Discussion Locked

This country was built on the sweat of Unions !

0 helpful
51 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For all those "uninformed" out there (and judging by your response to the Unionize IT Blog, you are uninformed), Unions built this country.
For if it weren't for the unions, "Management" would be making little or no money with no benefits at all...Professionals and unions "are" a perfect match (because Unions don't take just anybody). You need credentials to join one. I've been on "both sides of the fence" and believe me with corporate greed at a new high, unionize or get used and abused friend ! It's not about the money, it's about respect for a good days work !If anyone disagrees, let them work in a non-union sweat shop(like my Mom did)for less than $70 per week with conditions that the homeless would reject ! Her Vacation was getting "layed-off" for 2 weeks a year and collecting un-employment !So, get your facts straight, before you dis unions...

51 replies

by jamesrl

I have my facts pretty straight. I managed in an environment where we had two groups that did the same job - at one site they were union, at the other they were not.

Salary ranges were the same. But for my non-union shop, I could reward the people who put out extra effort. In the union shop there were very strict regulations and it was very difficult to single out one individual, unless you were prepared to give the rest of the crew the same reward. And you didn't need credentials to join either one - who needs to get their facts straight.

My father was a hydro lineman, and when he started, he was not unionised (in the 50s). In the early 70s he was unionized and did see some improvements. He even became a shop steward. By the time he was ready to retire, he was so fed up with union politics and infighting that he wouldn't speak with union officials.

Unions were helpful before governments implemented workplace health and safety and general labour laws were in place to protect people from the worst abuses. There were good and bad employers before unions, and good and bad employers after unions.

James

by prefbid ii

Unions suffer the same fate as any monopolistic arrangement. The power goes to their heads eventually and its very hard to control the group once they believe they have a devine right to be in control.

I think I would be more likely to think of unions in a positive light if they were regulated like the SEC regulates the business world. The SEC is far from perfect, but it does generally help level the playing field. Unions, by and large, are too easily controlled by ruthless people who can figure out ways to keep their own membership from knowing what they are up to.

by maxwell edison

You said, "...believe me with corporate greed at a new high...."

Before I automatically "believe you", will you please qualify that statement by comparing corporate greed's new high to corporate greed's old high? When did it break the old high? Is that adjusted for inflation? Please chart the highs and lows of corporate greed over the years and decades, or provide links to existing charts. There are surely charts available, as corporate greed is cited time and time again for whatever ails us lowly workers. And please define corporate greed, and provide a benchmark of some sort so we can compare it to other kinds of greed, and so we can differentiate between corporate greed and acceptable corporate profit. Speaking of which, will you also please provide some sort of measure to show when an acceptable corporate profit breaks through the ceiling to become corporate greed? And while you're at it, will you also please answer the same questions as it relates to individual greed?

Thank you in advance for indulging my questions.

by maxwell edison

.
I'd guess that Jimmy Hoffa's tomb was built on the sweat of that particular union boss! Man, he must have been sweating!

by maxwell edison

Where can I get a list of all the non-union sweat shops in the United States?

And when did your mom work for $70 a week. Was that in 2005 or 2004? Or was it before that? And when she earned only $70 a week, how much did a gallon of milk cost? How much did the average house cost? Everything is relative, you know.

by sleepin'dawg

helping to increase the rate of inflation Otherwise unions themselve have become big business. I wonder how all those employees at GM and Delphi are feeling now. Their laziness and the greed of their union has put their jobs in jeopardy.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by maxwell edison

It's cost the company market share, it's caused huge corporate losses, and now it's causing the layoffs of thousands.

And that guy's emotional rant won't change it. In fact, if he had his way, it would only get worse.

Unions are bad -- bad for business, bad for the consumer, and bad for employees.

(Think he'll answer any of my questions?)

by tony hopkinson

So you are saying criticising unions is unpatriotic now ?
I was in a union for 19 years in the UK, paid my dues and they did alright by me personally, but they didn't build anything except a heathly bank balance and a job for life for their officials.

10,000 members who voted the mealy mouthed whining two faced back stabbing self serving gits into that position took it right up the ass though.

Once the real labour movement became unncessary, unions became political. Officials became politicians and their entire reason for existance was remodeled so the b'stards running them could keep their faces in the trough.

Don't ask me to trust or believe in a politician, it isn't going to happen.

by tonythetiger

But they have become an albatross around the neck of productivity.

Jobs can become obsolete, and so can institutions. The union is the blacksmith of institutions.

by sleepin'dawg

A lot of things have changed since then and union have outlived their usefulness now.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

Right off the bat, it was the "Unionize IT" DISCUSSION, not a blog. (nice to get your facts wrong in the same sentence that claims other people aren't getting the facts right! :D )

Unions had a purpose, a long time ago. That time is long past.

The Union worker is as lazy as the government worker is. they got their position and have to do very little to keep that job and walk out with a paycheck everyweek.

Lots of stand around time WASTED, because three workers have to stand around waiting for the CORRECT union rat to come to that one specific thing that would have taken any one of the three workers 10 seconds to do if they were ALLOWED to touch that part.

ANY organization where you advance based on how many years you have been punching a clock instead of they quality of worker you are, is corrupt and full of incompetent people.

A non-union shop will out perform a union shop everytime because they will ususally give an incentive like profit sharing based on PROFITS. The harder they work, the more they get.

I have worked both union and non-union, both on the floor as a shop rat and in the "front office". I would NEVER want to go back to the union shops again.

I used to get yelled at by the oldtimers in the union for working too fast more than I would EVER get yelled at by management. Got to milk that job, don'tchaknow?

Unions are why the US automakers have lost ALL competative advantages over the imports. The quality is STARTING to get better (it was horrible for a long time) but the COST of a new GM vs Toyota says that more people are going to buy that Toyota.

Oh yeah, for all the BS about "Buy union", I personally know several GM employees that shop at WALMART (anti-union) instead of Meijers (union) because it saves THEM money. Good for the goose....

Unions are for stupid lazy people that can't keep a job based on their work ethics. Are you stupid and lazy, or just protecting all the stupid lazy people you know?

by anykey???

This pretty much sums up my opinion of most unions,but mostly the UAW. The UAW has almost single handedly brought the big three to their knees,by demanding more money and less work each year.

My experience with unions is second hand through my dad.

In the late 70's early 80's he was a member of the flint glass workers union,he had been a member for 8 years and went through an apprenticeship to be a mold maker.At that time the american glass industry was very big and making alot of money, and so were the employees,as a journeyman mold maker he was in the $16.00 a hour range working 80+ hours a week making a nice living.

Then people began to realize the cost benefits of plastic bottles and the industry began to weaken as demand for glass began to drop,With that drop in demand came a drop in hours,and according to the union contract where he worked they were guaranteed a set amount of hours.So instead of just cutting overtime for everyone they had to lay off to maintain that level of hours for those b!tchy old b@stards. Did I mention I was 8 at the time and the layoff came the week of thanksgiving that year.

I will never forget the pain in my dads voice and the sorrow in his eyes explaining exactly how the whole santa claus thing works to his 8 and 6 year old boys(kids shouldn't have to find out this way but I respect him for it),and how he wasn't sure how christmas would turn out because of the layoff and the fact that mom wasn't working at the time.

After that whole mess settled down dad got a job as a(non union) machinist for a specialty machine company that dealt alot with the auto industry and has tons of stories about the BS he had to put up with when he was in an auto plant somewhere doing a service call.

I will not deny that unions have their place but they have totally forgotten what that place is, and I have the feeling that the auto industry is just about to remind them.

by tryten

And I can say that 99% of what you said is true. Its gotten so bad that our corporate is looking into ending its union affiliation. No one will be fired, but no union employees will be hired ever again. And the manditory lock-out for strikes has been increased from 90 days without pay to 180 days without pay for a strike and does not guarentee a job position upon return if the employee finds temporary work during the lockout. The last strike that we had lasted 3 day before the issue was resolved. An operator will have to work for the next 8 years before they come out ahead on their pay. For a $75
increase in health care cost these idiots were willing to lose 3 months of pay and possibly their jobs. Its not like we are losing money from product reduction. We have all non-union employees trained enough to work the union jobs and have contractors on standby at the first rumor of a strike.

Funny thing is...whenever there is a strike we tend to have a 15% profit increase. I think unions are giving these guys more than they deserve.
This has not gone through yet. But when compared with the numbers of a non-union site of ours being able to produce more and a better quality product prompted the idea for this change.

by jdclyde

While there ARE exceptions to every rule and you have SOME good workers that just end up in a union, the union quickly breaks them of that if they are to fit in.

Everyone hear about the Ford plant where the front office had to send out a memo to let the thugs in the union know that if they commit a crime of vandalism on non-ford cars in the parking lot they WILL be prosecuted like the crimials they are? This was a week ago.

So, was the 1% something I was wrong about, or was it the "exception to the rule" clause?

Unions create a hostile work environment as well. Go ask any free-lance truck driver what they are like!

by jdclyde

Thanks both Max and Any.

Any, sorry to hear what your family had to go through. It was divorce when I was 4 that put us in the poor house for a long time, but we got over it, and obviously so did your family.

My mom now has her Masters in Computer science. A far cry from that single mom on welfare in the early 70's.

While putting myself through school I have been in and out of many shops. The work wasn't the hardest in the unions shops, but the job satisfaction was the lowest and the work environment the worst.

I also have relatives working for GM NOW, as well as a few friends.

If is kind of funny that GM people define themselves by WHERE they work, not what they do.

When someone asks me what I do for a living, I tell them I play with computers. If they follow it up with where, I then tell them the company.

If you ask a GM emplyee what they do, they will ALWAYS say "I work at GM", as if that is suppose to mean something.

Oh yeah, a few years back they were doing MANDATORY seven day weeks (so they could lay people off) and my ex-father-in-law was paying more in taxes than I took home.

by anykey???

used to carry some prestige when talking to others involved in manufacturing,I think that is why auto workers just refer to what company they work for and not what they do.
But now it doesn't carry the weight that it used to.

From my experience the union contracts have made many jobs in a plant very mundane because the focus of each position is so small, and you don't dare veer off what exactly what it is you are supposed to do because of fear of a grievance that it has killed morale.

JD, thanks man, yeah my family pulled through very well but there was a couple of very lean years that I remember, and it has definately left its mark on how I view things now that I have a family of my own.

by sleepin'dawg

their making logical sense, that will be an entirely different matter to which he will have no no answer never mind logic.

Maybe unions were necessary at one time but they've long outlived their usefullness and have become one of the major causes of outsourcing both here and abroad. If a company can produce its products cheaper and with fewer labour problems outside or offshore the company in fulfilling its duty to make profits for its shareholders, is obliged to do so. Companies exist to benefit their shareholders not their employees who are benefitted by their wages and salaries. Workers need to be made to understand that and until they do, they will only see more outsourcing. This is a double edged sword as more jobs are outsourced the need for management and supervisory staff will decline as well and you will see more downsizing.

Unions now exist to benefit the unions as the organisations and businesses they've become. They do not exist to benefit their worker members who exist strictly as cogs or tools to be used in the manipulation of the process. Maybe shop committees make a little bit of sense but big unions are no longer necessary and are now detrimental to the workers and the overall economy. If their is a need for unions, its in the third world, where the jobs are being outsourced. Get the wages of those workers on a par with ours and a lot of the problems for our workers would disappear but unions here only serve to exacerbate the problem. BTW would you wager his $70/week mother's job wouldn't be one of the first to be outsourced, if not offshore, at least to a contractor??? :^0

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by maxwell edison

.....In 1960.

Average annual salary 1950-1959: $2,992

A loaf of bread cost 14 cents.

By the way, did you know that Homer Simpson made more money than Fred Flinstone? (Yes, adjusted for inflation.)

by sleepin'dawg

you were considered a big shot and successful. Nowadays, even janitors are making $20,000 per year but the purchasing power of that, is probably less than the average 50s salary. An interesting minor item, go into any outlet in any town that relys on the auto industry as its core industry and within a week of the announcement of a new contract you will find most of the prices have increased by 10%. I read that somewhere and wish I could remember where but as the article pointed out a 10% increase in prices was always in excess of what the new contract was worth. The effect is of taking a step forward so you can take two steps back. For a while there in the past few years the economy was in a slump. Did you notice inflation was minimal except for petroleum products??? Now the economy has picked up and the unions are making demands again. Notice the rate of inflation this year compared to last year??? Enough said. You know my feelings regarding unions. X-(

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by maxwell edison

(All adjusted for inflation, of course.)

Archie Bunker also made more money than Fred Flinstone. However, Fred did make more than Al Bundy, but not much more. But then again, even Fred Sanford made more money than poor old Al Bundy.

Homer Simpson ALSO made more money than Ward Cleaver. But Ward's house was much nicer, don't you think? And his wife was much more attractive as well -- and she could even talk jive.

Andy Taylor (Sheriff) made more than Homer did, but not as much as Rob Petrie. George Jefferson, however, put all those guys to shame, just raking in the dough. But J.R. Ewing literally took George to the cleaners when it came to earnings.

by sleepin'dawg

destroyed American Motors in the 90s. In England, the unions destroyed most of the UK auto industry and in Germany the unions are the major reason why Mercedes Benz, BMW, Audi, Volkswagen are opening new plants everywhere except in Germany. The workforce of the German auto industry has declined by almost 25% since the 70s, largely due to excessive demands of the German unions.

Why do you think Mercedes bought Chrysler??? Simple, it was going at a bargain and it is now cheaper to develop new vehicles here than it is in Germany however, if unions keep upping their demands at Chrysler they should be aware that Mercedes owns facilities in many other countries. The jobs aren't locked in here and the union members better be cognizant of that before their union sells them down the river.

The only good thing a union has ever done was to force me into opening my own company back in the 80s and you can be sure there will [b]never[/b] be a union in any company of mine as long as I'm there running it. We started with five guys in 88 and today we are over 700 in three different locations. I pay over union scale, provide benefits better than the union and have profit sharing.

Try unionizing my company; go ahead and try. I will shut down and pull up stakes and move elsewhere before I will let any union rat past the front or back doors of any company of mine. I have received threats of bodily harm from unions but as I explained to the last guy who tried that, he might cost me a lot but I will make sure he, as an individual, will lose more. Unions are bullies but when you bring it home to their people on an individual basis, they soon lose interest. I really wasn't too worried because I know most of my people would have voted against the union; there isn't anything a union can give them that they aren't already getting. Unionize?? For what???

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

Yes, it sounds much better to say "GM" than to say a "bolt tightener".

You can tell the GM "rich guys" from the DOW "rich guys" in the state. The GM guy will have ever toy you can imagine and is living from paycheck to paycheck and can barely afforde to buy their "miller lite". The Dow guys live in a nice home, in a nice neighborhood and don't really have a whole lot going out each week because everything is paid for as they go instead of "charge it".

I see it all the time, and the ONLY difference between the GM worker and some guy in a no-name shop making 1/4 the wage, is they got hired in 30 years ago. High school diploma? Your good enough to work the floor. Who needs college when you can make $80K a year doing monkey work?

(it would drive me nuts!)

My buds dad is maintance. He makes about $30/hour to play darts in his office waiting for something to break. Give him a broom!

by anykey???

that fnm48 threw the bucket of sh!t, but hauled @ss before it hit the fan, seems pretty cowardly to me...

by jdclyde

Had JUST noticed that and was about to point it out. You beat me to it! If I would have got up from my nap earlier I would have gotten it in! :D

It looks like Fnm48 just wanted to get in on the fun, as firebrand posts take less thought and get the most emotional responses.

It is known as the "seagull affect". Fly in, $h1t all over everything, and then fly out.

What a dweeb!

Bet he has never worked a union job in his life and is just going off the drunken propoganda spewed down his daddys leg as he grew up and now that he is out of high school this is his first chance to make his mark. If course, living with your parents, it is hard to be taken seriously..... :0

by oz_media

You should know by now, it happens all the time. How do people get of fon that? Do you think he's still reading along thinking "hey look what I started! I'm popular!"

by jdclyde

I don't think the dweeb expected people to catch on to him, because the last union discussion got so out of hand so quickly.

The comments in the last one were so stupid I couldn't even bring myself to read it after the first day.

He just carried on the tradition and dropped that ball. Baddly.

by maxwell edison

He wasn't on the list that I found.

Did they use money back in that future world? Did Spacely Sprockets actually pay him?

by oz_media

I always figured your country was built on the dreams of escapists who fled from a brave new world in hopes of building their own brave new world.

As far as unions go, they are great to be on if you are unable to progress your own career and just want a system to channel you along like cattle. On the outside of the union world, you have no restrictions and can excell based on your own performance easier without watching some idiot take kay positions due to seniority.

I too have seen both sides, and have operated moer than one company, it just depends if you are feeling complacent (unions job works) or if you are more agressive and eager to progress (corporate employment/self employment).

by jdclyde

with a different people.

Unfortunately, It is true that while we have some of the best workers in the world, we have more than our share of the worst as well.

That is why we still need unions and government jobs. To keep them out of the soup lines.

Land of the free, to do as much or as little as you wish. Sad that so many have been fed the entitlement crap and think they have a right to all kinds of nice things that people that have worked hard have.

Want to see ugly? Go watch some teamsters on a picket line. Not ugly enough? Go ahead and cross that picket line and you will see more ugly than you can take. Better hope a cop is handy or your in a hospital.

by oz_media

The secuity company I was with was a Teamsters union, the cartage company I was with was a teamsters union.

In the early 90's I started a cartage company, the staff wanted to unionize, so I fired everyone, closed the company and reopened/registered in Sarnia Ontario. Three months after the transfer, (I wasn't actually in Sarnia, just a company name registration) I closed and moved it back to BC,hired new staff and the union was never mentioned by the new staff.

by oz_media

Let me guess, you are one of those guys who thinks it's cool to have a HOFFA bumper sticker on your pickup truck? Every teamsters union is full of those guys. It's as if they feel that being in a union in 2006 makes them a relative of a mob family, give your head a shake it's just a way to control your wages and stop you from passing others by on the ladder to success.

if you are wondering what ever happened to Hoffa, he's hanging in my closet, a bit fuzzy and stinky. Almost time for e-Bay.

by bob in calgary

I would have thought you would have found a pig farm somewhere.

Just a side note, hope you weren't on the ferry.

by oz_media

It would hae been quite an entertaining day to say the least. It's not like it was crossing the Pacaific or something, that's just north of where I used to Kayak all the time. That ferry leaves from e hdock where I used to sit and TR in the mornings with my laptop.

I can only dream I was there now, or on that ferry even. Nobody was hurt, it was pretty straight forward and not really a big deal at all.

by maxwell edison

People are beginning to see how destructive unions have actually been, especially over the past 30 years. And people who make $15-$20 an hour, with NO pension plan at their place of employment, don't like paying 30 grand for a vehicle put together by people making $30-$40 an hour who ALSO get a cushy pension plan.

Another thing people are going to wake up to before long is the notion of paying people for their "government service". How long before people realize who's really "serving" whom?

The average salary in the USA is around $35,000 a year. The average salary in the government sector, not even counting the military, is $65,000 a year. (And then look at those pension plans!) I'd like someone to give me one good reason why the one who is supposed to "serve", is actually the one getting serviced.

Like I asked, how long before people realize who's really "serving" whom?

by sleepin'dawg

I won't hold my breath in anticipation. Civil service; neither civil nor servile and are overpaid for what they do, considering most of the time they exist only to aggravate people.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by bob in calgary

the news said that a couple are missing and were presumed to have gone down with the ferry. But as it's sitting under 300 metres of water chances of finding the bodies are slim to none.

by oz_media

I hadn't heard that, just the radio blurb. they cracked a sinking joke about it. One jock said it wsa too soon for jokes about it and the other said, "well nobody was hurt so it's not THAT bad".

I just assumed all were okay. Not too BC newsworthy it seems, for some reason.

Oh well, swimmin' with the fishes in the same calm coastal waters as the orcas. Bald eagles, rainforests,kermode (spirit) bears and mroe, what a beautiful part of God's country, could've been worse and I should be so lucky when my time is up.

by oz_media

They jumped to teh conclusion nobody was lost, now they can't find two passengers. The Damn press.

First crew were waist deep in water as they fled their cabins below deck. Then they were chest deep in water as they were in cabins below deck. this was in the same report.

"And there are stories of crew members wading through waist-deep water to get out of their below-deck quarters...Some off-duty crew faced their own fight for life even before aiding the passengers. Their quarters were below the ship's waterline and they awoke to find themselves chest-deep in sea water."

okay probably different people, and TECHNICALLY if you awake you are usually on laying down so your chest would be close to knee height and then... sure, damn press.

by fnm48

Yes, unions have their good and bad points. And, yes they also protect the poor workers as well as not always rewarding the good ones...But, (for the Gentleman that wondered)I have been on "both sides of the fence". Unions protect workers from people like the guy who fired all his workers for "thinking of going union'. Is he right ??? Not by a longshot...he's the very thing that people should fear ! And by the way, my Mother (speak kindly of her she is not with us)was a "sweat shop" non-union worker in the late 70's. Yes, $70 a week was relatively more than now, but she "busted her but" doing peacework (sewing a whole dress on a machine for about $1 per dress. Is that right ??? Also (friends out there) be more weary of outsourcing your jobs (with no union protection)and it's happening now...good luck. I was "laid off" after 15 Years of Good Management service, bacause of a "takeover". I had the "management mentality" that i'll never be laid-off if I'm a good worker (so much for that theory).

by tony hopkinson

Not laid off if you are a good worker ?
It took a long time but you just learnt something.

There's no way to have secure employment, it's a myth promoted by those who wish us to accept less over a longer period.

The rule is, dog eat dog.

Don't stand around, take a munch out of everything that gets within biting range and above all beware of those nice friendly chaps with nets offering you a safe haven and a regular supply of food. They are eating half of what you could have got for yourself.

Going to take a guess here but I bet the company you worked for were a big fat easy financial target.

I know it's hard being chucked out of your safe and secure rut to retirement, but start ducking and diving and going in whatever direction you want to, its a lot more interesting.

I was in the same rut for 19 years, but jumped the tracks myself, best thing I ever did.

Try and get the difference between the socialist aspects of the union movement which are valuable and valid, from the graft, corruption and self serving manipulation parts that those who want to run them, promote.

Another wild guess, your union reps weren't anywhere near as inconvenienced by the takeover as you were. In my experience union reps are management double agents whose purpose in life is to give you the illusion that you have some sort of control over your fate.

If you want control, take it, the only way you are 'given' control is by someone taking yours and then lying their ass off about it.

by oz_media

Unfortunately you found out the same way most other peopledo, you think you'r epretty much indesposable and get the carpet swept out from under you.

It's happened tome many times throughout my career, I also change career choices pretty much once a year or so, if not a complete change at least a redesigned vertical anyway. It's much easier when you don't try andplan years ahead but just work on today.

As for firing everyone for wanting to unionize, that was me. It is done all th etime for many cited reasons usually well covered up but it's a relity. I didn't want a unionized operation, in order to avoid that I had to move my business. Was that what I wanted to do? Not really, I'd rather just operate and earn money, so I was just as inconvenienced as those that plotted secretly and without confronting me.

Get over it, there's two sides to every copin, just as you were somewhat shocked to find that you were disposable, this is just a simple reality we face in life. Your employer doen't owe you anything except pay for hours worked, that's it.

In my case, it had NOTHING at all to do with pay, I was paying $15/hr to deliver flat packed furniture, which wasn't bad back then, not exactly a sweat shop as you've described.

Just because a company doesn't have a union, it doesn't make it a sweat shop that exloiits workers.

And I too have worked 'both sides of the fence' for different companies and different unions. It's no big screaming deal, I can secure a fair wage and create some stability myself, without a union.

This discussion is closed to new replies.