Discussion Locked

The best song of all time

0 helpful
488 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

488 replies

by jck

once I had an ingenious idea...

the local uni used these long, light blue garbage bags...I wasn't having any good ideas for a costume...

So, I had a brain storm, stole a bag off the janitors cart and proceeded home to make my costume with it.

Later that night, I stretched out a part the bottom with my head, made a hole in the side for my face, and then pulled it over my body...

I went that night as a condom with a reservoir tip. :)

I didn't get anything that night except for some dirty looks. :D

by jck

You just gotta save your pennies like me...I think Playboy is probably $10 an issue by now :(

by tony hopkinson

Def Leppard ?
For some reason I've got Europe's The Final Countdown looping in my head now. Going to have to play all my Slayer albums to exorcise Joey Tempest's ghost.

by mirrormirror

I know what you mean. I have this urge to dig up my Bon Jovi albums. Yes, I actually have vinyl albums stashed away somewhere.

by tony hopkinson

admit I wasn't unfortunate enough to hear that one. Fairport Convention's version did me in.
How about Belinda Carlisle's version of The White Room.
I've been known to sing a long to my favourites as well, I'd never do the disservice of recording them though.

by anykey???

Wow,I read about a third of these and feel like I'm hangin with my bestest buds, and boy do things get taken way off course.
One glaringly obvious omission that I've seen is no mention of Duane Allman, greatest natural talent of all time,I bet he plays slide for god himself...
as for my choice for best song of all time.
Jessica-Allman Bros.
Stealin-Uriah Heap
Sun Spot Baby-Seger
and any thing else that needs turned up too eleven to be properly appreciated.

Remember, If a reboot don't work the BFH will make you feel better about workin on it.

by craig herberg

I fell in love with her music when I heard her on WAMU (I think -- the campus radio station for American University, in Washington, DC). She played at the Carter Barron Amphitheater in DC, and it was heavenly. . .

by jellimonsta

My wife and I met at a summer camp where quite often campers needed the 'silver bullet'. The Halloween after camp my wife went as a doctor and I went as a suppository. We actually won the prize for best couples costume.
Apparently, I am still a pain in the a$$ :)

by craig herberg

I did not like him in concert, but his records. . .
Once played Dynamo Hum for a lady friend, and she proclaimed it "Too chocolate for my taste!" Nobody EVER accused Zappa of writing tasteful music.

by jck

Technics SL-BD22 FG-Servo turntable...still works...and I have lots of JT, CSN, Clapton, and other guys to play on it on occassion. :)

by craig herberg

About four or five boxes of Hendrix, Cream, Who, Derek and the Dominos, Carly Simon, Eagles, Beatles, Moody Blues, John Lee Hooker, and tons of others lay in my basement for many years. Some day. . .

by oz_media

I have Harman Kardon and a Mission turntables, in almost daily use. Both use the Mission cartridges too and just ROCK!

by craig herberg

My Technics 1200, filled with damping material and lead pellets, connected to Sure tone arm and strain guage phone cartridge, went into retirement when my older boy was born seventeen years ago.

by maecuff

Wow, I thought my husband having 1000 albums and two working turntables was a bit psychotic..you have him beat :)

by mirrormirror

I do!! It is old as well but it still works. I had to demonstrate it to my kids. They were amazed that we were so primitive.

by jellimonsta

I have around 100 vinyl albums. A lot of them are 80's rock and metal that were given to me when I purchased the record player from a friend of my wife (for $15). :)
I do have some limited edition Ozzy, Soundgarden and Faith No More picture discs though, (that was the reason I went looking for a record player again).

by craig herberg

She had a snake for a pet
And an amulet
And she was breeding a dwarf
But she wasn't done yet
She had gray-green skin
A doll with a pin
I told her she was alright
But I couldn't come in

Camirillo Brillo

Don't you just love it?

by jck

I've wanted to get a peek at her since I was 17...damn...who says dreams don't come true?????? :D

by oz_media

You are seeing just eh US music industry. See really, the US industry is an entity of it's own. Has VERY little influence on the rest of the world as most people know it is a complete farce, except the kids that are sucked into wasting their money everyday.

As I said though, the rest of the world has a very unique and opportunistic industry, and that's EXACTLY why I stay so busy. Too many people lookign to find new deals or find a first deal OUTSIDE of what some consider the music industry of the world.

by oz_media

They sell those (full body condoms) at joke store here, and then there's the little rubber cap/hat with the reservoir tip too.

Perhaps someone saw you and thought you had a good idea afterall.

by oz_media

I was thinking about the same. I haven't taken an inventory since the late 80's but I did get a bunch of racks from a friend that closed a record store.

I made one more so I'd say it's a pretty close tie between Max and I. I certainly don't have the interest in doing a count, but I've always guessed 4000-5000 or so.

I also have several thousand CD's and raw DAT's but I think digital music is pretty lame for the most part so they are catalogued and stored.

So hey Max, thought about upping your offer for that Abbey Road yet? LoL ;)

Just kidding, I'll hang onto that one for quite a few more years yet.

by oz_media

He'll start spinning records backwards and trash your tone arm and cartridge. :D

I think they just do that these days because the album isn't worth listening to, may as well make some funny scratching noises with it, better than the album itself.

by maxwell edison

.
For those who don't know the "inside reference".

A year or more ago, we were having a similar discussion (music), and our respective record collections came up. In the course of conversation, Oz mentioned a particular Abbey Road album that he had.

In the mid to late 70s, a company called MFSL, Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab.....

http://members.aol.com/boardwalk7/mofi/mofi.html

.....released a number of records that were digitally remastered, thereby improving the sound quality enormously. Although not as desirable as the original recordings in one sense (of which I have bunches and bunches), they are more desirable in another sense -- namely, sound quality. Anyway, I surmised that the way Oz described it (by memory without the benefit of seeing it), that it was probably MFSL's copy of Abbey Road that he was talking about. I offered him $50, and he turned me down. (Abbey Road will probably go for around $150 on ebay if it's in pristine condition.

Okay, I'll give you $60.

by oz_media

You DO have a good sense of humour don't you!

Thanks for the details on the recording, as I said, for now it's in another country with some other collectibles (a gold album or two)where I can't get at them to sell them. I used to buy and sell stuff lke that all the time, have made more than one regrettable deal and since hav learned to hang onto my 'treasures' for a time where I have some sense.

Thanks again for the chuckle Max! Despite all of our differences I think we have found more in common sometimes than either of us is willing to admit. :)

by jck

used to be a store at the mall in Oklahoma City that had those too.

I bought one for my buddy in high school when he said he was doing his first girlfriend.

Told him it was "just in case". hahaha

by jamesrl

Who worked at a couple of different record companies and who was a trading maniac. He ended up with about 12,000 albums. He would trade promo copies of his label's artists for promo copies of other labels' artists.

Helping him move was a huge chore, because there were so many milk crates full of records to move. The sofa and bed were nothing in comparison.

I was there when he decided to liquidate much of his collection in the late 80s. He sold them to a used record store for fraction of what they would be worth today. He let me cherry pick a few albums any time I did a favour for him. I still have some pretty good CBS masterworks classical albums, some experimental jazz and some of the remastered super hi fi discs that Max was referring too.

And yes I have a turntable, a technics, but not a Linn turntable, which excellent though it may be, is a little too pricey for me.

I remember the turntables at the university radio station, with wooden arms and massive 18 inch platters. They could easily be spun backwards and we did.

James

by itgirli

Bobby Brown was a great one. The first time I heard that I thought I would piss myself.

by maecuff

prompted my husband weed out his collection. Moving. He said that moving all my books was a pain in the ass, to which I replied, his records were no less a pain in the ass. We both conceded the point and gave away some of our collections. We're still overrun with music and books, but at least, with a little work and disguises, our house is presentable.

As long as no one looks on my side of the bed. I have a table that has books stacked on top and underneath, and a small mountain beside the table. It drives my husband crazy, he can't understand how I can have 4 different books going at the same time.

by jck

If I'd have grown up outside the USA, I'd probably have been a musician.

Love music...but, the idea of working to make a record company rich seemed stupid...and touring to make pennies while some record exec sits and talks to his wife and takes profits from my hard work...yeah...that turned me off too.

Plus, I hate being in front of a crowd or a camera...so...wouldn't have been a task for me to take.

by maxwell edison

.
.....I movie sound track.....I blues.....I big-band.....and yes, I even have some (ugh) Wayne Newton.

I absolutely love my record collecting hobby. I buy and sell them on ebay, look for the bargains at flea markets and such, go to the record collectors' expos (setting up a booth of my own from time to time), and I must admit that it's kinda' fun to have something that a visitor might request, regardless of the genre or era. (My mother once asked for some Tiny Hill big-band, and it was playing in 2 minutes.) I have mostly LPs, but a fair number of 45s, 10" LPs, some EPs, and several hundred 78s. It's frustrating, however, to "know I have it", but I can't find it. Only about 25 percent of my collection is organized enough to go right to it. (I'm still looking for that Bob Dylan Freewheelin' album that I promised to send to Julian.)

I collect them not only for the music and/or nostalgia, but album art and album covers are another interest. Some of the artwork is absolutely outstanding, and I have several framed albums hanging around the house. Right now I'm on a quest to find some Beatles "copy-cats" or labels that exploited the Beatles (and British) invasion. The Beetle Beat (Bee...instead of Bea...), The Liverpool Sound, Beatle Mania recordings, the Supremes did a Liverpool album, Chet Atkins (the best guitar player of all time) "Picks on The Beatles" (I'm looking for a pristine Stereo copy), and on it goes.

And I just recently added something to my collection that I've been seeking for a long time: an absolutely pristine Stereo copy of the movie soundtrack Casino Royale. It's not extremely valuable, it probably tops out at $150 for a sealed item, but I picked mine up for $25 on ebay, still in the original shrink, a perfect cover, and a shiny gloss vinyl without even the slightest scratch that looks like it was pressed yesterday. It's a sought after record because of the outstanding Stereo sound quality engineered by a younger Phil Ramone, and some pretty neat arrangements by Burt Bacharach and Herb Alpert and his Tijuana Brass. Using your words, this record really "rocks", but in its own way. (And a pretty neat funky cover as well.)

I'm pretty loaded up with Beatles stuff, about 60 pieces, some of which are pretty rare and valuable. (I still need a good Butcher Cover album, however.) A lot of 50s, 60s and 70s rock and pop. A good amount of jazz, a lot of it on the Blue Note label. I could have a disco party, a western swing party, a rockin' out party, a flashback to 1920 or 1930, candle-light dinner mood music (Jackie Gleason's orchestra is great for this kind of mood - yea, that Jackie Gleason), or just about any other "mood" we might want.

I love to break out my Napoleon XIV album (They're coming to take me away, ha, ha......) for some laughs, or my Bob Newhart, or Alan Sherman, or.......

(I guess I kinda' went off on another tangent, there, didn't I?)

by oz_media

Of course it will Max, whether we like it or not.

$5.99 (er....uh....yeah sure, I'll get right on that) :D.

by maxwell edison

.
It's at $56.99 right now, not $5.99. My guess is that it will sell for over $100, maybe as high as $140+.

(The fact that it's still sealed will drive up the price.)

by awalt

where life is beautiful all the time and I'll be happy to see those nice young men in their clean white coats... That's just about all I can remember for now. I have that on 45. Boy did I get a kick out of that as a kid. The flip side is the song backwards.

As for Herb Albert and the Tijauana Brass, well, it just wasn't (and still isn't) Christmas at my Dad's house until we crank up Herb's Christmas album.

Thanks for the memories Max.

by oz_media

Never been played, hasn't been touched in quite a few years now.

But I have a lot more far more valuable goodies (to me) than that. I just knew it would be worth SOMETHING one day so I decided to put it away and hang onto it, it IS the Beatles after all.

by maecuff

I'm not a country and western fan, however, some time ago, my husband and I had tickets to see Dick Dale and a Western Swing band opened for him, Big Sandy and the Fly Right Boys. They were really good, you might want to check them out.

I never did get to see Dick Dale, I had too many beers before the show, kind of fell asleep at our table after Big Sandy and missed the show.

by maxwell edison

.
"Red Tricycle" is song one:

Napoleon XIV
They're Coming to Take Me Away, Ha-Haaa!
Warner Bros. Records W/WS1661 (1966)
Rhino Records (reissue 1983)

My copy is the original Warner Bros. Records Mono version album (getting an original Stereo copy is on my want list), but there's been a reissue of that album by Rhino Records on CD. You could probably find it most anywhere if you look.

http://www.powersalad.com/music/napoleon.htm

It's good for some chuckles, and the kids like it as well.

Remember when you ran away
And I got on my knees
And begged you not to leave
Because I'd go berserk

Well you left me anyhow
And then the days got worse and worse
And now you see I've gone
Completely out of my mind

And they're coming to take me away ha-haaa
They're coming to take me away ho ho hee hee ha haaa
To the funny farm
Where life is beautiful all the time
And I'll be happy to see those nice young men
In their clean white coats
And they're coming to take me away ha haaa

You thought it was a joke
And so you laughed
You laughed when I said
That losing you would make me flip my lid

Right? You know you laughed
I heard you laugh. You laughed
You laughed and laughed and then you left
But now you know I'm utterly mad

And they're coming to take me away ha haaa
They're coming to take me away ho ho hee hee ha haaa
To the happy home with trees and flowers and chirping birds
And basket weavers who sit and smile and twiddle their thumbs and toes
And they're coming to take me away ha haaa

I cooked your food
I cleaned your house
And this is how you pay me back
For all my kind unselfish, loving deeds
Ha! Well you just wait
They'll find you yet and when they do
They'll put you in the A.S.P.C.A.
You mangy mutt

And they're coming to take me away ha haaa
They're coming to take me away ha haaa ho ho hee hee
To the funny farm where life is beautiful all the time
And I'll be happy to see those nice young men
In their clean white coats

And they're coming to take me away
To the happy home with trees and flowers and chirping birds
And basket weavers who sit and smile and twiddle their thumbs and toes
And they're coming to take me away ha haaa!

.
.
.
.
.

(I seem to remember posting these lyrics once before -- with some changes, of course, to fit the circumstances -- in a message I posted to flame Oz. At least I humored myself.)

by craig herberg

Since he and his friend completely dismantled my oscilloscope while I was at work many years ago, I think I will wait until the kids are on their own -- in thirty or forty years :-)

by oz_media

Th original SHOSK rocker Alice Cooper has a reasonably new radio show, Nights with Alice Cooper, that is broadcast from his hometown in Arizona.

There some great audio clips with him interviewing Kelsey Grammar, Ozzy, DIO and others.

Kinda cool hearing him catch up with Ozzy, Ozzy starts out REALLY rough but settles into the conversation as his nerves settle a bit. Kelsey Grammar's interview is pretty cool too.

http://www.nightswithalicecooper.com/

by jck

too sedate for my blood.

I bet he's scared of the FCC like everyone else is right now, even after Herr Fuhrer Powell has announced his resignation.

Friggin amazing. They beeped out "laid" on Howard Stern this morning. I don't get it. I learned that word in school, not off the radio. What are people friggin thinkin.

Thought police are next, I tell you. Just wait...you'll see.

by oz_media

Listening to him interviewing Joe Perry of Aerosmith right now.

It's cool because he interviews so many 'old friends' and they all talk about how rock bands that all survived all had the same hardworking, guitar driven, garage band background.

Both Joe Perry and Ozzy both bring up how GNR screwed themselves out of a career with Axel Rose too, funny how they all see the same difference between the way rock was then and the way it is now, but everyone gives props to Slash as a hard working and talented guitar player.

by itgirli

Is, in my opinion (and just my opinion), is the biggest waste of human flesh. I was not amused by him when I was 12 and I'm not amused by him now. He outlived his use to society. What a pathetic piece of garbage. Ignorance, pure, f-ing ignorance. The fact that people continue to listen to such refuse leads me to continue in my beliefs that the majority of our society is absolute ignorant swill.

by jellimonsta

... I would want to spend the night with Alice Cooper. "Nights with Eva Longoria and/ or Salma Hayek" maybe, but Alice... noooo!! :)

by oz_media

That depends and it would be a tough decision ut as for hangin out, I'd take Alice any day of the week. Have met him only twice, once was very briefly if that, but he's one of the coolest dudes in the business.

His touring Guitarist (Pete Friesen) owns a studio and has done some really top end recording and mixing for bands I used to work with. Never heard ANYTHING negative about Alice, he's got the respect of the whole industry.

Now, Eva Longoria and Selma Hayek, there's a history that would put any shock rocker to shame. "I dont want to know about that" comments would be present I think.

But I'd rather hang out with someone 'real' before anyone with that kind of overblown celebrity status any day. As for looks, well there are women just as good looking all over the place, big deal.

Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't kick them out of bed for eating crackers, but I wouldn't be buying the crackers for them.

by jck

fact is tho, he's stayed in radio for 30 years now. Quite successfully, I might add.

Well, I'm swill and an a**hole now.

I'll have to put that on the resume.

by oz_media

And from what I've seen and heard, thank god.

BUT, we have Bryan Adams manager Bruce Allen instead. He is seen by most as a hard a$$ed, opinionated pr*** though others see him differently.

He's actuallly a really nice guy in real life though, and a VERY clever guy that knows everything there is to know (and WHO) in the industry worldwide. He knows what he is talking about and usually makes a solid point, especially when it comes ot the business of music and the players on the field.

But fom what I've seen of Howard Stern, he's just a knob with opinions. (Don't say it) ;)

by jck

from someone like Rush Limbaugh. Loved he used to say "I'm right 97% of the time." with all his drivel, and then a political group actually started checking his facts and he was actually only right less than 50% of the time.

Too many blow hard sensationalists out there. At least Stern doesn't cover up stuff with lies and propaganda. He gets to the point, whether soccer moms like it or not.

Stern isn't that bad, Oz. He's just a lot of juvenile rhetoric that is akin to Beavis and Butthead if they actually ever did get inside the nudie bar. That's all.

by tomsal

I'll admit he made me laugh a couple times back during my high school days (which back then it was "cool" to be a Stern fan).

But over time I've tried to listen to him here and there...just not funny at all to me anymore. Its the same old stuff -- just trashy talk and being an a$$ non-stop...

It just so damn boring anymore and now he's annoying to me after only like 5 minutes.

Hence, I never listen to him at all and haven't for a couple years now.

by jamesrl

He did manage to get some CRTC complaints, but in the end the market faded away and the show was dropped.

I was never a fan.

James

by tomsal

/begin rant

...is when folks defend someone who has no talent as sucessful merely basing that success on popularity within a specific group (whether that group is 20 or 20,000,000 strong).

Stern has no talent, his "success" is because millions of folks listen to him...why? Well we are all individuals some may be warped in the head (when it comes to Stern I wouldn't doubt it..lol), some have very lax senses of humor, and others just don't really care what's on during their trek to the office through horrible traffic so they leave it on..."hey its something to listen too" mentality.

Either way -- with 6 billion people on the planet, 300 million of which are in the USA, you are bound to get a few million to listen to you when you are broadcast all over the country. Some stay listening to Stern because they hate him -- strange I know, but true..I call this "car wreck syndrome" (no its horrible, but I can't look away...ahhhh).

Furthermore on my rant here....folks write that Brittany Spears is a talent...BAH! She's horrible, but millions buy her crap -- for the same reasons as above.

Rap I think is talentless drivel, yet Rap is one of the most popular "music" (used very loosely here) of the times.

Success through popularity doesn't mean squat to me, is the bottomline.

/end rant

PS. JCK -- I'm not saying you said he did have talent btw...I'm just talking in general. lol

by maxwell edison

.
(Disclaimer: I'm expressing neither a like or dislike for either Howard or Britney, or whatever it is they may or may not do.)

For someone to be able to amass a fortune into the tens of millions of dollars, there has to be some talent that was tapped into in some way. Whether it be a singing talent, or speaking talent, or witty talent, or marketing talent, or persuasion talent, or Monica talent, or whatever, to suggest that a successful person and "happy with what they do" person doesn't have talent is just down-right silly.

You may not think Britney Spears has any talent, for example, but she can do whatever appeals to hoards of young teenagers, or at least what they've been convinced appeals to them. Could you emulate her and make tens of millions of dollars in the in the process? If not, who's really lacking the "talent" (to do that particular thing)?

Jimi Hendrix had no talent, at least according to millions of people. However, there are millions of others who would disagree.

Janis Joplin had no talent, at least according to millions of people. However, there are millions of others who would disagree.

Bob Dylan has no talent, neither/either singing and/or song writing, at least according to millions of people. However, there are millions of others who would disagree.

Rush Limbaugh and/or Howard Stern and/or Al Franken have no talent (on loan from God, or otherwise), at least according to millions of people. However, there are millions of others who would disagree -- including not only their listeners, but the curators of their respective bank accounts as well.

To critique someone's talent, or lack thereof, is to see it and judge it through the prism of your own preferences and/or experiences. Even if Britney Spears is merely a puppet of her handlers, she certainly has the talent to go where the strings are pulling her. And she has the tens of millions of dollars in her pockets to prove it. I sure wish I had as much talent in my pockets.

by jck

you're right...I didn't say he was talented. He is successful at what he does, which in a nutshell is...to get ratings.

He's been on and off in more cities than I can name (I think over 80 total), but the current number he's on has gone down since the run-in with Clearchannel, the FCC getting ultra-conservative, etc.

I am not saying there's no part of his show I dislike...I've had times it bored me to death within 10 minutes and I turned it off...there were times that Stern has actually made me think "now that's low..." and changed the station. But, I'd rather listen to him question a Playboy bunny about sleeping with Heff than listen to Limbaugh drone on about how great Bush is for a half hour in the morning.

As for Britney Spears...she has talent...she is just not incredibly talented. She's a cute girl who did a video, got famous with older guys, then went all wild. She's pretty much done for now.

Not a rap fan either. nuff said.

Success through popularity...I've never strived for it...so, I can't say I make it a priority. But, I won't knock someone for doing their job well. Stern has done that.

by jck

Two words: William Hung

The guy has *zero* performance talent...and, he's made a couple million already.

He's had good success...no talent.

There's exceptions to every rule.

by jellimonsta

Hehe, my Dad eats Jacobs crackers in bed all the time. It drives my Mom nutz!! She is always getting jabbed in the back in the middle of the night by his cracker shards! :)
I was being facetious, they are some beautiful women, but probably about as deep as a puddle. I do not really know much about Alice as a person so I was not passing any judgement.
However [q] "Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't kick them out of bed for eating crackers, but I wouldn't be buying the crackers for them." [/q]
I must say I am a little shocked that a high roller like yourself Oz, would not shout the ladies a box of Ritz :)

by oz_media

See, that's why you ALWAYS go to THEIR place and not yours.

Then she knows where everything in the kitchen is, otherwise you keep getting woken up when they can't find the omelette pan or egg beater.

by jellimonsta

I have been married almost 7 years so my wife is the only one who knows where the egg beater is anyway (in fact I don't even know what an egg beater looks like) :).
I doubt those girls do eat though, they probably only like their weight to fluctuate by a couple of ounces. :)

by jellimonsta

I have never listened to him on the radio, however I have noticed he is on late at night on one of the TV stations.
I do not watch him either, pretentious drivel if you ask me (although I know you didn't) :).
I rarely listen to the radio as most the time is it some jock strap spouting off his mouth. I turned it on to listen to music not some moron stating his opinions or version of the truth.

by jck

His show has gotten more sedate in the past 10 years. I remember him doing the TV show in NJ on cable. It was funny as hell.

I don't know if it's because he's lost it, or because the FCC fining people and tightening rules so much that even ABC affiliates are scared to show "Saving Private Ryan" because they can be fined up to 250,000 per incident for indecency violations is just ridiculous.

Even "family values" broadcasters get scared now over the FCC regulation changes. In fact, a television evangelist somewhere got fired the other day because, when asked if he thought the Pope was going to Heaven or Hell and he believed because the Pope hadn't been "saved" that he'd go to Hell, someone complained about him and his station/broadcaster dropped him because of him talking about the Pope going to Hell.

amazing...I'll find the news story if I can

by tomsal

I disagree with your post that success means talent, mostly yes - but not always.

And...morever....I was in a mood to rile things up, sincerely I could give a rat's arse.

I still think Stern and Spears are T-A-L-E-N-T-L-E-S-S.

And money proves nothing in their case, just that the world has lots of idiots. ;)

(just kidding)

by jamesrl

I would agree that these people have talents - we all do to some extent. Whether or not we admire their talents is another question.

Britany may not be the best female singer around, she may not sing better than an American Idol winner, but her talent combined with her looks, professional management and marketing etc., combine to create a success. Likewise I don't appreciate Howard Stern, but he has a talent for capturing attention by doing outrageous things.

James

by craig herberg

[at being successful]

How true and sad. This also explains why we have formula pop artists making $$$, and truly creative musicians starving in smoky clubs, because the record companies want commercial, not original.

by jellimonsta

I found this regarding the evangelist guy...

[ Marty Minto, 39, a senior pastor at a New Castle church, was fired Friday after three years as a host on WORD-FM in Pittsburgh. He said he was told that he was alienating listeners.

"As far as I'm concerned, I was doing what I've always done on the radio -- look at events around the world from a biblical perspective. I've always been willing to talk about controversial subjects," said Minto, who has had shows in Albany, N.Y., Denver and Phoenix. ]

Personally I think the guy is a moron to state the Pope is going to Hell. I am sure the Pope believed Jesus was his personal savior and the Pope 'wanted' to be in Heaven at His right hand. Sure, good works will not get you into Heaven, but I am pretty sure the Pope is not going to Hell.

by oz_media

Michael Moore had no talent, at least according to millions of people. However, there are millions of others who would disagree.

John Kerry had no talent, at least according to millions of people. However, there are millions of others who would disagree.

George W.Bush had no talent, at least according to millions of people. However, there are millions of others who would disagree.

OzMedia had no talent, at least according to millions of people. However, there are millions of others who would disagree.

Isn't that just a cop out Max?

by maxwell edison

.
.....that success doesn't involve talent, of one kind or another, and/or to one degree or another, then you and I have a different way of defining success.

I challenge you to name one successful person and/or one successful attempt at achieving something that didn't involve the application, of one kind or another, and/or to one degree or another, of a someone's talent.

The edited part:

P.S. I suppose that was a rather silly "challenge", since you'll just name the people you already have named. So I guess we'll just agree to disagree, and I'll go away thankful that I don't think like you.

by oz_media

The Greatest Rock'n Roll Swindle of the all.

A bass player that had NO idea how to play a single chord, a 'vocalist' (who arguably has image talent, but that was crafted by someone else, at least the successful part of his image), a drummer that had never played before.

Truly the only talent present in the Sex Pistols was Malcom McLaren, the manager that MADE them and got them on stage.
Truly the first packaged band, Back Street Boys eat your heart out.

by tomsal

Calm down there Sparky..you sound like you are getting too emotional charged over what was my heavy laden sarcasm.

One thing - I know you are stubborn on your points you feel strong about...so am I. You can write a billion replies...won't sway my stand.....TALENT DOES NOT ALWAYS EQUAL SUCCESS!! Don't confuse someone's ability at luck or seizing opportunity as talent, which I think you are. You are calling everything a "talent" and THAT is truly where our thoughts part.

Talent to me is not luck, is not chance, is not merely seizing the opportunity. If someone has the SMARTS to seize opportunity that's being smart and decisive, but its not a talent.

Brittany Spears HAS NO TALENT for singing, this is how I feel -- rant what you will...my opinion in this is absolute.

JCK proved my point..with William Hung.

Another thing is you are saying "I'm glad I don't think like you".....that's fine....you constantly equate success as only a dollar value --- so I'm VERY glad I don't think like YOU.

If you think a measure of success is merely how much money one makes, that's VERY sad.

Under your theory of money = success and success means you have talent....someone who wins the $200 million lottery is talented?

Everything is not a talent. That's my whole point. Talent to me is consistently repeatable. Otherwise its just an ability or "knack"....or luck!

by jamesrl

But he was brave enough to audition, and keep his head high.

I would suggest someone was talented enough to promote him, despite his lack of ability to stay in tune.

James

by jamesrl

I can't speak for Max, but I am sure he would agree. Michael Moore has some talents.

Just not a talent for making fair and objective documentaries. Though neither were the people who made the anti-John Kerry swift boat movies. They were both talented in their way - as propagandists. Al Franken has a talent - for being funny and serious at the same time.

I don't dismiss everything Moore says as crap, the same way I don't dismiss everything that say, Rush Limbaugh says. I listen, think about their viewpoint, their biases, their history, and I put in context.

James

by itgirli

No, I wasn't referring to anyone here.
But on topic, William Hung is very good at sounding bad. His talent is sounding bad and being marketable for it.

by jck

I think a previous poster is right. The real talent is the talent agent who saw him and thought "That kid is a gold mine. Who can disrespect a nice polite humble asian kid who 'did his best'. That'd be like booing a retarded kid singing the national anthem at an NFL game."

Talent implies a quality of excellence not common to most individuals. I know a lot of people that can't sing and are incredibly nice and personable.

What you're saying is somewhat akin to putting a monkey in front of a computer and watching him bang on the keyboard and saying "Hey that monkey is cute...and look at him use that keyboard! Boy, he's so talented at computers."

William Hung is a nice guy and he's marketable, but not talented.

Apples and oranges...definitely.

by maxwell edison

.
All of those people you mentioned have an enormous amount of talent. And it only illustrates my point even further. Just because I don't particularly care for Michael Moore, for example, neither his style or his content, I would never suggest that he has no talent. He's extremely talented at what he does.

My only point was this. Just because you may not like what he (or she) does, it doesn't mean the person is lacking in talent. And if a person suggests that Britney Spears isn't talented, regardless of whether they like her or not, they're only showing their own contortionist talents of getting their head planted..........well, never mind.

by jck

I think that's God's place.

I figure I'm going to hell..that's about it.

by jck

I can see it now on A&E biography:

"William Hung was destined for greatness. This no-talent talent was, despite his awkward appearance, came to be loved by all for his shy, modest demeanour. At age 7 after noticing his talent at no-talent, William's parents enrolled him at the Julliard School's innovative program for talentless singing. William excelled in every area, despite thoughts that he might not have enough no-talent."

Jeez...this discussion is a Douglas Adams novel. Anyone for a cup of no-tea?

by maxwell edison

.
First of all, I'm not getting "emotional" at all. If anything, I'm getting anal.

Words mean things - specific things - and people constantly misuse the English language. Britney Spears has a talent for _______________ (something - fill in the blank), so to suggest she has none is not only ignorant, but mean-spirited. Personally speaking, I believe each and every one of us has a talent to do a lot of things. And applying that talent to achieve a predetermined goal is what I would call success. Whether or not that goal involves the acquisition of money is immaterial. So I do not, as you suggested, "constantly equate success as only a dollar value". However, the acquisition of money is a fact of life in today's world, and to not admit that is the epitome of ignorance. Moreover, for all you people who even suggest that the quest to acquire money is a bad thing, I would say this. Get off you're friggin' high-horse, put your own money where your mouth is, and give all of yours back to whomever gave it to you. Or are you the type of person who simply presumes to tell another person when he or she has earned enough?

By the way, you can take your condescending "Sparky" type comments and shove it. (And if you want to think that's "emotional", I don't really give a rat's behind.)

by tomsal

"My only point was this. Just because you may not like what he (or she) does, it doesn't mean the person is lacking in talent. And if a person suggests that Britney Spears isn't talented, regardless of whether they like her or not, they're only showing their own contortionist talents of getting their head planted..........well, never mind."

Do you really want to start a flame war with me..just be upfront about...I will NOT back down. Apparently you take things way to serious some times.

Don't piss me off....I'm not one to lay down easy.

Your starting to piss me off. so STF up.

by jamesrl

Getting personal with someone here only serves to disinterest others, and frankly debases your arguments.

If you wanna throw personal inhectives around, do it by email.

If you want to drive away people from discussing things on TR, keep up the rhetoric. But don't forget to shut the door if you are the last one out.

James

by hal 9000

That they have toned it down quite a bit since the OLD DAYS it must be their age catching up with them. :D

But it just reminds me of a TV add over here where a guy walks into a so called "Music Store" and asks the pimply faced youngster behind the counter for a CD of the WHO. It gets the kid totally confused and he has to run to the manager for help as he has no idea of what the person is asking for. :)

Col ]:)

by maxwell edison

.
TomSal, the reply you quoted was in a message to Oz, not you. If you read into that message a reference to you, so be it. But why should I care?

TomSal, you said, "Your (sic) starting to piss me off. so STF up"

Again, why should I care? If you want to get pissed off there's nothing I can do about it, nor do I care. Get pissed off all you want, Sparky.

by maecuff

Some of you need to take a walk around the block... Be nice or you'll have to listen to William Hung singing all of Britney's songs.

by maecuff

What do you mean the Sex Pistols have no talent? What is wrong with you, you putz. I still enjoy listening to the Sex Pistols. Okay, technically, they may not be the best, but..but.. okay.

I didn't really mean any of that, I just wanted to go off on someone, it looks like fun.