The "Describe your Ideal Job" interview question
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tdeckert
Hi there,
You asked the question...
"What are they really looking for?" with the Ideal Job question.
I am the Director of IT and Engineering for a tech company and I ask this question a lot in interviews.
While I would like to say there is a deep meaning to this question, when I ask it, there is not. Its exactly how it sounds.
Since I know exactly what the job is going to entail (more than I can communicate in a single or even several interviews to a person) I know the type of work and the environment the person is going to be put into. I use this question to get a feel for what the person thinks is an idea job, and I compare their desired job with the type of job they will be getting if we bring them on. We don't want someone to be put into something that is completely at odds with what they deem is a great job to have. I can use this information to think about the distance or gap between their ideal job and the environment they are going into.
If there ideal job is very different, that is a data point that we need to consider when making the decision.
Also, there is a reality check here. We understand there is an purely idealistic IDEAL Job and a reality IDEAL Job. Its ok to mention both. Just be honest.
I personally do not like generic answers at all. Oftentimes the person being interviewed I don't think gives enough credit to the person doing the interviewing. Be specific and honest, don't hedge or be vague. If you don't get the job and you were honest in your answers, its a good thing. It means its not the place for you and you avoided putting yourself into a bad situation that you would probably have to leave.
We don't cross someone off the list because they say they ultimately want to run their own business, or write novels, or anything else. Everyone has those types of goals of some sort. When they tell me an answer like that I always follow up with something like, "ok, that sounds like it would be a great job. What would you consider your ideal technical job or IT Job" so that the person can be more specific.
I hope that helps and good luck,
p.s. All questions have as a running background process the purpose of serving to paint a picture of your personality. Aside from the question itself and what is being asked, a question like this is one more chance for your personality to come though, to show your ability communicate and articulate. Use it to your benefit.
by cb0503
this is the link where I first saw it
http://www.gantthead.com/article.cfm?ID=222667
and then I tracked it down in a longer version to
http://www.erexchange.com/articles/db/652B83B36BAC11D582F900105A12D660.asp
by cb0503
sure, but surely 60% cut is better than 100% cut !
I took a cut - after redundancy while ex-pat so trying to move home.
And as sole income-earner, I HAD to be realistic and go for an income, even with a significant cut, rather than sitting around and making myself even LEss employable !
So don't be too quick to judge it you don't know what the alternatives are ;)
by john.thomson
The interview is a two way process - are you right for each other, and if one of you answers no, then ideally you should not engage any further as the benefit to one or other will be limited at best.
My advice is to be positively honest, your last "ideal opportunity" is the one you are looking to leave - correct? use their company culture to slant your answer regardless of whether you give a "billionare dreamland" or "your advertised position" by all means. Reflect this "very astute question" back to them (as a mark of respect do this after you answer thiers)- what is their ideal candidate? they want to know if you will fit and I repeat, this is two way - are they good for what you want.
This is not a question for a short term (<15 month) duration within an organisation so they are looking for commitment, you are looking for your reason to stay. I pick 15 months as a duration based on the fact that less could border on being a contract position and greater than 12 months certainly means vesting an amount of Intellectual Property in someone.
I wish you and any readers the very best in your career advancement search because, when you get it right its fantastic, wrong is not somewhere anyone wants to go.
OK - I have not answered the question, the answer really lies in X months time i.e. did you get the position, are you both happy. If you did not get the position then you gave the right answer, as your prospective employer realised something about you that would not work or visa versa. Either way, this is good news.
by jamesrl
I was laid off in 2002, and though I found some contract work, I struggled to find my current position. They had the exact same conversation regarding stability - how can you accept a cut so large, how do we know you wont leave when the economy picks up. I promised 2 years. Thats enough time to make some permanent changes.
The alternative was unattractive. My wife can't work due to medical conditions. I have three kids. I may not have had much choice at the time to take the job, but I do make a conscious decision to stay.
James
don't get me wrong, when I left my previous job ( I was talking about my company moving out of the city) I knew for sure that I will have to take the cut and I did.
Now that I know we are talking 60% out of more than 100k, of course, I might think of taking it, its way better than unemployment moneywise.
by kathleenmuro
This is easy. The best answer is to describe the qualities of an ideal job:
One where I work in a team (or as an individual)
One where I have full responsibility to get something done (or one where my supervisor will work closely with me)
One where I am learning something new every day
etc.
What the interviewers want to know if how you will fit into their work culture. Are you a loner? Do you always want to grab all the credit? Do you hoard information? Are you gunning for your boss's job? Will you get along with everyone else?
They are not asking you to specify a job, they are trying you on for size to see if you will fit into their jobsite in a psychological sense.
depend on what they've told you or you've picked up. Getting the right data is definitely not easy.
I once got told by a recruiter that his client was looking for a team player who was happy to work alone. I'd be the first to say recruiters couldn't find their ass with both hands, two mirrors and some friendly advice, but it's an impossible querstion when the the people interviewing you don't know what they want.
When your living on bread and jam under the stairs to dodge your creditors you have to put up with crap like that though.
After all anyones true ideal job is where work fits around their desires not the other way round.
if you get caught not being honest.
If you are in a job and under no financial pressure to move, you can afford to be honest. If you are out of work with bills piling up lie like a mother....
I once told someone what my ideal job was, got the job and then found out they'd lied their ass off, so it works both ways.
I'll admit I've been fortunate, but I always approach an interview with a what can you offer me approach.
Save this question for any interviewer who comes out with ideal job, what's your idea of ideal employee, never had a reasonable answer to that one yet. Got the impression I should waive my salary and change into my work clothes very fast in a phone box.
because there is no right answer there are a great many wrong ones. How successful you are with your answer depends on how much of an idea you've got of what they want, so that depends on how many questions you've had answered already.
Even scarier when you get into a multiple interview scenario, and you give the right answer to one person in the food chain while making an outright enemy of another. That happened to me once. The IT Director loved me, the IT manager figured he didn't want his boss to have an ally in his department.
Interviews are not something you get right, they are something you have to get not wrong.
I've always been uncomfortable with people who feel the need to ram their nose in my rear orifice.
Seriously that is to the answer to the question.
What makes you the ideal candiadte for this job, and even in that case screams brown nose.
Soft drinks and strong women and occasionally switching my adjectives when communicating.
I never answer this question. I usually detail weaknesses that I say used to have, so I can leave out JD and the redhead.
Another question that tests how convincingly you can lie or evade an inquiry.
Ask people what their strengths are and how they apply them.
where you need the job. If you are just fishing of course then you might as well land a big one.
Money should always come up after the offer though in my oppinion, both parties should already have a range and know they are in the same ball park.
by talentonloan
Greetings Tony
I see the interview process as a dialog. You share with your perspective employer some things about yourself (only part of which is your skill set) and and listen to them and their presentation of the job and then join with them to mutually decide whether or not there is a good fit. Mutually in the sense that the decision is theirs to hire, but yours to accept. Have you ever been offered a job and realized that, for certain reasons, it is not for you? I used to be in sales, and I can usually spot the 'sales approach' and will try to get behind the pitch to the real person who is seeking the job - their motivations, skills, interests, etc.
I know the shortcoming of the hard sell approach personally. I once 'sold' myself quite well into a job, and what I ended up doing was missing all the important clues as to why simply my passionate desire to acquire that position blinded me to why it was NOT where I needed to be.
A listening, relaxed and personally engaging approach actually ends up helping immensely in building confidence in the inteview team in you as a person. This means that they can trust all the high power verbiage in your resume and trust you with their business.
If I was on an interview team and you told me that you were interested in landscape gardening I would probably ask you whether you found it to be just a welcome respite from all the cerebral or interpersonal stresses of IT work, or whether you found some connection to the kind of approach you have in your IT work. If you honestly said you did it because you like to see things grow or you like to structure environments to enable growth to happen I would be far more impressed with that than with some blurb on a technical resume. It might imply a willingness to interact with an 'environment' - a truly valuable skill. It also tells your perspective boss something about what might make a appropriate holiday gift - like a unique plant or something. A relationship is forming. Then when it comes to deciding who is hired, someone with a positive 'relationship' in the works is always a stronger candidate.
BTW - Best wishes to you when you elect to pull the IT plug and pursue the landscaping work!
by super_it_mom
by brj1980
by klempan
I haven't run into this question (yet), but bombed on a good interview with my answer to "What do you do in your spare time?"
My answer of gardening/landscaping on a 1/2 acre was met with some polite boredom. I learned from that, so now the answer is that I run an organic orchard with culinary and medicinal herbs as key components of the landscaping. I also hasten to add that there's a couple weekends of the year that are busy, but it's much easier to maintain on a professional's schedule than other forms of gardening.
Both answers are true, but one makes me more compatible with a team of other techies.
by hiprasad22
I want to become SE.
I m post garduate student in search of job.
Mostly I like to wor in java & J2EE technology.
Please Replay Me.
by ChrisP547
"Remember, the truth doesn't matter here. There's no chance that your interviewer will notice if you're bullsitting. As long as you give the expected answer, you're fine."
First, the truth always matter in a job interview, you won't get a job offer if the interviewer knows your not telling the truth... or BSing, as the case may be. And the whole point of this discussion is... what IS the expected answer? Telling someone 'as long as you give the expected answer' is useless.
by djysrv
What the employer is likely looking for is your "other directed" view of the ideal job and not your personal satisfaction. By "other directed" the employer is looking for how you see your "ideal" contribution to the bottom line, solving the employer's most pressing problems, and otherwise adding value. In this regard, the question "describe your ideal job" is an opportunity to state your value proposition in terms of the employer will recognize and understand as being meaningful to him/her.
You already have figured out that the tropical island paradigm is a non-starter. Keep going and think about how you would qualify the employer as a prospect prior to the interview. For instance, what do you know about how the firm uses IT to seek/maintain competitive advantage, etc. Going into the interview with a view of the key issues that matter to management gives you a springboard to answer the "ideal job" questions and score the job.
sorry for the delay (as i said, took a new job, 25% less :-), lots of changes/trainings ...etc, no time to post).
still, I don't know of ANYONE who can purchase a house and cars outright even if you were going for >100k. And that in 8 years ? Again : WOW, your case is definitely an exception, I don't think you can advise others to do the same, it's just not possible for regular guys :-)
60% would probably get me very close to the unemployment benefit level. Personaly I think that working for 60% less means you also perform 60% less important or challenging tasks, not very good for your career either. So .. why should I go working for let's say 2000/mo. when I can sit at home and concentrate on finding a decent job getting 1500 from the government ? 60% is just too much ...
Of course (here your point is valid) I totaly reject the possibility of not finding something in a few months.
by johnterry807
Hi everyone!
I am a new member of the board. I saw this topic I have many things and people have to learn. I think people can share documents related to this subject.
Sincerely!
John
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending