Discussion Locked

The biggest election irony

0 helpful
150 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

150 replies

by tonythetiger

was going to be "Reagan" before he got into office. I mean, ANYONE from California just couldn't be good for the whole country, right?

Now that the election is over, Obama is "our man" now. To not want the best for him and the best from him is petty and un-American.

by jdclyde

How many people are not wage earners?

Something that has always bothered me is the people that get back more in their tax return than they paid in. X-(

by tonythetiger

[i]The quadrupling of the federal deficit.[/i]

unless you're one of those WATB protectionists.

Protectionism is cheating. If we can't compete without cheating, we're a pretty sorry lot.

by nicknielsen

I meant "quadrupling the national debt."

My brain must have stuttered while I was typing.... ;)

by jck

Ironically, Barack Obama's campaign had nearly triple the number of donations under $200 as John McCain's campaign.

67 percent of John McCain's contributors donated $2300 or more.

If Obama taking small donations is "buying elections", then taking 67 percent of your campaign contributions in the amount greater than the average American nets per month...i might label "buying influence".

check the numbers. they're interesting

http://www.opensecrets.org

by tonythetiger

of Obama's donations are untraceable. Since donors who donate less than $200 don't legally have to be identified. For all we know, they could have come from the same source, and not necessarily American!

Of course, that reflects on the donor(s), not on Obama. He's in now, and until the next election, our duty is to let him know how he can best represent us. If he's an honest representative, he'll listen. I'll pray for him and for all of us.

by jck

He's got a lot of stuff to fix that the current administration has f***ed up.

I wonder if he'll make me Ambassador to Ireland? WOOHOO!!!!!!!!!

by maxwell edison

Didn't Mickey Mouse donate? He lives in that castle in southern CalEfornia. (Not a typo - did it for Governor Terminator.)

by jck

Apparently according to their/someone else's research, about 61% of the people who voted for Obama...were "white".

You're right...it wasn't about race, except to the press who wants a story to spin...and the ignorant biggots who still think they're living in 1940s Mississippi.

He's American. That's what matters.

by jdclyde

http://www.cnn.com/ELECTION/2008/results/polls/#USP00p1

but then again, when people play around throwing stats around....

A cnn chart, so take it for what it is worth. I did notices for all the pretending it is upper class, enlightened Democrats, the biggest voting block for bama was the under 50k block. (the people getting the payouts from obama policies). funny how that works.

by jck

John McCain took, essentially, what is campaign "welfare" (money collected by the government, pooled, and handed out to people wanting it and doing nothing for it).

Ironic...the candidate from the party that wants hand-outs to end...took the hand-out.

Shouldn't a campaign be run like a business? More people liked Obama, so they bought into his candidacy?

Personally, I think the campaign reform should be more like...cap donations at $50 per person/organization/household/address.

Then, it would be a fair shake.

by cupcake

Frankly, I won't debate with someone who turns to insults and name calling. I suppose it suppose to bully me into answering, but I am now withdrawing my participation in any future political discussions on this board because it is clear that if someone has an opinion that differs from yours or jd's, then the two of you tag team until you beat them into submission.

Funny, I have many friends who are Republicans and none of them reverted to brow beating when hearing that McCain lost to Obama. It seems that civility is the first casualty of this election... at least on TechRepublic.

I am moving on to tech discussions... good luck to both you gentlemen.

by Member 25348569

I'm trying to find if there is any real truth in the idea that there is this huge underclass and if it's the case that the Democrats deliberately created and perpetuate it to retain their voting share. Or, perhaps, if it's just a natural by-product of their policies.

I'm perfectly willing to believe it but I would like some definitive proof. The Romans did it with "bread and circuses" for a couple of hundred years, keeping the masses fed and happy.

Neil :)

by jck

if you give a hand-out to a working man, it's welfare....

if you give it to a corporation, it's a "growth incentive"....

if you give a working man a block of cheese, it's a "commodity"...

if you give a private investor held corporation $700,000,000.00 a year for 7 years in "synthetic fuel credits", it is "investing in the future"...

The Republicans want government to stay out of business, but they sure are good with giving them free money and writing off their tax debts.

Wish they'd do that for the working class individual. I'd like to be able to just write my house off as a "bad investment".

by tonythetiger

[i]Personally, I think the campaign reform should be more like...cap donations at $50 per person/organization/household/address.[/i]

I think that only PEOPLE should be allowed to donate. Only PEOPLE can vote! I have no problem with the current limits on individuals.

by jck

about the 527s and other organizations?

Particularly, the RNC who were running massive amounts of ads in the last two weeks in ad slots next to the McCain campaign ads?

Is it right that they should be able to donate money in the form of paid advertising?

And if so, what stops a guy like Warren Buffett from just establishing an ad firm and buying all the air-time for Obama he wants as a "group"?

by maxwell edison

Although I wouldn't personally call it [i]name calling[/i], it's you who used words like [i]idiotic[/i], not me. And of course you won't debate substance, liberals seldom do. (Liberals? Was that [i]name calling[/i]?)

My two messages to you:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=278059&messageID=2633639

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=278059&messageID=2633909

Please share with everyone the instance in which I engaged in [i]name calling[/i]. You won't, because you can't.

You started this:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=278059&messageID=2633566

It appears that I replied to your snide comment with an invitation to discuss real substance, and you declined. That's okay. It speaks volumes.

P.S. As to your [i]tag-team[/i] nonsense, jdclyde is a big boy, and he speaks for himself. I have nothing to do with what he posts, and he has nothing to do with my posts. Based only on the dialogue between you and me, it appears you're not only declining to have a discussion based on substance, but you're making false charges against me.

by jck

[i][b]...the biggest voting block for bama was the under 50k block. (the people getting the payouts from obama policies). funny how that works.[/b][/i]

I make under $50k a year now. You're calling me a leech? a welfare recipient?

My mother and father both made under $50k a year all their lives. They both worked over 50 years. I guess they're leeches too.

I suppose you were a system-leeching piece of crap when you made under $50k?

BTW...the average working American household income is $50,233. So, I guess half our country statistically is getting payouts.

Nice generalization there, jd. You've mastered the ancient art of footinmouth.

You should ask Biden for a job.

by maxwell edison

(Serious reply, by the way.)

jck, without looking it up, I might guess that half the population actually is [i]getting payouts[/i] in one form or another. That's my problem with the whole government meddling into social issues. I'd concede and compromise to allow government to help those who truly cannot help themselves. It's concerning the rest of the population where I want the government to butt out.

P.S. I'd bet you ten bucks that [i].....half our country statistically is getting payouts.[/i] (I would offer to bet one hundred, but my savings has taken a hit lately.)

by jck

all of the wealthy people who take tax loopholes and off-shore savings not to pay taxes...

Yeah, i'd say that's right.

But, I was making a point about jdclyde's assertion that below the $50k income level = those people who take handouts.

BTW, I don't take handouts. In fact, I'm working my job plus starting a company.

I'm gonna go make my fortune and then leave you all here to debate things sitting on your butt at your desks, while I go fish and swim and get some sunlight. :p lol

by jdclyde

that was promised MORE tax cuts, even after the cuts WE (middle income) people got under Bush?

Every program that Obama threw out there was aimed at the un-rich.

Pretend to be insulted if you want. Just the fact that over 40% of all people in the US pay zero to the feds for income tax is a benefit not shared by people that have climbed up higher.

That doesn't count the people that get BACK more than they paid in.

Yes, I pay fed taxes every year.

by jck

[b][i]Every program that Obama threw out there was aimed at the un-rich.[/b][/i]

I don't know about your spending habits...but unless you're living somewhere like Manhattan, LA, DC, Chicago or Atlanta....$250,000 is a HELL of a lot of income.

And, Obama has always stated that he would raise taxes on those over $250k. It was McCain's campaign that made up untruths about what numbers Obama has said. Hell, Obama makes over $250k a year...he's gonna raise his OWN TAXES.

If I made $250k a year, I could be retired in 5-6 years easy. Couldn't you?

I don't know where you get "unrich" from...but, $250k is a lot of money.

Actually, Bush promised cuts across the board...most of the tax cuts fell upon those making over $150k per year. Real fair, ain't it?

WE...the middle income people...who make $50k a year...saw little, if anything. I know my tax refund that I got shrunk by about $70 after Bush's "across the board" tax cut.

And just for your reference, here's a little article that lays out why your claim to that "over 40%" is totally wrong:

------------------------------------
[i]The ?half of Americans pay no income tax? fraud

By Jay Bookman | Tuesday, October 7, 2008, 11:44 AM

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

One of the right-wing?s favorite talking points is the claim that 50 percent of American households don?t pay income taxes. From that claim flow a couple of other points: First, it?s impossible to ?cut? taxes for those households because they don?t pay any tax in the first place; second, those households are somehow less deserving of respect or even a voice in politics because they aren?t paying their own way.

That claim is bogus both in its details and its general charge.

The actual figure of ?taxable units? who don?t pay the standard income tax ? a taxable unit being a couple filing jointly or a person filing ? is somewhere around 38 percent. Even that number is grossly exaggerated, because it excludes what people pay through the payroll tax.

That tax, in total, amounts to 15.3 percent of earned income up to a gross income ceiling that this year is $102,000. Above the ceiling amount, a taxpayer pays only 2.9 percent. (Employers technically contribute half the 15.3 percent, but economists classify the entire amount as a tax burden on the worker because it is a tax on their labor. If you?re self-employed, you have to pay that entire 15.3 percent yourself.)

Because of that income ceiling, high-income workers end up paying the tax only on a relatively small part of their income, while poor and many middle-income households pay it on everything they earn, so the payroll tax is to some degree a surtax on the poor and middle-class worker.

How much does the payroll tax amount to? Well, last year the standard income tax brought in $1.17 trillion, while the payroll tax brought in $873.4 billion.

Technically, payroll tax receipts are supposed to be reserved for paying for Social Security and Medicare, which is what allows some people to claim it is not an income tax. However, in practice that distinction was abandoned long ago. For decades now, the payroll tax has been bringing in a lot more revenue than needed for Social Security, and the excess has been siphoned off for general fund use like any other government money.

Last year alone, $190 billion in payroll tax receipts was diverted to general fund use, paying for everything from Iraq to the salaries of park rangers.

As of 2007, a total of $2.25 trillion of payroll tax money paid into the Social Security and Medicare trust funds had been diverted to general fund use and replaced with government IOUs. In effect, the trust funds are an illusion. Payroll taxes and income taxes go into the same pool of money and are withdrawn from that same pool of money to fund government.

And for that reason, the claim that 50 percent, or even 38 percent, of Americans pay no income tax is flat out wrong.[/i]
--------------------------------------

So, read that and understand...you've been spoon-fed a heapin helpin...of right-wing BS.

And about your "pretend" comment, I am insulted.

I pay my friggin taxes, I work more than standard hours, I am trying to build a business, etc. I earn what I get.

I don't take a handout from my employer and have them reimburse me for job-based costs, I don't take freebies, I don't take gifts or money from co-workers or suppliers (save maybe a birthday card I might get).

I have pride in what I do, and it irked me that because of my income you would lump me with some lazy-ass bastard who sits on his butt, eats twinkies and plays world of warcraft all day, and lives off the welfare system without even trying.

And I pay fed taxes too. A lot more than what I get refunded. That's for sure.

Oh...I claim 0 exemptions too. I don't even take the credit for myself.

How about you? Ya taking the standard deduction for thing 1 and 2?

And, just for it to be clear: I took offense to it...cause, you've implied that people like me and my parents who make/made an amount (probably less than what you make, oh Warren Buffett Jr.) is akin to being scum and lazy ilk.

So yeah, it pissed me off. At least playing online games when I get home, people just tell me I suck at a game and don't compare me to the lowlifes I've always wanted to remove from any kind of assistance program. Remember that? I want welfare to become "workfare" so that anyone who gets assistance is EARNING it and CONTRIBUTING?

Anyways. Hasta luego, muchacho. Vaya con Dios and all that stuff. Enjoy your over $50k a year. Hope it buys you more booze and golf.

by jdclyde

[i]"The study, which is likely to add to a growing debate among politicians and policy experts over the contribution of businesses to Treasury coffers, did not identify the corporations or analyze why they had paid no taxes. [b]It also did not say whether they had been operating properly within the tax code or illegally evading it.[/b]"[/i]

The entire story is BS until they look at WHO, WHY, and HOW. They ignored both because it doesn't help the agenda of hyping anti-business hysteria.

Who are the companies paying no income taxes?
Why aren't they paying income taxes?
How are they not paying income taxes?

[i]"Among foreign corporations, a slightly higher percentage, 68 percent, did not pay taxes during the period covered ? compared with 66 percent for United States corporations. [b]Even with these numbers, corporate tax receipts have risen sharply as a percentage of federal revenue in recent years."[/i]

by maecuff

Maybe it wasn't name calling, but you did question on whether or not she would know who James Madison was.

It wasn't name calling, but it wasn't nice, either.

by maxwell edison

Yes ma'm.

However, CupCake doesn't realize what kind of cupcake I really am.

Besides, she may not know who James Madison is/was. Let Leno do a segment of Jay Walking asking the question, who's James Madison, and he'd have a lot of fun with the various answers.

P.S. I think you might agree that her initial snide remark also wasn't nice. Are you suggesting that one person gets a free pass on a snide remark, but a reply to one can't push the [i]being nice[/i] envelope just a little bit?

P.P.S. I suppose I'm assuming that CupCake is a her, not a him.

by jck

I want to be Ambassador to Ireland, and I want a lifetime appointment...I wanna live there and drink Guinness at night in the pubs with the locals and listen to that wonderful spirited Gaelic song they sing and play there.

I can't wait til 2010. That's when I'm going to spend 3 weeks in Europe.

by tonythetiger

"Possible but incredibly complex."

Many of these are undocumented people (some alien, some not) who show up on no census. Even with the ones who are in the census, it's difficult to extract exactly the data you seem to be asking about. For one thing, there ARE people who are working, AND receiving public assistance (help with housing and/or food and/or medical). You can add up all of the categories and come up with a sum larger than the number of citizens.

I will see what I can come up with though.

by ic-it

It is her own party and confidants doing the tossing. They may have a bit of a reason for not wanting her around in the future, but most of it is self-presevation.
They just don't want to accept any of the blame for the loss and wish to be there for the next go round. Or to loosly interput their style; they are a$$-kissers and back office weanies. :-)

by nicknielsen

Implying that taking a tax credit is taking a handout is a cheap shot. With the obvious exception of the earned income credit, tax credits do not generate income for the taxpayer; they can only reduce the tax obligation to zero. Tell me you won't take the tuition tax credit when Thing One and Thing Two go to college.

I have paid income tax [u]every year[/u] since 1969. I not only take all the tax credits I can, I take all the deductions I can. It's my money to start with, so why the hell shouldn't I (or for that matter anybody else) be allowed to reduce the tax obligation by any [u]legal[/u] means possible?

by jck

[i]Do you take every tax credit you can?
hmmmmmmm.[/i]

The answer is: no. I claim 0 exemptions, I haven't written off tax-deductible donations in years, and I haven't taken money for donating plasma either.

I earn what I get, and don't go chasing every penny I can get back from my country like it's their duty to hand me back everything I can take.

so mote it be. later

by jdclyde

Someone to blame.

Another part, there are many that really do like her and what she stands for, and so this is an attempt to get her out of the picture BEFORE she can become to powerful to be removed.

They don't like that she was not nice and controllable.

One more reason I like her.... ;\

by jdclyde

Jck was talking about people using tax loop-holes, and being the logical and consistent person that I am, it was a fair question on how he approaches having the same options.

I clam myself and my two boys, for a total of three. I make to much to get the earned income credits.

I also claimed college credit when I was going to school (graduated a year ago)

I do the short form because I don't have enough deductions through out the year to file long form.

I am not saying there is anything wrong with taking the deductions, jck was.
[b]
Food for thought John, figure your taxes both ways, THEN claim the tax deductions, and donate the difference to your favorite charity. The money will do more good to help out that way than leaving it with the government.[/b]

If you care about that charity, you can BACK file your taxes, get that money, and donate that as well. Imagine walking in and handing 1k over to the charity of your choice.....

by Member 25348569

My question was mostly around the idea that the underclass - of the sort that we both have, whatever its size - is deliberately created and maintained or simply an inevitable part of the mixed economy and a follow-on from the more overtly racial society of thirty years ago.

I note, from reading around this subject, that one third of all African Americans live in one of just 16 urban areas. These neighbourhoods are so racially segregated they have almost no chance at interracial contact. This parallels some of the towns and cities here and in other European cultures where we all have areas of concentrated, specific immigrant communities. Ghettos? Pretty damn close...

I fear for what will happen if we get a severe economic downturn as I believe that the residents of these enclaves, probably affected more than other areas, may well evolve (even more) isolationist attitudes and aggressive behaviour patterns that further marginalise them and reduces even more than already their chances of integration in mainstream society.

On that cheerful note, I think I may go and have a beer.

:)

by tonythetiger

There are several issues involved. But companies are not people, and do not necessarily have the same protections.

by nicknielsen

Deductions reduce taxable income, credits reduce tax, and loop-holes are used to hide income. Using deductions and credits to reduce your tax obligation is perfectly legal. Using loop-holes to hide your income is often illegal, since such loop-holes often rely on questionable misinterpretations of the tax code for their effectiveness.

by tonythetiger

[i]My question was mostly around the idea that the underclass - of the sort that we both have, whatever its size - is deliberately created and maintained or simply an inevitable part of the mixed economy and a follow-on from the more overtly racial society of thirty years ago.[/i]

that crap flows downhill. That attacking the wealth-makers for creating wealth results in a retaliation of sorts. Tax them more, and that tax will show up in the price of whatever they make, making it less affordable. Of course,there are relatively few rich, so taxing them more doesn't bring in enough money to make up for the damage they've done to the poor, so the middle class will have to be taxed more too.

I don't know what the right answer is, but it would seem to me that if taxing wealth were going to work, it would have ALREADY worked.

by road-dog

If the rationale was to vote for this legislation under the assumption it would be struck down by the SCOTUS, then this is Washington cynicism at it's apex. The old "Potomac two-step".

There is a reason that Limbaugh and Hannity flamed McCain so badly over it. It was really nothing more than an attempt to pack a bunch of incumbent protection measures under a bill title that promised "campaign reform".

THAT (and other profound stupidities)is why McCain had so much trouble mobilizing the base. Conservatives haven't left the GOP, the GOP left us.

Maybe that is really the reason for the drubbing the GOP is taking. Disagree with the DNC/Obama, but they wear their socialism on their sleeves. At least you know what you're getting. Maybe it's a little (lot) polished, but it's unapologetic. They know who they are, the GOP hasn't been loyal to the base on spending since Clinton left.

by sleepin'dawg

[b][i]GDP = consumption + gross investment + government spending + (exports − imports), or, GDP = C + I + G + (X-M)[/b][/i].

The study of economics is the study of failure. There has never been, nor will there ever be, an economic system that hasn't crashed. Whether it's unbridled capitalism or bleeding-heart socialism, they will all fail after a time.

http://www.fdic.gov/bank/analytical/index.html
http://www.federalreserve.gov/

The [i]conventional[/i] definition of a recession is two quarters of decline in the GDP but as Bernacke says the current situation is unconventional. He said in an interview, precisely where and when I must admit escapes me, that with a financial crisis, a housing crisis, a credit crisis, market crashes both in commodities and securities, ten straight months of rising unemployment, there's rising trouble in manufacturing and a decline in consumer spending since early in the year, that the conventional definition was no longer adequate and that if all the numbers were examined together, it could be said that the US was and had been in recession since the end of March. He said something similar in his appearance before congress or the senate. Add to that the increase of the national debt to $12+ trillion (double what it was when Bush was elected) plus, not just one war but two, Iraq and Afghanistan, and you still want to claim the US isn't in recession. Hell with all the numbers I see, and the rise in them, we might not be talking recession so much as depression. There is also the very real danger of deflation and/or stagflation, not just inflation. Mind you that is sort of a doomsday scenario but it could happen if things keep going as they are.

I agree that economic growth is cyclical but this time around it's a bit more scary than usual. It's world wide and the numbers are getting worse. Today US unemployment was close to 6.8%, ten straight months of job losses and rising unemployment, and folks planning their Christmas shopping are looking more to WalMart rather than Sears or Neiman-Marcus.

When Bernacke says the US is in recession and has been since the end of March, based on all the other info, I'm inclined to believe him. The capper, for me, was Greenspan claiming he was shocked and surprised by the situation. The guru of deregulation missed one thing. Even deregulation needs some regulation and oversight. Greenspan the architect of financial ruin.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by tonythetiger

[i]
The conventional definition of a recession is two quarters of decline in the GDP[/i]

when the P leaves the D?

by jackofalltech

Whatever you call it, I know I won't be on the receiving end of any of that "sharing" so I'll probably lose my house.

by jck

It's a legitimate news publication, unless the only thing you consider reputable are articles you often showed from a campaign or supporter sites. At least I got a news periodical rather than campaign literature.

And it's BS because they didn't look at the WHO WHY and HOW? Hm. Seems to me they quoted a report. Maybe they expect literate adults to be able to go find that report and learn from it?

OK then. I'll go make 10 kids...and work 2 jobs...and even though i'll pay more in and the receipts the government gets from me will go up...i'll get it all back...plus go on welfare...and get even more!

Sound bad to do? You'll bastardize a person for doing it, but it's okay for a corporation to do it? Does the hypocracy ever end with you?

It's a bunch of bull$hit. Now you know why working people are homeless and unemployed across this country. Cause fat cats in D.C. let guys like Cayne at Bear-Stearns walk away with $60M in compensation after he left it and the shareholders essentially penniless and the Feds had to bail them out with $29B.

It's cause of attitudes like yours. Oh yeah...the government got more receipts. But...how much did they keep...and how much were credited back to corporations through loopholes and schemes?

I wish I could get the US Government to just hand me money. Oh wait, that would be wrong wouldn't it?

BTW...just to explain something to you, in case you don't understand:

There's this thing corporations and wealthy people do to evade paying taxes...it's called off-shore investments and banking. They move their monies into companies outside of US banking jurisdiction. And a lot of times (as plenty of reports on TV have shown), many companies and wealthy people have been evading paying $100Ms in taxes yearly by doing this.

So if you're willing to trust big business and the top wealth holders in the country with your money to do what's right, then I encourage you to take your childrens' college funds and give it to them to invest for you.

I'd rather trust the working class American to spend the money with the businesses who treat them right, rather than giving it to the corporations who FAILED at operating right and letting them continue to reward irresponsible and inept corporate management with funds that could benefit working class people more.

And as for taking my taxes back and giving it to a charity? I should do that...cause part of my taxes...although just a few bucks probably...go to help fund part of your schools and law enforcement via federal grants and funding.

I'll be glad to take your kids' books away and the cops that keep them safe. Good idea. I'll get that money and donate it to my local FOP so I am safer.

And, I'll have my parents do the same. -1 textbook for a Michigan kid.

by jck

[i]"Two out of every three United States corporations paid no federal income taxes from 1998 through 2005, according to a report released Tuesday by the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress.

The study, which is likely to add to a growing debate among politicians and policy experts over the contribution of businesses to Treasury coffers, did not identify the corporations or analyze why they had paid no taxes. It also did not say whether they had been operating properly within the tax code or illegally evading it.

The study covers 1.3 million corporations of all sizes, most of them small, with a collective $2.5 trillion in sales. It includes foreign corporations that do business in the United States."[/i]

That was at the very top of the article. Guess you just kinda missed that part.

http://gao.gov/

You can find the report on that site. I did your work for you. Go read now. Learn what is happening.

BTW...just because names aren't given, I guess things don't happen?

I guess then when a little kid gets molested and they hide their name on the news...it must mean they're lying and they didn't get molested....right?

This discussion is closed to new replies.