Discussion Locked

strange behavior of pc-100-dimms

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

i have two different looking 168pin-dimms. on all my super socket 7-boards they count up to 128mb. even on one pII/pIII-board(MS6163VA)-supports six memory banks using 3x168-pin unbuffered dimm.max memory size of 384mb(8mx8)or768mb(16mx4)
now i am setting up a new board, qdi-legend V.
here i have seen a very strange behavior:
dimm A alone counts up to 64mb, dimm b(smaller one) only to 32mb. it can be populated in any order, but must be set in order for optimum ma-time. now comes the sensation: both together count up to 196mb. i have pentium 233(66x3.5)
i had to make some changings in the bios(cmos-setup) until the machine started. referring to my other question of yesterday i still do not know what to set exactly. it is try and error.iknow there are a lot of explanations on the net but i need to know what are the specifications of the dimm.

8 replies

by thechas

You have stumbled upon the problem of evolveing standards and SDRAM DIMMs.

Unfortunently, not ALL DIMMs work in ALL motherboards with DIMM sockets.

For this very reason, I keep on hand a known good low density 128MB PC100 DIMM.
I know if thisDIMM works in a motherboard, that the motherboard functions, and just has a DIMM compatability issue.

Things that changed along the way that not all older motherboards support.

2 versus 4 clock lines.

Increase in the chip density, and how the memory manager in the chipset needs to address the RAM.
(this has happened at least twice)

Changes in the number of supported address lines.
This is more a motherboard implementation than a DIMM specification issue.

Things you can do:

Update the BIOS. Many times the MB mfg has a BIOS update available to address DIMM issues.

Keep your eyes open, and buy up older style DIMMs as you find them at reasonable prices.

Chas

by thechas

As to the RAM installation order.
It is possible that 1 DIMM is bridgeing the RAM clock lines for the other DIMM.
Also, many BIOS's set their RAM settings based on the first DIMM, and ignore the other DIMMs as far as clock and timing specifications.

As to the hard drive.
If the RAM does not count up correctly, it can cause an error on the system bus that will prevent other hardware from being accessed, or detected properly.

Chas

by europanorama

merry christmas and many endless thanks to all of the helpers and commenters!i have just saved your answers.

by cg it

This is a comment more than an answer. Chas really answered the question. My Comment is on the mainboard, the Microstar 6163. This is one of the older motherboards and supports only (as stated 384 MB of SDRAM 3 each 128 MB dimms. It uses the older SDRAM and (as Chas stated) using the new dimms on this old board will cause some of the chips on the memory board to not be seen by the mainboard (and this causes tons and tons of problems with the operating system). Because the mainboard doesn't see all the memory chips on the newer memory boards, one would think the memory board is only,say, 64 MB when in reality it's 128 MB. Once you place that memory board on a newer mainboard that can "see" all memory chips on the memory board, Viola! you'vegot more memory that you thought. New hardware such as memory, cpu's and even hard drives aren't always downward compatible with older hardware.

by europanorama

sorry, one is a 64M(8Mx64) 133 mhz(pc 133) the other could be a pc-100.
the following news of today:
1. when populated the "wrong way" it counts up only to 32mb.
2. a wdc(westerndigital caviar 33100-3.1 gb could not be recognized when the second dimm together with the pc-133(the probably pc-100) was installed but they count up to 196mb which is mysterious.

This discussion is closed to new replies.