The last time Brittan sent a prince to war
Weren?t they invading France? Price Harry wants to go to war. Will history repeat?
http://www.news.com.au/story/0,10117,18904474-401,00.html
Surely there's nothing easier to spot than a red nut in camo.
Community archive
Weren?t they invading France? Price Harry wants to go to war. Will history repeat?
http://www.news.com.au/story/0,10117,18904474-401,00.html
Surely there's nothing easier to spot than a red nut in camo.
by jevans4949
Actually, France frequntly sends troops into other countries, mainly to deal with civil wars in its former colonies. Usually with reasonable success.
They usually don't pull troops out as soon as a couple of their guys get shot.
Also, as far as I am aware, they don't usually do things by bombing the hell out of civilans from 3 miles up.
by redgranite
The post you responded to stated that the foreign legion are good troops. Then you respondez (pardon my French, which I actually know) with, "Actually, France frequntly (sic) sends troops into other countries. . . " What exactly are you arguing against?
As for your last little crack. . . are you suggesting that our brave, patriotic, well-trained, US pilots are using their precision, laser-guided bombs to purposfully kill civilians? The US military goes to great lengths and places themselves at great risk to avoid civilian casualties. To suggest otherwise shows your incredible ignorance. I served in the Navy and Air Force; so I know first hand.
As for the French, the people of France are decent. They just need to get rid of their corrupt, commie-rat, socialist dictatorship government.
Last month's recent unrest just over the Channel from here was caused by the French people resisting their government's (small) efforts to open up their labour laws to mitigate the 20% (and increasing) unemployment amongst the under-25s. It would seem, then, from the size of the demonstrations that the people of France do not consider that their government is corrupt, commie-rat, socialist dictatorship [b]enough[/b].
Well, they will - eventually - get everything they deserve from their attitude and that is total economic meltdown. One day soon, if the wind is in the right direction, we will be able to smell Paris burning as the country self-destructs. Just so long as they don't expect the EU - i.e. me - to pay for the rebuilding.
As for the efforts of your fine troops in minimalising the civilian casualties in the recent toasting of Iraq. Might I put forward the tentative suggestion that you could have reduced "collateral damage" even further by not starting it in the first place?
Or maybe I just have the Monday Morning Grumps...
Neil :p
by jamesrl
Change your avatar. We usually chose avatar pics that reflect ourselves, if sometimes humourously. I don't find anything about Hitler to be very funny.
And I understand the point that the previous poster is making. French troops have been successful in Africa for some time now. They have been involved in the Congo, Central African Republic, Chad and Ivory Coast. They worked alongside American forces in Lebanon, Kosovo and the First Gulf War.
As for US Pilots, we all know that friendly fire has taken place, with British troopsin the Gulf War and with Canadians in Afghanistan. I would never suggest that friendly fire or civilian casualties are deliberate. Perhaps they are inevitable to some extent and that means we should be very careful before we commit to war.
James
by jdclyde
What about Prince Harry?
Is he REALLY ALLOWED to just "quit" if choses?
I understand the brass keeping him out of harms way, because it will be THEM in a sling if anything were to happen to the "young prince".
I still don't understand the whole life of luxury and wealth bestowed on the "Royal Family". Guess I don't need to though, huh?
by jamesrl
His uncle the Prince of York was not kept out of harms way. During the Falklands war he was piloting helicoopters to act as decoys for anti-ship missles. The idea was that they were to sacrifice themslves for their ship.
His cousin Lord Mountbatten in WWII was a destroyer captain and had his ship sunk in the Med.
Prince Harry like any soldier, has to fulfill his contract. There are always circumstances that people use to bend the rules and get out of the contract, but pressure would be on him not to do that, as it would reflect badly on the family.
The whole issue of the existence of the monarchy is interesting - I can see both sides of the argument. I would never be a member of either the monarchist league or the republicans.
James
Not just Harry kicking up a fuss - William is as well. In this, at least, I admire them for wanting to be "real" soldiers. They can just "quit", either of them can resign his commission and he's out of there.
As for the "life of luxury", doen't the Prez have it pretty cushy while in office as well? Anyway, don't ask me? I'm a republican. I think that Her Maj is pretty damn rich in her own right, anyway.
by jdclyde
when they become president.
Sure, he gets good benifits and guards for life, but the pay isn't that great.
by jevans4949
The point of the debate over the issue is that Harry, like his uncle Prince Andrew, wants to be allowed to go with his unit IF they are posted to Iraq (or any other conflict zone), and would be minded to resign his comission if he were deliberately prevented from doing so.
With regard to the finances of the British Monarchy, I believe the cost to the taxpayer generally compares well to the overall cost of the average presidency in any other country; in fact the Queen probably subsidises some official functions from her private wealth.
For purposes of international comparison, bear in mind that the effective "executive branch" in the British constitution is the leader of the majority party in the major house of the legislature. Where countries following this model have gone for a presidency, it usually ends up that the president is an old politician who didn't quite make it to the top, which isn't a very inspiring thought. The Australians had a referendum on this matter a couple of years back, and as it was reported in the UK, they rejected the model proposed as it was too obviously a way to reward old party hacks. My personal view is that, although the British Monarchy hasn't really flexed its political muscles since the early days of Queen Victoria, it is comforting to believe that it's still theoretically possible that there could be this check on the power of the executive if they really lost the plot.
by thefrown
The consequences of a capture just don't bare thinking about. I actually don't respect them for wanting to go, they have far too much responsibility to put themselves at such risk. So did Prince Andrew in my opinion.
In such a situation they could easily be responsible for the death of their entire unit. To go putting hundreds of lives at enormous risk would be bad enough, but there would be blood in the UK's gutters if they couldn't keep them safe.
Extremists on both sides would have a field day.
by jamesrl
The president gets Great! benefits.
No housing costs.
No travelling costs.
No food bills.
Clothing I don't know about - I remember Nancy Regean getting free dresses.
The president must be able to bank a fair amount of his income. I know in Canada, MPs and the PM get a portion of their salary interest free because some of their living expenses are for their job.
James
by jdclyde
they can go out and "speak" to groups, and bring in some good coin for a daze work.
They even get an office setup and paid for, until they kick the bucket. Last I heard, Clinton wanted a pad that would cost the tax payers $700K a year? Anyone remember the numbers? (this is just office space.)
by mjwx
get over 10 times more money than the president by playing the president on tv.
These are the figures P/A (I think).
Prez: $450,000
Sheen: 6.6 Mil
by redgranite
It's rather the mis-informed grumps. The US didn't start the war in Iraq. The invasion and subsequent takeover of Iraq were a resumption of hostilities that ended with a cease-fire agreement after the allied forces kicked Iraq out of Kuwait.
The hostilities resumed because Saddam Hussein refused to abide by 17 (that's right) UN resolutions.
by redgranite
He's the biggest joke in history. Haven't you ever seen the Benny Hill skits where he dresses as Hitler - they're hilarious!
I agree with the rest of your post. We should be very careful before committing to war. Also, civilian casualties are never acceptable but are, unfortunately, inevitable in any armed conflict.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending