Discussion Locked

State Dept & CIA are anti-Bush. over 500 WMD's found since 2003

0 helpful
47 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have known some of what they found for a couple of years.

Why did the State Department try to keep the WMDs and the situation in Iraq from being publicized.

Why did the Democrats, including those who were briefed on the Armed services committee still say "No WMDs"?

I say it was a deliberate attempt to discredit GWB, and to make Political Hay. If they could discredit him and take power away from the Republican Majority, did they care if the issue they used to win was a fabrication, as we now know it is.

47 replies

by Member 25348569

I don't actually understand what you're trying to say. What WMDs?

Your task - should you choose to accept it - is to treat me as an ignorant but slightly interested foreigner (I'm all of that) and explain fully with diagrams and a pointy stick. You may use long words but may not assume my background knowledge of US-centric political concepts is anything less than crap.

This post will self-destruct in the same way that an awful lot of TR posts seem to be doing recently.

:)

by x-marcap

The U.S. State department didn't declassify the documents along the way, and the CIA just cleared them last night... Both CIA and State Department personnel are heavily Democrats in DC about 80%-85% from what my wife's family say. We have a couple of Under Secretary of States in the family,
as well as other spooks and idjits.

Hundreds of functional WMDs have been found along the way Many by 1st MarDiv LRRPs! OOH Rah! People in the State Department and CIA had prevented the information from being published.

The U.S. State Department is loaded with people who are far left of OZ and Julian. My wife's cousin was a Deputy Under Secretary of State. He has been forcibly "retired" recently (I read it fired). He actively tried to suppress anything that would be good for the US while Bush has been in office. Virtually all of my wife's Family is in Government service. Most of them hate Bush. I can't even describe the level to which they would go to damage him. They don't even care if it would hurt the country.

I have my contacts with the Corps still. Remember I told people to wait for about another three months before saying anything about no WMDs. I had heard that the State Department was allowing CIA declassification of documents.

The purpose is that they can now try to re-influence the elections by defusing a September Surprise which was the original suggested release date for the documents. Now they DNC wants time to defuse the WMD existance being used against the Democrats in the November elections. They said the original Sept 28 deadline was too close to the elections, and likely to shape opinion against the Democratic Party. So people have worked around the clock rather than the normal 8 hour day on classification of documents. (That should be a clue that the impact would be lessened. It took the State Department 2+ years to turn the documents over to be declassified.)
It does the administration no good to have the documents declassified at this time politically. In Late September (under normal work conditions) it would have been disasterous for the Democratic party.

by tonythetiger

of most government agencies tends to lean more to the Democrats, simply because the democrats hire more people (Republicans, on the other hand, tend to buy more stuff (new office equipment, vehicles, etc).

Ironically, the reason for the Democrats doing this is that it tends to keep unemployment low, as well as driving up wages in the private sector (smaller pool of applicants).

Also ironically, the Republicans do what they do for a similar reason... buying stuff requires more people to make stuff.

They're both wrong in their thinking... but unfortunately, it appears we'll be stuck with one or the othr for the forseeable future.

by x-marcap

It looks like all the intelligence Departments were right after all. The scale may have been off, but not the accuracy of WMD existance.

I have long thought the CIA and State Department ever since the Carter administration was political. I was given disinformation which is deliberately wrong. (Disinfromation as you know is a deliberate lie like NO WMDs in Iraq.)

After WMD exisatance was known, why did the State Dept and CIA sit on the information? Since the armed services committee was briefed multiple times, wasn't it a deliberate effort to commit fraud by the Democratic Party menbers who had been briefed? Shouldn't they have said "Wait until the facts are in" or something other than support the party line if they had any personal ethics?

How close would the 2004 election been if the "Bush Lied" crowd had been silenced? Was the State-Department-CIA rank and file in league with the Soros-Kerry camp? That would be a much bigger scandal than Watergate.

That would be the deliberate attempt to commit fraud backed by non-elected government power.

by maxwell edison

I've long thought that the whereabouts of those elusive WMDs carries a few possibilities.

Some may have been found, but for some reason it's not being disclosed. This could be for the reasons you stated (see note below), or the White House even knows about it. If it was a choice between taking heat, even to the point of putting his political life on the line, and protecting military/national security secrets, the president would take the heat. President Bush, as we can probably all agree to, does not cater to political pressure or public opinion polls. He is staying the course, and in my opinion, he has some damned good reasons for doing it.

Retired Marine Lt. General Michael DeLong (former deputy commander of CENTCOM) states that military intelligence, in the weeks during the VERY PUBLIC build-up to the war, observed very telling movement that suggested some of the WMDs were taken out of the country to Iran and Syria. The fact that a terrorist attack was thwarted in Jordan a year or so later, one that intended to kill thousands in a chemical weapons attack, also suggests they were removed from the country, as those captured weapons had to come from somewhere. (This incident, by the way, received absolutely no major network or major newspaper coverage in the United States.) And we're taking Iran's saber-rattling VERY seriously. They (the powers that be) know a lot more than we know.

Lt. General DeLong also suggests that some could have been buried, or otherwise hidden, somewhere in a country the geographical size of California. "Stockpiles" of weapons, in this case, as Lt. General Delong points out, equals biological weapons that could fit inside a few briefcases, and chemical weapons that could fit into the trailers of a few trucks. How hard would it have been to bury, somewhere in Iraq, a tractor trailer? Hell, they buried a half-dozen, or so, MIG fighter jets that were discovered only because the tail of one of them was sticking out of the ground!

I've both read Lt. General DeLong's book, [i]INSIDE CENTCOM: The Unvarnished Truth About the Wars in Afghanistan and Iraq[/i], and I've heard him speak. He makes a very compelling argument. Much more compelling, by the way, than the usual band of misfits known as Bush political enemies, with absolutely no credibility. Lt. General DeLong, on the other hand, is just dripping with credibility.

Was President Clinton wrong in 1998-99 when he stated, with absolute certainty, that Saddam still had WMDs? Was Secretary of State Albright wrong when she stated the same thing? Was the entire U.S. Senate wrong? Was U.S. intelligence wrong? Was British intelligence wrong? Were the Saudis wrong? Was President Bush wrong? Was military intelligence wrong? Was the United Nations wrong when they stood fast saying that Saddam DID NOT adhere to UN resolution 1441 and show that all WMDs, that were known to exist, were all destroyed? Were ALL these people wrong? Either the entire world was wrong, or these WMDs simply vanished into thin air. Call me an idiot, but I don't believe things can simply vanish into thin air.

Bottom Line: There's more going on (behind the scenes) than we know. Maintaining geopolitical stability is probably a driving factor. Maintaining an adequate level of national and military security is another. Political posturing is certainly another. The missing factor in the argument advanced by all the detractors and nay sayers is the answer to the question, where did they go? It's something they conveniently never discuss. And the elusive answer, in my opinion, speaks volumes.

Note: I'm with Neil in one regard. It sounds as though you have reasons to make the suggestion that the Department of State and the CIA are out to destroy President Bush and/or the efforts to fight terrorism. What's your support? I will say this, however. We really have TWO governments, of sorts. The one we all talk about and debate about is the elected government. But behind and between the elections we have career diplomats and bureaucrats who want to steer the government and U.S. foreign policy in certain direction, regardless of the preferences of any current administration. Presidents come and go, but career government bureaucrats just keep going and going. They certainly have agendas and preferences, and they don't all just bow to the whims and desires of the current elected leaders. So I won't doubt what you say, but I would like to see some evidence to support it.

by x-marcap

From Department of the Navy, to US Information Agency, to the Dept of Agriculture all GS 13 and above... Ny wife's nephew was a State Department intern, and Her cousin was in the State Dept.

Since the DC area is 80% democratic, and that is where the agencies are, the only Republican in her family is in the Dept. of Agriculture.

Father's Day was a Family reunion in Moundsville WV. I heard how depressed all of them were that were in information and intelligence and the State department. It was obvious Good news for Bush was coming.

by x-marcap

They will not help...

Look at the Valerie Plame incident. Dick Armitage was the leaker... The SP still went after the administration in obvious misfeasance and malfeasance.

Where are the anti-Bushies now on this issue.

Dick Armitage was told by his superiors not to resign, or make public statements...

by jdclyde

Max covered just about everything, so it will save me a lot of typing.

First point, if there ARE NO WMD in IRAQ, they why wasn't ANYONE worried about where they went? We have heard the snyde snips from the extremely far left of "Of course we knew they had WMD, because Bush has the Receipts". This showed someone more interested in a political slam against Bush than caring if Saddam had them or not.

Second, It seemed impossible that EVERYTHING could have been moved out of the country, that quickly.

Third, we all hear about how Bush intentionally lied because some "intellegence" said one way and some "intellegence" said the other. Any honest person would say that he listened to the wrong side, not that he lied. Be we are not talking about honest people here, are we?

Fourth, why had Bush not stood up and explained this more on how it was not accurate? Maybe because it was accruate and he knew that his time would come? "he who laughs last?"

Think about the MAJOR crediblity hit on the WORLD, for all of the anti-Bushers out there? Gee, what if it turns out he was right all along? Where does that leave the hateful masses?

Keep us posted as documents get released. I know we won't see most if it on CNN, and I would hate to go more into this topic until we find out more. I too will bide my time.

Thanks for the heads up TJ!

by tonythetiger

Disinformation designed to keep our enemies off balance (of course, it has the side-effect of keeping the public off balance as well).

by jdclyde

for President Bush to sit there and listen to the hateful masses in the Democratic party go on and on about this?

He knew it would look bad for now, but the last laugh would be his?

Oh, when/if this all comes out, what will people like Oz_Media have to say? Will they step up and admit they were wrong? Time will tell.

by tonythetiger

"And imagine what character it would take for President Bush to sit there and listen to the hateful masses in the Democratic party go on and on about this?"

... he gets to sit in the big chair :)

by jdclyde

There is less competitiveness in government work than in private work, so Democrats would be more prone to be drawn to work here.

In the real working world you have to be ambitious to get ahead, instead of based on how long you have been punching a time clock.

Do you think Unions create Democrats or Democrats gravitate to Unions? I would say it is the second option.

The same for people that work for a college instead of a trade school. The college has a higher percentage of Democrats. This is true in the administrative side as well, compared to the administrative percentage in companies. Not as competative or demanding.

by tonythetiger

"There is less competitiveness in government work than in private work"

I'm not so sure about that, but I would say that there's less danger in "going for it" in government, because there's no risk in failing. Most agencies let you fall back to your old position if the new one doesn't work out for some reason, even to the point of bumping your replacememt. You're old company probably wouldn't do that :)

"In the real working world you have to be ambitious to get ahead, instead of based on how long you have been punching a time clock."

In some agencies it may be still like that, I can't speak for all of them. In the one I work for, seniority is only a tie-breaker should all other things be equal. (and if that's equal, the last 4 of your SSN is the tie breaker (how dumb is that?)).

"Do you think Unions create Democrats or Democrats gravitate to Unions? I would say it is the second option."

I honestly don't know. I only know that their idealism has overridden their common sense. Governments don't help people, people help people. Governments don't build cities, people build cities, etc. Governments are a drain on the work product of thier citizens (though many employees struggle to make it less so). It is up to the citizens to insure it's the smallest necessary drain. We've failed miserably in that respect. Now even the majority of the GOP have hopped on the "Big Government" drain , er, I mean train :)

I guess when all of the real work is gone, everyone can work for the government. Question is, who will pay them?

by x-marcap

Amazing that the lies could have been allowed to continue this long anyway. I had lost my temper about not being able to say anything on the subject.

by oz_media

because Max DID support it.

I can't fin dmention of it on any other world news sites though. The only thing I'v eseen is that they are justifying an earlier find, not that they found anything new. Sounds like mroe hocus pocus to make people feel it is worthwhile.

But you never know, either way, that still doesn't justify ignoring wishes of allies AND going against your own word in order to invade a county.

by Member 25348569

buried by Iraqi troops during the eight-year war with Iran in the 80's and long forgotten.

Your military found a load of crates of old shells containing a blister agent that was no longer active back in 2004 but no-one considered the shells evidence of a current Iraqi program to make chemical weapons.

This is more of the same.

by tonythetiger

Some people worry more about a few drops of oil leaked in a pond than they do 500 tons of "old munitions" ... when it suits them.

by Member 25348569

the declassified report states "approximately 500 weapons munitions which contain degraded mustard or sarin nerve agent". I assumed shells.

This very old non-news.

by maxwell edison

You claim to be right.

You are proven wrong.

You dismiss the proof and still claim to be right.

Amazing. Simply amazing.

And you people wonder why I'm convinced your nothing but a predetermined conclusion in search of justification! ("You People" know who you are.)

by Member 25348569

I haven't seen any proof of anything except that some 500 chemical munitions of an unstated manufacturing date have been found in Iraq since 2003 but we ALREADY KNEW THAT THEY HAD FOUND THEM. All the munitions that have been specified in any detail in other reports have been 1990 or previous manufacturing date and have been found in a war zone where chemical weapons were used.

Considering that you do not feel that you need the justification of WMDs for the invasion of Iraq - unlike those of us who are British - you and TJ do seem to be making a lot of fuss about this non-story.

Find some manufactured [b]since[/b] Desert Storm or give it up.

by puppybreath

All the reports I've seen state that the majority of the weapons found were from 1991. Even the libs are claiming this as a way to minimize the importance of the finds.

You stated "buried by Iraqi troops during the eight-year war with Iran in the 80's and long forgotten."

How did they bury weapons from 1991 in the 80's?

by Member 25348569

But, what the hell. I'll answer anyway. Iraq acknowledged producing nearly 800 tons of Sarin and thousands of Sarin-filled rockets and artillery shells between 1984 and 1990. They produced many more times that in Mustard Gas munitions from the early 80s onwards and were also looking into such things as VX. The Iran-Iraq war ended in 1988. Iraq had stockpiles into the early 1990s. They didn't use them in Desert Storm because (oops!) you've got some too and much, much better ones.

The likelihood of some of these weapons being "mislaid" in the Iran/Iraq war is a perfectly rational scenario. The likelihood of others being cached around the time of Desert Storm by well-meaning officials either with or without the approval of the Baghdad government and planned or unplanned is also perfectly feasible. Whether or not any of [b]these[/b] caches could have been forgotten - paticularly if unsanctioned by Baghdad - I leave up to you because, fankly, it's [b]your[/b] politics, not mine.

by tonythetiger

'Tons' was my error.

But you have to admit it's amusing what gets maximized or minimized depending on its importance to maintaining your world view. Old does not mean inoperable (a recent blast in Germany, I think, from a WW2 bomb comes to mind) nor does degraded mean non-lethal. If offerred a whiff, I'd have to say I'd pass. And then there's the problem of the stuff we knew he had that nobody knows where it is or what happened to it, as well as the possibility of stuff nobody knew about.

by Member 25348569

The problem is that Iraq used a LOT of chemical weapons during the Iran-Iraq war and they contributed to the end of the war when Iraq were really pushing forward. Around 80% were Mustard gas and the rest were mostly Sarin nerve gas. Mustard is pretty stable but the Sarin was much less so.

Now, I have to believe that any half-sensible Iraqi soldiers with a cache of potentially unstable chemical weapons are going to lock 'em up or bury them and, maybe, a few caches were forgotten. Some of these chemical weapons have been found since 2003, almost all within the war battle zone. This has certainly been reported here and no-one ever tried to claim it as "proof" of the current WMD claims.

Again, I'm really puzzled why this is such a story NOW.

Neil

What's NOT well known is that Iran used chemicals towards the end as well!

by tonythetiger

I can't fathom that they would forget. More likely to me would be that they were intentionally left because of their degraded condition.

"Again, I'm really puzzled why this is such a story NOW."

I get the impression that the mainstream media were trying to avoid reporting it at all, relenting at the last hour to avoid being "scooped".

by maxwell edison

.
1. TJ personally asked me my opinion, so I posted the following message (even agreeing with YOU on one point), before I even saw the story.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=7250299081&rd=1&sspagename=STRK%3AMESE%3AIT&rd=1

2. I later saw the story link on Drudge Report, and posted the link for TJ with only a sarcastic comment about the news media.

3. I replied to your denial message, pretty much laughing at you.

You call that "a fuss".

Okay, dude. Whatever you say.

But if you insist.......

by maxwell edison

...which was passed as a condition of the cease-fire of the first Gulf War, directed that any and all WMDs currently in Saddam's possession (those) must be destroyed, and proof of destruction must be provided to the UN inspectors. He obviously did neither. How many times, during the build-up to the war in 2002, did President Bush and his cabinet mention violations of resolution 1441 as justification? And what else did Saddam lie about? And what else is stil classified, not made public? And what else are you going to deny?

by Member 25348569

Well, that's a funny one. How the hell do I know if they won't tell me.

This whole thread is fluff with nothing new, nothing substantive in terms of WMD-related justification for the invasion.

As for 1441, well Security council Resolution 678 justified Desert Storm, 687 was the Resolution passed at the end of the war requiring information of weapons programmes and 1441 was passed in November 2002 - not at all as a condition of cease fire - to put the weapons inspectors back in with increased powers. You're usually better informed...

The inspectors had been out since December 1998 so what went on between then and December 2002, we have no idea. After 1441, had I been the UK's Prime Minister, I would have continued to support inspections but the US and the UK's real government were surely already committed to invasion.

What am I going to deny?

Firstly, that this thread is anything other than a waste of space, time and effort about this non-story.

Secondly, that 1441 was ever a justification for invasion. It was not. In UN-speak it stopped short of invasion. Check the wording of Resolution 678!

Thirdly, that it matters one jot. We're in and we have to do the best we can and yet I fear that no-one has any idea what that is and who it will be best for!

by x-marcap

Active duty troops will secure and classify all items and then the officers will sort and reclassify. Eventually the info leaves the military and works through the civilian side.

There is information that troopers know from the 1976-80 timeframe that would have gotten everyone in the Carter administration tried for treason or just impeached and removed. These things get buried for national security by the Administrations for the good of the country and the politicians. Especially the politicians...

Many illegal things that are damaging to politicians never see the light of day.

by oz_media

What else would he do?

He was on national TV stating he had NOT found teh stockpiles of WMD he expected to find.

ANYWAY, and regardless of ANYTHING else said here.
He STILL went to war without justification. Shoot first and ask questions later? The USA and allies had an agreement on th etable that IF inspectors were kicked out again, they would use force ONLY to complete inspections.

There was NO comments regarding if they didnt like what the inspectors were doing they would invade. Why do you think everyone stood down when you decided to go agains your word and invade a country?

WMD, that's not the issue that was wrong. You KNEW he had them, that wasn't in question. Where they were and IF he destroyed them was the question. This still does not offer justification for an invasion, that was not the plan that your allies agreed to.

by tonythetiger

I guess that must be why the President of the United States didn't ring you up and ask permission.... He knew you'd say "No" :)

by oz_media

What irks me is that he had originally sat around and the general concensus agreed that if teh inspectors were not allowed to complete inspections, the use of force is justified, in order to complete inspections. Now that itse;f may have been a full scale invasion, IF neccessary. I have no problem with the resoning of this, I have no problem with removing dictators, toppling repressive governments, spreading democracy to those who want it but are repressed, ridding these areas of terrorists etc.

But stick to the game plan, you can't change the rules halfway through, go at it alone and then slander anyone who doesn't support it.

You wanna go and take these matters into your own hands, DO SO, but leave others out of it without chastizin them for not perticipating. Don't expect me to support it, I support what the allied countries agre eon as a multinational agreement/resolution. Not what some lone cowboy with a fat budget decides to do.

by oz_media

BBC shows nothng on this issue, neither does Global, CBC, BCTV etc.

I wonder why this is purely US news?

Then again, there is little mention of how Bush was accused of leaking secret information on Iraq to reporters in order to gain support for the invasion, but other sites have in depth news and video of it.

Press, not good for anything at all these days.

by delbertpgh

Throughout this whole buildup to war, any man of integrity with access to information could have seen that crap was being passed off as cause de guerre, and that the whole adventure was perforated with foolish assumptions and strategic errors. Our media is supposed to be able to tell us when fortunes are being wasted on boondoggles, when politicians are whooping it up and telling lies. But the press this time was afraid to be labeled unpatriotic, just like two thirds of the Congress was afraid to object to the flaws they all could see.

So they all ducked their heads and went along, and let a pack of unscrupulous and incompetent scoundrels run the country off a cliff. It'll take us decades to clear the ruin left by George W. Bush and his team.

by Member 25348569

as far away from my camp as possible in case they were hit by a stray Iranian shell, I would certainly "forget" them once peace broke out unless I had a [b]very[/b] good reason not to.

As for the story, I'm still not convinced it's news. The only "new" bit is this declassified document which, now I've read all ten lines, find it contains nothing new. Whover released it has "sexed it up a bit" with a mention of the fact that "terrorists would like to buy some chemical weapons". Basically, as an official document, it sucks.

http://www.usatoday.com/news/world/iraq/2004-05-17-sarin_x.htm

suggests that insurgents had at least one sarin-filled shell but probably didn't know what it contained. There have been quite a few finds like this over the past three years that, in my opinion, make up this "500 munitions" that people are wetting their kecks about.

by oz_media

After the days of Bush, much will surface I am sure. And there will be a lot that never does se ethe light of day again, must be nice to have so much protection for your mistakes.

the worse and mreo condemning the truth is, the less we hear. It is shown by lety agencies and then squelched by the right (or vice versa in an opposite government). It's easy to get away with it, it seems, when you are a politician in the USA.

In Canada, these scandals always get unsurfaced it seems, due to our two party system. One always calls the others bluff, it keeps them in a line a bit more. Yes I know there is a massive Canadian Liberal scandal that has unsurfaced, the point being, they didn't get away with it because of the two party system.

by delbertpgh

Sorry to flame you, but you need to get a clue. 500 15-year-old artillery shells don't count as a WMD program. The shells were all mustard gas (the chlorine based poison that was used in World War I), except for a couple sarin shells (a nerve agent, developed by the Germans in WW2.) Sarin doesn't have a long lifetime, especially in the desert heat, also if it was carelessly manufactured, which leads to very rapid breakdown because of impurities. I don't know how many years mustard gas lasts in a 120 degree desert, but I bet those shells were pretty degraded, too.

Saddam used chemical weapons in the war against the Iranians in the 1980s, and against some of his own rebellious villagers. It takes thousands of gas artillery shells to support an infantry attack. You need at least one per acre, and because it blows away, you have to keep sending more in. 500 isn't enough to do much. Saddam had tens of thousands of shells stockpiled during the Iran war. Apparently he destroyed most of them and his gas manufacturing plant during the ten years of U.N. sanctions.

So we find a trivial amount (yeah, trivial) of battlefield gas weapons that have been baking in the desert since three wars ago. You think that constitutes an ongoing weapons-of-mass-destruction program? No. It's a forgotten ammo dump.

If there had been many thousands of shells, if there had been gas that had been manufactured in the last couple of years, if the small quantities of gas that were found had been had been rigged as concealable, man-portable mines instead of 155mm artillery rounds, then maybe you could have said there was a current gas warfare program, or at least a program to equip terrorists. But instead, all you have is some worn-out weapons to use against infantry formations.

The Democrats, CIA, Army, and the State Department didn't make hay over this, because have no reason to lie about it (like Bush or Santorum), and they're not stupid (like people I'm too polite to name.) There's your answer.

by protiusx

There were WMD as is evidenced by the tens of thousands of Kurds killed by nerve agent and the massive amount of evidence all over Iraq. Again, I can't get too specific but I've seen pictures. One might look at Halliburton?s or KBR's websites and wonder why they need Nuclear Technicians in Iraq. If were "the man" I would put Saddam into GITMO, strap him to the water board and you'd find out in about 15 seconds where the WMD's went to. My guess is Syria. Bathists - the lot of them.

by deepsand

managed to keep sectarian vilolence contained, a niggling little detail that GWB seems to have overlooked; or, did he simply choose to ignore such?

by deepsand

managed to keep sectarian vilolence contained, a niggling little detail that GWB seems to have overlooked; or, did he simply choose to ignore such?

by x-marcap

Even more munitions found. Still old but if this is correct this is a fairly large cache...

Old News again the shells were made in 1997, or at least that is the claim, and they are blister agent, but not made after 2000 A.D.

by rjsides

Let us imagine a world quite the opposite from this one. In this imaginary world, the US relies mostly on the FBI and CIA to hunt down and capture terrorists after 9/11/01. We give each terrorist the same rights as every American citizen and pay for their attorneys since all claimed that they could not afford to do hire legal help on their own. We start to get so many of them that we have special ?Islamic? compatible prisons built for them. Meanwhile, someone in an intelligence agency (probably the NSA or CIA) ?leaks? a story about Saddam Hussein?s development of weapons of mass destruction. The president?George W. Bush?insists that the intelligence reports are wrong. Then someone leaks reports from the Israelis. It says Saddam is close to having his own atomic bomb. Then the British say the same thing, in chorus with the French and Germans, etc. All of these intelligence agencies disagree with the American president, who insists they are wrong and continually ignores their advice. Although Saddam has also successfully kicked all UN inspectors out of his country, he maintains he does and he doesn?t have weapons of mass destruction. His claim seems to depend upon his audience?he will tell the foreign press that he has no such weapons and he will tell the Arabic press that he is the master power broker of the Middle East?because he has fooled Mr. Bush and has such weapons. He rants against Iran and warns them not to compete with him in his attempt to create an anti-American Islamic coalition. He brays everywhere how Americans are afraid of him and how the USA is a paper tiger. Meanwhile, Pres. Bush sticks to his belief that Saddam is a blowhard and does not pose a threat to the US.

What position do you suspect the Democrat Party would take in such a situation?

Would the president?s refusal to listen to all of the world?s major intelligence agencies amount to a refusal to protect the US and be interpreted as an impeachable offense?

Would anti-Bush people claim the problem was that Bush (43) was afraid of taking on Saddam, just as was his father, Bush (41)? Both seemed to refuse to deal with the problem and let Saddam infest himself with more and more power. Both presidents are compared to former British Prime Minister Chamberlain, who signed a Munich agreement with Hitler, in which the German dictator promised to not invade any more countries. Chamberlain claimed he gave us ?peace in our time.?

The Democrats try to whip up war fever against Saddam. They point out how he has murdered hundreds of thousands of his own people, as well as hundreds of thousands of Iran?s troops, using weapons of mass destruction. They claim Bush (43) is a coward and does not deserve to be president. He lacks the will to save America, they claim. Instantly, the Democrat Party becomes the ?war party??they even find some generals who claim that the American Army could whip Saddam in a couple of weeks?all they would need would be 135,000 soldiers. Democrats also advocate getting rid of all the bad guys in Iraq?including Saddam?s two sadistic sons, and all Bathists, whom they describe as modern-day Nazis.

In such a world, what would you believe?

This discussion is closed to new replies.