Discussion Locked

So What is the DMC's problem - with GWB visiting Iraqi that takes some guts

0 helpful
156 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

OK GWB went off to Bagdad to thank the troops - and celebrate Thanksgiving. Great treat for those serving in the theater when the Commander and Chief comes.

So then the DMC - starts crying - "It was all political." - "It was for next years election." - Yadada - But at the same time they had two over in Afghan - Billary and someone else - I guess she was there to AID the Morale of the Troops by going down on each of them?

The DMC - has nothing better to do the critize some other polictal party for doing the same thing they are doing... I think they are PO'ed for being Upstaged - by a better man

156 replies

by dbertsche

Jim,

What did you expect from the Democraps? It was so predictable I called it before they ever said anything.

I think most people will see through their feeble attempts to tear down Bush. They are really pathetic.

by cactus pete

I, as a citizen of the USA, consider any sitting president who knowingly travels into more than simply 'hostile' lands - in this case a country with which we are still currently AT WAR - to be of poor judgement.

On the eleventh of September, 2001, the currently sitting president was 'kept safe' by flying around in Airforce One to several undisclosed places. On Thanksgiving, he flew this plane into an airport known for having large aircraft downed. He risked himself, yes. That would normally be fine with me. But he risked the president of the United States of America. That's just not sound judgement.

by dbertsche

So I suppose when FDR went to Europe during WWII that was poor judgement too? I suppose when Eishenhower went to Korea that was poor judgement too? I suppose when LBJ went to Viet Nam that was poor judgement too? How about Clinton going to Kosovo, poor judgement there as well right?

As long as the proper security measures are taken I really don't see anything wrong with the Commander-in-chief visiting the troops in the field.

Unless you're prepared to site all the examples listed above as poor judgement find something else to criticize Bush about.

by cactus pete

The president of the United States has a duty to fulfill. This person should not be allowed to take such a risk.

Yes, I cede that other may have travelled when they should not have. But I find it inexcusable for any sitting president, as I had stated, to fly into harm's way.

There is no security measure that could have been taken to ease my thoughts of this. If there were, they sure should have been taking these steps long ago to stop the violence that is oozing about Iraq.

You don't see generals on the front lines of a war for a reason. The commander in chief should be much farther away than that.

Note, I am not arguing the political side of this. I am saying that the president should not do such things.

by maxwell edison

You compared being "kept safe by flying around in Air Force One" to "flying this plane into an airport known for having large aircraft downed".

You haven't considered that the former was a situation out of control, (being controlled by others - terrorists), while the latter was a situation considered much under control.

Even the Democrat Party presidential opponents weren't opposed to it. (Although they didn't really have much choice.)

Candidate John Edwards, said through his spokeswoman, "I believe President Bush's visit to the troops was a nice thing to do. But unless this visit is followed by a change in policy that brings in our allies and truly internationalizes the effort, our mission is not going to be successful."

"I don't have anything political or partisan to say about it," said Democrat Joe Lieberman. "There are days when you have to say, we're not Republicans, we're not Democrats. We are Americans. "

John Kerry said, "I thought it was terrific. I think it's the right thing for a president to do."

Personally, I think it was a great thing to do. What a boost it must have been for the troops serving there, especially the ones who met him.

by cactus pete

What level of threat to the office of the president is acceptable?

Iraq is not under enough 'control' for me to go there. Sure, the president gets screens of men between him and bullets, but his plane could have been hit, if not downed. What a terrible thing to give our enemies - the thought that they really can get at us...

It was too risky.

Maybe he should have had a live two way broadcast via satellite to the troops. He could have reached more of them that way, anyway. That's just a quick idea off of the top of my head.... I'd think that the real planners could have come up with something at least as good and at least as safe.

A lot of people who don't like the man say that it's too bad he wasn't shot down. I can't subscribe to that, either. He just plain should not have gone.

by jardinier

it's exactly the sort of thing I would do: spontaneous and unexpected. (That's Julian the person speaking, not President Julian).

Was it a good thing to do? I haven't read any argument here that states other than it proved to be a good thing to do.

Was it a bad thing to do? Again I have not read any statement which convinces me it was a bad thing to do.

Whas it staged for propaganda? Well surely it is the prerogative of a government or its leader to use propaganda to further its cause.

Was it declared beforehand to be an investigative study of the state of the war? No it was not.

So it appears to me that (1) it was a good thing to do (2) it was not a bad thing to do (3) any discussion of ulterior motives remain speculative.

by jimhm

It was better than Billary's comments to the troopes that "The People of American do not support your efforts... " or something like that.

Plus - You would think all the GWB haters would of loved to see him shot down. Gee - then who are the republicans going to run? Right now you got about 8 Dem's running - none of them have a similiar voice - So that tells me that the Democraps don't have a clue about what they want to do.

Yes - you are correct about the president should be protected and not take adverse risks - and yes the risks were high going there - but I think it was well protected - I believe that keeping it out of the Leftest Media made excellent sense - I also feel it was well worth it - and gave those brave men and women serving something special - and a shot in the arm.

by maxwell edison

.
If it's too dangerous for a President to go to this war zone, is it also too dangerous for the Vice-President? How about a cabinet member? What about the Senators and Representatives? At what point is the person expendable enough to get a pass on the risk factor, and who should make such a determination?

by cactus pete

It's not really what I'm addressing, however. I do believe that the office of the president is clearly past that line.

Let me just say that, of course, I wish every positive thing possible for the troops, especially those deployed. I just don't feel that the risk was proper.

by john_wills

I don't like Dubya - though I might have voted for him had I been a U.S. citizen. The Democrats like him even less. Most people vote on a touchy-feely basis, which they often mistake for a bread-and-butter basis - adequate brad and butter touching them and making them feel good. Dubya has done quite a lot of things that make people feel good, however irrationally. The Thanksgiving caper was the latest, and really quite appropriate for the Comander in Chief, at least if those security precautions were all really taken. So more people are likely to vote Dubya come November. So the Democrats are annoyed: they do not detachedly watch the karmic pattern emerge, and they have no principles suitable for changing the pattern, so they get annoyed, exactly what tey should not do, for their own sakes.

by jimhm

You're correct about most of the American voters - Touchy, Feely is he someone you would let your daughter date. Never look at the hard issues that need answered with hard solutions.

It's a shame - we Americans need to take responsibility back into our own hands for our elected leaders, and elect them on the basis of what they can do about the current and future issues that will present themselfs.

Gore - to me was a spineless man - during his 8 years as VP - he did nothing. Yes - he was the second most important person - but did he do anything that can be remembered? OH yea - he invented the Internet...

I agree - Americans need to get away from the touchy feely (look what happened to us under the Peanut farmer - Jimmy Carter)... Nice guy, very intelligant, some good social ideas - but just not a leader.. Was a Nuc researcher in the Navy - those guys were locked away - and went to work.

Hey - I never heard GWB called Dubya? Is that stand for something?

by maxwell edison

I'm not sure who started calling GWB "Dubya", but the earliest use of it that I've seen was from columnist Molly Ivans, an extreme left-winger (a border-line socialist, even). Molly Ivans writes for the Fort Worth Star Telegram, and has a nationally syndicated opinion column. Molly Ivans was a huge Ann Richards supporter, is a Democrat party drum beater, is a Republican party critic, and has been most critical of G.W. Bush for years, going back to his earliest days as Texas governor. Ivans referred to GWB as "Dubya" when he was first running against (and defeated) Ann Richards in her run for re-election as Texas governor.

"Dubya" is the "Texas drawl" way to pronounce the president's middle initial, and its intended use has its roots in disrespect. Even though it's probably used, at times, by those who like the president, it's almost exclusively used by those who dislike (or despise) him in an attempt to somehow reduce him in stature.

by jimhm

Us northerners - got to hit us on the head with a brick sometimes...

by dbertsche

Disagree totally, if we followed your logic to it's ultimate conclusion the president would never leave the whitehouse! Perhaps we should stow him away in a bunker to keep him away from all the evil in the world. Remember JFK was shot and killed in Dallas and Reagan was shot at in D.C.

I believe anyone who is elected president does so knowing there is always going to be risk assoicated with the job. Reasonable methods are employed to insure their safety but one only has to look at the recent sniper killings in the D.C. area to know that none of us are totally safe.

As far as your idea about the president appearing on closed circuit, I was in Viet Name and if that had happened there it wouldn't have meant much to me or my fellow soldiers. Afterall the president has sent his fellow americans into "harm's way" for tours of duty lasting one year while he is only there for a very brief amount of time.

You also mention our enemies being able to "get at us". Didn't they already do that? Isn't that one of the reasons we're fighting terrorism? What would have happened if one of the planes on 9/11 had gotten to D.C. and hit the whitehouse? Thank God it didn't happen but the president doesn't have to travel across the pond to be in danger.

I salute him for going and thought it was the right thing to do, they also took the proper precautions and insured the cat would not get out of the bag concerning the details. Was there some risk? Sure but perhaps not as much as you might think. Air Force 1 is well equipped and I'm sure there was fighter protection the whole time.

by cactus pete

You show that an extreme is unlikely to happen, or to prevent it, we'd have to take other extremes. Well, no duh.

But all the fighters in Iraq and all the precautions of AF1 don't really matter squat to the RPG shot from near the landing strip...

Yes, the terrorists 'got at us' on 9-11. But those aren't the same enemy that is over in Iraq right now, shooting at all the servicemen and women and the coalition aids. If THEY got at us, then we risk more of the populace joining in and really creating a quagmire [the term thrown in for those of you who I know just love it] over there.

The cat didn't even have to get out of the bag for this to have easily been turned to a tragedy. THAT is the point that I'm making.

If the sniper were still threatening a certain gas station, and no one had caught him yet, do you think the secret service would allow the president to tour it? Would it really matter to most people in the area who no longer get fuel at that station if he did, and survived?

Your comparisons aren't practical or at all in the scope of what happened. He shouldn't have gone.

by dbertsche

Once again I have to disagree with you. You are obviously not knowledgeable about the capabilities of AF1 or our fighters as they would be able to deflect an RPG away easily.

You make a distinction between terrorists, what difference does it make, ask someone to make that distinction when their life is being threatened.

I fully understand the point you're making, but a tradegy didn't happen and wasn't likely to happen. Once again you assume the worst is going to happen. We can't live our lives always assuming the worst thing is going to happen!

Regarding your comment about comparisons, you made the point about the president's safety, my comparisons only brought up the fact that we can not assure that any situation will be 100% safe. You calling them not practical doesn't negate the fact they happened and in our own country.

You're certainly entitled to your opinion that he shouldn't have gone but I think he should have and I'm glad he did.

by maxwell edison

...there are plenty of people who agree with your risk assessment and would conclude that it was poor judgement to expose the President to such an amount of risk, regardless of the level. And I can understand the sentiment, although I don't share it. I suppose I'm just more risk tolerant.

(Be responsible for one's self in life? Too risky, say the Dems.)

Presidents have gone to war zones before, and it's usually a huge boost for troop morale; it obviously was in this case. President Lincoln went to a war zone and gave a little address to the folks there - the Gettysburgh Address. President Johnson visited troops in Vietnam. President Bush genuinely cares about the troops over there, and he did everything he could to show them as much.

I think it was a risk well worth taking. Besides, considering all the circumstances and all the precautions that were surely taken, the risk was most likely, at best, very minimal.

by cactus pete

But this is a very different war than we've seen before. In Iraq, the resistence is now using terrorist tactics. This is the most difficult type of war against which to protect oneself.

As to risk aversion - I'm fairly liberal with it. However, I do draw the line. I don't carol through well known gang areas in Chicago to spread Christmas cheer to those less fortunate than me. But I do ride the adrenaline boost of a mountain bike down a precarious slope.

The latter might break my arm. But I've taken really good security measures to keep my life relatively safe. The former, well, a helmet won't protect me from a stray bullet that had missed its drive by target...

I don't think that many security meaures in Iraq would have been able to prevent someone from saying, "Hey look, a big plane landing - let's see if we can hit it from here."

We know this is going on, and I think the leader of this nation should consider the nation and what his office means to the citizens before trapsing off where harm is quite likely. Just as I consider my family before I venture off into the slums...

by oz_media

Iraqis were laughing at the attempt and also saw it as a US propaganda mission. If he wanted to visit Iraq and show himself as a saviour, he could have at least spoken with Iraqi's.

He was flown in under heavy cover, skirted into a special bunker/meeting room. Had a few smiles and waves for the cameras and he was gone.

Yes it is VERY moral boosting for US soldiers, unfortunately he was in and out without most soldiers even knowing he came, just the select few that circled in front of the cameras for good measure.

I don't know how many factes have to be posted regarding the US propaganda and coverup of these stories, but you should have all caught on by now.

YOU'RE NOT HEARING THE FULL STORY!!
LOOK OUTSIDE YOUR COUNTRY'S MEDIA, IT IS REPUBLICAN OWNED AND CONTROLLED WHILE BEING WHITE HOUSE CENSORED!!!

GOT IT YET!?!?!?!?

by jimhm

Come on Oz - do you really believe all that crap from CNN (Commie News Network) -

I thought you always viewed all media information before making a comment - what about FOX (or don't you get that news network) or even MSNBC - there were a few Iraqis that didn't understand, some could cared less and others that were happy he felt safe enough to travel there.

by oz_media

I wouldn't watch CNN for anything including the weather, which nobody gets right.
It was on CBC and I also saw a report on BBC online. Now I know that these stations must be paying Iraqi citizens to say these things, becuae the two Iraqi's they interviewed actually spoke in Iraqi and it was subtitled. They MUSt have been saying how happy they were to see GWB and were simply disappointed that they didn't get to sjake his hand.

CMON Jim! What's a reliable news source in the USA? I seriously doubt there is one what with almost all of them being owned and driven by Republican networks. I would never rely on the US for news, you should know that by now. I've seen the Canadian news and compared it with the US medias magical interpretations.

Sometime you will actualy see the SAME interview that was bought from a commmon source, Canadian news will show the full audio of an interview. The American version is cut and edited to remove many comments that we see here on Canadian TV.

If you can see the level of censorship by simply changing channels, that is an good indicator that I'm not getting the full story from American networks.

American news sucks completely in my mind, there's no consistency, no acuracy and too many edits to remove key comments that may cause one to see things differently. Change the channel and see what others are seeing, this may in turn help you to understand WHY people feel the way they do.

by oz_media

"in an attempt to somehow reduce him in stature."

George W Bush has no stature, unless you are a Republican. Other countries can't stand the guy, Iraq doesn't know what the hell he is doing in Iraq, the British are said and done with it, then this little publicity campaign where he saw NO people of Iraq, heard NO voice of the Iraqi people. Back door in Back door out (damn, I'll resist)and that was that. Few select troops get to see him ramble through his We're winning for the people propaganda and that's that.
Not exactly Bob Hope, at least he would have been worth watching.

by mrbill-

would have been some beautiful girls, but in this day and age that would have been inappropriate. Unless he took some Chippendales for the female GIs.

by oz_media

Fill the place with poon-tang and have at 'er.
AF1's wings could have had girls dancing on them with fireworks and flags waiving in the backgroud. Now that would have been good TV. Of course in the US it probably would have been censored to the point of looking all jerky like a silent film.

by oz_media

But screw your kids?

The President is sure enough that Iraq is being saved, the people all love him, there are a few bad apples but they will also be caught.

So why all the fear of the President visiting Iraq? Don't you have Iraq under control now? Isn't the major fight over? Isn't America the most powerful force in the world with the BEST military known to man?

I'd have stayed at home if I were Bush, this is just his way of showing how much he cares, although he didn't talk to the Iraqi's several of whom just down the road who commented that he didn't ask THEM what they thought, he didn't address any Iraqi issues with his ONE visit since the invasion. I dunno about you but if I was an Iraqi and the guy who'd ordered my country invaded in MY best interests was in town, I'd have a few questions too, especially after taking a look around.

by generalist

Given all of the special hardware that AF1 admits to having on board, the flight in and out of Bagdad should have been reasonably safe.

It wasn't like it was announced in advance to full media coverage so that various groups could plan something. And I suspect that ground security for the area was MUCH better than usual.

Personally I felt that it was a good gesture in support of the troops. The fact that it could also reap political brownie points is a side issue.

by oz_media

It was safe VERY safe. Made out to be quite an excursion but not really so. As you said, AF1 now that's a pretty hard tagret. He was flown in and shuttled to the back door of a bunker under HEAVY military cover in a secured area. He had his 5 minutes of fame and a quick shout-out to the troops, then left as fast as he came.

This guy could be Santa! You never know.

Only thing is, when Iraqis headr he was in town they wer quite pissed that he didn't address the citizens of iraq or ask how they felt about the current situation. Live TV always gets the truth from the people interviewed, which would not be permissible in the US Media as it is prohibited by the White House.

It would have looked like a Britney Spears concert,
Iraqi's lips say,
"when are you going to fix my country that you destroyed?" When are you going to pay for the loss of my sons"

While the audio says,
"THANK YOU Mr. Bush sir, you have saved me and my family. How will we ever repay you!"

Probably best he just snuck back home again.

by jimhm

Oz - if I recall it was around 7 hours he spent with the troops ... not 5 minutes... If you are going to collect information from CNN they are very leftest ..

by jimhm

That form of Government doesn't work - Lets see for example - Russa - China is moving more towards something else since taking over Hongkong (learned about economic power). Lets see North Korea now there's an economic power.

Just a few - Can't say it works ... Russa had long lines for food, clothing - poor healthcare (unless you were a party leader - the select few), everyother person was KGB, you couldn't travel freely around the country, no incentives to advance business or create more wealth - Shall I go on ...

by tr_member

Who brought those countries down - directly or indirectly? Is that a trivia question :-)?

by jimhm

Your turn - tell me where has it worked successfully for hundreds of years... with a successful economy -

Tell me why its such a good form of government ...

by Jay Garmon

You said Trivia, so here I am.

Politics aside, the fall of virtually all Stalinist-Communist countries, besides their ultimately self-destructive reliance on totalitarianism as a means of political control, is largely attributable to the central flaw in Marxist economics.

Namely, Marx argued that all work has value, and therefore the worker should be the primary beneficiary of the work he performs (not unreasonable) and that by extension, the working class should be the primary beneficiary of all the goods and services they create, rather than the factory-owner or elite classes employing the workers (reasonable on the surface, but fatally naive).

The flaw in all this is the assumption that all work is of equal value. To paraphrase Heinlein, give apples, flour, sugar, milk, eggs, salt, and cinnamon to a master chef, and he will turn these items into a delicious pie. His work has increased the value of the items, therefore his work has value.

Give these same ingredients to an idiot (me, for instance), and he'll turn them into a burnt, inedible mess. He may have worked just as hard as tye chef, but his work has decreased the value of the items. Thus, his work has a negative value.

Under communism, all work is rewarded equally, regardless of the quality of that work. Thus, without competitive incentive, the net quality of work, products, and servcies will inevitably decrease, and economic collapse is thus inevitable.

Even if economic communism and political totalitarianism weren't synonymous, communism as an economic model is still doomed to failure.

by oz_media

At first you questioned Jim as to why he thought communism was a bad idea.

He offered a very simplistic personal view of why communism doesn't work, well it sounded more like a collective he agreed with.

You then said Why communism doesn't work?!?!?

Was this just a Trivia question for Jim? Or were you making a redundant statement?

by mrbill-

?? You are obviously not knowledgeable about the capabilities of AF1 or our fighters as they would be able to deflect an RPG away easily??

An RPG is a shoulder fired rocket with no guidance, you shoot it and it flies sorta straight ahead. Radar guided missiles can be jammed or chafed. Heat seeking missiles can be defeated with flares. The aircraft have sensors that tell them when a radar signal hits them, but they have no way, except by visual, to detect a heat seeker. The flight profile that AF1 would have used to get into and out of Baghdad would make hitting it with an RPG near to impossible. Hitting a low flying helicopter is easier than hitting a rapidly descending aircraft, even a 747, speed and angle. The shooter would have to be really good and with exceptional intel to know when and where to be at for the optimum shot, in the dark. They are not that good over there, just lucky sometimes.

by jimhm

I would love to see news reports from Canada - England - Germany - but the great and powerful news media (cable, Dish) don't carry it, nor will they ... Which is BS..

I would love to see what others in the world are getting - which would balance the BS - Hype - Editorials - that the American media toss around like yesterdays table scraps.

I try to catch - Fox - MSNBC - and like you wouldn't watch CNN if someone paid me by the minute to do it....

Hey that's one of the first times we kind of agreed with each other in a long time...

by oz_media

I don't know if you have a decent connection at home but you can watch world news online.

Just tap into CBC or BBC or ALJazeera networks around dinner time (thier time zones of course) and it streams freely. Unless they are blocking that too, but I doubt it. The best part is when they show what US news reports aired and how different the stories are.

by jardinier

Every significant newspaper in the world has an online version. I have always steered clear of TV news because by its very nature it relies on visual images.

So pick a country, and read some newspapers. I am sure before long you will find one that doesn't have any particular bias either towards or against the US.

While Maxwell has this obsession with finding errors and bias in news reporting, rather than extracting the simple facts, I always look first at www.smh.com.au (The Sydney Morning Herald) because I am more interested in state and national news than overseas.

Despite major dramas by Maxwell about the bias of independent reporters who remained in Baghdad during some of the hottest parts of the war, I have not, in retrospect, found any particular bias in the reports from the SMH correspondent in Baghdad, Paul McGeough.

As I read the online press each day, I see items of interest, with no apparent censorship or bias. Believe it or not, in Australia we read without fear or favour virtually literal acounts of local events (no bias at all that I can find in reporting of Australian politics) and any overseas news that may be incorrect at the time of inital reporting, is usually straightened out as new information comes in.

There are of course feature writers who just like the sound of their own voices, but the straight facts of the news are just presented as they come in from various overseas sources, including Associated Press.

I have detected NO America bashing in local news reports, but then of course Australia has no cause to push the American Republican line.

In local politics, whatever happens is reported, with no bias towards any party.

by oz_media

Sounds like somethig the americans already have Jules. Freedoms are what the US is built upon.........isn't it?

free speech, freedom of the press, freedom to colour the news. ;-)

by oz_media

That's the report I heard and again I NEVER WATCH CNN, American news sources are a complete circus. There's no accuracy in the reporting, you hear at best HALF the story and even that is with more edits than an Bruce Willis movie.

Don't you guys get TV broadcasts from other countries? You must, everyone else does.

2.5 hours relatively, when you consider the importance of his visit and how he is wanted to answer so many questions, that is 5 minutes of fame. I knwo that they said how insecure it was and how under threat they were, but with his Army beside him , howo could he possibly feel insecure.
If I was being protected by the worlds most powerful superforce, I wouldn't want to leave!
These are the worlds best soldiers, the most advnanced military on the globe, so you all seem to feel. Why the need to fear for your safety?

It was a big joke that achieved it's goal by 150%.
It was aimed at getting people such as yourself to see what a brave soldier GWB is and how he is not afraid to visit his troops on thankgiving ad bring them words of approval. What a nice guy.

Lets not forget who sent these soldiers there in the first place. 5 month said Colin Powell, well it's been longer than that already and GWB needs a covert operation with no landing and marker lights getting the worlds super fortress to land in Iraq while being accompanied by fighters so he can sneak in and out.

Sounds like you've really toppled Saddams regime and have liberated this poor country. What do you think, couple more months and is done?

How about a couple of years and your still fighting terrorists in America. Well done.

by jennifer.gardner

I don't think that we do get news broadcasts from other countries. Our cable has a BBC channel, but I don't think there are any news programs...

by oz_media

I talking about the British Broadcasting Corporation or as I like to call it (The British Broadcorping Castration), BBC news is another channel in England (they have several BBC's).

You can find BBC onine and read stories if not view then live.

OM

by jimhm

Nope - no international news on Cable or sat tv (dish/direct). They don't even have a BBC channel, one local channel has German news or Japaneese news - without subtitles on between 2 AM and 3 AM.

So our great media keeps the Americans closed in most of the country. In Cal, Texas, Az and New Mexico you do have some Mexican stations - there maybe some in New York. But the rest of the country is fed straight American news - very little worldwide events are covered.

I guess - search - Broadband cable at home should handle the feed - 3.2 Meg download with 650 upload speeds...

by oz_media

HOwever I'm not surprised and it explains a lot of the comments I see here that I call ignorant. They truly are ignorant as they don't know any better. Not stupid, but ignorant as in they are not aware of a situation.

In Canada, we have a full time french channel (thank god for programmable channels surfing!) and a milti-cultural channel (mainly asian news, often about Canada and the USA, with subtitles)
we also have an Indo-Canadian channel for our Indian residents (not subtitled) Watching Apni-Boli-Apni-desh is always an amusing cultural experience on Sunday morning, after Coronation Street of course). So we have Asian, Indian, French plus Canadian news which incorporates, world news stories in depth to show what the rest of the world is seeing.

Better get that broadband fired up guys, you're REALLY missing the other side.

OM

by oz_media

I agree with your claims about Rocket Propelled Grenades, it would take a pretty sharp shot to hit AF1.

Your assumption of the enemy is typically underestimated. As you know, the saying goes "never underestimate your enemy".

Reports from Baghdad have had military commanders saying that this is NOT Iran, these people are trained and major casualties are ineveitable before this war is over.

Not exactly the malnourished and poorly trained Taliban that you faced last time.

by mrbill-

Even hitting the Blackhawk in the dark required luck. They are well trained, but they are not innocent citizens but combatants. Many Taliban fighters trained with the Iraqi forces, at the time they were going by a different name. The group that tried to hit the two convoys were Fetehin (sp?) not regular troops. These guys were the ones who trained with the terrorist organizations.

by mrbill-

Even hitting the Blackhawk in the dark required luck. They are well trained, but they are not innocent citizens but combatants. Many Taliban fighters trained with the Iraqi forces, at the time they were going by a different name. The group that tried to hit the two convoys were Fetehin (sp?) not regular troops. These guys were the ones who trained with the terrorist organizations.

by mrbill-

Even hitting the Blackhawk in the dark required luck. They are well trained, but they are not innocent citizens but combatants. Many Taliban fighters trained with the Iraqi forces, at the time they were going by a different name. The group that tried to hit the two convoys were Fetehin (sp?) not regular troops. These guys were the ones who trained with the terrorist organizations.

by lesdabney67

The president spent about 10 minutes with the troops, just long enough to get pictures and then he got the hell out of the danger zone.

If he really was serious about visiting the troops he should have rucked up and went to visit the combat troops.

by lesdabney67

and 10 whopping minutes visiting with the soldiers. Just long enough to get lots of photos and get the hell out of there.

JAPO (Just another photo op)

by jimhm

Well whatever you want to call it - JAPO - good timing - a political move ... It worked. Latest ratings in GWB has over a 61% approval up from 54%... even 54% is above the highest Clinton even had...

by lesdabney67

2 things.

Remember the USS Lincoln? It back fired big time and this will back fire too just give it time.

Bill Clinton's approval rating at the time of impeachment was over 70%. You must be watching FAUX news.

by oz_media

Got it the first time :-)

Damn discussion threads!

Did you have a siezure while submitting?

by mrbill-

Yea I posted thhat as I was leaving work and it sat there for a few minutes then I stopped IE. When I checked from the training center I go to I saw all those posts. Hey it was important stuff, right.

by lesdabney67

And it is declining in the US. If anyone believes we have a free press in America I have a bridge to sell you in New York.

by maxwell edison

.
It was a 73% approval rating. (Exact question: Do you approve of the way Bill Clinton is handling his job as president?)

However, the rest of the story - the rest of the numbers:

Same gallop poll in December, 1998:

30% wanted Clinton to resign.
29% wanted the Senate to convict Clinton and remove him from office.
35% approved of the House's decision to impeach the president.
41% thought the Senate would indeed remove Clinton from office.
67% wanted President Clinton to either stand trial in the Senate or be censured.
59% wanted President Clinton out of office.

One more:

78% approved of President Clinton's recent order to attack Iraq for continuing to violate 1991 UN resolutions.

----------

By the way, that observation of yours that President Bush's visit to the USS Lincoln "backfired" (whatever that's supposed to mean) is certainly in the eyes of the beholder, so to speak. Since the only ones critical of that aircraft carrier landing have been partisan Democrat party members or operatives, which is always to be expected, nothing "backfired" at all. As I recall, the public, in general, thought favorably on that particular event.

Also, President Bush had a 65% approval rating in May 2003, the month he landed on the USS Lincoln.

by john_wills

Molly Ivins is not "a border-line socialist"; she is a straightforward socialist, applying socialist principles in an environment wavering between libertarian and liberal (proper sense), with some deviation over towards corporatism. She is not "extreme left-wing", just plain socialist, not communist or loony-left U.S. pseudoliberal or anything like that. She would fit right into the London Guardian's columns, but would be less remarkable there. I used to read her quite often in "The State" of Columbia SC, but the SF Chronicle doesn't run her so often. What kind of person thinks that an ordinary socialist is "extreme left-wing"?

by maxwell edison

.
...I was being, shall I say, "kind" when I referred to Molly Ivans as only "extreme left-wing". I know all about Molly Ivans. I've been reading her stuff for years.

And you're right on with your assessment of Molly Ivans as a socialist. Does she admit to it, or is she a closet socialist masquerading as Democrat?

And is she the one who coined the term "Dubya"? I can't recall anyone using it before her, as she used it against then gubernatorial candidate GW Bush.

by oz_media

"What kind of person thinks that an ordinary socialist is "extreme left-wing"? "

An ordinary Republican that is extreme Right-Wing?

:-O

by john_wills

The purpose of the state is to secure such God-given rights as those to life, to liberty and to property. There are several theories about the best way for the state to fulfil its purpose. For the economic aspect we can name the main theories socialism, liberalism and corporatism. An extremist is someone who embraces such a theory without remembering its purpose: he makes the means into an end in itself. Extremists, in this sense, must be wrong. A communist is an extremist socialist, a libertarian is an extremist liberal, a fascist is an extremist corporatist. They are all wrong.

by tr_member

...the GOD-given rights? How do we know clearly that God wanted to have those rights?

by jimhm

I think that said it pretty good ... Don't you.

If your not affraid read the bible - it may shed a little light on the subject...

by john_wills

For the present purpose I might perhaps as well have said NATURAL rights, which are derivable by reason from the nature of the person. The reason many people praise the God of Israel, however, is that "thy statutes are all of them true", i.e. in accordance with natural law. In particular, there are commandments "Thou shalt nor murder" and "Thou shalt not steal", so the rights to life and to property are there, and the right to liberty is somewhere inbetween (I don't mean an immediately relevant commandment is inbetween). Many people think that once one has accepted the principle of natural law one has implicitly accepted that God put that law in nature.

by tr_member

...maybe. But, the capitalist forces never wanted Communism to flourish. Left to itself, communism would have morphed to something else. But we never let it in peace.

Power corrupts. The leaders of the communist regimes were corrupt. So, that was an additional factor in communism's demise. Let's not associate leaders' corruptedness to the flaws in communism.

I am not saying the world should be communist. I am happy with capitalism. But, let us not phooh phooh other concepts and ideas. How different would we be then when compared to the brainwashed religious fanatics?

by maxwell edison

I'm sure it's exactly the thing you would do. And it's exactly the sort of thing I'd do.

And you're right, the motives are all speculative. How do any of us know what's going in the President's mind, or anyone else's for that matter?

So why not give the man the benefit of the doubt? It was a nice thing to do for the troops, it's something almost any of us "would" do if we were in his shoes, so why criticize him for it?

by oz_media

Isn't that the most common excuse for all his BS though, Max?

How many times do you give him the benfit of the doubt before you doubt?
I'm not implying you all made a mistake in electing him, he squeaked into the White House has made nothing but controvesial decisions sonce then and is still being given the benefit of the doubt. This would be a good reason for DOUBT when it coems to his re-election, against the will of the rest of the world, I see him getting elected once again due to the strong Republican supporters that are fed BS by the media in order to cloud the reality of his mistales. The scary part is that you eat it up hungrily as you look for some tiny piece of justification to support your last decision. It has been proven that he initiated many of the problems with the sanction breaches, other countries ar also breaching BUSH's imposed sanctions, no problem there, but with Iraq it's an issue?!
Other countries have WMD, nuclear technology and etc. that could eliminate half the continent, yet they are left alone as it is in Bush's better interests. To avoid conflict or negative relations.

Tell me Max, why do you PERSONALLY, think the war in Iraq was neccessary? Keep in mind, Liberation wasn't why you all supported the effort in the first place, that was Tony Blair.

I can often let things slide as perhaps there is more to it that we see, which is very obvious in the US. How many times do you let the it slide before you realize he is giving your country a bad name and pushing longtime allies to the wayside. Do you REALLY think these Allies will be happy to support the US in the future? Have you not heard and read all the negative comments from other countries about the US actions lately?

What is it Max, your Allies or the USA, that is important. If it is just the USA, why are you concerned about liberating another country?

If it your allies, why would you go against thier wishes?

If it is BOTH, why was there no middle ground or at least further discussion before the invasion?

You all stand alone and spit on the world but complain that you are not supported?

by john_wills

The Iraq trip will undoubtedly help Dubya to re-election. He has squandered international goodwill engendered by September 11, and people do not ignore that, but the Demcorat disarray, a recent Massachussetts Supreme Court decision, the passage of the law against partial-birth abortion (never mind whether it survives judicial scrutiny) and various other things will make Dubya seem the world's best hope against the loony pseudoliberal left. And that same loony left may not all be voting Democrat: Al Gore has come to SF to persuade people to vote the Demcorat candidate for mayor in a few days because if they vote the Green candidate in the Green party will throughout the lefty parts of California pull a lot of votes from the Democrats and California may thus give its electoral votes to Dubya. I'm a bit cynical about politics, and skeptical about the ability of any form of government to fulfil government's function, whatever party or politician is in power, but I do find some amusement in the present dominance of Dubya and his like.

by oz_media

First, I was chastized for offering statistics from a Poll.
"Sick of Opinion Polls
I am sick of the media's use of opinion polls to gage the mood of the population.

Poles can be easily configured to provide the desired results.

Further, I am VERY tired of our elected "leaders" using poles to define their course of action."

I guess that a poll can be easily construed to report favourably or infavourably depending on the needed outcome of the poll.

Secondly, you posted a poll regarding BillClinton from five years ago, I understand you were referring to a previous statement but isn't Clinto no longer the President? Who cares what people thought in 1998?

You also added that "78% approved of President Clinton's recent order to attack Iraq for continuing to violate 1991 UN resolutions."

This is because NO BODY had a clue what sanctions wer being violated, WHY they wer violated, WHO was violating them and moerso how many people knew that Iraq isn't the ONLY country violating a US implied sanction?

From what I saw on American news, there was a major concern over dual purpose goods being shipped to Iraq. I never saw a single reference as to WHY or that the USA was holding back needed supplies to Iraq as they were 'inspecting' them for up to 18 months.

The oil-for-food program would benefit, the USA, the UN BIG TIME, Russia, Syria, Iraq and many others. Yet as soon as the major benefit was someone elses, the US started complaining that sanctions were being violated.

In order to show some integrity after this given cause for war, you must now go and invade, Russia, China, Syria, UK, etc. Otherwise, you're just blowing hot air out of your butts.

And nobody supoprted you, make me wonder why, nobody was behind you, are the rest of the world's citizens just jealous of America? Is it possible that they didn't see fact or believe allegations that are still do this day unproven?

by road-dog

The US opposed the Soviet Union since the end of WWII, but really worked toward containment, not destruction. This was followed throughout the cold war and various other actions where steps were taken to prevent communist expansion all over the world.

The US could have attempted to bring about the demise of the USSR by simply ceasing grain shipments, but did not do so for fear of the communists launching WWIII as a response to the inevitable uprising from starvation. These grain shipments amounted to life or death for the USSR many years because of the repeated failures of agricultural programs implemented by the central committee.

To assert that this ideology wasn't given sufficient time to succeed is laughable. Since the dissolution of the USSR, records have shown that the USSR was nowhere as strong nor as stable as their diplomatic bluster portrayed them to be.

In the end, they could not supply the guns and butter. Had the US simply allowed them to starve, millions would have died when they turned to expansionism. Fortunately, they went with a whimper...

by road-dog

I see plenty of news that I feel is slanted against the Bush administration. As far as I've seen, no US newspaper has been forced out of business or sanctioned in any way.

Blogs and other Internet media have flourished in recent years. The flow of information and opinion seems to flow unimpeded.

On what grounds does one make the assertion that free speech is being infringed upon?

by lesdabney67

I told you...given time the rest of the story will come along. The turkey that Bush was using in that Iraq photo op turns out to be...a prop...that's right...a fake turkey...that makes two fake turkeys in the same picture.

By Mike Allen
(c) 2003, The Washington Post

WASHINGTON -- President Bush's Baghdad turkey was for looking, not for eating.

In the most widely published image from his Thanksgiving day trip to Baghdad, the beaming president is wearing an Army workout jacket and surrounded by soldiers as he cradles a huge platter laden with a golden-brown turkey.

The bird is so perfect it looks as if it came from a food magazine, with bunches of grapes and other trimmings completing a Norman Rockwell image that evokes bounty and security in one of the most dangerous parts of the world.

But as a small sign of the many ways the White House maximized the impact of the 2 1/2-hour stop at the Baghdad airport, administration officials said Wednesday that Bush picked up a decoration, not a serving plate.

by jimhm

Come on - it was a photo Op - do you really think the Military - feeding 800 men and women is going to be carving turkeys in the chow line. My God get a Life....

If you're an American you got to be a Democrate - or are you just that stupid that you believed that they had uncarved turkey in line at the chow hall... God get a life...

by lesdabney67

I have a life

I am a Republican

Thanks anyway though.

10 minutes with the troops and a fake turkey does not improve morale.

by tr_member

...Glad you brought up the subject of NATURE. Let me ponder for a second on your view of God's law. What if people did not believe in 'God of Israel'? And did not believe in those commandments?

If we look at Nature, taking into consideration Darwin's theories, or discounting them, clearly the strongest survives. We have seen in countless TV documentaries of how animals flee leaving the weak behind, when attacked by the predator. But, there are cases where animals clearly help out each other.

I am not here to slight Capitalism nor sing the glory of Communism. Just trying to see the other side too.

Maybe if we were not so Materialistic, then we would not be infatutated with Capitalism.

by jimhm

Actually it was 2.5 hours with the troopes and from all accounts it did more for them the Hillary. But no one is talking about Hillary telling the troops that "America doesn't support your efforts" ... Hum wonder why.

I remember Thanksgiving and Christmas in the Nam - it wasn't much but it was better than other meals we got. Being X-Military that is a real bost to morale when your commander shows up in Harms way - just to say - Great Job guys - we appreciate your efforts.

It would of taken 8 hours to carve and serve 800 troops, rather than just slap it on a plate of tray - and move down the line...

I guess you were never in the military and remember seeing those plastic birds - on sitting on the top of the Hotlines - with the fake cranberries and sweet taters...

It was a photo-op, it looked better than slapping a hunk of turkey on a plate... If you are going to blame someone - blame the press.

Gore would of never had the balls to go to a war zone - let alone do anything after 911. He thanked God after 911 that he lost the election.

by lesdabney67

It was 10 whopping minutes with the troops. Just long enough for pictures. He didn't even eat with them.

From the time he landed until the time he left totaled 2.5 hours.

I was in the US Army from 1985-1990, left for college in 1990 and got called back up for Desert Storm 1 in January of 1991.

Gore actually WENT to Vietnam unlike Bush who was AWOL!

by cactus pete

Can you post any reference that would back up your claim of either sentence:

"Gore would of never had the balls to go to a war zone - let alone do anything after 911. He thanked God after 911 that he lost the election. "

by lesdabney67

Bush needed 9/11 to rescue his selection in the 2000 election and to make him seem like a legitimate president.

by mrbill-

Let?s see Al Gore, the son of a prominent politician, did some combat reporting during Nam if I remember right. GWB, the son of a wealthy Oilman, spent most of his ?wartime? service flying F4s over Texas, I guess they were afraid Oklahoma was going to invade. The son of the politician, who may have been 4f to begin with, went to the combat zone while the son of $$$ stayed home where he was safe.

I also remember when GWB went to Saudi during his Papa?s gulf war and got his butt thrown out of the AOR by Gen Norm. It seems junior was getting in the way of the men at war.

by lesdabney67

However, I would disagree that Bush spent much time actually flying in the Gaurd. Bush lost his flying priviledges in 1972 after failing to show up for a physical. After that he went AWOL for a year.

The sad thing is he went AWOL during a wartime situation in America.

Some leader.

by maxwell edison

.
He flew F102s over Texas.

(Or was it the F105?)

Your "memory" is really bad.

"Wouldn't it be great for our armed forces and for America if we could have another commander in chief named George Bush?"

-Norman Schwarzkopf (August 1, 2000)

by road-dog

the 911 attack had Gore been elected. He is a brilliant predictor of future events, as planning of 911 began around 1996...

If Gore were President instead of Clinton, would the first bombing of the WTC have happened?

by oz_media

"I'm a bit cynical about politics, and skeptical about the ability of any form of government to fulfil government's function, whatever party or politician is in power"

That is pretty much where I stand. I don't think anyone will do the perfect job. It's when they go hell bent for leather on some cavarly campaign that I get pissed off.

Our PM is rarely a topic of discussion, just the way O like it. He does his job and makes decisions but neither REALLY have e horrible effct whether positive or negative. A fex tax dollars here, the odd restriction there but nothing really that life effecting like invading countries or getting us terrorized.

All in all it's peaceful and I can enjoy my life and the unsurmounted beauty of BC in peace with the wildlife that brought us all here in awe, while my PM just quietly sits in his office and pushes paper, not buttons.

It kinda like the difference between a boss that's always in your face and always making major changes in an attempt to score the ultimate goal, and a boss who let's you write your own ticket, come to work and manage your own time, create with your own ideas and practically run your own business.

by maxwell edison

.
To suggest that 9-11 would not have happened with Al Gore in the White House only shows your naivete' (and/or extreme politically motivated wishful thinking and/or sour grapes).

The events of September 11, 2001 would have, most likely, happened regardless of who was sitting in the White House, and all but only a few misguided people would agree. Absolutely NO ONE in a position to know has ever made such a ridiculous statement. But the subsequent retaliation and war on terrorism, on the other hand, would, most likely, not have been much more than a whimper under an Al Gore presidency. If your man (Gore) would have responded like his man (Clinton), a few more cruise missiles would have been lobbed into yet another empty tent in Afghanistan killing a few more innocent and harmless camels.

by maxwell edison

.
Why not get over it already?

Get over the fact that Al Gore lost the election.

Get over the fact that Al Gore's court challenges failed.

Get over the fact that ALL of Florida's lower courts ruled against Al Gore.

Get over the fact that the ONLY court (out of many) to rule in favor of an Al Gore requested recount was subsequently ruled unconstitutional by a 7-2 margin in the U.S. Supreme Court.

Get over the fact that 9-11 was in the planning stages since 1998, during a Clinton-Gore administration.

Get over the fact that your guy (Gore) and his guy (Clinton) couldn't do in 8 years (deal with Saddam Hussein) what GWB did in 8 months.

Get over the fact that Al Gore is a loser.

It's time to start supporting your next loser. (Howard McGovern Dean, perhaps?)

by dbertsche

This is one of the most idiotic posts I have ever seen anywhere. The 9/11 attack would have happened no matter who was president, do you really think fanatical terrorists would have been "quivering in their boots" because Gore was president? Get real.

by lesdabney67

I expected the howling wing-nuts to come unglued with that comment. Good job. I am replying here because I got a message that some threshold had been reached on the other.

Let's begin shall we?

Road Dog
Clinton and the WTC bombing - To understand what happened here we have to put this in perspective. When was Clinton elected? Answer. the winter of 1992 and sworn in in January 20th of 1993.
Now, when did the first WTC attack occur? Why barely one month later on February 26th. Bill didn't have time to get his security apparatus together in one month.

Get real. Unlike GWB who had 8 months but could not be bothered to concern himself with the security of the US.

Next
Maxwell Edison

9/11 wouldn't have happened because Al Gore would have followed Bill Clinton's path in the protection of the US. His record speaks for itself. All of the recommendations that Bill Clinton made to the incoming Bush administration WENT IGNORED. The bi-partisan security report that had been put together for the previous 2 years was shelved by Dick Cheney. All of its recommendations WERE IGNORED.

Al Gore did not lose the election. Watch the independent movie called "Unprecedented" for a real history of what happened in Florida.

Next
DeBert
Are the terrorists quivering in their boots now? It appears that Bush hasn't caught not one of the people he said he would catch "dead or alive". The Taliban is back and in force in Afghanistan and we are losing the war in Iraq.

The thing you have to ask yourself about 9/11 is...

Who benefited from the attacks?

Follow the money...it leads right back to Halliburton, Bechtel, Dynacorp and others...

9/11 wasn't a security failure, it was deliberate.

by road-dog

The point was not preventability, it was ideology of terrorists as relates to causality.

The bin ladens of the world attack us for who we are, and more importantly what we are not, Islamic that is.

Terrorism is difficult to stop, and only a repeal of the Bill of Rights would facilitate changing that.

To say that 911 would not have happened if Gore were President is outrageously ignorant. That is the point I was addressing. We were not attacked because of our leader, we were attacked because of the insanity of theirs.

by road-dog

I don't think that we're coming unglued. We're quite used to dealing with folks who believe that if a lie is told enough times it becomes truth.

If you would like to see some folks who are unglued, go on over to democratic underground. That site is rife with those with a tenuous grip on their sanity.

Wassamatter? not getting enough attention on http://www.praesentia.us ?

7 piles of flamebait posted, 2 responses, one of them your own? My, I can see why you're here. It must get lonely over there in kooksville. That's ok, welcome aboard. We conservatives are used to your type. Maybe Oz has a spare tinfoil hat you can use so GWB can't read your brain waves....

by road-dog

Surplus grain is purchased in the US to artificially support prices. This grain was given to the USSR as foreign aid.

by oz_media

"After Sept. 11, Bush press secretary "got off to a wobbly start when he was instructed to tell reporters that the president had not returned to the White House the day of the attacks in part because of reports that Air Force One was a target. Later, the administration had to backtrack and admit there had never been a credible threat."

http://tinyurl.com/xrmn
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Many Troops Dissatisfied, Iraq Poll Finds
A broad survey of U.S. troops in Iraq by a Pentagon-funded newspaper found that half of those questioned described their unit's morale as low and their training as insufficient, and said they do not plan to reenlist.

http://tinyurl.com/xrp1
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
US 'censored' green report

"the amendments demanded by the president's staff were so extensive that the climate section "no longer accurately represents scientific consensus on climate change", according to an internal EPA memo quoted by the Associated Press news agency. "

http://tinyurl.com/fajy
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
No cameras for US war dead's return

"...the media is being denied access to the return to the United States of the bodies of those who died - because of a Pentagon ban on such coverage...Ever since the Vietnam war, it has been assumed - in the United States and abroad - that American public opinion cannot stomach high casualties. "

http://tinyurl.com/xrqb
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
There have been widespread complaints that the US media is, at worst, openly partisan in favour of President Bush and, at best, cowed into withholding criticism of his administration - and policy towards Iraq

"In the United States there is already a war going on - the battle for public opinion.
It is being waged through the pages of the print media and over the airwaves."

http://tinyurl.com/xrtq
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Since the end of the Vietnam War, presidents have worried that their military actions would lose support once the public glimpsed the remains of U.S. soldiers arriving at air bases in flag-draped caskets.
To this problem, the Bush administration has found a simple solution: It has ended the public dissemination of such images by banning news coverage and photography of dead soldiers' homecomings on all military bases."
http://tinyurl.com/xru7
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Iraq: Al-Jazeera and free expression
http://tinyurl.com/xrup

Al-Jazeera TV wins award for battling censorship
"Its willingness to give opposition groups a high-profile platform has left it with a reputation for credible news among Arab viewers. But that same quality has enraged Arab governments and the US - which have sought to have the station more closely controlled."
http://tinyurl.com/xrvc
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Now these are just a few sources from hundreds of available sources from everywhere imaginable.
Some may dismiss these reports as Left-wing, Socialist BS or whatever you choose.

To think that only a single source or political view is offering all the correct information would be really stupid.

Even if one is Republican, you must look to all sides to ensure that YOUR side is correct.
With ALL sources OUTSIDE the Republican owned and controlled networks and newspapers pointing the finger at censorshp, the reporters from the front lines pointing the finger and Canadian Television SHOWING the different reports (Canadian news AND US news here)you must agree that the level of censorship on the war reports is sufficient to create a biased and uninformed viewpoint.

This is without question, 100% government controlled propaganda that dates ack as far as WWI. You'd think that after nearly 100 years of contrary reports, people would have caught on by now that they are only seeing part of the story, the pretty part.