Discussion Locked

The Rating Meter should go live this week

0 helpful
73 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

As discussed in an earlier thread, we're deploying a new signature system for discussions posts which will include a rating meter. The meter output is based on an evolving algorithm of site participation.

Now, many of you were recruited to the TRI ranks because you "set the bar" for community participation, so some of you might rightly expect to score pretty highly on this first incarnation of the meter. You will, at least relative to the rest of the group.

However, while our heavy hitters will certainly be the highest scorers, but you won't peg the meter. That's because the meter algorithm accounts for participation in features that aren't built yet. You can't score points in these areas because the areas don't exist, so don't be suprised when the best of the best still have ample opportunity to improve.

As we phase in features during 2005, I'm sure you guys will be able to race up the charts as fast or faster than anyone...especially since you'll know about the features first. So now you know.

That, and you guys are usually far better at fielding questions from the community masses than we are, so it's best to keep you informed as much as we can.

--Jay

73 replies

by house

I'm really looking forward to this feature too. I think that it will promote a "tighter" and more personal Tech community here at TR.

Are the rating meter and the peer directory going to be developed during the same time frame in 2005? I can't wait to see everyone's ugly mug.

I'd like to extend a welcome to "apotheon". I've recently seen his name floating around in the Insider's threads. Good job...and welcome to the TR insiders.

by maxwell edison

.
I was rather surprised to see a couple of newcomers (relatively speaking, of course) to the TR Insiders group, but not disappointed in the least. You guys have made some great contributions.

by house

Thank you. I've seen all of your names in the regular discussions, and I'm glad to see that the TR members that I've often agreed with, learned something by reading their posts, or simply respected, are the same members that I see here.

by oz_media

It'll be fun anyway, I think the first little while will be a mad scramble by many peers to get some ratings together, kind like a gold rush on TR.

I certainly hope you can restore the 'View all open questions' link in the Q&A section, it will needed, I was there for about ten minutes the other day and simply gave up, it's too much hassle trying to help people.

FIX THE LINK PLEASE JAY!!!! Wave your magic wand and whip the guys into shape, this needs to be a priority for the new rating system to take off.

by house

...for the guys/girls who are serious about the TR community.

I just hope it doesn't spawn some new abuse patterns in the discussions area. Although, I'm not a point monger, it is a shame to see that kind of activity. Do they honestly think that their points mean anything when their posts are flagged as useless contributions?

by oz_media

It's life, EVERY system has a way to be beaten. There will ALWAYS be people trying to beat the system. One thing you should know about TR though; There has never been any real moderators, contact with editors etc. In recent months a team has started to look at all the complaints from long time members and little quirks that TR has had and they've come forward and decided to get things sorted.

In the beginning... they made a few odd changes with no notice and everyone went crazy, then the dust settled Jay (Thy Trivius Geekus) came forth and spoketh unto us.
[i]
>"Arthur.....Arthur......KING of the Briton's...Oh don't grovel. One thing I can't stand, it's people grovelling"

-"sorry"

>"And don't apologize! Every time I try to talk it's 'sorry this' and 'forgive me that' and 'I'm not worthy'...NOW what are you doing?!?"

-"I am averting my eyes, O lord"

>"Well don't! It's just like those miserable Psalms. They're SO deperssing...now KNOCK IT OFF!

-"Yes Lord."

>"Right. Arthur, King of the Britons your knoghts of the Round Table shall have a task to make an example in these dark times."

-"Good idea, O Lord!"

>"'COURSE IT'S A GOOD IDEA! Arthur behold, THIS is The Holy Grail. Look well, Arthur, for it is your sacred task to seek this grail. That is your purpose, Arthur, to seek the Holy Grail."

-"A blessing, a blessing from the Lord. God be praised!"[/i]

or something along those lines.. :p

Anyway, he has started this group to get some input and feedback before unleashing the horrors on others. This is actually the most proactive and interesting thing I've seen done here. Sure it'll have flaws but they seem to be open to addressing these issues now. :)

by Jay Garmon

...we just have to cache it. I finally found out why this highly popular feature was taken down: it was a major performance issue. The link you guys privately use (and which I encourage you guys to use, so long as it isn't posted in a public thread) actually hits a live database call, which searches the entire Tech Q&A system and formulates the list. When this was public, it jammed the server pretty regularly, and as you guys notice, our system already gets jammed up enough.

Our Supreme Engineer is going to work out a clever little cache for that particular feature, so it isn't a live call, and then the link will resurface. Until then, enjoy the private privilege of the old link.

--Jay

by oz_media

You see that's EXACTLY what I was telling 'house' about yesterday. You guys ARE getting things fixed and it's great.

Glad to hear it will be back and hope it works out and stays.

Cheers,
OM

by shiny_topadm

Wow, am I really on the "inside"? It's very interesting to read people's opinions and to find out what's happening before it changes. I feel priveleged to be in this company and I don't know what kind of hours you folks keep for your level of participation. I'll try to keep up!

by maxwell edison

.
I never work, never sleep, never eat, never do anything except read and post messages or read and answer questions.

by willcomp

Wish I had more time to devote to TR. Some of us have to work or go hungry. Being self employed and your own boss has many rewards, but abundant free time isn't one of them.

Not being a touch typist is also a major hindrance.

Keep posting. I enjoy you, Oz_Media, and others in the discussions and The_Chas in Q&A. All of you write and express yourselves well.

Dalton

by oz_media

I went through half a thread with another 'peer' about how I don't live on TR and I actually have a life off-line.

I do have a life, I KNOW I have a life somewhere around here, now if I could only remember what I did with it ?!?" :(

Yeah, it's been rainy for days and days as expected here, how can you tell I haven't adjusted yet? Maybe a few days camping would help, that'd be cool! :)

by hal 9000

And then you go and admit that you spend all of your time here.

I at least admit to getting some sleep at least once a year.

Cheers Mate!

Col

by house

I hit this site at work, at home...it's a good thing that my girlfriend is a web designer who plays video games, otherwise I'd have been shown the door a long time ago.

The only time that I'm not here is when the "wife" is playing Everquest, and I'm on the Gamecube.

I have also noticed that I am not the only one chewin' his nails after midnight on this site. Even though I'm in Eastern Standard time, and considering the three hour difference to the west, the site still shows responses after 12:00.

I should also say that TR is a highly addictive drug. I need to start going to bed at a decent time and waking up earlier...I haven't done anything besides go to work, come home, read eWeek, and hop on TR. The weather sucks in Ontario right now too; that could be part of it. Maybe not though; perhaps I'm just looking for an excuse to be here.

PS - My non-tech buddies are starting to worry about me too.

by apotheon

You've got a geek girlfriend that doesn't mind your obsession with online computer-geek activities. You don't NEED to go outside!

by apotheon

Welcome to the party. I just received my email invite yesterday, and I'm already enjoying myself.

by house

King Arthur! I was a little bit worried about the rating meter and not so much the "open questions" link.

By the way, if this is the Round Table, and I am the new kid...does that make me Lancelot?

I'd much rather be Merlin or someone you can trust to leave alone without causing a ruckus. Besides, I didn't even run the "Gauntlet" yet.

by oz_media

The whole round table thing was just a little bit of a Monty Pythons run off, I have a tendency to do that, sorry.

But just look at your fancy new status bar, oooweee! That's some neato gear!

by apotheon

Good work, guys.

I have a question, though. Am I the only one here that sees the meter as running over the length it's allowed? I've got a cropped-down screen capture of what I'm talking about at the following URL:
http://www.apotheon.org/images/rating01.png

Note: I'm using Firefox 1.0 on Debian Testing with screen resolution set to 1152x864.

by hal 9000

How about a hundred end users who are so knowledgeable that you have to turn on their computers for them every day as pushing that switch is just far too technical for them.

Does that sound bad enough?

Cheers Col :D

by house

I'm doing tech support at an ISP right now...don't get me started.

Someone told me "I've got the new acrobat ethernet virus thing"...it's an inside joke now at the office.

There should be a "Funniest help desk calls" link here, would be a lot of fun, but it could insult others.

by apotheon

I went to a LUG meeting and a LUG group dinner at Bennigan's afterward last night, not getting home until about one in the morning. I'm going to a small party tomorrow night. Amazingly, I seem to have a life outside of t3h Intarw3b.

I just have amazing touch-typing skills and am an impressively prolific windbag.

by hal 9000

God I need help I'm in the process of loading a new LT with Debian for the customer and what's far worse is I just love it.

You might like this one the other day I saw a bumper sticker that read "I stop for Penguins but run through walls and fences!" I just had to wait around until the owner returned and I was told that she had no idea what it was about as it was on the car when she bought it down south and she thought that it was something to do with protecting the Penguin populations that we have around some areas of the AU coast.

Col. :D

by hal 9000

Don't forget your LT and solar charger as well as the phone adapter who cares about the cost of staying on TR but you'll either need a satellite phone of be close to a repeater tower to be able to use it.

Col :D

by oz_media

I actualy do get a pretty good signal until midway across on the ferry. All the mountains around here are fine, that's where everything runs through, no streetside poles even,it all comes in from the alley, they are really big on aesthetics.

A funnt one is when I am on the top deck of the ferry surfing around TR, the top deck is where ALL the UVIC students go to smoke weed during the crossing. I'll be sitting there clicking away on a laptop while they all sit around on the various benches gazing at me like the apes when they saw the obelisk in 2001 a Space Odyssey. A few head scratches and a litle chest pounding and they are back to thier own business though. :D

by apotheon

I want that bumper sticker. Oh, yes, I do.

Debian, so far, is without doubt my OS of choice.

by house

I haven't given debian a proper trial yet, though I've heard nothing but good things. Ran Redhat 8 through 9, but now I'm using ...xp....
Don't slap me, I'm just not a master Linux user and I got frustrated with dependencies and stuff like that. I will try Debian though, as soon as I get the urge to download 101 disk images. Last I saw, the package was at 7 Cd's.

PS - My girl just gave me a desktop with the penguins all over the windows logo. Pretty cool.

http://tinyurl.com/4ejho

* Thanks for the tiny URL info. I learn something new everyday here. In case someone is reading this for the first time, my url was the length of your browser window.

by oz_media

Why is the status based on the last 30 days? THis will result in some absurd results. Many people drop in to discussions and just post EVERYWHERE stirring it up for a while and they are history, not exactly someone you would want to promote as a viable member to be trusted. Yet this person has the ability to APPEAR to be a highly preferred member or 'peer'.

If the time frame is lengthened, say 1 yr or even 6 months, then it would be a much better indication of who is valid and useful as opposed to who is most actively making noise.

My apoligies to those of you who are new to TR and yet have a lot of useful input, you will soon understand who I am referring to though and it certainly isn't yourselves.

by house

That will help in fighting off any new abuse trends that may arise due to the new rating system. If someone wants to sit there and fill a six month average to the max, let them...they will die from Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. Hey, I think we found a way to get rid of these people.

I understand exactly what you're saying, and I won't mind sacrificing my rating for the cause. Even though I've been here under different names in the past (just for info, not discussions), I've only recently decided to proactively contribute to this site. I think it is fair that new guys put in their time to earn the respect of others.

by apotheon

You've got fully half again the recent activity rating I have, it looks like.

I'm sure my own activity rating would suffer if it was made a longer-term measure, but I too would be willing to make the sacrifice for greater integrity for the system. Then again, I don't know why a 30-day activity meter was implemented. Maybe there's a very good reason for such a short-term measure.

by smorty71

This has been a topic of much friendly debate here at TR, so let me share our current thinking on the 30-day timeframe.

1. The selfish reason: we want to maintain a super-active community. We hope that, in some small way, the meter acts as a kind of reminder that you need to stay active to stay on top.

2. The better reason: we want new members to feel challenged by the meters of the top members; however, at the same time, we want them to know that if they, too, are very active then they have a chance to be recognized as one of our top members. Our current TechPoint system makes it impossible for a new member to ever reach the top.

Internally, we've been referring to the idea of a "persistent challenge," so things like the meter and other elements of the upcoming profile page design will have many different ways to show/reward your technical knowledge, skill and level of interaction with the site.

How do we avoid junk posts to boost meter?
Although I won't go into all of the details of the algorithm, I will say that the all of the variables are weighted to help minimize "meter abuse." So some community activities (like answering TQ&A questions for example) are weighted higher than others. And if a member wants to post a junk answer to attempt to get a meter boost, their meter will actually take a hit when the member who asked the question rejects it.

As I mentioned in another post, the meter and its algorithm are still in beta. We hope to add more variables so that no one activity will cause wild swings in status.

Please keep the feedback coming since we will be constantly looking for ways to make it better.

sm

by apotheon

It occurs to me that there's a small problem with the relationship between point values for questioners and answerers. I'm not positive (I haven't read the point-system explanation recently), but I seem to recall reading something about people asking questions having to give up points when an answer is accepted. If that's the case, there's a huge incentive there to reject all answers, even when the answers provide the needed information.

In general, in any case, I think there needs to be at least three consideration stamps possible: Rejected (for answers that are just BAD), Accepted (for good answers, or answers that are in the right vein, but don't necessarily answer the question), and something else for answers that actually provide a solution or the information to get to a solution. That keeps good answers that just aren't perfect for that individual from being Rejected out-of-hand.

The reason the three options seem necessary largely arises from the fact that many people ask questions that are not specific enough to precisely explain what is needed. When someone tries to answer it, often the answer is the Right Answer for a given interpretation of the question, but not for the meaning the question-poster originally intended. As a result, I see a lot of good answers get rejected, which means that knowledgeable and helpful people are getting unfairly shot down.

Thanks again, guys, for all the hard work. It's good to see you taking constructive criticism so well.

by Jay Garmon

To add to sMoRTy's points, the meter is just one of several "activity indicators" we're working on, so it probably seems a little naked right now. One of our key goals is to establish a Top 100 badge, and to track your "streak" of Top 100 appearances. So, if you've been in the Top 100 for, say, the last week, it won't be nearly as impressive as being in the Top 100 for the last 3 years. We're hoping these indicators (assuming we pull them off) will give the meter a little context, while encouraging users to stay active consistently.

--Jay

by apotheon

Heh. I'll never be in the top 100 for the last three years. While I tend to be VERY active in communities like this when I'm active at all, I tend to have dry spells as well.

C'est la vie. I ain't in it for the little meters anyway.

by oz_media

At one time, URL's used to get wierd spaces randomly inserted into them, thus breaking the link and ending up displaying a %20 in the wrong place. TR has since added HTML formatting to accet URL's, kinda cool and also a few of the little Smilies :) :D etc. [B]AND[/b] [i]some[/i] [u]formatting[/u] so most links work okay, as did yours.

When the space problem was an issue, TheChas pointed me to tinyurl.com it is a small Link in your toolbar that allows you to obtain a short URL for pages, thus the space was never added.

it will give you a URL like http://tinyurl.com/4w4pd for this page, if your link is too long.

http://www.tinyurl.com

by apotheon

That rules. It's now my background image. Thanks.

Do you know where I can get a larger version of the image? That one doesn't scale up so well, and I'd prefer to have it cover the entire workspace rather than just be centered.

by smorty71

The meter should appear on one line. We had quite a time getting this to display properly on both Firefox and IE on Windows.

Honestly, I doubt anybody in our location is running Debian for us to test it.

Is anybody else seeing the meter wrap to a second line? If so, let me know what OS and browser you're using and I'll see if I can tweak the style sheet some more.

Thanks for the QA, apotheon.
sm

by maxwell edison

.
It's all in fun, Colin, as I'm sure you know. And there are a few of us who do keep some pretty strange hours. At my office, for example, we are, pretty much, an 8 to 5 kind of place. But I'm the ONLY IT person, and one of my goals is to have 100 percent "up time" on both my network and everyone's personal computer. So whenever I have to take someone or something down for a bit, I'll do it after normal working hours so I don't interrupt anyone's work-flow.

But I see that as a win-win. The company gets to have as close to 100 percent up-time as possible, and I can take some hours, a half-day, or a whole day, or whatever to go play golf or to watch my son's sporting events, (to post at TechRepublic), and so on.

As far as how much time I really spend at this site, of course I was exaggerating just a bit when I said I spend all my time here. If I were to estimate some sort of average, however, I might guess that I spend perhaps an hour a day either reading or writing something.

Hey TR guys, can you tell me how much time "Maxwell Edison" has been logged in over the past year? Let's take that time and divide it by 365, and there ya' go; that's my daily average.

Oh my gosh - think about even that. 365 hours divided by 24 equals 15.2 days. That's THREE WEEKS (5 day "working weeks") of my time - FULL TIME! 365 divided by 8 (8 hour "working day") is a WHOPPING 45.6 DAYS! Geesh, I should start billing TechRepublic for my time. (Just kidding. That's a win-win as well. Or am I just kidding?) But geesh, maybe I should really think about that.

by hal 9000

Isn't it fun pulling an E-Mail Server?

The complaints that I get when I just have to pull one for some reason and they will not let me or one of the guys at it after hours.

I sometimes think that all business runs on e-mail from the way that they carry on I think I'd have fewer problems if I slept with their wifes or whatever.

If you think the time you spend on TR is long I just hate to think of the wasted time that I have to hang around waiting to pull whatever because something important is coming and even though the server isn't working properly it just has to say working no matter what. At one of the places I have an old Dual Slot 1 with Hot Swappable SCSI's that was always falling over and they wouldn't do anything about it so I just Ghosted another drive and left it running so that next time it fell over I could have it up and running in the time it took to reboot and pull the first drive mostly under a minute. It hasn't fallen over since but I can guarantee if I was to remove that second boot drive I wouldn't get back here before I had another call out because it had failed.

Any way look after yourself and Have a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.

Col

by house

Thanks for that list. I'm going to show it off at work today.

Listen to this - We offer Commercial web hosting. A new client has recently registered for our services and has given us the site name "Cracks-n-Hacks..." or something along those lines. He kept calling us complaining that he could not get anything to work. We kept saying "upload your index.html, we still can't see it". After about a week of calls back and forth, we checked out exactly what he was doing...

...He was using the file "index.hotmail" - Everytime that we said ".html", he thought that that was our short form for "hotmail". Cracks-n-Hacks indeed. LOL.

Chris

by apotheon

house: No biggie. I ended up increasing the image size in GIMP and smoothed out the edges so that it's pretty again. This was the first time I've tried to increase image size in GIMP and adjust it to look good at the new size, and I discovered it's much, much easier than it was in Photoshop. This pleases me. Heh.

sMoRTy71: Quite welcome. I do what I can. Additional information about my setup follows, in case it matters. I'm actually reasonably certain that the fact it's Debian is irrelevant.

kernel: 2.4.25
window manager: WindowMaker
resolution: 1152x864
graphics: ATI Radeon 9700
character set: ISO-8859-1

Viewing the page with character encoding set to UTF-8 (Unicode) instead of ISO-8859-1 (Western) doesn't change the look at all.

by hal 9000

"It's been a long time since I actually read the details" but you are able to chose several possible solutions or ratings for answers to a question. They are Rejected, Not Accepted and Accepted.

Naturally with the accepted choice the question should be closed and the points awarded but you also have to remember that TR gives you 1,000 points for asking the question and closing it as well no matter the outcome. I used to spend quite a lot of time in the Q & A section but after seeing far too many Rejected responses to what should be at the very least part way correct answers and the fact that The Chas always seems to be first in with what should be the correct answer I very rarely visit there any more.

While I do not expect my answers to be correct particularly when some very vague questions have been asked the outright Rejected statement without explanation tends to put me off a bit. Even on the few occasions when I've seen a question closed with some form of what has happened I've seen Rejected Responses on what should at the very least have put the person on the right track to a solution.

Col

by oz_media

Now if we could only get that Chas guy....hmmmmm. JUST JOKING CHAS!! Man, that guy is pretty damn clever with hardware!

I think there is an option in Q&A to reject an answer and still leave the question open for response and then accept it and award the points too.

Now, if someone DOESN'T get the right answer they can reject all answers of course, but there MUST be a forced reason or comment window for them to explain either what DID fix the issue so we all learn from it, or explain that they ended up reformatting or something. It is just plain RUDE to not at least say "Thanks for the tries everyone but I found it to be due to ..."
I mean it is classless and disrespectful, bottom line.

You ask for someone's help and they take time to find links, type out responses, sometimes work for several posts to help someone through an issue and then the answer is rejected and no points awarded. Have a little respect people, what the heck worked????

Yes it is frustrating and after a while it most certainly pushes you away from helping people, now I am even one who has said that we need to put the a**holes aside and continue in Tech Q&A because not everyone is a jerk, but to be proven wrong time and time again sure is frustrating.

Sorry to go on, it's a bit of a peeve for me.

And now that I have ruffled up my feathers a bit, WHERE'S THE DARN 'VIEW ALL OPEN QUESTIONS' LINK!!!! AAAAAAARRRRGGGGG! :D

Why I oughta.....!

by oz_media

A while ago the discussion about who and why they use Firefox was posted by a TR editor (I think).

Now we see the REAL truth, if nobody used Firefox, you didn't have to fix your code!! VERY cunning! :D

Just joking :)

OM

by house

I've recently decided to give Firefox a second chance. I'm using it right now without a single problem. I've defended IE though, because I still believe that it is the best choice in a corporate environment.

Right now at home, Firefox rules. I had some issues with the MS port beta, but since 1.0, it looks good. I also tried Netscape for the first time since the 90's and soon got rid of it. Too much information and clutter for me.

I didn't see any problems on this site regarding any of those browsers. Must be the "perfect" Debian distribution acting up. Joke.

Chris

by house

...but I do this for fun - not competition.

Jay's already brainwashed the rest of us. You're next. You will never do anything else but join in our discussions.

PS - I'm thinking of running a dedicated line to TR...what do you think?

Just kidding. :)

Chris

by apotheon

Ooooh, purty meters.

Ahem.

I think that running a dedicated TR connection is a terrible idea. At least, it is if it's just for you. If it's for me as well, though, I'm all for it.

by oz_media

I can get a great deal rom the railroads running fibre down the tracks, I actually got to watch a line being dropped that I had sold it's pretty cool seing a train and fibre crew lay down your work.

Might have a TAD of a problem weaving through the Gulf Islands but we can figure that out later, my pipe is quick enough for now.

by house

Hey...thanks for mailing out the "Bad Weather" thread - http://tinyurl.com/536t3 - we've already got some goof dancing around with useless remarks. Maybe he's trying to build up his meter by insulting everyone.

Maybe he's just insulting me...I'll read the rest...but the number of posts here seems to be growing exponentially. I'm going to go to bed early tonight and cry myself to sleep.

Joke.

Chris

by oz_media

Gee, that wouldn't have been Oz_Media would it?

I don't think I had a poke at you but I sure did have a go at a few people there. Sorry but I lived in the Maritimes and in Central BC, I don't buy snow and ice fears form Texans.

I used to go off pretty bad on a lot of people, but think I have mellowed since becoming comfortable with the crowd here. I have a hard skin and always start with a harsh approach, oncei am comfortable with people I will lighten up a bit. I find I usually don't attract candy a*sed friends that way.

I used to be an a-hole but I feel much better now! :D

by house

Actually, you agreed with me regarding my post, and I agreed with your response. I'm actually going to cut some wood this Sunday out in the "boonies".

I left my comment over three weeks ago and just saw it pop up in my discussions again just to be heckled by some kid.

All he did was agree with everyone who was as lazy as he is, and insult people who hold their careers up high. Useless member of society in general. We all pay for whatever social program he is crawling out of. Maybe not me, but our American friends certainly do. Maybe though, he just lost his job over such an issue.

PS - Glad you like the country. I wouldn't think of living anywhere else. :)

Chris

by apotheon

Linux is Linux is Linux. All that really differentiates the various distributions as OSes is A) the software management system it uses (how software is installed, tracked, and removed and, to a lesser extent, how it is configured), and B) the installation procedure for the distro. Somewhere between these two points is the consideration of what is installed by default.

If you choose to install all the same things with Debian that are installed with Fedora, though, they're exactly the same thing when you're done, excepting the back-end to package management. In fact, though the system is nowhere near as mature on Fedora as it is on Debian, Fedora can use the apt system as well. Of course, a case could be made for simply switching to Debian if you are using apt with Fedora anyway.

Yes, by the way, I noticed you were making a joke about Debian being "perfect", and I appreciate the joke with some amusement. I just figured I'd take the opportunity to point something out. Like I said, the fact that it's Debian I'm using should be functionally immaterial/irrelevant to the difference in display of the meter. More relevant would be configuration details and software packages installed.

by house

I am perfectly aware of everything you just said. Just taking a jab at your undying love for the Debian distribution.

I'm actually looking forward to checking it out one day. I did notice some issues with certain sites a while back when I was running Red Hat 9 with a Firefox release (can't remember version). I don't claim to know anything "indepth" about the Linux flavours, but it is something that I am interested in pursuing.

On that note, I am interested to know if you have any publishers/writers that you could recommend on the subject. I went through O'Reilly's Red Hat Linux and Apache texts one after the other - useless books if you ask me...the Red Hat Book didn't tell me anything that I didn't already know - The Apache book was ok, but Web isn't really the direction that I am going right now - I've been leaning towards the Cisco route lately.

PS - You really are quick to defend yourself. :)

by oz_media

I moved within a mile of a logging camp, so the backroads are not short of a few good logs.

I had some time off a while back and got about 1 1/2 cords done, and it hasn't snowed yet. We've had some rain and it dropped to about 4 or 5 degrees but foday it was actually somewhat warm(er, ish) and sunny.

As for leaving, I have been SUPPOSED to be moving back to England for the last two years, I just can't pull myself away though and just find ways to communicate and get the work done from here.

BC's kinda like wilder-crack, you just can't get enough and every day you find yourself in awe at something you see happening around you.

by house

England sounds wicked. The first trip (when me and the wife get our finances in order) is going to be a tour of England, Ireland, and Scotland. My girl is Irish blood, and without my last name (long story), I'm mostly English blood. I guess I shouldn't say that though because we are third and fourth generation Canadians.

On another note, I don't need wood myself. I live downtown in the city. I'm going to help my father-in-law cut some wood for himself and for a few of his friends. They have a huge lot with three massive fields, thick bush, and wildlife galore. I just love it out there.

It has been a little bit warmer here lately too... the snow's starting to melt and the slush sucks.

I can't wait to get out of the Urban setting. It's been a couple of months since I've been out to the bush...

...oh yeah...sorry Jay! uhh...good site - keep up the good work. :)

Chris

by house

That link was posted a little while back. Where were you? You're fired.

http://tinyurl.com/4pc32

Max gave it to us with thanks to TheChas, and I posted it elsewhere under one of apotheon's comments here at TRI when he showed up.

by apotheon

"I am perfectly aware of everything you just said. Just taking a jab at your undying love for the Debian distribution.": That's what I figured. Heh.

Feel free to look me up if you want someone with which to commiserate about all things Linuxy. In the meantime, if you haven't already, I recommend signing up to a LUG mailing list if you're going to be working with Linux at all. That is seriously the best tech support resource I've ever seen: LUG mailing lists. InfoWorld even once rated the Linux community as the best tech support "organization" of the year, despite the fact that it's largely more of a DISorganization.

"On that note, I am interested to know if you have any publishers/writers that you could recommend on the subject.": It depends on the specific subject you're talking about, of course.

For Linux in general, it has been my experience that books about Linux in the generic tend to be much more useful than those that focus on a particular distribution, particularly if they purport to be about Linux administration and the like. Unfortunately, it always seems like no matter how many Linux books you've got on a shelf, the one that has the answer you need to a particular problem at any given moment is a book you don't own.

You can find any information you need, generally, somewhere between documentation on the system, various resources online, and a LUG or two. O'Reilly publishes a great many very good books, but I have yet to find a Linux book from O'Reilly that I bothered to shell out any money on, with the exception of one pocket guide. Mostly, O'Reilly seems to be useful for programming references. The O'Reilly _Linux_In_A_Nutshell_ reference, though, is useful. I've been borrowing a copy for close to a year now.

For LUGs in your area, check out this URL:
http://www.linux.org/groups/

"PS - You really are quick to defend yourself.": Nah, I'm just a windbag. Minor points of defensiveness serve as ready excuses to pontificate.

by apotheon

By the way, that's a "secret" link that we're not supposed to pass on to the hoi polloi, I think. It seems that they use a display-time search script to generate that result, which puts a bit of a load on the servers. As such, the general public should not be made aware of its existence, considering the way the servers already labor pretty heavily during peak hours.

by Jay Garmon

While sMoRty continues our healthy debate about whether Tech Q&A and Discussions need to be unified, let's proceed right now from the assumption that a distinct Tech Q&A will survive.

We continue to discuss "regulations," if you will, that will force participants in the Tech Q&A "economy" to behave appropriately. As with any regulated economy, excessive oversight risks strangling the market. If we place too many rules on Tech Q&A, no one will want to participate, especially the new users we need to grow the site. This is the "administrative burden" that rightfully concerns sMoRTy.

So, let's conjure up a little Adam Smith, and make a case for more market transparency, not more market regulation. What if we started tracking stats on how often unique users close questions, how often they reject vs. accept answers, how often they post closing comments, how generous they are with techpoints, and how long they leave questions open and idle. Condense these stats, and place key indicators on their Tech Q&A signatures, like we do with the meter in the discussion area.

If you are a persistent offender in Tech Q&A, these indicators will call you out, and the community can self-police by simply refusing to answer an "unfriendly" user's question. Conversely, if you act positively--awarding points and posting back--there will an incentive for others to answer your questions. By becoming more transparent, the market will be able to sort itself out.

Just an alternate idea.

--Jay

by apotheon

I love you! Holy cow. Yes. A libertarian approach to T Q & A!

Hmm. Is "Jay" short for something feminine? I could definitely go for a wife that thinks like you do.

Heck, things are changing in this country. Maybe it doesn't matter WHAT your gender is.

/joke

Seriously, though, I quite like your idea for how to approach it (even discounting the fact that some of it echoes other comments I've made). Even my suggestion for requiring comments with rejections was an attempt at increasing process transparency, though in retrospect I see that it was a little wrong-headed. Your approach is by far superior.

Let's go with that. I declare it The Best Option (so far). Since my main superpower is Being Right, this means that all should heed your words.

by oz_media

I remember Jay posting about the secret link but never knew it had been given. I expected it to show up in the regular Tech Q&A page, the same way they conceal the Insiders forum.

Thanks! Kinda foils my fun though, ]:) oh well.

by oz_media

Not that I am surprised that you had a good idea of course, but I hadn't thought of some form of duplicate meter to show who is even worth helping in the first place. I know that you can view people's stats and see their Q&A activity but it is quite misleading.

When someone shows as having 500+ questions rejected, it looks pretty bad but many times it is due to a poor sport on the other end.

Tracking the people's activity similar to the current meter would be interesting, if it could be intergrated or even done as a separate meter.

Perhaps two meters, smaller and one on top of the other. A Discussion activity meter and a Tech Q&A meter?

by house

That is a great idea for sure. I think that you've found a great way to cover the entire spectrum. Three levels of participation... contributions to the Q&A, common courtesy regarding reactions to input from the other techs, and discussion participation.

The main question is...do we want two seperate stat meters? - one for discussions and one for Q&A - or do we want a general "three bar" signature that will appear on both?

PS - When do our 'action figures' come out? And what about the trading cards? I think Todd McFarlane could design some pretty wicked "Psycho-Techs". :)

by apotheon

Ooooooh, the meter all fits on one line for me now. Good work, guys! Thanks for the effort.

This discussion is closed to new replies.