Discussion Locked

The Global Warming debate of 2005

0 helpful
101 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

On this year's Earth day (04/22/05), PBS'S Now featured the effects of global warming, the climate changes of years to come, the Crichton effect, and several different perspectives. It looks at recent scientific evidence that has set off alarms about the implications of melting glaciers for rising ocean levels and talks to one coal-burning energy company that has voluntarily pledged to stabilize its greenhouse gas emissions:

http://www.pbs.org/now/transcript/transcriptNOW116_full.html

http://www.pbs.org/now/thisweek/index_042205.html

According to Now, scientists say that over the last century, almost every glacier on earth has gotten smaller and that the Arctic, which serves as the "air conditioner" for the world, is warming twice as fast as anywhere else. It's part of the body of evidence, they say, that proves humans are changing the atmosphere and causing a global climate change, which has enormous implications for the health of the planet and its inhabitants. The government however still claims that global warming is a hoax. Where do you stand on this issue and what do you think we should do about it?

101 replies

by dr dij

I don't think even our govt says that, however they didn't join the international accord partly for selfish reasons and partly because it exempted China and India from emissions controls. It appears that one 2 cycle car in India spews out vastly more pollution than quite a few cars in industrialized nations, and that factories also spew out pollution.

China is particulary bad. They are scrambling to produce more industrial goods, and most electricity is coming from coal which is very dirty. There may be clean burning coal to electricity technologies implemented but now.

Not only will global warming continue and extinctions rise to unprecedented levels but sea levels will rise, not only due to bulk of ice caps that are melting (the sea north of Canada is predicted to be ice free in a few years) but supposedly sea levels will rise 36 feet or so. I'm told this is due more to the effect of warmer water expanding. Sure it's only one or two degrees but that is 2 degrees times roughly 1,260,000,000,000,000,000,000 liters of water.

Will we survive just that? Probably.
Will it cause great hardship on the worlds peoples? definitely.
Just stopping the atlantic 'conveyor belt' of warm water (GUlf stream) that hits the arctic then falls to the bottom of the ocean and ends up winding around cape horn to the indian ocean will cause major climatic changes in Europe, probably a mini-ice age despite planet being warmer elsewhere. This is a major way planet equalized heat. And the conveyor stops quicker than we thought, could stop in 10 years we've found from glacial cores. End result is more heat difference between tropics and north will spawn more hurricanes, cyclones, tornadoes to equalize heat.

For those in LA, the '72 and partly cloudy' may be a thing of the past, witness near record rains this year, 36" in a few weeks.

You AXF and Sim City fans may have an answer, building an orbiting solar shade of thin mylar might become a global necessity project soon.

While we're at it, we could add orbiting solar power stations, beaming the energy down to receiving stations on the surface. Have fun roasting if the beam goes off tracking and frys the area around the station!

by montgomery gator

"You AXF and Sim City fans may have an answer, building an orbiting solar shade of thin mylar might become a global necessity project soon."
...
Saw a rerun of Futurama last night, which was about global warming, and Wormstrum (scientist rival to Professor Farnsworth) built a huge mirror to reflect the sun's rays away from the Earth. However, a small asteroid hit it and turned it back to Earth to concentrate the Sun's rays back towards Earth, burning a swath through the building where the Global Warming meeting was being held. The solution then proposed was to destroy the robots who were releasing greenhouse gas. However, Professor Farnsworth had a better idea. He had all the robots turn their jets upward from the same location (Galapagos Islands, where they were tricked to go for a party where they wer actually destroyed). These jets then pushed the Earth into a orbit further out and solved the problem. So, we can can learn from Futurama that a giant space mirror is a bad idea.

by dr dij

Yes, that Futurama was hilarious. We'll have to ban fuel hungry robots in the future.

Previously I had from articles that coral reefs bleached due to them being very picky about exact temperature, no problem (kindof), some other tropical species of coral will take their place? This was just their best guess it appears.

Apparently not. Last nite on PBS, researchers found several actual reasons coral reefs bleach. Around Jamaica, we've overfished 90% of the big fish in the ocean. Anyway I think the show said the herbivorus fish that eat the algae that tends to grow on coral reefs were reduced in numbers such that nothing was left to control the algae and it quickly covers the coral, killing it. In a nearby island, they setup marine reserves (no fishing areas that are actually enforced effectively) a few years ago after nearly wiping out their reefs also. On these islands, larger fish are returning and reefs are much healthier.

And in Australia, crown of thorns starfish (they eat coral) population explosions wiped out reefs. It appears it was slightly different reasons: algae again grew rampant, setting off the crown of thorns. Sugar cane appears to blame. Farmers add nitrogen fertilizers heavily, which they must use on sugarcane and tropical storms wash it into the ocean, causing the algae to overrun the coral. They've cut down all the trees between the river and the fields, so it washes right in.

Suggested fix was to increase the border of trees between the fields and river, wide enuf to soak up the excess nutrients.

In both these cases we'd collapsed the whole local ecosystem, making recovery much harder. Ecosystem collapse may be the actual cause of most of our problems in the near future, as plant life is very adaptable and can move to warmer / cooler regions. In fact signs point to trees in the appalachians doing just that in last ice age.

Sadly cruise ships still just push garbage out into the ocean and many developing countries have no pollution laws.

by tonythetiger

Many of the theories on global warming start with a basic assumption that any warming of the earth since man has been on it must have been caused by man.

Sorry, I just don't buy it. It requires a belief that mandkind is more than a mere pisant in the scheme of planetary climate change and, much to the chagrin of the more egotistical among us, we aren't.

The earth has its cycles of hot and cold, some of which have been far more dramatic than what we're seeing now. It's changing... as it has done before... and as it will do again. The earth is not going to adapt to us, we must adapt to it... or die.

by dr dij

No, not natural. we already understand that a large amount of global warming is due to animals and plants. Something like 20o is due to ants giving off huge amounts of formic acid and termites methane. Problem is, this is irrelevant to current portion caused by man, as this built up very slowly over millions of years and the earth adjusted, and it is constant. Climate is changing but not like it has been doing naturally, much faster.

Man is adding several degrees on top of the biomass warming. Man's contributions to global warming built up in last 100 years or so, very short geological time. It is changing the current balance, is in addition to other warming and from all evidence is making significant changes to the climate. 3/4 of all glaciers worldwide are receding. they'd be gone except they are so huge it takes a while to melt.

Other fun facts: half of all CO2 released by man is now dissolved in the ocean. it forms carbonic acid which dissolves diatom silica, making it harder for them to reproduced. Wipe them out and it becomes a stagnant pool not producing any oxygen. (get out your inhalers and rebreathers quick!)

Then we're also chopping down the carbon sinks, forests, which sequester large amounts of CO2, much more than farmlands or grasslands.

The newest fun destructive activity in US is the 'topping' of mountains. (see recent PBS appalachian special and latest issue of Harpers).

9 men with explosives, dozers, draglines and huge haul trucks take off multiple layers of coal on a mountain. Instead of strip mining and restoring the trees, they shove the mountaintop off the side, filling up forest and streams below. crushed rocks give off sulphuric acid when pyrite is exposed to air. Several layers of coal are removed, and no resculpting of mountain is done. All that will live on the debris is hydroseeded lepedza grass, as unlike strip mining, none of the original soil is left. Mountain tops are gone permanently. probably affecting local weather patterns due to both topology and killing of forests.

Uh, and yes we will adapt or die. And probably alot of us WILL die.

by maxwell edison

.
When you say the government claims that global warming is a hoax, you are mistaken. Some people IN government may think that it is, while some people IN government may not. And "the government" has not issued any formal proclamation one way or the other, at least not the United States government. If anything, "the government", per se, has pandered to the silly notion. Even President Bush has been pandering to people making such claims and/or to the idea (although you wouldn't know it by listening to his political opponents):

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2001/06/20010611-2.html

Moreover, one thing the global warming zealots always omit is the modifier "man-caused" to the global warming claim. Some scientists think the globe is warming as a result of natural changes. Some scientists think the globe is warming as a result of man-made influences. Some scientists think the globe is not warming at all. While some scientist think that too little time has been spent studying the theory, as any climate change occurs over hundreds of years, not a couple of decades, and there's insufficient data to determine for sure. (And if it is happening, but it's a result of the natural cycle of change, there's not a dang thing that can be done about it anyway.)

Here's my opinion: FOLLOW THE MONEY!

The people who are screaming the loudest about man-made global warming are the ones getting government grants to "study the problem". Or perhaps they are nations whose industries are struggling to keep up with the USA in the global market place, and they want to take steps to slow down US industry. Or they are the extremist collectivist-type thinkers who are using environmental issues to gain control over private business. Or they are merely using "global warming" as a political tool to gain power and influence over others. Personally, I think it's all of the above.

In my further opinion, the "global warming" scare did not happen for scientific reasons, but rather political ones. After all, how many "scientists" have you really seen and/or heard issue warnings about "global warming"? The fact of the matter is that it's not "scientists" who are advancing the "global warming" warning en masse, but rather politicians who want control over people or something that is not theirs. And if that doesn't raise your flags of skepticism, you could probably be convinced that the sky is falling.

That's where I stand on the issue. And what should we do about it, you further ask? We should politically defeat the zealots who are advancing such nonsense.

by cactus pete

Following the money...

I'd like to think that we can kick this economy into high gear by investing more in renewable energies than building more refineries, etc.

My opinion is that fuel prices don't need to drop, we need more alternatives. Eventually, the alternatives will be cheaper and cleaner. I believe it can be done - I believe our scientists are smart enough to make it - I believe our consumers care enough to try. They just need some guidance from the "government" such as it can...

Now, I don't need to propose this as a response to global warming - but it fits. I think it makes sense to use renewable energies, cleaner energies, cheaper energies. Whatever context one wishes to view it, fine.

by jdclyde

The american tax payer should pay for the world to have a clean renewable energy source?

Aren't there a lot of people complaining that there isn't enough funding for our schools, medical, SS or whatever? Should we cut back on school spending and divert that money to the kind of research that has ALWAYS been done by private companies?

Where do we (americans) cut back to have this money come from? Or is this just another case of raising taxes AGAIN so that the "government" can finance this? Do we put this added tax on everyone or only the rich people we always hear about?

Saving for my kids to go to college is a major concern for me. The earth beging ten degrees warmer in a thousand years while important, just doesn't push the other one away for me.

And on the non-serious side, where was that global warming I was promised last week when we had 6 inches of snow? AND why have the summers not been as hot as they used to be? Even in the summer, it cools down quite a bit at night. So much for warming.....

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "I'd like to think that we can kick this economy into high gear by investing more in renewable energies than building more refineries, etc."

I agree 100 percent. (As long as it's private investment, and not the forced government redistribution of "investment".)

You said, "My opinion is that fuel prices don't need to drop, we need more alternatives".

I agree 100 percent.

You went on to say, "Eventually, the alternatives will be cheaper and cleaner. I believe it can be done - I believe our scientists are smart enough to make it - I believe our consumers care enough to try."

Again, I agree 100 percent.

But when you say "guidance from the government", if you mean "control", I disagree. But if you mean encouragement and incentives, again, I agree 100 percent.

Personally, I don't like to be duped into doing something -- especially if it's being duped with faulty claims and scare tactics. I'd rather have real and reasonable reasons to pursue a particular course of action. (And my "real and reasonable" reason: To tell the thugs and the despots in the middle east to take their oil and shove it up their tail-pipe.) And energy independence is certainly a goal worthy of vigorous pursuit. Quite frankly, I'm really surprised that some politician hasn't aggressively stepped up on this particular soap-box. (My fellow Americans............)

by ozi eagle

Hi,

I am in Australia and we have a surplus of sugar, which our Gov. is trying to foist off on the world, which also has a glut. Why not develop ethanol based energy, particularly for transport?

Reasons I've heard for not doing it include

cars can't use ethanol because it erodes the
metals in the fuel system - use different
metals!

refining sugar to ethanol produces more CO2
than refining oil - maybe, BUT the source of
the CO2 in the sugar is from the atmosphere,
not from underground "storage"

the oil companies won't like it!!!!! - its
easier and more profitable to use existing
technology and materials than to explore new
methods - this is probably the biggest killer
of alternative sources. The answer may be to
help the oil companies to become the ethanol
producers, thus maintaining their financial
interests.

by tony hopkinson

Scientific evidence suggests that things are getting warmer, the argument appears to be whether this is a 'natural' phenomena or the result of human activity. Quantitatively there's no doubt humans are having some impact on the environment, so now it's a question of whether it's enough. But global weather patterns are chaotic and so very sensitive to small changes in initial conditions.

This means whatever small impact we have, might not cause a large problem if we reduce/stop it. It also means that we might be able to have enough of an impact to damp a naturally large change in our favour.

Doing nothing about it, means if it's going to happen 'naturally' it will and if it's going to happen because of human involvement it will.

This is not a decision we are making for us but for our children and grand children, I personally wouldn't want to explain to my granddaughter why millions of people died so I could make a bit more profit from polluting her environment.

by dr dij

All indications I've seen seem to indicate we've made vast changes to the atmosphere in terms of greenhouse gases. Even if global temps only rose 1 or 2 degree, this is not because of one person and their Hummer, it is the result of huge#'s of people and activities sustained over a hundred years or so. The earth climate IS very variable, however all trends point to UP overall.

I don't think humankind has it in us to band together and stop the causes of warming we're adding. we're not unified enuf.

one problem is that after a certain point, triggers cause massive disruption such as stopping the planet's underwater 'cooling loop'.
And due to the 'trigger effect' this is likely to be a problem we'll face in the next decade or two, not 100's of years. Indications show the gulf stream could dissipate in a decade, plunging northern europe into a mini ice age.

Will a rise in sea levels destroy us all? no, only destroy those in poor countries like Bangladesh where the average elevation is something like a yard. ANd 75% of cities worldwide are supposed to be very close to the coast.

I also see a trend among tech people to be good at the tech stuff but not widen their horizons and research widely into other fields such as climate warming and the env't. Add to this our usual optimism may put us in denial of the problem.

by tony hopkinson

When Lorenz did his original model that showed an example of sensitive dependance on initial conditions (The Butterfly Effect), he discovered it by truncating his input to three decimal places.
The other thing chaos theory showed was that in a chaotic system averages and trends were of very little value as miniscule changes in one of the variables could reverse the apparent trend in an instant. So if global weather is chaotic it's just as valid to say humanity's input to global warming may damp a massive change in the environment as cause one.
It's too complex for us to model chaotically or classically.

My personal opinion is we should clean up the environment no matter what, it isn't ours to f**k up and making a profit now, passing the burden of cleaning up the environment to the next generation is immoral, unethical and pathetically short sighted.

I remember hearing the Al Gore approach on CNN and I've rarely heard such crass stupidity in my life as he detailed the american governments position, and no I'm not judging the rest of you based on that greedy self serving hack's statements.
I was ambivalent about it until he spoke, now I'm a rabid green.

by holdcraftm

So it's your fault? You freely admit that you are the cause of Global Warming, so you can make more profits? I quote from your text,"so I could make a bit more profit from polluting her environment."

by tony hopkinson

I exhaled sharply recently and caused a Hurricane. Stamping my foot in anger not so long back had devastating consequences as well. Seeing as I'm this powerful may be you pay attention before the beans I just ate work their way through my system !.

by tony hopkinson

You've two sets of scientists funded by different vested interests showing that their position is 'scientific'. Lets face it there's no way you can study global weather without investing serious money. The people with the money aren't going to do that if the results aren't what they want, and it's very easy to make the results of the study look like what your benefactor wants.

The real problem is the 'polluters' are the ones funding government and politicians don't get voted for if they can't campaign. If it were the other way round arguments against human involvement in global warming would get the same level of respect from the august bodies who theoretically have the potential to do something about it.

So they are following the money and probably will keep on doing so until their coastal retreats get innundated under six metres of sea water at which point they'll say the scientists gave them bad advice.

by thechas

While I was not able to quickly track down the funding sources of Dr. Robert Essenhigh and his research, I find it interesting that most of the scientists and researchers who claim global warming is not happening are funded by fossil fuel related interests.

Following the money further, why is the US the only major country that is not working toward solutions to global warming and man made environmental impacts?
The US economy is based on cheap energy and plundering the Earths resources.

While I agree that part of the softening of the Bush administration stand on global warming is political, I suspect that the larger factor is the lack of credible science that supports taking no action.

Like other Bush administration efforts to circumvent environmental regulations, they have magically discovered that the science does support the need for reducing man's impact on the environment.

One last thought.

Why is it so hard for you to accept the research of scientists who's primary goal is to preserve the Earth for future generations?

Yet, you still believe the US was justified in invading Iraq on what turns out to be very poor information?

To wit, the assurances of GWB on a subject he has not personally researched holds more merit than the research of dozens of scientists.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
The study I cited was funded by Ohio State University itself, and the research was for a paper the professor submitted to a scientific journal. It was purely an academic study.

You said, "I (you) find it interesting that most of the scientists and researchers who claim global warming is not happening are funded by fossil fuel related interests." Will you please cite your source for that assertion. Quite frankly, I don't believe it to be true. To "fund" anything in an attempt to prove a negative is silly.

by maxwell edison

.
You asked, "Why is it so hard for you to accept the research of scientists who's primary goal is to preserve the Earth for future generations?"

I already answered that question in a previous message. I said:

"The fact of the matter is that it's not scientists who are advancing the 'global warming' warning en masse, but rather politicians who want control over people or something that is not theirs. And if that doesn't raise your flags of skepticism, you could probably be convinced that the sky is falling."

by absolutely

Or is it "hear, hear"? I'm sure a Brit or Aussie will know and enlighten the colonials ;)

To the point, the war over falsified information has had at least one useful effect: it has proved beyond a shadow of a doubt that there is no intelligence in the White House at present!

I would not trust Dubya to mind my vegetable cart for 5 minutes, if that were my business. I certainly do not expect that he will do anything with government money for "alternative energy" other than to help his petrol pimps control that industry, too, when the time comes to make whatever switch we make.

Now, to those who believe that criticizing the President is un-patriotic, how would you characterize lying, with full knowledge of the truth, in order to commit a nation to a war that was enormously financially beneficial to the Veep's most recent employer?

TREASON

by dr dij

according to this article
www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/1605/ggccebro/chapter1.html

Levels of several important greenhouse gases have increased by about 25 percent since large-scale industrialization began around 150 years ago (Figure 1). During the past 20 years, about three-quarters of human-made carbon dioxide emissions were from burning fossil fuels.

by Member 25348569

The "Evolution Lie" debate all over again. But SO much more important.

During the EL debate, one thing that the creationists kept pushing was the need for "equality" between the two "conflicting" viewpoints and the unfair way in which the research of creation scientists was being ignored or belittled by the vast majority of the scientific world.

Their argument was that each of the scientists following the current theories had a vested interest in maintaining the paradigm. I see some of the same happening here.

This is probably - certainly, if man-induced Global Warming is real and reversible - the most crucial scientific question of the new century. The winning side will shape economic policy, political and technological developments for decades to come. For this reason we must debate this properly as the consequences of getting it wrong are potentially catastrophic. "Real" global warming will kill many millions and an unnecessary major shutdown of the World's economy will likely result in the early deaths of millions also.

If the sceptics are to be believed, the evidence for global warming is full of holes, the field full of argument and uncertainty and the consensus is enforced by a scientific establishment riding the gravy train.

Well, I don't think so.

The basic physics of the greenhouse gases, carbon dioxide, water vapour and methane, and their ability to reflect infra-red radiation is a simple fact. As is the fact that carbon dioxide levels are 35% greater than pre-industrial levels and are still rising linearly when measured over the last fifty years. It is also a fact that the measurement of IR radiation - in the specific wavelengths that would be trapped by CO2 - that escapes from the earth has decreased in proportion over the last thirty years.

"Anthropogenic" greenhouse gas emissions, then, are tending to make the atmosphere warmer. Fact!

Then the uncertainty starts. The observed warming could be all natural as solar cycles and the changing frequency of volcanic eruptions have an effect on climate and have been calculated to account for at least 40% of the measured atmospheric warming (pro-gw) or all of it (anti-gw). It is interesting, however, that the climate models currently in use can be used to restrospectively "predict" the climate since 1850 and this matches well with the observed up until 1965 when the divergence begins and the Earth warmed more than predicted.

Where the greatest contoversy exists is in the role of feedback, negative to damp down the warming in a normal oscillation pattern and positive to kick it into something else that might not be reversible before another ice age. Melting ice on land reveals more land to absorb more heat - that one is happening. Negative - melting Arctic ice might weaken or shut down the Gulf Stream and make Northern Europe get much colder so more snow, more ice and more heat reflected back and cools again. Positive -Methane Hydrates held in permafrost and cold sea basins could melt resulting in a runaway warming releasing more hydrates ending with an increase of up to 11 degrees C.

Undecided - more water vapour in the atmpsphere means more clouds reflecting back more heat into space and more heat back to the ground. Which is greater?

We have to have the research done so that we can plan for the consequences even if we can't stop it.

There is a consensus amongst scientists that global warming is real. A review of the 928 peer-review papers on climate change published in the ten years up to 2003 showed that consensus to be real and near universal.

Is there, then, a gigantic conspiracy funded by the perfidious UN and its bastart child the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change? I think we should be told!

We know for sure that human activity is influencing climate change even if we don't know by how much or if it is reversible. We might still get away with it and the sceptics could be right. The majority of the world's climate scientists could be wrong.

It would be a lucky break.

Do you feel lucky?

Well, do you?

by maxwell edison

.
In fact, it's the MOST IMPORTANT aspect of this issue. And it's the driving force behind my passion and resolve to fight it.

You said, "The winning side will shape economic policy, political and technological developments for decades to come."

That is absolutely, without a doubt, 100 percent true; you and I could not agree more (surprise). However, which is coming first, the preverbal cart or the horse? The political solution or the problem for which a solution is being proposed?

I think that if you consider the fact that there's so much political momentum behind "global warming solutions", it becomes very clear that this is more of a political solution in search of a problem instead of the other way around. If you were to believe all the politicians and political activists, and believe to their level of urgency, you would have to think that scientists around the globe would be literally crawling out of the woodwork en masse and in total agreement, armed with indisputable data and evidence that WE ARE ABSOLUTELY DOOMED! That's simply not happening -- not even close. For every "scientist" you can find who insists that man-made global warming is happening, I'll find two -- or more -- who dispute it.

This is a political movement, pure and simple, not a scientific one. What's being advanced is a political solution in search of a fabricated problem, and they're using disingenuous doom and gloom scare tactics as their methods. And that's why I feel so adamant as to why it MUST be defeated.

by dr dij

we're still destroying ecosystems by other methods, as it appears coral reef bleaching is not caused by global warming (pbs show last nite).

but by overfishing and vast nutrient release causing smothering algal blooms.

The ocean's ecosystem is probably most critical as it is least regulated in terms of pollution, as unlike land no one owns vast portions of it, it is harder to research and people have the idea it is an endless dumping ground. Oceans produce over 2/3 of our oxygen so a collapse could be catastropic. And partial collapses undoubtedly nasty.

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "The basic physics of the greenhouse gases, carbon dioxide, water vapour and methane, and their ability to reflect infra-red radiation is a simple fact....."

Get real, for Pete's sake. A "simple fact"? Yea right. About 99.9 percent of the gullible human population doesn't know the first thing about physics. And all the scientific mumbo-jumbo tied together in a certain way would baffle most people. What's that old saying? If you can't dazzle them with your brilliance, you can baffle them with your bull-shit? Well I think this applies. You may think you're some sort of scientific expert, but for some reason, I'm very skeptical.

You said, "There is a consensus amongst scientists that global warming is real."

No there's not. As I said in a previous message (two previous messages), man-made is the key modifier-- MAN-MADE global warming, not just global warming. There's a BIG difference here. And no, there's not consensus. Again, for every "scientist" you can find who insists that man-made global warming is happening, I'll find two -- or more -- who dispute it.

You said, "We know for sure that human activity is influencing climate change....". No we don't. In fact, that's a crock of crap.

To think that human activity can significantly impact the natural cycle of the Earth is the epitome of pompus presumption. "Human activity" is so small and insignificant when compared to the vast powers that could be unleashed by nature. The smallest little burp from the mouth of Mother Nature can cause a tsunami of devastation to "human activity". And to see humans as being equally as powerful is just down-right silly.

by gralfus

Since we find wooly mammoths quick frozen in glaciers, still with flowers in their mouths, this indicates the world in that region was once much warmer and that something nasty happened to make it cold really fast. What we currently have could be readjusting to how it was then (not really all that long ago).

As far as manmade gasses being the primary contributor to ozone depletion and increase in CO2, I can hardly believe that. If anything, it would be deforestation in certain regions that is causing a large and long-term reduction in the consumption of CO2. At the same time, lightning storms replenish ozone in the atmosphere. The chemical system of the atmosphere is very complex, so to reduce ozone depletion to just manmade gasses is unreasonable.

So, I think that before we "do something about it" that we should find out if it really is a problem (as opposed to a natural function of balancing temperature), and what the real causes are.

by dr dij

would simply have meetings and never 'do anything' about it.

www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/1605/ggccebro/chapter1.html
indicates manmade CO2, primarily from fossil fuel burning over last 120 years added 25% to CO2.

the US is not the only one 'not doing anything' about it. Certain developed countries, while signatory to pollution reduction treaties, have largely been exempted from the rules. China is spewing out vast amounts of dirty coal pollution.

by Member 25348569

but what is deforestation if not manmade? and, as it's still going on...

As for Ozone, it's caused by the action of solar radiation on oxygen. The rate of formation is constant and the rate of depletion naturally catalysed by Nitrogen Dioxide was also roughly constant but only happens when the sun shines. Depletion catalysed by freons and other halons - from refrigerators - doesn't need sunlight. Pretty damn simple.

Shall we or shan't we "do something" about refrigerants. Ummm? Hey! - it's only the Aussies getting skin cancer. We're all right 'cos OUR polar ozone hole is tiny.

by jbaker

What amazes me is that the "scientists" fail to mention that the number one greenhouse gas is water vapor, and man has very little to do with the amount of water suspended in the atmosphere.

Sure, the Earth is warming. Global temperatures have risen almost 3 F in the past 300 years.

by dr dij

.7 to 3 degrees, various estimates of warming affect not just the atmosphere. this represents a vast amount of energy spread out over the crust and oceans. oceans and crust have more embedded energy in them.

this is likely to cause an increase in volcanism, plate shifting and any earth movement activities that could be related a higher temperature crust and increased pressure.

climate variations could put rain in mountains and cause more mudslides like the one in columbia a few years ago that wiped out a whole town.

by cactus pete

That's funny...

The current administration is now proposing financial incentives for additional refineries, etc. Why not make those financial incentives for renewable energies?

Say it with me, "investment". If we develope and promote renewable energies, they are much cheaper in the long run.

Why isn't the top or side of every highrise covered in solar panels? Why don't the buidlings in downtown Chicago have small wind turbines attached to them? [You know, the "Windy City" - and yes, I know why it's really called that.) Why don't wind farms' turbines have solar panels on all the blades [so even dormant ones can produce energy]?

There are lots of possibilities - someone needs to say that energy is as important and necessary as going to the moon was.

by jdclyde

Was just trying to take it to the next step. It is easy for a lot of people to run out as say the government should do this or that without realizing that the government gets all of its money from us. I realize that you do not fall in that catagory, so I will follow a few statements with a few questions that I really don't know that answer to.

There have been in the last few years they wanted to put the windmill farms off the coast, but it would ruin the view.

There are a lot of ideas of how to minimize polution. Electic cars was an idea, and talk about requiring a percentage of all cars in California to be electric. Didn't they just have an electricity shortage? Don't many of the electricity generating plants polute still? Why is it so much more expensive to run an electric dryer over a gas dryer?

Where is the data to support that the renewable energies are "much cheaper"?

You don't think we should have gone to the moon? Don't you remember that we wouldn't have VELCRO in our lives without the space program and I LOVE velcro straps for my network cables! And TANG. We wouldn't have had TANG!

by cactus pete

I didn't say we shouldn't go to the moon - I said if we can go to the moon, we can develop cheap alternative fuel sources. We just need the leadership - the drive, if you will.

You're right, there are a lot of ideas, I even spit out a few. So let's get someone moving on these ideas at a national level.

I'm not saying we should add more taxes, or divert more taxes. I'm saying instead of spending them on the same old solutions [which aren't working too well, and I guess aren't really solutions] that we spend it on new sources.

More gas isn't going to help, long run. But developing renewable sources will be cheaper in the long run.

How do I know? They are renewable, there isn't a shortage. And if we have a diverse group of resources, when one is diminished, others take over. Wind is more plentiful in storms, when there is less light. On nice calm days, there is likely more sun than wind... Waves produce some energy just because the moon exists...

And when things are good, they're really good - a bright sun shiny windy day with turmoil on the seas...

I'm just a layman... Think what we could do with smart leadership and determined scientists.

by roger99a

I like the windmill farm idea, and generally speaking, I think it could work well. I suggest we use Texas and Oklahoma for wind farms and not ruin the nice ocean view. I see it as a national security issue and a long term economic issue. Just being dependent on imported oil makes our economy vunerable. Biodiesel smells like popcorn. If we grow it, burn it, and grow more then we put the carbon in a cycle instead of pumping it out of the ground and putting it in the air. Hydrogen is a joke. They pull it out of natural gas because electrolosys is too ineficient.
Electric cars don't sell because they have a limited range. When I can go 500 miles in a day on electric I would do it. The California argument doesn't apply because electric vehicles are mostly charged at night after everyone has gone home. Energy shortages come in the mid-summer days when everyone is running their air conditioners full blast. Economically they are super efficient and usually cost a penny or two per mile according to the electric car enthusiasts. My car cost over 10 cents a mile now, and requires tune ups and oil changes regularly. On the other side, we have expensive battery replacement. We need better battery technology and electrics will work. Then we have to convince a manufacturer to make them.
On principle, I'm against TANG. Regular orange juice grows on trees and trees use CO2. Drink more OJ.

by cactus pete

Looks like we agree 100% then!

The "guidance" remark was a referral to earlier when I commented on incentives for mroe refineries...

By the way, there's another 50k pointer out there...

by cactus pete

My Prius is now 11 months old. I only had to wait 4 months for it. [So it WOULD be 15 months old, if I had my way.]

by aldanatech

Yep. If it would have been your way you would of start saving sooner, but good ideas just take a while to fully materialize every now and then.

by tony hopkinson

There's a bucket load of money to be made from renewable energy, the reason it is n't researched with more vigour in certain arenas is there is a lot more money in burning up sh1t and not wasting profits researching something we don't 'need' yet.

A slight disagreement with Dr Dij, Solar Panels with our current technology are more dangerous than fossil fuels. They're reliant on large quantities of toxic metals such as cadmium and disposing in a safe manner the quantities we have now is an expensive and potentially dangerous business.
Just because something doesn't pollute while you are using it doesn't mean creating and disposing of it is pollution free. Nuclear power for instance, that used to be called clean power as well.
In fact one of our biggest pollution problems is the disposable society we have now.

by ozi eagle

Hi,

Unfortunely when solar panels are mentioned we think of electricity generating ones.
However, high rise buildings (and domestic houses too) use large amounts of energy for heating and cooling. Lets have solar panels that directly heat our hot water, use cooling based on a heat input ( though it has a very slow pull down time), recycle heat ( a novel idea I came across years ago is to have a circular radiator like device with a large thermal mass rotating across the fresh air inlet and the {hot} exhaust air vent in high rise buildings, thus absorbing heat from the exhaust air and adding it to the cool fresh air). How about heat exchangers in our shower / bath waste pipes to warm up the incoming cold water?

by dr dij

I think newer solar panels will solve that. besides being toxic are also make cost higher. There are sheet solar panels, that don't use crystaline silica that are in the works. problem is they're still being developed.

wind power however is supposed to be more than competitive now. however some communities don't want them due to unsightly towers, bird kill and tv interference (chopping of air chops the tv signal too, so they should get a dish?)

bird kill might be solvable by not placing them in flyways, problem is flyways are narrow gaps between mountains, which also funnel the wind for wind power.

I'd be for nuclear if it was a meltdown proof technology (such as the pebbles reactors being developed) and they did not leave the waste in pools around every nuke plant.

by tony hopkinson

They are moth-balling some now in the UK now they are past their sell by date. The damn plant is near as bigger danger than all the toxic crap it produced while it was working. I rather my kids have a cough than three legs and one arm.

by thechas

While I do trust the government to make "better" decisions than the "free market", I don't expect to get unbiased information from politicians.

Be it my local (conservative) newspaper, National Geographic, or science coverage on NPR, I have yet to see a report in opposition to global warming where the scientist did not have either ties or funding from fossil fuel related industries.

If we had left air and water pollution control to free enterprise:
The Cuyahoga would still be burning.
The air would be much darker than it is.
(of course, this could result in global cooling)
Open landfills and tire piles would dot the landscape.

The consumer just does not see the connection between the lowest priced goods and the impact on the environment and the economy.

The free market will not respond with solutions to pollution or new energy sources until they cost less than doing business as usual. And, the transition has a 6 month payback!

I for one do not desire to wait for the Earth to be near desolation before we start working to save our planet.

Even if you don't agree with the scientific evidence that supports the theory of global warming, does it not make sense to take steps to reduce human induced impact on the climate?

The sooner we take the small steps:
Smaller cars, smaller homes, shorter commutes,
The less apt we are to be required to take the big steps of shutting down industry and commerce.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "Be it my local (conservative) newspaper, National Geographic, or science coverage on NPR, I have yet to see a report in opposition to global warming where the scientist did not have either ties or funding from fossil fuel related industries." Well then, Chas, it shouldn't be too hard to link to just one such story, complete with the "funding" behind the source. For once, just for once, why not provide some support for your assertions instead of spewing unsubstantiated claims? (Side observation: A "conservative" newspaper to you is probably extreme left-wing to me.)

And comparing a polluted river or lake, or even air pollution, to the man-made global warming scare is like comparing illegal immigrants from Mexico to invading space invaders. One is something real that can be seen and measured. The other is pure speculation at best, or science fiction at worst.

by thechas

Max,

I accept global warming as REAL.

Just as I accept the fact that there is a God.

I also accept that evolution is the method God used to implement our universe.

Further, I believe that there is as much if not more money to be made from producing low impact products and lifestyles as you expect from a hydrogen economy.

If our government and industry leaders embraced environmental protection and invested the money they are throwing away attempting to discredit global warming in green technologies, we could have every bit as large an economic boom as the Internet boom of the 90's.

Rather than dragging our feet and sticking our heads in the sand, the US could become the world leader in green technologies.

Chas

by kriaken

Lets inject some real fact here.

Melting glaciers will contribute to about a 1 foot rise in mean sea level.. So What????

The bigger issue here is the effect of the rise in mean water temp. As water heats it expands, more space between molecules, therefor much higher sea levels and some really wack tidal effects resulting from less dense water. Tsunami, massive tidal surge, death of our world climate system.

So invest now in that new beach front property around LasVegas and get in before the rush.

by maxwell edison

.
...we'll all be crushed when they meet.

...and now if you'll buy that:

I got some ocean front property in Arizona,
From my front porch you can see the sea.
I got some ocean front property in Arizona,
If you'll buy that, I'll throw the golden gate in free.

by tomsal

I guess we have to pick what we want to be paranoid about..the global warming thing, a mass earthquake that'll have California floating out to sea, some super-volcano erupting and ending life, etc.

Well scientists keep saying one day we'll get hit by a meteor first they said that it could be in 2029, but then they came back and said the chance is better in 2034 or 2035 something like that.

Fun stuff....either way....global warming isn't what we should spend our scientific resources on in my opinion...

How about we worry what to do when a 6 billion ton piece of rock slams into our planet at 95,000 MPH. ;)

by maxwell edison

.
If you believe me, 'bout global warming,
And I won't ever give you flack.
Girl, your senses won't ever sway me,
'Cos I just know it, and now if you'll buy that:

I got some ocean front property in Arizona,
From my front porch you can see the sea.
I got some ocean front property in Arizona,
If you'll buy that, I'll throw the golden gate in free.

I don't care 'bout the non-believers,
I never have, and that's a fact.
I won't follow or understand you,
'Cos I just know it, and now if you'll buy that:

I got some ocean front property in Arizona,
From my front porch you can see the sea.
I got some ocean front property in Arizona,
If you'll buy that, I'll throw the golden gate in free.

I got some ocean front property in Arizona,
From my front porch you can see the sea.
I got some ocean front property in Arizona,
If you'll buy that, I'll throw the golden gate in free.

Yeah, if you'll buy that, I'll throw the golden gate in free.

by itgirli

It won't happen for hundreds of years. We'll all be dead as well as our children and grandchildren. I don't think our decomposing bodies are really going to give a crap. Besides, 102 years ago flight was impossible (not truly impossible, but untried). Now people are buying rides into space. As quickly as technology advances (do you really think it will stop advancing? no.)in a few hundred years they'll have found a fix or a new planet or maybe we will have already blasted each other into craters. Who cares? not me. I'll be dead and not giving much of a thought to anything.

by tony hopkinson

aren't you. I think it's admirable that you support your husband in private as well as public.
However your philosophy has some holes in it. For instance if technological advances in medicine keep progressing at their current rate my granddaughter will still be alive in a 100 years time.
It's more than probable I will be alive when my great grandchildren are born. I'll have to see if they can accept your 'reasoning'.

So basically you're not giving a thought to anything or anyone. Being alive or not seems to have little to do with it.

by itgirli

call me Mrs. Gore. I've never been so insulted in my life. To think....a liberal! yech! bleh! I think I just threw up.

by holdcraftm

Hey,
I don't care if you die either, but some of us might like our children to grow up in a world that is beautiful. That said, warm is wonderful! Makes trees and plants grow faster (make up for South America Deforestation)and makes the girls get out in their swin suits! Global warming - Bring it on!!!

by dwiebles

but a very good one? I am afraid I will have to disagree. I am not going to drag my children or grandchildren into the fray, as they don't exist, and with all my dating prowess, may never. I think there is some over-reaction to the percieved threat, and that far more research and data is equired to make any conclusions, and since we are missing a few million years of data, it could take a while to make up for it. That said, our environmental record has been somewhat irresponsible on most fronts, if not all. Wether or not global warming is a result of Human impact or a natural progression of the climate has no bearing on things such as deorestation, toxic waste and emissions, and the degrading quality of our waterways. Sure, we may be able to find advances in technology to reduce the impact on future generations (again, prolly not my own), but I would rather have resources dedicated to research on new fronts, as opposed to fixing old mistakes.

by dwiebles

Well, then you have my apologies for misunderstanding, and for my lack of a sense of humor.

by jdclyde

Not sure if you threw up?

Now we KNOW that your a liberal for sure or you wouldn't be questioning the evidence on your shoes.

Have a great day!

by dr dij

the aztec calendar is supposed to end an epoch in 2012, around Sept 12? They predict a huge cataclysm at end of epochs. So pack your picnic for the end of the world show.

by tomsal

..that is that it sucks. I think if our scientific community would concentrate on something the masses would truly benefit some enjoyment out of we'd be a little less stressed when that rock hit us -- causing a wave of molten death to spread throughout the land, choking out the sunlight killing all living things, etc.

;)

by maxwell edison

.
We will all drive our monster SUVs to the (new and improved) beer bash to watch and participate in the end of the world party. That sounds like a good plan to me. Just remember to assign a designated driver, however, so you don't have to drive home after drinking.

by tomsal

That just reminded me of another funny thought....

Like when they rub the arm of death row inmate with alcohol *before administering them a lethal injection*...lol.

by dr dij

I think our causing local ecosystems to collapse (where climate change is only a small portion of stress on system) is probably even more urgent.

In a previous post I outline why researchers now think coral reef bleaching is due to ecosystem collapse caused by various manmade pressures rather than simply the ocean being a degree or two warmer.

The much higher carbon dioxide level dissolved in the ocean could be the tipping point on killing massive amounts of diatom life, that produces most of our oxygen. Also to note, we've produced vast extra amounts of CO2. The ocean acts as a natural sink, and while the atmospheric level has risen, some say 25%, it would have risen alot more based on what we spewed out if it did not dissolve in the ocean. Groovy, the ocean is a naturaly buffer? Yes but it changes the chemical makeup of the ocean and the dissolved CO2 as carbonic acid seems to dissolve diatom shells, the method by which it could cause a phytoplankton ecosystem collapse.

by tony hopkinson

are pulling their heads out of the sand now as it's too damn hot. To say we are not having an impact on the environment is arrant nonsense. What and how we do something about it and whether in real terms our cummulative impact is a negative in terms of a stable environment is an open question though.
Those who chhose to ignore this should note that most of out weather models have another stable solution which is white earth (total glaciation). Also the earth could have a stable ecology without man, that's our problem not the planet's

by dr dij

there was one point, short period in early history the earth was a giant iceball, even the oceans covered over with ice. appears that phytoplankton could still hang on in the deep oceans as sunlight could penetrate 6' thick clear ice. Life would also hang on at the deep ocean chemically powered thermal vents if all else died.

by holdcraftm

Global warming is occurring, no doubt at all. However, I'm not convinced that we aren't in a naturally occurring cycle. Auto and Industrial emisssions may be a contributing factor, but I believe Global warming will still happen even if we stopped emission from all cars and factories. Recent studies (Harvard) suggest that we are in a naturally occurring warming spell. Core samples taken in the Artic show that the Artic was once in a warm climate (see National Geographic Magazine). It's been warmer around the earth before in just the last 2000 years and man survived and we will continue too survive, probably is air conditioned comfort. The Chicken Little's are saying the sky is falling, and it may be, but it has before and there is nothing we can do to stop it except adapt. So lets get on with life and stop this stupid screaming Hollywood movie syndrome alarm crap. New Orleans has been below Sea Level for 200 years, so who cares if it is 20 feet below or only 10 feet as it is now. Keep the pumps working and watch out for Hurricanes. Climate Change Happens!

by Member 25348569

Sorry, Tony - major hard sci-fi geek so I had to answer. Stick a payload hung from strings on the edge to turn the mirror into a light-sail then you can align it to the Sun until the "push" of the Sun equals the pull of gravity on the payload. Light pressure on a flat mirror is always perpendicular to the surface as the bounce-away is at the same angle as the incidence so the more you tilt away from the Sun, the lower the force. Gets more complex with a curved mirror but it still works. The faster you spin the mirror, the flatter it gets.

Edit: So dumb, that. You were asking about Futurama and I'm in with both feet!

by dr dij

Kirk will come down, fall in love with an Native American woman, bang his head, and activate the alien artifact that whips up a high powered laser that deflects the asteroids course by enuf to miss us.

In case he fails, we should build a moon base, and colonize Mars.

by dr dij

while is is a good idea to recycle this stuff, it too is somewhat impractical. YOu need a 2nd tank for regular diesel to start the car, as when cold the biodiesel turns to jelly which won't flow in fuel line, and biodiesel tank needs a tank heater, which sometimes uses waste heat from engine. ALso we would need all the farmland in US to grow biodiesel only and still not enuf for current energy needs.

by tony hopkinson

on pompous presumption.
Chaos theory and the models that are used to investigate it prove that they can be very sensitive to small changes.
Of course whether the model is an accurate description of the real world object and whether the changes we make to it map to real operations in the real world is very subjective.

Chaos theory has been very useful, but we can barely even start on modelling the planet and the best predictions we can get from the models is about three to five days, so for a prediction of global weather in hundred years time, you might as well wet your finger and guess.

Neither side can prove their position, but one messes with the planet and keeps the economy, the other changes the economy and maybe keeps the planet.

by Member 25348569

I think your attack on my "basic physics" paragraph was a bit over the top. I made - and still make - the assumption that this audience are well aware of what I meant. Oh, yeah, is it in any way WRONG?

I did say, "There is a consensus amongst scientists that global warming is real." Is THIS wrong?

As for "matching scientists" - LMAO! We've done this in the EL thread with ippirates pathetic list of bible-bashing schoolteachers. Did you not read the paragraph on peer-review journals or did you choose to ignore it? It's a conspiracy of science!

Scientists DO believe that human activity is influencing climate change. I posted a couple of very checkable arguments as to why and I'll happily post more except that it's probably a waste of time. I do accept that they aren't "provable" and that "know" is not quite the right word but I wasn't expecting the same level of "lawyer meets science" crap that we had over in the EL thread as there we had religious nutters to contend with.

Your last paragraph was, quite honestly, pathetic. Who mentioned "equal"? Considering what man has demonstrably achieved to date, I'm surprised at this post. The Dust Bowl, which took a decade to recover, isn't a bad example of how man can easily f.uck up bigtime with little effort and some ignorance. We've all got better at it since then.

by dr dij

supposedly it takes more oil to produce ethanol. and causes lots of pollution. cars can be adjusted to a portion of ethanol but you're right it can be very corrosive as it is both a polar and non-polar solvent. what should not be done as is being done here in US is subsidy of it (in US is corn based production of ethanol, with vast subsidies going to ADM, cargill).

If a company can produce it and sell it and mix with gas great. but why subsidize it if it causes more pollution (fertilzer runoff, etc) and uses oil to till the fields still?

by tony hopkinson

you could get drunk instead.
Hydrogen based fuels are more promising ecologically from a point of use, though of course the power to make them has to come from somewhere.

by dr dij

Yes, we don't really want hydrogen produced from fossil fuels, instead want it from renewable sources like splitting water.

Serious problems compressing hydrogen, so practical problems with tanks of it fueling cars. Unlike Andromeda where they have a whole star built of carbon nanotubes filled with hydrides and deuterium, probably the best solution is to turn it into methanol for cars. this is already used on drag races. color added so fires visible, and emissions are water + carbon dioxide for the carbon molecule added to make it methanol. In fact I think this is what the new PC fuel cells will use.

advantage of methanol burned in fuel cell instead of internal combustion is it is 2x as efficient, so even if the cost slightly higher, costs less per mile. and huge battery banks not needed in the new cars, yet they would be on electric drive which simplifies car, eliminates driveshaft, etc.

even burning hydrogen is not pollution free. Sure if you burn hydrogen and oxygen it produces only water. But cars don't carry an oxygen tank, they burn air which is only 21% oxygen, and some of the nitrogen burns forming NO but is minimal.

I'm not promoting big gov't. I'm suspicious of govt like max. However private or govt, the problems with envt exist.

Have a beautiful day, as you watch the tuna fleets cleaning the sea out (U2) :)

by montgomery gator

We had a TV show called "Futurama" on Earth, and the old episodes are rebroadcast on the Cartoon Network. If you were from Earth, you woud know that.

by tony hopkinson

Perhaps it's us
Perhaps we can do something about it
Perhaps we'll keep on making massive profits and perhaps then everything won't go pear shaped.
Perhaps Kevin Costner will save the day.

My money is on Dennis Hopper to be quite honest.

by dr dij

but 1000 years ago there weren't vast cities built on the edges of the water.

I'm sure the people in Florida, New Orleans, Bangladesh, lowlying islands in the south pacific and indian oceans, and any coastal cities and beachfront communties will breathe a sigh of relief and say 'Whew, glad that my being flooded out could be just "normal warming" '

by tony hopkinson

All those rich people in the bay area, who discover a fun clause in the insurance for their property and boat that a six metre rise in sea level is an act of god.
What you want to do is build a beach store half way up the Rockies, you'll make a fortune.

by montgomery gator

The global environmental system is so large, and the change is so slow, the people in coastal areas will have time to move inland. The rise of the oceans due to warming is gradual, it will not be like the tsunami that flooded southern Asia a few months ago.

But can we stop the seas from rising? King Canute (or Knut or Knud) attempted to stop the sea from rising, but was unable to. Of course he knew he could not, but was demonstating to his followers that his powers were limited, even though he could conquer England and all the Viking lands in Scandinavia. He lived at the same time as Eric the Red, (and, who knows, he may have been aware of the Global Warming at the time :-) ) but knew that it would be the height of arrogance to think he could stop the sea from rising, and proved to his followers he could not. It would be folly to think that we mortal humans can fight against major environmental trends with our limited technology, even 1000 years after the reign of Canute.

http://www.viking.no/e/people/e-knud.htm

Also, there were some large cities on the edges of the water 1000 years ago (although it is true there are a lot more today, with much larger populations). Venice and Constantinople, for example. London, although inland still gets tides rising up the Thames, was in existence 1000 years ago.

by tony hopkinson

I used to eat tuna by the dozen, but now I have to hang them on the wall so I can see how much warmer the planet is.
Mercury poisoning, never.

by tony hopkinson

Den : But I've got all these helpers, you are badly outnumbered.
Kev : So what, they know who's paying them.

by tony hopkinson

fellas studied Cascading Re-combinant Chaos. !
Theoretically we could ameliorate the effects of a natural cycle. When I say theoretically, I mean the theoretical models we have now say we could theoretically do it, theoretically.

Climate change is actually very quick, when viewed on a geological timescale. Unfortunately politicians can only plan a maximum of four years ahead and any plan would require hundreds. So we are in I'm gonna get my sh*t while the there is some sh*t to get mode.

by dr dij

I've heard evidence that previous shifts in climate are sometimes very fast, 10's of years. And since it didn't just start, glaciers have been disappearing for decades, who knows when results of warming will hit?

and as it is an analog process, we won't wake up one day and suddenly find sea levels 30' higher. I'd suggest would start with some sea level flooding in some areas, but also massive rains over some land areas, etc.

a rhode island sized chunk of ice broke of antarctica a few years ago. the poles are reflective, so as they melt, warming accelerates as less heat reflected to space.

and while it could be natural or manmade, or a combination, certainly us using up the energy from millions of years of fossil fuels releases huge amounts of both heat, greenhouse gasses, and chemicals that interfere with ecosystems, so it seems that we play a part in it, which means we could reduce our part in it.

How much or even if we will reduce our contribution to global warming is a quantitative question for the world.

Show on PBS last nite said warming of oceans was most intense in Indian Ocean. the warm area streams directly east from there. This has affected the 'north atlantic conveyor', a dual hi-low pressure system which directly influences south atlantic weather.

However increases in the energy in the Indian Ocean directly over the recent earthquake fault line made me wonder if there could be a connection. Earthquake faults are usually under stress below what would cut them loose so if there had not been a quake in a while, the added energetic stresses from a warmer ocean might have triggered it.

Perhaps no way to tell if it was a factor but it is good to think about macro trends. Scientists can check out possible validity of hypotheses like these by modeling.

by maxwell edison

You global warming advocates often claim that it's a forgone conclusion that there is general consensus within the scientific community that human activity is indeed causing global warming.

1. Define "scientific community" by describing those "scientists" who are both educated and experienced in whatever fields which would qualify them as being a person who can offer an expert opinion -- make that an expert conclusion based on their own findings or the review of other's findings. And, of course, define the field in which those particular scientists work. A nuclear scientist, for example, who works for the Atomic Energy Commission wouldn't qualify.

2. Show me the results of reliable poll conducted by a reliable polling organization which showed that the "scientists" you described above -- and ONLY the scientists you described above -- agreed that human activity was causing global warming, and that concluded there was a "general consensus" among those people that human activity is causing global warming.

3. Define "general consensus". Would that be at least 50 percent of those scientists polled? 60 percent? 76.8 percent? 100 percent? The poll results are necessary to reach this conclusion.

4. And as a matter of full disclosure, who do these "scientists" work for, and who pays their salary and/or provides their means of income?

You continually cite these people and presume to speak for them. How about defining and identifying who they really are?