Discussion Locked

The secret of the Universe - the "void", measuring infinity

0 helpful
66 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Researchers who have spent years analyzing data from the LEP accelerator at the CERN nuclear physics lab near Geneva, Switzerland say that the elusive Higgs boson, which is central to the theory on which physicists base their whole understanding of matter, does not exist. If there is no Higgs, they are totally unable to explain mass.
The current model of the universe says that a collection of fundamental particles make up matter, including muons, electrons, neutrinos and quarks. In the 1960s, researchers successfully worked out how these particles interact and bind with each other using strong and weak nuclear forces.
But that doesn?t explain why the particles also have mass. Then Peter Higgs of Edinburgh University suggested that space is filled with a heavy substance, now called the Higgs field, which gives particles their mass by dragging on them through a particle called the Higgs boson.
Thus began the 30-year quest to find the God particle. From interactions between other particles that we know exist, physicists calculated that the Higgs is most likely to have a mass (or energy) of around 80 gigaelectronvolts (GeV). If particle accelerators could smash particles together at that energy or higher, it would be possible to make one. This is what members of the Electroweak Working Group at CERN have been doing for the 5 years until LEP (the Large Electron Positron Collider) closed down last year. Since then they?ve been searching through the data they gathered, and they?ve found no sign of the Higgs boson. ?It?s more likely than not that there is no Higgs,? says group member John Swain of Northeastern University in Boston.
Last year researchers from another group at LEP claimed they had found the Higgs. Their announcement came shortly before LEP was due to close, and it got them one month?s extra time on LEP. But they later admitted their calculations were wrong.
Now their calculations have been reworked, and members of the Electroweak Working Group say there is no sign of the Higgs. Its existence is looking ?less and less likely,? says Steve Reucroft, also of Northeastern University. ?We?ve eliminated most of the hunting area,? adds Neil Calder of CERN.
Frank Wilczek, a particle physics theorist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, believes that the Higgs can be found only at an improbably high energy level. He says he?ll stop believing in the Higgs if it doesn?t show up by about 130 GeV. ?Then I would have a good long think,? he says.
Swain says he doesn?t think the Higgs exists. But he still thinks it?s important for CERN to build its Large Hadron Collider, which is scheduled to start smashing particles at even higher energies in 2007. ?It?s not until you've ruled out more than 99 per cent of values that everyone will be convinced,? he says.
The problem for physicists is that without the Higgs particle they don?t have a viable theory of matter. ?There is nothing remotely as plausible or compelling to replace it,? says Wilczek.
For physicists who have spent years trying to find the Higgs, admitting it may not exist is hard. But Swain is ready to move on and says, ?You search for the truth, and the truth is whatever it is.?

Here is an except from a near death experience
Mellen-Thomas Benedict's - about this subject --- is this what they are looking for??

Mr. Benedict has been closely involved in the mechanics of cellular communication and research dealing with the relationship of light to life called Quantum Biology.

http://www.near-death.com/experiences/reincarnation04.html

When I say that I could see or perceive forever, I mean that I could experience all of creation generating itself. It was without beginning and without end. That's a mind-expanding thought, isn't it? Scientists perceive the Big Bang as a single event which created the universe. I saw that the Big Bang is only one of an infinite number of Big Bangs creating universes endlessly and simultaneously. The only images that even come close in human terms would be those created by supercomputers using fractal geometry equations.
Where is the void? I know. The void is inside and outside everything. You, right now even while you live, are always inside and outside the void simultaneously. You don't have to go anywhere or die to get there. The void is the vacuum or nothingness between all physical manifestations. The SPACE between atoms and their components. Modern science has begun to study this space between everything. They call it zero-point. Whenever they try to measure it, their instruments go off the scale, or to infinity, so to speak. They have no way, as of yet, to measure infinity accurately. There is more of the zero space in your own body and the universe than anything else!

more at

http://www.near-death.com/

66 replies

by Member 25348569

There's no reason to get all metaphysical and MrMiami-like!

In the Standard Model the Higgs boson mass is correlated with top quark mass. The top quark (aka Truth quark) mass is being revised upwards with each experiment and is currently moving towards 130GeV wich is well beyond anything but CERN's Large Hadron Collider which isn't finished yet (due 2007). A couple more years and we'll either have the Higgs from LHC or not.

Chill out - we'll all get excited at around 150GeV if we haven't found it by then.

Neil

by black panther

They have been working on this already over 10 years

The search has been on for over ten years, both at CERN's Large Electron Positron Collider (LEP) in Geneva and at Fermilab in Illinois.

What makes you think they will have a 'definite' answer in 2 more? The Higgs Bosun is but just an 'idea' !

by deepsand

To say the the Higg's Boson is "just" an idea either assumes facts not in evidence, or, mistakes absence of proof for proof of absence.

by Member 25348569

Current theory puts the Higgs Boson at well over 100GeV when derived from the Truth's current value. What I said was that we need to wait for CERN's new kit to get energies that high.

I didn't say that they WOULD get a definite answer, merely that they MIGHT and that now is not the time to abandon the search for something so crucial to the Standard Theory.

It's certainly not the time to go all metaphysical and start wittering on about near-death experiences!

by stress junkie

Understanding leading edge physics requires a gift for mathematics and many years of study. The subject is pretty much beyond the comprehension of mere mortals like us, at least at the level of the key contributors in this field.

If anyone would like to gain a basic understanding of the theories currently being studied in physics I would highly recommend the book "The Fabric of the Cosmos" by Brian Greene. (Copyright 2004, ISBN 0-375-41288-3, published by Alfred A. Knopf, a division of Random House Inc., www.aaknopf.com)

This book does a great job of explaining difficult concepts in a way that is easy for non-mathematics majors to understand. For instance, I finally now have a basic understanding of time dilation due to reading this book's chapter on Special Relativity. The concept of time dilation had completely escaped my grasp for decades before I read this book, and it's not like I hadn't given it a lot of thought. It just hadn't been explained well by other people.

Taking a couple of quotes from leading edge scientists may lead to misinterpretation of the intentions of the speakers. It is entirely possible that the quotes, if taken in context of the project, mean something entirely different than what we might understand them to mean. It is like when a television news show reports some breakthrough in medicine. They may make the new scientific finding sound like a cure is around the corner for whatever when, in fact, the breakthrough just means that a tiny advance in understanding has been gained.

So it's pretty pointless to discuss bosons and mesons on this forum. This community doesn't have the background to fully understand or to comment on a couple of quotes taken out of context.

by sleepin'dawg

I can think of at least two who could discuss this intelligently and no, I am not one of them.

Dawg ]:)

by black panther

You know more than you think!

Here are some interesting facts about (optics ) light:-

The human body stores immense amounts of light: The 100 trillion atoms in each of our 100 trillion cells together store at least 1028 photons. This is enough light to illuminate a baseball field for three hours with I million watts of floodlights.

Ultimately, through the process of photosynthesis by which the green leaves of plants utilize the energy of sunlight to create carbohydrates, a process that also releases oxygen, Father Sun, and the sunlight he so generously and unstintingly radiates in all directions, is the source, and the sine qua non, of all the food we eat and all the air we breathe on Mother Earth.

more at:-

http://www.hyattcarter.com/path_of_l_&_l.htm

:)

"Pure logical thinking cannot yield us any knowledge of the empirical world. All knowledge of reality starts from experience and ends in it." - Albert Einstein

:)

by tony hopkinson

and the much more readable Elegant universe before it. I personally wouldn't say that we can't understand, or that we shouldn't discuss it. I never 'got' the theory of relativity until I read the latter. I still don't get how we can come up with the many worlds theory, don't understand what the hell chirality is about, and don't for one moment believe some of the theoretical conclusions that quantum theory would have us draw. Some of that is probably down to my lack of understanding, but I firmly believe that some is down to the scientific community's dogmatic adhererence to the accepted paradigms.

by stress junkie

I haven't read The Elegant Universe yet. I had seen Brian Greene on television talking about The Fabric of the Cosmos. He thought that it was easier to read than Elegant Universe. So while I have struggled with Fabric of the Cosmos I haven't even looked at Elegant Universe.

I have seen the PBS series based on Elegant Unverse. It's really excellent.

As for whether this discussion is, in fact, pointless, I suppose that I will retract my position. While it is clear to me that new frontiers in mathematics and physics are not likely to be crossed here I suppose that if it gives people a sense of gratification then that is justification enough.

by deepsand

It's a trap that all too many fall easily into.

20 years ago I was in a situation where, as a consequence of my divorce coupled with the simultaneous default by my then most profitable client, I was forced to resort to debt financing using my credit cards and revolving lines of credit in order to continue to service my existing debt. As a stopgap, I also applied for certain government grant.

My application was initially denied, as the individual charged with vetting my application failed to grasp the concept of debt financing, and so insisted that I must have unreported income that I first needed to declare before he could determine my eligibility for said grant.

I had one hell of a time trying to get him to understand that one cannot prove a negative; I finally prevailed on appeal of his denial of my claim.

That the Higgs boson has yet to be found merely means that, if it exists, its properties are not quite as predicted. There is nothing unusual in this; in fact, it is quite the norm in the hard sciences.

by black panther

"Time and space are modes by which we think and not conditions in which we live." - Albert Einstein

"Pure logical thinking cannot yield us any knowledge of the empirical world. All knowledge of reality starts from experience and ends in it." - Albert Einstein

Dr Robert Jordan ( Scientist )

I think scientists, if we possess any sense of humility, must acknowledge that science cannot provide us with Ultimate Truth, only little hints of understanding about how the Universe operates. Scientists are appropriately taught that today's comprehensive theory is merely tomorrow's special case of an even more comprehensive theory.

by deepsand

See
[v]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=174725&messageID=1776033[/v]

by black panther

"Time and space are modes by which we think and not conditions in which we live." - Albert Einstein

"Pure logical thinking cannot yield us any knowledge of the empirical world. All knowledge of reality starts from experience and ends in it." - Albert Einstein

Dr Robert Jordan ( Scientist )

I think scientists, if we possess any sense of humility, must acknowledge that science cannot provide us with Ultimate Truth, only little hints of understanding about how the Universe operates. Scientists are appropriately taught that today's comprehensive theory is merely tomorrow's special case of an even more comprehensive theory.

by deepsand

It has been oft said that it is the journey that matters, not whether or not we reach the expected destination.

The journey here leads us to discover the Hows; that shall have to suffice for the moment.

by Member 25348569

What on Earth do I have to be "Uneasy" about?

You really need to address your priorities. I can assure you that they are not the same as mine!

Neil :)

by absolutely

Hopefully mist is way out of her league, but if EL is any indication, that will make her MORE talkative, not less.

Do you get the feeling that she's trying to blow you off when she says "cool"? Like, I don't know, maybe I'm waiting for her validation of my input, so all she needs to say is "that's cool"?

As if!

by Member 25348569

of particle physicists and other parties researching the Standard Theory say "Oh, sh:t. we've blown it. What the f*ck do we do NOW?"

That's not just yet so pretty damn simple, eh?

Neil

p.s. Watch the multiple punctuation. It's a recognised sign of a deranged mind. This subject isn't that important, you know. Not yet, anyways.

by absolutely

But in this case I must.

The search for a Grand Unified Theory of the four forces baffles me. There are four, which explain observed phenomena quite nicely. The "missing piece" of physical theory which "requires" this "god Particle" to unify the theory, is what happens at unusefully large energies. That is, unsurvivable for our entire planet, or possibly the solar system or more, if such energies are ever attained. What is the scientific necessity?

by absolutely

The most interesting thing on that page was the question "What is it about light that makes it the most enduring metaphor for the divine presence?" and its answer: because we gather the majority of our information about the world around us visually, and that information increases enormously under illumination. Habituation tends to counter the human proclivity for analysis, and since we have all been seeing since before we learned speech or the concepts that speech alone can introduce, the fact that light brings empowering knowledge in enormous abundance is largely unanalyzed, hence the perception of a "mystical" quality.

My optometrist had a poster claiming 80% or more of our information comes through our eyes. I've seen 70% elsewhere. The psychobabble is entirely my own invention, but I find it more likely than God.

by deepsand

For example, gravity still remains, for the most part, enigmatic & an understanding of it elusive.

We've yet to discover evidence of either gravity waves or gravitons (the particle that mediates the force), both of which are predicted by the General Theory of Relativety.

Discovering the Higg's boson would serve to validate the current Standard Model of Particles. Lacking such allows for the possibility that there are other flaws in the model.

Additionally, there remain the problems of dark matter, negative energy, the pre-ponderence of matter as compared to anti-matter, action at a distance, not to mention the apparent existence of, under certain conditions, the instantaneous conveyance of information between particles.

It would not be unexpected were we to learn that those particles which are currently considered to be the basc ones form which all others are constructed may in fact themselves be composites of even smaller ones.

by captg

Are quantum physicists of the world looking for God by banging particles together? Most of them probably wouldn't admit to it.
Ask them and, they'll tell you they're trying to figure out how the universe works, nothing more.
The search for understanding is the same whether you search in your own psyche or in the building blocks of matter. We just want to know why things happen the way they do, whether it's God exerting his will or a field effect from some exotic particle.

by deepsand

and is therefore [b]not[/b] amenable to being observed by the corporeal. Thus, it remains unknowable.

Therefore, I am an agnostic.

by black panther

Only unknowable by the definition as what you know as knowable :)

I hope that makes some type of sense! :)

Have you ever had any life experience / event / dream that may have had any tendancy for you to consider that there is some other dimension/s or spiritual world?

ie maybe Astral travel!

ie Dream of things / people you have never seen /met ( how do they get into our imagination? )

Do you believe we have a soul??

When we die, the brain dies, then was our universe we live in totally contained inside our memories or imagination?

by deepsand

Consider a series of seemingly separate states, each characterized by perceptions of different places, times & events.

How might we determine those which represent physical reality, as opposed to, for example, dreams? The answer is quite simple.

Those states which carry a memory of, i.e information about, previous states, so that such form a logically contiguous stream of places, times & events, constitute physical reality.

Those states which are non-contiguous, are dreams. These states appears as isolated islands amidst an unbroken ocean.

Spiritual experiences fall into the latter class. This is not to say they they are not real, only that they are not part of physical reality as we know it; i.e., they are meta-physical.

Might they be part of our physical realm? If so, then we lack the faculties required to observe & retain sufficient information about such so as to construct a logically contiguous stream of consciousness re. such. And so, until such time as we acquire said faculties, by definition, such remains meta-physical in nature, and any ponderings about such are but speculation.

Does this mean that we should cease speculating? Of course not. Such is that which drives us to explore ourselves, our world, & our universe.

As for your questions regarding personal experiences of the sort mentioned, I've no doubt that every person has had some such on multiple occasions. As for their causes, and their interpretations, which varies greatly depending on the individual, that too remains, for the present, unknowable.

by black panther

So you do believe in another unknown realm?

What proof do you need that there is another spiritual realm?

by jellimonsta

Upon first glance of your last post, I thought it read 'second only to procrastination' :)
That would have been pretty funny, but maybe, sadly enough true. :)

by deepsand

It'only the degree to which one is so inclined that varies.

Perhaps we procrastinate as a means of making sure that we're available when a suitable mate is at hand.

by deepsand

It'only the degree to which one is so inclined that varies.

Perhaps we procrastinate as a means of making sure that we're available when a suitable mate is at hand..

by black panther

How do you know what is good and what is evil? What does an agnostic consider a sin?

What kind of evidence could convince you that God exists?

by Member 25348569

on the question of morality for nonbelievers. It's probably a better place to ask that question.

http://tinyurl.com/aqhob

What kind of evidence would convince you that God didn't exist or, and perhaps easier than disproving existence, would convince you that God is actually not very nice.

by absolutely

Neither are her followers.

Note that after asking "How do you know what is good and what is evil?", samurai warrior ignores the most useful half of the dichotomy, virtue, and asks only "What does an agnostic consider a sin?" It depends which agnostic you ask.

I know one who considers obsessive concern with guilt to be sinful. It is more important to know what is virtuous and seek that than to know what is sinful and seek to avoid it. When I pursue virtuous behavior with the knowledge that it is the source of pride and self-esteem, I am perfectly content and have no time for sinning. I don't need any "Thou shalt not" list!

by black panther

And what do you see as 'virtuous'?? This is exactly what I am exploring - I am not a member of any church myself! :)

by black panther

an old Zen story:

a farmer in the hills only horse ran away during the evening and later that day the neighbors gathered and said "poor farmer, isn't it terrible you have lost your only horse." The farmer seemed unfazed and said "who is to say what is good and what is bad?". The next evening the run away horse led sixteen wild horses and ponies to the farmers stable. When the neighbors gathered, they couldn't believe his luck and exclaimed, "oh farmer, that's great, what luck has come your way, you now have sixteen new horses." The farmer replied "Who is to say what is good and what is bad?" The following day the farmer's son was trying to break one of the horses, fell and broke his right leg. That evening the neighbors came and said "poor farmer, how terrible it is your son broke his leg." Once again the farmer replied, "But who is to say..." The next day the Chinese Army came to the farmer house to draft his son but because of his broken leg, he was deemed unfit to serve at this time...

by black panther

only a continuous journey...infinite

2 parallels - the scientific and the spiritual.

I rely on others for the scientific discoveries and have faith that they are telling the truth!

I rely on my own experiences and the experiences of others for the spiritual and meta-physical and try to correlate the 2 together for some similarities! :)

by deepsand

We all stand on the shoulders of others.

If you are seeking to explore the possibility of a spiritual realm witch purports to be well integrated with our physical one, you might investigate the Spiritualists.

A good starting point would be the General Assembly of Spiritualists (GAS); the below link is for the results of a Google search for same.

[v]http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=%22general+assembly+of+spiritualists%22&btnG=Google+Search[/v]

If you require/desire personal contact with a Spiritualist, I've a good friend who is a Reverend of the GAS.

by deepsand

There is no possible proof for or against its existence.

Should a proof of [i]existence[/i] be forthcoming, then, by definition, such realm could no longer be described as meta-physical.

See meaning 2 below.

==================================================

Main Entry: meta?phys?i?cal
Pronunciation: -'fi-zi-k&l
Function: adjective
1 : of or relating to metaphysics
[b]2 a : of or relating to the transcendent or to a reality beyond what is perceptible to the senses b : SUPERNATURAL[/b]
3 : highly abstract or abstruse; also : THEORETICAL
4 often capitalized : of or relating to poetry especially of the early 17th century that is highly intellectual and philosophical and marked by unconventional imagery

by tony hopkinson

by definition. As a concept it simply came from counting. The only two mathematical things we can do with it are cancel and limit.
If you want a read about it try The Mystery of the Aleph by Amir D Aczel, which starts with Numerology, whizzes through the life of Cantor and finishes with Godel's assertion that there are mathematical concepts that can be stated mathematically but can't be proven mathematically.
Inifinity itself is an almost mystical concept anyway and one very tied to most forms of spirituality, and there's no proof of existance in the real world, just the accepted models of it.

by deepsand

In fact, it is easy to prove that some sets contain a [i]greater[/i] number of [i]infinite[/i] members than others.

Therefore, infinities [b]can[/b] be measured relative to others.

The result is that the ratio of certain infinities is a [b]rational[/b] number!

by tony hopkinson

You'll be taking cold baths like dear old George. You're getting very close to the continuum hypothesis there. Personally I refuse to think about things like that, I've got enough neuroses already.

by absolutely

you can get dizzy!

I think Aczel may be posting here as MrMiami, who also whizzes through a lot of topics, without understanding any of them.

by tony hopkinson

much easier to read, it runs through the early stuff up to and including relativity and quantum mechanics in a much more approachable way. Even string theory is explained without much problem. Fabric when it hit quantum mechanics really burnt my head, probably going to have to go back to it a few times, in places I found it almost unreadable.
You do get to learn that some of our greatest thinkers are really f'ing weird though.

by deepsand

A large portion of them were/are manic-depressive and/or given to using psychotropics.

by tony hopkinson

mind expanding drugs. Though my concept for man powered flight sucked big time, when I sobered up on the way down. Lucked out with the water landing though.
Hint to the wise , don't get drunk while sat on the edge of a bridge.

by tony hopkinson

Strange that you use a word like virtuous then. Full of virtue ? Which ones honesty, bravery ?
Chastity ?
LOL
The search for attributeness ?
Only you peers can judge virtue. With an alias like yours I would have thought harmony would have been a key goal in your quest.

by deepsand

2 simple examples will suffice to demonstrate the concept of the measurability of infinite sets.

Take, for example, the following 3 sets:

1) Positive integers, S(i), where
S(i)=1,2,3,...,i,...
2) Even positive integers, S(j), where
S(j)=2,4,6,...,j,...
3) Signed integers, S(k), where
S(k)=...,-k,...,-3,-2,-1,1,2,3,...,k,...

While it may intuitively seem that S(i) contains twice as many members as S(j), in fact, they each have the same; i.e., for each member of each set there is one, and one only, corresponding member in the other set.

For each member of S(j) there is a member of S(i) whose value I = J/2; likewise, for each member of S(i) there is a member of S(j) whose value J = 2*I.

Therefore, S(i) and S(j) are of equal magnitude.

With respect to S(k), while it is true that for each of its members there is a single corresponding member in S(i), such that I = |K|, i.e. the absolute value of K, the converse is [b]not[/b] true.

For each member of S(i) there are [b]2[/b] corresponding members in S(k), +I and -I.

Therefore, the magnitude of S(k) is precisely [b]twice[/b] that of S(i)!

by deepsand

the [b]correctly stated[/b] version of the [b]Golden Rule[/b].

[i]"Do [b]not[/b] unto others as you would have them [b]not[/b] do unto you."[/i]

by absolutely

Instead of a laundry list of virtues, I'll just tell you the single value from which I derive them: real life. Generally, the preservation and betterment of my life is the primary virtue I seek through all other specific virtues. I expect any truly Supreme Being, if one turns out to exist, to fully appreciate and reward my recognition that in life, my primary concern is knowable reality, not speculation about the unknowable-by-definition afterlife.

It's fun to speculate about such possibilities, but in the real world I see no reason to assume that near death experiences are any more a glimpse into another reality than are regular dreams or drug-induced hallucinations.

by deepsand

It both avoids the impossible task of attempting to enumerate those things that are to be embraced or avoided, and provides a principle by which any situation can be consistently evaluated.

by black panther

With current SuperString theory, electrons and quarks (the essence of all things to science) are just strings of vibrating energy, each vibrating at it's own frequency, or playing it's own note like in music, and the combination of these strings produces an orchestra playing a symphony, and this symphony is the rock, and that one is the tree, and this one is you.

The stuff that is there, the vibrating strings of energy, are waves. Like all energy waves, they consist of crests and troughs. An "on" state and an "off" state. Untold millions of times per second the energy vibration is on, then it's off, on, off....it's there,
it's not there, something, nothing, we exist, we don't exist, we exist, etc.

In fact as we make our microscopes more and more powerful, we will find smaller and smaller stuff within the Super Strings. Because it is said, that the universe, when being examined in this way, must make itself smaller and smaller, in order to hide from itself. The universe cannot look at itself. Just as you cannot see the back of your own head, or see your own eyes. This was theorized by a respected western mathematician, G. Spencer-Brown.

Everything and nothing are all interconnected, inseparable, a made whole.

The modern physicist H.P. Stapp wrote:
"An elementary particle is not an independently existing, unanalyzable entity.
It is, in essence, a set of relationships that reach outward to other things."

Nagarjuna, a second century Buddhist philosopher understood it already:
"Things derive their being and nature by mutual dependence and are nothing in themselves."

by absolutely

are almost always useful as demonstrations of the need for far-fetched and/or convoluted scenarios in any attempt to provide even anecdotal support for the claim that reason is insufficient to guide human interactions.

This discussion is closed to new replies.