada, and despite the fact that England, being tied up with the Napoleonic Wars, couldn't provide much assistance, we managed to beat them off, with the assistance of our native allies in many cases. There are many occasions when American forces badly outnumbered Canadian militias, but natives attacked ferociously and turned the tide.

The main battleground was southern Ontario. Early on in the war, a British expedition seized Detroit, but the supply lines were pretty long and they abandoned it. The Niagara area saw a few battles, and a couple of forts there traded hands back and forth. York (Toronto) was invaded by the Americans, then burned, including the parliament buildings, inspiring British marines to invade Washington DC and return the favour.

In the end, it was pretty much a stalemate. The British invaded Louisiana to take the pressure off of the Canadian frontier. But the war was over by that time.

And for those of you who will undoubtably insist that Canada didnt exist at that time, while the country didn't exist, there were colonies called Upper(Ontario today) and Lower(Quebec) Canada, with early forms of Parliament.

The only other incident was after the American Civil War. The Fenians, Irish immigrants committed to throwing Britain out of Ireland, had participated in Irish regiments in the Civil War, on both sides. Some fenian leaders recruited many of these veterans and convinced them to invade Canada and throw the British out. They crossed the Niagara river, but a) most of them were drunk and b) someone let the Canadian militia know they were coming, and they were soundly routed.

After the war of 1812, Canada fortified itself against future attack. Forts on the Niagara, at Toronto, Kingston and Quebec City were greatly strengthed, and the militia enlarged. They make great tourist attractions today, but they seem to puzzle American tourists. The building of the railroads was seen as vital to Canadian defense.

The timing of the creation of the country of Canada is a direct result of fear of invasion from the US. Canadians feared that the large standing Union Army at the end of the Civil War, might just be persauded to come north. Thus a group of separate colonies banded together to form the country of Canada.

BTW there were war plans drawn up between WWI and WWII for American invasion of Canada. And Canadian military drew up plans to repulse them. Presumably the exercise was in case Canada was involved in a European conflict and "fell" to an enemy, though even today it would be difficult for any country in the world to invade Canada successfully, except of course, the United States.

James

by computer dude

I wasn't aware of some of that information. Always cool to learn non-traditional history. I had once read that just prior to the outbreak of WW1 that the U.S. was on the verge of invading Mexico (damn Mexicans didn't learn the first time) because of the Panco Villo fiasco. Might not be a bad idea these days to stem the flow of illegals invading our country.

by montgomery gator

There was an attempt to take Quebec during the American War for Independence in 1775. Probably good in the long run that it failed, otherwise, the USA would have to deal with Quebec and their language issues.

by hal 9000

Fusion rather than Fission. The Fusion is a controlled reaction of Atomic particles for nondestructive purposes while the second is chain reaction that once set off can not be controlled until the energy has expended itself this is always accompanied with a largish mushroom shaped cloud arising from the initial detonation point. :)

Nuclear Fusion is used in every Linear Accelerator and just about every hospital with a Nuclear Medicine Department has at the very least one of these and more often than not several. They use very low grade materials with little to no long term adverse affects. Even the waste is always a very short Half Life substance which is easily stored and has very few uses.

Fission on the other hand is a totally different thing and I very seriously doubt that there are all that many students studding it in Canada as the country lacks the ability to produce Military Grade Materials. Even the very little Plutonium that is produced by the Uranium Reactors that are used in Canada is of a very low quality and would need a massive amount of refining to even come close to being called Weapons Grade, it really would be more expensive to make and would be much cheaper to buy the necessary Raw Materials that are produced in such vast amounts by the "Fast Breeder Type Reactors."

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

That the Canadian Government will also be paying for replacement reactors when the existing ones reach the end of their working lives? :)

After all you can not trust Private Company who's only interest is in the Bottom line to follow every safety protocol with out question can you? And you certainly could not trust them in replacing a end of life reactor with something new and not have every safety protocol followed let alone the right type of reactor installed could you?

After all why use a U Reactor when you can make so much more money from a Plutonium Fast Breeder Reactor which just doesn't offer the same type of output as a U Reactor.

While you did mention Medical Isotopes no doubt in Canada they also Dope Silicon for the Electronics Industry as well because they have the right type of Reactors which from my limited understanding are not available in the US in any large numbers.

Col ]:)

by jamesrl

No one could invade US OR Canada.

Even in the deep dark days of the Soviet Union, while they could use nuclear weapons to attack North America, they couldn't mount a conventional invasion.

The Soviets did not possess a "conventional" aircraft carrier, they had a mainly helicopter one with a few jump jets(about 20). Canada has 140 much more capable fighter bombers(F/A 18s) that could carry anti ship missles. The Soviet Navy did not have the amphibious assualt capacity to carry more than 3000 troops to battle - Canada could muster 10x that number in case of national emergency(about 65,000 in armed forces, plus about 50,000 in reservers/militia, minus all the support staff, generals etc). The Soviet navy could dominate an area, but would not be able to stick around if they were in range of land based strike aircraft.

The only other countries with full deck(not jump jet) carriers are France and Argentina(not sure if its still operating). You need to own the airspace before you launch an invasion.

Yes, I have wargamed this scenario.

Canada, and the US are simply too far from other major combatants to be attacked. You would have to have an incredible navy to mount such an effort, and the only country that could is the US.

James

by hal 9000

To prevent a handful of religious zealots form launching the 9-11 attack did they?

And even after the 9-11 attack there was no solid target for any of them either even if their destination could have been reprogrammed at short notice and here I do mean the big long range ones that pack so much fire power into such a small package.

Before things like that are of any use to you, you need a target for them and currently one doesn't exist. :p

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

That would only involve a name change for the illegals as after any invasion they would be legal non-combatants escaping a military conflict. I doubt it would help to stem the tide but in all probability would only increase it.

Col ]:)

by jamesrl

Dafe can chime in any time.....

The Ontario government owns the company that provides power for Ontarians. Same in the other provinces that have reactors, Quebec and New Brunswick. But they did try to privatize but the conservatives were kicked out before it went private. There was one site with a number of reactors that was leased to a private company. It is now much more efficient than the "public" reactors.

Canada chose the Canadian CANDU designs for a number of reasons, including supporting their own industry, chosing a safe design and contiuing to maintain the skillsets of Canadians in nuclear energy.

Some of the earlier reactors are being refurbished, but its not without controversy as they are continually over time and budget. Meanwhile some of the private reactors operators are also renewing their reactors but handling it much more efficiently.

In terms of operating costs, the CANDU is inexpensive to run compared to a fast breeder, and thats why Korea and China bought them. But the big cost is the cost of heavy water. Heavy water is not manufactured per se - its a natural occuring event where you get an extra molecule, and it occurs in parts per billion - so think how much water you have to go through to get enough heavy water for a nuclear plant.... So the capital costs are larger, the operating costs smaller.

The newer designs(not yet built) are looking at using less heavy water and slightly enriched uranium - check out www.aecl.ca and look at the ACR project. http://www.aecl.ca/index.asp?menuid=21&layid=3&csid=358&miid=519

I was aware of some of the other work at Chalk River, including use of the research reactors for materials research. I understand the space shuttle tiles were tested there.

James

by jamesrl

Canada did have some gaping holes in policy that it was slow to close.

In the 80s we had a lot of immigrants from Portugal, who claimed refugee status. They claimed that they were Jehovah's Witnesses and that they were persecuted at home for their faith, so bingo, instant approved claim. But there were far too many of them. The government kinda looked the other way for years, knowing it was a scam but not caring.

It may take time, but if you are an immigrant and are convicted of criminal activity, you will eventually be deported.

Canada doesn't invite illegals. But we have enough "legitimate" immigration and allow a fair amount of refugees.

James

by computer dude

... that it was clear the nuclear weapons were to deter an invasion. A terrorist strike is not exactly an invasion, is it? Our country is not going to be defeated by terrorist strikes.

Would religious zealouts invade our country for the purpose of a take over if they knew that the consequence would be a nuclear winter?

by hal 9000

If he had any troops left at his disposal that where not required as reserves and then appoint one of his buddies from Enron to run all of Canada's infrastructure and that would open the doors to Free US TRADE. :)

But it would only be a short term thing as the people concerned would destroy the goose that laid the Golden Egg in no time at all. :D

Col ]:)

by jamesrl

Why would he want all those new Democrats - it would unbalance the whole electoral process. Seeing as Canada would represent roughly 10% of the electoral college, and that its been relatively close over many recent elections, adding Canada to the US would seem to ensure Democrats get elected forever.

James

by computer dude

And speaking of Democrats, whatever became of the mass exodus of pissed off liberals to Canada after the election?

by hal 9000

They are only interested in destroying as much as possible and if you help them to do it so much the better for them.

In their Zealot thoughts they already have their ticket into heaven so what does it matter who they take along with them?

No they will not invade your country but they could do serious damage along the way that made 9-11 look like a child's temper tantrum. If they where to take out a few Nuclear Power Generating plants that are Plutonium based just how long would it take for the contaminated areas of your country to become livable again? And once this had been done who would want or need to invade?

Col ]:)

by jamesrl

I know that the way the War of 1812 is taught in the US, the cause for war is always the British stopping US ships and seizing sailors for the Royal Navy. Truth is that many of those sailors were British citizens...

In Canada, we learn about the Munroe doctrine, the Warhawks(southerners mostly) and opportunists who saw British involvement in the Napoleonic wars as a chance to snatch Canada while Britain was otherwise occupied. As Napoleon was defeated, the negotiations for peace accelerated.

But not all of the US supported the war. New England, who had built up a lot of trade with both Canada and England, for the most part opposed the war. There were those in upstate New York who continued to trade goods with Canadians even though the main city closest to them(Kingston) was actively building warships(some with US nails).

Ottawa was chosen as the nations capital in part because it was not close to the US border. Ottawa really came into its own because of the Rideau canal, built to enable another trade and transportation route away from the border.

Clearly the war affected Canada more than the US.

James

by computer dude

One other interesting but not taught fact about New England is that there was a potent succession movement during the time frame of the War of 1812. Then ironically those same states raped the south 50 years later because of the same thing.

by computer dude

How would you suggest that I help these zealots? Because helping Islamic terrorist attack us is not on my list of things to do.

Interesting how you've taken a discussion about the need for nuclear protection and used it against me by suggesting that I'm somehow helping the terrorists. Clever.

by jamesrl

We had one wag selling an instant Canadian kit and they were selling - recording of O Canada, Canadian flag T shirt and badge for your backpack etc. They sold like hotcakes, but it turns out the buyers were mostly Republicans buying them to tease their Democrat friends.

We did get a few deserters from the US. Now Vietnam was one thing - if you were drafted and came to Canada, you had a claim. But these people signed on the dotted line to voluntarily join the US military, and nothing in the contract said they got to pick and chose which wars they would fight in.

I didn't support the invasion of Iraq myself, but if I had joined the military I understand that I go where they send me. The Canadian courts, at least on the first round, think so too. The appeals have already been launched.

We get a few college professors and so on moving up but not many political types. We do politics differently here -when some parties have tried to use "American" style attack ads they usually backfire. Most US immigrants to Canada these days are working for a multinational company.

James

by oz_media

Col you're right, now you know why I am not a nuclear scientist! :D Ka-plowie!

Deepsand, I still don't know what or why you are trying to get at. IS it public sentiment? I don't know, care or would even begin to care if it was.

What if it WASN'T? So what, nobody is speaking out against it. NObody cares, nobody is trying to reverse such a decision.

In my original post I VERY clearly defined how it was enacted by City Council and has little effect but a couple of happy signs at city entrances. Vancouver has always been a nuclear free zone, what sentimentis required for th ecity to officially declare it a nuke free zone? Are they bullying pepople in to it or something? Perhaps we are being controlled by our city councils because they enact publicly acceptable policies without a vote or something? What is the objective you are seeking here? It certainly isn't to aquire information, you have a search engine I'm sure.

by oz_media

I am the first one to laugh at the dog and pony show we call a government. Canada's is a farce just like England's, Australia's, US etc.

All politicians are a living breathing farce and an embarrassment to their respective country, unless they do it all my way,

THat still doesn't detract in any way from the question asked and the answer I provided.

NO...Vancouver doesn't have nuclear power, in fact it is declared a nuclear free zone, we have no need for nuclear power plants.

Is this untrue, we DO have a need for nuclear power now?

by liame

Unfortunately it is far from obvious that that it was a facetious remark. Irony is sorely neglected on that side of the pond.

by jamesrl

If you accept the premise that BC needs the rest of Canada, the rest of Canada needs nuclear power.

Ontario produces 25% of its power through nuclear, we've maxed out hydro-electric, and if we didn't use nuclear, we'd have to burn coal, oil or natural gas, contributing substantially to pollution.

James

by deepsand

Most Americans do NOT use the word "dude" in the manner you allude to.

The usage that you cite is urban slang. One should not assume that such colloquial usage will be universally understood or accepted.

The word was originally used as a term of disparagement.

For many Americans, the word carries a negative connotation; to address them as such is an insult.

by oz_media

Was oringinally used as a term to describe someone obsessed with his attire. Not exactly a nagative statement at all. And it has been used to refer to 'guys' for enough years now that you are VERY well aware of it's use, especialy in a freakin' alias!

Should we then be lead to believe that you are a person who is a bottomless hole of finely crushed gravel?

Find something real to argue for a change.

Here's a good description of DUDE as used in America, quite clearly a slang phrase for 'guy':
http://www.randomhouse.com/wotd/index.pperl?date=20010621

by oz_media

Forgive him. Some people who seem to have been locked in thier basements with thier computers during the last 30 years and are completely unaware of common social slang.

Australians know what it means, Asians and Middle Easterners know what it means, Europeans know, we have all seen television and movies and, in the context it is used in his alias, it is most definitely clear what the meaning is.

Someone has just had a dirty diaper for a few weeks now and is getting quite tiring. OR

Someone's basement door just automatically unlocked after 30 years and they are seeing the world anew and completely unaware of society. But I'd put my money on the first one, just a dick with a dirty diaper.

by Member 25348569

What he was saying - at least what I read - is that having a nuclear power industry does leave open the possibility of a terrorist act that would be as devastating as a nuclear strike. Blow up a nuclear power plant and you will have areas of your country uninhabitable for years. That is how you "help" the terrorists.

In the same way, if it wasn't for the fact that the Twin Towers were the size of a small city, 9-11 would not have been so spectacularly bad.

Neil

by computer dude

Coal is a major pollutant with negative impacts on the environment. Should the US have a coal industry?
Guns can be stolen by theives and used to kill people. Should the US have a gun industry?
Vehicles can be stolen and used as a getaway car. Should the US have an automobile industry?

Wake up and smell the jet fuel. There's a whole world full of people looking for ways to do us harm.

Any type of industry is going to have risks involved. My point is that if we "give up" the nukes, we're asking for a foreign attack. If you don't think that's true, get your arms from around the tree and stop singing Imagine and step into 2005.

by Member 25348569

Picture the scene:

Robin Hood is at the archery contest and we KNOW that he will win it and be captured by the Sherrif of Nottingham. All of the spectators are tense. Maid Marian is at the side of the Sherrif wishing that Robin were not there but she can see through his disguise of his hat pulled low over his eyes. No-one else can - yet!

There are only two left to fight it out for the title of Champion Archer of Nottingham.

The Sherrif's Champion steps up to the mark and lets an arrow fly - whoosh - clunk into the centre of the target. The crowd gasps! How is Robin going to win, now?

Robin steps up to the mark and smiles - ching! - at Maid Marian and draws back the arrow along his cheek. He sights at the target and we KNOW that he will split the Champion's arrow in two.

Whoosh! Gasp! Urgh! Oh, sh:t! The arrow flies straight into the left eye of Maid Marian.

The Arrow: You
The Target: The Point

Missed it, didn't you?

Never mind. Just read the posts again and assume that neither Col nor myself are trying any anti-American rhetoric and think about it.

Neil

by jdclyde

As I recall, there wasn't a single country that stood up and said that there weren't any WMD.

Saddam did everything to make people think that he DID have them, as ways to keep the neighboring countries in line.

WMD also covered the chemical weapons that he had already used. How could you not think he not only had them but would use them again?

And only kind of a little sort of may have slightly broken sanctions? Remember for the Gulf war (the reasons for the sanctions) it wasn't America that was attacked, and that is who the sanctions were in place to protect.

by jamesrl

I tend to think of the attack on Quebec the way I think of the New Orleans campaign in the War of 1812, or the North African Campaign in WWII.

I don't think there was a real intent to take it and keep it. But if the American army could capture it quickly and fade away, the British would have to bulk up the forces there, draining troops away from some of the other campaigns.

Many of the veteran soldiers in the Quebec campaign had fought with the British to take Quebec from France a few decades earlier - Washington and Arnold had both been on the campaign.

As for the language issues, there is some historical documentation that says the acts of Britain in 1760 to allow Quebec to keep its religion, language, and civil code legal system help push some rabid anti-catholic New Englanders towards revolution. They didn't want to see the day when Quebec joined the colonies and added their distinct voice to the group. While I enjoy having Quebec in Canada, I can see their perspective.

James

by tomsal

Computer guided death from thousands of miles away hitting the target with accuracy that just 60 years ago would never have been believed even possible.

Contour mapping, source-programmable guidance, laser targeting, digital signals, satellite communications, GPS guidance, radio communication, etc. etc.

Just some of the technologies that come into play with ICBM's over the years and currently.

And this isn't technology? LOL

When's the last time your computer launched a missle that guided itself 4500 miles and released 200 megatons worth of MIRV warheads that laid waste to an entire city and about 5-10 mile radius thereafter?

by hal 9000

So if one was launched it would lay waste between 7 and 9 individual sites. All with Silicon Based Technology.

But they are fairly inaccurate things as the individual warheads will only come into about 50 Meters of its intended target and the ones on the ICBM are not the tiny little ones that where used on Japan at the end of WW11 but much larger so I would hazard a guess that they would take out a far bigger area than the 5 - 10 mile radius that you stated. :)

Remember that these things are "Air Burst" and mainly rely on the concussion forces released to do the damage the radio activity is only an after thought with the older units as all the fission material isn't consumed during the detonation of the unit. The newer ones can do far more damage with very little if any residual radiation after the event and although these produce a extremely hot reaction at the point of detonation that may only extend for a 5 - 10 mile radius where everything within that area is fussed into a mass of melted silica which eventually will cool down and turn into a pool of solid glass. But that would only be a very small area of devastation in comparison to the real damage that has been done. :D

The actually warheads are really extremely simple things and even the control circuits that produce a controlled implosion are no where new technology. :)

But the delivery systems are very complex and I suppose because they are a disposable item some may consider them as a non issue. And be able to say that there is virtually no technology involved in an atomic weapon, but they are missing the entire point of the whole thing as they seem to think that all you do is press a button and the ICBM does the rest. Even the microprocessor which drives the thing into a sub orbital trajectory has to be far more robust than any current PC that is available on the market and have multiple redundant systems which would make even the most advanced current computer look like a second rate child's play toy. :D

Of course things like the Cruise Missile with all of its anti detection systems and anti destruction systems are actually far more complex play toys with if anything even more complex guidance systems that are extremely complex, but that isn't technology because it again is a disposable item whose only job is to get the warhead to its detonation location, so from that prospective there is very little technology involved in the actual warhead but a hell of a lot is involved in the delivery system which many just do not want to think about. :)

It really would be interesting to see one cross a major city and avoid all the High Rise buildings there but of course this will never happen because they are never allowed near one of these places and even if they are to hit this city they fly in at virtually ground level and then only pop up for the detonation cycle so they appear to drop straight down from the sky. :D

Perhaps we could get together and get this guy to deactivate one that we have set to take off and allow him 5 minutes to mess it up to such an extent that it can not take off. What do you think? At best he might get one of the covers off in that time before he was killed by the wash from the motor/s as they fired up. :D

Col ]:)

by tomsal

Unfortunately I think disarming our nuke arsenal would be like taking the teeth out of a well trained guard dog. Without the threat that the dog can bite, your suddenly left quite vulnerable to the bully down the street who still has his vicious guard dog with all his canines.

The only way we could remove our nukes is if every other country in the world who has them did the same at about the same time. And the chance of something like that happening is less than my chance to win a $100 million lottery.

by hal 9000

We build a great big self propagating computer and turn the control of every WMD over to it? :D

I'll put forward the Name of Skynet as a possible name and we then let it control all of the nuclear weapons in the world. :)

Col ]:)

by tomsal

I am Hanz and I am Franz and we are here to pump...you up......oh wait wrong character... ;)

Anyway cool...as long as Skynet isn't run by Windows. ;)

(Talk about a new meaning to blue screen of DEATH)

;)

by jck

get in on writing software for it? If I'm gonna have a machine looming over me with control of all the worlds nuclear weapons, I wanna write the routines to control cargo shipments of Guinness to my house once a week too....or at least, to the coast near my house :D

by deepsand

Since you are a resident of the area, it was reasonable to allow that you might know the background of the city proclamation.

If you were unable to answer the question, simply saying so would have sufficed.

by montgomery gator

You seem to know your history. The British policies you mentioned that allowed Quebec to keep its language, etc. apparently worked quite well in 1775, since the invading American colonists were unable to convince the people of Quebec to join the revolution. If Britain had not raised taxes in the colonies (to help pay for the French and Indian War), most likely the 13 colonies would not have rebelled.

by jamesrl

Well I wasn't a Computer science major, I was a political science major and contrary to Oz's opinion, I have known some great selfless public servants who were politicians(and some bad people too). I did take a few history courses out of interest.

I know the 1812 stuff better than the American Revolution, because I know the battlegrounds, have visited the forts etc. I grew up near an Indian Reserve(Six Nations) where the Iroquois war hero(to the British) Joseph Brant settled after the revolution.

I've walked the Plains of Abraham where the British defeated the French, and both opposing generals were mortally wounded.

I've even been to Platsburg in Upstate New York where the British invaded to attempt to scuttle the American ships being built for the War of 1812. There were even battles as close as 10 miles from the house where I grew up, and I've traced the path of the American forces through the farms where I played as a boy.

I also gained a love of history from my grandparents - scottish descendants who fled during the highland clearances. And from a couple of great high school teachers. We did take American history as well, and I remember well the discussions and role playing around the Civil War.

I treat history as a living thing - we gain perspective on recent events as new information surfaces or we change our perspective. Its instructional.

James

by oz_media

Think about it, you asked and I offered an answer to what I thought you were asking by saying that Nuclear power has never been needed IT'S A NON ISSUE! What part of that DON"T you get?

You then asked again how city council has taken it upon themselves to make this declaration. Uh, IT'S A NON ISSUE!! If it WAS something we NEEDED and city council had declared us a nue free zone, then there WOULD be a need for public opinion. If you've never had it and nobody wants it, it is NOT an issue to be discussed or contested, i just IS.

Again, if you have never had NOR needed cars, would it be outrageous for a city to say it was a car free zone without public opinion or referrendum or whatever to support it? NO, it's NOT an issue. WHY do you INSIST on making EVERYTHINGsuch an issue in your posts, not just here but everywhere lately. You DIG for issues to create so you can contest them. When the day comes that Vancouver decides it needs nuclear power, there WILL be a public inquiry as to nuclear power plants and if Vancouver wants them.

Now if the city had said, "Proudly supporting nuclear weapons since 1946", then the public probably WOULD speak out against it. IN this case it's not a matter of concensus or public opinion, it just IS because we don't generate nuclear power and don't build nuclea arms, hterefoe we are declared a nuclear free zone. I don't see what you don't grasp here, it's pretty simple.

As for saying I didn't know. First of al I didn't understand our question, I figured you were just asking if we had nuclear power here, NO we don't.

But when I said the city coucil posted signs saying we were a nuke fre zone, you implied there should be some form of public inqury as to whether we were or not. I DID answer you as best I could, it never has and therefore just IS.

I said "IS it public sentiment? I don't know, care or would even begin to care if it was. "

I DID say I didn't know, and it isn't discussed nor an issue for discussion in Vancouver, if it was people WOULD be speaking out against it, but WHY ? I have NEVER had ANYONE mention ANYTHING about either Vancouver being declared nuke free or not, why would even the city question it?

by oz_media

But they don't need it in Vancouver and therefotre are declared a nuke free zone, NOT country, ZONE.

Where's' the headwrecker in this?

Canada doesn't produce nuclear weapons, we have no need to nor would people be too quick to accept it.

Canadians don't like nukes as a rule.

When there is a need for power, I am sure nobody has an issue with a nuclear power plant if it is done so without possible harm to thisands of people. C'mo James you know Canadians! As long as PEOPLE aren't effected, nobody gives a crap.

by oz_media

The government runs the country and you have no say in it and even a democratic voting process seems rigged at the best of times, just like any government really.

BUT, the US government and it's people are MUCH more closely tied together than Canada's for example (England it's 100% govrernment decisions, people just live with it).

In Canada people grudgingly vote and all of them say, it doesn't make any difference who they vote for 'team X' will win anyway. But when the government acts up, all hel breaks lose and Canadians stand up to be counted. This is noticed sometimes and actually does have effect.

In the case of Clinton, the entire nation was involved and played a role in determining the outcome fo his destiny. When the president does something you all stand up as you are more politically focused as a nation than most others.

In the case of GWB, everyone just went to bat for him and started flaming and chastizing any country or person that didn't support it blindly and actually said, "HEY, what's going on with that?"

People ignored and defended his deceit, his pathetic public speaking ability (when first in office) that proved him to be unsure and a liar even when based on FBI profiling techniques. Good enough to send a man to jail but completely ignored in the pres.

I thought that out of any nation on Earth, yours would have been the most adamant about such BS and put him against a wall. But barely a peep, "we are saving our lives, would you let YOUR children and families die?" Yessssss maaaaaassssterrrrr! :D

by deepsand

As for your repeated analogy, one does not ban that which is merely unnecessary; one bans, in advance of its becoming realized, that which is deemed to be a possible threat.

Now, have a brew on me & lighten up.

by hal 9000

People like Bin Laden. You kill innocents and destroy peoples homes who are noncombatants and expect them not to be even slightly pissed off. But when the same thing happened to your country eg 9-11 the whole country rose up as one and demand retribution quite rightly I might add but you have to be careful in how you get what you want. :)

The more people you disenfranchise the more recruits you will find flocking to organizations that just plain and simple do not like your country one little bit. Sure not every one directly affected will join these organizations but there will also be impressionable people who see things that they do not like and consider that their only alternative is to join these organizations in an attempt to destroy you and your country as you are all the same in their brain washed eyes at least.

In Iraq prior to the invasion just about everyone hated the Bath Party with a vengeance and now we see that hatred being transfered to your country to a great extent and to the COW to a lesser extent as well. The events that happened in Bali and Spain where all "SOFT TARGETS" designed to do maximum damage at little or no expense to those involved.

Your country is helping these organizations in a couple of ways by what is considered as their heavy handed approach in Iraq right now and even if the action is sanctioned by the current administration there it is the US Troops who are mainly caring it out and the Administration is seen as nothing more than US puppets admittedly by those who where previously in power and those who where so suppressed that they dare not speak out for fear of their lives by the Administration that was overthrown by the invasion.

As much as Saddam was a nasty piece of work he did hold the country with its various ethnic groups in check and was able to control all of the plotting against him by taking out those who where capable of leading a revolt against him. Currently the Troops on Iraq are given poor intelligence and do things all wrong so they are only producing greater hatred of them by the citizens there and then some of these people will join groups who's only concern is to see the destruction of their most hated enemy the USA.

The USA on the other hand is only too willing to help these people attack it and allows them into the country and even trains them for their missions every one of those who flew aircraft in the 9-11 attack was trained in the US to fly.

Now I personally do not want to see the USA destroyed one iota as the very fact of that destruction would require another country to float to the surface as a "World Power" and currently only China could fill that role. But while the US wants to go it alone without world wide support they are running the risk of increased attacks like the one of 9-11 but next time they could be far better planned and executed which personally scares the crap out of me. You where very lucky that those involved in the 9-11 attacks had a fixation on the WTC and ignored the possibilities of better targets that would have resulted in truly massive destruction and laid waste massive areas of mainland USA.

While we try we have to understand that we can not stop the money to these organizations and we just have to learn to live with them but what we do not have to do is to encourage people to join them. What makes you think that what upsets you will not upset others?

If it is unacceptable to fly aircraft into buildings killing lots of people why is it acceptable to destroy peoples houses in another country?

Basically what I'm saying is if there is something happening that you do not like what makes you think that it is acceptable to do exactly the same thing in another country under the guise of self protection?

If you get pissed off by something do you not expect others to feel exactly the same thing when they experience similar events?

You have the targets freely available on any maps of your country marked out quite nicely and you have to defend these targets what you do not have to do is to encourage people to join these groups as people like Bin Laden are not willing to actually do these things but rely on others who they have brainwashed to do them for them so if you know you can not stop the funding the next best thing is to minimize the conscripts who willingly want to join.

Now we all know that the head of these organizations are unreachable so instead of removing the head we have to try a different course of action remove the body from the head and the head is incapable of doing anything that doesn't endanger itself which it is unwilling to do and even if it was willing it is only a few people that would be capable of launching one attack which may or may not be prevented but once it has succeeded there can be no follow up.

So what would be better 200 individual attacks or 200,000 and counting attacks? With no end in sight.

Col ]:)

by oz_media

I honestly doubt there is a BAN placed on anything, but perhaps a PRIDE in what IS.

Much like saying #1 Sunniest city in Canada, well that would last until it started to rain too much anyway.

Vancouver a nuclear free zone.

Beautiful British Columbia

California - The Golden State

etc.

by roger99a

is keep the Russians from invading Germany. They may have kept the Canadians from invading Montana, too, but I have no evidence for that.

by tomsal

So I know I was lying on the side of "extremely conservative" in my estimates.

Yes I know they have multiple warheads, in fact that's what MIRV means Multiple Independent Reactionary Vehicle (MIRV). The accuracty I was referring to was on the travel to the target, you know getting there from a launch orgination point literally thousands of miles away. And this is something that FAR exceeded the technology of WWII.

In actuality accuracy of the actual point of detonation isn't even really attained or cared about getting 100% precise. Let's face it, why squabble over a few hundred meters to the left or right here and there when the weapon hitting the target will kill everything for miles around where ever it hits anyway?

I do believe the closer estimate would be like a 100-200 mile swath of destruction.

But again, I actually have a book at home with the real info in it perhaps I'll post some stats.

Either way, the original post was really just a sarcastic joke at "I want to talk about technology not politics"!. lol

by Member 25348569

Back in the Cold War days, not all of the Multiple Independent Re-entry Vehicles in an ICBM contained warheads. Numbers of them were decoys which returned the same radar signature of a "real" warhead. The destruction would probably just be a mere 1000 square miles

It's likely that any anti-missile system that doesn't get a modern ICBM before it "pups" won't be a lot of use as it will be overloaded. Still, it's something for your Defense Industry to continue to rip you all off to "develop".

One thought. If, as is claimed, the US development of an ABM system is for defense only, surely the correct thing to do would be to make the technology available so that any country that wants it can build a similar system. YOU'RE not going to fire at them, are you?

Happy days!

by oz_media

the sound off on TR was more what I was reflecting on. I can see a very divided left and right in th US, it seems many people judge by political affiliation befor eeven asking someone's name. It reminds me of when dogs sniff each other, two Americans bump heads and the first topic of interest is poitical affiliation. To 'sniff' each other out.

I see a very hard core extreme on both sides and it often results in people just hating th eother because of what it represents, more than what has actually been said or done. I definitely don't envy this 'measurement of character'in your society. As I have said before, Canadians are far from infatuated with politics, many Canadians don't even know when election day is, until they get an afternoon off to go vote.

But you should have seen the flame wars and hissy fits people had here when Bush wasn't backed 100%, it was Anti-American, Anti-Bush, Terrorist even, pretty sad and pathetic display really.

Sorry for the generalization, i just expected the whole country to be up against Bush due to his deceptions but they weren't. TR was full of blind defenders of the faith.

by hal 9000

Skynet would have to be a Windose based system so all the third party software could run and clash on it. Or else just how would we ever see the Blue Screen of Death again? :)

As it would involve Bureaucrats from many nations to setup it in all likely hood would end up being a hotch potch of Windows, Unix, Linux, OS2 and just for good measure a bit of DOS thrown to totally mess the entire system up completely.

Or better still the whole thing could be written in basic. :D

Col ]:)