Discussion Locked

The fall of the Roman Empire ...

0 helpful
136 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

After an exchange of emails with my nephew, who is a student of ancient Roman history,
I have drawn the following parallels between the fall of The Roman Empire and the current situation in America.

Marcus Aurelius was a good leader. He wanted his stepson to succeed him. But it is widely agreed that his natural son Commodus murdered both his father and step brother. Commodus was an inept ruler, and the decline of the Roman Empire can clearly be seen to begin under the Caesarship of Commodus.

So Commodus took the throne falsely and through his incompetence the Roman Empire started to disintegrate.

The parallel:
Everybody except a few ignorant Republicans are quite sure that the voting in Florida was rigged (I have various email friends in the US of all political persuasions who give me their opinions.)
Hence, like Commodus, Bush most likely became leader illicitly.

Bush is the most incompetent leader in US history. Already he has ensured that no country in the world (with the exception of Australia for as long as John Howard remains Prime Minister, and Britain as long as Tony Blair remains Prime Minister) will ever again trust or respect the USA.

Additionally the US is about to be tumbled from its current position as the most economically powerful country in the world, partly because of Bush's incompetence, but also because China, because of its sheer numbers, is rapidly heading to the top. A trade alliance between China, India and a few other countries would certainly topple America from its current position. China has the numbers, India has the skills.

Additionally the European countries are working towards becoming a much more unified and powerful economic bloc.

Bush achieved his post illicitly, and because of the factors mentioned above, I think the US has passed it peak and it will be downhill from here on.

Whilst America accounts for 50 per cent of the world?s entire spending on the military and armaments, it has lost the trust and respect of the rest of the world, and in the not too distant future will also most likely be toppled from its position as the most economically powerful country in the world.

And responsibility for this lies fairly and squarely with George W. Bush. God knows what further havoc he will create if he is re-elected, which is currently looking very likely.

So it will be a case of goodbye America ? thanks for helping to save us from Hitler and Japan, but we don?t trust your motives any more.

America, under the bumbling Bush, who of course is merely a puppet manipulated by the likes of Rumsfeld and Cheney, has lost probably irretrievably the status it enjoyed (or at least claimed) as leader of the free world.

136 replies

by dc_guy

One need not indulge in Bush bashing, a topic from which I must recuse myself when posting from my employer's workstation, in order to see the larger pattern, one which has played out in every great nation throughout history -- with a single exception.

Sumeria, Cushitic Egypt, Babylon, Harappan India, Phoenicia, Persia, Greece, the Olmecs, Rome, Byzantium, the Maya, the Mongols, Zimbabwe, Holland, the Aztecs, the Incas, Spain, Hindu India, Manchuria, France, Austro-Hungary, Turkey, Imperial Russia, Germany, Japan, Britain, Soviet Russia... those are just the big names that come to mind easily.

Every great nation has fallen -- with a single exception. Some endure in a state of genteel decline like Greece. Others exist in name only, populated by the descendants of foreign invaders like Egypt. Others are barely more than legends like Zimbabwe.

Their falls don't follow a pattern. All of the causes you mentioned are common but not universal. Yet the pattern and the universality is that they do indeed eventually fall. Sic transit and all that. Civilization continues and in the long run advances, but individual civilizations burn out.

Is it America's turn? Who can say? Despite all of the arguments presented, she could find a new lease on life and endure for as long as Byzantium, its shaky foundation nearly unequalled in history.

The single exception? China. Six thousand years of continuous history and culture. She endured the long occupations of the Mongols and the Manchus, and assimilated THEM. (Anybody heard of a place called Manchuria lately? It's now nothing more than several provinces inside China.) It is the only large country to survive a communist takeover, and it shows every sign of assimilating the Reds just like all its earlier "conquerors."

Look not to our internal problems for a clue to our future. Remember Napoleon's counsel: China is a sleeping dragon, and when it awakes... it will shake the world.

Or something like that. ^_^

by jardinier

and thanks for the history lesson.

I have always said that, to become the most populous nation on earth, despite the fact that (from memory) only 30 per cent of the land is arable, China must have done something right.

And, as you point out, they have absorbed rather than conquered some neighbouring territories (perhaps with the exception of Tibet, which may in due course be granted autonomy again.)

by jardinier

No Garion, it is not wishful thinking but merely a hypothesis which has to a large extent been supported by the other postings already made.

Actually I would have no problem with the USA remaining the most powerful nation in the world, if you could just get yourselves a half-way decent president.

by garion11

have a decent president, you don't like him because he won't give handouts and isn't afraid of flexing American power whether or not we passed some sort of "global test". Do you guys take a poll of what Americans think when you elect your leader? And how would you feel if I came onto your countries' messageboards (I am not saying TR is..but I hope you see my point) and post crap about your country?

by g.brown

It's really the Neo-CONs, with big emphasis on the CON !!

IMO, they are the ones pulling Bush's strings. His daddy .. senior Bush didn't listen to them as much and didn't invade Iraq when he was president.

They've just been scheming and waiting until they do have someone who will blindly listen to them .. Bush junior!!!

So, unless America gets rid of these ideological, power hungry, empire builders like Wolfowitz, Rumsfeld and the like, just expect more of the same.

by hal 9000

Message board that only services AU you are welcome to do so.

But do not imply that TR is a USA only forum as it is supposed to be for IT professionals "WORLD WIDE!"

Also when someone starts a thread on this miscellaneous side of things it is accepted that there are not many rules as far as free speech goes. Of course if you would like to prevent anyone but Americans exercising this right feel free to contact the TR Administrators and ask for this.

If they agree to your request you will get to hear exactly what you want to but do not be fooled that you will be hearing the full story as it will only enforce the idea that Americans are so far up themselves that they are unaware of the rest of the world. Which is really funny as most of the Hi Tech stuff that is talked about here on TR is not US made!

Col

by garion11

All these impressions that Americans are not aware of the rest of the world...where do you come up with crap like that? With increased outsourcing (TR is only possible because of an American invention), globalization, our charitbale donations to third world countries by American pharmaceutical industries, our independent citizens, etc, and our past actions from WWII onwards, what the hell makes you say such ludicrious statements such as those? Do we care about other countries' interests (more than you could ever hope to know)? The question is do you care about American interests and its people (you do but only if it benefits you)?

by hal 9000

Now lets take a long look at exactly what you are ranting on about. I notice that there is nothing there about you wanting to join an AU discussion group and deride AU but you would be an amateur by our standards as we are far better at deriding the various forms of Government that we have here than any US citizen that I've ever meet.

But back to your ramblings:-

"With increased outsourcing"

Is this really a good thing?

And do you really think that if someone had not of come up with HTTP in the USA it would never have been invented?

If memory serves me correctly it was us Aussies who taught the USA a lesson in computer security all those years ago when what is now known as the Internet was put into place for computing power to be spread out around first the USA and then its allies for strategic reasons.

"our charitbale donations to third world countries by American pharmaceutical industries"

Is this why the FTA between the USA and AU is being held up in being implemented because your pharmaceutical companies think that the amendments that where made in AU made things too hard to give away their product? Silly me I thought it was because if it was implemented they would not find it possible to rob us blind.

"Do we care about other countries' interests (more than you could ever hope to know)?"

More to the point is do you care? As a citizen of the USA? Exactly how are some other countries best interests served by funding terrorists to destabilize their Lawfully elected Government? Remember the Contras in South America?

I can go on and on with places where the USA has imposed its will at the expense to the general population and supported terrorists when it was in the USA's best interests but certainly not the best interests of the general population of that country.

More to the point do you know your own countries recent history?

AS a people I find most of the US population nice people but they do tend to take themselves far too seriously for my liking and I've seen a lot who seem to think that the world owes them because of something that their country did long before they where born.

This to me is as bad as the Irish who seem to hold a grudge forever I once was told by an IRA sympathizer just how the British had caused the death of thousands of good Irishmen and women during the potato blight 400 years ago and he was speaking as if it was yesterday and that the people and governments had not changed at all.

You are doing exactly the same thing here but because of the lack of long term history of your country you can only point to things that have occurred within the last hundred years or so instead of the older civilizations who can go back hundreds of years for examples of the wrongs that have been done to them and rights that they have been responsible for.

Actually Garion how about you starting a thread of "Why some People seem to thing that Americans are stuck up so & so's!"

I'll contribute very happily with constructive criticism which you seem to take as a direct attack upon yourself rather than a general comment about the state of play around the world.

First you as a nation have to learn not to take yourselves too seriously by believing your Governments Press Releases but far more importantly you have to learn to laugh at yourselves which is something that the average American finds very hard to do probably because they have been brainwashed into believing that they live in the best country in the world.

If it is so good why do you have to pledge allegiance to your country every day over here it is taken for granted that the general population will do this and they are not required to have it drummed into them on a daily basis!

Col

by jardinier

Well Garion, predictably with your unique capacity for stupidity, you have got that one totally ass-up.

It was not until I joined TR about two years ago that I learnt that I was supposed to dislike America and Americans.

The various Americans whom I have met in Australia have for the most part been polite, full of zeal and easy to get on with.

One of the most stimulating relationships of my life with with an American girl who was born in Hawaii.

Blind Freddie could see that the only reason that America gives a stuff about Australia is because our geographic position makes our country vital to American interests as a communication base at the very least.

You most likely would not be aware that the live video of the first moon landing was only possible because of a large radio telescope in New South Wales.

America also needs its base at Pine Gap for comunication purposes via satellite.

If America didn't need Australia, I can think of no reason why they would give a s**t about us.

by delbertpgh

The Roman empire functioned for about 800 years; the American empire began with the Second World War, only about 60 years ago. Rome's empire was formal and authoritarian; ours is based on trade, a defense umbrella, and cooperative relationships. Rome's governance was based on such vast corruption, brutality, and cynicism that it makes Halliburton, Abu Ghraib, and the Republican National Committee look like a eunuchs' choir.

A better comparison would be England's empire. They ruled the waves, ruled commerce, ruled finance, and ruled more territory than anybody else in the world, and then they went broke.

by jardinier

Your point is well taken, and I will check back in another 740 years to see how America is doing.

However, regarding your reference to Britain going broke, you may like to make a comment on the following (an extract from a contributed article that is posted on my website):

Britain was at the mercy of Hitler. With its artillery tanks and transport lying on the beach at Dunkirk, Winston Churchill, with Hitler at his doorstep, turned to our great American ally for material help and Lend Lease was born. The first American requirement was that all the gold in the Bank of England be transferred to the US; that is, what little was left after the disaster of the WW1 and the 1929 stock market crash. (Some would even say engineered by the Americans for their own ends.)
This was followed by the technological developments -- British rayon, radar, Huff Duff (a device for locating submarines), and Frank Whittle's jet engine with all the plans. In fact, together with the Enigma Machine and all of the German and Japanese, diplomatic, military and naval codes, everything of commercial value but with no patent protection applied. Lend Lease was the next. This hire-purchase plan was to provide guns, aeroplanes, tanks and munitions and food to conduct the war.
The war ended in 1945. In Britain on that day, Lend Lease ceased and the repayments began. It is estimated by the British Government that it will be another ten years before the debt is repaid, (2014) nearly 70 years after the war ended. This burden has effectively crippled Britain as the world power it once was, leaving the US to step into Britain's shoes.

by delbertpgh

Yup, we scoured them out, evil and by the books. Now the Brits are our favorite Significant European Country, bearers of the candle of the Special Relationship, our number one pals in all the world (not counting Canada, which we never count. Hmm.) Americans don't reflect too much on why other English-speaking countries cleave to us. We tend to think it's our natural popularity factor.

You're right on all the financial history. My wife wrote her thesis on the U.S., Britain, and Lend-Lease in the Middle East during WWII, and it went down just that way. She is among the couple dozen Americans who are aware of the financial side of military power in this century. As you have probably guessed from Mr. Bush and his crew, there isn't a big taste for nuance or complex detail here. Buy them out, blow them away, or drive them out of business... there is a faith that these tactics, derived from America's strength and size, will succeed forever and everywhere. And thus, Iraq.

If we don't bankrupt ourselves in the next decade, we'll have to face China for mastery of the world, by 2040 or so. As another contibutor has pointed out, that is the one true imperial success story of all history. (Not counting India.)

I guess a lot of Americans would read this and gather the impression I hate what America is and has done. Not true... the exercise of American power has been a net positive for the 20th century world. There were mistakes, and losers in the game, but overall the world would be a much sorrier place had we not seized the power and shouldered the global responsibilities, as we did. I just prefer to face things true.

by hal 9000

I know I must be wrong but I was under the impression that they along with AU where the COW who where responsible for the pre-emptive strike on Iraq and are currently moving into place to support American troops in Iraq.

Please I would like to know!

If what you mean is the breakup of the Commonwealth well you are wrong as the Commonwealth is alive and well thank you very much and we even have our own games every 4 years for Commonwealth countries only.

If you mean the demise of England's domination of "Gunboat Diplomacy" well they just grew out of that stage and left it to someone else to look foolish while they continued on with making money and saving people in trouble.

Col

by delbertpgh

England was feeling the strain around 1900, when it began a battleship race with Germany. It had already spent several decades spending more in the world than it spent on itself. (Empire is expensive.) World War I was devastating to finances, leaving it deep in debt to the US. The additional responsibilities it acquired (Iraq, in particular) following WWI were no help. Still, it did not shirk its imperial duties, and the cash continued to bleed out.

When WWII showed up, the Brits got into it two years before the US, and it proved to be a fabulously expensive war, worse than WWI. Roosevelt supplied the Brits with war materiel on a cash-and-carry basis, and finally lend-lease, which was used especially in the Middle East to pry open the closed markets of the sterling bloc and thus open English dependencies to American competition. The Americans liked the political cover that the English empire offered the world, but they hated the closed economies and the pound-denominated trade. The war caused vast, expensive damage to the English homeland, and left the Brits without foreign exchange reserves and deep debts on top of it, with an empire falling apart and the old financial props knocked away. The U.S. did not believe it could bankrupt England, but it succeeded, and was stunned when England began to fold up its empire, withdrawing from Asia, Africa, and the Middle East by stages, starting shortly after WWII, and through 1972.

Lots of comparisons: the big dollar versus the big pound, as the international currency; the trade deficits; the balance of payments deficits; the budget deficits; an era of technological, financial, and military mastery leading to an era of imperial over-extension.

by sleepless in wa

Hey Hal 9000, you're interrupting some good arguing here with your advertisements. We're not interested. We just want to keep up with the arguing between maybe the last 3 'Normal' countries in the world (2 starting as British Colonies by the way). As the great American philospher, Rodney King once said, "Can't we all just get along?"

by hal 9000

As to what exactly you mean here?

If you do not want to reply directly here you can contact me through the Peer Listing just click on my Allis and you'll get to my contact point.

Col

by olprof67

England fell from her position of leadership as she became unable to sustain the demands of an overseas empire (which became unjustifiable with the passing of mercantilism) and the simultaneous growth of a welfare state within her borders.

And while Dubya regrettably doesn't get the whole picture, the growth of a global market economy makes it unlikely the United States will fall into the same trap. Note that not even the most rabid lefties are whining that governmental intervention can do anything to address the growing scarcity of petroleum.

Furthermore, as anyone who lived through those times can attest, no other industialized nation has come so far, in so short a time, in correcting the imbalances due to racial differences, and working toward a level playing field. Most of us instinctively know that in economics or any other conflict, all other factors being equal, an ethnically-diverse group will outperform an ethnically-uniform group every time.

And finally, the emergence of a global culture will diminish the overall role of the nation-state. Some, like Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union, will balkanize. The global model will evolve by borrowing from the more successful (and I wouldn't count on any socialist or theocratic states getting very far).

by hal 9000

Muslim Malaysia? Where Intel makes a lot of their CPU's.

Taiwan that China wants back in the fold so terribly?

Col

by delbertpgh

I can't agree that England's supremacy fell with the passing of mercantilism. It fell because of competition. It fell because England became addicted to a unique historical moment, and the world in turn became addicted to England in that role. Mercantilism dropped by the boards for the reason that Adam Smith said it should, because it ignored comparative advantages between producers.

England became the super country in the 18th and 19th centuries because it overcame cultural inertia, changed on a number of fronts, and became the world leader in the modern state of mind. The key to all that was the faith that whatever a man with money could earn was a sign of righteousness; that the competing righteousnesses of religion and government should be confined to strictly limited spaces within personal and social life, so as not to screw up the moneymaking. Economics was allowed to run away with society, change anything, overturn old order and custom, dissolve humanitarian links between merchant and society. England learned to do this well, becoming the technical, financial, political, and military leader of the world, making the most of its geographic and cultural advantages. Everybody else could only marvel, and wonder "why don't we do that here?"

After other nations learned to compete on the same footing, they started to eat England's lunch, but by this time England was the world's currency, giving it the power to hand out money in trade, instead of matching goods with goods. England exported its capital and neglected internal investment for 50 years before it hit bottom. That's how I see it.

I can't agree that racism is licked, or even that beating racism is a financial transformation. Race hatred in America has always been a surrogate for class hatred. Class is real and matters in America, and the differences and barriers between classes are getting higher. Engendering suspicion of the dark races has been a social technique for keeping working men's attention off the sad state of the working wage.

I can't say that global culture impresses me much, either. It will erase a lot of differences, but I don't see that it's going to stop much fighting. Lots of societies have reacted to change and transformation by going to war. As the world gets richer, there will be ever more money to fight over, too.

We're not looking at the end of history yet.

by jardinier

Garion, I invite you, even encourage you to comment on Australian affairs as often as you wish -- that is of course if you can find any news about Australia in the American media.

And please don't forget that, for better or for worse, Australia was the only country besides Britain which participated in the pre-emptive strike on Iraq.

Although it WAS covered in the American media, I will remind you that our conservative Prime Minister, John Howard, was re-elected on October 9. George Bush and Tony Blair each telephoned him personally to congratulate him on his victory.

So PLEASE, share your thoughts on any Australian issues.

In Australia, unlike America apparently (refer to the discussion: "How can this be?" by maecuff) we still enjoy freedom of the press and freedom of speech.

So PLEASE, share with us Aussies your views on our humble little country.

by garion11

I think you have been listening to OZ too much. We have more freedom than any developed nation believe it or not. Again you would never know that (and I don't expect you to) unless you live here, because the comments you are getting from your own press (which you base your opinion) indicate otherwise and it simply is not true. What do you want me to comment about regarding Australian issues? Our local evening news doesn't cover it and I don't watch TV, I get 90% of my information from the Internet. The Bali bombings and US relations with Australia is as far as my knowledge goes?? As I stated before I completely appreciate Australian efforts and support in this war, Bush has stated that as well. Its Kerry who thinks otherwise by calling this "the wrong war, at the wrong time, and wrong place." Bush and Republican American citizens appreciate all the foreign countries' support, its the Democrats that don't (why? because if they did, god forbid they would be supporting the war in Iraq and that means they wouldn't be in power etc).

Again its just an incredible amount of half information that lot of these posters from other countries' receive and they are making bad assumptions about Americans based on their own media...not the truth. My point was I just don't appreciate that since I don't see Americans post or comment to any Australian issues (regarding Aussie issues) because we know better and we know that we don't have all the information and it isn't our place to do that sort of stuff (again obviously I don't speak for all Americans) but we were called arrogant and misinformed (by the more colorful posters of the board). I just don't get it.

by oz_media

this is abotu the most accurate and non-baised perspective on the WHO'S who of the world.

You ranmk in the bottom of some KEY categories and at the top of the most absurd categories.

Even those areas where YOU claim you are the leaders of the world, military spending, education in general, health etc. You are not even close to the world providers you THINK or have been taught you are.

Do some digging there is hours of fun for the whole family in here.

Juding by the health issues, pamaceuticals, avg. life expectancy etc. I certainly AM glad to not be American.

Then for things such as literature (LIBRARY books available) you don't even rank in the top 100!

Countries like Germany have a much higherracial mix than you do, they allow more immigrants than the US, have greater education levels etc. yet everyone here, including yourself, makes a regular issue out of downplaying Germany.

In fact MOST Eastern European countries beat out America in SO many stats it makes me wonder how you can constantly downplay thier role in the world the way you do by constantly saying how they screw everythig up. I'd take Germany over the US any day, as would most.

So perhaps THIS will give you some idea of WHY everyone outside America, thinks that Americans are delusional, uneducated and arrogant for constantly claiming they are the best at everything.

I've had several intersesting predictions on how you guys will react to the information so your responses keep me in anticipation. :)

http://www.nationmaster.com

Compare the top lists and the bottom lists you will be quite surprised at the findings, I know I was, I had always thought America lead the world in several categories where they actually scored quite poorly. In regards to HEALTH, even prescriptions available, hospital beds available, doctors etc. you scored FAR lower than I had thought you would. And in many cases no beter if nto lower than Canada's horrible system that you guys ut down for a living.

by garion11

China and India and don't forget Russia (after they learn how to handle Capitalism).

by delbertpgh

The 2nd World War busted the British. The Americans financed their war, and demanded payment or concessions for everything. The Brits spent more than they could afford to pay back.

by hal 9000

Still paying it off?

What happens to the USA economy when they finish paying it off?

Also what do you think will happen to the British economy when they finish paying it off as well?

As I've said previously FDR was a very astute politician and get exactly what he thought he wanted but it has come back to bite your country on the arse without you ever knowing about it until it was far too late.

Col

by hereinoz

So how about it Garion? Just join up to an Australian forum and get stuck into us.

As Col said, you would be a rank amateur alongside most of us in criticising our own government - it is something we do well!!

I am sure that Col has a list of forums (good Roman word, that) that allow you to sling off at Australia. Or you could actually start a post in Tech Republic such as "Why John Howard lives in the '50s and why Mark Latham has a media presentation problem" That should get you going on a good one.

There are plenty more.
"Why Bondi beach stinks in Summer and what are you doing about it"
"Why are we killing hundreds of cute cuddly koalas on Kangaroo Island"
"Why don't we send John Howard and Mark Latham to Kangaroo Island disguised as koalas?"

The list is endless. Go for it!! Or is the problem that you really don't know anything about us, so you don't know what things to talk about?

Cheers,

Alan

by garion11

I have no problem if you guys criticize your own governments or candidates that are running for your governments. Hell, I hope you do. I certainly criticized both Bush, Clinton, Gore, Bush, Kerry etc.... and continue to...

The polite factor comes into play for me when I am invited to provide opinions on other countries' politicians (unless he is a dictator etc). I refrain from doing that because it simply isn't polite and shows a lack of class and stupidity when you post crap about things you don't know...(for example: stuff about foreign countries' democratic leaders etc). You don't know the issues facing this country (domestic and foreign), past behavior of the parties, certain characteristics that both displayed which I am sure is omitted by your media, etc...So why would you think it is entirely approriate to come and post about Kerry and Bush when you know nothing and it frankly isn't your business?

If Bin Laden's video didn't prove that it isn't your business I don't what did. No citizen of any country (unless you lived in the US for a certain amount of time) knows the US candidates and political parties...so out of respect and politeness you shouldn't post stuff because it isn't your country and most of all you don't live here. If you want to ask a question about either parties or candidates, by all means go ahead...but don't assume things about Americans (and her politics) which I find misinformed and just plain rude.

So I thank you for the invitation but I respectfully decline. Although I must express my thanks to the Australian people for electing your incumbant.

by jardinier

"things you don't know...(for example: stuff about foreign countries' democratic leaders etc). You don't know the issues facing this country (domestic and foreign), past behavior of the parties, certain characteristics that both displayed which I am SURE IS OMITTED BY YOUR MEDIA, etc...So why would you think it is entirely appropriate to come and post about Kerry."

Actually Garion, I would say that the Australian media covers American political news in greater depth and with less bias than apparently is the case in America.

But then I guess you are so self-focussed that you wouldn't bother to read the online Australian newspapers and learn this for yourself.

by mlandis

Because Australia is an ally of the US they had lost 202 people 2 years ago, in a terrorist attack. Their efforts at bringing the terrorists to justice are frustrated with the same legal dances that we experience here in the States.

Not quite 2 months ago a car bomb went off in front of the Australian Embassy in Jakarta, Indonesia killing 9. Australian citizens are at risk abroad because of her relationship with the US.

At 12,000 or so miles away North Korea may seem a distant problem to many Americans. However, to Australians, New Zealanders, Chinese, Japanese and others in nearby environs North Korea and her potential threats are practically on their doorsteps.

The foreign policies of the US have far-reaching ramifications, and touch more lives than you realize. They don't live here, but find themselves affected by US policy and US leadership nonetheless.

It behooves the Australians to have an interest.

In this case, it is not the Australians who are misinformed.

Maureen (New Jersey)

by hal 9000

You should be bitterly complaining about the AU Prime Ministers comments recently about who is his preferred President in the USA.

I think it totally inappropriate his behavior in this case but then again he is so far up GWB's arse that even if GWB was to have a colinstectmentcy you would still be unable to see JW Howard's soles of his shoes.

Maybe if you where to push a laparscope down GWB thought you just might get a glimpse of JWH's bald spot but even that is unlikely. Incidental JWH seems to think because of his relationship with GWB he knows what is best for AU and is also incapable of saying he was wrong even when a person currently on trial in a close neighbor makes threats against AU for its support of the US policy.

But you are quite correct I know very little about individual US politicians and really I'm not all that interested. If you actually take the time to read what I've posted elsewhere you will not see any Political bias at all for one candidate or the other from me just a general dislike of every Politician.

Col

by hereinoz

You are spot on - the British Empire fell for exaclty the same reasons that the US is manufacturing for itself now. History is like Garlic - it just keeps on repeating.

by jardinier

All in favour say "Aye." Motion carried.

Without mentioning names, I can think of one peer who, when his postings are attacked, often tries to make out that it was intended to be a joke.

Of course there are some noticeable exceptions at this website among American members -- and may The Force be with them.

But my all-time favourite comment was made by GOD.
"The only time I look down my nose at an American is when my wife is bl**ing me."

by mlandis

Hi Col,

I'm going out on a limb here and I might need some burn gel after I get flamed, but here goes.

The way history is taught in the USA from the primary through secondary grades is in isolated curricula.

Let's take the Atlantic crossing arrival of Columbus in 1492, a familiar event in history.

To read most of my children's history books, (third grade = 8 yoa and sixth grade = 11 yoa) you would think that Columbus got this brainstorm
out of the clear blue sky one day, and went looking for the Indies, simply because he wanted to prove the world is round.

To fully understand how Columbus got to that point of course, one would have to at least know that Marco Polo had re-developed the itinerary to the orient in the 13th century, and the ancient "Silk Road" as it was called was again traversed and a well-known trade route, and Marco Polo, a European, continued eastward and extending the overland trade route to China.

One would have to be familiar with the group of battles collectively called the Crusades, and the beginnings of the Ottoman empire.

One would have to be familiar with the fall of Constantinople in 1453

One would also have to know that the Ottoman Empire was expanding into areas that were travelled by "Silk Road" traders, making an already dangerous journey practically a suicide mission for anyone who would consider himself a Christian.

And of course, it would also help to know of Queen Isabella of Spain's Inquisitons and banishments of Jews and Moors in that very year.

None of this is in the book. That Columbus went to prove the world is round and find a new route to the spice producing Indies is mentioned is thought to be sufficient information. That is thought to be reason enough to take this perilous and untested journey.

The stage which developed throughout the previous centuries necesitating this journey for an alternate route to the Indies for securing Spain's continuing place in the European theatre and hope for domination is not given a mention at all.

This is just a "for example." There is little Ancient Greek or Roman history taught in the schools in New Jersey. I had 3 years of Latin in High School a century ago, and have some knowlege of both Latin language and the Roman Empire's history. Today, most High School teens are not given these subjects in the New Jersey public schools.

The curricula to be covered are taught, but the connections are hard for students to grasp when one year the history taught is the American Revolution, and the next year, the Holocaust of WWII.

The "whats?" are taught, the more thought provoking "whys?" are seldom covered. Part of the reason is that the US has over 225 years of her own history, and almost 3 hundred years prior to 1776 of colonisation history. I believe if there were a stronger base (in European and English history) going into the colonisation period, more Americans would be far more interested in global history and current events.

With the stresses of making sure that children can pass the reading, writing and math standardized testing expected by the 50 states, other subjects are not covered as extensively as ought be done.

Most of the Americans in this forum would be better educated than the average American, but that does not go on to say that they are more aware of how world views Americans. Some of us are, and some aren't. It all depends on what we experience, read, think and listen to, and whether we are willing to learn a thing or two from others.

Anyway, I thought that all Aussies were crocodile huntin', Foster's drinkin' and barby cookin' folk.

Maureen

by jardinier

Unquestionably without assistance from America -- especially in terms of military hardware and supplies -- who knows how far Hitler's poison may have spread?

Not being a great historian, I have no idea why Japan attacked Pearl Harbour, but I cannot see any obvious reason why America would have become involved in the conflict in the Pacific without this provocation from Japan.

And while some guys at this website like to repeatedly say: "If it weren't for America, you would all be speaking German," the greater reality is that if it weren't for America, Australians would all be speaking Japanese.

So yes, in may ways America has exerted a positive influence in the world -- that is, up to the Iraq debacle which it currently appears will prove to have done more harm than good.

While all you hawks like to say that the war in Vietnam could have been won if it weren't for all the protesters, this is highly speculative, as the enemy was prepared to sacrifice as many lives as it took to win the war.

And after all that horror and bloodshed, Vietnam is now a communist country anyhow.

by garion11

But you can say that about any other country. This is a global stage, more than ever. So please don't lecture me about the US foreign policy effects, because other countries' policies affect the rest of the world OOOOH...*GASP* in a much worse way. How could that be? NK is an excellent example, thank you for strengthing my point.

by hal 9000

After I picked myself up off the floor from laughing so hard. I think you forgot about the Kangaroos and Koalas in everyones yard as well.

But I wonder if any pictures of Columbus's ships are ever shown and how that "Rose Crux" on the fore sail is explained away. Maybe it just isn't even noticed or even understood that actually Columbus actually sailed under the Templar's protection hence their symbol on every one of those 3 ships to ward off attack.

Anyway next time your over here I'll throw another crock on the "Barbie" along with some wallaby stew and while Fosters isn't a big seller in this part of AU I'm sure I can dig up a slab or 20 of 4X the local brew around here.

Col

by jardinier

Are you actually suggesting that Fox News is a reliable source of information? Do you personally form your opinions based on Fox News?

Well let me tell you something. I am personally indebted to Rupert Murdoch because he paid my wage for four years on the now defunct Sydney Daily Mirror.

But Fox News? Well here is a good example of how the Australian media reports American news more accurately and with less bias than some American media.

It has been clearly demonstrated, from former reporters of Fox News who have resigned in disgust, that this is nothing more than a propaganda machine for Bush.

When reporters are given an assignment, they are TOLD beforehand what their stories are to say.

Tragically, this carefully manufactured propaganda outlet for Bush is currently the most widely watched news service in the USA.

But to answer your question, the Foxtel network is available in Australia by cable or satellite dish.

by olprof67

Maureen's observation is an accurate one. However, it should be noted that many of the issues raised would have been considered far too controversial to have been adressed by open discussion in the public schools until a few years ago.

I grew up as a farm boy outside a small industrial center of 25000 pupulation in the late 50's and early 60's. The mill ran for 13 blocks down the center of town. The East Side was predominately German and (mostly Fundamentalist) Protestant; the West Side predominately Eastern European and Catholic. The role of religious differences in European civilization simply was not discussed by mutual agreement.

My Dad, who surely had his predjudices, often told of a story that depicted the company in which he trained during World War II being bitterly divided along ethnic lines. It was not until I entered college and was exposed to Humanities I that I encountered a forum where these issues could be raised without anticipation of an argument.

Unfortunately, while the study of our overcoming of these problems is no longer such a third rail, I can't escape the impression that the NEA works much too hard at spoon-feeding it's own soft-left eco-feminist agenda within the classroom.

by mlandis

Col

I prefer the ales, porters and stouts, myself. Was I ever surprised to see Budweiser touted and advertised in England and Ireland. I warned my cousins they would be subject to torment in hell if they drank that stuff if there were another choice to be had. If I must drink a lighter beer and Stellas are available that would be my first choice.

No, I did not know about it being specifically the Rose Cross of the Templars being on the sails of Columbus' ships. Was he one?

If GWB had a colonoscopy done and JWH were found, would that be a better or worse diagnosis than colon cancer?

I'm not lecturing anyone, Garion. You would be surprised how many people do not understand how one policy in one country affects other nations, and why there is such an interest in US politics.

Olprof67,
I went to 12 years of Catholic school through the 60's and early 70's. My parents were from Ireland, and I lived in a very diverse neighborhood in NYC. I had a very enriched education because my parents supplemented what I had in school, and read various newspapers, including Irish and English ones. My father taught me that education is not just about school, it is an ongoing process. Both of them instilled in me a love for people, reading and learning that I hope I can do half the job in giving my children such rich experiences.

My neighborhood was quite diverse. In addition to the scores of Irish and first generation American Irish, there was a Yeshiva University down the street, Cuban political refugees, Greek immigrants, a few Armenians and quite a few immigrants from other countries as well. God bless my parents - they never discouraged my friendships with these "other" kids. I had learned Spanish and Greek from my friends. I knew Jews, Eastern Rite/Roman Catholics, and Greek Orthodox too. I preferred going to Greek Orthodox Christmas and Easter Services than to RC. I had an access to many cultures that helped me gain a much wider world view at a very young age than most people would have had opportunity to enjoy.

I learned a lot of history growing up.

I also have cousins in Australia, and family by marriage in Canada.

(By the way - I have since converted and am now a Unitiarian-Universalist. My father is gone, RIP, and my mother is still recovering.)

Gotta go to work-

Later,
Maureen

by oz_media

Ahhhhhh STELLAAAA~ My fav at the race track. Nothing better than a cold Stella (Becks if Stella's are gon) and some ponies for the punters.

I am a HUGE Guinness guy though. My dad owns a pub in England and when I was young I picked up the half pint knickname because he gave me a half of Guinness for helping my mum around the hotel part.

I was hooked! Now they hae FINALLY started to being a decent Guinness into Canada on TAP but before that it was bottles (eeeeew!) and Widget cans (not too bad). At first, they had a few pubs here pouring Tap Guinness on the regular lines (MUCH TOO COLD!) now the reps insist that the pubs install separate lines and coolers for the Guinness to keep it consistent.

The Guinness family has a huge history for building Vancouvers North Shore (which they once owned, thus the name 'British Properties') and the famous Lions Gate Bridge.

Then there's the creamy Boddingtons once in a while, the odd Newcastle etc. as the local pubs have started to upgrade thier tap fair.

sorry to jump in on the off-subject but the beer post got my attention.

Fosters, disgusting, I think they send it to North America because nobody in Australia drinks the crap.

There's a GREaAT site (I think it's called the 'OPG.com ' Opinionated Beers Guys (something like that). Beer grades from ALL over the world, they are Americans that realized what GARBAGE beer we get thrown at us in North America, they have collected and reviewed beer from all over the world. Great site, great beer humour.

have a great day,
OM

by oz_media

Foz news approached the Canadian Radiotelevision and Telecommunications Commission about broadcasting in Canada. They were told it must include a certain percentage of Canadian news content but refused sayign that they ONLY wanted to provide US news angles.

Aj Jazeera news actually as a better chance of makign our CRTC guidelines and has agreed to present a specific amout of Canadian focused news as well as thier own.

So WHY won't FOX broadcast a Canadian view? Is it prehaps because the Americans news would seem so inadequate ad incomplete? From the US News I get, it sure does seem to only be HALF of the trues story on most issues.

Like with teh Canadian man who was jailed for buying 2500 explosives from Halliburton, getting them ito Caada and back across the line to his US base for counterterroism training camps.

The US spin on that story was SO far out of whack it wasn't even close! He has now been released and is suing Halliburton and another weapons builder who were told to destroy the explosives under military law, and sold them out of the country istead.

by hal 9000

made by Castlemain Perkins called XX XX or VB produced locally but if pushed I could always get a six pack of Darwin Stubbies these things are small bottles of beer brewed in Cairns but only for sale in Darwin I think they are about 80 fluid ounces or so. Suffice to say that the make the average Winchester of Champagne look small. There are a multitude of others available in cans but you will mostly only find the XXXX & VB on TAP in the pubs up here.

As far as Chris Columbus goes no he wasn't a Templar he was just sailing under their protection hence their mark on the fore sails of his ships as a warning to any who might attack his convoy although I'm not exactly sure what the Templar's could have done since he was so far out of there sphere of influence at the time. But if anything had of happened to his convoy and the people responsible ever returned to the Templar's sphere of influence I'm sure that there would have been dire consequences for those involved. It might also have helped to control his crew as well.

Well about your last question I'm not really sure but I'm sure JWH would be kicking the laporscope and saying go away I'm happy here! Over here we constantly refer to the AU Federal Parliament as Kindergarten for the badly behaved out of control children who just have to be sent some place where they can not hurt themselves or others. We built a special city for them in the middle of nowhere and used an Aboriginal work to name it Canberra which I'm told means "Land between hills that is worthless and no one wants!"

We tried to burn it down last year with all the pollies there but failed miserably so we had to have the place rebuilt "If only the wind had not of died out. It appears that the pollies stopped talking and all the hot air that they produce stopped the massive updraft which was sucking in the fire!"

A couple of years ago we even built them a new sandpit to play in as the old one was not producing the incentive that it once did and they where starting to not spend as much time in Canberra as they used to. We just had to alter that as they are all far too dangerous if let out of their sand pit for any length of time.

Col

by hal 9000

On the late night news last night. It appears that NATO currently has a lot of troops in Afghanistan trying to keep the place together and not descending into chaos again once the bulk of the US troops where pulled out.

The guy who was answering the questions an ex Air Minister who is now teaching at Kings was claiming that while most of Europe supported the invasion of Afghanistan and where helping there they just lack the troop numbers to be able to offer support to Kerry's solution they would have to pull troops from Afghanistan to be in a position to send troops to Iraq.

I really do not think that a lot of our American cousins know just how much Europe is actually doing in the "War on Terror" Even Japan's Government is going against their citizens wished by having troops in Iraq something like 80% of Japans population is against this move as it is placing the Japanese Defense forces back into a position like they where prior to WW11 not a defensive force but an aggressive force it's very unpopular in Japan.

Col

by tomsal

This like some boring re-run of a once funny and/or interesting show, but after you heard it (seen it) the first 1 billion times it got old.

I thought we put the 2000 election to bed you know 4 YEARS AGO....please don't tell me tomorrow we will re-live it again.

by olprof67

If the American electoral process is again thrown into the courts, it will be bcause the most simplistic and egalitarian-oriented of the political professionals put it there.

Our nation's record of expanding the base of the elecorate is an admirable one. But unfortunately, there are those, generally on the lower left side of the political spectrum, who will sink to any level to recruit one more disenchanted misfit to their cause.

Basic standards of literacy and foresight should be a requirement for voting privelages, and I guarantee it will be the leftists who will fight this tooth-and-nail in the name of class-consciousness. What ruined France and almost ruined Great Britain and Scandinavia must not be permitted to happen here.

by hal 9000

Those who forget their past are bound to relive it until they eventually get it right!

Col

by mlandis

Colin -

Whatever I was doing in the 70's has made me forget quite a bit.

I get to do it again? Practice makes perfect?

Maureen

by tomsal

True...I like that saying, good meaning.

But how many times must we (the taxpaying, hardworking, ethical americans) have to hear non-americans singing the same songs from the choir?

My ears are beginning to bleed....please a new song!

:)

by garion11

Your pathetic attempts to bash America again shows how clueless you are to the obvious.

America is doing something right to be labeled Hyperpower by France and Germany.

America is doing something right to have the largest and most vibrant economy in the world

America is doing something right to have the largest and most powerful military in the world

If Europe and other countries' beat out America in so many other categories as you state, I wonder where American wealth is coming from? I actually agree with you on the education part, but while Europe/Asia (a big laugh, more like Asia)has a better educated populace, America is where the opportunity. So they are moving here and they can come here and be American.

Please go and educate yourself, you are a Canadian socialist who depends on the government to give you stuff, while people in America still have the noble character to work for themselves.

by oz_media

hi Colin, Noticed the Castlemaine post and had to smile.

The REAL Oz's dad gets me to fix his PC once in a while when I go to town, he ALWAYS has a case of Castlemaine XXXX for me, I still have a 6 in the fridge now. I don't REAlLY care for it, too much though as it has an almost winish taste to it, a little too much like a merlot?!? As much as I love some whites, I don't care for most reds and Castlemaine reminds me too much of a really heavy red.

I am thinking he must be getting an old dead batch, he's a longshoreman and everything comes from 'the docks', but I hav neer been interested in puicking it up at a liquor store because if it IS the right one, then I wouldn't wat to pay for it.

but it would simply be impolite to say no, so I smile and thank him as he hands me yet another case of it. He's Irish, why the hell can't he get Guinness!? :p

by tomsal

First I think there is nothing wrong we people having different likes or dislikes....I think it should be a worldwide right for us to all hate equally...LOL!! (for those born without a sense of humor...we call that sarcasm, its a joke).

Secondly, and keep in mind in my own little world (re: my circle of friends and family) I'm considered one of the biggest cynics out there known to man....come everyone must insist on such a negative slant ALL THE TIME, boasting that what in reality is just their own emotional personal belief or opinion is FACT?

The only reason this country supports that country is because of xyz....the only reason this nationality hates that nationality is abc...

Its always gear to money, oil or some other precious resource.

Can't their be even the slightest bit of chance that just MAYBE their does exist people who ARE NOT as cynical or jaded about things as we in this forum are?

Maybe one nation simply enjoys the mutual benefit of sharing its cultural and love of freedom and the pursuit thereof?

I don't have a damn thing against most countries or races on the face of the planet, I have very strong feelings about the middle east however...but leaving that region of the world out... I think Australia would be AWESOME to visit, its on my list of places to go before I'm a worm feast....along with Scotland and England. To be honest I'm not really into the Asian cultures all that much, though Martial arts fascinates.

Anyway...

I think we are all flawed as people, none of us are perfect. Just as EVERY country the whole lot of them , including the USA, Australia, UK, Canada, etc. there are things that are ugly, nasty and sickening about all the countries on the earth, you know why? They share a commone weakness.....they are run, rule, founded, managed and lived on by humans.

;)

And for the record, ok I get it guys....some folks hate us Americans...duly noted...I'm constantly told by people of other countries you americans don't know how the rest of the world views you....um actually no you are all dead wrong...I hear WAY WAY more people preaching the bad things about my country and how we are viewed than the good things...I'd say it's like a 10:1 ratio in fact.

So that's the real reason a chord get's struck with me on the "hating" american thing....that's all I hear....and how ironic...people telling me how awful my society is over and over again, meanwhile....I'm saying FAR FAR FAR less about any other countries.

So who really is the bad guy here?

I'm sorry it just gets very upsetting and incredibly frustrating and so damn old!

by oz_media

Ad you just kep repeating it, one day people may actually believe you.

Now start studying the military facts and personal wealth of nations, you are not the highest in personal wealth by a long shot.

So call Liberal Canada what you will, the facts remain the same. I HAVE spent more than enough time in the US, deal with US companies and get a portion of my income in US dollars form US companies, I have subcontracted US staff etc.

Having lived in other parts of the world, I know better than to move to the US or become a citizen. You claim that everyone is moving there, based on the statistics provided in the link, can you point out just how you reached that conclusion? I think you have more people leaving Aamerica for Europe from what I remember reading. In fact GERMANY is the most popular dstination for them.

Spend a few hours trying to familiarize yourself with it, there are so many different stats that are similar it is easy to draw such conclusions, but the details are there if you look.

Bottom line, you are not the world leader at everything you do, as many seem to feel. In fact you are the leader in VERY few categories and even within those categories only on certain specifics.

such as:
Economic Aid Donor (per capita) where you sit in 20th spot, Luxembourg at #1 with $352.30 per person

You economy GDP (per capita)is another place where Americans think they lead the world, Luxembourg also beats you here. $48309.28 per person to you 2nd place of $35991.65 per person.

Military expenditures per capita: You are third behind Israel and Singapore.

Life Expectancy: you rank 48th

You did pretty good with Most Trigger Happy, Total Crimes 'NUMBER ONE' (however not per capita)!! But MILITARY AND ARMY personelle per capita, you came in 32nd behind places like Kuwait, Greece, Great Britain, Norty Korea (#1).

Economic Freedom, I believe where you feel the US excells the most, you sit in 7th place, behind HK, singapore, New Zealand, Luxembourg, Ireland and Estonia.

Health Drug Access: your superior health system that you comment about so often, leaves you in 27th place, behind Canada, UK, SWAZILAND, Sri Lanka, Saudi Arabia, even though the stats for EACH are between 95-100% availability.

The list of areas in which you BELIEVE to be superior where you actually aren't are endless.

As I have always said, Americans aren't bad people, they just need a little taste of Humble Pie and forget about Mom's apple pie.

It is the world around you that sees you for what you are, you seem not to.

When you propose to be more and are not, this is called arrogance, which people don't care for.

Yet you STILL think the world is full of people wanting to be American? My god, go outside or something. Pinch yourself, maybe reality will set in.

Tell you, given the choice, most people choose Germany over America I know I sure as hell would.

by hal 9000

I was working with mainframes back then the great Unix systems and then I made the mistake of starting to play with PC's. Sure there is a bigger market and they are far cheaper but in all honestly Windows can not be called an improvement.

So my lesson is to learn as much as possible about Windblows because sure as hell M$ will not help at all. I almost long for the days when I was working with microprocessor controlled things with out anything that was made by Microsucks to stuff things up totally.

Incidental if you enjoyed what you where doing in the 70's then you will never get to relive them as you would be having far too much fun!

Col

by mlandis

And multi-user licensed WordPerfect through Dos.

There was always something gratifying about the "kill user" command especially when it was the same lulus who would be logged on, but long out the door, before the nightly tape back up.

People would scratch their heads when I said I had to get t y on the way home. (there were gas stations called "Getty" - I don't see too many of them any more.)

I guess I have to get a grep on the changes.

Maureen

by hal 9000

But I guess that I'm as geriatric as the equipment that I just loved to work with.

Incidental I'm still using Word Perfect and it runs rings around Word. Currently it is up to version 12 and I just can not tear myself away from it as it is my preferred WP and most other Office apps.

Most of the people I have working for me where dedicated M$ Office people and they insisted that they have Office on their workstations. Now they all claim that it is "Cruel and Inhumane Punishment" when they are forced to use Office to do anything. Strange that after playing with Word Perfect for a few months they all switched to it rather than use M$ Office.

I really miss the command line prompts as well but then again I did start with Unix and it is what I'm happiest working with.

Col

by mlandis

The guys in the office were asking me what was so funny.

You forgot to mention the eyedrops, though.

I keep a barrel of moisturizer on my desk. Doesn't everyone?

Later,

Maureen

by maecuff

they should. I have a 19 year old stepdaughter who will NOT wear moisterizer because it feels 'icky'. I keep telling her she'll regret it sooner than later. Her reply, of course, is "what difference will it make if I'm wrinkled when I'm THIRTY."

by bfilmfan

Most Americans are well aware of our long tradition of election day fiascos. These are just a few of the many examples in the Presidential race:

1824
Andrew Jackson won the popular vote but lost the presidency to John Quincy Adams in the House of Representatives.

1876
Rutherford Birchard Hayes is elected President in a backroom deal over Samuel J. Tilden by ONE vote of the Electoral College . The way the decision was reached almost started a constitutional crisis and threatened to start another civil war.

1960:
Widespread allegations of voter fraud in Chicago, New Jersey, Texas and Illinois in the election of John F Kennedy. Multiple federal suits brought by the GOP to have the election results retabulated and thrown out.

1996:
Widespread accounts of fund raising irregularities lead to charges that the election was bought and stolen.

Get out and vote today! Keep an American vote stealer employed!

by jamesrl

The relationship between Canada and US has been compared to a mouse sleeping beside and elephant. When the elephant sneezes, the mouse gets very sick. When the elephant twitches, the mouse gets convulsions. When the elephant rolls over, the mouse gets crushed.

US economic policy has huge impact on Canada. We are by far each others biggest customers. When the US puts tariffs on softwood lumber or blocks Canadian beef, tens of thousands of people and billions of dollars of business are negatively impacted. If you double the importation of Canadian perscription drugs into US, we will be short of drugs for our own citizens.

So we do have a stake in your election. In our wallets.

James

by hal 9000

What exactly do you want broken.

Just list it here and I'll send Big Louie around to perform the surgery.

Col

by hal 9000

Consider 30 to be the use by date?

OH how they change their minds as they get a few more years under their belts.

Col

by maecuff

It will get here before she knows it, and then she'll realize that '50 is the new 30'. :)

by hal 9000

Some git places some very large speakers 12 inches from each ear and then plays Black Sabbath at max output and at 78 RPM at 3.00 AM while you where asleep. The first thing that you realize is that you are clutching the paint on the ceiling and there is funny red stuff leaking every body opening.

But for a few nanoseconds you image that you've seen your GOD!

Col

by tomsal

Nice post! :)

Good thing this was in text otherwise we'd probably be screaming at each other to be heard...

lol

by oz_media

Iron Maiden had a concert tour through 82-83 (the World Slavery tour) where they were bragging the poudest PA ever installed in an indoor arena, 150,000 watts (which at that time a lot of power (pre lasers))

I was working backstage scheduling security detail and a roadie asked for a hand, so I helped yank a few bass cas out of a truck for the first sound check (non musicians). While laughing at the size of the cabs, I crawled inside a bass dump just as Niko's (drummer's) tech tested the kicks. I was rushed to hospital with bleedig eardrums, idiot! I made it back in time to do the show but only with landing crew hearing protection on and a constant whistle in my ears.

Funny thing though, given the chance I'd do it again tomorrow. I LOVE clean power!

The self proclaimed LOUDEST band on Earth though is MOTORHEAD, and after some 35 years of tours and at age 60 he STILL rocks like he has no ears.

and every year I STILL get right in front of the bass monitors and watch the show from the wings, where it's loudest! !

if music was meant to be played quietly, they wouldn't have invented AMPS.

by mlandis

I have nightmares about nursing homes when it is "our turn"

The nurses will have tattoos that cover their entire bodies with pierced lips, noses, ears, eyebrows and more. I can just imagine how sympathetic they would be when giving a needle or setting up an IV.

"This is nothing, dear. I had it much worse when I got this tattoo, pierced my (parts known, not politely mentioned)..."

And if able to speak, would we dare say "Yes you eejit, but you had a choice, and could have been stoned at the time. I am to be medicated, not made aerodynamic!!!"

Who knows by that time maybe there would be a choice of tattoo with whatever needle you are getting.

"Do you want the flower tattoo or the pirate tattoo with your injection of B12?"

Will playing air guitar be permitted in the old-age home?

A friend's ruminations on Rod Stewart:

He'll still be out there with a WALKER in 20 years...

"Dooo you think I'm breathing,
And you want my wheelchair,
Come on grandma let me know!
Just reach out and hold me,
Don't let me fall over,
Get the pan, I gotta go!"

The old standards he started recording in later years? "Steal my Daddy's cue, and make a living outta playing pool" ... ? He's probably inherited it by now!

Later,
Maureen

by jardinier

Every now and then I have to remind myself that you are almost 30 years younger than myself, and belong to that generation which believes that the louder the music the better, and if it so loud that you can't distinguish the words at all, then it must be outstanding.

Being an audiophile in my youth, I designed and built my own sound equipment. In the very early 1960s, my amplifier used twin 6V6s in push-pull mode with feedback, giving the extraordinary output of 14 watts.

The speaker was a twin-cone Peerless (from Denmark) with quite a small magnet, in a vented enclosure which I built.

The pick-up was an Australian-made MBH magnetic (flat from 20 Hz - 20 KHz) and if there was any better pickup in the world, it would have been the Ortofon.

Yet this system was quite adequate for roudy dancing at private parties, and was even used satisfactorily at a dance in a small hall.

It sufficed my needs quite adequately for 20 years.

I have never been able to understand why musicians (and this includes top jazz groups as well as R & R) are happy to use sound equipment which completly destroys the natural quality (timbre) of their music.

Perhaps you can resolve this mystery for me.

by jardinier

Col, In response to your posting (and I am indeed delighted to learn that at least one modern group prefers quality to volume) I simply class all popular music produced in the past 3 - 4 decades as "Young People's Music."

Of course there are exceptions, but to my ears I can't tell the difference between one "song" and another. For the greater part there is no discernible melody, and no rhyme or metre to the lyrics.

And why do I call it "Young People's Music?" Because if I were 30 years younger I would probably enjoy it too.

I well remember that when I purchased Bill Haley's "Rock Around The Clock" album about 45 years ago, my mother cried and my sister slammed the door to think that I would bring such evil music into the house.

Recently at a garage sale I picked up a copy of the original Bill Haley album. I STILL love "Rock Around The Clock."

by maecuff

That my son and I are so much different than my parents and I were when I was a teenager. My mother has never been a fan of ANY music (which to me is sad and empty) and my dad listened to The Clancy Bros. and well, that's about it, Irish folk music. They HATED the music I listened to. My son and I however, share very similar tastes, even more so, the older he gets. It warms my heart when he wants to borrow my Clash, or Ramones, or Pixies albums. Granted, I'm not too crazy about him going to see the Isane Clown Posse, but at least I'm not going to freak out like my parents did when I snuck out to see Aerosmith. (and I paid 6.00 for that ticket!)

by bob in calgary

Grateful Dead had the loudest sound system, They use to rent in out to other groups for the concerts, I remember seeing Deep Purple at knebworth park in the early 70's Now that was a concert, you could clearly hear the music over three miles away, And I was about 100 yards from those speakers..........Pardon did someone say something.

by hal 9000

And I'm already had it so things can only go downhill from here.

I just hope nothing really bad happens today as I'm far too fragile for it to happen.

My son who is now pushing 30 quit a job yesterday and at 5.00 am there was a phone call from him top drive him to work so I've now been up for a little over 3 hours which is more sleep than what I had last night.

Col

by jardinier

I like your comments TomSal.

I think the reason that America gets so much adverse comment from around the world could be simply that it is the most high profile nation the world.

quod erat demonstrandum.

by jesuss

If you hate the US so much, why are you still here. Go live in China or India. It's obvious to me that you are and extreme-left pessimistic liberal. That's the beautiful thing about this great country of ours: You can believe whatever you want without worrying about being publicly executed.

My question to you and everyone who reads this is: Why can't we all just be friends and stop bashing the GOP? I'm not saying Bush hasn't done anything wrong, but he's not the incompetent moron most people make him out to be. If I remember correctly, the democtrats also had an "embarrasment" of their own. None other than William Jefferson "Bubba" Clinton. So why don't we call this discussion even and focus on the important things like the outcome of next year's world series. (Yankees all the way). :)

by hal 9000

But the Politician's just beg for some bashing by their actions and it's fun.

Actually if whats been said about GWB makes you think people hate him you would be lost for words if you where to hear how the AU Prime Minister is talked about over here most describe him as a little boy who is constantly complaining to mommy that he doesn't want to go to Parliament today because all the others pick on him and steal his bucket and spade in the sand pit. That is just some of the nicer stuff and I could go on but it would mean that this discussion gets pulled.

Col

by jardinier

Quite possibly some of our American friends are unaware that Opposition Leader, Mark Latham, first attracted the attention of the media, and subsequently the public, by describing Howard as an "arse-licker" because of his subservient attitude to Bush.

Well of course it was quite wrong of Mark to use that term, when the more precise term would have been "suppository."

And as for telling lies, well GWB could learn a thing or two from Howard. While Bush is inclined to paint a rosy picture of unpleasant events in Iraq for example, Howard simply tells outright lies -- again and again and again.

Now I know that some of you guys think I am a committed leftie/commie or whatever, so I would like to take this opportunity to set the record straight.

I DO NOT judge/assess our PMs on the basis of their political affiliations, but on their perceived character and ability to introduce sound policy.

I can name at leat two conservative prime ministers whom I have respected -- Harold Holt and Malcolm Fraser.

In contrast, I don't recall any American in any of these discussions EVER saying anything nice about any Democrat president since JFK. [Please correct me if I have overlooked any posting that has said something nice about these Democrat presidents).

So who is biased?

by oz_media

To be a grumpy old codger!

"You kids these days! Why, when I was young..."

The nursing home would be a fun pllace to pee yourself and watch the little ungrateful bastards clean up after you.

But I think the Rolling Stones will still be around, and AC/DC of course.

by hal 9000

It is meant to be drunk ice cold. While I no longer drink beer because of a Hep scare a couple of decades ago I understand that it only reaches it's proper taste when cold unlike the beer that I had when I was in the UK which was luke warm.

But to be brutally honest I was the guy standing on the beach in Briton in a duffel coat watching all those crazy Poms in brief swimming costumes complaining about the heat to me it was far too cold to even consider getting undressed let alone get wet.

Col

by hal 9000

To build a time machine and take us all 740 years into the future at a nice pub where we can all get plastered and talk about what went on in our time.

I can't think of a better way to blow an afternoon away.

Col

by hal 9000

Minimize the load through your potentiometer {in nontechnical words {Turn it up!}"

That is how real music is supposed to be listened to and at volumes that I describe as "Audio Assault" levels is best.

Groups like Slade AC,DC and their ilk just have to remain as they are the only real music makers left who do not lip sink.

I remember the concert for E11 Jubilee it was all the old rockers who could just pickup an instrument and play unrehearsed while the so called "Pop Groups" could only stand around looking silly for the final song. They looked totally unprofessional beside the likes of Clapton, Mc Cathy, Ozzie and the rest of them.

But I'll admit that AC DC just isn't as good as they used to be when Scott was alive but they still manage to rock along but maybe I'm preduced as I used to work with them back then here in AU when they where a small group and I always thought it would be Angus who would die first as he would always come offstage with all the veins on his head sticking out throbbing he looked like a heart attack waiting to happen.

Col

by hal 9000

That in the early days at least AC DC never compromised they wanted it loud but never to the stage where distortion was heard and the singer was always audible over the music.

Even on their latter stuff it was the same and I still love their music but I can not listen to a recording without seeing Angus going crazy it is just something that sticks in your head like Pete Townsend from the Who caring on the way that he did.

The only thing that I see wrong with what is called modern music is that they rely far too much on visual enhancements rather than allowing the music to speak for itself.

Col

by maecuff

I really hope you get some sleep. I've been an insomniac for years and there really isn't anything that substitutes a good night of deep sleep.

by hal 9000

It's now 1.10 AM and I have to be on the road by 5.20 am so I don't think I'll even bother trying to get a few hours sleep as I'll only feel worse when I have to get up.

Col

by hal 9000

You wicked girl Mae wasting all that money on an Aerosmith concert. Now those where the days weren't they.

The last concert that I attended was a Dylan concert here in Brisbane about 20 odd years ago now I suppose and even then I think I paid well over $100.00 per ticket.

Col

by hal 9000

I did say I was trying to be polite didn't I?

Anyway I don't thing that our US cousins would understand the term "Brown Nose" as we apply it here or the way the then Treasurer Paul Keating was portrayed running through a mine field that he had just laid on a golf course to kill the then Prime Minister all for a $1.00 coin.

Actually it was Malcolm that made me so jaded about Politicians from his actions in 74 when he grabbed power the way that he did. It only confirmed my suspicion that these people where not interested in the good of the country but in their own perceived power and to win at all costs.

God only knows what Little Johnny Rotten will get up to now that he has total control of the Federal Government. However I think his current Treasurer will be stabbing him in the back very soon and taking his position as that political party needs a long time for their new leader to become palatable to the general population just like Malcolm Frazer's treasurer did who was Little Johny Rotten. It only took something like 12 years for him to become acceptable to the community.

Col

by hal 9000

America is doing something wrong to upset the Muslim world to such an extent that they attack you on your own soil.

Personally I can not remember any group that has gone to that much trouble to attack their supposed enemy.

As far as Germany and France goes I think it is very clever of them to use words like that as it diverts things away from them on to some one else namely your country.

Col

by delbertpgh

I doubt that when England finishes paying down their WWII debt to the U.S. it will make any difference. As the years and inflation go by, the sum becomes less and less significant. I remember my social studies teacher in 1962 talking about what a huge amount of money it was, and how we would probably never see it repaid. I think a number of our allies never paid. I'm actually pretty surprised to hear that Great Britain tried to pay, and is still paying.

Once the debt is clear, it will probably make no difference, except that now and then an English MP will puff up and be snooty about how the bill was paid off. Truth is, the Brits stick with us because we stabilized Europe and a large part of the world after the big war, and they want to keep us there because the Europeans still can't pull their own oars as a team; because Brits benefitted a great deal from the special relationship with us through two huge wars, and they perceive that by being the chief acolyte to our power, they will derive strength and influence; and because the English don't actually think they are Europeans. They have some scorn for Europe, and believe that both they and the U.S. are divided from Europe by water and by inherited qualities that render Europeans inferior to English-speaking folk.

So, the English will continue to be our friends for a long stretch, being the first to join us in our misjudged wars, at least until we lose our perspective and abandon Europe. They have learned the value of speaking flattery to power.