Discussion Locked

The REAL impact of product activation...

0 helpful
7 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We've heard that product activation for Office and Windows XP is non-intrusive. We've heard that it won't stop you upgrading your PC. Now we discover the truth:
The following has been reported to hardocp by Jason Bellifemini:
"Anyhow I reinstalled my system 2 days ago and put back on XP.... then today I decided to throw my 40 gig HD from my server in here.. so I can take my 2 30's for my new server raid motherboard.... so ALL I changed was the hard drive... and I get this message saying this product has already been activated and I have to call them now!!! Oh and yeah I have a legit copy that I paid for!!"
So now we know. One component changed and the machine reinstalled, and all of a sudden it's "illegal". Anyone else want to revise their opinion of this joyous new technology?

7 replies

by generalist

The 'product activation' problem is standard operating procedure for a lot of software run on minis and mainframes. Your site license is based on certain hardware configurations so you have to call the vendor when you go outside those boundaries.
Usually it just takes a short phone call to get everything up and running. Of course you're paying tens of thousands of dollars in maintenance for the packages and you're running on machines that aren't often upgraded.

At the same time these machines and software packages are usually very stable and can handle millions of transactions without breaking into a sweat. You rarely have to worry about the 'blue screen of death' and you can count on the fact that things usually work.

If Microsoft wants to emulate the mini and mainframe with their 'product activation' scheme, then they had better consider that they are dealing with a different environment for a critical chunk of the users. Those people who are most likely to reconfigure their PCs are often those that ultimately advise their superiors on what software works best.

PCs may touch on the mini and mainframe worlds, but they are a different breed of animal.

by epepke

This is one of the reasons that micros have displaced minis and mainframes in many areas, because heretofore they have been relatively free of this sort of nonsense.

The reconfigurers provide room for hope. If they become annoyed with Microsoft to the extent that they advise their clients not to go along, Microsoft may feel it. Unfortunately, there's an easy way for Microsoft to defeat this, but I'm not going to mention it because I don't want to give them ideas.

by pxttocyob

And what about all those people in Latin America who will have to spend time (money) waiting for little nonsense problems like this so they can get on with their business. These delays will not make them happy.

by timmitchell

I HAVE read what Microsoft says about product activation. However, if I were to believe everything that comes from the MS press office, I'd be living in my own little world:
--> I'd believe that IIS is the most secure and stable internet server app on the market.
--> I'd believe that Microsoft will not share my personal data when I use the Microsoft Passport in Windows XP.
--> I'd swear that General Protection Faults/Kernel Page Faults/BSOD's, etc., are caused by a badly written app and NEVER by a badly written OS.
--> I would buy Windows 2000, knowing that it would easily run on my Pentium 133 with 64 mb of RAM. I would also rest assured that, when it's finally released, I can run Windows XP on my PII-350 with 128mb of RAM.
--> I would trust Internet Explorer to act as a server. (Download Zone Alarm and see if it doesn't!)
--> I would never use an open-source product, because I can trust Microsoft when they tell me that open source is "potentially viral".
--> I would believe that Microsoft does not hold a monopoly in the software market; rather, they are just a hard-working company that serves their customers well and tries to provide the best products and services on the market.

Of course, I do have some grasp of reality so I do not believe any of the above. The point is, don't take MS at their word; listen to the users who are ALREADY struggling to live with the product activation feature. Microsoft assumes all of us to be thieves, and are trying to force sanctions on the masses for sins of a few. Lastly: When I go to Wal-Mart or 7-11, I see signs indicating that surveillance cameras, undercover police officers, and other countermeasures may be used to deter theft; this is done to to keep our prices low. Hey Bill, if you're doing this nonsense as a favor to the consumer, should we expect that the next batch of Microsoft products will cost the same as the last? Doubtful!!!

by nichomach

...and I note with interest that MS have ALREADY been forced to modify product activation because of the svere inconvenience that it's causing beta testers. In other words:
1) The evidence is that it does not work as described; and
2) Even the described behaviour is causing significant difficulties.

This discussion is closed to new replies.