Discussion Locked

The religious fist stops where the legal face begins

0 helpful
62 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This part of a discussion recently started by Stargazerr which referred dealing with foreign religious customs within our own countries. I would like to focus on this aspect and hear what people have to say.

I?ll begin, the title I have chosen sum?s up what I think. The religious fist stops where the legal face begins. I firmly believe that you have the right to practice your religion be it Christianity, Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, Satanism, Paganism, Maxwell Edisonism or whatever you believe [b]up until the point you break the law[/b]. At this point I would like to point out that I am talking about [b]our[/b] countries and [b]our[/b] laws (US, Australia, UK specifically but anyone is welcome to join in). After the point you have broken a law religion should have no bearing what so ever. The old saying ?if you do the crime you do the time? the defence that it was part of your religion to steal, rape or murder is no defence at all (yes I am talking about Islam here) in my mind. By the same token hate criminals should be treated more harshly by the law, White supremacists and extremist Imans are two types of people I?d like to get out of my nation. A nation that has truely and completly separated church and state should be able to implement both of these ideas without stepping on anyone?s toes, can we find nations like this?

Look forward to reading your opinions after the weekend (sunday for you yanks, you're back about 16 hours from here)

62 replies

by jamesrl

If we abandon the rule of law, we abandon the hope of living together in peace.

If you emigrate from a country with one perspective on criminal laws to another one, you need to make your decision understanding the implications. While you may seek to change the laws of your new home, as is your right in a democratic system, you must respect the laws that are in place, unless they contravene inalienable rights (ask Maxwell).

I would question your persception of Islamic law. In most situations, Islamic law is harsher than "western" countries laws. It wasn't that long ago that they used to cut of the hands of a theif in Saudi, they still treat drug dealers extremely harshly in Islamic countries. Your chances of getting a fair trial there are less than here. Now this is not to say I agree with all Islamic laws - many Islamic states still treat women as second class citizens and as a consequence rape is nto prosecuted as it is here.

James

by mjwx

is harsher than western law. I was reffering to Islamic (or any other religion) abiding by western law (in western countries).

Didn't mean to give you the wrong impression.

by mickster269

What about the Native American Indians? Some of them practice a relgion/lifestyle that requires somking Peyote. Is that an exception?

What about religious practices that require the sacrifice of animals?

There are certain religious "practices" that are illegal for most, but allowed for some. Where and when do you draw the line?

It's not as easy to say "A nation that has truely and completly separated church and state should be able to implement both of these ideas without stepping on anyone?s toes...". The last one that supposedly was able to do that was the U.S.S.R. China isn't having a whole lot of luck there.

Now, I do agree that in principle, the State and the Church(es) should be totally seperate. But it's not a one way street. If you keep religion out of the state, then you also must keep the state out of religion.

In summation, one man's Religious Practice is another man's Violation of the Law.

by absolutely

I don't know if it is still in effect, but there was an organized Native movement of peyote users who had their religious custom recognized under law as a right, when used [b]ceremonially[/b].

by deepsand

The core principle of any functional governing body is that it must provide for the general welfare of the governed such that the sovereign survives.

The express purpose of, for example, a constitution is to try to best insure that peoples of disparate beliefs co-exist with the least amount of conflict.

This demands that the power of the sovereign be superior to that of any and all particular beliefs, including those of religion.

by jdmercha

Some examples of religeous extremsits are easy to condemn, such as genocide or suicide bombings. But the line gets a lot grayer with religious issues such as abortion, assisted suicide and refusal of medical care.

All of these examples may result in the loss of an innocent life. I agree that the law of the land should take precidence over the law of religion. But what if the law of the land is wrong? If your religion forbids you to have a blood transfusion then that should be your choice to refuse it. But when your six-year-old needs a transfusion and does not have the capacity to make the choice, should the parents be allowed to refuse a transfusion? Doesn't this result in the death of an innocent child, just like a suicide bomb would?

by deepsand

The laws of the land do [b]not[/b] allow for the withholding of necessary medical treatments to insure the life of a minor, even though the parents or guardians religious beliefs may hold otherwise.

So, how is the law of the land here wrong?

by jdmercha

Actually I don't have an answer. I am undecided as to wether or not a parent should be able to refuse medical treatment for their child based on religious beliefs. As I am not in a position where I have to make such a choice, I choice not to stand one way or the other.

I do however think that an individual has the right to refuse medical treatment for themselves.

by absolutely

If a person's beliefs (religious or atheist) conflict with law, they [b]know[/b] they have the option of conforming to the law, or risk suffering the consequences. If one's convictions are strong enough to violate the law, they ought to be strong enough to endure the legal consequences. If not, it's irrational to take seriously any claim that violating the law was based on any "higher" moral belief. King and Mandela did their time peacefully for their beliefs. Everybody who claims the right to violate the law and not serve time is a hypocrite.

by nicknielsen

If I remember my comparative religion classes correctly, the primary tenet of the world's four most influential religions (Judaism, Christianity, Islam, & Buddhism) is essentially to love thy neighbor as thyself. Religious leaders through the centuries must truly have hated themselves, Christianity in particular having been nothing if not brutal in the name of God. Study the history of the Crusades and the Inquisition sometime.

The problem is that too many Americans have lost sight of the fact that while they have the right to believe and worship as they wish, they do not have the right to infringe on the rights of others. In other words, we Americans have forgotten that our rights come with responsibilities.

by deepsand

They also have, for the most part, forgotten that many of the original colonies were founded by those seeking to flee religious [i]intolerance[/i] in Europe!

And, perhaps most importantly, they have re-written the so called Golden Rule. It's original and only logical form is "Do [b]not[/b] unto others as you would have them [b]not[/b] do unto you."

by Member 25348569

One little point of history, Sandy.

There is a myth over where you are that the Pilgrim Fathers fled England to escape religious intolerance. If you check the history that [b]we[/b] have then you find out that the intolerant ones were the Pilgrim Fathers. Generally, the English Government and its agents of the time only persecuted Catholics and those Protestants who [b]really[/b] stepped out of line.

Looking a little more into it it, you find that they were just a mob of unruly country-bumpkin parishoners (from Lincolnshire - US equivalent maybe Arkansas) who went against the teachings of the Church at the time and then tried to sneak out of the country when the established Church got a bit pissed with their activities. As leaving the country without a license was illegal, they all got put in the cells for a month and their belongings confiscated to pay the fines.

When they were kicked out of jail the authorities turned a blind eye and let them "escape" to Holland. (Good riddance!) They met up there with some like-minded puritans from the London borough of Southwark - a sect called the "Brownists". Then, Holland was no good because they were "evil", too. They cames back to England where some of the Brownists were executed. Finally they decided to go to Virginia, got permission (this time!) and the rest is History - though probably not at all factual. They missed Virginia and ended up in Massachusetts where they carried on arguing about - and with - anything.

Doesn't really sound like persecution to me. Seems to me like they got quite a good deal considering that they rebelled against the teachings of the established Christian Church. Most heretics against Christianity used to get burned alive! Still, it's your history and, just like religion, you can believe what you want.

I think you'll find that most of [b]our[/b] colonies were founded to make money. That's what we've always done.

Neil :D

by oldmaven

Great clarification. Even better than Shaw's take:

"Do not do unto others as they would have them do unto you. Their tastes may not be the same."

by mjwx

As a quick way of getting my point across. Churches should have to abide by law, without law (which in western countries is made by the people) there is anarchy.

by oneamazingwriter

I have been following this discussion and reading it more than once. The respect that I see flowing among you is really wonderful.

by deepsand

Did I say "persecution?" I thought I said "intolerance."

And, yes, they did get a good deal.

The bastards ran away because they did'nt like being told what was and was not acceptable behavior, so that they could inflict the same treatment on others.

A bunch of damned hypocrites!

by Member 25348569

You even put it in italics...

Alas, knee-jerk standard Neilb aggressive response to mention of Pilgrim Fathers by US poster.

Teach me to read, won't it? Maybe...

:D

by deepsand

Particularly for the sanctimonious who persist in perpetrating the myth that ours was founded as a "Christian" nation.

Of course, they're not likely to give any credence to it.

by deepsand

Should that perhaps be "Do not do unto others as [b]you[/b] would have them do unto you. Their tastes may not be the same."

It's amazing how many people quote the Golden Rule incorrectly, without even [b]thinking[/b] about what they're saying.

Let's see now - I'm a masochist; I like to be beaten; ergo, the Golden Rule instructs me to beat others. But, wait, wouldn't that make me a sadist? But, I'm a masochist, which means ...

Danger, danger, that does not compute, overload iminent, danger, ...

by wire

I personally think that ALL religions (and also politics) is for WEAK peoples which need "protection" from "goods" to give excuses for their weak lives

by deepsand

"religions ... [b]is[/b]" - try [b]are[/b]

"weak people[b]s[/b]" - how about [b]people[/b]

"peoples [b]which[/b] need" - definitely [b]who[/b]

"protection from [b]goods[/b] - yeah, we all need that, but I'll bet that here it should be [b]gods[/b]

"to give excuses for" - I've done my part; you're the multimedia deveploper, figure it out for yourself.

P.S. You can stick your fairfrugal where the sun don't shine. On second thought, that may not work, as how can the sun miss such a large one as yourself?

by deepsand

Is it that you prefer to prey on the "weak?"

Or, are you merely yet one more hypocrite?

by deepsand

You should apologize to the people of Poland for your thoughtless stupidity.

Domain Name: FAIRFRUGAL.COM
Registrar: TUCOWS INC.
Whois Server: whois.opensrs.net
Referral URL: http://domainhelp.tucows.com
Name Server: DNS3.HOME.PL
Name Server: DNS.HOME.PL
Name Server: DNS2.HOME.PL
Status: REGISTRAR-LOCK
EPP Status: clientDeleteProhibited
EPP Status: clientTransferProhibited
EPP Status: clientUpdateProhibited
Updated Date: 07-Apr-2006
Creation Date: 10-Mar-2006
Expiration Date: 10-Mar-2007

Current Registrar: TUCOWS INC.
IP Address: 212.85.96.95 (ARIN & RIPE IP search)
IP Location: PL(POLAND)
Lock Status: REGISTRAR-LOCK
DMOZ no listings
Y! Directory: see listings
Data as of: 14-Jun-2005

by deepsand

"Grups" lose their sense of wonder, not to mention that of humor.

I'm fast approaching 60, and doing everything that I can to remain a child in spirit.

As for "cool," I suspect that that is a quality best displayed by not being a fool.

A quote that seems appropriate, attributed variously to either Mark Twain or Abraham Lincoln, is "Better to remain silent, and be thought the fool, than to speak and remove all doubt."

by nicknielsen

"Wise men talk because they have something to say; fools, because they have to say something."

My problem is that I am unable to tell whether I have something to say or have to say something.

by deepsand

Besides, your post reminds us that the problems of our era are not much different in kind than those of times long past.

by jdclyde

There was once a time when you moved to another country and became a citizen of the country.

This meant that you learned the language of the land, as well as respect and obey the laws of the land.

If you move to a country that has laws you can not abide by, then it would be a good idea not to move to that country.

Someone even mentioned animal sacrifice. It is my understanding that in the US it is NEVER allowed, even if for a "religious" reason.

Under the same token, we do not ALLOW cock fights, nor dog fights. That does not mean some dumb hick somewhere isn't doing it illegally, it just means they need to HIDE this behavior because it has been deemed unacceptable.

I disagree with the entire premiss of "Hate Crimes. It is NOT a worse crime to kill someone because of religion or ethnicity, than because you want their shoes or watch.

Extremists should not be condoned, and (as the government does not) they should be watched closely and smacked down hard everytime they get out of line.

by tig2

It has long been my impression that we have given over the concept of American, preferring to "celebrate diversity". Somehow we got away from the idea that it is really okay to set rules in place and manage to them. How this happened, I don't know. I get the sense that it might have been a result of more Liberal thinking than I generally entertain.

Your thinking, my friend, is way out of date. Join the club- my thinking is just as out of date. The country in general is so afraid of being perceived as intolerant that we no longer tell newcomers, "These are the rules- DON'T break them". Instead there is a lot of bending over backward to "understand the cultural differences".

My question, is "Why isn't celebrating my Americanism just as important as celebrating diversity?"

by jdclyde

The liberal movement is like a cancer that needs to be cut out before it destroys the whole country, let alone the world.

Nothing but disgust for that whole intentional attack on values and OUR traditions, while holding everyone elses up on high.

I AM intolerant of people that come here with no respect for us, yet somehow expect for us to respect them. If your on vacation and can't speak the language, cut them all the slack in the if they at least try. You live here? The language is english.

Answer to your question. The liberals that are undermining America HATE America and are ashamed of being an American.

by deepsand

It existed in my parents' time, and in my grand-parents' as well. This, from their own lips.

And, a brief reading of history will show that it is as old as the records of mankind himself.

by mjwx

Here in Australia, for breaking it you get a fine and are barred from keeping animals either as livestock or pets.

Hate Crimes are different from ordinary crimes as one who commits a crime for money is less likely to kill than one who commits a crime out of belief. Hate crimes are more likely to spread than crimes of necessity/greed (mugging and murdering for money) or crimes of insanity (think Ed Gain or David Berkowitz). On some level even Berkowitz knew what he was doing was wrong and later even admitted it, when one commits a hate crime (especially a religious hate crime) one is reassured that it is the right thing to do (often my like minded individuals, think KKK).

I do agree on the premise of "A murder is a murder is a murder regardless of motive" and should all should be punished accordingly, but my point is with hate crimes that one murder could easily become 10 or 100 murders if the murderer(s) thinks he/they are right and additional punishment should be placed on top of the original punishment to discourage any similar crimes. It's not about punishing the original crime but stopping others before they happen.

To the Melting Pot, A people can integrate into society and maintain an identity. Take the Australian Greeks for example, these people interact seamlessly with English descended society but you can always tell when a Greek owns a house (concrete as far as the eye can see). In my reckoning a multi-cultural society is a two way street, one gets the same amount of respect as one gives (in the case of Islam, we have given ample respect now they must reciprocate).

by deepsand

is not borne out by statistics on recidivism rates.

While you may be correct with respect to the person who is [/b]not yet caught and punished[/b], it does not logically follow that such holds true for one who has been.

Therefore, to predicate punishment on such premise is without a logical foundation.

by deepsand

I quite agree with your position re. "Hate Crimes."

The very concept implies that it is [i]more[/i] acceptable to deprive one of his rights, without benefit of law, when done for certain reasons than it is for others.

And, by extension, it would therefore be acceptable to punish peoples based on what they've thought about doing, rather than on the basis of their actions.

by deepsand

The law, in this country, does[b]not[/b] allow a minor to make such a decision.

Not does it allow an adult to deprive a minor of treatment required to sustain their live solely on religious grounds.

The guiding principle here is that one whose has the legal capacity to make contractually binding decisions for himself is free to do so for himself, but is constrained with regards to making such decisions for others.

by mjwx

When hate is a [b]clear[/b] motive. For example someone who hands out racist or anti-religious propaganda.

I think "thoughts of hate" is not a good description. A hate crime can only be described as such when, there is physical evidence indicating such (see example above) or when a criminal wilfully admits hateful (such as racial or anti-Semitic) intent in a court of law before a jury of their peers.

Most violent crimes involve a measure of hate. for the most part this is directed towards individuals or society in general (in the case of truly psychotic individuals it is fair to say that it may not be directed at all). A crime which is directed at a section of society (blacks, Jews, Asians) is a clear indication of a hateful motive (as long as there is clear evidence supporting this motive, which as I understand it clear evidence of motive is key in convicting someone anyway).

I would bring up people like Jack Van Tongeren in Australia who was convicted of firebombing several Chinese restraints as someone who would fit this bill. An organisation like the KKK would be a prime example of the kind of people a "Hate Crime" law would punish.

by deepsand

Regardless of how the motive is described, absent a true mental illness, there is no basis in fact for the premise that those who commit "hate crimes" are more likely to be repeat offenders than are others, and therefore require harsher punishment as a deterrent against future offenses.

by mjwx

Prevention of copy cat crimes, Hate criminals typically have very powerful personalities. The easily influenced among will be very tempted to go along. Take post WWI Germany, the Versailles treaty bankrupted Germany, bread was 5 marks a loaf and the people were looking for someone to blame. Hitler popped up and said lets blame the Jews and the people followed because he promised that with fewer Jews there would be cheaper bread.

An anti-sematic person with a personality like Charles Manson, how many people would follow him like sheep. The general populus is very easily influenced.

Abs, Indeed power corrupts I wont argue the point. But I still think that hate criminals are the worst kind. It is also the responsibility of the people to ensure that their governance is in accord with their wishes, every now and then the pollies need to be reminded whom they serve.

by absolutely

I believe that hate crime laws are supported, frequently, with the argument that hate crimes are attempts to intimidate, in addition to the particular violent act. I'd like that assertion to be supported, explicitly, in court, by prosecuting the next hate crime as one or more of the other existing laws that prohibit intimidation.

by deepsand

That you continue to stretch further and further from your originally stated premise as to why "hate crimes" [i]require[/i] harsher punishment toward one in which they [i]deserve[/i] such is an indication that your position is one born of emotion rather than logic.

Do understand that I do not condemn such feelings, as it is our lot that we are 1st and foremost irrational beings. However, I must point out that your feelings regarding "hate crimes" are in principal not unlike the feelings of hatred that you detest.

In summation, while your feelings of revulsion are no doubt genuine, & not unjustified, the conclusion that crimes committed out of a motive of "hate" demand harsher punishment lacks a basis in fact.

May the future be kind.

by deepsand

hate crime?

While I take no issue with your view as to how some may view such, it is obviously a rationalization on their part.

It's not unlike the debate over the applicability of the RICO laws.

Who gets to define "hate" or "organized crime?" Given the choice, how many would render definitions that just might someday include themselves? How many would even consider the possibility?

by mjwx

We, humans are emotional and irrational beings. My concern is how this can be prayed upon by someone with a bad agenda.

I believe hate will spread amongst a population like a virus if left unchecked. I view it as trying to stop a potential problem before it begins, to nip it in the bud.

We have varying degrees of crimes, Assault, violent assault, assault with a weapon, assault with intent to harm (premeditated). Also with murder, voluntary manslaughter, involuntary manslaughter, premeditated murder. Courts often make adjustments to punishments for "crimes of passion", what I would propose is that to someone who believes themselves right to commit crimes because of prejudice should be punished more harshly (by a jury of peers I do believe in a modern democratic legal system) and of course given every benefit of the legal system such as the right to appeal. A hate criminal will generally show himself as such, a person whom I would describe as a hate criminal in my experience makes no attempt to hide their prejudice.

On A side note, DS I respect your views and thank you for trying to point out the flaws in my arguments (it's the best way to perfect them) although you have not dissuaded me and would like you to know I am not so arrogant that I cant see past my own bias.

by mjwx

a regular crime and an organised crime. Organised criminals are generally guaranteed a hasher penalty in order to get them to trade information for leniency.

With harsher penalties for hate crimes I know that the chances of persuade the criminal himself that he is wrong but to dissuade others who are likeminded but not as dedicated yet.

You will have to forgive me for trying to drive this point home but as DS pointed out this is something I believe passionately.

by absolutely

that the purpose of hate crimes is the same as the mechanism of protection rackets: intimidation. Both are forms of threatening communication, not protected under free speech, and prohibited by numerous laws. Adding another law, to me, diminishes the seriousness of "hate crimes" by implying that they are "special treatment" because they are distinct from acts of intimidation that are already illegal. Attempts to intimidate were illegal before "hate crime" laws. If prosecutors had done their jobs conscientiously, the crimes we now call "hate crimes" would always have been prosecuted as cases of intimidation and terrorism, and there would be no need for separate, unequal, "hate crime" laws.

by deepsand

without needing to resort to special punishments.

Hatred is as old as any other emotion, and has never come close to destroying civilization.

I understand you feelings, and make no attempt to diminish their importance. I do, however, believe that your fears regarding acts of individuals are not justified by the facts.

Now, acts of hatred carried out by groups, and on a large enough scale, are quite a different matter.

by deepsand

Hatred is but an emotion, and not a unique one at that.

Like all emotions, it can be felt over a wide range of intensities; and, given a sufficiently strong intensity, it will drive one to action, just as all emotions will.

It is the nature of man that any sufficiently stong emotion will cause us to act in a manner that we know is neither logical nor necessarily in our best interest; and yet, we find ourselves acting on that emotion.

This has been the central theme of many a novel, play, movie, etc.. Witness the characters of Capt. Kirj and Spock in the original Star Trek series.

You can legislate against "hate" all you like, but to no avail.

by deepsand

If it can be proved that the crime was commited with the [i]intent[/i] to intimidate, then I agree.

If it your position that all so-called "hate crimes" should be defined at law as being deemed to carry such intent, then I dissent.

by mjwx

Is to dissaude those who arent as dedicated from commiting a crime they know is wrong. An organisation like the KKK should be illegal and in australia they are (I think, the law gets a little fuzzy around this part) because they want violent acts commited against blacks. I want to stop the anyone who would potentially comit this crime on the advice of another.

"I do this without being commanded what others do only through fear of the law"
Not many people think like this.

by mjwx

I should have used discrimination. Just to help clarify myself a bit.

by deepsand

"[i]I do this without being commanded what others do only through fear of the law[/i]"

This is an admirable position, and would so be for all who adopted it. Unfortunately, even fear itself is oft times insufficient to compel charitable behavior.

My the futre be kind.

by absolutely

[i]If it can be proved that the crime was commited with the intent to intimidate, then I agree.

If it your position that all so-called "hate crimes" should be defined at law as being deemed to carry such intent, then I dissent.[/i]

I should have further qualified my own statement. I disagree with all attempts to punish intent, or to alter punishment based on intent. As an Objectivist, all that may be justly judged is objective, which excludes intent.

by absolutely

The power to prohibit the existence of any organization, for any reason, is too similar to the power to punish people for the act of existing while black, which is a de facto privilege of many people, in many otherwise "civilized" nations. I simply don't trust my neighbors enough to make such decisions on behalf of all.

by deepsand

Well, now I'm confused.

You stated "that [i]the [b]purpose[/b] of hate crimes[/i] is the same as the mechanism of protection rackets ..."

Since [i]purpose[/i] and [i]intent[/i] are synonymous (see definition of [i]goal[/i] & synonyms at bottom), there appears to be a contradiction here.

Furthermore, [i]intent[/i] is pivotal in determining whether an act was deliberate or accidental, and the degree of seriousness of a deliberate one.

It also plays an important role as a mitigating factor in the event of a conviction.

Kindly clarify.

--------------------------------------------------

Entry Word: goal

Function: noun

Text: something that one hopes or intends to accomplish

Synonyms aim, ambition, aspiration, design, dream, end, [b]intent[/b], intention, mark, meaning, object, objective, plan, pretension, [b]purpose[/b], target, thing

by absolutely

Sometimes the intent to intimidate is communicated. Sometimes, that communication is accompanied by an [b]act[/b] of violence. In these cases, it should be possible to prosecute both the illegal, intimidating speech and the illegal violent act, both without the additional variety of crime known as "hate crimes".

The existence of separate laws that protect minority groups stinks, to me, of the same viewpoint that was rejected by the Supreme Court in Brown v. Board of Education. All individuals are to be protected equally by laws prohibiting intimidation & violence. When that is not the case in practice, the proper solution is to address the improper law enforcement and/or interpretation, not to create new laws, and not to provide protection for certain arbitrarily defined groups of humans by "separate but equal" laws!

by deepsand

between "hate crimes" where the intent of the act itself is to intimidate those other than the immediate victim, and those where the intent is solely to harm said victim?

This discussion is closed to new replies.