Discussion Locked

TAX DAY, and 47 percent of all adult Americans pay NO Federal Income Taxes

0 helpful
220 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

220 replies

by tonythetiger

and there's force of innuendo by those sworn to uphold the law. (I know that Oz believes these people do not exist).

She (Reno) indicated that she was going to investigate every refused application from those areas. In other words, the banks were going to be forced to expend a lot of time and money "proving their innocence". It was cheaper for them (at the time) to simply cave in and to approve the loans, so they did. It's similar to companies settling lawsuits even if they weren't guilty of any wrongdoing... because the trial, even if they won, would be long and costly.

They do the same thing in criminal trials. Did you ever hear of a defendant getting his legal fees back from the government after a not-guilty verdict?

by oz_media

Guffaw! Knee slapper! Don't quit your day job though. it's funny how pissed off people get when their heresay is countered with facts.

by oz_media

But I applaud your wit all the same.

You seem to miss the focus of my debate. One person CLAIMED that someone forced something upon banks. That person FORCED regulation, that had been in place for years already and simply ignored. So what was it exactly that they were being forced to do? Lend money to people without the proper qualifications? As a result of looking at exactly what they were forced to comply with, most obviously not. That's all.

I didn't say it was right or wrong, just that the half-cocked media spin that was presented as fact simply wasn't fact at all.

I don't care if you were president or guru of banking finance, the regulations are printed in black and white. The regulations also made publicly available, children in Botswana can look it up. Regardless of someone's personal feelings and interpretation, regulation was being enforced, regulations did not state what the poster stated.

I have sat in on many cases where people feel they understand the way the law should apply (especially corporately) or who is responsible, based on simple logic or common sense, but it often results in people saying "that's just not right, I shouldn't be at fault because...", because the letter of the law is completely different than they see it.

End of, full stop. Like it or lump it, facts are facts.

by oz_media

[i]She (Reno) indicated that she was going to investigate every refused application from those areas.
...
It was cheaper for them (at the time) to simply cave in and to approve the loans, so they did.[/i]

As you later state, it's similar to out of court lawsuits due to cost and time.

Are those companies are FORCED, to settle out of court OR do they simply make their own judgements and feel it is in their best financial interests to do so?

I suggest that saying they are FORCED to settle out of court is merely silly, unless we are unclear on what the term FORCE means.

What's funny is that any time I have used teh term forced here, to illustrate urged, pressed to action etc. I get blasted that it was not force but ultimately a choice that was made. When the term suits you though, all of a sudden everyone has a different view of what 'force' means. Hypocrisy runs rampant amongst those with a mission of correction it seems.

P.S. In most criminal trials, the government is not responsible for your legal fees. Only a VERY few states offer the defendant (such as an employee in a corporate trial)the common law right to reimbursement. Such fees are generally only awarded as a result of counter suit against the plaintiff.

If a defendant files a suit against the city for wrongful arrest or detention, YES, I have seen such monies awarded on the odd occasion. As you should know, I have spent a LOT of time in courtrooms and watched a lot of misguided defendants try to recover costs that are not covered, as well as high profile trials where they are through counter claims, mostly corporate though as criminal trials put me to sleep real fast.

by tonythetiger

[i]I suggest that saying they are FORCED to settle out of court is merely silly, unless we are unclear on what the term FORCE means.[/i]

Using coercion (from a superior position of power and authority) to compel someone to do what they ordinarily wouldn't do is included in my dictionary under the definition of "force".

by oz_media

Companies are wrongly forced to hire women or African Americans.

You also don't seem to recognize that a GREAT portion of the homes in foreclosure were from people who would have normally qualified for loans without banks adhering to a regulating body. Sure, people who earn 40,000/yr shouldn't have been granted loans for 300,000 homes, but neither should people earning 80,000/yr be granted loans for 500,000 homes.

It's not like it was just people in desciminated neighbourhood were the only people screwing over the banks. The banks were also, once again, not FORCED to offer loans, just FORCED (as per your definition) to properly consider each applicant. If someone was a high risk loan, the bank was not FORCED to lend them money, merely FORCED to accept and process their application, just as anyone else should be.

If you feel that such descrimination was valid, then you will also accept other forms of descrimination. However that's not such a stretch to accept from you, you have clearly separated yourself as being superior to and more worthy than your fellow man on more than one occasion.

by tonythetiger

[i]Companies are wrongly forced to hire women or African Americans. [/i]

In my opinion hiring "because of" anything besides job qualifications is just as bad as NOT hiring "because of" anything besides job qualifications. Fire departments lowering required physical standards in order to hire more females, for example.

[i]You also don't seem to recognize that a GREAT portion of the homes in foreclosure were from people who would have normally qualified for loans without banks adhering to a regulating body. Sure, people who earn 40,000/yr shouldn't have been granted loans for 300,000 homes, but neither should people earning 80,000/yr be granted loans for 500,000 homes.[/i]

Right... they tried to mitigate their anticipated losses by expanding the pool.... Making it easier to slip a bad piece of paper in with some good ones when they sold them off. And I'll even give you that BUSH had a significant hand in that! (The politicians in this country aren't as different as they'd like us to think they are.)

[i]It's not like it was just people in desciminated neighbourhood were the only people screwing over the banks. The banks were also, once again, not FORCED to offer loans, just FORCED (as per your definition) to properly consider each applicant. If someone was a high risk loan, the bank was not FORCED to lend them money, merely FORCED to accept and process their application, just as anyone else should be. If you feel that such descrimination was valid, then you will also accept other forms of descrimination.[/i]

I don't recall any accusation that applications weren't being accepted and processed... only that they weren't being approved... Of course, there are those who think "consider" and "approve" are synonyms, and that if they weren't "approved" it MUST be for some nefarious reason.

[i] However that's not such a stretch to accept from you, you have clearly separated yourself as being superior to and more worthy than your fellow man on more than one occasion. [/i]

Well... I wouldn't say "superior"... but I WOULD say I don't regret not jumping into the mortgage fray... I waited until I had cash in hand... and because of that, can live better on a lot less and with fewer worries NOW, and that I now have more free time and resources to put toward the betterment of my community in a "non-enabling" way.

Our goals really aren't all that different, Oz... just our way of getting there... The difference is that my way doesn't require the threat of force to beat people into submission. I've been "beaten"... both figuratively and literally... I didn't like it... and I won't do it to anybody else!

by oz_media

And there you go again with bizarre, a rash generalizations that simply are NOT accurate in descriobing the actions taken.

in order for government force to a be applicable, a federal law would need to be passed to enforce action. In teh case of your quick bash at Clinton, he passed no such federal law stating that banks had to offer loans ot unqualified applicants. They just saw an opportunity to make money and ran with it, end of.

It can be somewhat funny to watch how you abhor any use of government force to support an agenda said to be in your best interests, but adamantly support the same force when directed towards a foreign nation in your best interests. It's as if they are no good when aimed inward but good enough for control of others, you as do many others defend it as being in America's best interests. Just a bit one sided with what you deem right and wrong there. You blindly oppose or blindly support. Investigation and fact being irrelevant.

Anyway, have a nice weekend, you've flogged that dead horse for too long now, it is no longer amusing to watch you change, sidle, slither and slink as always, while you try and diffuse your original point of false contest.

by nicknielsen

and the intent of the same law are quite often two different things. The results of enforcing that law are often a third thing.

Pity the law can't be written in plain language...

by oz_media

When I first started studying law I thought that laws should be far more definitive, clearly worded and precise to ease in execustion and justice. Then I realzed that it had actually been done long ago, back in the Tudor years for example, law was extremely definitive and clear. However, due to that, it was easier for lawyers to circumvent it and find loopholes than with looser definition. So now broader definition is appropriate and often just stacked on top of each other to provide more room for conviction with less room for specific loopholes. In one sense it is better for society because lawyers get fewer breaks for true criminals, in other ways it leaves too many open questions in cases such as politics (not that politicians aren't criminals).

But that's why I try to leave emotion or political bias aside in these cases and merely look for specifics in written laws or regulatory bodies, there was no federal law passed in this case particular to force such actions as people are trying to suggest. Politicians might be pricks but they usually do a good job of legally covering their butts. I'm not supporting or codemning Clinton's actions, I am merely saying that no such "force" was directly applied, as was suggested.

by tonythetiger

[i]in order for government force to a be applicable, a federal law would need to be passed to enforce action.[/i]

I wonder what "law" enabled these officers to do this...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAPwyodTkYA

Ah, but surely no government official would do ANYTHING unless there was a law in place specifically allowing it.

[i]It can be somewhat funny to watch how you abhor any use of government force to support an agenda said to be in your best interests, but adamantly support the same force when directed towards a foreign nation in your best interests.[/i]

An attempted diversion... If we can keep governments busy with each other, maybe they'll leave their people alone.

[i]Anyway, have a nice weekend, you've flogged that dead horse for too long now, it is no longer amusing to watch you change, sidle, slither and slink as always, while you try and diffuse your original point of false contest. [/i]

(Every day's the weekend for me now :) )

You too. And keep learning... Before you know it, you'll achieve abject ignorance.

by oz_media

With respect to federal law, yes there was a law passed. But to go full circle again, that law did not say that banks had to offer loans to people that weren't normally qualified. I have proven that fact over and over again, without a single YouTube snippet, just the actual docs.

With respect to your video demonstrating a police beating, we have had a problem with that here, and a good one in Victoria too: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnwi6wO03As

My point was not that the law isn't bent by police though. My point was, Clinton did not pass a law stating that banks had to lend money to unqualified applicants(see the theme here yet?).

As for government, it wasn't an attempted diversion at all, it was just me realizing the futility of going in circles again.

[i](Every day's the weekend for me now)[/i] :)
Me too, really. I think I am ready for another F/T gig soon though.

[i]You too. And keep learning... Before you know it, you'll achieve abject ignorance [/i]

Not sure what to make of that, was it merely sarcasm or is a F-U-2 in order?

by av .

I wouldn't put it past them though. It would kill the economic recovery. People will stop buying.

We do have unsustainable debt thats going to have to be addressed. Just think how much money we could save if we weren't at war in Iraq and Afghanistan.

AV

by tonythetiger

they're already taking the money from us. They'd find something else that is "of utmost importance" to spend it on :(

by tonythetiger

Never did I claim that there was a "law stating that banks had to lend money to unqualified applicants". Janet Reno (the "police", so to speak) simply intimidated them into doing it.

by oz_media

Clinton did no such thing, he threatened to have them investigated for not adhering to the CRA Laws restricting redlining.
There is NOTHING in that law that states they must make risky loans, in fact it is quite the opposite, as I have already pointed out (if you had actually read the regulations set ou by the CRA),

Clinton threatened banks who broke the law, he didn't make them offer risky loans, if those applicants showed a fair risk (as with ANY other loan) the banks were NOT under any regulation to offer one anyway.

Conversely, if they HAD offered risky loans, it was on their own accord, nothing to do with Clinton or Carter or Janet Reno, Bob Las Vegas, Emma Atlantic City.

They simply used the excuse, of being restricted from breaking the law, for their irresponsible lending.

If a bar is told to serve all legally aged customers, without prejudice, they can't then turn around and say they were forced to serve minors because they were pressured to not check ID's.

by tonythetiger

[i]Clinton did no such thing, he threatened to have them investigated for not adhering to the CRA Laws restricting redlining.[/i]

there was no credible evidence as to having occurred. It was an intimidation tactic, pure and simple.

by oz_media

Redlining has been going on for decades! It's a VERY common business practice for home or car loans, insurance sales even employers determining whether or not to hire.

When I sold cars it was the same thing when we considered financing. EVERYONE does it, and the banks don't even argue the practice, it's simply a fact of life. now you are going to babble on for a few weeks about whether or not they were redlining?

Give me a break, go find a hobby or something.

http://syracusethenandnow.org/Redlining/Redlining.htm

I know you REEEEEEEALLY want to make a point and you REEEEEEEALLY don't want to conced by saying that your initial comment was over the top and a simple exaggeration based on a half truth, but Tony, you have nowhere to go with this. Your assertions was concise and firm, and incorrect, as proven time and time again. YOu posted with your typical emotional shot at government, it's common for you, expedcted of you, no big deal, you were just off base and again YOU WERE SIMPLY WRONG! Get over it already. God! I don't know why you even bother, then again I don't know why I bother with replying to your circular BS.

by tonythetiger

"The results of a recent Harvard University study suggest that inner-city residents of all income levels are less likely to own a home than suburban residents of similar incomes."

Well, Dumbass, homes in cities are more expensive, because there are fewer of themthere's only so much room.

But some people LOOK for a chance to claim victimhood status any way they can...

by oz_media

So yoru true feelings is that because MANY peoeple living in suburban areas would not be qualified for a loan, then ANYONE livig in such an area should automtatically be disqualified from a loan due to their current region.

That is redlining and MANY people living in such areas are VERY valid loan applicants, no different than you or anyone else.

Your true discriminitive nature keeps shining through.

Don't you feel that the bank should make such decisions based on each applicants true credit history and potential?

Or would you only oppose that when it was applied to yourself in a way that restricted you from following your beliefs and seeking your goals, as anyone living in 'the great land of opportunity' should?

This discussion is closed to new replies.