Discussion Locked

The UN: New Communist Karma Thugs

0 helpful
118 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

118 replies

by road-dog

Piranhas will ignore smaller prey and attack larger prey en masse. Just because a school of piranhas will ignore a monkey swimming in the river to swarm an ox doesn't mean that the monkey isn't food.

I find it intriguing that you saw fit earlierin this debate to remind us of Australia's presence of the coalition of the willing, yet you take our enemy's ignorance as evidence of the lack of animosity toward Austraila.

I've seen GB and the US as the primary targets of our enemy's ire. I submit that this is because of our nations' identification as the primary participants. Your PM did not participate in globally televised debates in the UN and the Azores Summit. We (the US) make the biggest splash on the world stage, and we are the primary personification of the COW.

Don't take the fact that Arabs aren't burning your flag in their streets as lack of animosity toward your country. Additionally, don't take this posting as evidence of ungratefulness for Australia's participationin the liberation of Iraq and other historic conflicts such as GWI and Korea.

by maxwell edison

Oldefar,

Very well said.

This has my vote for the absolute BEST message posted in all of the "off-topic" dicsussions that have been started lately.

A++

by john_wills

You need to get the facts right. The Palestinians are in fact one of the oldest nations/ethnoses in the world. They are the first Jewish nation and the first Christian nation. However, even if we didn't know that, we would know by objective analysisof the history since 1903 that Zionism is thoroughly immoral. The division of the territory into two states is largely irrelevant: the purpose of any state is to secure such God-given rights as those to life, to liberty and to property. If the Israeli state stops violating property rights a tenth of the exiled Palestinians will return home to freehold, and many more to other kinds of tenure. All the terrorism you condemn is the result of dispossession: you cannot name any justification, can you, for the 1903 decision to dispossess the Palestinians in the first place? As long as you spout pro-Zionist rubbish you ARE controlled by the Zionists, whether or not you admit the fact. And as long as you support the dispossession of the Palestinians as such YOU are a racialist, not I.

by road-dog

Define zionist for me.

I understand zionism as the Israeli (post UN creation after WWII) assertion that they have a right to security within their UN established and internationally recognized borders. The term Zion historically meaning the Jewish homeland. "Zionist" doctrine justifies the occupation of what Arabs refer to as Palestine which was never a country, but a region of Jordan under "spoils of war" and as a buffer zone between Israel and hostile arab nations.

As I recall, Palestine as a province of Jordan was a problem where the King of Jordan forcibly put down secessionist movements, killing thiousands of Palestinians in the process. Is this the 1903 event to which you refer? If not explain further, please.

by john_wills

In 1903 the Zionists picked the Palestinians to dispossess. They could have had a then uninhabited territory elsewhere. This really belongs in a different discussion, mis-headed "Light on the Middle East".

by admin

I am either pro-Palestine or Zionist? Rubbish.

The truth is, there is not enough property for everyone, especially in that region. There will never be a "Right" or "Fair" decision for everyone, but there probably can be a workable one. It's thefleas arguing over who owns the dog again, well, no one does, but for their own survival and well-being there are going to have to be some borders drawn not on the basis of what is right, but what is best for those involved. What is best is not a black and white decision and the extreme camps that think they are fighting for God (like a God by definition really needs us to fight FOR them anyway) or who was there first will only maintain the death counts and unrest in the region.

I'm going todeclare myself pro-human on this issue: I want the people of all races there to benefit and compromise. How does this make me a Zionist?

by john_wills

The Palestinians are not violating property rights. The Israelis are: most of the land in the 1948 territories is the private property of people being kept in exile. Practically all of the settlements in the 1967 territories are on stolen private property. This discussion is really about the UN; this item belongs more properly in the discussion entitled "Light shed on the Middle East".

by hal 9000

Curbed the power of the King and Lords/Barons ect it also curbed the power of the Government of the time and all subsequent times. For example "No free man shall have a complaint bore against him by an officer of the Crown". This documents is TitledIn Perpurtery and For All Time. It's preety clear to its exact meaning little things Like no free man sahl be deprived of his horse and cart and many others like that. It actually placed controls upon the peerage of the then time and all subsequent times to free the comon people from the excesses of the Perrage.

As far as being called subjests it just a word and I notice that the Queen of England/British Commonwealth draws bigger crowds when she visits the US than when she visits any of herso called members of the Commonwealth.

by hal 9000

But lets leave aside the bit about the Emperor for the time being, Yes a lot of the higher miletary chose to comit suside but there where still quite a few more who where installed into political office by the US after the ceasation of hostilities. Then ther was the U35 branch of the Japanese Government which did something similar to what J. Mengelar did in Germany. Once the war had finished the Allies rightly claimed that all Mengelars work where crimes against humanity, however the Japenise group that did the same things where transported into the US and formed the basis for your current Bio & Chem warfare weapons. None of this group was ever tried as War Criminals but then they only infected people and disected them while still alive tosee the rate of progress of the Bio or Chem contimanition that they had inflicted.

by maxwell edison

colinluck - get your head out of your down under.

This is about the fourth time in as many threads that you've responded to someone else's message, argument, claim, or charge (against you), and you addressed me in your reply as though I'm the one who said it. It started with the "know-it-all" charge someone (someone else, by the way) made against you, yet you turned on me for it. (I did agree with him, however.)

You and Julian must spend your days seeing who can guzzle the most Fosters.I think you've had enough.

The only thing I've ever said about you is that you're a blow-hard prevaricator, and a disingenuous, unintelligible moron. Well, okay, I've never really said that. (But I've sure thought it.)

You're obviously obsessed with me for some strange or deranged reason. Get over it, already.

by road-dog

You have finally said something that I agree with. Operation Paperclip was the program where we absorbed German engineers and technology. This same treatment was also extended to Japanese war criminals. I'm not sure why, but I have a couple of theories.

1- The President considered the atomic bombs sufficient punishment nationally.
2- The world was tired of war, and the US was afraid that American citizens would call for the total destruction of Japan if the scope of the atrocities came to light, as would happen in an international trial. Of these atrocities, many were committed against Americam POWs, a little more inflamatory than the Holocaust committed against other nationals.
3- It had generally become accepted that Patton was right, and that we would soon be worrying about the USSR. If this were the case, then any weapons advantage would need exploit, regardless of source.

I think you're confusing me and Max.

I can't even remember what got us on the subject of Japan, but I must say I agree on this issue.

by admin

Pericles in Athens, Greece around 400 B.C. said:"

"Our government does not copy our neighbors, but is an example to them. It is true that we are called a democracy, for the administration is in the hands of the many and not of the few."

and although Greece may be the cradle, it didn't start there either.

Either way it was long before Christ set foot on this planet. :)

by hal 9000

There has in the past been no colinising power who has ever provided a real form of Foregin Policy it has what has always been Politically expident at the time. The current India/Pakistan borders where drawn up purely on religious grounds when the Poms where forced out of India which covered both these countries. They also took no responibility for the mass killings that ensured in the so called transisition period.

But surely this type of supitidy is what we should be learning from and not continue to repeat it at every opportinuty.

by road-dog

that the British Empire really had no control over the demarcations arising in their former colonies. They were leaving after rebellion and were in no position to dictate the terms of post war government and borders.

Perhaps the maxim should be:don't overthrow your government unless you've thought through a new one.

Iraq is a different case, as we have overthrown an existing government. (let's not debate justification again) The COW now has a direct responsibility to provide for all ofthe needs of Iraq to transition them to self-rule. If they are invaded by another nation in the interim, we MUST protect them. If they need food, It is our job to provide it. This is daunting indeed.

I believe that we are up to the task, and we now must keep all of the different factions from open warfare and get them to create a government that they can agree on.

by hal 9000

To any of Bob Dylans Songs as in most of these he points out exactly what you have been saying above.

by maxwell edison

I wish that for just one time you could stand inside my shoes,

and just for that one moment i could be you.

Yes, i wish that for just one time you could stand inside my shoes.

Then you'd know what a drag it is to see you.

-Bob Dylan

by john_wills

I did not ask you to address a question about governmental stupidity. The question is: What are the states with which you are concerned doing contrary to the purpose of the state? Not: How are they failing in their purpose, or how they are being stupid or which of their policies you disagree with. I have several times found via such analysis that the things I thought more or less important are really less or more important.

As for the UN being consistently against US interests, you seem unaware that many people think the UN a US front. I do not attempt to defend that position, but you should be aware that it exists.

by jardinier

What I perceive as I browse these disucussions is that if you are an American -- and especially if you are also a long-established member of TR -- you can express any point of view about America and that's cool.

But if you are a foreigner, any posting that is perceived in any way as anti anything about America, you (well let's say me, if you prefer) are immediately derided as a bigot, anti-American, oversensitive, or making an emotive statement not supported by facts.

I find the proof ofthis observation in the case of John Wills who, while continually trying to push his Zionist theories, is never labelled a bigot, fanatic, ratbag or anything else. He is apparently immune from criticism because he is an American.

I won't accept the label of "bigot" just because my opinion may differ from yours. Nor am I over sensitive: I am genuinely concerned about how international events are evolving at the present time.

This discussion is closed to new replies.