The medical balancing act
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by oz_media
The absolute basic neccessities than most other countries citizens have?
I have all that and more, as my tax dollars are stretched farther and the government is held accountable for pretty much evey penny they spend; well that and we didn't just throw 700 billion at poor lenders and trillions on a war of little relevance at all.
You still pay more than I do and get less, so this whole paying for those who do not see to themselves BS is pure crap.
You already pay for the leeches too, its just YOU that doesn't see benefit beyond the most basic provisions that any nation provides from tax dollars.
You get less than I do and pay more than I do, yet you criticize [i]our[/i] system. seems like you got your wires crossed there,
Our system is not perfect by ANY means, I wouldn't even begin to suggest as much, but if our system gives more back to the taxpayers, who pay less in taxes, how does your system stack up?
It simply doesn't.
For you to downplay what you still believe is socialized medicine and yet accept an inferior system with no coverage at all, for more money, is just ridiculous.
Make some sense, Tony!
'No, I don't want to have more. I am happy getting less and paying more, why can't we pay even more and give even less back to those who paid? Now THAT would be ideal!'
by tonythetiger
[i]well that and we didn't just throw 700 billion at poor lenders[/i]
Businesses, like individuals, shouldn't get handouts at others' expense. If a business fails, bank or not, it should be allowed to fail.
Oh, and it's no longer just 700 billion... we're up to three trillion and counting... That's $100,000 for every man woman and child in the country.
Yes, my government is doing terrible terrible things... So many that I don't know where to begin... but common in all of them is a sense of entitlement, and a lack of responsibility.
There are over 9,000 earmarks in the latest bailout bill, none of which do anything for the economy, but are special favors for one small group at the expense of everyone.
[i]and the government is held accountable for pretty much evey penny they spend;[/i]
I imagine it would be much easier to hold them accountable up there... It's a much smaller group and that makes it easier to spot the bad apples. That only supports my position that less government is better.
[i]Our system is not perfect by ANY means, I wouldn't even begin to suggest as much, but if our system gives more back to the taxpayers, who pay less in taxes, how does your system stack up?
It simply doesn't. [/i]
I agree, but still think that emulating yours is the wrong direction for ours to go.
It is no more right to make everyone bail out an individual for their bad personal decisions than it is to make them bail out GM for their bad business decisions.
by oz_media
But in this case both quarries were importign the same stone, there were only a few in the world that could obtain it.
A key consideration though is that there IS a more durabel stone, available at a much lower cost from the local quarry. But th ecity wanted some rare, expensive stone. These are also not full paving stones but ones to be laid on edge (3" wide strips perhaps) BETWEEN paving stones to create a 'sexy' effect/contrast.
How about just using ordinary cement and then lowering the ferry fares to the Island instead or the cost of hydro power, which keeps escalating as we sell it to California.
We have mroe water in BC than pretty much anywhere, however we pay more than American to use our own hydro electric power which we sell to the US.
With the economic crunch on right now, the city should be more considerate of tax payers costs and keeping that money local and supporting local businesses, its not like a private builder making a courtyard that has to look just so. This is a main, pulbic sidewalk, where they have decided to use expensive materials at the tax payers expense and farm the work out to a European quarry.
But that's Vancouver, the most beautiful place on Earth but the politicians are still no better than any others.
by oz_media
However, our system was designed after the systems that have worked for almost every other industrialized nation for centuries now.
Our system is only different that yours in that, your tax money does not benefit you, but mine benefits me.
You could do much better than the Canadian system, which screws us daily and I don't pretend it's anything else but political bullspit that actually works for the people in some odd way, but you could do worse to, such as the system you currently get screwed by.
by tonythetiger
[i]such as the system you currently get screwed by. [/i]
my enthusiasm (ahem) in wanting it changed...
by oz_media
Tony and I found middle ground. It only took a few dozen posts this time, we're getting better at it I think. :D
What's funny is that I noticed we had similar but slightly different veiws at first, through our debate we grew father and farther apart in our beliefs. However, we then started to find some areas to agree and now have come full circle back to slight differences of opinion.
I suppose it was really a wasted excercise, but then again, is finding an are to agree ever a waste of time?
I think our key issue is that you believe your system is better than ours and I believe ours trumps yours. However the reality is, whether one is superior to the other is really not that important, we both agree our systems are not perfect and need much revision.
(I still prefer paying lower taxes and gaining greater benefits though. If you're gonna get screwed you may as well be given a smoke afterwards.)
Thanks for playing, Tony; it was fun once again.
by ksoniat
In 1989 I had a daughter Roxanne who at 3 months was diagnosed with Biliary Atresia (no connection from liver to gall bladder to get rid of bile). It took two weeks to diagnose and SC had no apropriate facilities at the time so we were at Emory children's hospital in Atlanta, GA. She had a Kasai procedure which created a bypass from the liver for the waste - another 2 weeks in the hospital.
Because the liver is regenerative it had created many bile ducts in an effort to find a "way out" making the functioning of the liver so poor she would need a tranpslant.
My husband was in his first 30 days of a new job (no insurance) I had a 300,000 cap on my insurance. My husband was able to return to his previous employer as if he had never left and received coverage.
In 1989 you had to have $100,000 available (insurance or cash-on-hand) to even get your name on a transplant list. Pittsburgh was the center of liver transplantation but had a long list. A doctor who had trained there was setting up shop in Philadelphia so we got on his list.
We carried a beeper (no cell phones then) for 15 months waiting for a donor. We had monthly appointments at Emory in Atlanta. Roxanne had 15 presciptions - 2 of them for formula because she need a "predigested" formula because of lack of liver function.
We got the call and lived in the Philadelphia hospital for a month while she received and recovered from her transplant. Two weeks after we got home she rejected the liver and died. She would have turned 20 this month.
Back then they didn't have partial or living donor transplants. There was a family from Mexico that had collected donations to get the funds to be put on the list.
In 1989:
70% of patients die waiting for a donor.
30% of patients reject the donated organ.
30% of patients have other complications due to circumstances around the transplant: for instance chicken pox will kill 100% of liver transplant patients. My husband actually got chick pox (for the second time) while we were waiting for the transplant. As Roxanne had been exposed she was removed from the list for a month. She did not get them, but since she was already off the list and exposed, and it was deadly later, our Pediatrician actually called another patient who had them and we reexposed her trying to give them to her. She never did get them.
In 1989 the anti-rejection medicine was $100 per bottle - and you have to take it the rest of your life.
The transplant itself is merely a portion of the total cost and effort involved. That's even assuming an organ would become available and their position on the list etc.
....and now you know the rest of the story.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending