Discussion Locked

The Pope and the Catholic Church

0 helpful
69 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Rather than risk corrupting Oz's positive thread in respect of Pope John Paul II, I am starting this thread for open comments on the teachings of Pope John Paul and the Catholic faith.

On sexuality:
Catholic teaching on sexuality provides that sexual relations are a gift from God to be shared between one man and one woman.
Further, sexual relations must not preclude the possibility of creating a child.

If one follows the teachings of the church, there is no need for birth control or abortion because one would only have sex with ones partner when a pregnancy would not cause a problem.

On Gay rights:
Pope John Paul was very forthright in the concept of love the sinner, hate the sin.
People and governments should not discriminate against Gay individuals.

However, homosexual intercourse is a sin.

The Catholic Church is very willing to accept anyone who is willing to repent and forsake their actions that could be considered sinful.

On medical research:
Artificial conception, embryonic stem cell research and cloning are considered to be inappropriate.

This is all to do with the teachings of the sanctity of the human body as a temple of the Lord.

As I do, the Catholic Church does not support the concept of the ends justifying the means.

Yes, there is potential good that might come from embryonic stem cell research. However, since life begins at conception, taking one life in attempt to save another is not right.

I am no theologian, nor am I as well versed in Catholic doctrine as I would desire. Still, I will come back from time to time and respond to those comments I can.

Chas

69 replies

by jaqui

then why do same sex pairings occur even in animals, like eagles, wolves, all living creatures that mate for life?
after all, the core of the monotheistic religions is that only man can sin.
so the animals can't, they aren't capable of sinning. so if it's something they do it's not a sin.

(btw, I just love rattling cages by arguing against belief systems, to get people to actually think about them )

ps, eating the body of and drinking the blood of Christ in the sacriment is canibalism, by any legal definition it's ritual canibalism.

>:)

by roger99a

Animals also steal, kill and covet. Animals can't sin because they have no gods.

by tony hopkinson

I've had several conversations with my dog, and while I'll admit canine afterlife has not yet come up as a topic, he did grasp the point that eating any more cupboard doors might end up with him investigating the possibility personally.
Can't be heaven if you can't have a dog.
Any one who thinks that's irreverant can discuss it with a large german shepherd whose big friends with me at the moment after a suitable bribe.

by tomsal

You guys/gals remember that debate? The ol' do animals have souls one. Some think they do, some think they don't. The ones that do think of course they go to heaven, etc. The ones that don't mostly think whatever an does is just because its an animal , it doesn't suffer consequences after it dies (like those of relgious faith believe -- heaven v. hell).

by thechas

Nearly all of the teachings of the Catholic Church are based on biblical passages.

I don't have the depth of theological knowledge to delve into the basis of the teachings.

Animals do not have a soul, nor freedom of choice. One must have freedom of choice for ones actions to be considered a sin.

As to the Eucharist, we are doing as Christ commanded at The Last Supper.

The Eucharist is one of the differences between the Catholic and other Christian faiths.

Most Christian faiths hold the bread and wine as a symbol of the sacrifice Jesus Christ made to redeem our souls.

The Catholic Church teaches that the bread and wine are transformed into the body and blood of Christ. This is but one of the mysteries of faith.

I can't explain the transfiguration. I'm not even sure that I fully understand it myself.

Chas

by jaqui

makes it canibalism.

who says animals don't have sould.
if god created everything, then he would have given them the same as us, sould.
they do have free will.
( cats are an excellent example of this )
what they lack is the knowledge gained by eating the forbidden fuit. that of good an evil.
so no action they take can be a sin.
every action an animal does is good, as they are innocent, and are doing as god intended.
so, since they have same sex pairings and are doing as god intended, then same sex pairings are not a sin in the eyes of god.

animals can and do communicate. so you can't really say they cannot have intelligence.

dogs chose to become domesticated.
so did cows and horses

if they had not chosen so, then we would not hav them as domesticated animals, they would be like deer, bears, cougars, wolves.

that is free will.

most herbivores have partaken of the forbidden fruit ( apples ) so they must have gained the same knowledge we have. if they havene't then that whole thing about the garden and the fruit is a lie.
which makes the entire mono-theistic beleif structure a lie.
( after all if eating apples causes you to gain the knowledge of good and evil so become able to sin, then the animals are capable of it.
if they aren't capable then the apple story is nothing but a lie.
there was no eden.
there was no original sin
there was no creation
there is no one god

if the creation myth is true, then I have a question:
why do you ignore gods own words as laid out in genisis?
"
let there be light..... and the eve and the morn were the first day"

that means the day according to god, starts at high noon, not midnight.
so the date should be changing at noon, doing otherwise is denying the word and will of god.

"judge not others lest thee be judged thyself"
implication:
and be found lacking for thine own judgement

the entire bible as currently used is a translation of an interpretation of a vision.
everyone's understanding is based on someone else's interpretation.

written in greek, with hebrew wording.
( using greek alphabet to spell hebrew )
so translated from the hebrew to greek to latin to english.
( scholars, at the time the old testament was written down were writing using the greek alphabet )
what the entire torah, koran abd bible are besed on is an interpetation of an acid trip, translated and re-interpreted throughout recorded history. what was originally written?
no-one can answer, as the "Holy Roman Church" burned the original documents.
so some pope destroyed the bible and used his interpretation as the bible from that day hense.

all this is recorded historical facts.
just go to any library and start reading the historical texts.

by tbragsda

.
Very good segment. That it happens in nature is good enough for me, whether it proves it?s a natural predication or not is meaningless to those that believe it?s a sin. Someone like a Pope has the ability to leade his people, and this is one of the areas that I criticized in the other thread, only to become a villain.

Sometime, when the waters a little calmer, I may post my one experence with Communion. Its a funney story for some.

by psifiscout

I would love to see the research on this. The wolves and eagles in the Pacific Northwest are reproducing very well for homosexuals. Could they be adopting? I have spent a great deal of time in the wild and have never seen a pairing of two males or two females of any wild species.

by tony hopkinson

I toned it down out of respect for other peoples respect as well.
However seeing as you let the pink wriggly things out of the tin.
Homosexuality is a sin ? So priests who shag little boys are ok because they are really sorry, but a same sex couple is going to get toasted on Beelzebub's trident becaused they aren't ?
It's ok for a woman to have eight or nine kids while her bloke is enjoying his gift from god ?
When catholic priests start talking about sex of any sort I get really annoyed. Either they've never done it so they are talking out their ar$e or they are lying b@st@rds and have been up one recently.
Pederasty started in the catholic church because, it was deemed a sin and immediate revoking of priestly perogatives to break their vow of celibacy and have sex with a woman. But they were still celibate having not been with a woman if they buggered some little boy. Why did they pick boys, because they could indoctrinate them into keeping quiet.
No ones telling me this was all going on in secret and a few bad apples were spoiling the cider.

They chose to ignore this vile crap, so the church would not be damaged. Continually throughout history when given the choice between harmimg it's flock or the institution, they've never chosen their seat of their power.

So how is that not the end justifying the means ?

They should start practicing what they preach before they start preaching what I or anyone else should practice.

Let him who is without sin cast the first stone as one wise fella put it.

by thechas

I make no exceptions nor excuses for the priests who have violated their vows and trust.

Yes, they have sinned.
In order for that sin to be absolved, they must both confess the sin and stop the sinful action.

I do have a problem with how the US Catholic Church dealt with the issue over the years.
All of the priests who broke their vow of celibacy with a same sex relationship should have been defrocked for the first offense.

I have known 2 priests who are caught up in this unholy problem. I would not have expected this from either of them.

I know that a large part of why priests were reassigned rather than defrocked is the shortage of priests.

The faithful of the Catholic Church have themselves to blame for at least part of the problem. Were vocations to the priesthood more strongly supported by Catholic families for their own offspring, there would be more and better priests around.

In the days of large families it was common for at least 1 child to be guided into becoming a priest or a nun.
Of course, human nature being what it is, the weak and "different" child was the one guided to a vocation.

While I personally do not agree with every position the church takes, if I desire to stay a member of the church, I must accept them.

Should it ever come to pass, I don't expect any of us to be alive if the church should find a theological basis to accept either married priests or Gay relationships.

As to your comment on preaching about sex, I think it falls under "those who can do, those who can't teach".
The church guides the flock in how they should live their daily lives. If one chooses to not follow those guidelines, one should find a faith that agrees with their beliefs.

Chas

by tony hopkinson

There is nothing in their belief structure (though much in how they practice it) to say you as a true christian genuinely regretful of sins you may have committed shouldn't go to heaven. Yet confession, sacrament, the last rites, hallowed ground all give them control on whether those you leave behind accept that you have gone upstairs. That is their power they use your own beliefs to manipulate people into believing that they have the power to damn your soul. Everything I know of the bible says only you have the power to do that.

As for the stance against homosexuality, I believe that came in by association with the roman empire which initially so persecuted them. All the texts must have been coloured by the beliefs that existed at that time. 'Bout time they moved on.

by tbragsda

.
Its in all religions. It is by far the most despicable part of organized religion. Its hard to ?practice what you preach? in a political environment like the Catholic Church. Too many to please to stick to your moral roots, and keep the flock in order.

by jamesrl

Is that people on earth run the religious organizations. Their failing project onto the church.

James

by jessie

though I'm not a GOOD Catholic per se, I am Catholic, and I have a minor correction on the issue of birth control. There is one "acceptable" method of birth control, aside from abstinence, and that is natural family planning. No, this is not "the rythm method." When practiced as it should be, Natural family planning is as effective as the pill. It involves daily temperature taking, checking cervical mucus, and uterine position, actually very scientific and extremely accurate. You guys should all go read the book "Taking Charge of Your Fertility" and learn more than you ever wanted to know about the female reproductive system.

The Catholic church's position on sex within marriage is that there should be no "man-made" barriers to conception, but if you're going to have sex only at those times when you're 99.9 percent sure you won't conceive, this is a good thing.

by sleepin'dawg

Never have understood the celibacy issue of the priesthood. In fact there were no restrictions on priests being married until sometime in the eighth or ninth centuries and in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries it is a well established fact that many priests, bishops and popes fathered children out of wedlock. What qualifies a celibate bachelor to be able to comment on marital problems. What terms of reference could he justifiably use??? It's never made sense to me and there are no biblical strictures regarding marriage or celibacy of the priesthood. The whole idea of papal infalibility is another thing I can't grasp. The pope is a man. Men make mistakes, otherwise they aren't human. If he isn't human then what is he and don't tell me about devine inspiration. That's a cop out and is used far to often to justify the errors and sins of the clergy. Even if it were possible how would the inspiree know for certain he was truly inspired and not halucinating. The miracle is why so many have remained loyal to Roman Catholicism in its present form.

I guess the above guarantees me a warm reception in the hereafter, assuming that there is a hereafter. ;)

Dawg ]:)

by dale lad

I believe that priests were able to get married right up until the Church worked out it was cheaper to keep one man than one man and his family.

by jamesrl

If you are a married Anglican priest, and you decide to convert to Roman Catholic, the RC chruch will accept you as a priest and accept the fact that you are married. If your wife dies or you get divorced however, you are out of luck....

James

by thechas

I'll start with your last statement.

Catholic teachings an redemption and getting to Heaven opened up significantly after the Vatican II reforms.

All one needs to do, is be true to their God and their faith to reserve a place in Heaven.

So Dawg, you can get there if you so desire.

On marital counseling:
As I understand things, the bulk of marital problems are interpersonal relationship issues. Sexuality conflicts is a result of other issues, not the cause of the issues that disrupt a marriage.

Being a good marriage counselor does not require that one have had sexual relationships. Just that one be able to listen and comprehend the problems that 2 people have living with each other.

I have listened to so many ideas in relation to Priestly celibacy since the mid 60's that I'm not sure what is the best course of action.

Still, Pope John Paul affirmed the Churches position on celibacy.

As to Papal infallibility:
The concept of Papal infallibility does not cover every action or pronouncement of the Pope. It does cover theological and doctrine pronouncements that the Pope makes.
These pronouncements are not made quickly or in a vacuum.
The Pope relies on a number of theologians to help devise and support any pronouncements that either affirm or change the articles of faith.

Chas

by jessie

Confession, is the act of asking for forgiveness. Most of us, when we ask for forgiveness from our friends and family are forgiven. Would you not expect the same from your heavenly father?

The basic Catholic belief is that you can be forgiven by asking for forgiveness, OR you can be forgiven by TRUE contrition and repentence, which only YOU and GOD know about but for forgiveness without confession, you must be truly and deeply sorry.

by dale lad

So if you aren't really sorry and contrite you can get forgiven anyway by telling the priest?
Easy way out...

by Member 25348569

You could buy an "indulgence" and repent before you've done it! You could buy time off from purgatory or, in some cases, buy your way out of hell and purgatory altogether. Tht's one of the (many) things that got Luther so ticked off with the Catholic Church.

by thechas

The act of confessing ones sins does not deal with earthly punishments.

The confession and absolution process redeems your immortal soul so you can go to Heaven. Or, reduce your time in Purgatory.

Jesus gave the Apostles and thus their successors the power to absolve a persons soul of the consequences of their sins.

To be absolved of a sin, three things are required:

A contrite confession,

Performance of a penance,

A conscientious effort to not commit the same sin again.

In the early days of the Catholic faith, many people waited until they were near the end of their lives to be baptized.
Since Baptism wipes out all past transgressions and cleanses your soul, people waited until they were done sinning to be baptized.

Any sinner can be absolved of their sin in the eyes of the Church and the Lord.

Confession and absolution in no way is meant to replace or supplant the legal system.

Chas

by tomsal

I absolutely agree dale.

The subject of confession is where I majorly part ways with Catholic belief.

The idea that you confess your earthly sins to another earthy sinner, who in turn is supposed to have the "power" to wash your earthly sins away is against my belief.

We (Lutherans) don't teach or ascribe to the concept that a man can absolve you of your sins, we ascribe that only God can absolve one of sin and therefore its through devote and honest worship, devote and honest prayer for forgiveness that you feel from your heart is how you cleanse yourself.

Of course I don't believe in purgatory either. But I'm not going to slam others beliefs on that.

Just some other thoughts..

The Virgin Mary is near "god like" in the Catholic faith, my faith believes in loving her and respecting her as the mother of Jesus Christ, but we worship God and Jesus, not Mary.

At Catholic services if their is communion you are not allowed to take communion if you are not Catholic. In our churchs, if you received the holy sacrament and believe with a true heart we don't care if you are Catholic, Baptist, Methodist, Lutheran, Penecostal, etc.... you are welcome to take communion with us together.

Because of these things and the others before, that's why *some* non-catholics feel like devote and strict Catholics are arrogant in their faith.

But again, just opening up and sharing here - not trying to bash. What you believe is great, and I respect that.

by tony hopkinson

Forgiven by whom ?
The only forgiveness that means anything is that of your victims.
The only contrition that means anything is public
The only gauge of repentance is to not do it again.
So keeping it all secret violates my belief structure and the ethical framework I choose to operate in.
P.S I aren't attacking christianity here or even catholicism as such, but I have no time for religious institutions particularly hierocracies.

by jessie

Personally, I've not been to confession in about 15 years... not since the last time my mother made me go. AFAIC, if I'm not truly and deeply sorry for something, then I don't feel guilty about it obviously, and asking for forgiveness for something I don't feel guilty about is hypocrisy. And I do TRY not to be a hypocrite.

What then are my reasons for still going to church? It's not that I believe all of the Catholic doctrine. I find mass very comforting, and it serves to remind me how I need to be living my life. I don't go to church to find God, He lives in my heart. I go to church to find Community, people who share the same BASIS of beliefs.

by tony hopkinson

whatever makes sure feel comfortable. I don't have any problem with your belief system as long as you don't try to make it more true by making me believe or making me choose between being burnt alive or saying I believe.
Other than that if it adds value to your life go for it. Just because some who claim they share your beliefs operate completely outside of them doesn't invalidate them. Nor is it necessary for anyone else to believe as you do to validate them.
If words and deeds match all confusion disappears, doesn't mean I like what you do or say, but at least everyone knows where they are at.
People are either basically 'good' or 'bad', which political party, religious group, colour, or sexual orientation has nothing to do with it because none of those are good or bad in and of themselves, simply labels indicating some sort of conformity.

by tomsal

Max thread was reached had to branch out to reply.

No kidding confession leads to forgiveness. Of course it does. But, and here's my little shocker phrase to you, if the bible does support your form of confession...guess what then...I don't care what the bible says on that as I don't agree with it.

Eeegats batman how can this be! Someone who claims love and belief in God dare knock the bible!!!? Be gone ye free-thinker!!!

Bottomline -- despite all you say, I do not agree with the Catholic faith on confession of my wrongs/sins to a priest or any member of the church directly. Period.

I confess my sins to God directly, its no one elses business or authority to know them or judge them.

I was trying to keep this one on wraps but I guess I voice this other thing I find "odd" about confession in the Catholic faith.

Catholics have this nice system of "ok you did xyz sin, so your prescription is xyz solution and then ALL DONE!"

As in just say 9483 Hail Mary's and prayer with the Rosary beads or whatever and that's it.

It changes every time dependant on what you confess and I think that is just plain wrong, and to be honest...its kind of weird and uncomfortable feeling.

(trying to be as polite as possible here btw -- to each their own beliefs)

by jck

for staying out of this...hahaha

Live and let live, I tell ya...til someone doesn't let you live.

by tomsal

..But I am truly saddened at the passing of the Pope. Why? Well what little I knew about the man is that he was decent and honest and that he really cared about people even those not of his same faith or exact belief.

I think this thread will be an emotional one and probably get folks angered or flustered but...

I never understood many things about the Catholic Faith...

1) Priests can't have sex? Priests are men, they are human. As such they have human desires. Isn't it a bit conflicting that God wants us to share our love with someone special -- including the physical expression of such love as sex, but yet Priests -- the very folks who are to bestow this message of God's love aren't allowed to have this special bond with another person they love?

2) Catholic position on sex is no man-made birth control within marriage. Yet don't they believe that you shouldn't have sex OUTSIDE of marriage too? So following that logic -- if you are a "perfect catholic" you are virgin when married, the first time you have sex is unprotected so if you are unlucky about the partner you chose you could get an STD and die. Nice. Remember unless there is a physical barrier, other methods don't protect against STDs.

3) Catholic undying believe in marriage at all costs. I've heard this many times, if its false let me know. Catholic faith says once your married you are married. Period. Doesn't matter what differences or difficulties you have in the marriage you MUST stay married forever. Because suffering together forever while married is better in the eyes of Catholics then being mature enough to know things in life don't always work out so you get divorced, start dating again and are very happy at last. And God forbid if kids are involved -- that's a big no no, must stay together for the kids (a personal belief of mine that this is one of the most absurd reasons I ever heard for staying in a marriage devoid of love and respect. "We are doing it for the kids". Yeah because everyone likes to see their parents miserable at each other everyday of their life!).

4) Confessions. Respectfully, to you Catholics out there but I think this is just wrong. My belief, faith and my personal hardships and sins are for me to share with whom I chose for support and comfort. If that is with God then its from me to God, not through another sinful man.

But this is just my two cents.

by dwdino

1) Vow of abstinence is of the Catholic, not God. It states in the Bible that it is better if a man can remain celebate (less things on the table to weigh him down), but is by no means a requirement. After all, in Timothy, Paul states that a Deacon (priest) must be able to manage his own family/household before being ready to handle responsibilities in the church.

2) I do not believe this view point to be correct. I do not agree with "the pill" as it allow insemination without implantation. But, barrier methods should be allow to prevent fertilization. On the matter of STD protection. Everyone should be a virgin when married and only stay with this one individual, but this is not a perfect world.

3) This is a huge can-o-worms so I will only dip my toe in. One question, why do most marriages fail? Because the newness wears off and everyone starts looking out for themselves, and the selfishness drives them apart. She's not meeting my needs, he's not doing this or that. Any time two self focused persons are forced to work together it will blow up.

4) Biblical confession involves no priests. First you align yourself with God's viewpoint and say: yes, I am wrong, please forgive me. Then, if there is a human person involved (person to person sin), you go to that person, admit your wrong doing, and ask there forgiveness. At that moment you clean of that sin. That does not mean that person is free from the consequences of that sin. Whatever punishments or messes are left to clean are still required.

by jessie

The only method of birth control that allows insemination without implantation is the IUD and it's variants. The pill and other hormonal birth control methods, prevent ovulation. The eggs do not "pop out", they simply die and are "flushed" during menses.

This is actually the reason why hormonal birth control can prevent some types of cancers. The more a woman ovulates, the more likely she is to develop ovarian cancer. When she does not ovulate either via taking hormonal birth control, pregnancy, or exclusive breast feeding, her chances of developing ovarian cancer are reduced (by how much I do not know).

by thechas

There is a general misunderstanding on the Catholic Churches position of marriage.

Yes, once consummated, a marriage is forever.

That does not mean that one cannot leave an abusive or otherwise failed relationship.

It does mean that you cannot start a new relationship. Unless, your spouse has died.

The Catholic Church does have 1 option for those in failed marriages. That is the annulment process.

Basically, to get an annulment, one must prove that:
1. The marriage never existed in the eyes of the Church.
2. The marriage was never one that should have been sanctified by the Church.

An easy process? No!

The annulment process takes the marriage off of the books as if it had never existed.

Chas

by jck

again...I'm not catholic...so forgive the ignorance...

Didn't God tell mankind to "be fruitful and multiply" in the beginning of the world?

If so, where does it say in the Bible that a priest must give up that original decree of God to be a holy man?

I just think there's a lot of mumbo-jumbo in modern religion. Man is imperfect, and therefore he's had centuries to screw-up, twist and maim the Word of God. And not just one religion...all of them...where man's influence has been, so has his imperfection.

My biggest example of this: from the time I was young, I was told you are supposed to tithe 1/10th of your earnings. Well, when did God start needing 10%? Did he consult his accountant on this? I heard later that the tithing number came from some edict back in the middle ages or something when kings were head of the church and it was a way to get money for the king in the name of God. That's just what I heard tho...never researched it.

I think the concepts behind most religions are that of humanity...kindness...happiness. That's what I try to focus on.

two more cents added...

by thechas

The last time I was involved in a serious discussion on marriage for Priests, one reason for the Church holding on to it's stance has to do with just how busy a Priest is.

In most parishes, the pastor is fortunate if his workload is less than 2 full time jobs.
He is on call 24/7 to minister to the sick and dieing.

Were a Priest to have a family, both the parish and the family would suffer.

Yes, I know that most Protestant Ministers have families. However, all but the largest Protestant congregations are much smaller than the average Catholic parish.

In the US, it is not uncommon for a single Priest to minister a flock of over 1000 families.

As to tithing, I believe there is a passage somewhere in the Old Testament that prescribes giving back 1/10th of your earnings.

Chas

by tbragsda

.
I would need to get to the source at home, but read a book touching on this subject. The main reason for the no marriage/sex rule was to break the legacy that priests were creating. They were becomeing wealthy landholders, and this broke that chain.

Again, for a complete recap of the forces behind this, I would need to get at my books at home. If anyone can put a little more light on this, please post.

TBR

by tony hopkinson

they gave it to the church. So it looked like they were giving up someything but the church didn't lose out. Fortunately a lot of them remained catholic, so big Harry and Good Queen Bess got to take it back, when they were at least foolish enough to look like enenmies of the state. The really rich catholic families got robbed blind. Still when you tell your King he's an offense to god for not doing what the pope says, you can expect a little pay back.

by tomsal

I was raised Lutheran (in an area where everyone and their mother is Catholic btw). Over the years because of changes in family situations, etc. I now go to a Methodist Church (my sister's father-in-law is the pastor).

Very laid back church, very well grounded folks. And yes both Lutheran and Methodist Pastors can marry and have kids (sex).

So it definitely has to be something specific to Catholic faith I'd assume anyway.

by montgomery gator

Eastern Rite churches (such as the Maronite Catholics of Lebanon) permit their priests to marry, even though they are subject to the authority of the Pope. I do not know the whole story, but I guess it was a compromise so that they could keep their local customs when they switched allegiance from Constantinople to Rome.

Also, (I do not have the exact year), but Roman Catholic priests were allowed to marry until about 1000 years ago when the Pope at the time changed the rules.

My tradition (Anglican) allows priests to marry, one of the changes when the Anglican church separated from Rome. Bishops are also allowed to be married. This goes along with Paul's letter to Timothy, where he said a Bishop should be a man with one wife. (I Timothy 3:1-7)
http://bible.gospelcom.net/passage/?book_id=61&chapter=3&version=50

The Orthodox churches allow their priests to marry, but if an Orthodox priest has hopes of becoming a bishop (Metropolitan), the priest needs to remain single. A local Greek Orthodox priest explained to me that was to prevent bishops from passing power to their children, similar to what you said. This priest said he loved his wife too much to remain single, so he is happily married with a son, and thinks the tradeoff is well worth not being eligible to become a bishop.

Most Protestant traditions have no barriers to their ministers getting married.

by free_lo2002

The most important thing about all this is not Catholics and or their rules but your relationship with God. If we have to talk about rules and all there is a book (the Holy Bible) which you can consult on God's rules and leave if you want the entire world behind. But... (and the but is always) don't let your opinions on some other people (Catholics) influence your relationship with God.
You'd be misled and you'd miss the point of all.
There is no "They?" in the God-man relationship but you and me.
You are an adult and you can have an opinion on your own and not borrow one from others.
So try to read, to get to know? to open your mind and you will understand that just like some bad days will not stop you from believing the sun can heat everything up, some persons can not decide if you want to hear anything from God or not.

by tony hopkinson

time. Now if we can get the church and the bulk of those who follow it's teachings slavishly without any self examination to agree with us, we'll be laughing all the way to heaven.

Slight (major understatement) disagreement on using the bible for rules though, which bit , which bible and whose interpretion of what it means. You might get guidance from it if you pick and choose, rules definitely not.

Anyone who starts quoting Thou Shalt Not Steal at me I refer to the Should intellectual property exist thread.

by tomsal

You are preaching to the choir on this one. I absolutely already do what you say in your post, have been since I've been old enough to think for myself.

Doesn't change the fact that I have large disagreements with the Catholic faith. Not one iota.

by montgomery gator

Does the Roman Catholic church have the same rules for married Orthodox priests who convert to the Roman Catholic church, since the Orthodox Church, (like both the Roman Catholic and Anglican churches) have bishops in the apostolic succession?

by jamesrl

I would think there are more conversions from Orthodox to RC than Anglican to RC.

I have actually read about a few Anglican priests and a bishop in Africa who converted, and kept their wives.

James

by jck

You crack me up, Jaqui

So since animals that eat herbs have lost their innocence and can't have same sex relationships without being sinful...does this mean that Mr. Green Jeans and Captain Kangaroo are doomed to hell for cohabitating with Dancing Moose?

by tony hopkinson

LOL
My daughter said the same thing, besides it's not 100% efective even if you follow the manufacturer's instructions exactly.
Lovely grandaughter though.

by ozi eagle

Maybe this proves God's omnipotence - if He/She wants you to have a baby, then no matter what man amde impedia you use it won't work.

by dwdino

"Redeem ones soul...", "...absolve a persons soul...", "...performance of a penance...".

Remember, "...not of works lest any man should boast..", "...He is faithfull and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness..."

Entrance into Heaven is based on one thing only, "a personal relationship trusting Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior."

These are the very perversions that drove Luther to speak out against the catholic church.

by thechas

Luther left the Catholic Church because of pervasive corruption in the process of confession among other problems when the Church and State were far too intertwined.

The biggest problem with the confession process in Luther's time was the purchasing of absolution by the rich.

I don't have my bible handy, but the biblical passage that confession is based on goes something like:
"Those sins you let loose on earth shall be let loose in Heaven. Those sins you hold fast on earth shall be held fast in Heaven".

I do believe that Luther was justified in leaving the Catholic Church.
His actions did force the Church to take a hard look at what it was doing and how far the role of the Church had drifted from the path God intended.

I also firmly believe that the Papacy of John Paul II brought the Church even closer to the path God intends for her.

Chas

by jck

"All one needs to do, is be true to their God and their faith to reserve a place in Heaven."

Man...so...hmmm...I gotta ask this one: whatever happened to God saying, "Thou shalt have no other gods before me." in the Ten Commandments?

Sorry, but I remembered about the cow worshipping and had to ask when I saw it phrased as "...their God...".

hope I don't encite a riot...

by thechas

On reflection, I think I oversimplified the stance of the Catholic Church on the potential for people of other faiths to gain entry into heaven.

Back in the late 60's as part of the Vatican II reforms, Church teaching was softened to allow that being a good Catholic was not the only way to gain entry into heaven.

It is not our place to assume that a loving God would allow for only members one faith to spend eternity with him.

We are not to assume that those we consider to be heathens will not be in Heaven.

Nor, can we assume that the evangelizeres are guaranteed a place in Heaven.

We do not know how God views any other religion. God may even be at the root of most faiths.

We do know that God does not want us to place the false gods of lust greed and glory ahead of him.

Chas

by aldanatech

Pope John Paul II was a wise man, and it would be wise of us to learn from many of his teachings. Lets look at some of them.

* July 3th, 1980:

"Social justice cannot be attained by violence. Violence kills what it intends to create."

* December 30, 1987, Pope condemns the excesses of capitalism:

"This determination is based on the solid conviction that what is hindering full development is that desire for profit and that thirst for power already mentioned. These attitudes and 'structures of sin' are only conquered - presupposing the help of divine grace - by a diametrically opposed attitude: a commitment to the good of one's neighbor with the readiness, in the gospel sense, to 'lose oneself' for the sake of the other instead of exploiting him, and to 'serve him' instead of oppressing him for one's own advantage."

* January 15, 1991, Pope opposes Gulf War on a message to George H.W. Bush:

"We cannot pretend that the use of arms, and especially of today's highly sophisticated weaponry, would not give rise, in addition to suffering and destruction, to new and perhaps worse injustices."

* March 13, 1998, on the shortfalls of consumerism:

"A disconcerting conclusion about the most recent period should serve to enlighten us: side-by-side with the miseries of underdevelopment, themselves unacceptable, we find ourselves up against a form of superdevelopment, equally inadmissible. because like the former it is contrary to what is good and to true happiness. This superdevelopment, which consists in an excessive availability of every kind of material goods for the benefit of certain social groups, easily makes people slaves of 'possession' and of immediate gratification..."

* January 27, 1999, the Pope speaks out against capital punishment:

"Modern society has the means of protecting itself, without definitively denying criminals the chance to reform. I renew the appeal I made most recently at Christmas for a consensus to end the death penalty, which is both cruel and unnecessary."

* March 22, 2000, Pope calls for a Palestinian State:

"The Holy See has always recognized that the Palestinian people have the natural right to a homeland, and the right to be able to live in peace and tranquility with the other peoples of this area."

* January 13, 2003:

"NO TO WAR! War is not always inevitable. It is always a defeat for humanity."

March 22, 2003, Pope condemns George W. Bush's invasion of Iraq:
"When war threatens humanity's destiny, as it does today in Iraq, it is even more urgent for us to proclaim with a loud and decisive voice that peace is the only way to build a more just and caring society. Violence and arms can never solve human problems."

Source:

http://www.tompaine.com/articles/papal_legacy_questioning_capitalism.php?dateid=20050404

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/04/04/opinion/04prejean.html?

More on the Pope:

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/religion/jan-june00/pope_3-23a.html

http://www.cnn.com/SPECIALS/1998/cuba.pope/

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/europe/2605367.stm

by tony hopkinson

missed out on all his contentious discourses.
LOL
Say why haven't you responded to the question you asked on importing emailed files in to MySQL ?
Or have you been the victim of an identity theft.

P.S. if you want peace you have to fight for it constantly. Violence was used to spread catholicism across the world, so one can only assume as the church has run out of continents, it's no longer required.

by aldanatech

The Pope was well aware of the crimes that the Catholic church committed against humanity in the past, and that is why he personally gave a public apology to the world on behalf of the church. Otherwise he would have probably been considered as a hypocrite -- at least I would. As for the MySQL question I will answer it soon, although that is rather irrelevant in this discussion.

by tbragsda

.
A book gathered from many source writings in different languages, told for generations story-teller style, translated again to english, and some insist that that "God said 'blessed are the?'". No joke, even prominent, respected people insist that God spoke in English.

What was chosen, and what was left out was a choice of man. That seems to imply that it can't be ?complete? or directly the word of god in anyway.

Peace
TBR

by jaqui

exactly my point

since everything in it was put there by man, known to be fallible, how can it be the "word of god"
he didn't sit down and manually write every line.

by thechas

I do believe that the Bible is the "inspired word of God"!

However, there are 2 significant sources for potential errors to exits.

First, there is the limited breadth of man's knowledge and understanding of both the physical and emotional world at the time the Bible was written.

Then, there is the amount of meaning that must have been lost in translation.

I'm confident that the "core" message is sound and true to the Creator's intentions.

Even today, there are numerous "different" Bibles.

There are at least 4 major versions along with a large number of variations among the Protestant faiths.

Chas

by tony hopkinson

Are you free to be gay ?
Are you free to have a different faith or none ?
Is it merciful to demonise someone in order to make them conform to your beliefs ?
Can you forgive them for threatening your faith by holding a different one ?

Ever heard of "Let him who is without sin cast the first stone ?"
Whether you are with or without sin as soon as you cast a stone, don't act surprised when someone chucks one back !
You need a much better aim to be effective with missiles, verbal or physical.

Note if you operate within a system of beliefs/ethics you are free to choose what they comprise, but you are not free to act outside them without being judged by your own standards.

by jck

The tithing thing...I then to think was added as someone told me...simply because...God, being the omnipotent and all-powerful soul, would not need a specific percentage amount of your money. Sounds more like an accountant came up with a specific number and someone put it in. All throughout the Bible, God has those think and give with their heart...except for that one place that involves money? Seems suspect to me.

As for the average size of a congregation, I think it depends on geography. I can tell you that you will regularly find Baptist churches in cities Oklahoma and Texas with better than 1000. In fact in my hometown in Oklahoma of about 15000, the First Baptist Church as 1500+ people or 10% of the city. In the larger cities, there are a number of churches over 5000 people. So, I don't doubt there are large Catholic churches as well. But, I tend to think there are small ones just like with any other religious affiliation.

there's two more cents...

by thechas

Despite beliefs to the contrary, Catholics do not Worship Mary.

Yes, she does hold a higher place in Catholic theology than in other Christian faiths, but we do not worship her.

Perhaps the biggest difference between a Lutheran and a Catholic Bible, is in a Catholic Bible Mary's body is lifted up directly to Heaven at the moment of her death.

Aside from Jesus, Mary is the only other person who's spiritual and earthly body are joined together in Heaven.

We pray to the Lord and to many Saints, including Mary.

Prayers directed to the Saints and Mary are usually requests for their intercession with the Lord on our behalf for help with a problem or guidance.

So no, we do not worship Mary. We do believe that Mary holds a special place in Heaven and we give Mary some extra attention in recognition of that special place.

Chas

by dingletec

The bible does say to "confess your sins one to another", however, since the bible also says that "God is no respecter of persons", "For all have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God", and "There is none righteous, no not one" it doesn't really matter if that fellow sinner is the pope or your neighbor. The point of confession is not so another human can forgive your sins, but humility, submission to God, and accountability. What we refer to as confession can simply be admitting to a spouse or close friend something we know we did wrong, and maybe discussing the best way to rectify the situation, or make it right, in other words.

Much of what we consider sin is simply rebellion against God. We know what we should do, yet we don't do it. As a child, I can remember many times stubbornly refusing to apologize to my sister for whatever I did to her at the time. Just pride. God doesn't want us to carry bitterness, anger, and resentment around with us, it's not healthy. That's why confession is so easy, and the bible says, "If we confess our sins, God, who is faithful and just, will forgive our sins and cleanse us from all unrighteousness".

It's as simple as saying, "God, I messed up, please forgive me and give me wisdom to resolve this situation". At that point, you are righteous, or in right standing with God. Confession is not for God's sake, but for ours. God is not offended when we do something wrong, and is not angry with us. The bible says that sin separates us from God. It's us that recoils from God, not the other way around.

I love my daughter more than life, it seems, even though parenthood is sometimes an exercise in frustration. But as a two year old, she does not have the experience or wisdom to know that something is harmful. As a parent it is my job to train her and teach her how to live life successfully. I can't always be there with her, I just have to trust that she has heard my instructions and obeys.

It's the same way with God. The bible says that sin has it's own reward. In the same way my daughter's disobedience yields a scraped knee after I tell her it's not safe to run here, or a burned finger when she is told the fireplace is hot, there are natural consequences for many things that we do.

Anyway, if you are a christian, the bible is your only authority. Not church doctrine, your pastor or priest. The bible is your reference manual for a better life. Jesus said that God didn't send him into the world to condemn the world, but that through him the world might have life. Choose life.

by tony hopkinson

He did indeed, a first and something I can respect. Course just saying sorry doesn't mean anything, and the church has stopped burning people alive, so maybe they are making progress.
The question I would have asked of him and anyone else who represents the church, is if it again became a choice between survival of the church as they know it or adherrence to their own system of ethics, what would the decision be ?
I 've seen no evidence whatsoever, that they'd keep their spiritual principals and sacrifice their secular privileges.

by jamesrl

As a movie that explores that very dilemma.

It takes places in 16XXs, and though fiction, explores a real event.

A Jesuit order sets up a mission in South America. Because the mission doesn't support slavery, and the land to north does, the mission grows and thrives.

But the church is faced with a dilemma. The area where the mission is has been ceded to the Portugese who support slavery. The mission has been ordered closed. When the priests resist, they are threatened with force of arms. The upper hierarchy of the church has been forced due to political considerations to accept this.

The real conflict comes when the priests split. One group of priests, led by Robert De Niro, chooses to meet force with force. Another group lead by the senior priest played by Jeremy Irons, choses to appeal to God, and appeal to the better nature of those who come to take the mission.

Not sure if there was any instance similar to the movie, but the church did abandon missions and turned their back on converts allowing them to become slaves. We would hope that they didn't take such a decision lightly.

Its a great movie, good music, great cinematography. And egads it makes you think.

James

by tony hopkinson

Hadn't heard of that one, sounds like my sort of thing. If De Niro's in it should be worth watching anyway.
My son bought me taxi Driver for xmas, watched it three times just for when you got the view of Bob's new haircut. Cracks me up every time.

by montgomery gator

You talkin' to me? You talkin' to me? You talkin' to me? Then who the hell else are you talkin' to? You talkin' to me? Well, I'm the only one here. Who do th f*** do you think you're talking to? Oh, yeah? Ok. Huh?

(Classic line by Robert DeNiro as Travis Bickle in "Taxi Driver")

by jaqui

did "the core" message get put down correctly by the first to record it?
or did they screw it there, causing everything to be screwed since?
an impossible dilema, as there is no proof either way.
you have to either accept that man got it right, for once, or you deny the validity of the whole thing.

and, concidering how history shows man's ability to get it right is less than a 1 in a trillion chance...

This discussion is closed to new replies.