Discussion Locked

The verbal flogging of MAX

0 helpful
53 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A new game, step right up and try it!

Rules, pick someone to flog. Reason? You don't need no stink'en reason! (say out loud with the proper accent)

How does one qualify for such an honor? They are just lucky I guess. ;\

Who gets to decide who gets flogged and over what? Why [b] I DO[/b] of course! (silly!)

Fair play? Maybe, maybe not. Just have to see how the day goes by! :D (I have a feeling he will do just fine!)

The only hard part of this, is going to be finding a post he has done that was [b]proven wrong with unbiased data.[/b] Hmmm, this may take a while.....

I know! Lets just try to make Mambo blush instead! That one is always fun!

53 replies

by old guy

Maybe we need to find that donkey to give YOU a hug today. Hmmmm?

(Added: Shrek)

by gadgetgirl

I'm all for making DangerMouse beam like a beacon, you know that, I'm game for it, but why oh why do you have to go and suggest something good like that, that would brighten up this rotten day for me, just as I'm about to pack up and go home? Grrrr!! X-(

oh, well, if I start, will you finish? (DE)

o........k!

I got the basque, matching nix and suspenders that you sent me for Christmas, but the seamed stockings were a bit shredded by the time they got here. Also the paddle is a bit large for playing ping-pong with - was there another use for it?

Oh, and I think my tame Postie must have realised the jar was the chocolate body paint, as the contents were missing by the time it reached my mail box......

Hope the squirty cream, willy weight training kit and love cuffs arrived in one piece. I had to write the contents on the back of the envelope not so that your postman would know, but so that they would know what was setting off the metal detector in the security bay......

(See any beacons across the US sky yet??!! ;) )

oh, it's good to be back!

]:)

GG

by jdclyde

If that didn't do it gg, then I don't seem much doing it anymore.

NOTE: Now you have something to look forward to when you com in in the morning! ]:)

Weight training is going just fine, and I have the oxygen takes standing by next to the fire place. (I had to put visqueen down over the bear skin rug so it wouldn't get ruined!

:x

by dmambo

I'm like the bad puritan. I know it's wrong, but I sneak a peek anyway. If you guys would be so kind as to keep the shades drawn on your virtual tryst, I can remain pure in peace.

That'll be the name of my auto-biography - "Pure in Peace"

by dr dij

him saying that newsweek lied about torture in gitmo? he had the gall to suggest newsweek, a printed magazine, by printing the truth, would somehow be responsible for deaths in a pakistan riot.

the pentagon later admitted it.

Max then had the nerve to say he was 'joking'.

He looked pretty serious in most of the posts as were the responders, till post 275 where after the torture was admitted, he didn't say 'i was wrong' but says the whole thing was , what was the word, maybe sarcasm?

he's so hung up on the 'liberal media' that he doesn't want to admit that they are sometimes right. There's a place for a free press, and this is a great example of it working!

The great thing about this country is that we hang our dirty laundry out, which tends to keep the govt from cr*pping their pants again.

Apparently not with domestic spying tho.

by dr dij

I didn't think of my reply as verbal flogging.

Maybe others do this, with name calling. I try and make reasoned replys. name calling etc is stupid even if you don't agree with someone.

I admire max for having his opinions even if I don't agree with all of them. Much like Apotheon starts people thinking. Some called him idiotic names, just plain silly.

If more people would think and have opinions, maybe this country (and planet) wouldn't be in the mess it is in.

by jdclyde

is I agree with MAX on this and feel there is such a thing as reckless journalism that is INTENED to inflame and incite.

You are intitled to your opinion. Everyone has the right to be wrong. :D

by dr dij

it happened. I doubt newsweek said 'go out and riot and carelessly kill each other by accident after being fanned into flames by radical clerics'.

if newsweek said the govt was killing puppies and PETA people got mad and got hurt, and it turns out it was the truth should we have hidden it?

the reality is there is no way to predict what might happen, and even if there was I don't see reason we should hide the truth. that's even more horrible to keep atrocities under the covers.

by maxwell edison

.
You waste your time arguing with even BIGGER idiots over issues about which you have absolutely no control. What's the friggin point, you MORON? Do you think you're going to change anyone's mind? Of course not. Try beating your stupid head against the wall instead.

And not only that, but you have an absolutely GREAT idea for a new business; you've spent hundreds of hours researching the market and writing a business plan; but you've done nothing to advance it. Where's that business plan that you wrote? It's probably still sitting in a friggin' desk drawer doing nothing. How stupid is that? Either S*** or get off the pot, and start to practice what you preach.

What a total imbecile you are.

Thanks, jd. I feel better.

by jdclyde

Of the people here, I knew you would take this in the right spirit! :D

Now I need to get back to GG's post. That one threw me off pace....... ]:)

by jamesrl

I came on reading the original post and working myself up into a state to write a nice stinging bit of abuse.

And then you take the wind out of my sails.

I think you owe me a coffee.

James

by jdclyde

there were no atrocities in the humiliation of these enemy combatants. Improper? Yes. Torture? No. Atrocities? No.

And there WERE parts of the story that were NEVER proven, about the sesicration of the Kuran. A huge book was flushed down the inadiquate plumbing in Iraq? Only a complete fool would belive that.

And there ARE times when all the information is not required to report a story. In very grisly murders, do you see pictures of it on the front page? Are they hiding the truth? Of course not.

It served no purpose other than to make Bush and the US look bad. Remember that the story was released by the military, not "discovered" as part of a cover-up. Investigations were already underway on this as you would know if you were following the story as it broke.

So parts of the Newsweek article WAS wrong.

Ask yourself honestly, who benifited by this atricle being released in the fashion it was. The only people I can think of in the WORLD that benifited were Newsweek stockholders and the Democratic party, because anything that is bad for the country right now is good for them.

And yes, you CAN reasonably predict what will happen when you print stories and world events happen. "even if there was I don't see reason we should hide the truth". you just admitted that the it doesn't matter if you incite people to violence based on the way you choose to report a story and on how much is reveiled.

I can't agree with that. Just like shouting "fire" in the movie theater, they shouted "fire" to the invaders coming into Iraq. (formally know as "insurgents"). They knew full well what would happen and that was their intention all along.

by jamesrl

The job of a journalist is not to editorialize, it is to report, honestly and truthfully, and hopefully with a minimum of bias.

Any publication or news program has to weigh releasing a story. If the story is already in the rumour mill, which the Koran story was, it is in the public's best interest to have what they know to be the truth at the time than to let the rumour circulate unchecked. But there are times when it is better to wait for more facts and detail than to publish unsubstantiated information (paging Dan Rather).

Its not up to any media to hide a story. They have to balance the public's right to know with the need to be accurate. That doesn't impact if the story will be released, but when. I don't disagree with Newsweek publishing the story, but the question open for debate is whether they had enough facts to go on (whether or not they were proven correct in the end is irrelevant).

Publishing the gory picture of the murder is sensationalism. It doesn't actually add any real content to the story, it can only serve to titillate some and horrify others. The Abu Ghraib pictures were published, and rightly so, because they contributed to the story - the issue being the definition of torture.

And JD I do disagree about whether anyone was tortured. If I arrested you, tied you up, refused to let you sleep, paraded you naked, deliberately tried to humuliate you, its torture. It is more psychologic than physical but its torture just the same.

If any police officer in North America did that, they would and should be tried. Unless you are willing to throw out the presumption of innocence, one of the cornerstones of our modern legal system, then how can you justify treating these people with any kind of torture.

James

by jdclyde

are NOT innocent until proven guilty.

combatants off the battlefield do not have ANY of the protections that OUR constitution provide as they are not US citizens.

combatants CAN have sleep deprivation and other mental forms of persusion used on them, and SHOULD have these used on them. The information they have is time sensitive, and if it leads to stopping future attacks, only a fool would care more about hurting their feeling than putting an end to terrorist strikes.

I have absolutely no problem with them having their feelings hurt. It is still much better treatment than YOU would recieve if they got their hands on you. They all lived to cry about it. You wouldn't be so lucky.

by jamesrl

The job of a journalist is not to editorialize, it is to report, honestly and truthfully, and hopefully with a minimum of bias.

Any publication or news program has to weigh releasing a story. If the story is already in the rumour mill, which the Koran story was, it is in the public's best interest to have what they know to be the truth at the time than to let the rumour circulate unchecked. But there are times when it is better to wait for more facts and detail than to publish unsubstantiated information (paging Dan Rather).

Its not up to any media to hide a story. They have to balance the public's right to know with the need to be accurate. That doesn't impact if the story will be released, but when. I don't disagree with Newsweek publishing the story, but the question open for debate is whether they had enough facts to go on (whether or not they were proven correct in the end is irrelevant).

Publishing the gory picture of the murder is sensationalism. It doesn't actually add any real content to the story, it can only serve to titillate some and horrify others. The Abu Ghraib pictures were published, and rightly so, because they contributed to the story - the issue being the definition of torture.

And JD I do disagree about whether anyone was tortured. If I arrested you, tied you up, refused to let you sleep, paraded you naked, deliberately tried to humuliate you, its torture. It is more psychologic than physical but its torture just the same.

If any police officer in North America did that, they would and should be tried. Unless you are willing to throw out the presumption of innocence, one of the cornerstones of our modern legal system, then how can you justify treating these people with any kind of torture.

James

by Member 25348569

You get to treat people as badly as you want because they aren't US citizens. Does that make them (me? GG? Colin?) somehow less entitled to be treated according to humane conventions? Anyway, aren't you supposed to be showing the Iraqi citizens - and certainly some of the captives are also citizens - the benefits of the American Way Of Life?

You also get to behave badly and torture - that's what it is, by the way - people because they might do the same or worse to you? Not acceptable behaviour at all!

Hey, JD. [b]We[/b] invaded [b]them[/b]. Then we forced our idea of democracy on them, then we torture some of them and [b]we[/b] are the good guys? LOL!

Just the Devil's Advocate viewpoint.

Neil ]:)

by gadgetgirl

(Happy New Year, btw!)

you had to go and mention behaving badly, torture AND me all in the same post....and he'd just been going on about sleep deprivation ;)

I just KNOW jd's gonna have a field day with that one...judging by the number of times he's posted "if it hurts - do it again!" :D

Yup, things are getting back to normal in TRland...:p

GG

by Member 25348569

on my "let's wind up JD post" I had a small bet when about about including you! I wasn't disappointed. :p

Still, I'm not sure that even Jacqui could get enjoyment out of sensory deprivation (except, perhaps, as one necessary part of a weekend's 'fun'). ]:)

And a Happy New Year to you, babz. :D

What's the weather like? It's sunny(ish) down here for the first time this week!

Neil

by jamesrl

it would be acceptable to be tortured?

The people held in Gitmo are neither Prisoners of war nor covered by your constition. If they are as you say combatants, they are entitled to be treated to the standards of the Geneva convention. And that convention forbids torture.

And not all those in Abu Ghraib were combatants caught in the act or found with weapons in their possession.

I don't give a damn about their feelings. I care that the US doesn't fight terrorism by becoming exactly what the terrorsist portray the US as. That helps the terrorists cause, and helps them recruit.

I doubt there is anything time sensitive about the information that anyone held in Gitmo has, seeing as they were captured in 2002 and held there for 3 years. Try them or release them. Otherwise it is no better than Russia's Gulags.

James

by gadgetgirl

[b]UNLIKE YOURSELF!!![/b]

(wahey! right in the kisser! couldn't resist!!)

Sunshine? Sunshine?? oh, hang on a mo', I think I remember that....yeah, that's ....no, that's the moon. Ah yes, that's the yellow beacon in the sky....sorry, was a bit confused, keep remembering the red beacon DMambo causes.

You have sunshine?

SEND ME SOME!! I'm in the dull, damp, dark and dismal north! and it's been like this (mostly) for weeks! Dammit, now I'm going to have to have a Lusso to cheer me up when I get home.....

:p

GG

by maecuff

All victims of torture (unless they are killed or detained forever) can walk away and cry about it later. That doesn't make it something other than torture.

by gadgetgirl

No, DM, more like "Red Moon Shining", I think! :D

[b]AND[/b] you just admitted to sneaky peeking on us!!

HEY EVERYBODY.........LOOK!!! OVER HERE!!!

DMambo is a [b]VOYEUR[/b] He admitted it!

He's a [b]PEEPING TOM!!!!![/b]

(Happy New Year, DM!! ;) )

]:)

GG

by jdclyde

He is a peeping MAMBO! :^O

A quote from the old Peter Sellers movie, - [i]Being there.[/i]
[b]
"I like to watch" :O

[/b]
Pure peice, is that like a holy f$$k? (did I just say that out loud? :8}

by gadgetgirl

yes, you said that out loud! Bad boy, jd! I've told you - keep language like that OFF the TR Board, and UNDER the duvet, with us.......;\

now, where's that choccie body paint when you need it....ooooh! watch where you're squirting that cream, jd! :8} :O

]:)

GG

by jdclyde

Ok, seems like I fell behind so I will try to handle (feel up) everyone at once! :O Well, maybe not James and Neil, but they can run the camera if they wish! ]:)

First, I only refered to the combatents, not other people "picked up" along the way.

Second, I NEVER endoresed physical abuse on anyone other than maybe BinLadin if someone gets their hands on him. Quarting would be too good for the likes of him.

Would I torture non-combatants? Only if they are really really cute and say please! Humiliation, sleep deprivation, and even a touch of fear are all just fine by me. sorry that this bothers you, but not sorry that I feel this way. I see torture as putting people in the rack and stretching them, or pullin their nails off, or putting them in the meat grinders (like Saddams son used to do to people). THESE are[b] torture[/b] people. What I have seen from the pictures, the only thing hurt on these prisoners was their pride. Waaa.

[i]"no better than Russia's Gulags"[/i]. James, obviously you have no idea what went on in the Russian Gulags or you would not make such a silly statement. Geniva convention does not state that you can't humiliate someone, does it? I DO know it forbids the bobytrapping of bodies, but I for some reason never heard an uproar about that. The silence was deafening.

NOW, on to tying up GG. Now we are ready to rock! And yes mae, with proper medication you can come and play too! (think waterboy, "you can do it, ALL night long!") ]:)

Sunshine, we are suppose to get our first sunshine of the YEAR today, but only for a while. We had very little last month as well (or so I heard. No window in my office. Dark when I go in, dark when I leave)

(Now I can't get the visual of GG licking her lips out of my mind! oh yeaaaaaah!)

By the way Neil, the irony was not lost on me about an athiest playing the DEVILS advocate? WAY too funny, but it seems I am the only one to pick up on that? B-)

by jdclyde

I hear all the time exercise is good for you, besides nobody listens to me! B-)

Newsweek and CNN reach global audiances with millions getting that message. (see a difference?)

And I never claimed to be a journalist, nor am I saying anything that would/should inflame you to commit acts of violence.

Also, being your first discussion you participated in, let me tell you this was a joke discussion. Just giving Max a hard time after he got worked up in a different discussion. Think of it as a "celebrity roast!" :D

Relax, welcome aboard, and enjoy the ride.

by tartanterror

I meant to add a smiley to the end of that last post. I do realise this is a joke discussion and as a namby pamby left wing liberal was really just taking the p*ss due to our obvious (to me, but maybe not to you since it was my first post) political differences.
I apologise if it seemed in anyway aggressive/nasty. Too much pot smoking and talking to flowers I guess :)

by jdclyde

no harm, no foul.

Hug a tree for me while your at it? :D

(yes, it DID seem agressive, but I just wrote it off to walking in the middle of a conversation and not getting the joke that it was intended to be.)

by jdclyde

I like it when your forceful! :x

"Come on baby, make it hurt so good" - John cougar Melencamp ]:)

by tartanterror

"Combatants CAN have sleep deprivation and other mental forms of persusion used on them, and SHOULD have these used on them. The information they have is time sensitive, and if it leads to stopping future attacks, only a fool would care more about hurting their feeling than putting an end to terrorist strikes."

While no sane person would argue that stopping future attacks is paramount surely torture is inherently flawed. How do you know if the information you are getting is true? You believe the people being tortured are capable of committing attrocities against your country but you don't believe they're capable of giving false information to stop the torture? Or, if they're willing to die for their 'cause', wouldn't be willing to send you on a wild goose chase in the hope of buying enough time for the attack to take place no matter what you do to them? If I was kept blindfolded but awake for three days I'd tell you anything you wanted to hear for a bit of shut eye! And I'd do it even quicker if it was physical torture.

by maecuff

participate in this. It's just mean. To pick on Max, well, isn't that like shooting fish in a barrel?

by jdclyde

if not MAX, then WHO?

Hey, Where is K_R_A_M, (I mean M_A_R_K)? He is always fun to give a hard time!

:^O

BAAAAAAAA!

:O

by maecuff

Personally, I like to find blind people with no legs and give them a swift kick. They can't see who did it and they can't chase me.

It's my own personal, cheap therapy.

by jdclyde

but different, very very different.

I LOVE the last scene where he is walking across the water, stops, sticks his umbrella down to see how deep it is, and then keeps walking......

It also teaches you what happens if you watch too much TV.

So how did you come to watch that show after all this time?

by maecuff

My husband is reading a book called 1001 movies you must see before you die, or something of the sort. We get netflix and he's adding movies from this book to our queue. (Not all 1001, just the ones he thinks look interesting).

I loved the ending. It was unexpected. Of course, now that we've seen it, my husband can't stop saying, "I like to watch, Eve."

We have such different taste in movies. He likes movies of substance. I just like it when sh*t blows up. At least that's what I say. I can't admit too often that I like his movies, or all we'll ever watch will have subtitles.

We just watched "In the Bedroom" last night. It was good, but extremely depressing. I'm glad I watched it, but I would never watch it again. I'm going to have to break out Die Hard to even out. (I have a thing for Alan Rickman)

by jamesrl

He seems to play the same charecter over and over - be it Robin Hood's Sherriff or Harry Potter's Snape, its the same sneer and snarl.

But in Truly Madly Deeply (warning Chick flick) he actually gets to play a lighter role(even though he is playing a ghost).

James

by maecuff

I LOVE that movie. Even though there are no explosions. It is so sweet. Every time I watch it, it makes me cry.

by jdclyde

on why people watch sad movies that make you cry.

A lot of the world sucks bad enough, I don't need to Pay money to feel bad, I could just walk down the street and go uptown.

Give me a comedy, give me an action, give me hot babes on spring break with no dialog other than "do these look real?" :O

Sad shows where the kid dies in the end or something, why would I EVER want to watch something like that? I wouldn't.

Chick flicks where the wife has a romantic fling or the chick flick where the poor wife is deglected while her pig of a husband is having a horrible affair. (notice the way the two are portraid differently and one is good the other is bad)

And yes, I too like to watch! ]:)

by jdclyde

doesn't sound promising.... :D

"We never even WANTED to until you told us we couldn't! You can have this and these but NOT this!" - Sam Kinison :^O

I miss Sam and his "home for interesting women". B-)

by oz_media

Stand beside a blind person with a friend, and while gasping in awe, say "I wouldn't believe it if I hadn't see it with my own eyes! Oh my GOD!!!....Look out!!!!"

Then run away while making heavy footsteps so the person hears you running away from ....something!

Another one we tried (unsuccessfully) as kids. I lived across the street from the CNIB (Canadian Nat. Inst. for the Blind). Years ago, it wasn't common to have an audio signal at a pedestrian crossing. The CNIB had signals on the crosswalks in front of their building. So we, as kind hearted children, decided to record the signal with a ghetto blaster (remember those babies!)and play it back while blind people were waiting to cros the street (Main street in Vancouver). I guess they have pretty good hearing though, because with the few people we tried, they pretty ,much all turned towards us and said, "That's not funny at all!" or just waited for the correct signal.

No, I'm a nice guy...LOL!!

by maecuff

Mr Smarty Pants..Truly Madly Deeply was none of those things. It was about a ghost who tries to get his fiance to get on with her life after his death.

I DON'T like movies where kids die or people cheat, or really, most chick flicks. I do, however, like some movies that are touching, like the Color Purple, Field of Dreams, Clockwork Orange.. :)

by oz_media

I just can't bring myself to flog Max for no reason. In fact recently we have agreed on more than we disagree on, except his senseless idea of how wonderful the USA's grand furor is.

But hey, Max and I go WAAAAAAAAAAAY back, I think we go back farther than most of the TR staff. One of my first posts here was after observing Max's banter with others that were regulars at the time. As I was intensly studying psyche at the time, and was having a debate over a magazine article, I used him as a guinnea pig with a similar post.

As far as politics go, I think Max is very informed of what he chooses to believe about the US, and appears to be very closed minded towards the rest of the world or hearing alternative beliefs to his own. In short, too quick to dismiss the alternatives before considering them.

But everyone is entitled to [i]my[/i] opinion.

It wouldn't be as much fun here if we all just agreed with everything each other said anyway, would be some pretty short, single tier discussions.

"I hate bush"
"me too"
"yup"
"and I "
"too true"

Wouldn't be any fun at all.

I know Max likes to resort to flames in the form of somewhat witty remarks, and slanderous character attacks, but that's how he keeps the energy up in the discussions.

Al in all, I welcome his comments, usually most of it can be easily dismissed but then again he has some good points too.

by oz_media

I always thought you would be into the more cerebral movies and left the teen focused action crap to your hubby.

I get both really, as I have close ties with Rogers, I still get DVD's sent to me fr review before they are released (I help count the bad stuff for the in store ratings).

A good friend of mine works for a DVD distribution company, so I end up gettng al the foreign films and indie films from him on promo too.

A few REALLY cool movies I've seen lately are Turles Can Fly (story about Kurdish orphans who band together to clear land mines for money from teh UN clearing teams while waiting for the US to invade Iraq). Danny Deckchair, a hilarious movie about an Aussie who ties ballons to his deckchair until he flies into Northern Australia (that's where the fun begins) and a whole bunch of really good indie films.

Between the enw releases and indie/foreign films, foreign films win out almost everytime. Less money on bombs, sorry, but excellent photography, acting, scripts and plots.

Sure beats the crap we are fed in our theatres, I just wish we could escape 'the big four' in the industry that control music, movies, radio and TV in North America, we really get ripped off for quality content!

by maecuff

Please, no delusions about me. I LOVE special effects. The bigger the better. I am willing to suspend my disbelief regardless of whether I'm watching a movie or reading a book. Or really, dealing with most of my employees. And my boss. And two of my kids.

Anyway, I LOVED King Kong. I loved all the special effects. I loved seeing Narnia with my son. I am completely sucked in by it. While it's happening, I believe it. (This is also why I having a trillion dollars worth of anti-aging things in my room, I truly believe they will work. They haven't yet, but there is one out there, I'm sure of it.) I am a total skeptic in real life, but give me a movie or a book and I believe it all..this is also why I won't watch slasher movies and why I don't like the real heart wrenching stuff, it's either too disturbing, or too painful. Or just plain sappy and stupid.

And yes, the cerebral stuff is good much of the time. But the mindless stuff has it's value.

by hal 9000

Your a Masochist and enjoy pain! :p

When I first saw the topic of this thread I thought it a bit unfair but when I opened it I couldn't stop laughing and then you posted. :D

Anyway got to get back to that dirty 4 letter word W##K. :(

See you latter.

Col ]:)

by jdclyde

it made me laugh too! Matter of fact, it got twice as funny when MARK didn't get my pebkac comment at the end. Good thing the Things went back to their female parental units place or they would be wondering if the old man has lost his marbles, sitting in the other room giggling like a fool.

Of course, some got WAY too serious, but we know how to handle them! :D

This discussion is closed to new replies.