Discussion Locked

The Terri Shiavo case; an emotional, legal and economic quagmire.

0 helpful
78 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Like most I've followed the playing out of Terri Shiavo's last days on television and front pages and am surprised at the elevated height of emotions engendered. I am also surprised that, considering the wide scope of topics posted to TR that no one has seen fit to bring this forth as a topic of discussion. I will reserve my comments for a later posting but have now decided to put the proverbial ball in play. I feel this may become as interesting a discussion as any we've had here and I have included the accompanying article as a starting point to get things underway.

Dawg
Date: April 1, 2005 3:57 PM

Her death ends one contentious battle but could have a wider impact as the US grapples with end-of-life issues.

By Linda Feldmann and Warren Richey, Staff writers of The Christian Science Monitor

WASHINGTON - The passing of Terri Schiavo ends one of the most protracted and high-profile right-to-die cases in American history. But beyond the personal tragedy it represents, the case also adds fuel to an array of unresolved legal and political issues and sets the stage for contentious national debate for years to come.

Already, the case of the brain-damaged Florida woman - who died Thursday after 15 years in what doctors called a persistent vegetative state and almost 13 days after her feeding tube was removed - has spurred some states to accelerate legislation aimed at preventing the kind of intrafamily conflict that kept Mrs. Schiavo in legal limbo for seven years.

The US Congress is also ready to take a fresh look at end-of-life issues, even after polls showed many Americans opposed the intervention of Congress and President Bush into the Schiavo case last month. Members of Congress from both parties, some spurred by right-to-life sentiments, others by advocates for the disabled, say the question of who makes decisions in disputed right-to-die cases is worth another look on Capitol Hill.

On a personal level, the legal tug-of-war over Schiavo has forced Americans to confront the unthinkable by vividly illustrating the importance of a living will.

Part of the culture war
At heart, the Schiavo case represents the latest skirmish in the nation's culture war, already heated over abortion, gay marriage, and stem-cell research. Social conservatives have long sought to tip the balance on these issues through appointment of conservative judges - and, analysts say, one direct effect of Schiavo could be to inflame passions even more than expected over a US Supreme Court vacancy that could come soon. The high court declined to take up the Schiavo case three times within the past two weeks.

"The most significant aspect of [the Schiavo case] is that it's likely a stage-setter for a huge conflagration over the first Supreme Court nominee," says Marshall Wittmann, a senior fellow at the Democratic Leadership Council and former Christian Coalition official.

But the most surprising aspect of the case, Mr. Wittmann adds, is that it brought to light the simmering tensions within the Republican coalition between the limited-government activists and religious conservatives. High-profile economic conservatives such as Grover Norquist and Stephen Moore, who usually support President Bush and the congressional Republican leadership, criticized their unorthodox move to turn what is normally a state issue over to the federal courts in the Schiavo case.

On the day of Schiavo's death, however, Bush remained undeterred. "The essence of civilization is that the strong have a duty to protect the weak," he said. "In cases where there are serious doubts and questions, the presumption should be in favor of life."

Negative public reaction to Congress's intervention may nevertheless deter similar attempts to federalize a case like this in the future, analysts say.

"A good number of those who cast votes last time are going to be frightened the next time," says Douglas Kmiec, a constitutional law professor at Pepperdine Law School who is critical of the federal intervention in the Schiavo case. "The polling data is telling them that most people are not all on one side or at least not on their side. So they will be gun-shy."

Role of guardians at stake
While many Americans are opposed to government intervention in what they view as private medical decisions dealing with end-of-life issues, the Schiavo case has also raised concerns about the power of guardians and judges to end someone's life even when a patient's wishes remain a matter of dispute among family members.

Florida state law requires that evidence of an individual's desire to cut off hydration and nutrition must be "clear and convincing." But some legal analysts say such a standard alone is not enough to head off concerns about spouses and guardians who may have financial or other personal motives to end nutrition or other life-support. In such cases, these analysts say, judges should be required to make specific findings dealing with each issue, including the credibility of guardians and spouses, future treatment prospects, and whether earlier casual statements by an individual who is now in a persistent vegetative state were well-informed and specific enough to justify a decision years later by a spouse and/or judge to end that person's life.

Ultimately the goal of pro-life activists is to establish as a matter of constitutional law that government has an affirmative obligation to protect life. In contrast, death-with-dignity supporters emphasize the existing and well-established constitutional right to decline unwanted medical treatment and be free from government intrusion into the most private aspects of their lives.

Analysts are divided over whether Congress will continue to take actions that favor the pro-life side in this broad debate. While some political observers have criticized the congressional action in the Schiavo case as being politically motivated, others stress that broad support for the measure among both Republicans and Democrats suggests many politicians were acting out of conscience.

In the long run, any political fallout over Schiavo is hard to predict. But it's possible, say Wittmann and others, that the Schiavo case - specifically, the unusual intervention of Congress in a family matter - could contribute to unease among moderate suburbanites who vote Republican on the economy and national security but are less comfortable with religious conservatives' dominance of the party on social issues. And at a time of narrow Republican control in Washington, every vote matters.

For the Democrats, the Schiavo case also presented no clear partisan advantage. "If you look carefully, you see that everyone is divided by the issue one way or another," says Jim Guth, a political scientist at Furman University in Greenville, S.C. "The very fact that the Democrats in both houses had such a hard time reacting to this - some went along with the Republican bill that passed, some opposed, others refrained from voting - suggests this is not an easy issue to discern exactly where long-term or short-term political advantage lies."

Like the embryonic stem-cell issue - on which some strong abortion foes, such as Sen. Orrin Hatch (R) of Utah, favor expanded federal funding for research - positions on end-of-life issues often don't break neatly along the same lines as those on abortion and gay marriage.

"There's a lot of debate on the evangelical side of the religious spectrum on these [end-of-life] issues," says Professor Guth. "I don't think anyone has settled into final positions on these yet. Some leaders on the religious right have, but among their constituency there's a lot more division on this than there is on abortion."

So there we are. On what side of the question do you come down???

Dawg

78 replies

by jessie

Controversy, thy name is Religion.

As a fairly religious person myself, I can't see how especially anyone who believes in the here-after, as I'm sure the right-to-lifer's do, can prefer a living death to allowing someone to be welcomed into the arms of their heavenly father.

However, it should NEVER have gotten this far... This was at MOST an issue for the local courts, and NEVER the government. In most states, I believe the spouse does have the right to decide whether or not to continue life support. God forbid the government should ever come down and tell me I can't remove life-support from my husband's persistently vegetative body.

It may be time for me to put my right to bear arms to good use.

by amcol

This was all political agenda pushing. Each side seized on an opportunity to piggyback onto a media feeding frenzy and gain access to an international forum in order to put their own viewpoints front and center.

That's what makes this whole thing so sad. We're talking about a human being here, and a family. That got totally lost. All these self righteous groups, whichever side they were on, cared less about Terry Schiavo, the Schiavo family, and the Schindler family than they did about just arguing the issue and using Terry Schiavo as their battering ram. I know that sounds cynical, because I'm sure there were plenty of people who sincerely cared about whether and how this poor woman lived or died. Too bad this was allowed to become yet another polarizing issue played out in the media.

We all point fingers at what continues to go on in the Middle East and can't understand how ostensibly intelligent people can allow their religious beliefs to be subverted into violence, hatred, and political turmoil. I'm not sure I see too much difference in the way this situation played out here.

Politics and religion don't mix well. It's too bad that no society across the spectrum of human history has ever shown any ability to figure out how to keep the two apart.

by deepsand

Terry's family used every resource available to try to advance their cause, including the media, as well as both the Florida and US legislatures.

Such is indicative of a great diviseness within the family itself. Those experienced in such matters will point out that a crisis such the perception of an iminent death of a family member will tend to bring such problems to the forefront.

The Republican leadership saw in this what they believed to be an opportunity to advance their agenda with the aid of a willing supplicant. Their miscalculation was is believing that they did indeed speak for the majority in this country.

by salamander

I agree. The government should never have gotten involved in a decision that legally belonged to Michael Schaivo. That's part of the point of having a spouse...you pick somebody who has your best interests in mind, and the law recognizes the primacy of this relationship. This should have been a private matter.

However, this situation was drawn out by special interest groups. I saw on the news that the Schindlers' legal fees had been bankrolled by right-to-life special interest groups. It's about an agenda, a convenient platform for government to shoehorn itself into citizens' personal lives by making judgments about a "culture of life."

That concerns me. The idea that Congress and the feds are severely unhappy with the judiciary for not falling into line raises questions of the basis on which new judicial nominees will be selected. The courts were not intended to be beholden to a party...they are to be separate, and they did their job. We should be worried about our system of checks and balances.

What also concerns me is that Congress apparently has nothing better to do with its time than involve itself in this matter...and doping in professional baseball. Aargh. I read that they're contemplating investigating football next. I would think that they can find more important issues to involve themselves with. Like, um, terrorism. Or identity theft. Or Social Security.

by oz_media

And one that I have no answer for myself. At one time I may have been VERY sure and confident in making a decision but now I see things differentlt it is impossible to say.

I had a most horrendous accident with a fire truck in '89 and it left me in a coma for a little over 6 weeks. I then just all of a sudden awoke or came to, at first thought my brother was santa claus and my friend had drowned (thinking I'd driven off a bridge). But I soon regained MOST of my faculties (I cannot claim complete sanity because some of you have read my posts now), I had to learn how to write again (got really good at Calligraphy at one time) how to walk in a straight line etc. But have since passed years of technical training, learned networking etc. So I guess I am not totally brain dead after all.

The reason I say this is because when I was in a coma, the doctor actually admitted little hope I would ever come to without severe brain damage and if I did I would most likely be paralyzed. My mother sat beside my bed for 45 days on a shift with my mother and sister and I evenetually just woke up one day.

They had been instructed on how to deal with the loss of a family member, had been shown all of the 'options' available and given VERY little hope.

I am not a very religious person, I accept everyones right to religion and respect their individual choices, no matter what religion they have chosen, i believe EVERY living person needs faith, whether in a religion or just the excitement of being alive.

But the other view of this I have is that IF I had been on life support and then my family had made a choice for me to pass. I can't say that I would have even known it anyway.

When I was 'out' I don't remember meeting God or seeing relatives or a white light or any sort of after-life experience, even though initially I was practically dead, but when I 'came to' I found that things sure looked good to me, trees were practically shining bright green and everything looked surreal. I could see the mountains from my window and sat there in awe for days.

Anyhow, blah, blah, blah...My point is, as you can tell by my inconclusive rambling, I wouldn't have known if I hadn't become concious again. My family MAY have been burdened forever, they may have always wondered if I would be better off dead, who knows?

If they had let me die, it may have been harder or easier for them in the long run but no different for me as I would have never known.

So I guess I HAVE reached some sort of conclusion, that it would be up to the parents or family to qualify such a decision I suppose?

I certainly wouldn't condone a church, state, province or judge to make such a decision.

For those who are religious, wouldn't it be best to leave your god's work to those who have loved, nurtured or cared for the person all of their life?

Sorry for the long haul Dawg, but like I said "Good question" got me pondering. :)

by sleepin'dawg

I can understand where you are coming from on this and it reinforces my thoughts of having a living will to eliminate the potential moral dilemmas that families and loved ones must have in situations like this.

Dawg

Sick joke for today; I give it being a scoot rider myself: What do they call motorcyclists in the ER???

Organ donors!!! ]:)

by oz_media

I have two Yamaha dual purpose bikes, http://www.yamaha-motor.ca/products/products.php?model=90&class=13&group=M&LANG=en and they both have BASIC insurance on them, so I can get from logging road or campsite to the store and back without moving the motorhome, and for a fraction of the price, but 99.9% is off road only. I don't trust people enough to ride around them anymore, I watched my best friend lose a foot when he was t-boned by a drunk, LONG befor ethe streets were as busy as they are now. Even though it's pretty good here (better nayway), no way I'd street ride on the mainland anymore.

I can get my own butt there but don't trust others around me to not kill me en route.

by sleepin'dawg

Not much off road opportunities around here. When I'm riding it's like my head is on a 360 degree rotating swivel. I view any car within 200 yards as if it were driven by a homicidal maniac with a specific mission to get me killed. So far, that tactic has kept me accident free for almost 50 years but conditions seem to be worsening. I may yet give it up because of the risks and pressure from friends and family.

Dawg :(

by oz_media

You seem to be out this way for your summer fishing, why don't you fly your bike out and try booting around Richmond one day. Now THAT'S a dare!

I wouldn't even drive my truck through Richmond, and anyone from around the Lower Mainland would agree wholly I am sure. Most people just avoid it now.

by jaqui

are you nuts?!?!?!?!
I won't even walk in the middle of a building there!
way to many teenaged / drunken / rednecked fools on the road.
( purposely avoiding the whole significant chinese population in that city, all with 3 cars per household, cause I know that it's only those that can't wrap thier minds around red = stop + green = go that get the bad rep for them )

by deepsand

Phrases like "the presumption should be in favor of life" might make for good sound-bites, but nothing more.

The premise for the radical Right's position is that there remained a non-zero probablity that Terry's brain functions could be restored. Their conclusion was that such be allowed as much time as needed to be realized.

The same argument can be applied to the debate re. the death penalty; for so long as there remains ANY doubt regarding the culpability of the accused, we must err in favor of allowing the accused to continue living.

Yet here Mr. Bush and his ilk insist on a rush to final judgement.

They seek nothing more than to impose their brand of "morality" on us all, and chose their stands so as maximize their political powers and thereby husband the resources required to advance that goal.

by roger99a

The Shaivo story got me thinking the other day about who people want to kill. The Republicans want to kill criminals and terrorists. The Democrats want to kill unborn babies and now, helplessly sick people. As far as seeking to impose their brand of morality on others, everybody does this and noone is afraid to use the courts to do it. Perhaps a compromise would be in order. No more criminal executions and no more abortions. Think anyone would go for that?

by Member 25348569

We have no executions and we have choice for women. Even with an Advance Directive, they'll keep on feeding you. Seems to suit us. Nobody stands out side prisons or abortion clinics protesting. Nobody shoots doctors.

I don't want to start another discussion on abortion as what you do in your country doesn't affect me in this case - even slightly. However, I think anyone can appreciate the difference between "killing unborn babies" and terminating an eleven-week pregnancy.

If using emotive language like that isn't an example of someone trying to "impose their brand of morality on others" then I don't know what is.

Practise what you preach.

by deepsand

Firstly, understand that I belong to NO political party; I am fiercely independent.

That being said, I must point out that you conveniently pass over the issue of whether or not there exists that which constitutes a person in both the case of the unborn & that of Terry Schiavo.

In the former, such is open to debate; in the latter, it is a known medical fact that there was no longer anybody home.

Therefore, to accuse the Democrats of being desirious of killing is a specious argument at best; at worst, it is an exercise in intellectual dishonesty.

by jessie

I happen to be a pro-life Democrat with no love for terrorists, and there are a LOT more like me out there. Don't generalize about us K?

I'd be ECSTATIC with a "compromise" but there have to be several social programs in place to help either rehabilitate criminals, or ship them off to their own planet, and we can't just make abortions illegal again without doing something to consistently PREVENT unwanted pregnancies (how about completely reversible sterilization at onset of menses?) and support the mothers who feel like they otherwise have no choice?

And somebody give me a damn gun so I can go kill some terrorist bastards! I've got pregnancy hormones a'ragin' and I need someone on whom to take out my aggressions... they seem like the perfect target.

by deepsand

Terry's family enlisted the aid of advocates for the disabled, who are traditionally supporters of Democratic candidates.

The Democrats, in their understandable desire not to loose such support, decided that "rolling over" would be to choose the lesser of two evils.

In this way they ensured that they will live to fight another day.

by sleepin'dawg

It seems that most of the population of Richmond are immigrants and where they originated from, bicycles were the normal mode of transportation. Thus they tend to drive cars the same way they drove their bikes back home, forgetting that a two ton automobile isn't quite the same thing as a bike. Drive in Richmond; get rear-ended at every stop light if you are foolish enough to stop in front of anyone. Depth perception seems to be a bit of a problem for a lot of people out there.

Dawg

by oz_media

I knew you'd recognize the idiocy of driving in Richmond though. Redknecks and drunken teenagers would have been the 70's & 80's, that's when Richmond was still full of Pilot's and Fisherman's children. They got very little attention and very big attitudes for a bunch of suburbian kids.

Nowdays a redkneck would not survive in the Ditch. They added U-Turns down the middle of 3Road! PSYCHO!!! The bars are full of Asian gangs and 'X' deals as it seems to be the center of trance music based clubs now.

For peers NOT from here, Richmond is called Ditchmond because it is actually below sea level. It stays dry due to huge ditches (6'-10' deep) dug on the sides of all the streets (avoid those when driving drunk!). They have filled in MOST ditches around the main throroghfare and added sewers that can handle the volume but the farms on the outskirts still have monster ditches around them.

Richmond (Sea Island specifically) is home of Vancouver International Airport, which is also below sea level and dammed/ditched all around. Yet they say in the event of a tidal wave or flood, the airport would not flood due to the design of the island.

by oz_media

The easiest way to blind a driver in Richmond is to put a windshield in front of them.

The most popular car on the street is the courtesy car from the body shop.

I think they will eventually just change the name to 'Lichmond'.

by Member 25348569

I got the American reaction to the lead-up to the death of Terri Schiavo completely wrong - and I'm glad. It's made me re-think some of the views I held of "Middle America". I've got a better understanding how your system works. More importantly, it's really made your government sit up and take notice!

Some people over here look upon the great part of American as a parochial, ignorant, lazy sort of place, full of bible bashers and ruled to a dangerous extent by trashy television, superstition and religious bigotry, a place lacking in respect for evidence based knowledge. I don't because I've been to the USA many times - though after the research that I've done for the "Evolution" thread I did sometimes wonder about the "bible belt". I've read about the $25m creationist museum which is about to open in Kentucky, complete with models of Adam and Eve being chased by dinosaurs! Thank you, ippirate, for opening my eyes to THAT one!

When Congress interrupted its holiday to change the law in order that Terri Schiavo's feeding tube should be reinserted, I though "Here we go! Bible-bashers rule, OK!". I was convinced that with GWB at the centre of this, Terri's feeding tube would be reinserted. Just another example of America moving even more conservative. I assumed that the politicians would not have acted as they did without some fairly strong belief that they would be backed by the nation.

Lets keep an irreversibly brain-damaged woman alive as long as possible but let's get the mmurderers topped as soon as we can do it!

I was amazed! Pretty damn good! Way to go! Of course, not because Terri was allowed to die, although were I in her position I would not want to continue living, but because the politicians were wrong and got told so!

Michael Schiavo convinced the courts. He believed that his wife would want to die and they agreed. And that was that.

Your system works better than I thought.

Neil

by oz_media

I just watched a one hour documentary about the whole case from her childhood forward. It showed both views very clearly and ultimately there is NO way that a court OR government should be in charge of making such a decision.

There were more than a dozen doctors who's care had been successful in bringing several people out of comas of up to 12 years. "Irreversibly brain damaged woman" was the entire issue in question really. There were many who said it WASN'T irreversible and had proof. So it would be an unqualified decision to begin with.

Those that were called in to Congress that evening were all taking turns saying how ridiculous it was that they were called in to vote on a case where they had not been breifed nor had ANY scientific or Medical knowledge to base such a decision on.
The vote went ahead although more than the majority had stressed their dislike for the vote at all.

My view is that when one needs ot make such a vote, you must do so in the same way the law is to be treated by a jury. If there's ANY cause for a reasonable doubt, you MUST aquit the accused. Now a lot of people think that means absolute certainty but it doesn't, reasonable doubt means proof enough that you would rely and act upon it without hesitation.

In this case, we are talking about people making a decision with a clear issue of ethics and morality, foundations of the country, the constitutional rights afford to human life and even the possibility of her recovery even if partial. That is enough DOUBT to consstitute reasonable doubt.

In the end though, they had asked to be allowed to TRY and treat her for 12 months at their own expense in order to try one doctors treatment, yet were denied.

The issue is plain and simple, WE DON'T KNOW, therefore we do have a reasonable doubt and MUST aquit. They cannot pass judgement on this issue, no human can.

We pay immense sums to lock up and care for criminals for decades. Yet we pass judgement on a normal citizen's right to extended care for life?

by cuteelf

Is why her parents were fighting so much.

To me, it was the Husband's right, by law, to make this decision. If he wanted to, he could call the family into a circle and do a vote or such. He chose not to, and made the decision to pull the plug.

To me, that's ok. But if her parents wanted her to be kept alive, WHY didnt he just hand over legal rights to her parents, and let them foot the bill? Divorce from her, and wash his hands?

Another question I have is: how alert was she?
Was she responsive? If she was not at all, then i think its legal to stop.

Me; I"m going to write a DNR /Living will this month. I'm turning 30 :( and I need to have this in place.

Cute

by Member 25348569

Always was. Both in law and from any other perspective. It never was about whether this treatment or that treatment would increase the quality of what was left of her life.

Had he handed "control" over to another party - her parents, the state or the most well-intentioned doctors - then he would have been admitting that his motives were not what he considered was best for her and - more significantly - what SHE wanted.

It may be that his motives were, in fact, less than pure - financial - and he wanted to move on but to surrender legal control would have meant publicly admitting exactly that.

She had the "right to extended care for life" but her husband went to convince the US courts that she didn't want it, didn't want to carry on the way she was. The parents and other groups tried to convince the courts otherwise whilst at the same time seeking maximum publicity and trying to apply maximum pressure on the husband from every which direction. Then the government stepped in trying to score a nice political point.

And the courts agreed with the husband. And so, I think, do the majority of the population of the US.

Neil

by deepsand

Given the great advances in medical science & technology, a mere 15% of Americans now experience a "natural" death; the other 85% are kept alive beyond their "natural" span through artificial means.

This means that the vast majority of people here are now, and have been for some time, dealing quite well with the issues at hand.

The cases of both Ms. Quinlan & Ms. Shiavo are unique, in that they both involve the young, and who had living parents willing and able to us the media to advance their causes. In neither case was there a reasonable doubt in the minds of the attending medical practioners as to the prognosis.

by sleepin'dawg

i.e.: The Christian Conservative Coalition, who with little forethought, plunged into this case as a right to life issue; an area in which their arguments weren't truly applicable. The only "life" Terri Shiavo exhibited was the fact that her autonomic systems were functioning but she was otherwise in a vegitative state with no hope of improving. Would any sane person want to exist in that condition and make no mistake about it; Terri Shiavo was existing not living. Why this dragged out for fifteen years only the participants know but frankly I do not believe they had Terri's best interests at heart. Fifty years ago she would have died in a matter of weeks if not days but modern medical technology was used or abused, in a vain attempt at a recovery that had no real chance of occurring.

Dawg

by tony hopkinson

From a personal point of view, if I was the one so afflicted, I'd definitely want to die. At least I've stated that verbally. Be too late to change my mind if it happened. My missus is of a similar opinion, but my mother said she'd come back and haunt us. Trying to make a general rule for this is doomed and stupid, each case has to be judged separately, otherwise the law becomes more important than those it serves, or at least meant to. The right to rescind life support or even euthanasia has to be asked for each time, making a law one way or the other simply means you'll be wrong far too often for comfort.

by oz_media

I have said the same Tony, yet soon after found myself reovering from a 6 week coma in which I did have a full recovery even after doctors had little hope.

I wouldn't want to live like that, only due to the burden on others. But then again, when we re IN those situations, we unconciously fight to cling to life and often do quite successfully.

Nearly everyone who has been hospitalized with spinal or knee/leg injuries is told they will not walk again. I am sure you have many friends who have heard this and proven dotors wrong. Doctors just say this to invoke a instinctive strength to improve our own abilities.

We DO fight for life to the bitter end, whether we think we will want to live or not while being healthy.

Something to think about, you are physically unable to react, you can hear, understand and see all around ou but simply FIGHT to make your body respons that you are feeling fine and alive, but you can't show this to others. This is called being 'locked in'. There are MANY cases around the world where people have shown FULL recovery from these situations, what if THAT was you? What f you KNEW you'd be okay but simply couldn't show others?

Then you hear,"He said he wouldn't want to live like this, let's stop life support."

It would be similar to being buried alive, starved to death, slowly dehydrated until you pass etc.

It is not uncommon for people to recover from these states,and in such a case where your natural instinct to fight for life comes into play, you would be screaming to get the truth out but unable to. Pretty scary if you ask me.

My views changed when that option was placed on MY life, and my family still stayed by me with hope. Had they acted on some comments or feelings that I made while watching TV one day, I may not be here today.

I thank god for people with hope.

by oz_media

That was a concsluion drawn by THREE doctors who had cared for her, one of whom lost his practice during the case. Several other doctors had living proof that this was incorrect and she DID have the ability to be rehabilitated somewhat if not quite considerably.

The factors I have seen that changed this possibility, were shown in teh form of video taken of her during visits, she reacted to lights and colors, she laughed, she squealed and smiled when her mother brushed her hair. She had the ability to use opposing force when doctors pushed against her legs or arms. This force was also said to be varying and would match the pressure applied, obviously indicating a motor skill, not a reflex.

BUT, this film was all shot to hell when her husbands lawysres opposed it. Apprently she didn't ALWAYS show such response and smiling or laughing or responding once in 20 attempts was not consluive enough for them. Yet to me, response IS response, it may take weeks for someone in that state to actually be able to respond,this doesn't mean that they AREN'T responding though.

I think the fact that she was shown as completely incapable of response, completely brain dead etc. makes it easier for some to accept, but in video I saw of her 'responses' she most definitely WAS aware of those around her on more than one occasion and only with specific people, these weren't random at all.

So it really casts a completely different light on things when you consider that she WASN'T a complete vegetable, she WASN'T completely unresponsive and she COULD react to stimuli.

HAD she been completely brain dead and incapacitated then it would be a different case altogether.

The fact that the husband had shown his need for money was greater than his need to rehabilitate her was FAR stronger than the fact that she was considered brain dead and without hope. Her husband had his lawyers ensure nobody else would be given a CHANCE at proving her ability to be rehabilitated, this doesn't sound like the HOPE that any truly caring person would hold, it sounds like a fear that it may be dragged out.

As for HER wishes, she had none that were conclusive enough to decide that's how she felt. While watching a film at age 19 she was SAID to have mentioned never ewanting to live like that, which pretty mush we would ALL say when being healthy and full of life. Yet when in these desperate situations, the instinctive fight for life has saved many people who would have died otherwise.
That she wouldn't want to live like that was ONLY ever heard by her husband and was NOT brought up until he had decided her desitiny, why not before when he was fighting for her rehabilitation?

This was very last minute fo rhim to suddenly remeber his wifes last wishes.

by deepsand

Terry was carefully examined & observed by a medical practitioner who stimulated her in attempts to elicit responses, observed her in the presence of himself but without stimulation, and with no one present in her room.

His observation showed that such "responses" were in fact random, as is normal in cases such as this.

Futhermore, MRI scans long ago showed that she suffered irreversible brain damage such that there was no longer any evidence of sentience.

In short, she WAS vegetative; the Schindlers simply chose to place their hopes above the facts.

by oz_media

HIs motives were never clear to SOME but crystal clear to others. Yes, IF he had handed control over to her parents SOME may have seen him as uncaring himself, but seeing as the parents DID want to seek alternate treatment he 'apparently' did not want them to persue this.

Around nurses in a home she stayed temporarily, he left many in tears, some had phoned police to question his motives. He is quoted as saying "When will she finally die and let me get on with my life", "I can't wait much longer for the money" and "Hasn't she gone yet?" These were all statements accepted in court asheard by nurses that had attended her, his attorney made them appear to be a plea for her relief.

As far as recovery, that WAS a huge and in fact most important/debated factor considered. There were enough cases of recovery from similarly incapacitated patients, after more than a dozen years, that had some dcotors convinced that she would be helped and could possibly become far more coherent and able over time. The parents had plead for them to be allowed to TEST this for one year, but the husband strictly refused any further attempts at her recovery.

While her husband was shown to be a sympathetic and caring man, he was also shown to have ulterior motives and be purely money hungry, which his comments around others had proven. Some people he stayed with had heard him say MANY things to the effect of "When will she finally die", "How long do I have to wait for independance?" etc. But they were NOT accepted as witnesses to this as the time frame had been several years.

I personally DON'T think her husband had her best intentions in mind at all, in the end, after seeing his BIO and hearing what people say they had witnessed him saying, different people from different states all hearing the same utterances from him?

In the end, this shouldn't be HIS sole decision, her parents are still alive and they should have an option of taking on the burden if he chooses not to. This most definitely should not be a decision of the court though as it will only be used as fodder for similar cases in the future. Other people MAY receive similar rulings due to this one unqualified decision that congress had made. This will in turn just make the process quicker and easier for others to 'cash in' in similar situations with little obstruction from the people or the courts.

She HAD been quite reactive, yet the film they showed was devalued by the lawyers as they said that the film where she DIDN'T respond was greater than when she did, SO WHAT? They say she didn't respond as it was not a constant response, yet when she DID respond it was very clear that she was aware of WHAT she rsponded to, she defintely recognized BOTH her parents and was completely different when they were in the room. She squealed with excitement when her mother walked in, she laughed when her father joked about her childhood. Yet they said that if she didn't respond this way EVERY time they were around then it was not to be considered concious response.

Too much grey area, too many horror stories from those who knew or were in the presence of her husband and too many questions asked by those who finally did vote the decision.
THIS is enough to dehydrate her her slowly in the presence of her loved ones until she dies? When another woman came out of a very similar stroke induced coma after more than 12 years? When another woman said to be 'locked in' for nearly 7 years became a reporter only three years after a similar incident?

by Member 25348569

in law, it was the husband's sole decision. You don't like it at all and I'm suspicious, too, but we don't have a say and I don't want one in the case of someone I don't know.

What it comes back to, though, is that he said it was what SHE wanted. If we can't prove him to be a liar then we have to agree to TERRI'S wishes via her husband - and that is what the US courts did.

The law needs to be absolutely solid on this. I don't know exactly what the law says in the US - whether it's state-specific or what - but back here its a medical decision by the patient's doctors that can override both relatives and even Advance Directives in favour of life.

Rarely does it come to the type of pitched courtroom battles seen in the US although there was a case recently of the doctors of a severely handicapped baby wiinning the case to be allow NOT to treat the baby in the event of further deterioration of its condition. The parents wished the babies life to be prolonged at whatever cost financially and to the child.

Food and water were withdrawn from my father a day before he died - he had advanced cancer, was 84 and was in a coma - with the permission of my mother. It WAS the right thing to do for him but even if it had not been in my opinion I would have kept quiet about it because legally and morally it was her decision and to criticise would have made it so much worse.

This case should NOT have been turned into a public 3-ring circus. How on earth does it benefit anyone that you and I can read her husband's "biography" - written by who? What's their motives?

The law and human society is having trouble keeping up with medical technology. That we can keep a person alive in her condition for so long - 15 YEARS. If lfe must be ended, and in this case I err towards ending it, though, there must be a better way without the starvation and dehydration. We treat pets better than we treat human beings.

Neil

by oz_media

There is a really cool show on A&E called Biography. It is not a news story nor a shot at people, it is merely an outline and details of a famous persons life. In most cases as in the recent one I saw, her husband was interviewed directly as well as others who knew him. SO there's no underahanded written assumptions offered and for the most part people all accept that Biography is a well researched and very well documented tribute tp most people's lives. It wasn't a negative shot at him, but the results of the facts left it to the viewer to make a decision based on both sides presented, inmy case it was clear cut that he had fabricated this late after many opportunities where such a comment would have saved many problems leading up to this.

There were other times when he never mentioned this and yet doing so would have strongly supported his case.

In the case of your father, I understand it is hard but he was terminally ill and had lived a long life, which I am sure makes such decisions a little more conclusive from your mother's perspective, as hard as it still must be.

In Terri's case it wasn't so cut and dry and the ulterior motives of the husband were quite apprent to those who knew and spoke with him. Accepting such testimony is almost like saying that anyone who can't defend themselves is at the mercy of their loved ones. In the case of a sour marriage this would almost offer an avenue to collect a nice sum regardless of the possibility of survival or recovery. I understand that in THIS case it was abiding by a law that makes the husband responsible, my issue is that this just isn't enough and it WILL be proven detrimental in the future. Even those who had voted said that they pray they have made the right decision.

That's just pathetic really.

by deepsand

That part of the brain where sentience lives had been physically destroyed!

Furhermore, prior to the time of her being moved into a hospice, her husband had been so aggressive in his demands for further greater use of speculative cures, that the hospital gave serious consideration to seeking a restraining order so as to bar him from the hospital!

by oz_media

Her husband did and said a lot of contradictory things, and yes they focused on the fact that he was what a nurse considers a bad headace. Always insisting on better care. He was also the one who decided to have her moved and her care greatly reduced to reduce costs. Then changed his mind and started to battle for care again.

He had MANY opportunities where saying that she had said she wouldn't want to live like that and it would have saved him a lot of greif, but he also sabed THAT information until the eleventh hour for some reason, when questioned he said that he had not remembered that moment until recently.

She was said to be LOCKED IN, possibly able to hear, see, think, smell etc. but unable to effectively move or use her motor skills, like being trapped in an unresponsive body.

The bottom line is there were conflicting opinions of her state, there was no conclusive evidence either way and yet a conclusion was drawn, as I said, an unqualified conclusion.

by roger99a

That's a nice term, "Terminating". It means the same thing, just sounds a lot nicer, don't you think? Terry Shaivo was "terminated" through dehydration. Pretty nasty way to go, but since it was a 'termination" I guess that's OK. I'm going to be old one day. I hope they don't decide I'm not worth feeding anymore.

As far as practicing what I preach, I have never terminated a pregnancy, executed a prisoner, dehydrated and starved a brain damaged person to death or bombed a terrorist. I've also never protested at a prison or shot a doctor. I'm of the opinion that when you cheapen a human life in this way, you also cheapen your own life.

by Member 25348569

is what we use to communicate. You might want to examine if YOU use it properly before launching into such a patronising attack.

If you employ the term "killing a baby" to describe an abortion - especially an early one - that, to me, indicates a religious mind-set, I would guess Christian, and that you are not going to enter into any meaningful discussion.

?Termination? is the precise medical term and that is why I used it. What has ?nice? got to do with anything in this discussion? None of it is ?nice?. Abortion is not ?nice? but sometimes, I believe, necessary and always ? so far ? not for me to get involved in the yes or no.

The death of Terri Schiavo was far from ?nice? but the laws of your country allowed her to be killed slowly - but not quickly, like you kill your criminals. Don?t have a go at ME about THAT! I have an Advance Directive stating what I want to happen to me were I to end up like Terri and it isn?t to be fed through a tube for 15 years.

?I'm of the opinion that when you cheapen a human life in this way, you also cheapen your own life.? Well hooray for you. I?m of the opinion that condescending phrases don?t really contribute much. Feel free to feel superior if you wish.

by deepsand

you have no right to deny others the freedom to choose for themselves.

And, do not expect that you have the right to demand that others bear the burden of keeping your heart beating when there no "you" left.

by tony hopkinson

but I can live with that or not as the case may be. But that was my point in your case it would have been wrong to turn you off, so if it had been easy to do so, you'd have been a sad loss. However, a law the other way and slightly different circumstances and you could be laying there still. Each decision has to be made on merit with the best interest of the patient in mind, we can only do our best but judging each case on it's merits gives us a better chance to get it right than ruling one way or the other without looking into it. They brought my grandad back seven times, for his own good !

by oz_media

Yet the tests were deemed uncontrolled ramdon responses even though she HAD responded many times to stimuli. She just wasn't consistent enough in her responses to be deemed conciously reponsive.

ANOTHER doctor who had worked with her for some time, said the exact opposite, she WAS showing controlled responses and COULD be helped. He had several living cases from very similar instances where he had been successful, as i mentioned, one woman has since become a news reporter, though told she would never snap out of her vegetative state and if so it would be with severe brain damage.

So there's two sides to the coin, the doctor who wanted to have 12 months trial twith her was denied against her parents pleadings.

They wouldn't even let someone TRY to rehabilitate her, at one point ALL care was greatly reduced by her husband, he was quoted as saying to a nurse, 'it would just suck up too much of his inheritance'.

So we have a problem, one or wo doctors say no way and have no cases to prove otherwise. One or two OTHER doctors say it is possible and have several successful cases to prove it.

Do we listen to the naysayers?
So we place faith in the optimists?

Either way, how can ANY person make a sound judgement with such inconclusive theories of her state?

You can't...but they did and prayed aloud that they had made the correct decision.

by deepsand

The courts heard more than ample testimony re. Terry's wishes in this regard, with the findings that to keep her alive at all costs would have contravened her wishes.

Simply put, it was her decision to make, not that for her parents.

by oz_media

All the courts heard about her wishes was last minute heresay from her husband.

Several psychologists have also said that this is a natural comment by any healthy human being when watching such a program on television. Of course when healthy they couldn't se eliving like that, but in cases where people HAVE been kept alive and recovered they have said otherwise.

This INFORMATION, heresay, ample evidence as you deem it, was brought up several years after a similar issue was discussed. When the courts asked why this hadn't been presented before, he said he'd forgotten until recently. HOW CAN YOU FORGET SOMETHING LIKE THAT, especially after being faced with it and having countless years to remember??!? He had withheld this information until the last minute, this was not ample evidence of her wishes by any stretch of the imagination.

She had no living will, which WOULD be considered ample evidence. She hadn't share this with her family or any friends either, just her husband apparent;ly while watching a movie one day where someone was kept alive in hospital for an extended term. At least that's what her husband claimed long after the issue had been raised several times over several years without his memory of her saying it.

But at least you didn't refer to her brain stem being beyond recovery this time.

by oz_media

"In neither case was there a reasonable doubt in the minds of the attending medical practioners as to the prognosis."

Yes there was and a couple of the doctors who had visited and worked with her had shown positive results in VERY similar cases. Sometimes a nearly full recovery and others just a way of communication, eye blinks, finger twitches etc.

Her husband had a restrainign order placed on the doctors and had her moved, this was the first time when he had her care greatly reduced to "save money" and shortly after decided to have her care increased again. A little too unsure and indecisive if you ask me.

The whole issue is that there WAS no conclusion drawn and they were only going on the allowed testimony of two doctors who had never seen a reversal.

by deepsand

Since you persist in raising the issue of money, how do you explain that Terry's husband declined to accept her parents' offer?

And, see my other posts re. her lack of a functional cerebrum, without which there is no "person."

by oz_media

His lawyer did, on his behalf.

And yes I have seen yuor constant referrals to your other post where you asserted that her brain stem was too far damaged, yet I have heard that it wasn't and that only TWO doctors (both employed by her husband) has reached that conclusion.

I am getting tired of repeating myself too, just make your comment and move to the next without your constant referrals to your other posts.

by tony hopkinson

For fifteen years !
If she was still aware like that, the only saving grace is she would have probably gone insane. If she wasn't thinking then it would be more like locked out.

by sleepin'dawg

An exerpt from a USA Today article with some illuminating facts.

Contributing: USA TODAY's Richard Willing and Jill Lawrence, USATODAY.com's Randy Lilleston and The Associated Press.

Described by her family as a shy woman who loved animals, music and basketball, Terri Schindler grew up in Pennsylvania and battled a weight problem in her youth.

"And then when she lost all the weight, she really became quite beautiful on the outside as well. What was inside she allowed to shine out at that point," a friend, Diane Meyer, said in 2003.

She met Michael Schiavo at Bucks County Community College near Philadelphia in 1982. They wed two years later. After they moved to Florida, she worked in an insurance agency.

But recurring battles with weight led to the eating disorder that was blamed for her collapse at age 26. Doctors said she suffered severe brain damage when her heart stopped beating because of a potassium imbalance. Her brain was deprived of oxygen for 10 minutes before she was revived, doctors estimated.

Because Terri Schiavo did not leave written wishes on her care, Florida law gave preference to Michael Schiavo over her parents. But the law also recognizes parents as having crucial opinions in the care of an incapacitated person.

Michael Schiavo and the Schindlers jointly supervised care for Terri after she collapsed. For the first 16 days and nights that she was hospitalized, Schiavo never left the hospital. Over the next few years, as she was moved from the hospital to a skilled nursing facility, to a nursing home, to Schiavo's home and finally back to a nursing home, Schiavo visited Terri daily.

Schiavo and the Schindlers even sold pretzels and hot dogs on St. Pete Beach to raise money for Terri's care. But everything seemed to change on Valentine's Day 1993 in a nursing home near here.

In 1992, Schiavo had filed a medical malpractice lawsuit against two doctors who had been treating his wife before she was stricken. Late that year came a settlement: Schiavo received $300,000 for loss of consortium - his wife's companionship. Another $700,000 was ordered for Terri's care.

Mary Schindler later testified that Schiavo had promised money to his in-laws. They had helped him and Terri move from New Jersey to Pinellas County, let them live rent-free in their condominium and had given him other financial help.

"We all had financial problems" after Terri's crisis, she testified. "Michael, Bob. We all did. It was a very stressful time. It was a very financially difficult time. He used to say, 'Don't worry, Mom. If I ever get any money from the lawsuit, I'll help you and Dad.' "

By February 1993, Schiavo had the money from the lawsuit.

On Valentine's Day that year, he testified, he was in his wife's nursing home room studying. He wanted to become a nurse so he could care for his wife himself. He had taken Terri to California for experimental treatment. A doctor there had placed a stimulator inside Terri's brain and those of other people in vegetative states to try to stimulate still-living but dormant cells.

According to Schiavo's testimony, the Schindlers came into Terri's room in the nursing home, spoke to their daughter, then turned to him.

"The first words out of my father-in-law's mouth was how much money he was going to get," Schiavo said. "I was, 'What do you mean?' 'Well, you owe me money.' "

Schiavo said he told his in-laws that all the money had gone to his wife - a lie he said he told Bob Schindler "to shut him up because he was screaming."

Schiavo said his father-in-law called him "a few choice words," then stormed out of the room. Schiavo said he started to follow him, but his mother-in-law stepped in front of him, saying, "This is my daughter, our daughter, and we deserve some of this money."

Mary Schindler's account of that evening is far different. She testified that she and her husband found Schiavo studying. "We were talking about the money and about his money," she said. "That with his money and the money Terri got, now we could take her (for specialized care) or get some testing done. Do all this stuff. He said he was not going to do it."

She said he threw his book and a table against the wall and told them they would never see their daughter again.

The accounts of that confrontation came in testimony during a January 2000 hearing on a petition Schiavo filed to discontinue his wife's life support. Pinellas County Circuit Judge George Greer ruled the next month that the feeding tube could be removed.

Despite the row over money, Schiavo and the Schindlers agreed on one major point in the 2000 testimony: the extent of Terri's brain damage, according to additional court documents cited by The Miami Herald. In the documents, Pamela Campbell, then the Schindlers' lawyer, told the court that "we do not doubt that she's in a persistent vegetative state." Campbell could not be reached to confirm the statement.

At this point, however, the gulf between Schiavo and the Schindlers could not be bridged.

"On Feb. 14, 1993, this amicable relationship between the parties was severed," Greer wrote. "While the testimony differs on what may or may not have been promised to whom and by whom, it is clear to this court that such severance was predicated upon money and the fact that Mr. Schiavo was unwilling to equally divide his loss of consortium award with Mr. and Mrs. Schindler."

Schiavo's feeding tube was briefly removed in 2001. It was reinserted after two days when a court intervened. In October 2003, the tube was removed again, but Gov. Jeb Bush rushed "Terri's Law" through the Legislature, allowing the state to have the feeding tube reinserted after six days. The Florida Supreme Court later ruled that law was an unconstitutional interference in the judicial system.

Nearly two weeks ago, the tube was removed for a third and final time.

It would appear that matters are not as clear cut as would appear and neither the Schindlers nor Michael Shiavo can be held up as having Terri's best interests at heart, although Michael did/does have the weight of legal opinion in his favor.
I think the $700,000 must have been used up some time ago so the next question I would want answered is, "Who was paying for her care and treatment??? Michael or the Schindlers??? Or was it being paid out of public funds and if that were the case I think I would find that disturbing if I were a Florida taxpayer."

Also I have questions on where does an individuals rights end in the matter of his own demise and public opinion takes precedence. Definitely an argument in favor of mandatory living wills as regards 'Right to Die' and organ donation.

Dawg

by tony hopkinson

Thank god for the national health system and a less litiginous society. When you start hearing a million bucks and death it gets a bit worrying.
Something to consider if the state had taken over responsibility for the lady's continuiing existance would they have also been prepared to take over the financial burden as well ?

by oz_media

Her MOTHER had offered to take on ALL financial burdens for 12 months in order for another doctor to work with her rehabilitation, as he had been proven very successful before. This was done with several local businesses who had also offered to sponsor her rehabilitation.

Are we now starting to consider the monetary worth of human life and the burden on taxpayers? Is it cheaper to buy enough bombs to kill them all instead of spending to save lives? People seem to support those tax dollars being haphazardly spent by the hundred billion.

Sometimes it's a reminder of just how nice it is to live in Canada where, for the most part, people put your personal well being ahead of their wallets and own best interests.

by sleepin'dawg

Shouldn't living wills become mandatory for all those past the age of majority; especially when considered from the view point of The Rights of the Individual to determine his own fate.

Dawg

by deepsand

People have property rights as well, but all too many fail to execute a will, with the result that the states have enacted defaults to deal with such.

The fact is that, while approximately 85% of Americans do not wish to be kept alive using extraordinary means, a number that agrees well with the fact that a mere 15% now die a natural death, people resist contemplating their own demise.

One might attempt to induce people to voluntarily execute a living will as a prerequisite for obtaining certain privileges, such as a driver's license, but there is no way to compell them to do so.

The only way to insure that all have a living will would be for the states to enact a default, just as they've done re. the distribution of the property of the deceased.

by oz_media

That's the whole point, Tony.

Tey showed a women who had been 'locked in" foor 12 years before a full and very sudden recovery. She is now a reporter for a major US news outlet.

It was HER doctor that also had another case of several years where a person was said tohave irreversible damage to the brain stem, yet she has now learned to walk, communicate with some sign language and sohw emotion, she's even able to say a FEW words, 'hello', 'thank you', love' etc.

What the problem is, dosctors and people are making decisions of absolute certainty, without having absolute certainty themselves. They have been proven wrong on mroe than one occasion.

If they had saled back to Europe and said the world was round would it have been acceptable for people to still insist that is was flat because they hadn't seen otherwise? Those that thought it was flat, were proven wrong, and must move on to use the new information discovered to better themselves and the world around them.

by oz_media

It is not a known medical fact that there was noone home at all. It is a rather conclusive medical THEORY, but not a fact. In order for it to BE a fact, one would have to determine that people in THAT state of mind will never recover. This has been proven wrong on more than one occasion.

One or two doctors were sure that there was NO HOPE for her rehabilitation and little hope she would even survive. This does not in ANY way, constitute a medical fact though.

If Medical theories were used as medical facts, I would not be concious, I would not be walking and I wouldn't be able to see. I have been told all three at different stages of my life due to accidents or compounded problems.

Thanks to those who DON'T think doctors know everything, I am here today.

IF there was conclusive medical FACT that she would not have ever been rehabilitated, then the case would never have come about to begin with. Because there WAS doubt as to the long term outcome, there was debate as to the best way to deal with it.

by deepsand

Terry's brain was damaged to the point of having lost most of her cerebrum and all but the most instinctive of neurological functions.

Without a functional cerebrum there is no "person."

Furthermore, the courts heard ample testimony to find that to be kept alive indefinitely under such conditions would be contrary to Terry's own wishes.

Therefore, to call her death a "killing" is without grounds.

by oz_media

Firstly, they judges had virtually NO evidence of her wishes except that at the elevnth hour, her husband had said that while watching a TV show one day, of someone being kept alive, she said she wouldn't want to live like that, or so HE says now. The first time this was dragged in front of the courts he failed to mention this, when questioned as to the late realization, he said he had just recently remembered. This is FAR from the courts having AMPLE testimony of her wiches, if they did have ample testimony it would have been reslved several years ago.

As for the damages to her brain stem, it was QUESTIONED as to the extent and never concluded at all. IN fact some doctors had said that it was far from beyond recovery even if just partial. They had similar cases of people with mroe damage who have recovered quite well actually.

She didn't DIE, she was merely left to die by dehydration. Call it what you will.

by sleepin'dawg

to object after four or five years passed with no signs of improvement. In this case we are talking about fifteen years of no improvement and after many different attempts at treatment. The woman had an IQ coefficient less than a six month old baby or as one TV reporter expressed it; a turnip.
I agree all should be done to preserve human life but after a certain point has been reached you know that your efforts are fruitless and you are just warehousing a corpse.
The wishful thinking of the Schindlers was just that, wishful thinking. They mounted a superior PR campaign which drew in support from the pro-life advocates and unfortunately unnecessarily vilified Michael Shiavo. The $700,000 was used up back around 1999 and a big portion of the $350,000 was spent by the beginning of 2001. The Schindlers claimed they would take on the support for Terri for one more year but never demonstrated any capability of paying for that support. Local businesses were going to sponsor her rehabilitation??? What, they planned to sell advertising space around her bed??? If these were public companies their shareholders would raise hell; if private companies or proprietorships, they probably have no clue as to what the costs involved would be but as soon as their contributions exceeded a few thousand dollars you might find that they would want out. Whatever could be done for Terri was done. Surely in fifteen years they must have tried just about everything and were down to charlatans who crawl out of the woodwork to take advantage of situations exactly like this where they have nothing to lose and everything to gain in terms of sucking the Schindlers monetarily dry.
Read the evidence. Both Shiavo and the Schindlers spent lots of time and money searching for anything that would improve Terri's condition. The Schindlers have even acknowledged this in court testimony.
In the manner of her passing, why Terri was not medicated for pain and suffering so as to ease her passage I'll never know but I think it was to create a much more dramatic effect on television. I have heard the repeated stories of her responsiveness but she had absolutely no responsiveness to heat, cold or pain when she was tested. Yes she might smile from time to time when she was having her hair brushed or while being washed; six month old babies do that too but we usually call that gas.

Dawg

by jamesrl

In Canada, the doctor in charge or the board of the hospital determine the course of care. If the doctors think the care is required, and its on the coverage list, its paid without question.

I think in a similar case to the Shiavo case, the doctor might recommend she be sent to a nursing home, which would have been paid privately, though in many cases this institutions do get some gov't subsidies.

James

by deepsand

As I've noted elsewhere, her brain was damaged to the point where most of her cerebrum no longer existed, and had lost all but the most instinctive of neurological functions.

With all due respect, I urge you to recognize that there exists a great chasm of differences between her condition and that experienced by you.

by roger99a

Perhaps you are ready to cross over to the Dark Side!

Actually, that's fine. I wouldn't generalize the voters of either party. They are too diverse. But the party platform is another matter........

by oz_media

I have VERY clearly explained that my case was not even close but is an example of doctors saying there is no hope after doing CAt scans and MRI's.

This is the very first I have heard that there was PROOF that her brain stem was damaged beyond the possibility of even partial recovery. In fact I have seen the doctors breakdown of exactly what damaged was foud and that there was more than enough reason to continue with the other doctors who felt she MAY be rehabilitated as they had revived similar cases with just as much brain stem damage. Oh yeah, like I said before.

by deepsand

His lawyer is his agent; he is the principal.

Basic law of agency: The acts and knowledge of the agent are the acts and knowledge of the principal.

As for the extent of her brain damage, such was determined by independent experts.

by deepsand

Terry stated her feelings in this matter to others as well.

And yes, her cerebrum was damaged beyond "repair."
The brain is NOT a self-healing organ.

While it is possible for certain functions to be regained as a result of its reconstituting some pathways via rerouting, to expect such to here occur would be akin to expecting pigs to learn to fly.

Oz, both the Schindler & the Schiavo families are from a neighboring town; their children attended school less than 3 miles from my house.

We here have had more information available to us, both public and private, than have any others posting here.

We are acutely aware that this incident is one that grew out of longstanding family problems that were exacerbated by Terry's unfortunate condition.

The Schiavo family members, who still live here, have been most gracious in their public statements, taking great care to not pass judgement on the Schindlers.

On the other hand, the Schindlers have allowed hope to blind them to reality, and chose to turn what should have been a private family matter into a 3-ring flying circus.

We have no right to intrude.

by deepsand

I'll not here engage in semantic sparring; we've had more than enough of that at "The Evolution Lie" discussion.

by deepsand

It was a void now filled with spinal fluid.

And, the court FIRST RULED over 5 YEARS AGO that Terri would choose NOT to remain in her then present condition.

There was no rush to "kill" Terri, as some would have you believe.

I do not know what your sources of information have been re. this matter, but it is clear that they have failed to provide you with a full and clear understanding of the facts.

by deepsand

Both families here involved hail from a neighboring municipality, Warminster Township.

Their children attended school less than 3 miles from my home; the Schiavos still live here.

From many of the posts here, and news clips aired on national TV, it is clear that very few possess more than a small understanding of either the lengthy time line involved, the true medical facts, or the great number of court decisions that preceeded the recent flurry of media coverage.

For those of you who care about the facts, I invite you to begin by reading the following:

http://abstractappeal.com/schiavo/infopage.html.

by sleepin'dawg

While a bit disjointed it gives a lot of background that even the papers don't have or have only bits of but not complete. The time line was very helpful in clarifying many things.

Dawg

by deepsand

It does help to provide an overarching outline on which to hang the plethora of factoids that presented by the media.

There are too many people who "know" so many "facts" to the point that they think they know enough to understand the case.

Not unlike the tale of the blind men and the elephant.

by oz_media

The lawyer acts in the clients best interests. If you still actually believe that you are sniffing too much glue. Remeber I come from a family with several(3) lawyers in it.

Lawyers TELL their clients what is in their best interests, the client is merely a puppet, told to shut up until instructed to speak and then only say what they have been told to say.

The lawyers working for her husband were questioned on more than one occasion as being so forceful of thier own beliefs on her husband that he ended up seeking counselling as he was too confused at times and couldn't keep his story straight.

by oz_media

As for local news reports and writings, they are news reports and writings, no more, no less. NO matter what corner of the world you are in you have the same biased quality to all news you read.

Location means squat, unless you knew them personally. Sure they spoke out on television and were interviewed, that tape is also selectively edited to show what the news wants to show. Don't tell me you still believe the news, local OR national.

I have also seen the angle YOU are trying to project, then they showed the OTHER angle, in a very nonbiased and unassuming way. The reports I saw left it to the biewer to reach conclusion based on both sides. YES I agree that the schindlers were not exactly eloquent in their accusations, I also saw that her husband has a knack of changing his mind too quickly and taking a different stand. HE may have been VERY nice, but also left doctors and nurses in tears after making comments wishing she would die so he could claim the insurance as he was going broke fast. One or two had even filed formal police complaints about his actions and comments while in the hospital, long before this came to a peak.

So there's two side to every story and that is wher I reached my conclusions. As for reperable damage, that ws also a matter of legal opinion, HIS doctors said it was irreversible damage, others said it wsoverexaggerated and wasn't actually what they had deemed it was.

So, IF we believe Her hubby and HIS doctors, ye swe will agree with him.

IF we believe the parents and their doctors we will believe them.

It comes down to credibility, which her husband had VERY little of by the time this was decided.

Whether he was a ncie guy from a neighbouring town or not.

I lived in London but it doesn't mean I had more factual info on the Queen than anyone else in the world does.

by sleepin'dawg

At least they were for me. I'm surprised we haven't heard more from the Right To Lifers or the Christian Fundamentalists on this.

Dawg

by jck

I lived down there in St. Petersburg when this wasn't a huge national story, right next to Pinellas Park where Terry Schiavo was. The right to lifers were out in front of that place every day protesting back when it was in local courts. You just didn't see em on the networks til the network news chiefs thought it'd get em ratings.

BTW...I understand having your commitments and standards in life, but how inconsiderate was it of all those people who never knew Terry Schiavo to stand out there and harass the nursing home workers when they were ordered to pull the tube out of her, inconvenience families coming to visit other patients, and most of all not give Terry Schiavo's family their peace at a time in their lives that was so fragile.

Just amazes me...two more cents in the TR pot

by deepsand

1) For years it remained a local issue. We here were aware of it, and considered it a private family matter. It was not until the Schindler's took it national, by way of the press and the legislatures, that most American's first heard of it.

2) The Republican leadership unilaterally engaged itself in an effort to satify its perceived need to satisfy the desires of the Fundamentalist Right. Had they polled that constituancy, they would have known that the overwhelming majority of such believes that such is not a matter for anyone other than the family to decide.

by jkaras

I posted this situation here when it broke locally over a year ago and the debate continues. It was, still, and ever will be a horrible situation. There never was going to be an easy way out.
My problems with this situation was:
1. The use of media and political grandstanding that was done for advancement of careers and angendas. This situation had been around for years and the most feverant never once cared about it before or in the multitude of others that experiences this nightmare. It was a poor example of supposed "humanity".

2. People's demand for politicians to break the law, defying checks and balances on pressures of voting support. This is a family matter not a political one. If you want the politicians to decide care just visit one of our V.F.W. Posts and ask our heroes the level of care they received on their sacrifice to defend our liberties and how it was too expensive to properly treat their health.

3. The speed that which politicians drew up the "Terri Bill" to save a brain dead person beyond rehabilitiation, yet no speed in passing any law to protect children from kidnapping/murdering/raping repeat offenders that are in our news and our neighborhoods everyday? I dont see them passing any laws or convicting corporate bigwigs for bilking investors out of their life savings while they sit fat above the law. How about increasing education rather than just passing the buck? Everyone bought their bs and are like wow he fought for her rights!! No, he didnt, never did over the 15 years, just pandered for votes.

4. People wanting vindication as Terri's survival to their religious beliefs that they are right and everyone is wrong That she was their champion. It became a right to life issue, not a practical treatment of life. In every war or E.R. decisions are made that deem what care is viable to save someone that needs saving. A doctor must prioritize how to save the most that he or she can under the circumstances, its an unfortunate side of life that happens everyday, yet we dont know their names. Many people die in the emergency rooms waitting for help, or because they dont have enough or any medical coverage for proper care, yet nobody cares.

5. Her parents for not willing to let go making her suffer like that selfishly. I understand their feelings, no parent should outlive their child. I too would do everything possible to save my children when I have them, but I cant let someone I love live like that because I cant let go. I have before, let go, I had to turn off the life support on my dad because he was a vegitable and his kidneys failed, the doctors gave no hope of rehabilitation. His wishes was to never be in that position and I had to do it and it hurts even to this day, but their was no choice, he was gone, modern medicine kept him around long enough for me to say my goodbyes to a great father. He gave me that dying wish and as a faithful son whom he protected, guided, and cared for I refused to let him down because I wanted him to be there witnessing my triumphs and there when I failed to make me feel better.

6. The lies that proliferated the media, characterizing her like an Ashwitz survivor, to sell advertisments. That was a disgusting ploy for attention. People reporting that Michael strangled her, that it was an attempted murder, yet not one doctor or nurse could determine that 15 years ago, like they couldnt possibly figure that out back then as if there was no test or that they were that incompetant. Lies were spread on both sides. Do I think Micheal was a saint or a jerk, maybe a little of both. Did he do everything? I dont know, it depends on the amount of good information that the doctors gave him, pushing him this way or that way. Maybe he was like me and didnt want to see someone he loved suffer, or let them down. I never met the man so I cant say, did he attempt to kill her, no. DId he do some offhand things, yes. Was he wrong in wanting to go on with his life after this tragedy? No, if I died I wouldnt want my spouse to never love or live life again, that's selfish. This was the prime example of how important it is to choose the right mate for life, it isnt just fun, financial, sex, and family appeasement you should be considering. You have to choose wisely, and saying you dont know what your spouse is capable of is a lie, you see them in the good and the bad and know full well how they will react in certin incidences, the difference is you blind yourself to meet whichever goal it was wanting them in your life.

7. Why wasnt there any pressure to create a law for proper euthanasia, we do it to our pets why not humans? She didnt need to starve to death.

I know my post sounds rough but it is the truth or my perception of an incident that was informed to me by sources that had agendas that didnt report the facts objectivly. I know from my past experience and how I would like to go. I appreciate all of your posts and not ment to belittle your beliefs. Ever since I heard this story over a year ago I thank everything that it wasnt me and sad for her perdictament. We all wanted her to die with some dignity, unfortunately she was denied it by selfish people.

This discussion is closed to new replies.