The "Evolution Lie" debate all over again. But SO much more important.
During the EL debate, one thing that the creationists kept pushing was the need for "equality" between the two "conflicting" viewpoints and the unfair way in which the research of creation scientists was being ignored or belittled by the vast majority of the scientific world.
Their argument was that each of the scientists following the current theories had a vested interest in maintaining the paradigm. I see some of the same happening here.
This is probably - certainly, if man-induced Global Warming is real and reversible - the most crucial scientific question of the new century. The winning side will shape economic policy, political and technological developments for decades to come. For this reason we must debate this properly as the consequences of getting it wrong are potentially catastrophic. "Real" global warming will kill many millions and an unnecessary major shutdown of the World's economy will likely result in the early deaths of millions also.
If the sceptics are to be believed, the evidence for global warming is full of holes, the field full of argument and uncertainty and the consensus is enforced by a scientific establishment riding the gravy train.
Well, I don't think so.
The basic physics of the greenhouse gases, carbon dioxide, water vapour and methane, and their ability to reflect infra-red radiation is a simple fact. As is the fact that carbon dioxide levels are 35% greater than pre-industrial levels and are still rising linearly when measured over the last fifty years. It is also a fact that the measurement of IR radiation - in the specific wavelengths that would be trapped by CO2 - that escapes from the earth has decreased in proportion over the last thirty years.
"Anthropogenic" greenhouse gas emissions, then, are tending to make the atmosphere warmer. Fact!
Then the uncertainty starts. The observed warming could be all natural as solar cycles and the changing frequency of volcanic eruptions have an effect on climate and have been calculated to account for at least 40% of the measured atmospheric warming (pro-gw) or all of it (anti-gw). It is interesting, however, that the climate models currently in use can be used to restrospectively "predict" the climate since 1850 and this matches well with the observed up until 1965 when the divergence begins and the Earth warmed more than predicted.
Where the greatest contoversy exists is in the role of feedback, negative to damp down the warming in a normal oscillation pattern and positive to kick it into something else that might not be reversible before another ice age. Melting ice on land reveals more land to absorb more heat - that one is happening. Negative - melting Arctic ice might weaken or shut down the Gulf Stream and make Northern Europe get much colder so more snow, more ice and more heat reflected back and cools again. Positive -Methane Hydrates held in permafrost and cold sea basins could melt resulting in a runaway warming releasing more hydrates ending with an increase of up to 11 degrees C.
Undecided - more water vapour in the atmpsphere means more clouds reflecting back more heat into space and more heat back to the ground. Which is greater?
We have to have the research done so that we can plan for the consequences even if we can't stop it.
There is a consensus amongst scientists that global warming is real. A review of the 928 peer-review papers on climate change published in the ten years up to 2003 showed that consensus to be real and near universal.
Is there, then, a gigantic conspiracy funded by the perfidious UN and its bastart child the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change? I think we should be told!
We know for sure that human activity is influencing climate change even if we don't know by how much or if it is reversible. We might still get away with it and the sceptics could be right. The majority of the world's climate scientists could be wrong.
It would be a lucky break.
Do you feel lucky?
Well, do you?