Discussion Locked

The Australian Version of the RIAA

0 helpful
24 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Well guys & galls over here the Recording Industry has taken the bold step of preventing parents videoing their children at performances because the video breaches copyright. Now here I?m not talking about some late teen age kids who could almost be considered as ?Professional? performers but kids as young as 4 years old.

It seems at a recent concert one man making a video of his young child was approached by the Organizers Security and requested to hand over the Video Camera. He could of course retrieve it after the concert had finished but of course minus the tape. It seems that the organizers of these concerts have been blackmailed into preventing any copies of the performances being made without some form of royalty being paid to whichever company currently owns the copyright of whatever song is being performed. So to save any problems they are just refusing to allow any taping of these performances being made.

This one is a minefield and has dramatic repercussions as there are many different record companies who can claim that their copyright has been breached by the simple act of making either an audio or video copy of a young child performing on stage which most parents want to do anyway and I for one don?t blame them a single iota.

However it is the recording industries greedy grab for cash that is preventing many proud parents from making copies of their children performing on stage and in all likely hood at home as well. While I?m the first to think that these companies need to protect their rights I think that this is taking a step too far and needs to be rethought.

Any body else have an opinion on this topic?

24 replies

by oldefar

An aspect of the human condition that seems to be evolving out of our societies world wide.

Guess I should have left with the dinosaurs...

by hal 9000

While I accept the right of certian companies to protect their material I can not honestly believe that a child singing a song or dancing is going to have a wide market appeal and cost these companies money in any form other than an initial loss of income when the parent records the performance.

Up until now this area has never been considered as important but in their mad rush for money they seem to have lost contact with reaility or maybe it is just us dinosaurs that think that way.

by oz_media

Fear, Uncertainty and Doubt.

The organisers may be unaware of legal reprercussions. A child can sing a song written by anyone but this eceoms a legal fear for some when the song is peformed for monetary gain (school donations, field trips etc)and even moreso if recorded while being performed fro monetary gain.

Many people are unaware of the full legalities surrounding artistic reproduction (they differ by label) and as a result just have a fear of anything that MAY or may not lead to further problems.

It's paranoia, if this were in the USA, Bush would convince American citizens to support an attack on the RIAA by instilling this fear due to ignorance on the people (wow, it's only the 4th of Jan and I'm ragging on Bush again), guess old habits never die.

People act out of fear and it effects everyone around them. It's the same with Vancouver and New Years celebrations, they don't know how to control the Vancouver public so they say it's too expensive to police and shut down free public celebrations. All because of the Grey Cup riots in Vancouver so many years ago that has instilled FUD into the city's administration.

The RIAA and others will not succeed in thier campaigns, they haven't in the past and won't now.

Currently there is a supposed 210 Million dollars from CDROM taxes that has been imposed on blank CD's. The money was to compensate the artists for the losses of income through file sharing. Of course, after they have collected millions, the first objection raised has come into play:
"How will you distribute these funds fairly between the artists?

Now, if I bought CDR's and filled them with downloaded Muddy Waters, Howlin Wolf, Janis Joplin etc. will THEY get compensation or will Christina Aguillera get it? If paying a blank CD surtax will make P2P sharing acceptable, then the RIAA should get on the badnwagon and start roviding high bitrate music in P2P channels.

If I download a bootleg version of "Sympathy for the Devil" perfomed by Janes Addiction at a night club and then burn it to CD, who should receive the surtax for the blank CD's? Janes Addiction SHOULD but we know they won't. The record companies don't have a clue what's going on or how to control it. We've seen it during the VHS/BETA days, we've seen it when cassette decks and blank tapes were made, we see it when P2P is popular and now we see it in childrens plays.

They have no clue, neither do most of the public and as a result, FEAR, UNCERTAINTY and DOUBT shut it ALL down.

The way I see it, I am not getting quality audio from P2P applications, I'll check out a new song or artist and will generally buy the CD for the liner notes, cover art and higher quality.
A compressed MP3 for example cannot be played by mobilemusic companies at dances and cannot be used to gain a profit as it is such poor quaity.

Kazaa, Fileshare etc. MP3 downloads and CD WAV files are not even comparable when it comes to sound quality, how can you restrict such a garbage medium as MP3 files are by considering it reproduction?

by hal 9000

But the original move on this came from the recording industry who circulated a form letter to all the schools and the like to prevent the recording of childrens performances.

To me it seems that they want their cake and eat it to. Hey but what's new there and after all only a very small part of any monies collected end up in the pockets of the artists most of it ends up in the recording companies coffers anyway doesn't it?

by oz_media

Artist contracts vary depending on the representation they receive. The larger the label, the larger the star, the less money the artist makes. On average, an artist selling 150,000 copies/yr from smaller marketing efforts will net more than the average artist selling millions each quarter with a major label.

The majotr labels pay the artist on CD sales, not movie soundtracks, not residuals from radio, not sales of dolls and toys in the artists likeness, not even touring. In MOST cases, the artist gets a couple of points on retail CD sales, end of story.

Many artists (very successful artists)have gone bankrupt and bought out of contracts to seek smaller marketing avenues and venues for live performances. This is why we see once very largely marketed acts now playing smaller clubs and bars.

The successful acts, Rolling Stones, AC/DC, etc. Manage to make money by touring, not selling records. The labels know this and then only pay artists for CD sales, not shows. Artists make a few hundred thousand in CD sales, they then run up a few million in touring costs (fronted by the label, but not paid for by the label)and end up bankrupt. Once an artist is bankrupt and owing millions to the record company, the record company then offer to BUY the rights to the music to help pay back the debt. Now the artist has no music (owned now by the label), no money (in debt to the label) and no credibility (dragged through the mud by the press during bankruptcy).

This is the reason I am so boggled by those who stat a band and set out to FIND a label above all else. People have the mythical understanding that the labels get you to the top, they only help themselves stay at the top not the artist.

I was ready to keep going but I think I've strayed enough for one day.
Conclusion:
Labels are baaaaaad, 'kay?
Artists are good, 'kay?

by oz_media

I actually see another side to all this however I don't feel it applies to school kids.

When setting up live shows, I usually encourage the use of tape recorders and video cameras, it's great for getting the name spread around.

IF the band is playing any cover songs in thier setlist, I will get on the security staff and have them keep an eye out for Video Cameras and tape recorders, and confiscate any tapes found in the audience.

If a band plays a cover song, it is usually to breeak a setlist or change tempo by familiarity. If this was videotaped and then found to be a popular version of the original song, it would cirulate. Once press circulates, you are responsible for having licencing to the cover song played. You can play the song but not for profit. Now lets say that the video is NEVER sold for money but hits Kazaa or Fileshare, the people viewing the video MAY be swayed into buying CD's or concert tickets based on the cover song. This then equates to the band making money from someone else's material.

It's all very innocent until someone loses an eye!

by hal 9000

The opening post the way I did. I was specifically speaking about young children and in the new article that I saw the children in question ranged between 4 - 7 years old.

Personally I can't see how taping any of these kids would have any adverse affects on anyone especially the person/band who wrote the song.

I can't even see how these tapes would have an adverse affect on the record companies but they are appearing to want money to tape the kids so it just looks like the GREEDY recording companies trying to get even more money while at the samr time complaining about just how bad they are doing.

I could understand it if it involved older kids who where almost of a professional standard but I can't honestly see anyone being swayed into going to a concert or buying a CD/tape of the original artist on the strength of a 4 -7 year old kid singing a song, that is other than the parents so the kid can compare how they performed the song in comparision to an artist with the full backing of a Lable {and all the resources that come with that.} There is no child who could perform like Enya wha lays down 57 Harmony tracks to her main track as sounds like this just can not be reproduced on stage no matter how hard you try unless the performer is prepared to mime to a recording.

Actually come to think of that it is not so far fetched with all these new manfactured groups that are heavly pushed by the record companies, but honestly can you see a 4 -7 year old really competing?

by oz_media

of a Simpson's episode. Bart and the Boys get hired as a boy band...?

You're right Colin, it is rificulous overkill, as I assumed due to fear of repercussions.

Just drop on by Think Geek and get yourslef a little tie pin camera or something and screw the recording industry. Artists that are owned by labels hate file sharing because they are popular by representation. They only get paid from CD sales so they dip out, or so they think so, most 11 -14 year old kids can't afford too many CD's.

Artists that are independant, self signed and want to play their music, would rather people downloaded it and bought concert tickets instead. They make a living on touring because they can play live, these are the true musicians of the wolrd who deserve all the free play they can get, the radio stations won't give it to them because the labels own the radio stations.

Corporate,Commercial,Capitalist,Products.(CCCP?)

by hal 9000

I sent a copy of an old AC-DC 3/4 tape that I have here from the pre Back in Black days?

Back then they where just mucking around in a studio over here and I was driving the sound board and got feed up with their stupidity so I just told them to pick up their act or I was going home along with the tape of the session. They didn't improve so I left and took the tape with me and I've still got it here but as it hasn't been run through a player for a very long time it is probably suffering from print through.

But when they started getting big I always threatned Angus that I would make that tape public one day. Now days the only way I have to ciontact him is through their recording company and I'm sure what would happen if I sent a copy of that 16 Track tape over addressed as "Personal" to Angus. He would never hear of it and I'd be burried in legal papers for the rest of my life not a plesent thought but one day I'll copy it to CD and when I get the chance I'll give it to Angus and tell him the "remember When!"

by oz_media

I've had some demo recordings from pre B*B days even Pre, '74 Jailbreak, when they were REALLY starting out. I don't know what I could say or do to get even some sample bytes from you but if you can encode some samples, I give you my word it would be completely between you and I and would not be shared or sourced to you. Pipe dreams but you know, I have to ask.

I actually have a vinyl 45 picture disk recording of Rock'N Roll Damnation where Angus was out of breath and huffing and puffing all through the background of Bons vocals. It was obviously cutout of the album and rerecorded. Apparently, he'd had detention and RAN from school or the BUS to get to the studio, picked up his guitar and started the session. Knowing recording studios and hourly costs, I can see this happening quite easily.

by hal 9000

I'll run off a few wav. files and e-mail them to you, but I wouldn't hold my breath as 16 tracks tape decks are a bit hard to come by now days seems that most of them have been replaced with DAT decks and all the old 16 track units have just disapeared.

I've been looking out for one for several years now and I haven't seen one for sale and then just to add insult to injury the 4 track unit that I have can't be repaired by this countries distributer so when the manfactures agents who are a subdivision of the parent company can't fix something and just say buy a new one which they no longer sell you don't have too many options and that is only a twin track that will read in both directions. I don't know what would ever happen if I was to get my hands on a 16 track unit that needed repairing.

Col

by tomsal

If it were April I'd think this would almost be an April fools joke.

How pathetic. When does it end? One of things I've been saying to be lighthearted about things is "they'd tax our air if they could only find a way". My god, the more greed I see in the world -- the more ridiculous "laws" governments pass -- my god maybe they REALLY ARE working on a system to charge us for the air we breathe!

I wonder if the putz who heads the RIAA even has little kids?

by jkaras

I take it that this is only happening in Australia and not in all other countries? I am awestruck to the rediculous thought of denying a parent the right to document the progression of their children. What money will be lost taping their own children? I wont be downloading it off the internet nor anyone else. Even if the child becomes the next Pacino or Britney Spears and the parents sell the footage to networks for life story documentation the network pays out all licensing to whomever. I am not a parent and when I get the chance to be blessed with having children I will tape anything I choose and anyone getting in my face will pay a huge price (physically that is). It's bad enough that they are taking the "arts" out of school funding. Let's face it why would anyone want their children to express creativity?(dripping sarcasm) Train them young to fall into line and not think for themselves. I'm actually suprised that we are devolving as a society defining our existence by lawsuits and liability. What strikes me as funny/bizarre is that when a celebrity says or does something offensive we boycott and make them apologize but we say go ahead RIAA screw us some more as long as we get some entertainment? Maybe we are the cattle we were raised to be afterall?

by maxwell edison

.
Do you have a link to the news story? There seems to be something missing here.

You mentioned that the Organizers' Security person requested that the parent hand over the Video Camera. What school function or typical child activity has such security personnel? You mentioned the organizers of these concerts. Well, who are the organizers, and what kind of concerts are they?

If a parent is taping a child singing with the school choir or in a school play, there's certainly nothing to secure or protect. If a child is taking dance or singing lessons, and this is an event to showcase what they've learned, again, there's certainly nothing to secure or protect. However, if the child was performing with the Sydney Symphony Orchestra, then that's a different consideration entirely.

Can you be more specific with the details of the story? I can't help but think that there's more to this than initially meets the eye.

by hal 9000

todaytonight.com.au as they where the current affairs program which I saw the broadcast on and it didn't appear to be anything other than a simple school concert and even then for very young children from the fottage shown.

I can ony assume that it was a night concert and they had security on the door to prevent gate crashers or maybe thew TV station got it wrong and it was a represintive of the organiser who made the request either way I don't know any more than was reported on that particular incident.

However as my mother is involved witht he Speech and Drama Teachers Association they got a copy of a letter informing them that they may be in breach of copyrite if they allowed anyone to make copies of performances or thay made a copy.

It was the normal sought of legal garbage that was nothing more than vauge warnings but there was no mention of making payments only the warning and some information that they where currently working on a system to avoid this in future but judging by the contents of the letter and the way it was worded that would involve some form of payment that will be advised at some time in the future. Currently the Speech & Drama Teachers Association is waiting on the next letter to find out what is involved here and when it arrives I'll post the main thrust of the message here.

But from the fottage shown there was no major involment of any kind and it appeared to be in a school hall and not a major performance centre. The music palyed that the children sang to was all recorded so that might be what they where getting upset about as there was definatly no band involved but at the same time there where no vocals involved either that is other than the 3 children that where shown.

by stuart_at_oz

Col,

Where did you read this? Sounds like it may have been at something like the Rock Eistedfod (?) where they would have security, and probably would be concerned about video of the event, as they have television coverage and rights etc to think about.

I would be extremely indignant if someone told me I can't video my 9 or 11 y/o 's school concert, but then again those are never big enough to need security either :-)

Stuart
Canberra,
Australia

by hal 9000

A couple of nights ago. They had fottage secretly taken by one of the parents which only show very young children performing.

While it may have been a Rock Eistedford they only showed extremly young children performing. My mother is connected with the Queensland Speech & Drama Teachers Association and they got the same letter about any of their students who perform and that isn't even songs but prose and the like most of which is long out of copywrite.

I could possible get a copy of the letter but it plainly said that until they had worked out a methoid of paying for the use of copywrite material anyone who allowed the taping of performances and those who recorded the performances ran the risk of legal action. \

Sought of like SCO's open letterto all comerical Linux users, seems that it is a work in progress and they are relying on "FEAR Tatics" until they work out something that is in their favour.

I couldn't believe it when I saw the TV report and it was even more difictualt to believe when I saw the letter which no doubt has been passed on the the current President of the Association.

by hal 9000

It can be found with pictures at http://todaytonight.com.au//stories/839181.html

Naturally remove any spaces that have been inserted on the upload.

Ban on home movies

REPORTER: Catherine Kennedy
BROADCAST DATE: December 22, 2003

Parents love to record their children's school concerts but some venues have banned parents from filming and the law says you need permission. What are your rights?

At the end of each school year halls and theatres around Australia are always booked out for children's end of year concerts.
Parents are keen to see their little darlings display their talents and many like to record the performance on video.

John and Jane-Anne Devisser are like many proud parents. They want to remember each special moment of their children's lives.
"We just want to capture our children with their great big beaming smiles, their excited looks and just having fun," Mrs Devisser said.
One event the family didn't want to miss was eight-year-old Danielle's end of year ballet concert. Mr Devisser is proud of his daughter's great smile.

"He confiscated his camera and told him he could have it back at the end of the night."
Fearing the same would happen to him, Mr Devisser was forced to secretly film his daughter from between the chairs.

It turns out that still or video cameras are now forbidden during some children's concerts and many parents are familiar with this situation.
"We are not allowed to videotape those sequences and that music, just because it's under that copyright law," Mr Devisser said.
"And we're not interested in that, we are interested in our daughter and seeing her performance only, that's it."

It all sounds a bit heavy-handed. So who are the "Christmas concert Nazis"?
The answer lies in the copyright laws covering published music in concerts.

Richard Mallett from the Australasian Performing Rights Association (APRA) explains.
"If you are making a copy you require the owner's permission and you do that through a licensing arrangement," he said.

The Devissers tried to do the right thing one year, arranging a licence to film. But they discovered they were the only audience members to do so.

Others have different reasons to ban videotaping concerts. Ballet coach Carolan Hall believes the performance is the number one priority.

"Videoing, photographing, flash photos going when they're dancing, all of that is distracting," she said.

But the copyright law seems to have everybody spooked. Ms Hall says you can even be fined for filming a concert without a licence.

Could this mean birthday parties at home with music playing in the background shouldn't be videotaped unless you have a licence?

Mr Mallett said technically that's correct but APRA does not seek licences for those kinds of events.

But Mr Devisser says it goes against democracy and freedom of expression.
"If you can't videotape your daughter's expression on stage, what's going on?" he asked.

"What's happened to our freedom?"

by oz_media

A 16 track demo? I thought you were referring to a finished master. Damn, Colin that is one hell of a gift to own! I am without any doubt GREEN with envy. You lucky bastard!

I have a spare nut if that helps. I've already got one teenager/adult, you can have both.

I've had some older 16 and 24 track reels copied to DAT by a local recording studio, funny enough it was Mushroom records and Little Mountain Sound in Vancouver, that's where ACDC has recorded a few albums now. I think they like the old 24 track analog board at Little Mountain Sound, talk about warm guitar and excellent bass drum reverb!

Metallica recently released a horrible piece of junk called St. Anger, the eclectic drummer )Lars Ulrich) actually decided to do his own production and his snare has a ring like a freakin bell. Talk about low quality production. It was mastered with Pro Tools! Now there's a kiddie studio. He is also the guy who was the lead argument and agressor against Napster. Whiny little loser, as if he's hurting for money enough to deprive kids of thier favorite music. I feel sorry for the kids who went out and bought the new CD only to find it is garbage, compared to where they have evolved from anyway.

If you have time, I know you're not a metal fan, download a copy from somewhere and at least give it a listen, you'll be rolling on the floor when you realize these are professional musicians with many millions.

Bob Rock was the key to thier success, why be arrogant about it now?

Sorry, long segue but music gets me going ya know.

See ya round, take it easy.
Oz

by oz_media

Although a prefer a console it is a nice classic piece of equipment.

I actually had the luxury of working on a 24 track Tascan last night at a guitarists home studio (Money's nice huh). Now THERE'S a board!

OM

by hal 9000

I can just imange what would happen if I even attempted to buy it however as I've already just bought a Quad Xeon Tyan M'Board and my wife has just found out how much it was but currently doesn't know about the CPU's or the 16 X 146 GB SCSI HDD's.

They will be hard enough to explain even though she will not see them but something that big with the import from America would certianly draw hwer attention. I'd be walking around with a squeaky voice for the rest of my life and that's only if she was in a "Good Mood" when she found out, I don't even dare think what would happen if she found out about it when she was the slighest bit upset.

Last time I upset her she made me give away a $50,000.00 sound board to one of her friends who has a small Pub/Club band and if she was even to think that I was the slightest bit interested in getting back into that industry again well it just does not "beer" thinking about.

God that is the stuff "Night Mares" are made of even now I'm not allowed to go anywhere near the USA without an escort just to make sure I don't go anywhere near CA and buy some high performance VW parts.

by fluxit

I am not familiar with the Australian Constitution and human rights down under. However, the first principle that needs to be addressed is that humans are weighed slightly more than other social entities such as business, clubs, organizations, or animals. The purpose of business in the grand scheme is to provide everyone with a paycheck, modest lifestyle, and dignity. It concerned me when you seemed to place companies ahead of humans. "I?m the first to think that these companies need to protect their rights." In short, companies do not have rights only humans do. Check your Constitution.

Second, there is a concept of public inspection. If these performances are in a open space that has unrestricted access then they are open to the public viewing, recording, listening, and photographing of them for personal consumption without recourse.

Third, there is the issue of future potential. What if one of the kids becomes famous and thier image becomes copyrightable material? If these companies have videos they were selling having the image of one of these kids - does the kid have claim to the proceedings?

If your ask me these campanies are opening themselves to a can of worms.

by hal 9000

But it ios a completely diferent story having to defend this right in a Court of Law. It is in cases like this where all parties involved loose out.

This discussion is closed to new replies.